@futdevpro/nts-dynamo 1.15.86 → 1.15.89

package/src/_modules/ai/_modules/open-ai/_services/oai-llm-chat.service-base.ts

@@ -1,635 +1,635 @@
-import { OpenAI } from 'openai';
-
-import { DyFM_OAI_Settings, DyFM_OAI_Model, DyFM_OAI_CallSettings } from '@futdevpro/fsm-dynamo/ai/open-ai';
-import { DyFM_AnyError, DyFM_Error, DyFM_Error_Settings, DyFM_getLocalStackLocation, DyFM_Log, DyFM_notNull, DyFM_Object, DyFM_Array } from '@futdevpro/fsm-dynamo';
-import { DyFM_AI_Message } from '@futdevpro/fsm-dynamo/ai';
-
-import { DyNTS_global_settings } from '../../../../../_collections/global-settings.const';
-import { ChatCompletion } from 'openai/resources';
-import { ChatCompletionCreateParamsBase, ChatCompletionMessageParam } from 'openai/resources/chat/completions';
-import { DyFM_AI_MessageRole } from '@futdevpro/fsm-dynamo/ai';
-import { DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests } from '../_models/interfaces/oai-llm-predefined-requests.interface';
-import { DyNTS_OAI_LLM_ServiceBase } from './oai-llm.service-base';
-import { DyNTS_OAI_global_settings } from '../_collections/oai-global-settings.const';
-import { DyNTS_AI_LLMChat_ServiceBase } from '../../../_services/ai-llm-chat.service-base';
-import {
-  DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input,
-  DyFM_AI_ConversationSelect_Input,
-  DyFM_AI_ConversationGenericSelect_Input,
-  DyFM_AI_ConversationMultiSelect_Input,
-  DyFM_AI_ConversationGenericMultiSelect_Input,
-  DyFM_AI_ConversationJSONKeysDescription_Input,
-  DyFM_AI_ConversationJSONExactKeys_Input,
-} from '../../../_models/ai-input-interfaces';
-
-
-/**
- * {
- *   organization: 'org-XY',
- *   apiKey: 'sk-XY',
- *   project: 'proj_XY',
- * }
- */
-
-// Di Dictionary DiModel DiEz DiAz
-
-export class DyNTS_OAI_LLMChat_ServiceBase extends DyNTS_OAI_LLM_ServiceBase implements DyNTS_AI_LLMChat_ServiceBase {
-  
-  // History management
-  /* private conversationHistories: Map<string, DyFM_AI_Message[]> = new Map(); */
-
-  /**
-   * Hozzáad egy üzenetet a conversation history-hoz
-   * 
-   * Adds a message to conversation history
-   */
-  /* addMessageToHistory(message: DyFM_AI_Message, issuer: string): void {
-    if (!this.conversationHistories.has(issuer)) {
-      this.conversationHistories.set(issuer, []);
-    }
-    this.conversationHistories.get(issuer).push(message);
-  } */
-
-  /**
-   * Törli a conversation history-t
-   * 
-   * Clears conversation history
-   */
-  /* clearHistory(issuer: string): void {
-    this.conversationHistories.delete(issuer);
-  } */
-
-  /**
-   * Visszaadja a conversation history-t
-   * 
-   * Gets conversation history
-   */
-  /* getHistory(issuer: string): DyFM_AI_Message[] {
-    return this.conversationHistories.get(issuer) || [];
-  } */
-
-  /**
-   * Converts generic AI messages to OpenAI-specific format
-   * 
-   * Az generic AI üzeneteket OpenAI-specifikus formátumra alakítja át
-   */
-  /* private convertToOAIMessages(messages: DyFM_AI_Message[]): DyFM_AI_Message[] {
-    return messages;
-  } */
-
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to answer a yes/no question
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.yesNo.request} to ask the question,
-   * and the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.yesNo.upperCaseYes} to check the answer
-   */
-  async requestYesNoInConversation(set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>): Promise<boolean> {
-    set.message += this.predefinedRequests.yesNo.request;
-
-    //this.logQuestion(set);
-
-    const answer: string = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
-
-    return this.convertAnswerToBoolean(answer);
-  }
-  //askYesNoQuestionInConversation: typeof this.yesNoQuestionInConversation = this.yesNoQuestionInConversation;
-
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to answer a simple question
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.simpleQuestion} to ask the question
-   */
-  /* async requestSimpleQuestionInConversation(
-    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
-  ): Promise<string> {
-    this.logQuestion(set);
-
-    return await this.getQuestionAnswerInConversation(set);
-  } */
-  //askSimpleQuestionInConversation: typeof this.simpleQuestionInConversation = this.simpleQuestionInConversation;
-
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to answer a percentage question
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.percentageOnly} to ask the question
-   */
-  async requestPercentageInConversation(
-    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
-  ): Promise<number> {
-    set.message += this.predefinedRequests.percentageOnly;
-
-    //this.logQuestion(set);
-
-    const answer: string = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
-
-    return this.convertAnswerToNumber(answer, set.message);
-  }
-  //askPercentageQuestionInConversation: typeof this.percentageQuestionInConversation = this.percentageQuestionInConversation;
-  
-
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to select one of the options from the list
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.selectRequest} to ask the question
-   */
-  async requestSelectInConversation<T>(
-    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationGenericSelect_Input<T, DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
-  ): Promise<T | { unparsableResult: string }> {
-    // replace the {{DyNTS_selectOptions}} with the list of options
-    const selectQuestionAddition = this.predefinedRequests.selectRequest.replace(
-      '{{DyNTS_selectOptions}}', 
-      this.getTextListAsText(this.stringifySelectOptions(set.selectFrom))
-    );
-    set.message += selectQuestionAddition;
-    
-    //this.logQuestion(set);
-
-    const answer = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
-    
-    return this.convertAnswerToSelectOption<T>(answer, set.message, set.selectFrom);
-  }
-  //askSelectQuestionInConversation: typeof this.selectQuestionInConversation = this.selectQuestionInConversation;
-
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to select one of the options from the list
-   * Similar to {@link askSelectQuestion}, 
-   * but with a more generic approach that can be used for objects
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.selectRequest} to ask the question
-   */
-  /* async requestSelectInConversation<T>(
