@enki-dev-expert/global-engineering-standards 0.0.0-stage → 0.1.1

package/skills/engineering-database-review/SKILL.md

@@ -0,0 +1,1364 @@
+---
+name: engineering-database-review
+description: Design, audit, secure, optimize and validate database systems using the Global Engineering Standards. Use for database architecture, SQL and NoSQL reviews, schema design, data integrity, multi-tenant isolation, indexing, query performance, migrations, backups, disaster recovery, scalability, cloud databases and autonomous database implementation.
+---
+
+# Engineering Database Review
+
+## 1. Purpose
+
+Provide a consistent and evidence-based workflow for database engineering.
+
+This skill supports:
+
+- Database architecture and selection.
+- SQL and NoSQL database reviews.
+- Schema design.
+- Data modeling.
+- Data integrity.
+- Transactions.
+- Access control.
+- Multi-tenant isolation.
+- Query optimization.
+- Index management.
+- Schema migrations.
+- Backup and recovery.
+- Database security.
+- Database scalability.
+- Managed database services.
+- Cloud database portability.
+- Cost optimization.
+- Database testing.
+- Autonomous database implementation.
+
+The objective is to build reliable, maintainable, secure and cost-efficient data systems that can evolve with real business requirements.
+
+Protect existing data.
+
+Never treat database access as permission to modify or delete production records.
+
+## 2. Global Engineering Standards
+
+The Global Engineering Standards repository is located at:
+
+~/engineering-standards/
+
+Primary reference:
+
+~/engineering-standards/docs/data.md
+
+Additional references when relevant:
+
+- docs/security.md
+- docs/privacy.md
+- docs/architecture.md
+- docs/scalability.md
+- docs/cost-engineering.md
+- docs/quality-and-testing.md
+- docs/observability.md
+- docs/ai-and-llm.md
+- docs/governance.md
+- docs/mobile-and-web.md
+- docs/platforms-and-applications.md
+
+Resolve these references relative to the engineering-standards repository.
+
+Apply standards according to the project's actual architecture.
+
+Do not load every document when only a subset is relevant.
+
+## 3. When to Use This Skill
+
+Use for tasks involving:
+
+- Database selection.
+- Database schema design.
+- Table or collection design.
+- SQL queries.
+- NoSQL queries.
+- ORM configuration.
+- Database performance.
+- Indexing.
+- Database migrations.
+- Transaction processing.
+- Backup strategies.
+- Recovery planning.
+- Multi-tenant systems.
+- Data retention.
+- Data deletion.
+- Database access security.
+- Data-intensive AI systems.
+- Scalability planning.
+- Database cost estimation.
+
+Also use when building database-dependent functionality in Autonomous Build Mode.
+
+Do not assume every application requires a remote database.
+
+## 4. Supported Database Technologies
+
+Work with relevant database technologies, including:
+
+- PostgreSQL.
+- MySQL.
+- MariaDB.
+- SQLite.
+- Microsoft SQL Server.
+- Oracle Database.
+- MongoDB.
+- Redis.
+- DynamoDB.
+- Azure Cosmos DB.
+- Google Cloud Firestore.
+- Firebase Realtime Database.
+- Supabase PostgreSQL.
+- Cloud SQL.
+- Amazon RDS and Aurora.
+- Managed document databases.
+- Search engines.
+- Vector databases.
+- Time-series databases.
+- Graph databases.
+- Embedded databases.
+
+This list is illustrative, not mandatory or exhaustive.
+
+Evaluate the actual database capabilities and requirements.
+
+Do not impose PostgreSQL, MongoDB, Supabase, Firebase or another provider on every project.
+
+## 5. Operating Modes
+
+Support:
+
+- Supervised Mode.
+- Autonomous Build Mode.
+
+Supervised Mode is the default.
+
+Autonomous Build Mode requires explicit user authorization.
+
+Both modes must preserve:
+
+- Data integrity.
+- Security.
+- Privacy.
+- Reliability.
+- Scalability.
+- Cost discipline.
+- Honest validation.
+
+Consult docs/governance.md.
