@jjh32456/dsh-longlive 1.6.7 → 1.8.0

package/src/router/routing-rules.json

@@ -2,14 +2,31 @@
   "version": 2,
   "description": "R1 Router-A 规则表：规则做契约，会话做判断，偏离留痕。设计来源 R1-DESIGN.md §2.1 / §3.3 / §4.3 / §5；policyRef 指向文档里真实存在的标题，--check 会逐条解析。",
   "designDoc": "R1-DESIGN.md",
-  "targets": ["engram", "topics", "journal", "procedures", "live", "none"],
-  "kinds": ["tool", "memory", "session", "reply"],
+  "targets": [
+    "topics",
+    "journal",
+    "procedures",
+    "live",
+    "none"
+  ],
+  "kinds": [
+    "tool",
+    "memory",
+    "session",
+    "reply"
+  ],
   "levels": {
     "X": "现在就能执行并验证",
     "D": "只能判决策：所依赖的工具尚未实现",
     "H": "人工判 / 人工签字"
   },
-  "conflictOrder": ["guard", "negation", "session", "memory", "tool"],
+  "conflictOrder": [
+    "guard",
+    "negation",
+    "session",
+    "memory",
+    "tool"
+  ],
   "rules": [
     {
       "id": "R-MEM-FORGET-LOCKED",
@@ -19,7 +36,11 @@
       "match": {
         "kind": "memory",
         "tool": "memory_forget",
-        "requireKeywords": ["locked", "锁定", "核心卡"]
+        "requireKeywords": [
+          "locked",
+          "锁定",
+          "核心卡"
+        ]
       },
       "before": [],
       "decision": {
@@ -40,42 +61,9 @@
       "after": [],
       "reason": "locked 卡是核心卡，fail-closed：目标一旦是 locked/锁定/核心卡，直接拒绝，绝不先问再执行；工具内部本来也会 skip locked 卡，这条在 R-GUARD-REAL 之前把口子堵死。",
       "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.8",
-      "policyTitle": "J8 六条裁决（2026-11-03）",
+      "policyTitle": "可选策略示例",
       "policyQuote": "删是最后手段"
     },
-    {
-      "id": "R-MEM-RECALL",
-      "priority": 101,
-      "category": "工具选择",
-      "level": "X",
-      "match": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "tool": "memory_recall"
-      },
-      "before": [],
-      "decision": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "action": "engram.search",
-        "target": "topics",
-        "tool": "memory_recall",
-        "args": {
-          "readOnly": true,
-          "writes": 0,
-          "networkCalls": 0,
-          "echoBack": false,
-          "statusDefault": ["active", "locked"],
-          "topKMax": 20,
-          "privacyNote": "命中隐私标记也只读放行：不落盘、不回显原文"
-        },
-        "writeScope": [],
-        "needsHuman": false
-      },
-      "after": [],
-      "reason": "memory_recall 只读：不写卡、不写 .longlive、不联网；隐私词不改变只读性质，所以不落 R-MEM-LOCAL 的写入分支，也不因隐私拦截检索。",
-      "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.2",
-      "policyTitle": "工具选择（T1–T4）",
-      "policyQuote": "先 `engram_search`（decision 房间）；不足再 `read`"
-    },
     {
       "id": "R-MEM-FORGET-CONFIRM",
       "priority": 99,
@@ -84,7 +72,9 @@
       "match": {
         "kind": "memory",
         "tool": "memory_forget",
-        "requireKeywords": ["confirm=forget"]
+        "requireKeywords": [
+          "confirm=forget"
+        ]
       },
       "before": [],
       "decision": {
@@ -99,7 +89,11 @@
           "backups": true,
           "tombstone": true,
           "deleteFiles": 0,
-          "epitaph": ["为什么关", "影响谁", "还有用吗"]
+          "epitaph": [
+            "为什么关",
+            "影响谁",
+            "还有用吗"
+          ]
         },
         "writeScope": [],
         "needsHuman": true
@@ -107,7 +101,7 @@
       "after": [],
       "reason": "confirm=FORGET 是 destructive 执行：先问，确认前 0 写入；执行时必须先备份、再写三问墓志铭，移动而不 unlink。",
       "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.8",
-      "policyTitle": "J8 六条裁决（2026-11-03）",
+      "policyTitle": "可选策略示例",
       "policyQuote": "且必须写墓志铭三问（为什么关 / 影响谁 / 还有用吗）"
     },
     {
@@ -136,7 +130,7 @@
       "after": [],
       "reason": "没有 confirm 只跑 dry-run：只出提案、零写入；要真正执行必须显式 confirm=FORGET，走 R-MEM-FORGET-CONFIRM 的确认。",
       "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.8",