-    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationGenericSelect_Input<T, DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
-  ): Promise<T | { unparsableResult: string }> {
-    const selectQuestionAddition = this.predefinedRequests.selectRequest.replace(
-      '{{DyNTS_selectOptions}}', 
-      this.getTextListAsText(set.selectFrom.map(item => `"${JSON.stringify(item)}"`))
-    );
-    set.message += selectQuestionAddition;
-
-    this.logQuestion(set); 
-
-    const answer = await this.getQuestionAnswerInConversation(set);
-
-    return DyFM_Object.safeParseJSON<T>(answer);
-  } */
-  //askRequestSelectInConversation: typeof this.requestSelectInConversation = this.requestSelectInConversation;
-
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to select one or more of the options from the list
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.multiselect} to ask the question
-   */
-  /* async requestMultiselectInConversation(set: DyFM_AI_ConversationMultiSelect_Input): Promise<string[]> {
-    const selectQuestionAddition = this.predefinedRequests.multiselect.replace(
-      '{{DyNTS_selectOptions}}', 
-      this.getTextListAsText(set.options)
-    );
-    set.message += selectQuestionAddition;
-
-    let answer = await this.getQuestionAnswerInConversation(set);
-    
-    answer = answer.toLocaleUpperCase();
-    
-    const result: string[] = [];
-
-    for (const item of set.options) {
-      if (answer.includes(item.toLocaleUpperCase())) {
-        result.push(item);
-      }
-    }
-
-    return result;
-  } */
-  //askMultipleSelectQuestionWithOptionsInConversation: typeof this.multipleSelectQuestionWithOptionsInConversation = this.multipleSelectQuestionWithOptionsInConversation;
-
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to select one or more of the options from the list
-   * Similar to {@link askMultipleSelectQuestionWithOptions}, 
-   * but with a more generic approach that can be used for objects
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.multiselect} to ask the question
-   */
-  async requestMultiselectInConversation<T>(
-    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationGenericMultiSelect_Input<T, DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
-  ): Promise<T[] | { unparsableResult: string }> {
-    const selectQuestionAddition = this.predefinedRequests.multiselect.replace(
-      '{{DyNTS_selectOptions}}', 
-      this.getTextListAsText(this.stringifySelectOptions(set.options))
-    );
-    set.message += selectQuestionAddition;
-    
-    //this.logQuestion(set);
-
-    const answer = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
-
-    return this.convertAnswerToList<T>(answer, set.message);
-  }
-  //askRequestMultipleSelectInConversation: typeof this.requestMultipleSelectInConversation = this.requestMultipleSelectInConversation;
-
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to answer a question that must result a JSON object
-   * 
-   * If the answer is not a valid JSON object, it will return { unparsableResult: answer }
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.jsonRequest} to ask the question
-   * 
-   * (uses {@link DyFM_safeParseJSON})
-   */
-  async requestJSONInConversation<T = any>(
-    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
-  ): Promise<T | { unparsableResult: string }> {
-    set.message += this.predefinedRequests.jsonRequest;
-
-    //this.logQuestion(set);
-
-    const answer = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
-    
-    return this.convertAnswerToJSON<T>(answer, set.message);
-  }
-  //askJsonQuestionInConversation: typeof this.jsonQuestionInConversation = this.jsonQuestionInConversation;
-
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to answer a question that must result a JSON object with specific key descriptions
-   * 
-   * If the answer is not a valid JSON object, it will return { unparsableResult: answer }
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.jsonRequestWithKeysDescription} to ask the question
-   * 
-   * (uses {@link DyFM_safeParseJSON})
-   */
-  /* async requestJSONInConversationWithKeysDescription<T = any>(
-    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationJSONKeysDescription_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
-  ): Promise<T | { unparsableResult: string }> {
-    return this.jsonQuestionWithKeysDescriptionInConversation<any>(set);
-  } */
-
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to answer a question that must result a JSON object with specific key descriptions
-   * 
-   * If the answer is not a valid JSON object, it will return { unparsableResult: answer }
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.jsonRequestWithKeysDescription} to ask the question
-   * 
-   * (uses {@link DyFM_safeParseJSON})
-   */
-  async requestJSONInConversationWithKeysDescription<T = any>(
-    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationJSONKeysDescription_Input
-  ): Promise<T | { unparsableResult: string }> {
-    const jsonRequestWithKeysDescription = this.predefinedRequests.jsonRequestWithKeysDescription.replace(
-      '{{DyNTS_jsonKeysDescription}}', 
-      set.keysDescription
-    );
-    set.message += jsonRequestWithKeysDescription;
-
-    //this.logQuestion(set);
-
-    const answer = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
-
-    return this.convertAnswerToJSON<T>(answer, set.message);
-  }
-  //askJsonQuestionWithKeysDescriptionInConversation: typeof this.jsonQuestionWithKeysDescriptionInConversation = this.jsonQuestionWithKeysDescriptionInConversation;
-
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to answer a question that must result a JSON object with specific keys
-   * 
-   * If the answer is not a valid JSON object, it will return { unparsableResult: answer }
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.jsonRequestWithExactKeys} to ask the question
-   * 
-   * (uses {@link DyFM_safeParseJSON})
-   */
-  /* async requestJSONInConversationWithExactKeys(set: DyFM_AI_ConversationJSONExactKeys_Input): Promise<object> {
-    const result = await this.jsonQuestionWithExactKeysInConversation<any>(set);
-    return typeof result === 'object' ? result : {};
-  } */
-
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to answer a question that must result a JSON object with specific keys