+
+## 6. Supervised Mode
+
+For an existing database system:
+
+1. Identify the authorized scope.
+2. Inspect relevant schemas and source code.
+3. Review application data flows.
+4. Evaluate current safeguards.
+5. Identify confirmed problems.
+6. Distinguish hypotheses from evidence.
+7. Assess proposed changes.
+8. Evaluate migration risks.
+9. Recommend minimal effective improvements.
+10. Obtain required approval before significant changes.
+
+A default audit of a production database is read-only.
+
+Do not execute data-changing statements during read-only assessment.
+
+## 7. Autonomous Build Mode
+
+When explicitly authorized to build a complete application:
+
+1. Identify data requirements.
+2. Select an appropriate database architecture.
+3. Design entities and relationships.
+4. Define data invariants.
+5. Implement authorized local schemas.
+6. Write necessary database access logic.
+7. Create migration files.
+8. Implement authorization and isolation.
+9. Add data integrity tests.
+10. Validate queries and transactions.
+11. Review performance.
+12. Correct identified defects.
+13. Document deployment requirements.
+14. Continue independent authorized tasks.
+15. Consolidate human actions at handoff.
+
+Do not interrupt for every ordinary local schema or query change.
+
+Autonomous Build Mode does not authorize destructive production operations.
+
+## 8. Scope and Authorization
+
+Before database operations, establish:
+
+- Project repository.
+- Database engine.
+- Environment.
+- Connection scope.
+- Available permissions.
+- Data sensitivity.
+- Approved operations.
+- Protected resources.
+- Backup requirements.
+
+Treat production, staging and local development environments separately.
+
+Do not assume a database URL grants permission to modify its contents.
+
+## 9. Initial Database Assessment
+
+Inspect relevant authorized information:
+
+- Schema definitions.
+- Migration files.
+- ORM models.
+- Database clients.
+- Query builders.
+- Stored procedures.
+- Access policies.
+- Index definitions.
+- Test data.
+- Backup documentation.
+- Database configuration.
+- Application data access code.
+
+Prefer repository and configuration analysis before live database access.
+
+Do not expose credentials.
+
+## 10. Data Requirements
+
+Identify:
+
+- Core entities.
+- Relationships.
+- Business rules.
+- Read patterns.
+- Write patterns.
+- Expected data volume.
+- Retention requirements.
+- Query latency targets.
+- Consistency requirements.
+- Availability requirements.
+- Regulatory constraints.
+
+Do not invent critical business rules.
+
+Document assumptions requiring validation.
+
+## 11. Database Selection
+
+Evaluate possible solutions according to:
+
+- Data model.
+- Transaction requirements.
+- Query complexity.
+- Operational maturity.
+- Ecosystem compatibility.
+- Scaling needs.
+- Security controls.
+- Hosting options.
+- Portability.
+- Total cost.
+- Team capabilities.
+- Recovery requirements.
+
+Select the simplest suitable solution.
+
+Do not select a database solely because it is popular.
+
+## 12. Relational Data Modeling
+
+For relational systems:
+
+- Define meaningful entities.
+- Select appropriate primary keys.
+- Model relationships explicitly.
+- Use foreign keys where supported and appropriate.
+- Apply suitable constraints.
+- Avoid unnecessary duplication.
+- Consider normalization.
+- Introduce denormalization only with clear justification.
+
+Align schema design with business invariants.
+
+## 13. NoSQL Data Modeling
+
+For document, key-value and other NoSQL systems:
+
+- Identify access patterns.
+- Define document or item boundaries.
+- Evaluate consistency guarantees.
+- Avoid unbounded document growth.
+- Consider indexing limitations.
+- Define update atomicity.
+- Plan for schema evolution.
+- Evaluate query costs.
+
+Do not assume NoSQL automatically provides greater scalability.
+
+## 14. Data Integrity
+
+Protect critical invariants using appropriate mechanisms.
+
+Examples:
+
+- Primary key constraints.
+- Unique constraints.
+- Foreign keys.
+- Check constraints.
+- Transaction boundaries.
