@fluidframework/tree 2.74.0-365691 → 2.74.0-368706

package/src/feature-libraries/sequence-field/sequenceFieldCodecV2.ts

@@ -11,16 +11,21 @@ import {
 	type DiscriminatedUnionLibrary,
 	type IJsonCodec,
 } from "../../codec/index.js";
-import type {
-	ChangeEncodingContext,
-	ChangesetLocalId,
-	EncodedRevisionTag,
-	RevisionTag,
+import {
+	areEqualChangeAtomIds,
+	type ChangeAtomId,
+	type ChangeEncodingContext,
+	type ChangesetLocalId,
+	type EncodedRevisionTag,
+	type RevisionTag,
 } from "../../core/index.js";
 import { type JsonCompatibleReadOnly, type Mutable, brand } from "../../util/index.js";
 import { makeChangeAtomIdCodec } from "../changeAtomIdCodec.js";
 import {
 	EncodedNodeChangeset,
+	getFromChangeAtomIdMap,
+	rangeQueryChangeAtomIdMap,
+	type EncodedChangeAtomId,
 	type FieldChangeEncodingContext,
 } from "../modular-schema/index.js";
 
@@ -28,19 +33,15 @@ import { Changeset as ChangesetSchema, type Encoded } from "./formatV2.js";
 import type { SequenceCodecHelpers } from "./helperTypes.js";
 import {
 	type Attach,
-	type AttachAndDetach,
+	type CellMark,
 	type Changeset,
 	type Detach,
-	type Insert,
 	type Mark,
 	type MarkEffect,
-	type MoveIn,
-	type MoveOut,
 	NoopMarkType,
-	type Remove,
 	type Rename,
 } from "./types.js";
-import { isNoopMark, normalizeCellRename } from "./utils.js";
+import { getAttachedRootId, getDetachedRootId, isNoopMark, splitMark } from "./utils.js";
 
 export function makeV2CodecHelpers(
 	revisionTagCodec: IJsonCodec<
@@ -49,100 +50,8 @@ export function makeV2CodecHelpers(
 		EncodedRevisionTag,
 		ChangeEncodingContext
 	>,
-): SequenceCodecHelpers<MarkEffect, Encoded.MarkEffect> {
+): SequenceCodecHelpers {
 	const changeAtomIdCodec = makeChangeAtomIdCodec(revisionTagCodec);
-	const markEffectCodec: IJsonCodec<
-		MarkEffect,
-		Encoded.MarkEffect,
-		Encoded.MarkEffect,
-		ChangeEncodingContext
-	> = {
-		encode(effect: MarkEffect, context: ChangeEncodingContext): Encoded.MarkEffect {
-			function encodeRevision(
-				revision: RevisionTag | undefined,
-			): EncodedRevisionTag | undefined {
-				if (revision === undefined || revision === context.revision) {
-					return undefined;
-				}
-
-				return revisionTagCodec.encode(revision, context);
-			}
-
-			const type = effect.type;
-			switch (type) {
-				case "MoveIn":
-					return {
-						moveIn: {
-							revision: encodeRevision(effect.revision),
-							finalEndpoint:
-								effect.finalEndpoint === undefined
-									? undefined
-									: changeAtomIdCodec.encode(effect.finalEndpoint, context),
-							id: effect.id,
-						},
-					};
-				case "Insert":
-					return {
-						insert: {
-							revision: encodeRevision(effect.revision),
-							id: effect.id,
-						},
-					};
-				case "Remove":
-					return {
-						remove: {
-							revision: encodeRevision(effect.revision),
-							idOverride:
-								effect.idOverride === undefined
-									? undefined
-									: changeAtomIdCodec.encode(effect.idOverride, context),
-							id: effect.id,
-						},
-					};
-				case "MoveOut":
-					return {
-						moveOut: {
-							revision: encodeRevision(effect.revision),
-							finalEndpoint:
-								effect.finalEndpoint === undefined
-									? undefined
-									: changeAtomIdCodec.encode(effect.finalEndpoint, context),
-							idOverride:
-								effect.idOverride === undefined
-									? undefined
-									: changeAtomIdCodec.encode(effect.idOverride, context),
-							id: effect.id,
-						},
-					};
-				case "AttachAndDetach":
-					return {
-						attachAndDetach: {
-							attach: markEffectCodec.encode(effect.attach, context) as Encoded.Attach,
-							detach: markEffectCodec.encode(effect.detach, context) as Encoded.Detach,
-						},
-					};
-				case "Rename":
-					// In documents generated by clients on release >=2.2 (i.e., running the code from the PR that added this comment),
-					// renames are encoded as AttachAndDetach with a special id.
-					// This ensures forward-compatibility of clients on release <=2.1 with documents/ops generated by clients on release >=2.2.
-					return markEffectCodec.encode(
-						{
-							type: "AttachAndDetach",
-							attach: { type: "MoveIn", id: renameLocalId },
-							detach: { type: "MoveOut", id: renameLocalId, idOverride: effect.idOverride },
-						},
-						context,
-					);
-				case NoopMarkType:
-					fail(0xb2c /* Mark type: NoopMarkType should not be encoded. */);
-				default:
-					unreachableCase(type);
-			}
-		},
-		decode(encoded: Encoded.MarkEffect, context: ChangeEncodingContext): MarkEffect {
-			return decoderDispatcher.dispatch(encoded, context);
-		},
-	};
 