-   * 
-   * If the answer is not a valid JSON object, it will return { unparsableResult: answer }
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.jsonRequestWithExactKeys} to ask the question
-   * 
-   * (uses {@link DyFM_safeParseJSON})
-   */
-  async requestJSONInConversationWithExactKeys<T = any>(
-    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationJSONExactKeys_Input
-  ): Promise<T | { unparsableResult: string }> {
-    const jsonRequestWithExactKeys = this.predefinedRequests.jsonRequestWithExactKeys.replace(
-      '{{DyNTS_jsonKeys}}', 
-      this.getTextListAsText(set.keys)
-    );
-    set.message += jsonRequestWithExactKeys;
-
-    //this.logQuestion(set);
-
-    const answer = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
-
-    return this.convertAnswerToJSON<T>(answer, set.message);
-  }
-  //askJsonQuestionWithExactKeysInConversation: typeof this.jsonQuestionWithExactKeysInConversation = this.jsonQuestionWithExactKeysInConversation;
-
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to answer a question that must result a list of strings
-   * 
-   * If the answer is not a valid JSON list, it will return the answer as a single item in an array
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.listRequest} to ask the question
-   * 
-   * (uses {@link DyFM_Object.safeParseList})
-   */
-  async requestListInConversation<T = any>(
-    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
-  ): Promise<T[] | { unparsableResult: string }> {
-    set.message += this.predefinedRequests.listRequest;
-
-    //this.logQuestion(set);
-
-    const answer = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
-
-    return this.convertAnswerToList<T>(answer, set.message);
-  }
-  //askListQuestionInConversation: typeof this.listQuestionInConversation = this.listQuestionInConversation;
-
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to answer a question
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link resolveSimpleUserMessage}
-   */
-  /* async getQuestionAnswerInConversation(
-    conversation: DyFM_AI_Message[],
-    question: string, 
-    issuer: string,
-    debugLog?: boolean,
-    messageSettings: DyFM_OAI_CallSettings = this.defaultSettings
-  ): Promise<string> {
-    const answer = await this.resolveSimpleUserMessageInConversation(
-      conversation, 
-      question, 
-      issuer, 
-      messageSettings,
-    ) as Promise<string>;
-
-    if (debugLog) {
-      console.log(' - ', answer);
-    }
-
-    return answer;
-  } */
-
-  /* async requestSimpleQuestionInConversation(set: DyFM_AI_ConversationMessage_Input): Promise<string> {
-    return await this.getAnswerInConversation({
-      ...set,
-      newMessage: set.message,
-    });
-  } */
-  /* getQuestionAnswerInConversation = this.getAnswerInConversation; */
-  //getQuestionInConversation: typeof this.getQuestionAnswerInConversation = this.getQuestionAnswerInConversation;
-  //askQuestionInConversation: typeof this.getQuestionAnswerInConversation = this.getQuestionAnswerInConversation;
-  //getConversationAnswer: typeof this.getAnswerInConversation = this.getAnswerInConversation;
-  
-  /**
-   * Asks the AI to answer a question using the whole conversation
-   * (If you want to use only the conversation, without adding a new message, 
-   * use directly the {@link resolveConversation})
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link resolveConversation}
-   */
-  async requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>): Promise<string> {
-    // Convert generic AI messages to OpenAI-specific format
-    //const oaiConversation: DyFM_AI_Message[] = /* this.convertToOAIMessages(set.conversation) */ set.conversation;
-
-    if (set.message) {
-      set.conversation.push({
-        role: DyFM_AI_MessageRole.user,
-        content: set.message,
-      });
-    }
-
-    const answer: string = await this.resolveConversation({
-      ...set,
-      getFullResponse: false,
-    }) as string;
-
-    this.logAnswer(answer);
-
-    return answer;
-  }
-
-  /* async resolveConversationMessage(
-    set: {
-      conversation: DyFM_AI_Message[],
-      issuer: string,
-      settings?: DyFM_OAI_CallSettings,
-      getFullResponse?: boolean,
-      debugLog?: boolean,
-       * this is used to readably replace too long contents to eg '...' in logs
-      replaceThisInLog?: string,
-    }
-  ): Promise<string> {
-    return await this.resolveConversation(set) as string;
-  } */
-
-  /**
-   * Resolves a conversation
-   * 
-   * Uses the {@link getMessageCreateInput}
-   */
-  async resolveConversation(
-    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
-  ): Promise<string | ChatCompletion> {
-    try {
-      if (!set.conversation.some(message => message.role === DyFM_AI_MessageRole.system)) {
-        /* throw new DyFM_Error({
-          ...this.getDefaultErrorSettings(
-            'resolveConversation', 
-            new Error('System message found in conversation'), 
-            set.issuer
-          ),
-          errorCode: `${DyNTS_global_settings.systemShortCodeName}|DyNTS-OAB-RC1`,
-        }); */
-        /* DyFM_Log.error('System message found in conversation', {
-          conversation: set.conversation,
-        });
-      } else { */
-        set.conversation.unshift(this.getDefaultSystemMessage(set.settings));
-      }
-
-      // conversation shortening
-      const shortenedConversation = this.shortenConversation(set);
-
-      this.validateConversation(shortenedConversation);
-
-      //this.logQuestion(set);
-      
-      this.logConversation({
-        ...set,
-        conversation: shortenedConversation,
-      });
-
-      // FR-002 — per-call cost-event timing
-      const callInput = this.getMessageCreateInput({
-        ...set,
-        conversation: shortenedConversation,
-      });
-      const start: number = Date.now();
-      const result: ChatCompletion = await this.openai.chat.completions.create(
-        callInput,
-      ) as ChatCompletion;
-      const durationMs: number = Date.now() - start;
-
-      // FR-002 — cost-event emit (resolveConversation = 'llm-chat' flow alapból)
-      this.emitCostEvent({
-        callType: 'llm-chat',
-        provider: this.aiProvider,
-        model: String(callInput.model ?? this.defaultModel),
-        tokensUsed: {
-          input:  result.usage?.prompt_tokens ?? 0,
