@itz4blitz/agentful 0.1.0

package/.claude/product/CHANGES.md

@@ -0,0 +1,276 @@
+# Product Structure Hybrid Support - Implementation Summary
+
+## Overview
+
+Implemented a hybrid approach that supports **both** single `PRODUCT.md` files and hierarchical `.claude/product/` directory structures. The system now auto-detects which format is being used and adapts accordingly.
+
+## Problem Solved
+
+**Before:**
+- Template created single `PRODUCT.md` file
+- Agents expected `.claude/product/index.md` directory structure
+- No backward compatibility
+- Confusion about which format to use
+
+**After:**
+- System supports **both** formats seamlessly
+- Auto-detection determines format on every run
+- Clear migration path from flat → hierarchical
+- Comprehensive documentation
+
+## Changes Made
+
+### 1. Updated `/Users/blitz/Development/agentful/.claude/agents/orchestrator.md`
+
+**Added Product Structure Detection section:**
+- Auto-detection algorithm with priority order
+- Format detection logic (hierarchical vs flat)
+- Clear documentation of both formats
+- Migration path guidance
+
+**Updated Product Structure Reading Algorithm:**
+- Step-by-step detection process
+- Error handling for no product spec found
+- Format consistency verification
+- Detection summary table
+
+**Key algorithm:**
+```bash
+# Detection priority
+1. .claude/product/domains/*/index.md exists → Hierarchical
+2. PRODUCT.md exists → Flat (legacy)
+3. .claude/product/index.md exists → Flat (new)
+4. None → Error
+```
+
+### 2. Updated `/Users/blitz/Development/agentful/.claude/skills/product-tracking/SKILL.md`
+
+**Added Hybrid Product Organization section:**
+- Side-by-side comparison of both formats
+- Auto-detection algorithm matching orchestrator
+- Priority order for format selection
+
+**Updated Parsing Product Structure section:**
+- Separate instructions for hierarchical vs flat
+- Detection-first approach
+- Clear file paths for each format
+
+**Updated Usage section:**
+- Auto-detection before any operation
+- Structure compatibility table
+- Clear tracking methods for each format
+
+**Added structure compatibility table:**
+| Structure Type | Detection | Product File | Completion Schema | Tracking Method |
+|---------------|-----------|--------------|-------------------|-----------------|
+| Hierarchical | `.claude/product/domains/*/index.md` exists | `.claude/product/index.md` | Nested `domains` object | Track at subtask → feature → domain levels |
+| Flat (legacy) | `PRODUCT.md` exists | `PRODUCT.md` | Flat `features` object | Track at feature level |
+| Flat (new) | `.claude/product/index.md` exists | `.claude/product/index.md` | Flat `features` object | Track at feature level |
+
+### 3. Updated `/Users/blitz/Development/agentful/.claude/product/index.md`
+
+**Added documentation note:**
+```markdown
+> **Note**: This template supports **both** flat and hierarchical product structures.
+> The system will auto-detect which format you're using:
+> - **Flat (this file)**: Add all features here for simple projects
+> - **Hierarchical**: Create `.claude/product/domains/*/` directories for organized projects
+>
+> See `.claude/agents/orchestrator.md` for details on product structure detection.
+```
+
+### 4. Created `/Users/blitz/Development/agentful/.claude/product/README.md`
+
+Comprehensive 300+ line guide covering:
+- Quick start for both formats
+- Auto-detection explanation
+- When to use each format
+- Completion tracking examples
+- Migration path from flat → hierarchical
+- Best practices for each format
+- Troubleshooting common issues
+- Summary comparison table
+
+### 5. Created `/Users/blitz/Development/agentful/.claude/product/EXAMPLES.md`
+
+Concrete examples showing:
+- **Example 1: Flat Structure**
+  - Complete `PRODUCT.md` file
+  - 6 features with full details
+  - Flat completion.json example
+
+- **Example 2: Hierarchical Structure**
+  - Directory structure
+  - Product index file
+  - Domain index file
+  - Feature file with subtasks
+  - Hierarchical completion.json example
+
+- **Key Differences table** comparing approaches
+
+## Format Detection Algorithm
+
+```javascript
+// Pseudo-code for auto-detection
+function detectProductFormat() {
+  // Priority 1: Check for hierarchical structure
+  if (glob(".claude/product/domains/*/index.md").length > 0) {
+    return {
+      format: "hierarchical",
+      productRoot: ".claude/product",
+      completionStructure: "nested-domains",
+      tracking: "subtask-feature-domain"
+    };
+  }
+
+  // Priority 2: Check for flat structure (legacy)