 	function decodeRevision(
 		encodedRevision: EncodedRevisionTag | undefined,
@@ -156,102 +65,312 @@ export function makeV2CodecHelpers(
 		return revisionTagCodec.decode(encodedRevision, context);
 	}
 
-	const decoderLibrary: DiscriminatedUnionLibrary<
+	const decoderLibrary = makeMarkEffectDecoder(changeAtomIdCodec, decodeRevision);
+
+	const decoderDispatcher = new DiscriminatedUnionDispatcher<
 		Encoded.MarkEffect,
-		/* args */ [context: ChangeEncodingContext],
+		/* args */ [
+			count: number,
+			cellId: ChangeAtomId | undefined,
+			context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+		],
 		MarkEffect
-	> = {
-		moveIn(encoded: Encoded.MoveIn, context: ChangeEncodingContext): MoveIn {
-			const { id, finalEndpoint, revision } = encoded;
-			const mark: MoveIn = {
-				type: "MoveIn",
-				id,
-			};
+	>(decoderLibrary);
 
-			mark.revision = decodeRevision(revision, context);
-			if (finalEndpoint !== undefined) {
-				mark.finalEndpoint = changeAtomIdCodec.decode(finalEndpoint, context);
+	return {
+		changeAtomIdCodec,
+		decoderLibrary,
+
+		encodeMarkEffect(mark: Mark, context: FieldChangeEncodingContext): Encoded.MarkEffect {
+			return encodeMarkEffectV2(
+				mark,
+				context,
+				(revision) =>
+					encodeRevisionWithContext(revision, context.baseContext, revisionTagCodec),
+				changeAtomIdCodec,
+			);
+		},
+
+		decodeRevision: (
+			encoded: EncodedRevisionTag | undefined,
+			context: ChangeEncodingContext,
+		): RevisionTag =>
+			encoded !== undefined
+				? revisionTagCodec.decode(encoded, context)
+				: (context.revision ?? fail("Expected a default revision")),
+
+		decodeMarkEffect: (
+			encoded: Encoded.MarkEffect,
+			count: number,
+			cellId: ChangeAtomId | undefined,
+			context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+		): MarkEffect => {
+			return decoderDispatcher.dispatch(encoded, count, cellId, context);
+		},
+	};
+}
+
+export type DecodeMarkEffect = (
+	encoded: Encoded.MarkEffect,
+	count: number,
+	cellId: ChangeAtomId | undefined,
+	context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+) => MarkEffect;
+
+export function decodeSequenceChangeset(
+	changeset: Encoded.Changeset<NodeChangeSchema>,
+	context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+	changeAtomIdCodec: IJsonCodec<
+		ChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		ChangeEncodingContext
+	>,
+	decodeMarkEffect: DecodeMarkEffect,
+): Changeset {
+	const marks: Changeset = [];
+	for (const mark of changeset) {
+		const decodedMark: Mark = {
+			count: mark.count,
+		};
+
+		if (mark.cellId !== undefined) {
+			decodedMark.cellId = changeAtomIdCodec.decode(mark.cellId, context.baseContext);
+		}
+
+		if (mark.effect !== undefined) {
+			Object.assign(
+				decodedMark,
+				decodeMarkEffect(mark.effect, mark.count, decodedMark.cellId, context),
+			);
+		}
+
+		if (mark.changes !== undefined) {
+			if (decodedMark.cellId !== undefined) {
+				context.decodeRootNodeChange(decodedMark.cellId, mark.changes);
+			} else {
+				decodedMark.changes = context.decodeNode(mark.changes);
 			}
-			return mark;
+		}
+
+		marks.push(decodedMark);
+	}
+	return marks;
+}
+
+function makeMarkEffectDecoder(
+	changeAtomIdCodec: IJsonCodec<
+		ChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		ChangeEncodingContext
+	>,
+	decodeRevision: (
+		revision: EncodedRevisionTag | undefined,
+		context: ChangeEncodingContext,