-          output: result.usage?.completion_tokens ?? 0,
-          total:  result.usage?.total_tokens ?? 0,
-        },
-        durationMs: durationMs,
-        issuer: set.issuer,
-        timestamp: new Date(),
-      });
-
-      if (set.getFullResponse) {
-        return result;
-      }
-
-      return result.choices[0].message.content;
-    } catch (error) {
-      throw new DyFM_Error({
-        ...this.getDefaultErrorSettings('resolveConversation', error, set.issuer),
-
-        errorCode: `${DyNTS_global_settings.systemShortCodeName}|DyNTS-OAB-RC0`,
-      });
-    }
-  }
-  //resolveSimpleUserMessageInConversation: typeof this.resolveConversation = this.resolveConversation;
-
-  protected shortenConversation(
-    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
-  ): DyFM_AI_Message[] {
-    try {
-      // Step 1: Clone the conversation to avoid mutating the original
-      const clonedConversation: DyFM_AI_Message[] = DyFM_Object.clone(set.conversation);
-      
-      // Step 2: Separate system messages from user/assistant messages
-      // System messages are kept and not shortened
-      const systemMessages: DyFM_AI_Message[] = clonedConversation.filter(
-        (message: DyFM_AI_Message): boolean => message.role === DyFM_AI_MessageRole.system
-      );
-      
-      // Step 3: Calculate system messages length as JSON string
-      // ⚠️ ISSUE: This measures JSON string length, not actual token count
-      // ⚠️ ISSUE: Doesn't account for message structure overhead (role, content keys, formatting)
-      const systemMessagesStringLength: number = JSON.stringify(systemMessages).length;
-      
-      // Step 4: Extract only content strings from non-system messages
-      // ⚠️ ISSUE: Only measuring content strings, not full message structure
-      // ⚠️ ISSUE: OpenAI counts tokens for full message format: {"role": "...", "content": "..."}
-      const msgs: string[] = clonedConversation.filter(
-        (message: DyFM_AI_Message): boolean => message.role !== DyFM_AI_MessageRole.system
-      ).map((message: DyFM_AI_Message): string => message.content);
-      
-      // Step 5: Stringify the content array to measure total length
-      // ⚠️ ISSUE: This is character count, not token count - ratio varies (1 token ≈ 1-4 chars)
-      let stringifiedMessages: string = JSON.stringify(msgs);
-
-      // Step 6: Log initial state if debug is enabled
-      if (this._debugLog || set.debugLog) {
-        DyFM_Log.info(
-          ' DyNTS_OAI_LLMChat_ServiceBase: before shortening conversation', {
-            stringifiedMessagesLength: stringifiedMessages.length,
-            conversationLength: clonedConversation.length,
-            lastMessage: DyFM_Array.last(clonedConversation)?.content,
-          }
-        );
-      }
-      
-      // Step 7: Initialize tracking variables
-      let removedMessagesCount: number = 0;
-      let lastStringifiedMessagesLength: number = stringifiedMessages.length;
-
-      // Step 8: Loop to remove messages until under character limit
-      // ⚠️ ISSUE: Comparing character count to token limit - different units!
-      // ⚠️ ISSUE: maxMessagesStringLength (120k chars) may not safely map to 128k tokens
-      // ⚠️ ISSUE: Condition allows single very long message to remain (length > 1)
-      while (
-        (stringifiedMessages.length + systemMessagesStringLength) > DyNTS_OAI_global_settings.maxMessagesStringLength &&
-        clonedConversation.length > 1
-      ) {
-        // Step 8a: Remove oldest message from full conversation
-        clonedConversation.splice(0, 1);
-        
-        // Step 8b: Remove corresponding content from msgs array
-        // ⚠️ CRITICAL BUG: Always removes from msgs, even if removed message was a system message!
-        // ⚠️ This causes array desynchronization - msgs and clonedConversation get out of sync
-        msgs.splice(0, 1);
-        
-        removedMessagesCount++;
-        
-        // Step 8c: Recalculate stringified length after removal
-        stringifiedMessages = JSON.stringify(msgs);
-        lastStringifiedMessagesLength = stringifiedMessages.length;
-      }
-
-      // Step 9: Log final state if debug is enabled
-      if (this._debugLog || set.debugLog) {
-        DyFM_Log.info(
-          ' DyNTS_OAI_LLMChat_ServiceBase: after shortening conversation', {
-            removedMessagesCount: removedMessagesCount,
-            lastStringifiedMessagesLength: lastStringifiedMessagesLength,
-            lastMessage: DyFM_Array.last(clonedConversation)?.content,
-            localStackLocation: DyFM_getLocalStackLocation(),
-          }
-        );
-      }
-  
-      // Step 10: Safety check - ensure we didn't remove everything
-      if (!clonedConversation.length) {
-        DyFM_Log.error('No conversation messages (left)', { 
-          /* conversation: DyFM_Object.clone(conversation), */
-          conversationLength: set.conversation.length,
-          clonedConversation: DyFM_Object.clone(clonedConversation),
-        });
-        throw new Error('No conversation messages (left)');
-      }
-
-      // Step 11: Reconstruct conversation: system messages first, then shortened non-system messages
-      // ⚠️ ISSUE: clonedConversation may still contain system messages mixed in
-      // ⚠️ This could result in duplicate system messages in the final array
-      return [ ...systemMessages, ...clonedConversation ];
-    } catch (error) {
-      DyFM_Error.logSimple('❌❌ Error shortening conversation:', error);
-
-      throw new DyFM_Error({
-        ...this.getDefaultErrorSettings('shortenConversation', error, set.issuer),
-        
-        errorCode: `${DyNTS_global_settings.systemShortCodeName}|DyNTS-OAB-SC0`,
-      });
-    } 
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Kérdez egy kérdést és JSON választ vár exact keys-szel
-   * 
-   * Asks a question and expects JSON response with exact keys
-   */
-  /* async requestJSONInConversationWithExactKeys<T>(
-    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationJSONExactKeys_Input
-  ): Promise<T> {
-    const answer = await this.jsonQuestionWithExactKeysInConversation<any>(set);
-    
-    if ('unparsableResult' in answer) {
-      throw new DyFM_Error({
-        message: 'Invalid JSON response from AI',
-        additionalContent: { answer },
-        userMessage: 'Failed to parse AI response'
-      });
-    }