+- Version checks.
+- Atomic updates.
+- Server-side validation.
+
+Do not rely exclusively on client-side checks.
+
+Do not use AI-generated decisions as substitutes for deterministic data constraints.
+
+## 15. Transactions
+
+Evaluate:
+
+- Transaction atomicity.
+- Isolation level.
+- Consistency.
+- Durability.
+- Concurrent updates.
+- Deadlocks.
+- Rollback behavior.
+- Retry handling.
+
+Use transactions for operations requiring coordinated data changes.
+
+Avoid unnecessarily long transactions.
+
+Document transaction boundaries for important workflows.
+
+## 16. Concurrency Control
+
+Review relevant:
+
+- Optimistic locking.
+- Pessimistic locking.
+- Atomic operations.
+- Unique constraints.
+- Idempotency keys.
+- Version columns.
+- Compare-and-swap mechanisms.
+- Distributed coordination.
+
+Test race conditions where feasible.
+
+Do not assume operations are safe merely because they work sequentially.
+
+## 17. Idempotency
+
+For repeatable or retried operations:
+
+- Identify duplicate execution risks.
+- Define idempotency boundaries.
+- Use stable request identifiers where appropriate.
+- Store processing status safely.
+- Consider transaction interactions.
+- Define retry behavior.
+
+Important examples may include:
+
+- Payments.
+- Reservations.
+- Inventory changes.
+- Claim processing.
+- Webhook handling.
+- Background jobs.
+
+Ensure retries do not accidentally duplicate consequential actions.
+
+## 18. Data Types and Precision
+
+Choose data types according to actual requirements.
+
+Consider:
+
+- Numeric precision.
+- Currency handling.
+- Date and time representation.
+- Time zones.
+- Unicode.
+- Identifiers.
+- Boolean semantics.
+- Large text.
+- Binary storage.
+
+Avoid floating-point arithmetic for monetary values when exact decimal handling is required.
+
+Do not silently truncate data.
+
+## 19. Data Validation
+
+Validate important data at trusted boundaries.
+
+Consider:
+
+- Required values.
+- Valid ranges.
+- Format requirements.
+- Referential consistency.
+- Domain-specific constraints.
+- State transitions.
+- Ownership.
+
+Application validation and database constraints should complement each other.
+
+## 20. Authentication and Database Access
+
+Review how application identities access the database.
+
+Consider:
+
+- Database roles.
+- Application service accounts.
+- Credential scopes.
+- Connection pooling.
+- Administrative clients.
+- Read-only accounts.
+- Privileged operations.
+
+Apply least privilege.
+
+Do not expose privileged database credentials in browser or mobile applications.
+
+## 21. Authorization
+
+Enforce appropriate authorization for:
+
+- Reading records.
+- Creating records.
+- Updating records.
+- Deleting records.
+- Exporting data.
+- Administrative operations.
+- Background processing.
+- File metadata access.
+
+Never trust a client-supplied owner or tenant identifier without verification.
+
+Authentication is not sufficient without resource authorization.
+
+## 22. Multi-Tenant Isolation
+
+For multi-tenant systems, evaluate:
+
+- Tenant identity.
+- Tenant-aware queries.
+- Row-level security.
+- Database-per-tenant patterns.
+- Schema-per-tenant patterns.
+- Shared-table designs.
+- Administrative exceptions.
+- Cache isolation.
+- Background job isolation.
+- Search index isolation.
+
+Select isolation according to requirements and risk.
+
+Test cross-tenant access using controlled fixtures.
+
+Do not retrieve real data belonging to another tenant merely to test isolation.
+
+## 23. Row-Level Security
+
+Where supported and appropriate:
+
+- Define clear policies.
+- Validate authenticated identity.
+- Restrict access by tenant or owner.
+- Review bypass roles.
+- Review privileged service clients.
+- Test read and write policies.
+- Verify administrative boundaries.
+
+RLS is not a substitute for secure application architecture.
+
+Do not assume every database engine supports the same RLS mechanisms.