+	) => RevisionTag,
+): DiscriminatedUnionLibrary<
+	Encoded.MarkEffect,
+	/* args */ [
+		count: number,
+		cellId: ChangeAtomId | undefined,
+		context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+	],
+	MarkEffect
+> {
+	function decodeMoveIn(encoded: Encoded.MoveIn, context: FieldChangeEncodingContext): Attach {
+		const { id, revision } = encoded;
+		const endpoint =
+			encoded.finalEndpoint !== undefined
+				? changeAtomIdCodec.decode(encoded.finalEndpoint, context.baseContext)
+				: undefined;
+
+		const mark: Attach = {
+			type: "Insert",
+			id: endpoint?.localId ?? id,
+			revision: endpoint?.revision ?? decodeRevision(revision, context.baseContext),
+		};
+
+		return mark;
+	}
+
+	const decoderLibrary: DiscriminatedUnionLibrary<
+		Encoded.MarkEffect,
+		/* args */ [
+			count: number,
+			cellId: ChangeAtomId | undefined,
+			context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+		],
+		MarkEffect
+	> = {
+		moveIn(
+			encoded: Encoded.MoveIn,
+			count: number,
+			cellId: ChangeAtomId | undefined,
+			context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+		): Attach {
+			return decodeMoveIn(encoded, context);
 		},
-		insert(encoded: Encoded.Insert, context: ChangeEncodingContext): Insert {
+		insert(
+			encoded: Encoded.Insert,
+			count: number,
+			cellId: ChangeAtomId | undefined,
+			context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+		): Attach {
 			const { id, revision } = encoded;
-			const mark: Insert = {
+			const mark: Attach = {
 				type: "Insert",
 				id,
 			};
 
-			mark.revision = decodeRevision(revision, context);
-			return mark;
-		},
-		remove(encoded: Encoded.Remove, context: ChangeEncodingContext): Remove {
-			const { id, revision, idOverride } = encoded;
-			const mark: Mutable<Remove> = {
-				type: "Remove",
-				id,
-			};
+			mark.revision = decodeRevision(revision, context.baseContext);
 
-			mark.revision = decodeRevision(revision, context);
-			if (idOverride !== undefined) {
-				mark.idOverride = changeAtomIdCodec.decode(idOverride, context);
+			const attachId = getAttachedRootId(mark);
+			if (cellId !== undefined && !areEqualChangeAtomIds(cellId, attachId)) {
+				context.decodeRootRename(cellId, attachId, count);
 			}
+
 			return mark;
 		},
-		moveOut(encoded: Encoded.MoveOut, context: ChangeEncodingContext): MoveOut {
-			const { id, finalEndpoint, idOverride, revision } = encoded;
-			const mark: Mutable<MoveOut> = {
-				type: "MoveOut",
+		remove(
+			encoded: Encoded.Remove,
+			count: number,
+			cellId: ChangeAtomId | undefined,
+			context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+		): Detach | Rename {
+			const { id, revision, idOverride } = encoded;
+
+			const cellRename =
+				idOverride !== undefined
+					? changeAtomIdCodec.decode(idOverride, context.baseContext)
+					: undefined;
+
+			return decodeDetach(
+				cellId,
+				count,
+				decodeRevision(revision, context.baseContext),
 				id,
-			};
+				cellRename,
+				undefined,
+				context,
+			);
+		},
+		moveOut(
+			encoded: Encoded.MoveOut,
+			count: number,
+			cellId: ChangeAtomId | undefined,
+			context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+		): Detach | Rename {
+			const { id, idOverride, revision, finalEndpoint } = encoded;
+			const cellRename =
+				idOverride !== undefined
+					? changeAtomIdCodec.decode(idOverride, context.baseContext)
+					: undefined;
 
