@furongjun1999/dsh-memory 0.4.7 → 0.4.8

package/md_cg/test_mr_m3.py

@@ -0,0 +1,703 @@
+# -*- coding: utf-8 -*-
+"""M3 定位自测（D1 字段级定位）：六类定位器 + 契约四键 + 批量/包 + 零写入。
+
+真源：docs/记忆评审系统_立项设计与施工交接_20260915.md §5 D1
+      `locate(node_id, issue_hint) -> [{field, span, issue_kind, evidence}]`
+
+纪律（同 test_mr_m1/m2）：
+  · **自备数据源**——合成节点 + tempfile 合成库，零依赖真源库（外部 clone 全绿）。
+  · **零写入实锤**——全部相位跑完后认知图指纹逐字节不变（M3 是只读模块）。
+  · **确定性**——同一输入两次调用逐字节一致；`now` 显式传入，不靠墙钟。
+  · **不猜**——语义级矛盾归 blindspot（`contradiction_semantic`），不编造字符区间。
+
+覆盖：A 基础工具（纯函数）  B 问题面定位器（含字段层门限、指纹不一致成因）+ 观测面
+      （observation_aged：观测时刻不是失效声明，**不进告警面**）
+      C 提示过滤与 blindspot（含 stale 的**依赖存在性**判据：载体消失/漂移）
+      D 契约与确定性  E 批量与包  F 零写入
+运行：python -m md_cg.test_mr_m3
+"""
+from __future__ import annotations
+
+import hashlib
+import json
+import os
+import shutil
+import sys
+import tempfile
+
+from . import codeindex as CI
+from . import conformance as CF
+from . import nodefile as NF
+from . import writelimit as WL
+from .mreview import locate as LC
+
+PASS = FAIL = SKIP = 0
+FAILS = []
+
+
+def ok(cond, label):
+    global PASS, FAIL
+    if cond:
+        PASS += 1
+    else:
+        FAIL += 1
+        FAILS.append(label)
+        print("  FAIL %s" % label)
+
+
+def skip(label):
+    global SKIP
+    SKIP += 1
+    print("  SKIP %s" % label)
+
+
+# ---------------------------- 合成库 ----------------------------
+
+def ccg(fn="示例节点", *, 生效="载体/位置：本地仓；时间：全时窗（任意时刻成立）；方法：test；约束：无",
+        sub="a/b", exe="python -m md_cg.demo", ver="test", neg="无", extra=""):
+    """六要素齐全的正文（防 `_loc_missing_field` 的 CCG 缺行噪声干扰其它判据）。"""
+    return ("# 功能名：%s\n# 生效条件：%s\n# 子功能：%s\n# 执行：%s\n"
+            "# 验证方式：%s\n# 不适用条件：%s\n%s" % (fn, 生效, sub, exe, ver, neg, extra))
+
+
+def full_cs(*, pos="本地仓", tw=(0.0, 9999999999.0), tool="test", con="无"):
+    return {"observation_position": pos, "time_window": list(tw),
+            "observation_tool": tool, "existence_constraint": con}
+
+
+def mkroot(root, nodes):
+    """合成认知图根：`_index.json` + 节点盘文件（文件文本由 NF.dumps 生成）。"""
+    os.makedirs(root, exist_ok=True)
+    idx = {}
+    for nid, spec in nodes.items():
+        fm = dict(spec.get("fm") or {})
+        fm.setdefault("id", nid)
+        content = spec.get("content") or ""
+        rel = spec.get("path") or ("knowledge/%s.md" % nid)
+        p = os.path.join(root, rel)
+        os.makedirs(os.path.dirname(p), exist_ok=True)
+        with open(p, "w", encoding="utf-8") as f:
+            f.write(NF.dumps(fm, content))
+        meta = dict(spec.get("meta") or {})
+        meta.setdefault("path", rel)
+        meta.setdefault("layer", spec.get("layer") or "knowledge")
+        meta.setdefault("content_hash", NF.content_hash(content))
+        meta.update({"id": nid, "path": rel})
+        meta["path"] = rel
+        idx[nid] = meta
+    with open(os.path.join(root, CF.INDEX_FILE), "w", encoding="utf-8") as f:
+        json.dump({"nodes": idx}, f, ensure_ascii=False)
+    return root
+
+
+def snapshot(root):
+    out = {}
+    for dp, _dns, fns in os.walk(root):
+        for fn in fns:
+            p = os.path.join(dp, fn)
+            with open(p, "rb") as f:
+                out[os.path.relpath(p, root)] = hashlib.md5(f.read()).hexdigest()
+    return out
+
+
+def kinds_of(hits):
+    return sorted({h["issue_kind"] for h in hits})
+
+
+def fields_of(hits, kind=None):
+    return sorted({h["field"] for h in hits if kind is None or h["issue_kind"] == kind})
+
+
+NOW = 1789000000.0        # 固定「当前时间」（2026-09 量级），不靠墙钟
+EXPIRED = (1000.0, 2000.0)
+
+
+# ---------------------------- A 组：基础工具 ----------------------------
+
+def phase_a(tmp):
+    print("[A] 基础工具（纯函数）")
+
+    c = "第一句。第二句！第三句？第四句；"
+    sp = LC.sentence_spans(c)
+    ok(len(sp) == 4 and [i for i, _s, _e, _t in sp] == [0, 1, 2, 3],
+       "A1 sentence_spans 句索引连续（%s）" % [i for i, _s, _e, _t in sp])
+    ok(all(c[s:e] == t for _i, s, e, t in sp), "A2 span 与原文切片逐字对应")
+    ok(LC.sentence_spans("") == [] and LC.sentence_spans("   ") == [],
+       "A3 空/纯空白正文零句（不编号空句）")
+    ok([t for _i, _s, _e, t in LC.sentence_spans("甲。\n乙。")] == ["甲。", "乙。"],
