@forgeax/engine-render 0.1.3 → 0.1.6

package/README.md

@@ -1,29 +1,38 @@
 # `@forgeax/engine-render`
 
-## MaterialAsset 唯一成功路径
+## Render happy path
 
-Render 只消费 `paramSchema -> derive -> compile/reflect -> cook/load -> extract/record`
-主线的 extract/record 阶段：从已验证的 material artifact 取得 slot 数据，按
-`coordinateSet`、transform 与 `physicalUvScale` 写入 record，并以
-`layoutIdentity` 选择匹配的 bind-group layout。发现 identity 或坐标不一致时，
-回到 producer inspect/repair/recook，不在 game-side 添加 padding 或 fallback。
+`RenderScene -> Standard Pipeline -> DeviceScope -> FrameReceipt` is the only frame
+model. The host calls `createRenderer`, `attach(world)`, and `draw(request)`; diagnostics use
+`inspect`, `observe(receipt, request)`, and `recover`. `FrameReceipt` is the synchronous proof that
+submit completed. A failed `Result` carries `code`, `hint`, and `detail`; repair the named owner,
+rebuild or cold-cook its source, then retry the same request.
 
-| 阶段 | 唯一 owner | 结果 |
-|---|---|---|
-| schema / derive | material producer | 派生参数与纹理字段 |
-| compile / reflect | shader compiler | 与 WGSL 一致的 artifact 输入 |
-| cook / load | pack 与 assets-runtime | 带 receipt 的 GUID payload |
-| extract / record | render | 与 identity 对齐的 draw bindings |
+```ts
+const created = await createRenderer(canvas);
+if (!created.ok) throw created.error;
+const renderer = created.value;
+const attached = renderer.attach(world);
+if (!attached.ok) throw attached.error;
+const frame = renderer.draw({
+  leases: [attached.value],
+  camera: { lease: attached.value },
+  environment: { lease: attached.value },
+});
+if (!frame.ok) throw frame.error;
+const observation = await renderer.observe(frame.value, { include: ['timings'] });
+```
 
-> [!IMPORTANT]
-> Render 错误通过结构化 `code`、`detail`、`hint` 恢复；不要把非结构化文本、
-> app 侧安装或替代材质当作 contract。
+The Standard pipeline selects direct or clustered lighting from capabilities and keeps shadow,
+PBR, IBL, SSAO, bloom, tone, antialiasing, sky, material, VFX, and debug feature ownership inside
+the same graph and submit boundary. CPU and WebGL2 fallback are capability lanes of that pipeline,
+not second renderer identities.
 
 ## Direct-light parity contract
 
 The direct-light proposition is: one public `DirectionalLight`/`PointLight`/
-`SpotLight` semantic snapshot must produce the same analytic result in URP and
-HDRP. The M4 authority is the revision-pinned
+`SpotLight` semantic snapshot must produce the same analytic result in every
+Standard capability lane. The authority is the revision-pinned
 [`three-r184-finite-range-authority.json`](../../apps/parity/color-lighting/cases/direct-light/calibration/three-r184-finite-range-authority.json).
 It is `ready` only when its Three revision, source hash, config, and expected
 samples are present. Missing authority or paired GPU captures is `blocked`; do
@@ -46,7 +55,7 @@ The public mapping is deliberately small:
 | Color | Linear RGB; no hidden global multiplier | Light snapshot and buffer layout |
 | Range and decay | Positive range is meters; `Infinity` means no cutoff; runtime uses `e=2` | Three r184 authority |
 | Cone | KHR radians import to component degrees; snapshot stores `cosInner` and `cosOuter` | glTF bridge and extract |
-| Direction | KHR local `-Z` after world rotation; extract normalizes once; downstream shaders consume the result | Extract snapshot and URP/HDRP shaders |
+| Direction | KHR local `-Z` after world rotation; extract normalizes once; downstream shaders consume the result | Extract snapshot and Standard shaders |
 
 The runtime finite-range factor is the Three r184 squared window:
 `clamp(1 - (d / c)^4, 0, 1)^2`. The KHR
@@ -61,228 +70,6 @@ must retain `provenance`, `captures`, `raw hash`, `analyticMax`, `roiMax`, and
 `verdict` for each backend x pipeline x case. A same-canvas self-comparison or
 analytic-only green result is not direct-light parity evidence.
 