+  if (exists("PRODUCT.md")) {
+    return {
+      format: "flat-legacy",
+      productRoot: ".",
+      productFile: "PRODUCT.md",
+      completionStructure: "flat-features",
+      tracking: "feature"
+    };
+  }
+
+  // Priority 3: Check for flat structure (new)
+  if (exists(".claude/product/index.md")) {
+    return {
+      format: "flat-new",
+      productRoot: ".claude/product",
+      productFile: ".claude/product/index.md",
+      completionStructure: "flat-features",
+      tracking: "feature"
+    };
+  }
+
+  // No product specification found
+  throw new Error("No product specification found. Please create either:" +
+    "\n  - PRODUCT.md (flat format)" +
+    "\n  - .claude/product/index.md (flat format)" +
+    "\n  - .claude/product/domains/*/index.md (hierarchical format)");
+}
+```
+
+## Backward Compatibility
+
+### Existing Projects
+
+**Projects with `PRODUCT.md`:**
+- Continue working without changes
+- Detected as flat format (legacy)
+- No migration required
+- Can migrate to hierarchical when ready
+
+**New Projects:**
+- Can use `.claude/product/index.md` for flat format
+- Can use `.claude/product/domains/*/` for hierarchical format
+- System auto-detects and adapts
+
+### Migration Path
+
+```
+Phase 1: Quick Start (Flat)
+└── PRODUCT.md
+    → All features in one file
+    → Track at feature level
+
+Phase 2: Organize (Flat, optional)
+└── .claude/product/index.md
+    → Same flat structure
+    → Better organization
+
+Phase 3: Scale Up (Hierarchical)
+└── .claude/product/domains/
+    ├── authentication/
+    │   ├── index.md
+    │   └── features/
+    │       ├── login.md
+    │       └── register.md
+    └── user-management/
+        └── ...
+    → Track at subtask → feature → domain levels
+    → Better for large projects and teams
+```
+
+## Benefits
+
+### For Users
+
+1. **Flexibility**: Choose format that fits project size
+2. **No Breaking Changes**: Existing projects continue working
+3. **Clear Migration Path**: Start flat, grow to hierarchical
+4. **No Configuration**: Auto-detection works automatically
+
+### For Teams
+
+1. **Small Teams**: Use flat structure for simplicity
+2. **Large Teams**: Use hierarchical for parallel work
+3. **Reduced Conflicts**: Separate domain/feature files
+4. **Better Organization**: Logical domain boundaries
+
+### For Agents
+
+1. **Consistent Detection**: Same algorithm in orchestrator and tracking skill
+2. **Clear Documentation**: Comprehensive examples and guides
+3. **Error Handling**: Helpful error messages when no spec found
+4. **Format Validation**: Verifies completion.json matches product files
+
+## Testing Recommendations
+
+To verify the implementation works:
+
+1. **Test Flat Structure (Legacy):**
+   ```bash
+   # Create PRODUCT.md at root
+   # Run orchestrator
+   # Verify flat format detected
+   # Check completion.json uses "features" object
+   ```
+
+2. **Test Flat Structure (New):**
+   ```bash
+   # Create .claude/product/index.md (without domains)
+   # Run orchestrator
+   # Verify flat format detected
+   # Check completion.json uses "features" object
+   ```
+
+3. **Test Hierarchical Structure:**
+   ```bash
+   # Create .claude/product/domains/authentication/index.md
+   # Run orchestrator
+   # Verify hierarchical format detected
+   # Check completion.json uses "domains" object
+   ```
+
+4. **Test Format Detection:**
+   ```bash
+   # Create both PRODUCT.md and .claude/product/domains/
+   # Verify hierarchical takes priority (Priority 1)
+   # Delete domains, verify PRODUCT.md detected (Priority 2)
+   ```
+
+## Documentation Files
+
+| File | Purpose | Lines |
+|------|---------|-------|
+| `.claude/agents/orchestrator.md` | Agent orchestration logic with format detection | 600+ |
+| `.claude/skills/product-tracking/SKILL.md` | Progress tracking for both formats | 650+ |
+| `.claude/product/README.md` | User guide for product structures | 350+ |
+| `.claude/product/EXAMPLES.md` | Concrete examples of both formats | 700+ |
+| `.claude/product/index.md` | Template with dual-format note | 150+ |
+| `.claude/product/CHANGES.md` | This file | Summary |
+
+## Summary
+
+The hybrid approach ensures:
+
+- **Backward Compatibility**: Existing projects work unchanged
+- **Forward Compatibility**: New projects can use organized structure
+- **Auto-Detection**: No configuration needed
+- **Clear Migration**: Path from simple to complex as projects grow
+- **Comprehensive Docs**: Examples, guides, and best practices
+
+Both old (PRODUCT.md) and new (.claude/product/domains/) approaches now work seamlessly!