+
+## 24. SQL Injection Prevention
+
+Use parameterized statements or safe query-builder APIs.
+
+Avoid constructing executable SQL from untrusted text.
+
+Review:
+
+- Dynamic queries.
+- Search filters.
+- Sorting parameters.
+- Raw SQL.
+- Stored procedure inputs.
+- Identifier interpolation.
+
+Apply allowlists where SQL identifiers must be selected dynamically.
+
+Do not concatenate arbitrary user input into executable queries.
+
+## 25. NoSQL Query Security
+
+Review:
+
+- Operator injection.
+- Dynamic filters.
+- Document ownership.
+- Aggregation pipelines.
+- Untrusted query objects.
+- Access-control enforcement.
+
+Validate input structures.
+
+Do not allow clients to provide unrestricted database query expressions.
+
+## 26. Index Design
+
+Review indexes according to actual access patterns.
+
+Evaluate:
+
+- Filter columns.
+- Join keys.
+- Sort order.
+- Selectivity.
+- Compound indexes.
+- Unique indexes.
+- Partial indexes.
+- Covering indexes.
+- Write amplification.
+- Storage costs.
+
+Do not create indexes indiscriminately.
+
+Measure effects when possible.
+
+## 27. Query Performance
+
+Analyze relevant:
+
+- Query plans.
+- Full table scans.
+- N+1 queries.
+- Excessive joins.
+- Large payloads.
+- Missing pagination.
+- Slow aggregations.
+- Repeated queries.
+- Unnecessary data transfer.
+
+Use engine-appropriate tools.
+
+Avoid unbounded expensive diagnostic queries against production.
+
+## 28. Query Plan Analysis
+
+Use safe inspection tools where available.
+
+For relational databases, consider EXPLAIN and engine-specific plan inspection.
+
+Understand that some analysis modes may execute the query.
+
+Do not run potentially costly or data-changing diagnostic statements on production without suitable authorization.
+
+Document actual plan evidence.
+
+## 29. Pagination
+
+Choose pagination according to workload.
+
+Consider:
+
+- Offset pagination.
+- Cursor pagination.
+- Keyset pagination.
+- Stable ordering.
+- Authorization-aware filtering.
+- Maximum result size.
+
+Avoid returning unbounded datasets from public APIs.
+
+Do not expose sensitive records through pagination bugs.
+
+## 30. Caching
+
+Evaluate caching when justified by measured or credible workload.
+
+Consider:
+
+- Cache keys.
+- Tenant isolation.
+- Expiration.
+- Invalidation.
+- Data sensitivity.
+- Memory usage.
+- Consistency requirements.
+- Cache stampedes.
+
+Never cache private data under keys shared across unauthorized users.
+
+Do not introduce Redis or another cache automatically when it adds no meaningful value.
+
+## 31. Connection Management
+
+Review:
+
+- Connection pools.
+- Connection limits.
+- Serverless concurrency.
+- Timeouts.
+- Idle connections.
+- Authentication.
+- Database proxies.
+- Resource exhaustion.
+
+Use appropriate pooling strategies.
+
+Avoid excessive connection counts.
+
+## 32. Read and Write Workloads
+
+Identify:
+
+- Read-heavy workloads.
+- Write-heavy workloads.
+- Batch processing.
+- Reporting.
+- Analytics.
+- Transactional workloads.
+- Search workloads.
+
+Avoid optimizing one workload at the expense of essential correctness.
+
+## 33. Horizontal and Vertical Scaling
+
+Evaluate:
+
+- Instance sizing.
+- Connection limits.
+- Storage throughput.
+- Read replicas.
+- Partitioning.
+- Sharding.
+- Caching.
+- Queue-based processing.
+- Workload separation.
+
+Start with the simplest architecture that satisfies measured requirements.
+
+Do not introduce distributed complexity prematurely.
+
+## 34. High Availability
+
+Review relevant:
+
+- Redundancy.
+- Replication.
+- Failover.
+- Availability targets.
+- Network dependencies.
+- Regional risks.
+- Operational monitoring.
+
+Distinguish high availability from backup and disaster recovery.