+       "A4 换行是句尾且空句不编号（分隔符不残留在句首）")
+
+    body = ccg(extra="尾句。")
+    ms = LC.mark_spans(body)
+    ok(set(ms) == set(NF.CCG_MARKS), "A5 mark_spans 六要素全提（实得 %s）" % sorted(ms))
+    ok(all(body[s:e].startswith("#") for s, e in ms.values()),
+       "A6 要素行 span 覆盖整行")
+    ok(LC.mark_spans(ccg() + "# 功能名：第二个\n").get("功能名")
+       == LC.mark_spans(ccg()).get("功能名"), "A7 同要素取首次出现（确定性）")
+
+    text = NF.dumps({"id": "n1", "path": "knowledge/n1.md", "tags": []}, ccg())
+    ks = LC.key_line_spans(text)
+    ok(ks.get("id", (None, None))[0] == 2, "A8 key_line_spans 行号 1-based（实得 %s）"
+       % (ks.get("id") or (None,))[0])
+    ok("功能名" not in ks and "---" not in ks,
+       "A9 正文 `#` 行与 `---` 分隔线都排除在 frontmatter 之外")
+    ok(ks.get("id") and text[ks["id"][1][0]:ks["id"][1][1]].startswith('id:'),
+       "A10 键行 span 切片以键名开头")
+
+    root = mkroot(os.path.join(tmp, "a"), {
+        "n1": {"content": ccg(), "meta": {"layer": "knowledge", "tags": ["a"]}},
+        "n2": {"content": "短", "path": "", "meta": {"layer": "knowledge"}},
+    })
+    nd = LC.load_node("n1", root)
+    ok(nd and nd["meta"].get("layer") == "knowledge" and "# 功能名：" in (nd["content"] or ""),
+       "A11 load_node 取索引 meta + 文件正文")
+    ok(nd and nd["fm"].get("id") == "n1", "A12 loads 解析出的 fm 是文件真源")
+    ok(LC.load_node("ghost", root) is None, "A13 索引无此节点 → None（不猜路径）")
+    ok(LC.load_node("n1", root, index={"nodes": {"n1": {"path": "knowledge/n1.md"}}})
+       is not None, "A14 index 可显式注入（不读盘 index）")
+    ok(LC._index(root).get("n1") is not None, "A15 _index 兼容 {nodes:…} 形态")
+    ok(LC._index(root, index={"n1": {"path": "x"}}) == {"n1": {"path": "x"}},
+       "A16 裸 dict 索引原样透传")
+
+    ok(LC._snippet("甲" * 200, [0, 200]).endswith("…"), "A17 超长片段截断加省略号")
+    ok(LC._line_of(text, nd["content"], [0, 5]) == 6,
+       "A18 _line_of 定位到正文首行（实得 %s）" % LC._line_of(text, nd["content"], [0, 5]))
+    ok(LC._line_of(None, "x", [0, 1]) is None and LC._line_of(text, "不存在", [0, 1]) is None,
+       "A19 无 text / 正文不在文件内 → line=None（不编造）")
+    ok(LC.canonical_kind("dup_content") == "dup"
+       and LC.canonical_kind("template_flow_digits_only") == "template_flow",
+       "A20 M1/D1 用词归并到 D1 规范名")
+    ok(LC.canonical_kind("天外飞仙") == "天外飞仙", "A21 未知类别原样返回（不假装认路）")
+
+
+# ---------------------------- B 组：六类定位器 ----------------------------
+
+def phase_b(tmp):
+    print("[B] 六类定位器")
+
+    # B1-B6 missing_field
+    m = {"id": "b1", "layer": "knowledge", "content_hash": "h1",
+         "tags": ["a"], "role": "", "importance": 0.5, "evidence_count": 3,
+         "lifecycle_state": "active", "condition_space": full_cs()}
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "missing_field", meta=m, content=ccg(),
+                        text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(fields_of(hits) == ["role"] and all(h["span"] is None for h in hits),
+       "B1 字段两处皆空 → missing_field 且 span=None（实得 %s）" % fields_of(hits))
+
+    m2 = dict(m, evidence_count=0, role="knowledge-card")
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "missing_field", meta=m2, content=ccg(),
+                        text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok("evidence_count" in fields_of(hits) and "evidence_zero" in {h["rule"] for h in hits},
+       "B2 evidence_count=0 → 专项命中（rule=evidence_zero）")
+
+    m3 = dict(m, importance=1.7, role="k")
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "missing_field", meta=m3, content=ccg(),
+                        text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok("importance" in fields_of(hits) and "field_invalid" in {h["rule"] for h in hits},
+       "B3 importance 越界 → 字段存在但不可用")
+
+    m4 = dict(m, condition_space={"observation_position": "本地"},
+              role="k", tags=["a"])
+    body = ccg()
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "missing_field", meta=m4, content=body,
+                        text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    h = [x for x in hits if x["field"] == "condition_space"]
+    ok(bool(h) and h[0]["span"] is not None
+       and body[h[0]["span"][0]:h[0]["span"][1]].startswith("# 生效条件"),