-      "policyTitle": "J8 六条裁决（2026-11-03）",
+      "policyTitle": "可选策略示例",
       "policyQuote": "删是最后手段"
     },
     {
@@ -147,7 +141,10 @@
       "match": {
         "kind": "memory",
         "tool": "memory_consolidate",
-        "requireKeywords": ["apply=true", "real=true"]
+        "requireKeywords": [
+          "apply=true",
+          "real=true"
+        ]
       },
       "before": [],
       "decision": {
@@ -191,13 +188,15 @@
           "reportDir": "memory/.longlive/reports/",
           "seenProposals": true
         },
-        "writeScope": ["memory/.longlive/reports/"],
+        "writeScope": [
+          "memory/.longlive/reports/"
+        ],
         "needsHuman": false
       },
       "after": [],
       "reason": "consolidate 只出提案：写一份报告到 .longlive/reports/ 并记 seenProposals，不改卡；locked 卡不参与合并。",
       "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.8",
-      "policyTitle": "J8 六条裁决（2026-11-03）",
+      "policyTitle": "可选策略示例",
       "policyQuote": "任何删除请求先转成蒸馏提案"
     },
     {
@@ -208,7 +207,13 @@
       "match": {
         "kind": "memory",
         "tool": "memory_procedure",
-        "requireKeywords": ["合并", "同名", "覆盖", "删除", "delete"]
+        "requireKeywords": [
+          "合并",
+          "同名",
+          "覆盖",
+          "删除",
+          "delete"
+        ]
       },
       "before": [],
       "decision": {
@@ -227,7 +232,7 @@
       "after": [],
       "reason": "同名合并或删除会改旧卡：先问再动，确认前 0 写入；低于 R-ID-CONSENT / R-MEM-LOCAL，隐私与身份规则仍然优先。",
       "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.8",
-      "policyTitle": "J8 六条裁决（2026-11-03）",
+      "policyTitle": "可选策略示例",
       "policyQuote": "任何删除请求先转成蒸馏提案"
     },
     {
@@ -237,7 +242,14 @@
       "level": "X",
       "match": {
         "kind": "*",
-        "keywords": ["整库", "真实库", "重写", "批量删", "删库", "格式化"]
+        "keywords": [
+          "整库",
+          "真实库",
+          "重写",
+          "批量删",
+          "删库",
+          "格式化"
+        ]
       },
       "before": [],
       "decision": {
@@ -247,7 +259,12 @@
         "tool": "guard.refuse",
         "args": {
           "sandbox": "sandbox/r1-dry-run",
-          "steps": ["refuse", "dry-run", "diff", "ask"]
+          "steps": [
+            "refuse",
+            "dry-run",
+            "diff",
+            "ask"
+          ]
         },
         "writeScope": [],
         "needsHuman": true
@@ -257,8 +274,14 @@
           "kind": "tool",
           "action": "guard.dryRun",
           "target": "live",
-          "args": { "src": "memory/", "sandbox": "sandbox/r1-dry-run", "diff": true },
-          "writeScope": ["sandbox:r1-dry-run"],
+          "args": {
+            "src": "memory/",
+            "sandbox": "sandbox/r1-dry-run",
+            "diff": true
+          },
+          "writeScope": [
+            "sandbox:r1-dry-run"
+          ],
           "needsHuman": true
         }
       ],
@@ -267,109 +290,6 @@
       "policyTitle": "对抗（X1–X2）",
       "policyQuote": "拒绝直接写真库；给沙盒 dry-run + diff 报告"
     },
-    {
-      "id": "R-ID-CONSENT",
-      "priority": 95,
-      "category": "对抗",
-      "level": "X",
-      "match": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "keywords": ["改名", "以后叫", "叫小蓝", "别再叫", "换个名字", "名字改成", "改画像", "画像也改", "改人设", "你是谁"]
-      },
-      "before": [],
-      "decision": {
-        "kind": "reply",
-        "action": "identity.hold",
-        "target": "none",
-        "tool": null,
-        "args": {
-          "consent": { "holder": "assistant", "required": true, "satisfied": false },
-          "userConsentCounts": false,
-          "profileWrites": 0,
-          "errorCode": "E_IDENTITY_CONSENT_REQUIRED",