+
+Replication does not guarantee recovery from accidental deletion.
+
+## 35. Partitioning and Sharding
+
+Consider partitioning and sharding only when requirements justify them.
+
+Evaluate:
+
+- Data access patterns.
+- Partition keys.
+- Query routing.
+- Rebalancing.
+- Tenant distribution.
+- Cross-partition transactions.
+- Operational complexity.
+- Cost.
+
+Do not claim sharding is required solely because an application may eventually have millions of users.
+
+## 36. Database Migrations
+
+Before schema changes:
+
+1. Inspect existing migration history.
+2. Understand current data structures.
+3. Identify dependent services.
+4. Evaluate compatibility.
+5. Assess data-loss risk.
+6. Prepare migration files.
+7. Define test strategy.
+8. Define recovery options.
+9. Obtain necessary approval.
+10. Verify execution results.
+
+Do not treat a migration file as evidence that the migration was successfully applied.
+
+## 37. Expand-and-Contract Migrations
+
+For compatibility-sensitive changes, consider:
+
+- Additive schema changes.
+- Dual-read or dual-write strategies where justified.
+- Backfills.
+- Application compatibility.
+- Phased rollout.
+- Old schema retirement.
+
+Avoid unnecessary downtime.
+
+Document cases where a migration cannot be rolled back safely.
+
+## 38. Data Backfills
+
+For large data changes:
+
+- Estimate affected volume.
+- Use bounded batches.
+- Consider lock duration.
+- Protect transaction integrity.
+- Monitor progress.
+- Provide restartability.
+- Plan recovery.
+- Define verification criteria.
+
+Do not perform uncontrolled production backfills.
+
+Require authorization for production data modification.
+
+## 39. Destructive Operations
+
+Treat the following as high risk when applied to important data:
+
+- DROP TABLE.
+- TRUNCATE.
+- Unbounded DELETE.
+- Unbounded UPDATE.
+- Destructive schema migrations.
+- Bulk record replacement.
+- Database reset.
+- Storage destruction.
+
+Do not perform these operations on production without explicit, action-specific authorization and appropriate safeguards.
+
+Autonomous Build Mode does not override this restriction.
+
+## 40. Development and Test Databases
+
+Use isolated development and test environments where possible.
+
+Prefer:
+
+- Local databases.
+- Ephemeral test containers.
+- Synthetic records.
+- Minimal fixtures.
+- Transactional test cleanup.
+- Dedicated testing credentials.
+
+Never point routine automated tests at production databases.
+
+Validate environment configuration before data-changing tests.
+
+## 41. Backup Strategy
+
+Evaluate backup requirements according to:
+
+- Data importance.
+- Recovery point objectives.
+- Recovery time objectives.
+- Business continuity.
+- Retention obligations.
+- Storage location.
+- Encryption.
+- Cost.
+
+Document what is actually backed up.
+
+Do not assume backups exist merely because the database is managed.
+
+## 42. Recovery Validation
+
+A backup is useful only if recovery is achievable.
+
+Assess:
+
+- Restoration procedures.
+- Recovery credentials.
+- Dependency requirements.
+- Backup integrity.
+- Restoration time.
+- Data completeness.
+- Application compatibility.
+
+Test restoration in an authorized, isolated environment where feasible.
+
+Do not claim tested recovery without an actual recovery exercise.
+
+## 43. Disaster Recovery
+
+Evaluate:
+
+- Regional failures.
+- Provider outages.
+- Credential loss.
+- Data corruption.
+- Accidental deletion.
+- Ransomware scenarios.
+- Configuration loss.
+- Operational dependencies.
+
+Choose recovery measures proportionate to business requirements.
+
+## 44. Data Retention
+
+Define retention according to legitimate business, operational and legal requirements.
+
+Consider:
+
+- User records.
+- Transaction records.
+- Logs.
+- Audit trails.
+- Backups.
+- Temporary data.
+- AI embeddings.
+- Uploaded files.
+
+Do not invent retention periods.
+
+Do not delete records subject to applicable preservation obligations.