-## Fog: authoring, inspection, and recovery
-
-> [!IMPORTANT]
-> Fog is the one public scene-radiance component. Spawn it in the World that
-> is passed as resourceOwner; the renderer selects zero or one Fog entity,
-> validates the fields, publishes a candidate, and commits it only after a
-> successful frame submission. Applications do not register a post effect,
-> pack a Fog buffer, import Fog WGSL, or maintain Fog history.
-
-The shortest authoring route is one public import plus the existing draw owner:
-The minimum form is world.spawn({ component: Fog, data: {} }) when defaults are sufficient.
-
-```ts
- import { Fog } from '@forgeax/engine-render';
- import type { RenderError } from '@forgeax/engine-render';
-
-const fogEntity = world.spawn({
-  component: Fog,
-  data: {
-    color: [0.45, 0.52, 0.6],
-    density: 0.018,
-    heightFalloff: 0.15,
-    maxOpacity: 0.85,
-  },
-}).unwrap();
-
-const drawn = renderer.draw([world], { cameraOwner: 0, resourceOwner: 0 });
-if (!drawn.ok) reportRenderError(drawn.error as RenderError);
-const fogInspection = renderer.renderScene.fog;
-void fogEntity;
-void fogInspection;
-```
-
-### Authoring domain
-
-| Field | Valid domain | Default | Meaning |
-|:--|:--|--:|:--|
-| color | three finite non-negative numbers | [0.5, 0.5, 0.5] | Linear Fog radiance color; HDR values are valid |
-| density | finite number >= 0 | 0.01 | Base optical density |
-| heightFalloff | finite number >= 0 | 0 | Exponential density falloff along world y |
-| maxOpacity | finite number in [0, 1] | 1 | Upper bound for the Fog mix; surface alpha is preserved |
-
-The component has no mode, profile, baseHeight, start, or end field.
-heightFalloff = 0 is the uniform-density lane. A missing Fog entity means
-disabled scene Fog and adds no Fog-owned graph resource, pass, texture, bind
-group, or history. A second Fog entity in the same resourceOwner is a
-structured conflict, not a winner-selection policy.
-
-resourceOwner is an existing numeric World owner, not a string resource:
-
-| Fog cardinality in the selected owner | Renderer fact | Recovery |
-|:--:|:--|:--|
-| 0 | enabled=false; no accepted Fog snapshot | Continue without scene Fog |
-| 1 | Candidate is validated and becomes last-known-good after submit | Read renderer.renderScene.fog |
-| N | fog-owner-conflict; no new candidate is published | Remove every extra Fog entity, then retry draw |
-
-### Bounded inspection
-
-Read the accepted facts after draw:
-
-```ts
-const fog = renderer.renderScene.fog;
-const accepted = {
-  enabled: fog.enabled,
-  resourceOwner: fog.resourceOwner,
-  entity: fog.entity,
-  revision: fog.revision,
-  reactive: fog.reactive,
-  failure: fog.failure,
-};
-```
-
-The inspection is bounded and read-only. revision changes when a successful
-Fog authoring candidate changes; reactive is true on the current frame when
-the accepted revision changed. A failed candidate does not replace the
-last-known-good snapshot. failure is either fog-owner-conflict,
-fog-parameters-invalid, or undefined; it is not a free-form diagnostic
-registry.
-
-### Structured errors and exhaustive recovery
-
-Fog failures are members of the closed RenderError union:
-FogOwnerConflictError has code fog-owner-conflict, while
-FogParametersInvalidError has code fog-parameters-invalid. Both errors expose
-code, detail, expected, and hint; detail carries the bounded values needed for
-a retry.
-
-```ts
-function recoverFog(error: RenderError): 'retry' | 'forward' {
-  switch (error.code) {
-    case 'fog-owner-conflict':
-      // Remove all but one Fog entity in error.detail.resourceOwner.
-      return 'retry';
-    case 'fog-parameters-invalid':
-      // Set error.detail.field to a value satisfying error.expected.
-      return 'retry';
-    default:
-      return 'forward';
-  }
-}
-```
-
-For fog-owner-conflict, inspect error.detail.entities and
-error.detail.omitted; remove every extra entity from that resourceOwner, then
-retry draw. For fog-parameters-invalid, inspect error.detail.entity,
-error.detail.field, error.detail.actual, and the structured expected domain;
-repair the ECS field and retry. Do not parse the error message, create a
-fallback material, or silently disable Fog.
-
-### Height-aware scene-radiance formula
-
-The shared forgeax_view::fog module integrates optical depth along a
-producer-supplied world-space ray. Let y0 be the ray origin height, dy its
-world-space vertical direction, d its linear distance, h the height falloff,
-and rho the authored density:
-
-$$
-\rho_0 = \rho e^{-h y_0},\qquad
-q = h\,dy,\qquad
-\tau =
-\begin{cases}
-\rho_0 d & |q| < \epsilon,\\
-\rho_0 \dfrac{1-e^{-qd}}{q} & |q| \geq \epsilon.
-\end{cases}
-$$
-
-$$
-T = e^{-\tau},\qquad
-\alpha_f = \operatorname{clamp}(m(1-T), 0, 1),\qquad
-C' = \operatorname{mix}(C, C_f, \alpha_f),
-$$
-
-where m is maxOpacity, C is the producer color, and Cf is the authored
-linear Fog color. The output keeps the producer alpha unchanged. CPU
-extraction and WGSL share the same field order and ray contract; near/far
-values and non-linear depth are not Fog inputs.
-
-### Producer and pipeline responsibility
-
-Fog is applied exactly once to linear scene radiance before the
-renderer-owned temporal resolve. URP and HDRP keep their existing pipeline
-order; opaque, masked, unlit, Standard PBR, transparent, Sprite, Text,
-Skybox, and the five VFX render paths supply their own ray facts and call the
-shared module. G-buffer facts, shadow maps, and overlay/debug output are not
-Fog inputs. Alpha is preserved for transparent and VFX output.
-
-```mermaid
-flowchart TD
-  Author["World spawns one Fog entity"] --> Extract["extract selects resourceOwner"]
-  Extract --> Candidate["validate and stage candidate"]
-  Candidate --> Submit{"successful frame submit"}
-  Submit -->|yes| Accepted["publish revision and bounded inspection"]
-  Submit -->|no| Lkg["retain last-known-good snapshot"]
-  Accepted --> Scene["linear scene-radiance Fog exactly once"]
-  Scene --> Temporal["existing temporal resolve"]
-```
-
-No Fog-specific pass, texture, bind group, upload, history, registry, or
-fullscreen fallback is part of this route. TAA remains the sole history owner;
-Fog revision changes use its existing current-frame reactive lane.
-
-### Real evidence commands
-
-Run the focused contracts first, then the two independent feature carriers:
-
-```sh
-pnpm exec vitest run --project='@forgeax/engine-render' packages/render/src/__tests__/fog-public-surface.integration.test.ts packages/render/src/__tests__/fog-source-absence.integration.test.ts packages/render/src/__tests__/fog-custom-render-feature.integration.test.ts
-pnpm --filter @forgeax/bevy-fog smoke
-pnpm --filter @forgeax/bevy-fog smoke:browser
-```
-
-Each carrier must write case-wise expected, observed, delta, verdict, and
-confidence fields plus revision/reactive/recovery facts. The Dawn artifact is
-evidence/dawn-fog-trace.json; the Browser artifact is
-evidence/browser-fog-trace.json. PNG is auxiliary evidence: it never replaces
-linear readback or the case-wise verdict.
-
-> [!CAUTION]
-> The current M4 Dawn and Browser 300-frame artifacts are real executions but
-> remain verdict: fail because their RGB deltas exceed 0.02. This README
-> records the failure rather than promoting it to green. Preserve the
-> artifacts and repair the Engine owner before claiming visual parity.
-
-### Custom RenderFeature responsibility
-
-A custom RenderFeature can consume the renderer-owned scene-color target and
-contribute an overlay through the existing graph seam. It must not become a
-second Fog owner or create fog-texture, fog-history, fog-bind-group,
-Fog-specific upload state, or a parallel formula. The executable fixture is
-src/__tests__/fog-custom-render-feature.fixture.ts; its compile/import/overlay
-evidence is evidence/custom-render-feature-compile.json and contains the
-fixture path, compiler command, exitCode, moduleImport, and overlay verdict.
-
-<details>
-<summary>Custom feature boundary checklist</summary>
-
-- [x] Consume existing graph targets instead of allocating a Fog resource.
-- [x] Keep engine-render as the Fog owner.
-- [x] Use the public RenderFeature lifecycle and opaque staging references.
-- [ ] Add a new public capability only through a separate design and owner review.
-
-</details>
-
-### Out of scope for this Fog contract
-
-| Deferred capability | Boundary |
-|:--|:--|
-| Linear start/end, Exp2, baseHeight, public mode/profile, or a second Fog component | Reopen design only if a real scene proves the single density field insufficient |
-| Froxel/raymarch volume, 3D density, phase/scattering, light/shadow injection, or temporal volume denoise | Separate volume and lighting owner |
-| Local Fog volumes, overlap/blend, or directional phase | Separate volume composition authority |
-| Atmosphere, Sun, analytic sky, clouds, weather, or cloud shadow | Separate sky/weather/environment owner |
-| OIT, layered media, volume compositing, or automatic exposure | Separate transparency and color-management owners |
-| Fog-specific pass, texture, bind group, upload, history, or coverage registry | Explicitly forbidden because they duplicate RenderGraph/View/TAA SSOT |
-| Frozen GPU epsilon, exponent, or full diagnostic UI | Keep implementation details behind ABI and bounded evidence |
-
-M5 closure remains explicit:
-
-- [x] Public Fog schema and bounded inspection are documented.
-- [x] One-cut app source absence and two closed recovery errors are indexed.
-- [x] Real Dawn/Browser evidence paths and their current failed verdicts are linked.
-- [ ] RGB tolerance repair and full smoke-fleet gates remain required.
-
 ## Particle feature boundary
 
