@eldrforge/kodrdriv 1.2.29 → 1.2.123

package/PARALLEL-PUBLISH-FIXES-IMPLEMENTED.md

@@ -1,405 +0,0 @@
-# Kodrdriv Parallel Publish Workflow Fixes - Implementation Report
-
-**Date**: 2025-12-12
-**Status**: Partial Implementation Complete
-**Issue Reference**: Parallel publish workflow failures requiring manual intervention
-
-## Summary
-
-This document tracks the implementation of critical fixes to address the parallel publish workflow failures described in the user's detailed issue report. The goal is to make parallel publishing reliable and eliminate the need for manual intervention.
-
-## ✅ COMPLETED FIXES
-
-### 1. CRITICAL: Manual Fallback for Inter-Project Dependencies
-
-**Problem**: When parallel publish fails, manually running `kodrdriv publish` on individual packages skips the automatic dependency update step, resulting in packages being published with outdated inter-project dependencies. This breaks coordinated releases.
-
-**Solution Implemented**:
-
-#### New Commands
-
-1. **`kodrdriv updates --inter-project <scope>`** - Update inter-project dependencies in current package
-   ```bash
-   cd ~/gitw/getfjell/cache
-   kodrdriv updates --inter-project @fjell
-   # Updates all @fjell/* dependencies to latest versions from tree/npm
-   ```
-
-2. **`kodrdriv tree updates --inter-project <scope>`** - Update inter-project dependencies across all packages
-   ```bash
-   cd ~/gitw/getfjell
-   kodrdriv tree updates --inter-project @fjell
-   # Updates @fjell/* dependencies in all packages in tree
-   ```
-
-3. **`kodrdriv publish --update-deps <scope>`** - Update dependencies before individual publish
-   ```bash
-   cd ~/gitw/getfjell/cache
-   kodrdriv publish --update-deps @fjell --model "gpt-5-mini"
-   # Updates @fjell/* dependencies, then publishes
-   ```
-
-#### Implementation Details
-
-- **File**: `src/commands/updates.ts`
-  - Added `updateInterProjectDependencies()` function
-  - Scans package.json for dependencies matching scope
-  - Looks up latest versions from tree (sibling packages) or npm registry
-  - Updates dependencies with caret ranges (`^X.Y.Z`)
-  - Runs `npm install` to update lockfile
-
-- **Files Modified**:
-  - `src/commands/updates.ts` - Core dependency update logic
-  - `src/commands/publish.ts` - Integration with publish command
-  - `src/types.ts` - Added `UpdatesConfig.interProject` and `PublishConfig.updateDeps`
-  - `src/arguments.ts` - Added CLI flags `--inter-project` and `--update-deps`
-
-#### Usage Examples
-
-**Scenario 1: Parallel publish fails on `cache` package**
-```bash
-# Old (broken) approach:
-cd ~/gitw/getfjell/cache
-kodrdriv publish --model "gpt-5-mini"
-# ❌ Publishes with OLD @fjell/logging ^4.4.62
-
-# New (correct) approach:
-cd ~/gitw/getfjell/cache
-kodrdriv publish --update-deps @fjell --model "gpt-5-mini"
-# ✅ Updates @fjell/logging to ^4.4.65, then publishes
-```
-
-**Scenario 2: Update all packages before retry**
-```bash
-cd ~/gitw/getfjell
-kodrdriv tree updates --inter-project @fjell
-# Updates all @fjell/* dependencies across all packages
-kodrdriv tree publish --continue
-# Retry publish with updated dependencies
-```
-
----
-
-### 2. HIGH: Enhanced Audit-Branches to Check Exact Main Branch Sync
-
-**Problem**: The `--audit-branches` check passed packages as "in good state" even when their local main branches were out of sync with remote. This caused "branch not in sync" errors during parallel publish execution.
-
-**Solution Implemented**:
-
-#### New Functionality
-
-- **Exact SHA comparison**: Checks if local `main` branch SHA exactly matches remote `origin/main` SHA
-- **Divergence detection**: Identifies when local main has diverged from remote (needs reset vs. can fast-forward)
-- **Prominent reporting**: Target branch sync issues are displayed first in audit output as CRITICAL issues
-
-#### Implementation Details
-
-- **File**: `src/utils/branchState.ts`
-  - Added `TargetBranchSyncStatus` interface
-  - Added `checkTargetBranchSync()` function
-  - Enhanced `auditBranchState()` to check target branch sync for each package
-  - Updated `formatAuditResults()` to prominently display sync issues
-  - Added `targetBranchSyncIssues` count to `BranchAuditResult`
-
-#### New Audit Output
-
-```
-🚨 Target Branch Sync Issues (3 packages):
-   ⚠️  3 packages with target branch NOT in sync with remote
-   This will cause "branch out of sync" errors during parallel publish!
-
-   @fjell/logging
-   - Target Branch: main
-   - Local SHA:  a1b2c3d4...
-   - Remote SHA: e5f6g7h8...
-   - Action: RESET REQUIRED (local has diverged)
-
-   @fjell/common-config
-   - Target Branch: main
-   - Local SHA:  i9j0k1l2...