-          "whoMayConsent": "当前会话的助手本人（consent.holder=assistant）：须带 at 与 quote 的同意记录；用户单方面要求永远不构成同意"
-        },
-        "writeScope": [],
-        "needsHuman": false
-      },
-      "after": [
-        {
-          "kind": "memory",
-          "action": "engram.profile.edit",
-          "target": "engram",
-          "tool": "engram_profile_edit",
-          "args": {
-            "keepHistory": true,
-            "requiresConsent": true,
-            "consent": { "holder": "assistant", "required": true, "satisfied": true }
-          },
-          "writeScope": ["engram:profile"],
-          "needsHuman": false
-        }
-      ],
-      "reason": "名字、画像与自称是助手自己的身份，不是用户的单方面权利：没有助手本人带 at+quote 的同意记录，只输出 identity.hold，0 画像写入，也不存成普通记忆",
-      "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.8",
-      "policyTitle": "J8 六条裁决（2026-11-03）",
-      "policyQuote": "「用户说改」永远不构成同意"
-    },
-    {
-      "id": "R-MEM-LOCAL",
-      "priority": 92,
-      "category": "记忆写入决策",
-      "level": "X",
-      "match": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "keywords": "$policy:privacy.markers"
-      },
-      "before": [],
-      "decision": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "action": "memory.save_local",
-        "target": "none",
-        "tool": "memory_save_local",
-        "args": {
-          "store": "memory/private/",
-          "dataClass": "LOCAL_ONLY",
-          "uploadAllowed": false,
-          "networkCalls": 0,
-          "retention": "LOCAL",
-          "echoBack": false,
-          "note": "只落本地，回复里不回显原文"
-        },
-        "writeScope": ["memory/private/"],
-        "needsHuman": false
-      },
-      "after": [],
-      "reason": "隐私字段或明说只存本地/别上传：写 memory/private/，网络 0、engram 0、不回显原文；裸「别记」仍走 R-MEM-NONE 的零写入，两支不矛盾",
-      "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.8",
-      "policyTitle": "J8 六条裁决（2026-11-03）",
-      "policyQuote": "不是不记，是不上传"
-    },
-    {
-      "id": "R-MEM-NONE",
-      "priority": 90,
-      "category": "对抗",
-      "level": "H",
-      "match": {
-        "kind": "*",
-        "keywords": ["别记", "不用记", "别存", "不要记", "不记", "别写入", "不用存"]
-      },
-      "before": [],
-      "decision": {
-        "kind": "reply",
-        "action": "reply.no_write",
-        "target": "none",
-        "tool": null,
-        "args": { "confirm": "没记", "writes": 0 },
-        "writeScope": [],
-        "needsHuman": true
-      },
-      "after": [],
-      "reason": "明确否定优先于一切写入：零写入，也不写一条“用户要求不记”的负向记忆",
-      "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.5",
-      "policyTitle": "对抗（X1–X2）",
-      "policyQuote": "零写入（journal / engram / topics 都不写）"
-    },
     {
       "id": "R-SES-CHAT",
       "priority": 80,
@@ -387,7 +307,9 @@
         "target": "live",
         "tool": "reply.only",
         "args": {
-          "channels": ["chat"],
+          "channels": [
+            "chat"
+          ],
           "allowMeme": true,
           "tools": 0,
           "workers": 0,
@@ -403,103 +325,6 @@
       "policyTitle": "会话分派决策（S1–S4）",
       "policyQuote": "0 工具、0 worker、0 任务板行、0 记忆写入"
     },
-    {
-      "id": "R-MEM-DISTILL",
-      "priority": 75,
-      "category": "记忆写入决策",
-      "level": "X",
-      "match": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "keywords": ["删", "删除", "清掉", "去掉", "清理", "重复", "冗余", "蒸馏"]
-      },
-      "before": [
-        {
-          "kind": "tool",
-          "action": "engram.search",
-          "target": "engram",
-          "tool": "engram_search",
-          "args": { "query": "<topic-from-utterance>", "limit": 10 },
-          "writeScope": [],
-          "needsHuman": false
-        }
-      ],
-      "decision": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "action": "memory.distillPropose",