+       "B4 四槽不全 → 指向正文「# 生效条件」行（%d/4）"
+       % (len(NF.CONDITION_SLOTS) - 3))
+
+    cut = "# 功能名：只有一行\n正文没有其它要素。\n"
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "missing_field", meta=dict(m, role="k", tags=["a"]),
+                        content=cut, text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    hm = [x for x in hits if x["rule"] == "ccg_incomplete"]
+    ok(bool(hm) and hm[0]["field"] == "content" and hm[0]["span"] is None
+       and "生效条件" in hm[0]["evidence"],
+       "B5 正文缺 CCG 要素行 → field=content 且 span=None（行不存在，不编造区间）")
+    ok(not [x for x in LC.locate_ex("b1", "missing_field", meta=m3, content=ccg(),
+                                    text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+            if x["rule"] == "ccg_incomplete"],
+       "B6 要素齐全 → 无 ccg_incomplete 噪声")
+
+    # B7-B10 weak_source
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "weak_source",
+                        meta={"verification_basis": "", "tags": ["计算机"]},
+                        content=ccg(), text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(len(hits) == 1 and hits[0]["rule"] == "basis_absent", "B7 基底为空 → basis_absent")
+
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "weak_source",
+                        meta={"verification_basis": "self", "tags": ["计算机"]},
+                        content=ccg(), text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(len(hits) == 1 and hits[0]["rule"] == "basis_enum", "B8 基底越枚举 → basis_enum")
+
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "weak_source",
+                        meta={"verification_basis": "textbook", "tags": ["计算机"]},
+                        content=ccg(), text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(len(hits) == 1 and hits[0]["rule"] == "basis_licensed"
+       and "science" in hits[0]["evidence"], "B9 理科×textbook → 赛道不相容（实得 %s）"
+       % (hits[0]["evidence"] if hits else "无"))
+
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "weak_source",
+                        meta={"verification_basis": "textbook", "tags": ["语文"]},
+                        content=ccg(), text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(hits == [], "B10 文科×textbook 合规 → 零命中（不误报）")
+
+    # B11-B12c observation_aged（原「stale」的时间窗口径：**观测时刻不是失效声明**）
+    m5 = dict(m, role="k", tags=["a"], condition_space=full_cs(tw=EXPIRED))
+    body = ccg()
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "observation_aged", meta=m5, content=body, text="",
+                        fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(len(hits) == 1 and hits[0]["field"] == "condition_space"
+       and hits[0]["severity"] == "info" and "观测时刻" in hits[0]["evidence"],
+       "B11 时间窗过期 → observation_aged（观测面·info，不冒充失效）")
+
+    m6 = dict(m5, condition_space=full_cs(tw=(0.0, NF.FULL_TIME_WINDOW_MAX)))
+    ok(LC.locate_ex("b1", "observation_aged", meta=m6, content=body, text="", fm={},
+                    peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"] == [],
+       "B12 全时窗是合法声明 → 不判")
+
+    # B12b-B12c 时间窗来源链（真库口径：索引快照只带 time_window，**无 condition_space 键**）
+    m_nocs = {k: v for k, v in m.items() if k != "condition_space"}
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "observation_aged", meta=dict(m_nocs, role="k"),
+                        content=body, text="",
+                        fm={"condition_space": full_cs(tw=EXPIRED)}, peers=[],
+                        now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(len(hits) == 1 and hits[0]["rule"] == "observation_window_passed",
+       "B12b 快照无条件空间 → 回退 fm 真源仍判（实得 %d 条）" % len(hits))
+
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "observation_aged",
+                        meta=dict(m_nocs, role="k", time_window=list(EXPIRED)),
+                        content=body, text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(len(hits) == 1 and hits[0]["rule"] == "observation_window_passed",
+       "B12c 快照只带 time_window → 真库口径下仍判")
+
+    # B12d-B12e **观测面不进评审告警面**（B+C 修正的关键隔离断言）
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", None, meta=m5, content=body, text="", fm={},