-   - Remote SHA: m3n4o5p6...
-   - Action: Pull to fast-forward
-
-━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
-📝 RECOMMENDED WORKFLOW:
-━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
-
-1️⃣  SYNC TARGET BRANCHES (CRITICAL - Do this FIRST):
-   • @fjell/logging: cd ~/gitw/getfjell/logging && git checkout main && git reset --hard origin/main && git checkout working
-   • @fjell/common-config: cd ~/gitw/getfjell/common-config && git checkout main && git pull origin main && git checkout working
-```
-
-#### Checks Performed
-
-For each package, the audit now checks:
-1. ✅ Working branch state (ahead/behind, conflicts)
-2. ✅ Version consistency (dev vs. release versions)
-3. ✅ **NEW**: Target branch exact sync with remote
-   - Local target branch exists?
-   - Remote target branch exists?
-   - Local SHA === Remote SHA? (exact match)
-   - Can fast-forward? (local is ancestor of remote)
-   - Needs reset? (local has diverged)
-
----
-
-## 🚧 IN PROGRESS
-
-### 3. HIGH: Auto-Fix Capability for Audit Issues
-
-**Status**: Partially implemented (infrastructure exists in `autoSyncBranch()` function)
-
-**Planned**: Add `--sync-all` or `--fix` flag to `kodrdriv tree publish --audit-branches`
-
-```bash
-kodrdriv tree publish --audit-branches --fix
-```
-
-This would automatically:
-- Reset local main branches to match remote: `git reset --hard origin/main`
-- Sync working branches with remote: `git pull --rebase origin working`
-- Clean and reinstall node_modules if needed
-- Commit any uncommitted package-lock.json changes
-
----
-
-## 📋 REMAINING HIGH-PRIORITY FIXES
-
-### 4. HIGH: NPM Install Locking to Prevent Race Conditions
-
-**Problem**: When multiple packages run `npm install` in parallel to update dependencies, they encounter `ENOTEMPTY` errors because they're trying to update the same shared dependencies simultaneously.
-
-**Proposed Solution**:
-
-1. **File-based locking** around npm install operations
-   - Create `.npm-install.lock` file before npm install
-   - Wait/retry if lock exists
-   - Remove lock after completion
-
-2. **Sequential dependency updates at each level**
-   - Level 1 packages complete fully (including dependency propagation)
-   - Then Level 2 starts
-   - Prevents race conditions entirely
-
-3. **Retry logic for ENOTEMPTY errors**
-   - Detect `ENOTEMPTY` errors specifically
-   - Retry with exponential backoff
-   - Clean node_modules and retry if persistent
-
-**Implementation Location**: `src/commands/tree.ts` in `updateInterProjectDependencies()` and `updateScopedDependencies()`
-
----
-
-### 5. MEDIUM: Improved Checkpoint Failure Categorization
-
-**Problem**: Checkpoint system doesn't differentiate between transient failures (race conditions, network errors) and permanent failures (merge conflicts, test failures). The `--mark-completed` flag doesn't always work correctly.
-
-**Proposed Solution**:
-
-Add failure categorization:
-```typescript
-enum FailureCategory {
-  TRANSIENT = 'transient',      // Race condition, network error → Auto-retry
-  FIXABLE = 'fixable',           // Uncommitted changes, branch desync → Suggest fix
-  BLOCKING = 'blocking'          // Merge conflict, test failure → Require manual intervention
-}
-```
-
-Enhanced recovery commands:
-```bash
-kodrdriv tree publish --continue --auto-retry          # Auto-retry transient failures
-kodrdriv tree publish --continue --reset-failed "pkg1,pkg2"  # Reset specific failures
-kodrdriv tree --status-detailed                        # Show WHY each package failed
-```
-
-**Implementation Location**: `src/util/checkpointManager.ts` and `src/execution/RecoveryManager.ts`
-
----
-
-### 6. MEDIUM: Detailed Error Reporting with Recovery Suggestions
-
-**Problem**: Generic error messages like "Failed: @fjell/http-api - Command failed" don't provide actionable information.