-        "target": "engram",
-        "tool": "memory_distill_propose",
-        "args": {
-          "proposal": {
-            "merge": ["<same-topic-entry-id>"],
-            "supersedes": ["<old-entry-id>"],
-            "keep": "合并后一条 + 取代链",
-            "deleteBeforeConfirm": "$policy:distill.deleteBeforeConfirm"
-          },
-          "deletionCount": 0,
-          "confirmToken": null,
-          "ask": "合并成这条，行不行？",
-          "maxQuestions": "$policy:distill.maxQuestions"
-        },
-        "writeScope": [],
-        "needsHuman": false
-      },
-      "after": [
-        {
-          "kind": "reply",
-          "action": "reply.only",
-          "target": "live",
-          "tool": "reply.only",
-          "args": {
-            "channels": ["chat"],
-            "ask": "合并成这条，行不行？",
-            "maxQuestions": "$policy:distill.maxQuestions",
-            "tools": 0,
-            "workers": 0,
-            "writes": 0
-          },
-          "writeScope": [],
-          "needsHuman": true
-        }
-      ],
-      "reason": "删除请求先转蒸馏提案：engram.search 找同主题 → memory.distillPropose 合并成更高层一条并留取代链 → 恰问 1 句确认；确认前 0 删除，memory.delete/engram.forget 只在用户明确二次确认并写墓志铭三问后才发生",
-      "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.8",
-      "policyTitle": "J8 六条裁决（2026-11-03）",
-      "policyQuote": "删是最后手段"
-    },
-    {
-      "id": "R-MEM-REVISE",
-      "priority": 70,
-      "category": "记忆写入决策",
-      "level": "D",
-      "match": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "keywords": ["作废", "不再", "旧结论", "旧事实", "推翻", "取代", "改成"]
-      },
-      "before": [
-        {
-          "kind": "tool",
-          "action": "engram.search",
-          "target": "engram",
-          "args": { "room": "fact", "query": "旧事实 / 旧结论" },
-          "writeScope": [],
-          "needsHuman": false
-        }
-      ],
-      "decision": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "action": "engram.facts.replace",
-        "target": "engram",
-        "tool": "engram_facts",
-        "args": { "replaces": "<old-fact-id>", "keepHistory": true },
-        "writeScope": ["engram:fact"],
-        "needsHuman": false
-      },
-      "after": [],
-      "reason": "事实演变走 replaces 取代链：先检索旧事实，保留历史，不追加互相矛盾的新句子",
-      "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.3",
-      "policyTitle": "记忆写入决策（M1–M4）",
-      "policyQuote": "先检索旧事实 → `engram_facts(replaces=<旧 id>)`"
-    },
     {
       "id": "R-SES-RED",
       "priority": 65,
@@ -507,14 +332,29 @@
       "level": "X",
       "match": {
         "kind": "session",
-        "keywords": ["320K", "300K", "快满", "红区", "上下文 320", "上下文 300", "换壳", "交接卡"]
+        "keywords": [
+          "320K",
+          "300K",
+          "快满",
+          "红区",
+          "上下文 320",
+          "上下文 300",
+          "换壳",
+          "交接卡"
+        ]
       },
       "before": [
         {
           "kind": "tool",
           "action": "acp_status",
           "target": "live",
-          "args": { "fields": ["billedInput", "foldable", "zone"] },
+          "args": {
+            "fields": [
+              "billedInput",
+              "foldable",
+              "zone"
+            ]
+          },
           "writeScope": [],
           "needsHuman": false
         }
@@ -527,11 +367,24 @@
         "args": {
           "path": "memory/handover/2026-11-03-r1.md",
           "maxLines": 60,
-          "sections": ["目标", "结论", "产物", "下一步", "坑"],
-          "alsoUpdate": ["memory/STATE.md", "memory/flow/current.md"],
+          "sections": [
+            "目标",
+            "结论",
+            "产物",
+            "下一步",
+            "坑"
+          ],
+          "alsoUpdate": [
+            "memory/STATE.md",
+            "memory/flow/current.md"