-			mark.revision = decodeRevision(revision, context);
+			const decodedRevision = decodeRevision(revision, context.baseContext);
 			if (finalEndpoint !== undefined) {
-				mark.finalEndpoint = changeAtomIdCodec.decode(finalEndpoint, context);
-			}
-			if (idOverride !== undefined) {
-				mark.idOverride = changeAtomIdCodec.decode(idOverride, context);
+				const decodedEndpoint = changeAtomIdCodec.decode(finalEndpoint, context.baseContext);
+				return decodeDetach(
+					cellId,
+					count,
+					decodedEndpoint.revision ?? fail("Revision should be defined"),
+					decodedEndpoint.localId,
+					cellRename,
+					{ revision: decodedRevision, localId: id },
+					context,
+				);
 			}
 
-			return mark;
+			return decodeDetach(cellId, count, decodedRevision, id, cellRename, undefined, context);
 		},
 		attachAndDetach(
 			encoded: Encoded.AttachAndDetach,
-			context: ChangeEncodingContext,
-		): AttachAndDetach | Rename {
-			const attach = decoderDispatcher.dispatch(encoded.attach, context) as Attach;
-			const detach = decoderDispatcher.dispatch(encoded.detach, context) as Detach;
+			count: number,
+			cellId: ChangeAtomId | undefined,
+			context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+		): Rename {
 			// In documents generated by clients on release >=2.2 (i.e., running the code from the PR that added this comment),
 			// renames are encoded as AttachAndDetach with a special id.
 			// This ensures forward-compatibility of clients on release <=2.1 with documents/ops generated by clients on release >=2.2.
-			if (attach.id === renameLocalId) {
-				assert(detach.idOverride !== undefined, 0x9f8 /* Rename must have idOverride */);
+			const encodedRenameId = tryGetEncodedCellRenameFromAttachAndDetach(encoded);
+			if (encodedRenameId !== undefined) {
 				return {
 					type: "Rename",
-					idOverride: detach.idOverride,
+					idOverride: changeAtomIdCodec.decode(encodedRenameId, context.baseContext),
 				};
 			}
+
+			assert(
+				encoded.detach.remove !== undefined,
+				"Attach and detach should always contains a remove",
+			);
+
+			const detachId: ChangeAtomId =
+				encoded.detach.remove.idOverride !== undefined
+					? changeAtomIdCodec.decode(encoded.detach.remove.idOverride, context.baseContext)
+					: {
+							revision: decodeRevision(encoded.detach.remove.revision, context.baseContext),
+							localId: encoded.detach.remove.id,
+						};
+
+			assert(cellId !== undefined, "Attach and detach should target an empty cell");
+			if (encoded.attach.moveIn !== undefined) {
+				context.decodeMoveAndDetach(detachId, count);
+			} else {
+				context.decodeRootRename(cellId, detachId, count);
+			}
+
 			return {
-				type: "AttachAndDetach",
-				attach,
-				detach,
+				type: "Rename",
+				idOverride: detachId,
 			};
 		},
 	};
 
-	const decoderDispatcher = new DiscriminatedUnionDispatcher<
-		Encoded.MarkEffect,
-		/* args */ [context: ChangeEncodingContext],
-		MarkEffect
-	>(decoderLibrary);
+	return decoderLibrary;
+}
 
-	return {
-		changeAtomIdCodec,
-		markEffectCodec,
-		decoderLibrary,
-		decodeRevision,
+function decodeDetach(
+	cellId: ChangeAtomId | undefined,
+	count: number,
+	revision: RevisionTag,
+	localId: ChangesetLocalId,
+	cellRename: ChangeAtomId | undefined,
+	detachCellId: ChangeAtomId | undefined,
+	context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+): Detach | Rename {
+	const detachId: ChangeAtomId = { revision, localId };
+	if (cellId !== undefined) {
+		context.decodeRootRename(cellId, detachId, count);
+		return {
+			type: "Rename",
+			idOverride: cellRename ?? detachId,
+		};
+	}
+
+	const mark: Mutable<Detach> = {
+		type: "Remove",
+		revision,
+		id: localId,
 	};
+
+	if (cellRename !== undefined) {
+		mark.cellRename = cellRename;
+	}
+
+	if (detachCellId !== undefined) {
+		mark.detachCellId = detachCellId;
+	}
+
+	return mark;
 }
 