+                        peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(all(h["issue_kind"] != "observation_aged" for h in hits),
+       "B12d 默认全量定位不含 observation_aged（不进评审告警面）")
+    ok("observation_aged" in LC.ADVISORY_KINDS
+       and "observation_aged" not in LC.ISSUE_KINDS,
+       "B12e observation_aged 归观测面（ADVISORY_KINDS），不占问题面 D1 六类")
+
+    # C stale —— **依赖存在性**（B+C 修正：时效判定看载体是否还在，不看观测时刻）
+    src = tempfile.mkdtemp(prefix="m3src_")
+    slines = ["def f():", "    return 1", "", "def g():", "    return 2"]
+    with open(os.path.join(src, "mod.py"), "w", encoding="utf-8") as f:
+        f.write("\n".join(slines))
+    ref_ok = {"path": "mod.py", "name": "f", "kind": "def", "lineno": 1, "end": 2,
+              "lang": "py", "precise": True,
+              "hash": CI.region_hash(slines, 1, 2), "root": src}
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("c1", "stale", meta={}, content=body, text="",
+                        fm={"code_ref": dict(ref_ok)}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(hits == [], "C1 依赖源文件在且区间哈希吻合 → 零命中（不误报）")
+
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("c1", "stale", meta={}, content=body, text="",
+                        fm={"code_ref": dict(ref_ok, hash="000000000000")},
+                        peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(len(hits) == 1 and hits[0]["rule"] == "ref_stale"
+       and hits[0]["field"] == "code_ref",
+       "C2 源文件在但区间哈希不符（已漂移）→ stale")
+
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("c1", "stale", meta={}, content=body, text="",
+                        fm={"code_ref": dict(ref_ok, path="gone.py")},
+                        peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(len(hits) == 1 and hits[0]["rule"] == "ref_dangling",
+       "C3 依赖源文件不存在（悬空）→ stale（载体消失）")
+
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("c1", "stale", meta={}, content=body, text="",
+                        fm={"doc_ref": {"path": "x.md", "lineno": 1, "end": 2,
+                                        "hash": "000000000000"}},
+                        peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(hits == [], "C4 ref 无 root（判不了）→ 零命中（观测手段不足不冒充失效）")
+
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("c1", None, meta=m5, content=body, text="",
+                        fm={"code_ref": dict(ref_ok, path="gone.py")},
+                        peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(any(h["issue_kind"] == "stale" for h in hits),
+       "C5 默认全量定位会跑 stale（依赖存在性属问题面）")
+    shutil.rmtree(src, ignore_errors=True)
+
+    # B13-B14 dup
+    same = ccg(fn="重复节点")
+    peers = LC.build_peers([{"node_id": "b1", "content": same},
+                            {"node_id": "b2", "content": same}])
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "dup",
+                        meta=dict(m, role="k", content_hash=NF.content_hash(same)),
+                        content=same, text="", fm={}, peers=peers.get("b1"),
+                        now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(len(hits) == 1 and hits[0]["field"] == "content_hash"
+       and hits[0]["span"] == [0, len(same)] and hits[0]["peer"] == "b2",
+       "B13 同内容指纹 → dup 指整篇正文（peer=%s）"
+       % (hits[0]["peer"] if hits else "无"))
+
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "dup", meta=dict(m, role="k", tags=["a"]),
+                        content=ccg(fn="甲"), text="", fm={},
+                        peers=LC.build_peers([{"node_id": "b1", "content": ccg(fn="甲")},
+                                              {"node_id": "b2", "content": ccg(fn="乙")}]
+                                             ).get("b1"), now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(hits == [], "B14 内容不同 → 不判 dup（不误报）")
+
+    # B15 template_flow：逐句骨架相同、仅数值不同
+    t1 = ccg(fn="批次 1 收官", extra="本批处理 100 条记录，耗用 12 秒。第二句写 200 条。")
+    t2 = ccg(fn="批次 2 收官", extra="本批处理 300 条记录，耗用 45 秒。第二句写 400 条。")
+    peers2 = LC.build_peers([{"node_id": "b1", "content": t1},
+                             {"node_id": "b2", "content": t2}])