 Particle rendering is provided by
@@ -291,71 +78,26 @@ generic RenderFeature host, prepared graphics resolver, pipeline readiness
 contract, and structured renderer errors; it does not own VFX simulation or
 particle asset authoring.
 
-## Deferred membership timing
-
-Render owns the opt-in `membershipTiming` contract for the real
-`hdrp-cluster-membership` compute pass. App and Runtime only forward the option;
-they do not define a second profiler or reason vocabulary.
-
-| Mode | Work | Result |
-|:--|:--|:--|
-| omitted | No query set, resolve buffer, map, or queue wait | No timing record |
-| `cpu-control` | Existing CPU binner remains the control path | Accepted control record with `gpu: null` |
-| `gpu` | Bounded timestamp query, resolve, async queue completion, and map | GPU ticks plus backend period, or a terminal refusal/error |
-
-> [!IMPORTANT]
-> A GPU request is refused when the backend does not advertise timestamp
-> queries or a positive timestamp period. RhiNull and the wgpu WebGL2 path are
-> intentionally non-timing backends. They never synthesize GPU duration.
-
-The controller timestamps immediately around the existing membership dispatch,
-keeps GPU ticks separate from CPU encode/submit and async readback, and
-terminalizes captures on timeout, submit failure, queue completion failure,
-readback failure, device recovery, or disposal. The closed
-`MembershipTimingReasonCode` union and its exhaustive mapping live in
-[`src/record/membership-timing.ts`](src/record/membership-timing.ts).
-
-Timestamp-capable backends must execute both raw timestamp writes. A missing or
-throwing write is a structured `timestamp-write-unavailable` refusal; Render
-never publishes a zero, reversed, or non-finite GPU interval as a report.
-
-## Deferred membership evidence closure
+## Deferred lighting evidence
 
-> [!IMPORTANT]
-> The close condition is `acceptedGpu=16`, with five accepted Dawn GPU
-> records at each of 32, 64, and 128 lights, one 256-light record, positive
-> tick intervals, per-light-count variance, and the 256-light overflow
-> fingerprint. `acceptedGpu=0` is a blocker. CPU control, WebKit refusal,
-> RhiNull refusal, PNG screenshots, and capability bits never count as GPU
-> evidence.
-
-The producer and validator are deliberately separate from the public Render
-API. Generate the exact manifest, run the full producer matrix, and inspect
-the machine-readable report in this order:
-
-```sh
-node scripts/dev-verify/generate-deferred-membership-manifest.mjs --output=report/deferred-membership-timing/full-matrix-manifest.json
-node scripts/dev-verify/capture-deferred-membership-corpus.mjs --manifest=report/deferred-membership-timing/full-matrix-manifest.json --output-root=report/deferred-membership-timing --webkit-download=webkit-evidence --report=report/deferred-membership-timing
-```
-
-The manifest contract is [`full-matrix-contract.json`](../../scripts/dev-verify/membership-timing/full-matrix-contract.json); the WebKit subset is validated by [`webkit-subset.schema.json`](../../scripts/dev-verify/membership-timing/webkit-subset.schema.json). The stable identity is `sourceHead`, `carrier`, `workload`, `profile`, and `artifactHashes`. The exact target is 20 top-level records and 32 nested references, with `record`, `profile`, `membership`, and `pixel` SHA-256 descriptors.
-
-The report exposes `valid`, `truthfulnessReady`, `completeMatrixReady`,
-`optimizationReleaseReady`, `counts`, `errors`, and `blocker`. A blocker uses
-`code`, `expected`, `hint`, and the observed `acceptedGpu` count so an AI user
-can recover by inspecting per-attempt refusal, profile, identity, and artifact
-hash records. The owner reason union remains closed; for example,
-`timestamp-query-unsupported` is a refusal, while `timestamp-write-unavailable`
-is a terminal producer failure. Neither is a successful GPU sample.
+Deferred lighting validation is consumer evidence, not a Render production
+subsystem. The learn-render smoke exercises the Standard clustered path and
+the profiler captures bounded CPU ownership evidence; the WebKit fallback
+gate exercises the browser delivery path. Runtime inspection uses the public
+`inspect` and `observe` projections, while any future timestamp benchmark
+belongs in `packages/render/bench` and its dev-verify producer. Render does
+not expose a timing controller or a second membership-specific API.
 
 ## RenderFeature: the producer seam (first-read index)
 
-The public route remains `RenderFeature` through `RenderPipeline` and the
-active RenderGraph pass. This is the RenderGraph pass for a `type FrameData`
-producer, which uses
-`createRenderer(canvas, { features: [feature] })`,
-`context.staging.addPass('named-pass'`, `execute: ({ pass })`, and the
-`Material pass` boundary. This is the graph-only Wave 1 feature route.
+The public route is one `RenderFeature<FrameData>` through the Standard
+Pipeline and the active RenderGraph pass. In the examples below, `type FrameData`
+is the producer-owned extracted value. A feature extracts one frame value,
+then its mandatory `plan(data, context)` declares named resources and passes;
+the host derives graph access, preparation, recording, and recovery from that
+plan. Register it at construction with
+`createRenderer(canvas, { features: [feature] })`. A feature never receives a
+device, queue, encoder, staging builder, or submit callback.
 