-    
-    return answer as T;
-  } */
+import { OpenAI } from 'openai';
+
+import { DyFM_OAI_Settings, DyFM_OAI_Model, DyFM_OAI_CallSettings } from '@futdevpro/fsm-dynamo/ai/open-ai';
+import { DyFM_AnyError, DyFM_Error, DyFM_Error_Settings, DyFM_getLocalStackLocation, DyFM_Log, DyFM_notNull, DyFM_Object, DyFM_Array } from '@futdevpro/fsm-dynamo';
+import { DyFM_AI_Message } from '@futdevpro/fsm-dynamo/ai';
+
+import { DyNTS_global_settings } from '../../../../../_collections/global-settings.const';
+import { ChatCompletion } from 'openai/resources';
+import { ChatCompletionCreateParamsBase, ChatCompletionMessageParam } from 'openai/resources/chat/completions';
+import { DyFM_AI_MessageRole } from '@futdevpro/fsm-dynamo/ai';
+import { DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests } from '../_models/interfaces/oai-llm-predefined-requests.interface';
+import { DyNTS_OAI_LLM_ServiceBase } from './oai-llm.service-base';
+import { DyNTS_OAI_global_settings } from '../_collections/oai-global-settings.const';
+import { DyNTS_AI_LLMChat_ServiceBase } from '../../../_services/ai-llm-chat.service-base';
+import {
+  DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input,
+  DyFM_AI_ConversationSelect_Input,
+  DyFM_AI_ConversationGenericSelect_Input,
+  DyFM_AI_ConversationMultiSelect_Input,
+  DyFM_AI_ConversationGenericMultiSelect_Input,
+  DyFM_AI_ConversationJSONKeysDescription_Input,
+  DyFM_AI_ConversationJSONExactKeys_Input,
+} from '../../../_models/ai-input-interfaces';
+
+
+/**
+ * {
+ *   organization: 'org-XY',
+ *   apiKey: 'sk-XY',
+ *   project: 'proj_XY',
+ * }
+ */
+
+// Di Dictionary DiModel DiEz DiAz
+
+export class DyNTS_OAI_LLMChat_ServiceBase extends DyNTS_OAI_LLM_ServiceBase implements DyNTS_AI_LLMChat_ServiceBase {
+  
+  // History management
+  /* private conversationHistories: Map<string, DyFM_AI_Message[]> = new Map(); */
+
+  /**
+   * Hozzáad egy üzenetet a conversation history-hoz
+   * 
+   * Adds a message to conversation history
+   */
+  /* addMessageToHistory(message: DyFM_AI_Message, issuer: string): void {
+    if (!this.conversationHistories.has(issuer)) {
+      this.conversationHistories.set(issuer, []);
+    }
+    this.conversationHistories.get(issuer).push(message);
+  } */
+
+  /**
+   * Törli a conversation history-t
+   * 
+   * Clears conversation history
+   */
+  /* clearHistory(issuer: string): void {
+    this.conversationHistories.delete(issuer);
+  } */
+
+  /**
+   * Visszaadja a conversation history-t
+   * 
+   * Gets conversation history
+   */
+  /* getHistory(issuer: string): DyFM_AI_Message[] {
+    return this.conversationHistories.get(issuer) || [];
+  } */
+
+  /**
+   * Converts generic AI messages to OpenAI-specific format
+   * 
+   * Az generic AI üzeneteket OpenAI-specifikus formátumra alakítja át
+   */
+  /* private convertToOAIMessages(messages: DyFM_AI_Message[]): DyFM_AI_Message[] {
+    return messages;
+  } */
+
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to answer a yes/no question
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.yesNo.request} to ask the question,
+   * and the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.yesNo.upperCaseYes} to check the answer
+   */
+  async requestYesNoInConversation(set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>): Promise<boolean> {
+    set.message += this.predefinedRequests.yesNo.request;
+
+    //this.logQuestion(set);
+
+    const answer: string = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
+
+    return this.convertAnswerToBoolean(answer);
+  }
+  //askYesNoQuestionInConversation: typeof this.yesNoQuestionInConversation = this.yesNoQuestionInConversation;
+
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to answer a simple question
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.simpleQuestion} to ask the question
+   */
+  /* async requestSimpleQuestionInConversation(
+    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
+  ): Promise<string> {
+    this.logQuestion(set);
+
+    return await this.getQuestionAnswerInConversation(set);
+  } */
+  //askSimpleQuestionInConversation: typeof this.simpleQuestionInConversation = this.simpleQuestionInConversation;
+
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to answer a percentage question
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.percentageOnly} to ask the question
+   */
+  async requestPercentageInConversation(
+    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
+  ): Promise<number> {
+    set.message += this.predefinedRequests.percentageOnly;
+
+    //this.logQuestion(set);
+
+    const answer: string = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
+
+    return this.convertAnswerToNumber(answer, set.message);
+  }
+  //askPercentageQuestionInConversation: typeof this.percentageQuestionInConversation = this.percentageQuestionInConversation;
+  
+
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to select one of the options from the list
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.selectRequest} to ask the question
+   */
+  async requestSelectInConversation<T>(
+    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationGenericSelect_Input<T, DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
+  ): Promise<T | { unparsableResult: string }> {
+    // replace the {{DyNTS_selectOptions}} with the list of options
+    const selectQuestionAddition = this.predefinedRequests.selectRequest.replace(
+      '{{DyNTS_selectOptions}}', 
+      this.getTextListAsText(this.stringifySelectOptions(set.selectFrom))
+    );
+    set.message += selectQuestionAddition;
+    
+    //this.logQuestion(set);
+
+    const answer = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
+    
+    return this.convertAnswerToSelectOption<T>(answer, set.message, set.selectFrom);
+  }
+  //askSelectQuestionInConversation: typeof this.selectQuestionInConversation = this.selectQuestionInConversation;
+
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to select one of the options from the list
+   * Similar to {@link askSelectQuestion}, 
+   * but with a more generic approach that can be used for objects
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.selectRequest} to ask the question
+   */
+  /* async requestSelectInConversation<T>(
+    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationGenericSelect_Input<T, DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