+
+Consult docs/privacy.md.
+
+## 45. Data Deletion
+
+For deletion workflows:
+
+- Verify authority.
+- Identify dependent records.
+- Respect referential integrity.
+- Consider cascading effects.
+- Evaluate backups.
+- Consider external copies.
+- Preserve required audit evidence.
+- Apply valid retention exceptions.
+
+Do not claim complete deletion without appropriate verification.
+
+## 46. Encryption
+
+Evaluate:
+
+- Encryption in transit.
+- Encryption at rest.
+- Application-level encryption.
+- Key management.
+- Credential protection.
+- Backup encryption.
+- Rotation.
+
+Use established cryptographic implementations.
+
+Encryption does not replace authorization or tenant isolation.
+
+## 47. Audit Trails
+
+For sensitive operations, consider recording:
+
+- Actor identity.
+- Operation type.
+- Affected resource.
+- Timestamp.
+- Authorized context.
+- Outcome.
+
+Avoid unnecessary personal data in logs.
+
+Protect audit record integrity.
+
+## 48. Observability
+
+Review database monitoring:
+
+- Query latency.
+- Error rates.
+- Connection utilization.
+- CPU.
+- Memory.
+- Storage growth.
+- Replication lag.
+- Lock contention.
+- Backup status.
+- Recovery indicators.
+
+Avoid collecting excessive sensitive query payloads.
+
+Consult docs/observability.md.
+
+## 49. Database Cost Engineering
+
+Evaluate:
+
+- Compute.
+- Storage.
+- Read and write operations.
+- Backups.
+- Replication.
+- Data transfer.
+- Index storage.
+- Connection infrastructure.
+- Monitoring.
+- Provisioned versus usage-based billing.
+
+Separate measured spending from projections.
+
+Do not invent provider pricing.
+
+Consult docs/cost-engineering.md.
+
+## 50. Cloud Provider Independence
+
+Support appropriate solutions across:
+
+- AWS.
+- Azure.
+- Google Cloud.
+- Supabase.
+- Firebase.
+- Self-hosted environments.
+- Other managed providers.
+
+Evaluate vendor dependencies.
+
+Consider:
+
+- Data export.
+- Schema portability.
+- Migration complexity.
+- Proprietary features.
+- Operational maturity.
+- Pricing.
+
+Do not sacrifice important functionality merely to avoid every vendor-specific feature.
+
+## 51. Kubernetes and Databases
+
+If Kubernetes is used:
+
+- Evaluate whether the database should run inside or outside the cluster.
+- Review persistent volumes.
+- Review storage classes.
+- Consider recovery.
+- Assess operator maturity.
+- Protect secrets.
+- Review network restrictions.
+- Assess operational costs.
+
+Do not assume databases should run in Kubernetes.
+
+Prefer managed services when they provide justified operational benefits.
+
+## 52. Serverless Database Considerations
+
+Evaluate:
+
+- Connection pooling.
+- Cold starts.
+- Concurrent requests.
+- Connection limits.
+- Transaction behavior.
+- Usage-based costs.
+- Regional latency.
+- Provider quotas.
+
+Do not assume serverless automatically means cheaper or more scalable.
+
+## 53. Mobile and Offline Data
+
+For mobile or offline-first applications:
+
+- Define local storage scope.
+- Encrypt sensitive local data where appropriate.
+- Plan synchronization.
+- Resolve conflicts.
+- Handle retries.
+- Support offline queues.
+- Protect credentials.
+- Consider device loss.
+
+Do not assume client-side cached data is authoritative.
+
+Consult docs/mobile-and-web.md.
+
+## 54. Desktop and Embedded Databases
+
+For desktop and local applications:
+
+- Review database file permissions.
+- Protect local credentials.
+- Handle upgrades.
+- Plan migrations.
+- Consider concurrent access.
+- Verify corruption recovery.
+- Support secure backups.
+- Respect operating-system constraints.
+
+SQLite or another embedded database may be appropriate when it meets requirements.
+
+Consult docs/platforms-and-applications.md.