 > [!IMPORTANT]
 > Render consumes the effective MaterialAsset snapshot produced by extract. Each texture slot carries its own coordinate set and transform into the built-in PBR binding layout; render records do not reinterpret authoring fields or manufacture shader artifacts. The effective `passes` are already validated.
@@ -393,31 +135,22 @@ The render path is `MaterialAsset` -> extract snapshot -> prepare resources -> r
 > Owner: render vocabulary and the extract → prepare → record frame boundary. Runtime selects concrete services and calls this package; it does not re-own these tokens.
 
 ```ts
-import {
-  Camera,
-  materialTextureValue,
-  MeshFilter,
-  MeshRenderer,
-} from '@forgeax/engine-render';
+import { Camera, MeshFilter, MeshRenderer } from '@forgeax/engine-render';
 import { createRenderer } from '@forgeax/engine-runtime';
 
 const renderer = await createRenderer(canvas);
-const ready = await renderer.ready;
-const attached = renderer.attachWorld(world);
-if (ready.ok && attached.ok) {
+const attached = renderer.attach(world);
+if (attached.ok) {
   world.update(1 / 60).unwrap();
-  renderer.draw([world], { cameraOwner: 0, resourceOwner: 0 });
+  renderer.draw({
+    leases: [attached.value],
+    camera: { lease: attached.value },
+    environment: { lease: attached.value },
+  });
 }
-
-// A numeric texture handle is normalized into the structured material slot.
-const values = { baseColorTexture: materialTextureValue(textureHandle) };
 ```
 
-For the full slot contract, read [`MaterialTextureValue`](../types/src/material/asset.ts)
-and keep `baseColorTexture` on the same `paramSchema -> derive -> cook/load ->
-extract/record` path.
-
-`attachWorld` installs renderer-required derived-state systems once. Hosts built
+`attach` installs renderer-required derived-state systems once. Hosts built
 with `createApp` get this wiring automatically. A custom loop attaches each
 World before its first update, then keeps `draw` as a read-only consumer of the
 state published by `World.update()`.
@@ -425,12 +158,10 @@ state published by `World.update()`.
 ## Persistent render scene
 
 The ordinary single-World path bootstraps one renderer-owned CPU projection,
-then drains the World's bounded change journal. Each attached World generation
-receives one renderer-local `WorldRenderId`; draw-array reordering cannot change
-that identity, while detach retires it before the same World object can
-reattach. A no-change frame reuses the last visible snapshot without traversing
-renderable archetypes; transform changes update only their stable projection
-slots. Unrelated gameplay component writes do not invalidate render state.
+then drains the World's bounded change journal. A no-change frame reuses the
+last visible snapshot without traversing renderable archetypes; transform
+changes update only their stable projection slots. Unrelated gameplay
+component writes do not invalidate render state.
 
 Mutable shared payloads use the same explicit-dirty rule: mutate the resolved
 payload, then call `world.sharedRefs.markChanged(handle)`. The renderer compares
@@ -458,7 +189,7 @@ are real driver/pixel proofs for the GPU-driven boundary; they do not make
 RhiNull a pixel backend or make the CPU projection cease to be the scene
 authority.
 
-Inspect the current path through `renderer.renderScene`. Its CPU counters expose
+Inspect the current path through `renderer.inspect()`. Its detached CPU snapshot exposes
 full rebuilds, no-change and delta frames, transform/material/instance updates,
 removals, the journal cursor, projection cardinality, and the last resync
 reason. The nested `gpu` status is one of `inactive`, `unsupported`, `resident`,
@@ -466,7 +197,9 @@ reason. The nested `gpu` status is one of `inactive`, `unsupported`, `resident`,
 upload ranges and bytes, grows, clears, rebuilds, and no-change frames. The
 `gpuDriven` inspection reports whether stable frames materialized or validated
 GPU-owned rows and whether candidate or batch topology bytes were uploaded.
-GPU errors also use the existing `renderer.onError` channel.
+GPU and renderer contract errors arrive through the single `renderer.subscribe`
+event stream (`event.kind === 'error'`); the renderer does not expose a second
+error listener registry.
 
 ## GPU-driven view kernel
 
@@ -480,28 +213,27 @@ primitive world transform with each ordinary instance-local transform, writes a
 compact `(instanceIndex, materialIndex)` stream, sets explicit overflow flags,
 and emits indirect arguments with `firstInstance = 0`.
 
-The URP frame activates the production raster lane when compute, storage
+The Standard frame activates the production raster lane when compute, storage
 buffers, and indirect drawing are available. The current lane accepts opaque,
 rigid default-unlit passes with batch-stable render state, ordinary instances,
 indexed or non-indexed geometry, multiple submeshes and material slots, and the
 canonical `12F` vertex layout. It also accepts persistent rigid multi-World
-composition keyed by stable renderer-local World identity instead of the
-current `draw(worlds)` order. Candidates come from the complete persistent
-projection rather than the CPU-visible snapshot. The same typed graph imports the scene and mesh
+composition. Candidates come from the complete persistent projection rather
+than the CPU-visible snapshot. The same typed graph imports the scene and mesh
 buffers, runs the three compute passes, and consumes generated arguments with
 `drawIndexedIndirect` or `drawIndirect`. Entities accepted by that lane are not
 also validated, uploaded, or recorded by the CPU forward loop on a stable
 frame.
 
-HDRP, PBR and custom shader variants, texture/sampler/video resource bindings,
+clustered, PBR and custom shader variants, texture/sampler/video resource bindings,
 transparent meshes, skinning, morphing, non-canonical layouts, and shadow views
 keep explicit CPU or specialized lanes. WebGL2 selects capability fallback from
 the same persistent projection; it does not emulate compute. Visibility and
 hierarchy changes, non-rigid multi-World composition, and some prepared-resource
 changes still require bounded reconcile work. The implemented lane proves a
 zero-upload stable data path and broad rigid geometry coverage, but hardware
-100k timing, schema-derived material variants, visibility/hierarchy-local
-routing, and GPU-driven shadows remain required before declaring P3 complete.
+100k timing, schema-derived material variants, stable world identities, and
+GPU-driven shadows remain required before declaring P3 complete.
 