+  ): Promise<T | { unparsableResult: string }> {
+    const selectQuestionAddition = this.predefinedRequests.selectRequest.replace(
+      '{{DyNTS_selectOptions}}', 
+      this.getTextListAsText(set.selectFrom.map(item => `"${JSON.stringify(item)}"`))
+    );
+    set.message += selectQuestionAddition;
+
+    this.logQuestion(set); 
+
+    const answer = await this.getQuestionAnswerInConversation(set);
+
+    return DyFM_Object.safeParseJSON<T>(answer);
+  } */
+  //askRequestSelectInConversation: typeof this.requestSelectInConversation = this.requestSelectInConversation;
+
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to select one or more of the options from the list
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.multiselect} to ask the question
+   */
+  /* async requestMultiselectInConversation(set: DyFM_AI_ConversationMultiSelect_Input): Promise<string[]> {
+    const selectQuestionAddition = this.predefinedRequests.multiselect.replace(
+      '{{DyNTS_selectOptions}}', 
+      this.getTextListAsText(set.options)
+    );
+    set.message += selectQuestionAddition;
+
+    let answer = await this.getQuestionAnswerInConversation(set);
+    
+    answer = answer.toLocaleUpperCase();
+    
+    const result: string[] = [];
+
+    for (const item of set.options) {
+      if (answer.includes(item.toLocaleUpperCase())) {
+        result.push(item);
+      }
+    }
+
+    return result;
+  } */
+  //askMultipleSelectQuestionWithOptionsInConversation: typeof this.multipleSelectQuestionWithOptionsInConversation = this.multipleSelectQuestionWithOptionsInConversation;
+
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to select one or more of the options from the list
+   * Similar to {@link askMultipleSelectQuestionWithOptions}, 
+   * but with a more generic approach that can be used for objects
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.multiselect} to ask the question
+   */
+  async requestMultiselectInConversation<T>(
+    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationGenericMultiSelect_Input<T, DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
+  ): Promise<T[] | { unparsableResult: string }> {
+    const selectQuestionAddition = this.predefinedRequests.multiselect.replace(
+      '{{DyNTS_selectOptions}}', 
+      this.getTextListAsText(this.stringifySelectOptions(set.options))
+    );
+    set.message += selectQuestionAddition;
+    
+    //this.logQuestion(set);
+
+    const answer = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
+
+    return this.convertAnswerToList<T>(answer, set.message);
+  }
+  //askRequestMultipleSelectInConversation: typeof this.requestMultipleSelectInConversation = this.requestMultipleSelectInConversation;
+
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to answer a question that must result a JSON object
+   * 
+   * If the answer is not a valid JSON object, it will return { unparsableResult: answer }
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.jsonRequest} to ask the question
+   * 
+   * (uses {@link DyFM_safeParseJSON})
+   */
+  async requestJSONInConversation<T = any>(
+    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
+  ): Promise<T | { unparsableResult: string }> {
+    set.message += this.predefinedRequests.jsonRequest;
+
+    //this.logQuestion(set);
+
+    const answer = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
+    
+    return this.convertAnswerToJSON<T>(answer, set.message);
+  }
+  //askJsonQuestionInConversation: typeof this.jsonQuestionInConversation = this.jsonQuestionInConversation;
+
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to answer a question that must result a JSON object with specific key descriptions
+   * 
+   * If the answer is not a valid JSON object, it will return { unparsableResult: answer }
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.jsonRequestWithKeysDescription} to ask the question
+   * 
+   * (uses {@link DyFM_safeParseJSON})
+   */
+  /* async requestJSONInConversationWithKeysDescription<T = any>(
+    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationJSONKeysDescription_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
+  ): Promise<T | { unparsableResult: string }> {
+    return this.jsonQuestionWithKeysDescriptionInConversation<any>(set);
+  } */
+
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to answer a question that must result a JSON object with specific key descriptions
+   * 
+   * If the answer is not a valid JSON object, it will return { unparsableResult: answer }
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.jsonRequestWithKeysDescription} to ask the question
+   * 
+   * (uses {@link DyFM_safeParseJSON})
+   */
+  async requestJSONInConversationWithKeysDescription<T = any>(
+    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationJSONKeysDescription_Input
+  ): Promise<T | { unparsableResult: string }> {
+    const jsonRequestWithKeysDescription = this.predefinedRequests.jsonRequestWithKeysDescription.replace(
+      '{{DyNTS_jsonKeysDescription}}', 
+      set.keysDescription
+    );
+    set.message += jsonRequestWithKeysDescription;
+
+    //this.logQuestion(set);
+
+    const answer = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
+
+    return this.convertAnswerToJSON<T>(answer, set.message);
+  }
+  //askJsonQuestionWithKeysDescriptionInConversation: typeof this.jsonQuestionWithKeysDescriptionInConversation = this.jsonQuestionWithKeysDescriptionInConversation;
+
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to answer a question that must result a JSON object with specific keys
+   * 
+   * If the answer is not a valid JSON object, it will return { unparsableResult: answer }
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.jsonRequestWithExactKeys} to ask the question
+   * 
+   * (uses {@link DyFM_safeParseJSON})
+   */
+  /* async requestJSONInConversationWithExactKeys(set: DyFM_AI_ConversationJSONExactKeys_Input): Promise<object> {
+    const result = await this.jsonQuestionWithExactKeysInConversation<any>(set);
+    return typeof result === 'object' ? result : {};
+  } */
+
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to answer a question that must result a JSON object with specific keys
+   * 
+   * If the answer is not a valid JSON object, it will return { unparsableResult: answer }