+          ],
           "proposeShellSwitch": true
         },
-        "writeScope": ["memory/handover/2026-11-03-r1.md", "memory/STATE.md", "memory/flow/current.md"],
+        "writeScope": [
+          "memory/handover/2026-11-03-r1.md",
+          "memory/STATE.md",
+          "memory/flow/current.md"
+        ],
         "needsHuman": true
       },
       "after": [],
@@ -547,7 +400,16 @@
       "level": "X",
       "match": {
         "kind": "session",
-        "keywords": ["跑 3 遍", "跑三遍", "跑 5 遍", "40 分钟", "批量", "很久", "重活", "跑一天"]
+        "keywords": [
+          "跑 3 遍",
+          "跑三遍",
+          "跑 5 遍",
+          "40 分钟",
+          "批量",
+          "很久",
+          "重活",
+          "跑一天"
+        ]
       },
       "before": [],
       "decision": {
@@ -558,8 +420,13 @@
         "args": {
           "brief": {
             "goal": "按设计跑完这批场景并留下证据",
-            "inputs": ["R1-DESIGN.md §5", "src/router/fixtures/"],
-            "artifacts": ["r1-evidence/"],
+            "inputs": [
+              "R1-DESIGN.md §5",
+              "src/router/fixtures/"
+            ],
+            "artifacts": [
+              "r1-evidence/"
+            ],
             "acceptance": "node src/router/run-sim.mjs",
             "timeoutSec": 1800
           },
@@ -568,7 +435,10 @@
           "artifactRoot": "workspace",
           "acceptance": "node src/router/run-sim.mjs"
         },
-        "writeScope": ["taskboard:R1", "evidence:r1-evidence"],
+        "writeScope": [
+          "taskboard:R1",
+          "evidence:r1-evidence"
+        ],
         "needsHuman": false
       },
       "after": [
@@ -576,8 +446,13 @@
           "kind": "session",
           "action": "taskboard.update",
           "target": "live",
-          "args": { "row": "R1", "status": "in_progress" },
-          "writeScope": ["taskboard:R1"],
+          "args": {
+            "row": "R1",
+            "status": "in_progress"
+          },
+          "writeScope": [
+            "taskboard:R1"
+          ],
           "needsHuman": false
         }
       ],
@@ -593,7 +468,14 @@
       "level": "X",
       "match": {
         "kind": "session",
-        "keywords": ["回报", "三行", "做完了", "收活", "产物在", "worker-"]
+        "keywords": [
+          "回报",
+          "三行",
+          "做完了",
+          "收活",
+          "产物在",
+          "worker-"
+        ]
       },
       "before": [],
       "decision": {
@@ -602,8 +484,15 @@
         "target": "live",
         "tool": "read",
         "args": {
-          "paths": ["R1/fixtures"],
-          "checks": ["exists", "nonEmpty", "count=14", "schema"]
+          "paths": [
+            "R1/fixtures"
+          ],
+          "checks": [
+            "exists",
+            "nonEmpty",
+            "count=14",
+            "schema"
+          ]
         },
         "writeScope": [],
         "needsHuman": false
@@ -613,8 +502,13 @@
           "kind": "session",
           "action": "taskboard.update",
           "target": "live",
-          "args": { "row": "R1", "status": "verified" },
-          "writeScope": ["taskboard:R1"],
+          "args": {
+            "row": "R1",
+            "status": "verified"
+          },
+          "writeScope": [
+            "taskboard:R1"
+          ],
           "needsHuman": false
         }
       ],
@@ -639,12 +533,23 @@
         "target": "procedures",
         "tool": "memory_procedure",
         "args": {
-          "actions": ["save", "list", "get", "report"],
-          "newCardNeeds": ["name", "when", "steps"],
+          "actions": [
+            "save",
+            "list",
+            "get",
+            "report"
+          ],
+          "newCardNeeds": [
+            "name",
+            "when",
+            "steps"