 The bounded inspection reports topology revision, candidates, batches, visible
 capacity, buffer capacities, update count, upload bytes, rebuild count, and CPU
@@ -509,7 +241,7 @@ fallback rows. RhiNull verifies graph dependency order and stable-frame zero
 work; Dawn and Chromium verification consume indexed, non-indexed,
 multi-submesh, and instanced arguments, read persistent scene tables in the
 vertex path, and compare the resulting pixel. The renderer-level RhiNull
-integration also proves that the built-in URP graph contains the compute chain
+integration also proves that the built-in Standard graph contains the compute chain
 before `main`, including rigid multi-World composition, without GPU plus CPU
 duplicate draws. The renderer retains one graph, one compile owner, one
 encoder, and one submit route.
@@ -522,71 +254,11 @@ encoder, and one submit route.
 > semantics; later coverage can make those changes entity-local without adding
 > another scene authority.
 
-When a host constructs a feature only after its World or asset catalogue is
-ready, use `await renderer.installRenderFeature(feature)`. The late path inserts into
-the same lifecycle host and RenderGraph ordering as boot-time features; it is
-not a second renderer. Installing the same object twice is idempotent, while a
-different object with the same identity returns the structured registration
-conflict. Awaiting also completes the feature's declared material-shader
-prewarm, so its first prepared draw observes the same ready barrier as a
-boot-time feature.
-
-This is the graph-only Wave 1 feature route; prepared graphics and late shader
-prewarm extend the same lifecycle for production asset features.
-
-When a late-installed feature remains registered through device loss, its declared material
-shaders remain part of the renderer's live prewarm set. `await renderer.recover()` therefore
-rebuilds those modules before the next prepared draw rather than relying on a one-frame retry.
-
-For capability composition, `rendererPlugin(renderer)` provides the Host-owned
-renderer and `renderFeaturePlugin(feature)` binds installation to a Cordis
-Fiber. Fiber disposal calls `uninstallRenderFeature`, waits for submitted GPU
-work, releases prepared batches/resources, and removes the feature's shader
-prewarm declarations before the disposer resolves. The Fiber is never queried
-inside extract, prepare, record, RenderGraph execution, or an RHI command loop.
-
-When an App or Engine Worker owns the host-created Renderer itself, it installs
-`ownedRendererPlugin(renderer)`. The same Provider publishes the renderer
-Service and calls `Renderer.dispose()` after dependent capability Fibers have
-unwound. Assemble-form Apps use borrowed `rendererPlugin(renderer)` instead.
-
-```ts
-const fiber = await app.pluginContext.plugin(renderFeaturePlugin(feature));
-await fiber.dispose();
-```
-
-Boot-time `features: [...]` remains the direct renderer-construction path. Use
-the plugin helper when the feature belongs to an optional or reloadable
-capability whose lifetime must be reversible.
-
-### Built-in pipeline identity and cleanup
-
-The built-in Universal Render Pipeline is registered under the stable public
-identifier `URP_PIPELINE_ID` (`'forgeax::urp'`). Import the identifier from the
-public `@forgeax/engine-render` entry when constructing a
-`RenderPipelineAsset`; the `urpPipeline` implementation remains engine-owned.
-
-```ts
-import { URP_PIPELINE_ID } from '@forgeax/engine-render';
-
-const asset = {
-  kind: 'render-pipeline',
-  pipelineId: URP_PIPELINE_ID,
-  config: {},
-};
-const cleanup = renderer.installPipeline(asset);
-if (cleanup.ok) {
-  // Keep this disposer with the Renderer / Fiber that installed the asset.
-  cleanup.value();
-}
-```
-
-> [!IMPORTANT]
-> Pipeline, post-process, and RenderFeature registrations belong to a
-> Renderer instance and must be disposed with that instance or its owning
-> Fiber. Do not add a module-level `installed` set or reach through
-> `renderer.store`; those are lifecycle and allocation internals, not public
-> extension state.
+Features are supplied through the construction options (`features: [...]`) and
+enter the same host-owned extract → plan → graph projection path. The public
+`Renderer` intentionally has no install/uninstall methods: optional capability
+lifetime belongs to the App host, while recovery re-runs the plan against the
+replacement device generation.
 
 | This package owns | Excluded concepts |
 |:--|:--|
@@ -657,92 +329,68 @@ const renderer = await createRenderer(canvas, { profiler });
 ```
 
 Use the package's `validateProfileCapture` and `buildProfileModel` entries for offline analysis.
-The render package remains the owner of render vocabulary and extract/prepare/record execution.
+The render package remains the owner of render vocabulary and extract/plan/record execution.
 
 ## RenderFeature: the producer seam
 
 Register one producer-owned feature at the renderer assembly boundary. The
-same `FrameData` type flows through `extract`, `prepare`, and `contribute`;
-the host supplies ordering, capability projection, graph composition, and
-lifecycle isolation.
-Both paths execute inside the active RenderGraph and the frame's single
-execute/submit boundary.
+same `FrameData` type flows through `extract` and the mandatory `plan`; the
+host derives preparation, graph access, recording, and lifecycle isolation
+from that one plan. Both paths execute inside the active RenderGraph and the
+frame's single execute/submit boundary.
 
-The smallest graph-only feature can still use `addResource` plus `addPass` for
-CPU callbacks. GPU work uses the typed methods on the same staging object:
+The smallest feature returns a closed plan with named resources and passes.
+Graph access is derived from those declarations; there is no staging object or
+second contribution API:
 