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.jsonRequestWithExactKeys} to ask the question
+   * 
+   * (uses {@link DyFM_safeParseJSON})
+   */
+  async requestJSONInConversationWithExactKeys<T = any>(
+    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationJSONExactKeys_Input
+  ): Promise<T | { unparsableResult: string }> {
+    const jsonRequestWithExactKeys = this.predefinedRequests.jsonRequestWithExactKeys.replace(
+      '{{DyNTS_jsonKeys}}', 
+      this.getTextListAsText(set.keys)
+    );
+    set.message += jsonRequestWithExactKeys;
+
+    //this.logQuestion(set);
+
+    const answer = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
+
+    return this.convertAnswerToJSON<T>(answer, set.message);
+  }
+  //askJsonQuestionWithExactKeysInConversation: typeof this.jsonQuestionWithExactKeysInConversation = this.jsonQuestionWithExactKeysInConversation;
+
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to answer a question that must result a list of strings
+   * 
+   * If the answer is not a valid JSON list, it will return the answer as a single item in an array
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link DyNTS_OAI_LLM_Predefined_Requests.listRequest} to ask the question
+   * 
+   * (uses {@link DyFM_Object.safeParseList})
+   */
+  async requestListInConversation<T = any>(
+    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
+  ): Promise<T[] | { unparsableResult: string }> {
+    set.message += this.predefinedRequests.listRequest;
+
+    //this.logQuestion(set);
+
+    const answer = await this.requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set);
+
+    return this.convertAnswerToList<T>(answer, set.message);
+  }
+  //askListQuestionInConversation: typeof this.listQuestionInConversation = this.listQuestionInConversation;
+
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to answer a question
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link resolveSimpleUserMessage}
+   */
+  /* async getQuestionAnswerInConversation(
+    conversation: DyFM_AI_Message[],
+    question: string, 
+    issuer: string,
+    debugLog?: boolean,
+    messageSettings: DyFM_OAI_CallSettings = this.defaultSettings
+  ): Promise<string> {
+    const answer = await this.resolveSimpleUserMessageInConversation(
+      conversation, 
+      question, 
+      issuer, 
+      messageSettings,
+    ) as Promise<string>;
+
+    if (debugLog) {
+      console.log(' - ', answer);
+    }
+
+    return answer;
+  } */
+
+  /* async requestSimpleQuestionInConversation(set: DyFM_AI_ConversationMessage_Input): Promise<string> {
+    return await this.getAnswerInConversation({
+      ...set,
+      newMessage: set.message,
+    });
+  } */
+  /* getQuestionAnswerInConversation = this.getAnswerInConversation; */
+  //getQuestionInConversation: typeof this.getQuestionAnswerInConversation = this.getQuestionAnswerInConversation;
+  //askQuestionInConversation: typeof this.getQuestionAnswerInConversation = this.getQuestionAnswerInConversation;
+  //getConversationAnswer: typeof this.getAnswerInConversation = this.getAnswerInConversation;
+  
+  /**
+   * Asks the AI to answer a question using the whole conversation
+   * (If you want to use only the conversation, without adding a new message, 
+   * use directly the {@link resolveConversation})
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link resolveConversation}
+   */
+  async requestSimpleMessageInConversation(set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>): Promise<string> {
+    // Convert generic AI messages to OpenAI-specific format
+    //const oaiConversation: DyFM_AI_Message[] = /* this.convertToOAIMessages(set.conversation) */ set.conversation;
+
+    if (set.message) {
+      set.conversation.push({
+        role: DyFM_AI_MessageRole.user,
+        content: set.message,
+      });
+    }
+
+    const answer: string = await this.resolveConversation({
+      ...set,
+      getFullResponse: false,
+    }) as string;
+
+    this.logAnswer(answer);
+
+    return answer;
+  }
+
+  /* async resolveConversationMessage(
+    set: {
+      conversation: DyFM_AI_Message[],
+      issuer: string,
+      settings?: DyFM_OAI_CallSettings,
+      getFullResponse?: boolean,
+      debugLog?: boolean,
+       * this is used to readably replace too long contents to eg '...' in logs
+      replaceThisInLog?: string,
+    }
+  ): Promise<string> {
+    return await this.resolveConversation(set) as string;
+  } */
+
+  /**
+   * Resolves a conversation
+   * 
+   * Uses the {@link getMessageCreateInput}
+   */
+  async resolveConversation(
+    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
+  ): Promise<string | ChatCompletion> {
+    try {
+      if (!set.conversation.some(message => message.role === DyFM_AI_MessageRole.system)) {
+        /* throw new DyFM_Error({
+          ...this.getDefaultErrorSettings(
+            'resolveConversation', 
+            new Error('System message found in conversation'), 
+            set.issuer
+          ),
+          errorCode: `${DyNTS_global_settings.systemShortCodeName}|DyNTS-OAB-RC1`,
+        }); */
+        /* DyFM_Log.error('System message found in conversation', {
+          conversation: set.conversation,
+        });
+      } else { */
+        set.conversation.unshift(this.getDefaultSystemMessage(set.settings));
+      }
+
+      // conversation shortening
+      const shortenedConversation = this.shortenConversation(set);
+
+      this.validateConversation(shortenedConversation);
+
+      //this.logQuestion(set);
+      
+      this.logConversation({
+        ...set,
+        conversation: shortenedConversation,
+      });
+
+      // FR-002 — per-call cost-event timing
+      const callInput = this.getMessageCreateInput({
+        ...set,
+        conversation: shortenedConversation,
+      });
+      const start: number = Date.now();
+      const result: ChatCompletion = await this.openai.chat.completions.create(
+        callInput,
+      ) as ChatCompletion;
+      const durationMs: number = Date.now() - start;
+
+      // FR-002 — cost-event emit (resolveConversation = 'llm-chat' flow alapból)
+      this.emitCostEvent({
+        callType: 'llm-chat',
+        provider: this.aiProvider,
+        model: String(callInput.model ?? this.defaultModel),
+        tokensUsed: {
+          input:  result.usage?.prompt_tokens ?? 0,