+/**
+ * If we want to make the node change aspect of this codec more type-safe, we could adjust generics
+ * to be in terms of the schema rather than the concrete type of the node change.
+ */
+type NodeChangeSchema = TAnySchema;
+
 export function makeV2Codec(
 	revisionTagCodec: IJsonCodec<
 		RevisionTag,
@@ -265,78 +384,382 @@ export function makeV2Codec(
 	JsonCompatibleReadOnly,
 	FieldChangeEncodingContext
 > {
-	const { markEffectCodec, changeAtomIdCodec } = makeV2CodecHelpers(revisionTagCodec);
-	/**
-	 * If we want to make the node change aspect of this codec more type-safe, we could adjust generics
-	 * to be in terms of the schema rather than the concrete type of the node change.
-	 */
-	type NodeChangeSchema = TAnySchema;
+	const { decodeMarkEffect, changeAtomIdCodec } = makeV2CodecHelpers(revisionTagCodec);
 
 	return {
 		encode: (
 			changeset: Changeset,
 			context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
-		): JsonCompatibleReadOnly & Encoded.Changeset<NodeChangeSchema> => {
-			const jsonMarks: Encoded.Changeset<NodeChangeSchema> = [];
-			for (const mark of changeset) {
-				const encodedMark: Encoded.Mark<NodeChangeSchema> = {
-					count: mark.count,
-				};
-				if (!isNoopMark(mark)) {
-					encodedMark.effect = markEffectCodec.encode(mark, context.baseContext);
-				}
-				if (mark.cellId !== undefined) {
-					encodedMark.cellId = changeAtomIdCodec.encode(mark.cellId, context.baseContext);
-				}
-				if (mark.changes !== undefined) {
-					encodedMark.changes = context.encodeNode(mark.changes);
-				}
-				jsonMarks.push(encodedMark);
-			}
-			return jsonMarks;
-		},
+		): JsonCompatibleReadOnly & Encoded.Changeset<NodeChangeSchema> =>
+			encodeSequenceChangeset(
+				changeset,
+				context,
+				(revision) =>
+					encodeRevisionWithContext(revision, context.baseContext, revisionTagCodec),
+				changeAtomIdCodec,
+				encodeMarkEffectV2,
+			),
 		decode: (
 			changeset: Encoded.Changeset<NodeChangeSchema>,
 			context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
-		): Changeset => {
-			const marks: Changeset = [];
-			for (const mark of changeset) {
-				const decodedMark: Mark = {
-					count: mark.count,
-				};
+		): Changeset =>
+			decodeSequenceChangeset(changeset, context, changeAtomIdCodec, decodeMarkEffect),
+		encodedSchema: ChangesetSchema(EncodedNodeChangeset),
+	};
+}
 