 ```ts
-contribute: (_frame, context) => {
-  context.staging.addComputePass('compact', computeDescriptor).unwrap();
-  context.staging.addGraphicsPass('draw', graphicsDescriptor).unwrap();
-  return ok(undefined);
-}
+plan: (frame, context) => ok({
+  resources: [
+    { kind: 'compute-program', name: 'compact.program', program },
+    { kind: 'compute-bindings', name: 'compact.bindings', program: 'compact.program', entries },
+  ],
+  passes: [{
+    kind: 'compute', name: 'compact', program: 'compact.program',
+    bindings: 'compact.bindings', dispatches,
+  }],
+})
 ```
 
-`computeDescriptor` contains only prepared program/binding references and
-dispatches. `graphicsDescriptor` contains logical feature targets, prepared
-pipeline/binding/data references, and draw or indirect-draw commands. The host
-projects both into one typed `RenderGraph`; neither descriptor owns an encoder.
+The plan contains cooked program descriptors, named buffers and bindings, logical
+targets, and draw/dispatch commands. Graph buffer and texture access is derived
+from those roles; producers never author a second `reads`/`writes` ledger and
+never receive an encoder or submit authority.
 
 ### Five render terms
 
 | Term | Meaning | Owner |
 |:--|:--|:--|
-| `RenderFeature` | Producer-owned extract/prepare/contribute callbacks and frame data | Feature producer |
-| `RenderPipeline` | Full frame policy selected or switched by the host | Render host |
-| RenderGraph pass | One declared graph execution node contributed to the active pipeline | Graph host |
+| `RenderFeature` | Producer-owned extract/plan callbacks and frame data | Feature producer |
+| `Standard Pipeline` | The single frame policy containing the supported capability/profile lanes | Render host |
+| RenderGraph pass | One declared graph execution node in the active Standard Pipeline | Graph host |
 | Material pass | One shader-facing pass in a `MaterialAsset` | Material asset |
-| Prepared graphics | Opaque pipeline, binding, vertex/index, and attachment references prepared by the host | Render host |
-| Prepared GPU work | Opaque persistent compute program, binding, buffer, dispatch, and indirect-draw references | Render host |
+| RenderFeaturePlan | One executable declaration of resources, bindings, targets, and commands | Feature producer |
 
 ### Prepared compute resources
 
-`RenderFeature` producers prepare cooked compute pipelines, reflected name-based bindings,
-uniform/storage buffers, and dispatches. The renderer joins reflection with prepared binding
-entries, imports the persistent buffers into the render graph, and derives `uniform-read`,
+`RenderFeature` producers declare cooked compute pipelines, reflected name-based bindings,
+uniform/storage buffers, and dispatches. The renderer prepares those declarations,
+imports the persistent buffers into the render graph, and derives `uniform-read`,
 `storage-read`, or `storage-read-write` access. Producers do not repeat a string `reads/writes`
 ledger and do not receive an encoder.
 
-Compute and graphics passes use the same contribution graph and submission boundary. The graph
-owns `beginComputePass` / `end`; prepared GPU work records only pipeline, bind group, and dispatch
-commands into the lent pass encoder. Persistent buffers retain device identity across frames,
+Compute and graphics passes use the same plan projection and submission boundary. The graph
+owns `beginComputePass` / `end`; the plan records only named pipeline, bind group, and dispatch
+commands. Persistent buffers retain device identity across frames,
 rebuild with the feature-host generation, and retire only after queue completion. A storage buffer
 may also be consumed as renderer-declared vertex data.
 
 Feature contexts never expose raw GPU graphics state, a complete pipeline
-context, submit authority, or a command encoder. They expose an immutable
-`Readonly<RhiCaps>` capability snapshot for capability-gated preparation. The
-graph-only `addPass`
-surface still exposes only named pass and frame identity; use the prepared
-graphics surface below when a feature needs pipelines, bindings, vertex/index
-data, attachments, and draw records. Both paths execute inside the active
-RenderGraph and the frame's single execute/submit boundary. The active RenderGraph
-owns that frame boundary. Do not cast either context to a raw device or encoder. See
-[`features/graph-contribution.ts`](src/features/graph-contribution.ts) for the
-staging shape.
-
-The copyable recipe above is therefore a graph-only Wave 1 feature; it stops at
-the graph seam and does not provide a production particle draw path.
-
-### Prepared graphics recipe
-
-Prepared graphics extends the existing graph-owned staging seam with five
-opaque reference kinds. A producer requests preparation during `prepare`,
-retains only the returned references, and contributes declarative records. The
-render host owns generation checks, graph composition, recording, and submit.
-
-Persistent GPU work follows the same ownership rule. A feature may retain opaque bindings for an
-active producer; bindings retain their transitive program and buffers. Untouched resources are
-detached after a successful feature frame and destroyed after queue completion, never while an
-in-flight command can still reference them.
-
-Prepare opaque references through `context.graphics` and, when compute is
-available, `context.gpu`; retain those references in producer-owned frame data
-and consume them only through `addComputePass` and `addGraphicsPass` during
-`contribute`. The executable contract examples live in
-[`render-feature-graph.integration.test.ts`](src/__tests__/render-feature-graph.integration.test.ts)
-and
-[`render-feature-gpu-work.integration.test.ts`](src/__tests__/render-feature-gpu-work.integration.test.ts).
+context, submit authority, or a command encoder. They expose immutable
+capabilities and logical targets for plan construction. The active RenderGraph
+owns the frame boundary; do not cast a plan context to a backend object or
+encoder. The executable contract examples live in the plan-focused tests under
+`src/record/__tests__` and `src/features`.
 
 ### Failure and recovery
 
@@ -756,19 +404,17 @@ consume the structured `error.detail` context.
 |:--|:--|
 | `active` | Continue the next frame |
 | `failed` / `render-feature-stage-failed` | Correct producer data and retry on the next frame |
-| `disabled` / `render-feature-capability-missing` | Provide the capability on a replacement device; after device-loss recovery call `await renderer.recover()`. On a live renderer, `recover()` returns `recover-not-needed`, so rebuild on a capable device instead. |
+| `disabled` / `render-feature-capability-missing` | Provide the capability on a replacement device; after device-loss recovery call `await renderer.recover()`. On a live renderer, the public recovery boundary returns a structured renderer-state-invalid result, so rebuild on a capable device instead. |
 | `render-feature-registration-conflict` | Fix identity/order at registration |
-| `render-feature-pass-order-conflict` | Reorder the declared dependency and retry contribution |
+| `render-feature-pass-order-conflict` | Reorder the declared dependency and re-plan on the next frame |
 | `render-feature-preparation-failed` | Repair the named prepared resource and retry on the action in `error.detail.recovery`; after device loss, verify that the feature's declared shader was included in the recovery prewarm set |
 | `render-feature-prepared-state-mismatch` | Read the discriminated `error.detail.reason`, repair the generation/layout/format mismatch, and retry |
 | `render-feature-draw-recording-failed` | Read `error.detail.backendReason`, then retry after the host reports renderer recovery |
 | `disposed` | Terminal; create a new renderer/feature registration |
 
-Use `renderer.renderFeatureDiagnostics()` for a read-only snapshot. Call
-`renderer.dispose()` once or repeatedly; disposal is idempotent. A pipeline
-switch keeps the feature registration list and rebuilds the active graph.
-The host still uses `renderer.registerPipeline(id, pipeline)` for a full
-pipeline change.
+Use `renderer.inspect()` for a read-only snapshot. Call `renderer.dispose()`
+once or repeatedly; disposal is idempotent. Feature plans are assembled once
+and the Standard host owns graph replacement and last-known-good recovery.
 
 For a temporary presentation-owner handoff, call `renderer.releaseSurface()`.
 It unconfigures the canvas and makes `draw()` fail closed without disposing the
@@ -778,9 +424,9 @@ next draw. Both calls are idempotent; `dispose()` remains the terminal path.
 
 For the complete declaration shape, read
 [`features/types.ts`](src/features/types.ts) and
-[`features/prepared-graphics.ts`](src/features/prepared-graphics.ts). For graph
-contribution details, read [`features/graph-contribution.ts`](src/features/graph-contribution.ts);
-for pipeline switching, read [`renderer.ts`](src/renderer.ts). The producer
+[`features/plan.ts`](src/features/plan.ts). For Standard profile and lane
+selection, read the internal pipeline implementation through the host seam;
+there is no public full-pipeline registration API. The producer
 asset contract is [`@forgeax/engine-vfx`](../vfx/README.md), while graph
 ownership is [`@forgeax/engine-render-graph`](../render-graph/README.md).
 
@@ -806,120 +452,23 @@ import {
   GlyphText,
   SpriteAnimation,
   Tilemap,
-  setTransparentSortConfig,
-  TRANSPARENT_SORT_MODE_LAYER_Y,
+  TransparentSort,
 } from '@forgeax/engine-render/authoring';
 ```
 