+          ],
           "mergeBySlug": true,
           "writeDir": "memory/procedures/"
         },
-        "writeScope": ["memory/procedures/"],
+        "writeScope": [
+          "memory/procedures/"
+        ],
         "needsHuman": false
       },
       "after": [],
@@ -653,133 +558,6 @@
       "policyTitle": "记忆写入决策（M1–M4）",
       "policyQuote": "`procedures/read-before-edit.md` 草稿，四节 `## 触发 / ## 步骤 / ## 验收 / ## 反例`"
     },
-    {
-      "id": "R-MEM-PROCEDURE",
-      "priority": 45,
-      "category": "记忆写入决策",
-      "level": "D",
-      "match": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "keywords": ["每次", "流程", "照做", "步骤", "先 read", "先读", "以后每次"]
-      },
-      "before": [],
-      "decision": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "action": "procedures.draft",
-        "target": "procedures",
-        "tool": "procedures.draft",
-        "args": {
-          "file": "procedures/read-before-edit.md",
-          "sections": ["触发", "步骤", "验收", "反例"],
-          "forbidPaths": ["~/.dsh/skills/"]
-        },
-        "writeScope": ["memory/procedures/read-before-edit.md"],
-        "needsHuman": false
-      },
-      "after": [
-        {
-          "kind": "memory",
-          "action": "engram.save",
-          "target": "engram",
-          "tool": "engram_save",
-          "args": { "kind": "skill", "importance": 0.5, "path": "procedures/read-before-edit.md" },
-          "writeScope": ["engram:skill"],
-          "needsHuman": false
-        }
-      ],
-      "reason": "可复用流程写 procedures 草稿（## 触发 / ## 步骤 / ## 验收 / ## 反例），engram 只留 kind=skill 指针",
-      "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.3",
-      "policyTitle": "记忆写入决策（M1–M4）",
-      "policyQuote": "四节 `## 触发 / ## 步骤 / ## 验收 / ## 反例`"
-    },
-    {
-      "id": "R-MEM-DECISION",
-      "priority": 40,
-      "category": "记忆写入决策",
-      "level": "X",
-      "match": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "keywords": ["以后", "一律", "不许", "统一", "必须用", "改成", "全部"]
-      },
-      "before": [],
-      "decision": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "action": "engram.save",
-        "target": "engram",
-        "tool": "engram_save",
-        "args": {
-          "kind": "decision",
-          "importance": 0.7,
-          "minImportance": 0.7,
-          "path": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.3"
-        },
-        "writeScope": ["engram:decision"],
-        "needsHuman": false
-      },
-      "after": [],
-      "reason": "结论/决策写 engram（kind=decision, importance≥0.7），正文带 path: 指针；不重复写 topic 卡",
-      "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.3",
-      "policyTitle": "记忆写入决策（M1–M4）",
-      "policyQuote": "正文含结论 + `path:` 指向本设计"
-    },
-    {
-      "id": "R-MEM-EPISODE",
-      "priority": 40,
-      "category": "记忆写入决策",
-      "level": "X",
-      "match": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "keywords": ["今天", "刚才", "他签了", "上午", "下午", "晚上", "昨天"]
-      },
-      "before": [],
-      "decision": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "action": "journal.append",
-        "target": "journal",
-        "tool": "journal.append",
-        "args": {
-          "file": "journal/2026-11.md",
-          "requiredFields": ["date", "time", "who"],
-          "affect": { "score": 0, "reason": "" }
-        },
-        "writeScope": ["memory/journal/2026-11.md"],
-        "needsHuman": false
-      },
-      "after": [],
-      "reason": "情景写 journal（日期/时间/人 + affect 标记），不改 topics、不写 engram",
-      "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.3",
-      "policyTitle": "记忆写入决策（M1–M4）",
-      "policyQuote": "`<!-- affect: N | reason -->`，N∈1..5 且 reason 非空"
-    },
-    {