+
+## 55. Game Data Systems
+
+For game applications, consider:
+
+- Player profiles.
+- Save data.
+- Multiplayer state.
+- Match history.
+- Inventory.
+- Virtual economy.
+- Leaderboards.
+- Anti-cheat integrity.
+- Concurrent updates.
+
+Use server-authoritative controls for security-sensitive multiplayer and economic operations.
+
+Do not trust client-submitted balances or ownership states.
+
+## 56. AI and Vector Databases
+
+For RAG and AI systems, evaluate:
+
+- Document ownership.
+- Vector store access.
+- Embedding metadata.
+- Tenant isolation.
+- Retrieval authorization.
+- Index lifecycle.
+- Data deletion propagation.
+- Model dependency.
+- Retrieval latency.
+- Inference and storage costs.
+
+A semantic match does not establish access authorization.
+
+Protect private document embeddings and associated metadata.
+
+Consult docs/ai-and-llm.md.
+
+## 57. Data Import and Export
+
+For import and export workflows:
+
+- Validate file structure.
+- Verify authorization.
+- Restrict scope.
+- Consider batch limits.
+- Prevent duplicate processing.
+- Handle partial failures.
+- Protect sensitive fields.
+- Maintain auditability.
+
+Do not export real production data without appropriate authorization.
+
+## 58. Database Testing Strategy
+
+Select relevant tests:
+
+- Schema validation.
+- Constraint tests.
+- Transaction tests.
+- Authorization tests.
+- Tenant isolation tests.
+- Migration tests.
+- Query correctness tests.
+- Concurrency tests.
+- Retention tests.
+- Recovery tests.
+- Performance tests.
+
+Use appropriate isolated environments.
+
+Do not claim tests passed without execution.
+
+## 59. Migration Testing
+
+When relevant:
+
+1. Apply migrations to a safe test database.
+2. Confirm expected schema.
+3. Test application compatibility.
+4. Test important queries.
+5. Evaluate data preservation.
+6. Test rollback where genuinely possible.
+7. Record failures.
+8. Correct migration defects.
+
+Do not automatically execute tested migrations in production.
+
+## 60. Performance Testing
+
+Use representative workload assumptions.
+
+Consider:
+
+- Query latency.
+- Database throughput.
+- Concurrent operations.
+- Index efficiency.
+- Storage behavior.
+- Connection exhaustion.
+- Lock contention.
+
+Avoid intrusive performance testing of live systems without permission.
+
+Do not claim support for a specific user count without relevant evidence.
+
+## 61. Database Review Findings
+
+For material findings, record:
+
+- Finding ID.
+- Category.
+- Affected component.
+- Severity.
+- Confidence.
+- Verification status.
+- Evidence.
+- Business impact.
+- Data integrity risk.
+- Security impact.
+- Recommended remediation.
+- Migration impact.
+- Testing requirements.
+- Required approvals.
+
+Distinguish confirmed defects from hypotheses.
+
+## 62. Severity Assessment
+
+Possible classifications:
+
+- Critical.
+- High.
+- Medium.
+- Low.
+- Informational.
+
+Consider:
+
+- Data loss potential.
+- Security exposure.
+- Availability impact.
+- Business impact.
+- Affected users.
+- Likelihood.
+- Existing safeguards.
+
+Do not inflate severity without evidence.
+
+## 63. Database Remediation
+
+For significant corrections:
+
+1. Identify root cause.
+2. Select the minimal effective change.
+3. Assess data impact.
+4. Review security.
+5. Evaluate compatibility.
+6. Prepare migration if needed.
+7. Define tests.
+8. Define recovery.
+9. Obtain required authorization.
+10. Implement within scope.
+11. Validate results.
+12. Report remaining risks.
+
+Avoid unnecessary complete database rewrites.
+
+## 64. Autonomous Database Corrections
+
+In Autonomous Build Mode, authorized local changes may include:
+
+- Creating schema definitions.
+- Adding constraints.
+- Writing query logic.
+- Adding indexes.
+- Preparing migrations.
+- Creating local test databases.
+- Adding test fixtures.