-`authoring` also owns the public transparent-bucket configuration helpers and
-their four named modes. A consumer that composes sprites with an existing 3D
-game may set the world-level mode here; it should not reach into `/internal`.
-
-The root barrel does not expose frame stores or extract/prepare/record owners.
-Custom pipelines use `RenderPipeline.build`, typed targets, and typed graph
-primitives; the renderer owns graph compilation and submission.
-
-`@forgeax/engine-render/internal` is an engine-owned assembly seam, not an
-application API or a compatibility route. Imports from `/internal` under the
-private `apps/` tree are engine dogfood for assembly coverage, not application
-recipes. First-party packages may use it while the engine is assembled;
-application code should not copy those imports. Its
-surface can change without a consumer migration promise. If a custom renderer
-needs a capability absent from the supported root operations, treat that as a
-request for an explicit public design rather than importing `/internal`.
-
-For a custom `RenderPipeline` with `Camera.antialias = ANTIALIAS_MSAA`, create
-count-4 scene colour/depth targets plus a single-sample resolve target, then pass
-the typed resolve target to `addTypedScenePass`. Downstream passes read that
-resolved handle; single-sample pipelines omit it.
-
-## Temporal antialiasing contract
-
-`Camera.antialias = ANTIALIAS_TAA` selects the renderer-owned temporal path. The fixed v1 order is linear scene color -> temporal raster -> one TAA resolve -> bloom -> tone/output/debug/UI. `Camera.historyVersion` is the explicit reset authority; increment it after a camera cut or other discontinuity.
-
-> [!IMPORTANT]
-> Read `renderer.renderScene.temporal` after `draw()`. It is the bounded inspection SSOT for history bytes, reset reason, coverage, failure, and recovery. Applications must not retain graph textures or create a parallel history registry.
-
-The none, FXAA, and MSAA lanes allocate zero TAA history and record neither `scene-temporal-clear` nor `taa-resolve`. The permanent real-backend oracle is [`apps/hello/taa`](../../apps/hello/taa/README.md).
-
-The main scene raster is the only jittered domain. Temporal replay uses unjittered current and previous view projection matrices plus its own cleared depth attachment; reusing main depth would compare unjittered fragments against jittered visibility. The packed `rgba16float` payload is `(currentUv - previousUv, log2(1 + viewDepth), reactive)`. Clip payloads use linear interpolation so previous projection remains a geometric authority rather than a perspective-correct material varying.
-
-Resolve and both history textures live in the unjittered output domain. Current scene color is therefore sampled at `uv + currentJitterUv`, while history is sampled at `uv - velocity`. This is the same coordinate transform as the jittered-domain form `uvJittered - velocity + (previousJitter - currentJitter)`: storing the previous resolve unjittered removes the previous-jitter term instead of dropping jitter correction. The v1 preset keeps hard UV/depth rejection, 3 x 3 current-neighborhood clipping, alpha preservation, and a fixed luminance-adaptive feedback range of 0.88 through 0.97 further reduced by reactive, velocity, depth, and startup factors.
-
-### AI-user recipe: TAA, reset, and recovery
-
-Enable TAA on the existing `Camera` and treat `historyVersion` as an explicit discontinuity counter. Do not increment it for ordinary camera motion.
-
-```ts
-import { ANTIALIAS_TAA, Camera } from '@forgeax/engine-render';
-
-const camera = world.spawn({
-  component: Camera,
-  data: {
-    fov: Math.PI / 4,
-    aspect: 16 / 9,
-    near: 0.1,
-    far: 100,
-    antialias: ANTIALIAS_TAA,
-    historyVersion: 0,
-  },
-}).unwrap();
-
-let historyVersion = 0;
-function resetHistoryAfterCameraCut(): void {
-  historyVersion += 1;
-  world.set(camera, Camera, { historyVersion }).unwrap();
-}
-```
-
-Register `onError` before the first draw, handle the returned `Result`, then read the bounded inspection after the draw. The inspection is the recovery authority; the error listener preserves the exact structured failure that caused it.
-
-```ts
-const stopErrors = renderer.onError((error) => reportRenderError(error));
-const drawn = renderer.draw([world], { cameraOwner: 0, resourceOwner: 0 });
-if (!drawn.ok) reportRenderError(drawn.error);
-
-const temporal = renderer.renderScene.temporal;
-if (temporal.recovery !== 'none') {
-  reportTemporalRecovery(temporal.recovery, temporal.failure, temporal.coverage);
-}
-
-stopErrors();
-```
-
-| `temporal.recovery` | Owner action |
-|:--|:--|
-| `none` | Continue; a stable submitted frame owns valid history. |
-| `seed-history` | Submit the next continuous frame; increment `historyVersion` only for a real discontinuity. |
-| `enable-temporal-capabilities` | Recreate the renderer on a device with `rgba16float` rendering and at least two color attachments. |
-| `fix-temporal-pipeline-topology` | Repair the custom pipeline's target domain, attachment, or resolve count. |
-| `complete-temporal-coverage` | Find `coverage.missingContributorIds`; make each producer exact or reactive. |
-| `retry-frame` | Retry after the submit failure; aborted frames never advance history. |
-| `rebuild-renderer` | Call `await renderer.recover()` after device loss and handle its `Result`. |
+`authoring` also owns the grouped transparent-bucket configuration values. A
+consumer that composes sprites with an existing 3D game can call
+`TransparentSort.configure(world, { mode: TransparentSort.layerY, yzAlpha: 1 })`;
+it should not reach into `/internal`.
 