-				if (mark.effect !== undefined) {
-					Object.assign(decodedMark, markEffectCodec.decode(mark.effect, context.baseContext));
-				}
-				if (mark.cellId !== undefined) {
-					decodedMark.cellId = changeAtomIdCodec.decode(mark.cellId, context.baseContext);
-				}
-				// Type deduction wrongly narrows the type of `decodedMark` to `NoopMark & HasMarkFields`.
-				// We declare a new casted copy of `decodedMark` to recover the correct type.
-				let decodedMark2 = decodedMark as Mark;
-				if (decodedMark2.cellId !== undefined && decodedMark2.type === "AttachAndDetach") {
-					// In documents generated by clients on release <=2.1 (i.e., not running the code from the PR that added this comment),
-					// rename-like AttachAndDetach marks are not normalized to Rename marks thus requiring this normalization step.
-					// This ensures backward compatibility with documents generated by clients on release <=2.1.
-					decodedMark2 = normalizeCellRename(
-						decodedMark2.cellId,
-						decodedMark2.count,
-						decodedMark2.attach,
-						decodedMark2.detach,
-					);
-				}
-				if (mark.changes !== undefined) {
-					decodedMark2.changes = context.decodeNode(mark.changes);
-				}
-				marks.push(decodedMark2);
-			}
-			return marks;
+export function encodeSequenceChangeset(
+	changeset: Changeset,
+	context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+	encodeRevision: (revision: RevisionTag | undefined) => EncodedRevisionTag | undefined,
+	changeAtomIdCodec: IJsonCodec<
+		ChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		ChangeEncodingContext
+	>,
+	encodeMarkEffect: EncodeMarkEffect,
+): JsonCompatibleReadOnly & Encoded.Changeset<NodeChangeSchema> {
+	const jsonMarks: Encoded.Changeset<NodeChangeSchema> = [];
+	for (const mark of changeset) {
+		jsonMarks.push(
+			...encodeMark(mark, context, encodeRevision, changeAtomIdCodec, encodeMarkEffect),
+		);
+	}
+	return jsonMarks;
+}
+
+function encodeMark(
+	mark: Mark,
+	context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+	encodeRevision: (revision: RevisionTag | undefined) => EncodedRevisionTag | undefined,
+	changeAtomIdCodec: IJsonCodec<
+		ChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		ChangeEncodingContext
+	>,
+	encodeMarkEffect: EncodeMarkEffect,
+): Encoded.Mark<TAnySchema>[] {
+	const splitLength = getLengthToSplitMark(mark, context);
+	if (splitLength < mark.count) {
+		const [mark1, mark2] = splitMark(mark, splitLength);
+		return [
+			encodeSplitMark(mark1, context, encodeRevision, changeAtomIdCodec, encodeMarkEffect),
+			...encodeMark(mark2, context, encodeRevision, changeAtomIdCodec, encodeMarkEffect),
+		];
+	}
+
+	return [encodeSplitMark(mark, context, encodeRevision, changeAtomIdCodec, encodeMarkEffect)];
+}
+
+function encodeRename(
+	mark: CellMark<Rename>,
+	context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+	changeAtomIdCodec: IJsonCodec<
+		ChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		ChangeEncodingContext
+	>,
+	encodeRevision: (revision: RevisionTag | undefined) => EncodedRevisionTag | undefined,
+): Encoded.MarkEffect {
+	assert(mark.cellId !== undefined, "Rename should target empty cell");
+
+	const inputDetachId = context.getInputRootId(mark.idOverride, mark.count).value;
+	const isMoveInAndDetach =
+		!context.isAttachId(mark.idOverride, mark.count).value &&
+		(context.isDetachId(mark.idOverride, mark.count).value ||
+			(inputDetachId !== undefined && !areEqualChangeAtomIds(inputDetachId, mark.cellId)));
+
+	if (isMoveInAndDetach) {
+		// These cells are the final detach location of moved nodes.
+		const encodedRevision = encodeRevision(mark.idOverride.revision);
+
+		// XXX: Use finalEndpoint if there is an associated cellDetachId.
+		return {
+			attachAndDetach: {
+				attach: {
+					moveIn: {
+						revision: encodedRevision,
+						id: mark.idOverride.localId,
+					},
+				},
+				detach: {
+					remove: {
+						revision: encodedRevision,
+						id: mark.idOverride.localId,
+					},
+				},
+			},
+		};
+	}
+
+	const renamedRootId = context.rootRenames.getFirst(mark.cellId, mark.count).value;
+
+	const outputRootId = renamedRootId ?? mark.cellId;
+	const isMoveOutAndAttach = context.isAttachId(outputRootId, mark.count).value;
+	const isMoveOutAndDetach =
+		renamedRootId !== undefined && !areEqualChangeAtomIds(renamedRootId, mark.idOverride);
+
+	if (isMoveOutAndAttach || isMoveOutAndDetach) {
+		// Detached nodes which were last at this cell location have been moved.
+		// XXX: mark.idOverride represents detachCellId, so we should represent it using the moveOut's ID and use outputRootId as the finalDetachId.
+		// Is that always true?
+		return {
+			moveOut: {
+				revision: encodeRevision(outputRootId.revision),
+				id: outputRootId.localId,
+				idOverride: changeAtomIdCodec.encode(mark.idOverride, context.baseContext),
+			},
+		};
+	}
+
+	if (renamedRootId !== undefined) {
+		return {
+			remove: {
+				revision: encodeRevision(outputRootId.revision),
+				id: outputRootId.localId,
+			},
+		};
+	}
+
+	// In documents generated by clients on release >=2.2 (i.e., running the code from the PR that added this comment),
+	// renames are encoded as AttachAndDetach with a special id.
+	// This ensures forward-compatibility of clients on release <=2.1 with documents/ops generated by clients on release >=2.2.
+	return {
+		attachAndDetach: {
+			attach: { insert: { id: renameLocalId } },
+			detach: {
+				remove: {
+					id: renameLocalId,
+					idOverride: changeAtomIdCodec.encode(mark.idOverride, context.baseContext),
+				},
+			},
 		},
-		encodedSchema: ChangesetSchema(EncodedNodeChangeset),
 	};
 }
 