+- Correcting ORM models.
+- Improving authorization checks.
+- Testing data integrity.
+
+Do not require repeated approval for each ordinary authorized change.
+
+Do not infer permission to alter production databases.
+
+## 65. Protected Database Operations
+
+Require specific authorization before:
+
+- Production schema migration.
+- Production data updates.
+- Production data deletion.
+- Bulk data exports.
+- Privileged database access changes.
+- Live backup restoration.
+- Disabling production constraints.
+- Removing audit controls.
+- Changing database billing plans.
+- Moving live data between providers.
+
+Document risks and recovery plans.
+
+Respect platform permission mechanisms.
+
+## 66. Database Exceptions
+
+When a standard cannot reasonably be met:
+
+- Identify the requirement.
+- Explain the limitation.
+- Evaluate alternatives.
+- Assess risks.
+- Define compensating controls.
+- Request appropriate approval.
+- Document review conditions.
+
+Use:
+
+~/engineering-standards/templates/EXCEPTIONS.md
+
+An AI agent cannot approve its own exception.
+
+## 67. Architecture Decisions
+
+For significant database architecture decisions, document:
+
+- Business context.
+- Data requirements.
+- Alternatives.
+- Consistency.
+- Security.
+- Scalability.
+- Operational complexity.
+- Total cost.
+- Migration implications.
+- Risks.
+
+Use:
+
+~/engineering-standards/templates/ADR.md
+
+An ADR does not grant permission for protected operations.
+
+## 68. Database Audit Reporting
+
+For significant reviews, use:
+
+~/engineering-standards/templates/AUDIT_REPORT.md
+
+Include:
+
+- Scope.
+- Technology.
+- Confirmed findings.
+- Unverified concerns.
+- Evidence.
+- Risks.
+- Recommendations.
+- Expected migration impact.
+- Tests actually executed.
+- Remaining limitations.
+- Required human approvals.
+
+Do not present unexecuted changes as completed.
+
+## 69. Database Definition of Done
+
+For significant database functionality:
+
+- Requirements identified.
+- Data model reviewed.
+- Business invariants protected.
+- Authentication and authorization considered.
+- Tenant isolation implemented where needed.
+- Transactions correct.
+- Queries validated.
+- Relevant indexes evaluated.
+- Migration compatibility considered.
+- Data retention assessed.
+- Recovery requirements understood.
+- Performance requirements evaluated.
+- Costs considered.
+- Relevant tests executed.
+- Actual results recorded.
+- Protected actions authorized.
+- Remaining risks documented.
+
+Do not claim production readiness based solely on successful local schema creation.
+
+## 70. Final Reporting
+
+Report:
+
+1. Database technology and scope.
+2. Architecture decisions.
+3. Schema or query changes.
+4. Data integrity controls.
+5. Security and isolation measures.
+6. Performance considerations.
+7. Scalability strategy.
+8. Migration status.
+9. Tests performed.
+10. Tests not performed.
+11. Backup and recovery readiness.
+12. Cost implications.
+13. Outstanding risks.
+14. Required human actions.
+
+Clearly distinguish local implementation from production deployment.
+
+## 71. Final Database Engineering Principles
+
+Protect data integrity.
+Preserve important business invariants.
+Enforce database access authorization.
+Maintain strict tenant isolation.
+Use appropriate transactions.
+Validate concurrent operations.
+Prevent injection vulnerabilities.
+Design indexes according to access patterns.
+Optimize queries using evidence.
+Avoid unbounded database operations.
+Preserve existing production data.
+Treat migrations as potentially risky.
+Never run destructive production changes without authorization.
+Maintain appropriate backup and recovery plans.
+Test restoration where feasible.
+Design for credible scalability.
+Avoid unnecessary distributed complexity.
+Choose database technology according to requirements.
+Evaluate cloud and managed services without vendor bias.
+Control database infrastructure costs.
+Apply privacy and retention requirements.
+Protect AI retrieval data and embeddings.
+Support authorized autonomous development.
+Never fabricate verification results.
+Document remaining risks honestly.