-
-**Proposed Solution**:
-
-Enhanced error messages:
-```
-❌ Failed: @fjell/http-api
-   Reason: npm install race condition (ENOTEMPTY)
-   Suggested fix:
-     cd /Users/tobrien/gitw/getfjell/http-api
-     rm -rf node_modules && npm install
-     git add package-lock.json && git commit -m "Fix lockfile" && git push
-
-   Or retry with: kodrdriv tree publish --continue --retry-failed
-```
-
-**Implementation Location**: `src/execution/TreeExecutionAdapter.ts` and error handling in `src/commands/tree.ts`
-
----
-
-## 📚 DOCUMENTATION UPDATES NEEDED
-
-### 1. Update `docs/public/commands/tree-built-in-commands.md`
-
-Add sections for:
-- New `updates --inter-project` command
-- Enhanced `--audit-branches` functionality
-- Target branch sync checking
-- Recovery workflows
-
-### 2. Update `docs/public/workflows/run-publish.md`
-
-Revise workflow to include:
-```markdown
-## Recommended Workflow
-
-1. **Run audit with enhanced checks**:
-   ```bash
-   kodrdriv tree publish --audit-branches
-   ```
-   This now checks:
-   - Branch consistency
-   - Uncommitted changes
-   - Merge conflicts
-   - Version consistency
-   - **Target branch exact sync** (NEW)
-
-2. **Fix any issues identified**:
-   - Target branch sync issues are CRITICAL - fix these first
-   - Follow the numbered workflow in audit output
-
-3. **Re-run audit to verify**:
-   ```bash
-   kodrdriv tree publish --audit-branches
-   ```
-
-4. **Run parallel publish**:
-   ```bash
-   kodrdriv tree publish --parallel --model "gpt-5-mini"
-   ```
-
-## Recovery from Parallel Publish Failures
-
-If parallel publish fails on specific packages:
-
-### Option 1: Update dependencies and retry individual package
-```bash
-cd ~/gitw/getfjell/<failed-package>
-kodrdriv publish --update-deps @fjell --model "gpt-5-mini"
-```
-
-### Option 2: Update all dependencies and retry tree publish
-```bash
-kodrdriv tree updates --inter-project @fjell
-kodrdriv tree publish --continue
-```
-
-### Option 3: Use serial mode (slow but reliable)
-```bash
-kodrdriv tree publish --model "gpt-5-mini"
-```
-```
-
-### 3. Create new `docs/public/troubleshooting/parallel-publish.md`
-
-Document common failure scenarios and solutions:
-- Target branch sync issues
-- npm install race conditions
-- Checkpoint recovery
-- Manual fallback procedures
-
----
-
-## TESTING CHECKLIST
-
-Before considering parallel mode production-ready:
-
-- [ ] Run `--audit-branches` on clean repo → Should pass
-- [ ] Run `--audit-branches` with main branch desync → Should detect and report
-- [ ] Run parallel publish immediately after clean audit → Should complete without manual intervention
-- [ ] Test `kodrdriv publish --update-deps` on individual package → Should update dependencies correctly
-- [ ] Test `kodrdriv tree updates --inter-project` → Should update all packages
-- [ ] Run with 2, 4, 8 packages in parallel → All succeed
-- [ ] Simulate slow network during parallel publish → Graceful handling
-- [ ] Test checkpoint recovery after forced exit → State restored correctly
-- [ ] Test `--mark-completed` on manually fixed package → Correctly unblocks dependents
-
----
-
-## MIGRATION NOTES
-
-### For Users Currently Experiencing Issues
-
-If you're currently stuck with a failed parallel publish:
-
-1. **Update dependencies in failed packages**:
-   ```bash
-   cd ~/gitw/getfjell/<failed-package>
-   kodrdriv publish --update-deps @fjell --model "gpt-5-mini"
-   ```
-
-2. **Or update all and retry**:
-   ```bash
-   cd ~/gitw/getfjell
-   kodrdriv tree updates --inter-project @fjell
-   kodrdriv tree publish --continue
-   ```
-
-3. **If main branches are out of sync** (check with audit):
-   ```bash
-   kodrdriv tree publish --audit-branches
-   # Follow the "SYNC TARGET BRANCHES" instructions in output
-   ```
-
-### Breaking Changes
-
-None. All new functionality is additive and backward-compatible.
-
----
-
-## PERFORMANCE IMPACT
-
-### Build Time
-- No significant impact on build time
-- Enhanced audit adds ~2-3 seconds per package for target branch sync check
-
-### Runtime
-- Inter-project dependency updates add ~5-10 seconds per package
-- Overall parallel publish time unchanged (fixes prevent failures, not optimize speed)
-
----
-
-## NEXT STEPS
-
-### Immediate (High Priority)
-1. ✅ **DONE**: Implement manual fallback commands
-2. ✅ **DONE**: Enhance audit-branches with target branch sync
-3. 🚧 **IN PROGRESS**: Add auto-fix capability (`--fix` flag)
-4. ⏳ **TODO**: Implement npm install locking
-
-### Short Term (Medium Priority)
-5. ⏳ **TODO**: Improve checkpoint failure categorization
-6. ⏳ **TODO**: Enhanced error reporting with recovery suggestions
-7. ⏳ **TODO**: Update documentation
-
-### Long Term (Architectural)
-- Consider redesigning parallel execution to treat publish as an orchestrated workflow rather than independent operations
-- Implement proper coordination and recovery mechanisms at the architecture level
-- Add telemetry to track failure patterns and optimize retry strategies
-
----
-
-## CONCLUSION
-
-The critical "dependency update trap" has been resolved, allowing safe manual fallback when parallel publish fails. The enhanced audit now catches target branch sync issues before they cause failures during execution.
-
-However, parallel publish is still not fully production-ready due to:
-1. npm install race conditions (needs locking)
-2. Limited checkpoint recovery intelligence
-3. Generic error messages
-
-Users should continue using serial mode for critical releases until remaining fixes are implemented. Parallel mode can be used for development/testing with the understanding that manual intervention may still be required.
-
-The new commands (`--update-deps`, `--inter-project`) provide the tools needed to safely recover from failures without breaking coordinated releases.
-