-### Custom pipeline temporal seam
+The root barrel does not expose frame stores or extract/plan/record owners.
+Applications contribute work through `RenderFeature` plans; the Standard
+renderer owns graph compilation and submission.
 
-A custom pipeline uses the same graph owner and follows one narrow order: scene color -> unjittered temporal raster -> feature contributions -> exactly one `context.resolveTemporal(...)` -> bloom/tone/output. For a TAA topology, allocate `scene-color` and `scene-temporal` as single-sample `rgba16float`; allocate a separate single-sample temporal depth target; clear temporal color to `(0, 0, -1, 1)` before replay; and call the public resolve seam exactly once. A non-TAA topology allocates and records none of those temporal resources or passes; calling the seam without `sceneTemporal` is optional and returns `undefined`.
-
-```ts
-const features = context.contributeFeatures([
-  sceneColorTarget,
-  sceneDepthTarget,
-  sceneTemporalTarget,
-]);
-if (!features.ok) return features;
-
-const resolved = context.resolveTemporal({
-  sceneColor: sceneColorTarget,
-  sceneDepth: sceneDepthTarget,
-  sceneTemporal: sceneTemporalTarget,
-});
-if (!resolved.ok) return resolved;
-
-const postInput = resolved.value?.resolvedColor ?? sceneColorTarget;
-```
-
-The snippet assumes the pipeline has already recorded its scene and temporal raster passes. `exact` feature coverage must write the provided `scene-temporal` target from current/previous producer state. `reactive` is conservative but complete coverage: declaring `temporalCoverage: 'reactive'` permits current-frame fallback, while writing `w = 1` to the target gives pixel-local rejection. A visible graphics producer that declares neither is `missing`; the renderer rejects that frame's history instead of guessing.
+The render package has one narrow construction seam owned by the host. It is
+not an application API or a compatibility route. Standard profile and
+capability lanes own MSAA target selection and resolve; applications do not
+replace the frame topology.
 
 ```mermaid
 flowchart LR
@@ -947,7 +496,7 @@ const snapshot = resolveVisibility(world);
 |:--|:--|:--|
 | Author intent | `Visibility.state` is `inherited`, `hidden`, or `visible` | Read the ECS field or reflected `labels` |
 | Effective state | `resolveVisibility(world).effective(entity)` applies valid scene parents | Inspect `snapshot.diagnostics` and `VisibilityResolution.source` |
-| Render result | Render producers skip hidden candidates before material work | Read `renderer.visibilityStats`; it is not a frustum or picking metric |
+| Render result | Render producers skip hidden candidates before material work | Read `renderer.inspect().visibilityStats`; it is not a frustum or picking metric |
 
 If the state write returns an error, preserve `code`, `expected`, `hint`, and
 `detail`, correct the enum value, and retry through `world.set`. If hierarchy
@@ -957,63 +506,3 @@ hide the issue with a custom mesh, camera workaround, or material substitute.
 Out of scope: camera frustum policy, picking, app lifecycle, asset import, and
 VFX shadow behavior. `@forgeax/engine-vfx-render` remains the producer-owned
 particle bridge and consumes the same effective visibility boundary.
-
-## Analytic atmosphere: one source, one submitted generation
-
-The analytic environment route has one authoring source and one renderer-owned
-submission transaction. `Atmosphere` contains exactly five medium fields; the
-resource-owner selector enforces one Atmosphere source per World (the ECS schema
-does not carry cardinality policy);
-Sun direction, colour and illuminance belong to the co-located
-`DirectionalLight` entity. The app never selects an atmosphere Skybox mode and
-never owns an evaluator, cache, lifecycle ledger, encoder or queue submit.
-
-```ts
-const sunEntity = world.spawn(
-  { component: Atmosphere, data: {
-    turbidity: 2.4,
-    rayleigh: 1.1,
-    mieCoefficient: 0.006,
-    mieDirectionalG: 0.78,
-    sunAngularRadius: 0.004675,
-  } },
-  { component: DirectionalLight, data: {
-    direction: [0.35, -0.88, -0.2],
-    color: [1, 0.93, 0.82],
-    intensity: 2.2,
-  } },
-).unwrap();
-
-world.update(1 / 60).unwrap();
-const frame = renderer.draw([world], { cameraOwner: 0, resourceOwner: 0 });
-if (!frame.ok) reportRenderError(frame.error);
-const submitted = renderer.renderScene.environment;
-```
-
-The final line is a bounded projection of the existing Renderer generation
-transaction. It reports state, source World/entity, desired/active signature,
-device generation, bytes, rebuild facts, failure/LKG and temporal publish/reset
-facts. It does not expose GPU handles or mutable caches.
-
-| Failure observation | Exhaustive recovery action |
-|:--|:--|
-| `environment-source-conflict` | Keep exactly one image or Atmosphere source and retry extract. |
-| `atmosphere-sun-missing` | Add the co-located `DirectionalLight`; do not invent a second Sun store. |
-| `atmosphere-capability-insufficient` | Admit only the M0 capability matrix result or fail closed. |
-| `atmosphere-producer-failed` | Read the stage, preserve LKG, repair the producer and retry the same Renderer owner. |
-| `render-feature-*` / `webgpu-runtime-error` | Read the discriminated `code`/`detail`, abort the frame transaction and follow its explicit recovery. |
-
-> [!WARNING]
-> `Fog`, day/night automation, clouds, aerial perspective, astronomy, auto
-> exposure and a high-frequency time-of-day system are not implemented by this
-> route. A compatibility alias, conceptual wrapper, second evaluator/cache or
-> second submit/lifecycle owner would fail the one-cut audit.
-
-<details>
-<summary>U-12 comparative-only boundary</summary>
-
-Three r184 and PMREM references may appear in comparative calibration evidence,
-but they are not an implementation dependency, runtime import, evaluator, or
-public API owner. Comparative observations cannot turn an unavailable
-Browser/Dawn readback into a ForgeaX pixel verdict.
-</details>