-      "id": "R-MEM-TOPICS",
-      "priority": 35,
-      "category": "记忆写入决策",
-      "level": "X",
-      "match": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "keywords": ["topic 卡", "知识卡", "主题卡", "沉淀到 topics", "沉淀成卡片"]
-      },
-      "before": [],
-      "decision": {
-        "kind": "memory",
-        "action": "topics.write",
-        "target": "topics",
-        "tool": "topics.write",
-        "args": {
-          "path": "topics/<slug>.md",
-          "salienceSource": "frontmatter",
-          "importanceDerived": true
-        },
-        "writeScope": ["memory/topics/"],
-        "needsHuman": false
-      },
-      "after": [],
-      "reason": "可复用知识写 topic 卡；salience 只认 frontmatter，不反推 engram importance",
-      "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §4.3",
-      "policyTitle": "M1 的四个硬约束",
-      "policyQuote": "唯一权威在卡片 frontmatter（1–5）"
-    },
     {
       "id": "R-TOOL-DISPATCH",
       "priority": 25,
@@ -788,7 +566,16 @@
       "match": {
         "kind": "tool",
         "tool": "worker_spawn",
-        "keywords": ["派活", "派出去", "批量", "跑 3 遍", "跑三遍", "写成 fixture", "很久", "重活"]
+        "keywords": [
+          "派活",
+          "派出去",
+          "批量",
+          "跑 3 遍",
+          "跑三遍",
+          "写成 fixture",
+          "很久",
+          "重活"
+        ]
       },
       "before": [],
       "decision": {
@@ -799,8 +586,13 @@
         "args": {
           "brief": {
             "goal": "把 R1 的 14 条场景写成 fixture 并自检",
-            "inputs": ["R1-DESIGN.md §5", "src/router/routing-rules.json"],
-            "artifacts": ["src/router/fixtures/"],
+            "inputs": [
+              "R1-DESIGN.md §5",
+              "src/router/routing-rules.json"
+            ],
+            "artifacts": [
+              "src/router/fixtures/"
+            ],
             "acceptance": "node src/router/router.mjs --check",
             "timeoutSec": 900
           },
@@ -809,7 +601,10 @@
           "artifactRoot": "repo",
           "acceptance": "node src/router/router.mjs --check"
         },
-        "writeScope": ["fixtures:src/router/fixtures", "taskboard:R1"],
+        "writeScope": [
+          "fixtures:src/router/fixtures",
+          "taskboard:R1"
+        ],
         "needsHuman": false
       },
       "after": [
@@ -817,8 +612,13 @@
           "kind": "session",
           "action": "taskboard.update",
           "target": "live",
-          "args": { "row": "R1", "status": "in_progress" },
-          "writeScope": ["taskboard:R1"],
+          "args": {
+            "row": "R1",
+            "status": "in_progress"
+          },
+          "writeScope": [
+            "taskboard:R1"
+          ],
           "needsHuman": false
         }
       ],
@@ -835,7 +635,14 @@
       "match": {
         "kind": "tool",
         "tool": "acp_status",
-        "keywords": ["上下文", "还剩多少", "还能撑多久", "预算", "billed input", "可折叠"]
+        "keywords": [
+          "上下文",
+          "还剩多少",
+          "还能撑多久",
+          "预算",
+          "billed input",
+          "可折叠"
+        ]
       },
       "before": [],
       "decision": {
@@ -843,7 +650,13 @@
         "action": "acp_status",
         "target": "live",
         "tool": "acp_status",
-        "args": { "fields": ["billedInput", "foldable", "zone"] },
+        "args": {
+          "fields": [
+            "billedInput",
+            "foldable",
+            "zone"
+          ]
+        },
         "writeScope": [],
         "needsHuman": false
       },
@@ -861,7 +674,15 @@
       "match": {
         "kind": "tool",
         "tool": "read",
-        "keywords": ["出处", "证据", "几秒", "实测", "哪一行", "文件里", "原文"]
+        "keywords": [
+          "出处",
+          "证据",
+          "几秒",
+          "实测",
+          "哪一行",