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "template_flow", meta=dict(m, role="k", tags=["a"]),
+                        content=t1, text="", fm={}, peers=peers2.get("b1"), now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(len(hits) >= 2 and all(h["field"] == "content" and h["span"] is not None
+                              for h in hits),
+       "B15 同模板流水 → 逐句给出 span（%d 句命中）" % len(hits))
+    ok(all(t1[h["span"][0]:h["span"][1]].strip()[:LC.SNIPPET_MAX] == h["snippet"]
+           for h in hits),
+       "B16 片段=span 切片去空白截断（与实现同口径，可肉眼复核）")
+    ok(hits and hits[0]["sentence"] is not None and hits[0]["peer"] == "b2",
+       "B17 携带句索引与对照节点（人工可跳行）")
+
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "template_flow", meta=dict(m, role="k", tags=["a"]),
+                        content=t1, text="", fm={},
+                        peers=LC.build_peers([{"node_id": "b1", "content": t1}]).get("b1"),
+                        now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(hits == [], "B18 无对照节点 → 不判流水")
+
+    # B19-B21 contradiction（确定性）
+    body = ccg()
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "contradiction",
+                        meta={"content_hash": "declared!", "role": "k", "tags": ["a"]},
+                        content=body, text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(len(hits) == 1 and hits[0]["rule"] == "hash_declared_vs_actual"
+       and NF.content_hash(body) in hits[0]["evidence"],
+       "B19 索引声明指纹 ≠ 正文实算 → contradiction")
+
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "contradiction",
+                        meta={"content_hash": NF.content_hash(body), "role": "k"},
+                        content=body, text="", fm={"id": "别的id"}, peers=[],
+                        now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(len(hits) == 1 and hits[0]["rule"] == "id_declared_vs_index"
+       and hits[0]["field"] == "id", "B20 文件 id ≠ 索引键 → contradiction")
+
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "contradiction",
+                        meta={"content_hash": NF.content_hash(body), "role": "k"},
+                        content=body, text="", fm={"id": "b1"}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    ok(hits == [], "B21 声明与事实一致 → 零命中")
+
+    # B22-B25 字段层门限（判据同源：派生自 M1 规则库，不另立一份）
+    scope = LC.field_layer_scope()
+    ok(scope.get("role") == ["knowledge"]
+       and scope.get("evidence_count") == ["knowledge"],
+       "B22 层门限派生自 rules/*.json 的 matcher.layer（实得 %s）" % scope)
+    ok("verification_basis" not in scope,
+       "B23 未限层的字段不入表 = 全层适用（M1 R-BASIS-MISSING 无 layer 门限）")
+
+    hits = LC.locate_ex("b1", "missing_field",
+                        meta=dict(m, layer="contextual", role="", evidence_count=0,
+                                  tags=[]),
+                        content=ccg(), text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)["hits"]
+    fld = fields_of(hits)
+    ok("role" not in fld and "evidence_count" not in fld,
+       "B24 非 knowledge 层 → 限层字段越层不报（与 M1 `_scope` 同口径，实得 %s）" % fld)
+    ok("tags" in fld,
+       "B25 未限层字段不受门限影响（tags 仍全层检查，实得 %s）" % fld)
+
+    # B26-B28 指纹不一致的**成因**（同一条命中，两种成因，处置完全不同）
+    cause, note = LC.hash_mismatch_cause({"content_hash": "x"}, root=None, path=None)
+    ok(cause == "unknown" and "成因未判定" in note,
+       "B26 无盘上证据 → cause=unknown（不假装知道成因）")
+
+    root = mkroot(os.path.join(tmp, "b_lag"), {
+        "n1": {"content": body, "meta": {"content_hash": "declared!"}},
+    })
+    node_f = os.path.join(root, "knowledge", "n1.md")
+    idx_f = os.path.join(root, CF.INDEX_FILE)
+    mt = os.path.getmtime(node_f)
+    os.utime(idx_f, (mt - 60.0, mt - 60.0))    # 索引快照比节点文件旧 60s
+    hc = [h for h in LC.locate_ex("n1", "contradiction", root=root, now=NOW)["hits"]
+          if h["rule"] == "hash_declared_vs_actual"]
+    ok(hc and hc[0]["cause"] == "index_lag" and "快照滞后" in hc[0]["evidence"],
+       "B27 文件比索引快照新 → cause=index_lag（正常写路径现象，实得 %s）"
+       % (hc[0]["cause"] if hc else "无命中"))
+
+    os.utime(idx_f, (mt + 60.0, mt + 60.0))    # 索引快照不旧于节点文件