+          output: result.usage?.completion_tokens ?? 0,
+          total:  result.usage?.total_tokens ?? 0,
+        },
+        durationMs: durationMs,
+        issuer: set.issuer,
+        timestamp: new Date(),
+      });
+
+      if (set.getFullResponse) {
+        return result;
+      }
+
+      return result.choices[0].message.content;
+    } catch (error) {
+      throw new DyFM_Error({
+        ...this.getDefaultErrorSettings('resolveConversation', error, set.issuer),
+
+        errorCode: `${DyNTS_global_settings.systemShortCodeName}|DyNTS-OAB-RC0`,
+      });
+    }
+  }
+  //resolveSimpleUserMessageInConversation: typeof this.resolveConversation = this.resolveConversation;
+
+  protected shortenConversation(
+    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationBase_Input<DyFM_OAI_CallSettings>
+  ): DyFM_AI_Message[] {
+    try {
+      // Step 1: Clone the conversation to avoid mutating the original
+      const clonedConversation: DyFM_AI_Message[] = DyFM_Object.clone(set.conversation);
+      
+      // Step 2: Separate system messages from user/assistant messages
+      // System messages are kept and not shortened
+      const systemMessages: DyFM_AI_Message[] = clonedConversation.filter(
+        (message: DyFM_AI_Message): boolean => message.role === DyFM_AI_MessageRole.system
+      );
+      
+      // Step 3: Calculate system messages length as JSON string
+      // ⚠️ ISSUE: This measures JSON string length, not actual token count
+      // ⚠️ ISSUE: Doesn't account for message structure overhead (role, content keys, formatting)
+      const systemMessagesStringLength: number = JSON.stringify(systemMessages).length;
+      
+      // Step 4: Extract only content strings from non-system messages
+      // ⚠️ ISSUE: Only measuring content strings, not full message structure
+      // ⚠️ ISSUE: OpenAI counts tokens for full message format: {"role": "...", "content": "..."}
+      const msgs: string[] = clonedConversation.filter(
+        (message: DyFM_AI_Message): boolean => message.role !== DyFM_AI_MessageRole.system
+      ).map((message: DyFM_AI_Message): string => message.content);
+      
+      // Step 5: Stringify the content array to measure total length
+      // ⚠️ ISSUE: This is character count, not token count - ratio varies (1 token ≈ 1-4 chars)
+      let stringifiedMessages: string = JSON.stringify(msgs);
+
+      // Step 6: Log initial state if debug is enabled
+      if (this._debugLog || set.debugLog) {
+        DyFM_Log.info(
+          ' DyNTS_OAI_LLMChat_ServiceBase: before shortening conversation', {
+            stringifiedMessagesLength: stringifiedMessages.length,
+            conversationLength: clonedConversation.length,
+            lastMessage: DyFM_Array.last(clonedConversation)?.content,
+          }
+        );
+      }
+      
+      // Step 7: Initialize tracking variables
+      let removedMessagesCount: number = 0;
+      let lastStringifiedMessagesLength: number = stringifiedMessages.length;
+
+      // Step 8: Loop to remove messages until under character limit
+      // ⚠️ ISSUE: Comparing character count to token limit - different units!
+      // ⚠️ ISSUE: maxMessagesStringLength (120k chars) may not safely map to 128k tokens
+      // ⚠️ ISSUE: Condition allows single very long message to remain (length > 1)
+      while (
+        (stringifiedMessages.length + systemMessagesStringLength) > DyNTS_OAI_global_settings.maxMessagesStringLength &&
+        clonedConversation.length > 1
+      ) {
+        // Step 8a: Remove oldest message from full conversation
+        clonedConversation.splice(0, 1);
+        
+        // Step 8b: Remove corresponding content from msgs array
+        // ⚠️ CRITICAL BUG: Always removes from msgs, even if removed message was a system message!
+        // ⚠️ This causes array desynchronization - msgs and clonedConversation get out of sync
+        msgs.splice(0, 1);
+        
+        removedMessagesCount++;
+        
+        // Step 8c: Recalculate stringified length after removal
+        stringifiedMessages = JSON.stringify(msgs);
+        lastStringifiedMessagesLength = stringifiedMessages.length;
+      }
+
+      // Step 9: Log final state if debug is enabled
+      if (this._debugLog || set.debugLog) {
+        DyFM_Log.info(
+          ' DyNTS_OAI_LLMChat_ServiceBase: after shortening conversation', {
+            removedMessagesCount: removedMessagesCount,
+            lastStringifiedMessagesLength: lastStringifiedMessagesLength,
+            lastMessage: DyFM_Array.last(clonedConversation)?.content,
+            localStackLocation: DyFM_getLocalStackLocation(),
+          }
+        );
+      }
+  
+      // Step 10: Safety check - ensure we didn't remove everything
+      if (!clonedConversation.length) {
+        DyFM_Log.error('No conversation messages (left)', { 
+          /* conversation: DyFM_Object.clone(conversation), */
+          conversationLength: set.conversation.length,
+          clonedConversation: DyFM_Object.clone(clonedConversation),
+        });
+        throw new Error('No conversation messages (left)');
+      }
+
+      // Step 11: Reconstruct conversation: system messages first, then shortened non-system messages
+      // ⚠️ ISSUE: clonedConversation may still contain system messages mixed in
+      // ⚠️ This could result in duplicate system messages in the final array
+      return [ ...systemMessages, ...clonedConversation ];
+    } catch (error) {
+      DyFM_Error.logSimple('❌❌ Error shortening conversation:', error);
+
+      throw new DyFM_Error({
+        ...this.getDefaultErrorSettings('shortenConversation', error, set.issuer),
+        
+        errorCode: `${DyNTS_global_settings.systemShortCodeName}|DyNTS-OAB-SC0`,
+      });
+    } 
+  }
+
+  /**
+   * Kérdez egy kérdést és JSON választ vár exact keys-szel
+   * 
+   * Asks a question and expects JSON response with exact keys
+   */
+  /* async requestJSONInConversationWithExactKeys<T>(
+    set: DyFM_AI_ConversationJSONExactKeys_Input
+  ): Promise<T> {
+    const answer = await this.jsonQuestionWithExactKeysInConversation<any>(set);
+    
+    if ('unparsableResult' in answer) {
+      throw new DyFM_Error({
+        message: 'Invalid JSON response from AI',
+        additionalContent: { answer },
+        userMessage: 'Failed to parse AI response'
+      });
+    }
+    
+    return answer as T;
+  } */
 }