+function getLengthToSplitMark(mark: Mark, context: FieldChangeEncodingContext): number {
+	let count =
+		mark.cellId !== undefined
+			? rangeQueryChangeAtomIdMap(context.rootNodeChanges, mark.cellId, mark.count).length
+			: mark.count;
+
+	if (mark.cellId !== undefined) {
+		count = context.getInputRootId(mark.cellId, count).length;
+	}
+
+	switch (mark.type) {
+		case "Insert":
+			count = context.isDetachId(getAttachedRootId(mark), count).length;
+			break;
+		case "Remove":
+			count = context.isAttachId(getDetachedRootId(mark), count).length;
+			break;
+		case "Rename": {
+			count = context.getInputRootId(mark.idOverride, count).length;
+			count = context.isAttachId(mark.idOverride, count).length;
+			count = context.isDetachId(mark.idOverride, count).length;
+			const cellId = mark.cellId ?? fail("Rename should have cell ID");
+			const renameEntry = context.rootRenames.getFirst(cellId, count);
+			count = renameEntry.length;
+			count = context.isAttachId(renameEntry.value ?? cellId, count).length;
+			break;
+		}
+		default:
+			break;
+	}
+
+	return count;
+}
+
+function encodeSplitMark(
+	mark: Mark,
+	context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+	encodeRevision: (revision: RevisionTag | undefined) => EncodedRevisionTag | undefined,
+	changeAtomIdCodec: IJsonCodec<
+		ChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		ChangeEncodingContext
+	>,
+	encodeMarkEffect: EncodeMarkEffect,
+): Encoded.Mark<TAnySchema> {
+	const encodedMark: Encoded.Mark<TAnySchema> = {
+		count: mark.count,
+	};
+	if (!isNoopMark(mark)) {
+		encodedMark.effect = encodeMarkEffect(mark, context, encodeRevision, changeAtomIdCodec);
+	}
+	if (mark.cellId !== undefined) {
+		assert(mark.changes === undefined, "Empty cells should not have node changes");
+		encodedMark.cellId = changeAtomIdCodec.encode(mark.cellId, context.baseContext);
+		const nodeId = getFromChangeAtomIdMap(context.rootNodeChanges, mark.cellId);
+		if (nodeId !== undefined) {
+			encodedMark.changes = context.encodeNode(nodeId);
+		}
+	} else if (mark.changes !== undefined) {
+		encodedMark.changes = context.encodeNode(mark.changes);
+	}
+
+	return encodedMark;
+}
+
+type EncodeMarkEffect = (
+	mark: Mark,
+	context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+	encodeRevision: (revision: RevisionTag | undefined) => EncodedRevisionTag | undefined,
+	changeAtomIdCodec: IJsonCodec<
+		ChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		ChangeEncodingContext
+	>,
+) => Encoded.MarkEffect;
+
+function encodeMarkEffectV2(
+	mark: Mark,
+	context: FieldChangeEncodingContext,
+	encodeRevision: (revision: RevisionTag | undefined) => EncodedRevisionTag | undefined,
+	changeAtomIdCodec: IJsonCodec<
+		ChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		EncodedChangeAtomId,
+		ChangeEncodingContext
+	>,
+): Encoded.MarkEffect {
+	const type = mark.type;
+	switch (type) {
+		case "Insert": {
+			const attachId = getAttachedRootId(mark);
+			const isMove = context.isDetachId(attachId, 1).value;
+
+			// If the input context ID for these nodes is not the cell ID,
+			// then these nodes are being moved from the location at which they were last detached.
+			const inputId = context.getInputRootId(attachId, mark.count).value ?? attachId;
+			const isInitialAttachLocation =
+				mark.cellId === undefined || areEqualChangeAtomIds(mark.cellId, inputId);
+
+			return isMove || !isInitialAttachLocation
+				? {
+						moveIn: { revision: encodeRevision(mark.revision), id: mark.id },
+					}
+				: {
+						insert: {
+							revision: encodeRevision(mark.revision),