+    hc = [h for h in LC.locate_ex("n1", "contradiction", root=root, now=NOW)["hits"]
+          if h["rule"] == "hash_declared_vs_actual"]
+    ok(hc and hc[0]["cause"] == "true_mismatch" and "真源相抵触" in hc[0]["evidence"],
+       "B28 索引快照不旧于文件 → cause=true_mismatch（需查，实得 %s）"
+       % (hc[0]["cause"] if hc else "无命中"))
+
+
+# ---------------------------- C 组：提示过滤与 blindspot ----------------------------
+
+def _mixed():
+    """同时命中多类的节点：role 空 + 四槽不全（missing_field）+ 指纹不符（contradiction）。
+
+    `condition_space` 刻意只声明 1 槽——让 D 组同时存在「可指区间」（`# 生效条件` 行）
+    与「无区间」（frontmatter 声明类）两种命中，契约两侧都被覆盖。
+    基底取 `textbook` + `语文`（文科档）——让 `weak_source` 真的干净，
+    C 组才能验证「该类无问题就返回空、不借机报别的类」。
+    """
+    body = ccg()
+    return dict({"content_hash": "declared!", "role": "", "tags": ["语文"],
+                 "layer": "knowledge", "verification_basis": "textbook",
+                 "importance": 0.5, "evidence_count": 3, "lifecycle_state": "active",
+                 "condition_space": {"observation_position": "本地仓"}}), body
+
+
+def phase_c(tmp):
+    print("[C] 提示过滤与 blindspot")
+    m, body = _mixed()
+    kw = dict(meta=m, content=body, text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)
+
+    all_hits = LC.locate_ex("c1", None, **kw)["hits"]
+    ok({"missing_field", "contradiction"} <= set(kinds_of(all_hits)),
+       "C1 hint=None → 全量定位（实得 %s）" % kinds_of(all_hits))
+
+    only = LC.locate_ex("c1", "weak_source", **kw)["hits"]
+    ok(all(h["issue_kind"] == "weak_source" for h in only),
+       "C2 hint=类别 → 只跑该类（实得 %s）" % kinds_of(only))
+    ok(only == [], "C3 该类无问题 → 空（不借机报别的类）")
+
+    by_field = LC.locate_ex("c1", "role", **kw)["hits"]
+    ok(by_field and all(h["field"] == "role" for h in by_field),
+       "C4 hint=字段名 → 按字段过滤全量结果（实得 %s）" % fields_of(by_field))
+
+    both = LC.locate_ex("c1", {"issue_kind": "missing_field", "field": "role"}, **kw)["hits"]
+    ok(both and len(both) == len(by_field), "C5 dict 形态 hint 同时收类别与字段")
+
+    lst = LC.locate_ex("c1", ["contradiction", "missing_field"], **kw)["hits"]
+    ok(len(lst) == len(all_hits)
+       and set(kinds_of(lst)) == {"contradiction", "missing_field"}
+       and LC.locate_ex("c1", ["contradiction", {"field": "role"}], **kw)["hits"] == [],
+       "C6 list 形态 hint 收集多个类别；类别与字段是收窄关系（交集空即空，不退回全量）"
+       "（实得 %d 条 %s）" % (len(lst), kinds_of(lst)))
+
+    ex = LC.locate_ex("c1", "contradiction_semantic", **kw)
+    ok(ex["hits"] == [] and ex["blindspot"] and "语义" in ex["blindspot"][0],
+       "C7 语义级矛盾 → blindspot 且零 hits（不猜、不编造区间）")
+    ok(ex["blindspot"] == LC.locate_ex("c1", "contradiction_semantic", **kw)["blindspot"],
+       "C8 blindspot 文本确定（可断言）")
+
+    ex2 = LC.locate_ex("c1", ["contradiction_semantic", "missing_field"], **kw)
+    ok(ex2["blindspot"] and ex2["hits"]
+       and all(h["issue_kind"] == "missing_field" for h in ex2["hits"]),
+       "C9 blindspot 与可定位类别同批共存（互不吞没）")
+
+    unk = LC.locate_ex("c1", "天外飞仙", **kw)
+    ok(unk["hits"] == [] and unk["blindspot"] == [],
+       "C10 未知提示 → 当字段过滤后为空，不炸也不假装认路")
+
+    alias = LC.locate_ex("c1", "dup_content", **kw)["hits"]
+    ok(all(h["issue_kind"] == "dup" for h in alias) and bool(alias) is False,
+       "C11 M1 用词 dup_content 归并为 dup（无重复故空）")
+
+    ok(LC.blindspot_reason("contradiction") == "" and
+       LC.blindspot_reason("contradiction_semantic") != "",
+       "C12 blindspot_reason 单一归口（可定位类别返回空串）")
+
+
+# ---------------------------- D 组：契约与确定性 ----------------------------
+
+def phase_d(tmp):
+    print("[D] 契约与确定性")
+    m, body = _mixed()
+    kw = dict(meta=m, content=body, text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)
+    hits = LC.locate("d1", None, **kw)
+
+    ok(isinstance(hits, list), "D1 locate() 契约入口返回 list")
+    ok(all({"field", "span", "issue_kind", "evidence"} <= set(h) for h in hits),
+       "D2 四键齐备（实得 %s）" % (sorted(hits[0]) if hits else "无命中"))
+    ok(all(h["issue_kind"] in LC.ISSUE_KINDS for h in hits),
+       "D3 issue_kind 全落 D1 枚举（实得 %s）" % kinds_of(hits))
+    ok(all(str(h["evidence"]).strip() for h in hits),
+       "D4 evidence 非空（白箱判据：为何算问题）")
+
+    sp = [h for h in hits if h["span"] is not None]