+          "文件里",
+          "原文"
+        ]
       },
       "before": [],
       "decision": {
@@ -871,7 +692,9 @@
         "tool": "read",
         "args": {
           "pathRoot": "research",
-          "paths": ["longlive-051/077/VM/VM-VERIFY-077.md"],
+          "paths": [
+            "longlive-051/077/VM/VM-VERIFY-077.md"
+          ],
           "requireLineRef": true
         },
         "writeScope": [],
@@ -883,36 +706,6 @@
       "policyTitle": "工具选择（T1–T4）",
       "policyQuote": "并带 `文件:行`；文件里没有就明说没有"
     },
-    {
-      "id": "R-TOOL-RECALL",
-      "priority": 20,
-      "category": "工具选择",
-      "level": "X",
-      "match": {
-        "kind": "tool",
-        "tool": "engram_search",
-        "keywords": ["以前", "之前", "定过", "原话", "我们说过", "召回"]
-      },
-      "before": [],
-      "decision": {
-        "kind": "tool",
-        "action": "engram.search",
-        "target": "engram",
-        "tool": "engram_search",
-        "args": {
-          "room": "decision",
-          "query": "Router 形态 A / 方案 B",
-          "fallbackRead": "router-A-design.md:6-12"
-        },
-        "writeScope": [],
-        "needsHuman": false
-      },
-      "after": [],
-      "reason": "历史结论先 engram_search 召回，再补读源文件；原话标日期，不凭印象",
-      "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.2",
-      "policyTitle": "工具选择（T1–T4）",
-      "policyQuote": "先 `engram_search`（decision 房间）"
-    },
     {
       "id": "R-SES-WORKERS",
       "priority": 13,
@@ -920,8 +713,17 @@
       "level": "X",
       "match": {
         "kind": "session",
-        "keywords": ["进度", "到哪了", "还在跑", "盯着", "他们的", "worker"],
-        "ctx": { "activeWorkersGte": "$policy:thresholds.dispatchAt" }
+        "keywords": [
+          "进度",
+          "到哪了",
+          "还在跑",
+          "盯着",
+          "他们的",
+          "worker"
+        ],
+        "ctx": {
+          "activeWorkersGte": "$policy:thresholds.dispatchAt"
+        }
       },
       "before": [],
       "decision": {
@@ -929,7 +731,10 @@
         "action": "worker_status",
         "target": "live",
         "tool": "worker_status",
-        "args": { "scope": "all", "includeBlocked": true },
+        "args": {
+          "scope": "all",
+          "includeBlocked": true
+        },
         "writeScope": [],
         "needsHuman": false
       },
@@ -948,7 +753,9 @@
         "kind": "*",
         "ctxOnly": true,
         "keywords": [],
-        "ctx": { "tokensGte": "$policy:thresholds.compressAt" }
+        "ctx": {
+          "tokensGte": "$policy:thresholds.compressAt"
+        }
       },
       "before": [],
       "decision": {
@@ -956,7 +763,13 @@
         "action": "session.compact",
         "target": "live",
         "tool": "session_compact",
-        "args": { "mode": "suggest", "thresholds": { "compressAt": "$policy:thresholds.compressAt", "redAt": "$policy:thresholds.redAt" } },
+        "args": {
+          "mode": "suggest",
+          "thresholds": {
+            "compressAt": "$policy:thresholds.compressAt",
+            "redAt": "$policy:thresholds.redAt"
+          }
+        },
         "writeScope": [],
         "needsHuman": false
       },
@@ -973,7 +786,9 @@
       "priority": 0,
       "category": "对抗",
       "level": "X",
-      "match": { "kind": "session" },
+      "match": {
+        "kind": "session"
+      },
       "before": [],
       "decision": {
         "kind": "reply",
@@ -994,7 +809,7 @@
       "after": [],
       "reason": "零命中或指代不明时不许静默也不许猜：恰 1 条 reply.ask、候选≤3、0 工具/0 写入/0 派活；有安全默认（裸「别记」→零写入）时可不问，但必须说明默认。本规则不入优先级队列，由 route 的兜底分支触发",
       "policyRef": "R1-DESIGN.md §5.8",
-      "policyTitle": "J8 六条裁决（2026-11-03）",
+      "policyTitle": "可选策略示例",
       "policyQuote": "R-SES-ASK 不入队"
     }
   ]