+							id: mark.id,
+						},
+					};
+		}
+		case "Remove": {
+			const encodedIdOverride =
+				mark.cellRename !== undefined
+					? changeAtomIdCodec.encode(mark.cellRename, context.baseContext)
+					: undefined;
+
+			const detachId = getDetachedRootId(mark);
+			const isMove = context.isAttachId(detachId, 1).value;
+
+			const outputCellId = mark.cellRename ?? mark.detachCellId ?? detachId;
+
+			// If the final detach location for the nodes were here,
+			// then the output cell ID would be the same as the detach ID.
+			// So if the cell ID is different from the detach ID, the nodes must have been moved.
+			const isFinalDetachLocation = areEqualChangeAtomIds(detachId, outputCellId);
+
+			const isMoveOrDetachedMove = isMove || !isFinalDetachLocation;
+			if (mark.detachCellId !== undefined) {
+				assert(
+					isMoveOrDetachedMove,
+					"Only detaches representing a move out should specify a detach cell ID",
+				);
+
+				// XXX: Set final endpoint on the move in.
+				return {
+					moveOut: {
+						revision: encodeRevision(mark.detachCellId.revision),
+						id: mark.detachCellId.localId,
+						idOverride: encodedIdOverride,
+						finalEndpoint: changeAtomIdCodec.encode(
+							{ revision: mark.revision, localId: mark.id },
+							context.baseContext,
+						),
+					},
+				};
+			}
+
+			const encodedRevision = encodeRevision(mark.revision);
+			return isMoveOrDetachedMove
+				? {
+						moveOut: {
+							revision: encodedRevision,
+							id: mark.id,
+							idOverride: encodedIdOverride,
+						},
+					}
+				: {
+						remove: {
+							revision: encodedRevision,
+							idOverride: encodedIdOverride,
+							id: mark.id,
+						},
+					};
+		}
+		case "Rename":
+			return encodeRename(mark, context, changeAtomIdCodec, encodeRevision);
+		case NoopMarkType:
+			fail(0xb2c /* Mark type: NoopMarkType should not be encoded. */);
+		default:
+			unreachableCase(type);
+	}
+}
+
+export function encodeRevisionWithContext(
+	revision: RevisionTag | undefined,
+	context: ChangeEncodingContext,
+	revisionTagCodec: IJsonCodec<
+		RevisionTag,
+		EncodedRevisionTag,
+		EncodedRevisionTag,
+		ChangeEncodingContext
+	>,
+): EncodedRevisionTag | undefined {
+	return revision === undefined || revision === context.revision
+		? undefined
+		: revisionTagCodec.encode(revision, context);
+}
+
 /**
  * Arbitrary ID that is used to indicate a Rename effect.
  */
 const renameLocalId: ChangesetLocalId = brand(-1);
+
+/**
+ * If the encoded mark effect represents a simple cell rename (with no effect on root nodes),
+ * returns the encoded form of the ID the cell is being renamed to,
+ * and otherwise returns undefined.
+ */
+export function tryGetEncodedCellRename(
+	encoded: Encoded.MarkEffect,
+): EncodedChangeAtomId | undefined {
+	const attachAndDetach = encoded.attachAndDetach;
+	if (attachAndDetach === undefined) {
+		return undefined;
+	}
+}
+
+function tryGetEncodedCellRenameFromAttachAndDetach(
+	encoded: Encoded.AttachAndDetach,
+): EncodedChangeAtomId | undefined {
+	// In documents generated by clients on release >=2.2 (i.e., running the code from the PR that added this comment),
+	// renames are encoded as AttachAndDetach with a special id.
+	// This ensures forward-compatibility of clients on release <=2.1 with documents/ops generated by clients on release >=2.2.
+	if (encoded.attach.insert?.id === renameLocalId) {
+		assert(
+			encoded.detach.remove?.idOverride !== undefined,
+			0x9f8 /* Rename must have idOverride */,
+		);
+		return encoded.detach.remove.idOverride;
+	}
+}