+    ok(all(isinstance(h["span"], list) and len(h["span"]) == 2
+           and h["span"][0] < h["span"][1] and h["span"][1] <= len(body) for h in sp),
+       "D5 span 是正文内的半开区间 [start,end)")
+    ok(all(isinstance(h["span"][0], int) and isinstance(h["span"][1], int) for h in sp),
+       "D6 span 端点为整数（可复算切片）")
+    ok(all(body[h["span"][0]:h["span"][1]].strip() != "" for h in sp),
+       "D7 span 指向非空片段")
+    ok(all(h.get("snippet") != "" for h in sp),
+       "D8 有 span 即有片段（人工核对可肉眼确认）")
+    ok(all(not h.get("snippet") for h in hits if h["span"] is None),
+       "D9 声明类命中无区间 → 片段为空（不编造区间）")
+
+    h2 = LC.locate("d1", None, **kw)
+    ok(json.dumps(hits, ensure_ascii=False) == json.dumps(h2, ensure_ascii=False),
+       "D10 同一输入两次调用逐字节一致（确定性）")
+    ok(LC.locate_ex("d1", None, **kw)["load"]["content_len"] == len(body),
+       "D11 load 回报正文长度（审计留痕）")
+
+    key = [(h["issue_kind"], str(h["field"])) for h in hits]
+    ok(key == sorted(key), "D12 命中按 (issue_kind, field, span, peer) 稳定排序（实得 %s）" % key)
+
+    try:
+        LC.locate_ex("d1", None, meta=m, content=None, text="", fm={}, peers=[], now=NOW)
+        raised = False
+    except ValueError:
+        raised = True
+    ok(raised, "D13 无正文且无 root → fail-closed 报错（不假装能定位）")
+
+
+# ---------------------------- E 组：批量与包 ----------------------------
+
+def _pkg(entries, bid="bE"):
+    return {"bundle_id": bid, "group_kind": "batch", "group_key": "g",
+            "size": len(entries), "entries": entries}
+
+
+def _ent(nid, *, excerpt="", h="", **kw):
+    e = {"ref": nid, "node_id": nid, "excerpt": excerpt, "content_hash": h,
+         "layer": "knowledge", "tags": ["a"]}
+    e.update(kw)
+    return e
+
+
+def _clean_meta(**kw):
+    """合规 meta（理科档 × test 基底）——「干净」必须是真干净，否则 clean 断言无意义。
+
+    `layer="knowledge"`：层门限（真源 = M1 规则库 `matcher.layer`）下，
+    `role`/`evidence_count` 只在本层检查；缺层节点根本不进判据，clean 断言会空转。
+    """
+    m = {"role": "knowledge-card", "tags": ["计算机"], "layer": "knowledge",
+         "verification_basis": "test",
+         "importance": 0.5, "evidence_count": 2, "lifecycle_state": "active",
+         "condition_space": full_cs()}
+    m.update(kw)
+    return m
+
+
+def phase_e(tmp):
+    print("[E] 批量与包")
+    same = ccg(fn="重复的")
+    diff = ccg(fn="独一无二的甲")
+    peers = LC.build_peers([{"node_id": "e1", "content": same},
+                            {"node_id": "e2", "content": same},
+                            {"node_id": "e3", "content": diff}])
+    ok([p["node_id"] for p in peers["e1"]] == ["e2"]
+       and [p["node_id"] for p in peers["e2"]] == ["e1"],
+       "E1 build_peers 同内容指纹互为对照（双向）")
+    ok(peers["e3"] == [], "E2 内容不同 → 不同组（不是「同批即同组」）")
+
+    t1 = ccg(fn="批次 1 收官", extra="处理 100 条。")
+    t2 = ccg(fn="批次 2 收官", extra="处理 200 条。")
+    p2 = LC.build_peers([{"node_id": "e1", "content": t1},
+                         {"node_id": "e2", "content": t2}])
+    ok([p["node_id"] for p in p2["e1"]] == ["e2"],
+       "E3 同标题模板骨架 → 互为对照（指纹不同也入组）")
+    ok(all(p["sk"] for p in p2["e1"]), "E4 对照项携带模板骨架（M1 同源口径）")
+
+    ok(LC.build_peers([]) == {}, "E5 空批 → 空映射（不炸）")
+    ok("e1" in LC.build_peers([{"node_id": "e1", "content": same}]),
+       "E6 单条批仍回填键（调用方不必判空）")
+
+    items = [{"node_id": "e1", "content": ccg(fn="干净的"), "meta": _clean_meta()},
+             {"node_id": "e2", "content": ccg(fn="有问题的"),
+              "meta": _clean_meta(role="")}]
+    rep = LC.locate_many(items=items, now=NOW)
+    ok(rep["nodes"] == 2 and rep["clean"] == ["e1"] and rep["missing"] == [],
+       "E7 locate_many 报「干净」条（没问题≠没看，clean=%s）" % rep["clean"])
+    ok(rep["by_kind"].get("missing_field") == 1 and rep["by_field"].get("role") == 1,
+       "E8 by_kind/by_field 汇总正确（%s / %s）" % (rep["by_kind"], rep["by_field"]))
+    ok(all(h["node_id"] == "e2" for h in rep["hits"]), "E9 命中归属到正确节点")
+
+    root = mkroot(os.path.join(tmp, "e"), {
+        "n1": {"content": ccg(fn="盘上节点"), "meta": _clean_meta(role="")},
+        "n2": {"content": ccg(fn="盘上无问题"), "meta": _clean_meta()},
+    })
+    rep2 = LC.locate_many(["n1", "n2", "ghost"], root=root, now=NOW)
+    ok(rep2["nodes"] == 2 and rep2["missing"] == ["ghost"],
+       "E10 读不到的节点单列 missing（「没看」≠「没问题」，missing=%s）" % rep2["missing"])
+    ok(rep2["clean"] == ["n2"], "E11 读盘形态同样分流 clean")
+    ok(rep2["hits"] and rep2["hits"][0]["field"] == "role",
+       "E12 读盘形态命中与显式 items 同判据")
+
+    exc9 = ccg(fn="只在摘录里的节点")
+    pkg = _pkg([_ent("n1", excerpt="摘录里没有特征码", h="过期指纹"),
+                _ent("p9", excerpt=exc9, h=NF.content_hash(exc9),
+                     **_clean_meta(condition_space={"observation_position": "本地仓",
+                                                    "time_window": [0.0, 9999999999.0],
+                                                    "observation_tool": "test"}))])
+    rep3 = LC.locate_package(pkg, root=root, now=NOW)
+    ok(rep3["bundle_id"] == "bE" and rep3["entries"] == 2 and rep3["nodes"] == 2,
+       "E13 locate_package 带包标识与条目计数")
+    ok(any(h["node_id"] == "n1" for h in rep3["hits"]),
+       "E14 包内可读节点走读盘正文（准确）")
+    p9 = [h for h in rep3["hits"] if h["node_id"] == "p9"]
+    ok(p9 and all(h["field"] == "condition_space" for h in p9)
+       and exc9[p9[0]["span"][0]:p9[0]["span"][1]].startswith("# 生效条件"),
+       "E15 文件不可读 → 用包内 excerpt 仍给出正文区间（降级但仍可指，实得 %s）"
+       % kinds_of(p9))
+    ok(not [h for h in rep3["hits"] if h["node_id"] == "n1"
+            and h["issue_kind"] == "dup"],
+       "E16 excerpt 不冒充正文做重复判定（诚实降级）")
+
+    s = LC.summary(rep3["hits"])
+    ok(s["total"] == len(rep3["hits"]) and s["nodes"] == len(s["node_ids"])
+       and s["by_kind"], "E17 summary 汇总口径自洽")
+    ok(LC.summary([])["total"] == 0 and LC.summary([])["node_ids"] == [],
+       "E18 空命中 summary 不炸")
+
+    md = LC.markdown_table(rep3["hits"])
+    ok(md.count("\n") >= len(rep3["hits"]) + 1 and "人工判定" in md,
+       "E19 markdown_table 逐条一行且留人工判定列")
+    ok(LC.markdown_table([{"node_id": "x", "issue_kind": "dup", "field": "c",
+                           "span": None, "evidence": "含|竖线"}]).count("\\|") == 1,
+       "E20 表格竖线转义（不破坏表格结构）")
+
+    code = LC.main(["--root", root, "--node", "n1", "--json"])
+    ok(code == 0, "E21 CLI --json 退出码 0")
+    code2 = LC.main(["--root", root, "--node", "n1", "--kind", "missing_field",
+                     "--markdown"])
+    ok(code2 == 0, "E22 CLI --kind + --markdown 退出码 0")
+    ok(LC.main(["--node", "n1"]) == 2, "E23 缺 root → 退出码 2（fail-closed）")
+    ok(LC.main(["--root", root]) == 2, "E24 缺 node → 退出码 2（不静默空跑）")
+
+
+# ---------------------------- F 组：零写入 ----------------------------
+
+def phase_f(tmp):
+    print("[F] 零写入")
+    root = mkroot(os.path.join(tmp, "f"), {
+        "n1": {"content": ccg(fn="批次 1 收官", extra="处理 100 条。"),
+               "meta": {"role": "", "tags": ["a"], "importance": 0.5,
+                        "evidence_count": 0, "lifecycle_state": "active",
+                        "condition_space": full_cs(tw=EXPIRED)}},
+        "n2": {"content": ccg(fn="批次 2 收官", extra="处理 200 条。"),
+               "meta": {"role": "knowledge-card", "tags": ["语文"],
+                        "importance": 0.5, "evidence_count": 1,
+                        "lifecycle_state": "active",
+                        "condition_space": full_cs()}},
+    })
+    before = snapshot(root)
+    LC.locate_many(["n1", "n2"], root=root, now=NOW)
+    LC.locate_package(_pkg([_ent("n1"), _ent("n2")]), root=root, now=NOW)
+    LC.locate("n1", None, root=root, now=NOW)
+    LC.main(["--root", root, "--node", "n1", "--node", "n2"])
+    ok(snapshot(root) == before,
+       "F1 全相位跑完认知图指纹逐字节不变（M3 只读）")
+    ok(not os.path.exists(os.path.join(root, "_mreview")),
+       "F2 定位不另立状态目录（无残留）")
+
+
+# ---------------------------- main ----------------------------
+
+def main(argv=None):
+    with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory(prefix="mrev_m3_") as tmp:
+        phase_a(tmp)
+        phase_b(tmp)
+        phase_c(tmp)
+        phase_d(tmp)
+        phase_e(tmp)
+        phase_f(tmp)
+    print("\nM3 自测：%d 通过 / %d 失败 / %d 跳过" % (PASS, FAIL, SKIP))
+    if FAILS:
+        print("失败项：")
+        for f in FAILS:
+            print("  - %s" % f)
+    return 1 if FAIL else 0
+
+
+if __name__ == "__main__":
+    sys.exit(main())