@dxos/plugin-assistant 0.8.4-main.bc674ce → 0.8.4-main.bcb3aa67d6

package/src/operations/set-current-chat.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
+//
+// Copyright 2025 DXOS.org
+//
+
+import * as Effect from 'effect/Effect';
+
+import { Capabilities } from '@dxos/app-framework';
+import { Obj } from '@dxos/echo';
+import { Operation } from '@dxos/operation';
+
+import { AssistantCapabilities } from '../types';
+import { SetCurrentChat } from './definitions';
+
+const handler: Operation.WithHandler<typeof SetCurrentChat> = SetCurrentChat.pipe(
+  Operation.withHandler(
+    Effect.fnUntraced(function* ({ companionTo, chat }) {
+      const companionToId = Obj.getDXN(companionTo).toString();
+      const chatId = chat && Obj.getDXN(chat).toString();
+      yield* Capabilities.updateAtomValue(AssistantCapabilities.State, (current) => ({
+        ...current,
+        currentChat: { ...current.currentChat, [companionToId]: chatId },
+      }));
+
+      // When clearing the selection (new thread), evict the cached transient chat so a fresh one is created.
+      if (!chat) {
+        yield* Capabilities.updateAtomValue(AssistantCapabilities.CompanionChatCache, (current) => {
+          const { [companionToId]: _, ...rest } = current;
+          return rest;
+        });
+      }
+    }),
+  ),
+);
+
+export default handler;

package/src/operations/update-chat-name.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,55 @@
+//
+// Copyright 2025 DXOS.org
+//
+
+import * as Effect from 'effect/Effect';
+
+import { Capabilities, Capability } from '@dxos/app-framework';
+import { AiConversation } from '@dxos/assistant';
+import { Feed, Obj } from '@dxos/echo';
+import { Trace, TracingService } from '@dxos/functions';
+import { invariant } from '@dxos/invariant';
+import { Operation } from '@dxos/operation';
+import { AutomationCapabilities } from '@dxos/plugin-automation/types';
+import { ClientCapabilities } from '@dxos/plugin-client/types';
+import { type Message } from '@dxos/types';
+
+import { type AiChatServices, updateName } from '../processor';
+import { UpdateChatName } from './definitions';
+
+const handler: Operation.WithHandler<typeof UpdateChatName> = UpdateChatName.pipe(
+  Operation.withHandler(
+    Effect.fnUntraced(function* ({ chat }) {
+      const registry = yield* Capability.get(Capabilities.AtomRegistry);
+      const db = Obj.getDatabase(chat);
+      const feedTarget = chat.feed.target;
+      if (!db || !feedTarget) {
+        return;
+      }
+      const queueDxn = Feed.getQueueDxn(feedTarget);
+      invariant(queueDxn, 'Feed queue DXN not found.');
+      const client = yield* Capability.get(ClientCapabilities.Client);
+      const space = client.spaces.get(db.spaceId);
+      invariant(space, 'Space not found.');
+      const queue = space.queues.get<Message.Message>(queueDxn);
+
+      const runtimeResolver = yield* Capability.get(AutomationCapabilities.ComputeRuntime);
+      const runtime = yield* Effect.promise(() =>
+        runtimeResolver
+          .getRuntime(db.spaceId)
+          .runPromise(
+            Effect.runtime<AiChatServices>().pipe(
+              Effect.provide(TracingService.layerNoop),
+              Effect.provide(Trace.writerLayerNoop),
+            ),
+          ),
+      );
+
+      yield* Effect.promise(() =>
+        new AiConversation({ queue, registry }).use(async (conversation) => updateName(runtime, conversation, chat)),
+      );
+    }),
+  ),
+);
+
+export default handler;

package/src/processor/processor.test.ts

@@ -2,71 +2,38 @@
 // Copyright 2025 DXOS.org
 //
 
-import * as Tool from '@effect/ai/Tool';
-import * as Toolkit from '@effect/ai/Toolkit';
 import { describe, it } from '@effect/vitest';
 import * as Effect from 'effect/Effect';
-import * as Layer from 'effect/Layer';
-import * as Schema from 'effect/Schema';
+import * as ManagedRuntime from 'effect/ManagedRuntime';
 
-import { AiService } from '@dxos/ai';
-import { AiServiceTestingPreset } from '@dxos/ai/testing';
-import { AiConversation, makeToolExecutionServiceFromFunctions, makeToolResolverFromFunctions } from '@dxos/assistant';
+import { AiConversation } from '@dxos/assistant';
+import { AssistantTestLayer } from '@dxos/assistant/testing';
+import { Feed } from '@dxos/echo';
 import { acquireReleaseResource } from '@dxos/effect';
 import { TestHelpers } from '@dxos/effect/testing';
-import { CredentialsService, QueueService, TracingService } from '@dxos/functions';
-import { FunctionInvocationServiceLayerTestMocked, TestDatabaseLayer } from '@dxos/functions-runtime/testing';
+import { QueueService } from '@dxos/functions';
 import { type Message } from '@dxos/types';
 
-import { AiChatProcessor, type AiChatServices } from './processor';
+import { AiChatProcessor } from './processor';
 
-const TestToolkit = Toolkit.make(
-  Tool.make('random', {
-    description: 'Random number generator',
-    parameters: {},
-    success: Schema.Number,
-  }),
-);
-
-// TODO(burdon): Create minimal toolkit.
-const toolkit = Toolkit.merge(TestToolkit) as Toolkit.Toolkit<any>;
-
-// TODO(burdon): Explain structure.
-const TestServicesLayer = Layer.mergeAll(
-  TracingService.layerNoop,
-  AiServiceTestingPreset('direct'),
-  TestDatabaseLayer({
-    // indexing: { vector: true },
-    // types: [],
-  }),
-  // CredentialsService.configuredLayer([{ service: 'exa.ai', apiKey: EXA_API_KEY }]),
-  FunctionInvocationServiceLayerTestMocked({ functions: [] }).pipe(Layer.provideMerge(TracingService.layerNoop)),
-);
-
-const TestLayer: Layer.Layer<AiChatServices, never, never> = Layer.mergeAll(
-  AiService.model('@anthropic/claude-opus-4-0'),
-  makeToolResolverFromFunctions([], toolkit),
-  makeToolExecutionServiceFromFunctions(toolkit, toolkit.toLayer({}) as any),
-  CredentialsService.layerFromDatabase(),
-).pipe(Layer.provideMerge(TestServicesLayer), Layer.orDie);
-
-// TODO(burdon): Create actual test with mock LLM.
 describe('Chat processor', () => {
   it.scoped(
     'basic',
     Effect.fn(
       function* ({ expect }) {
-        const services = yield* Effect.runtime<AiChatServices>();
         const queue = yield* QueueService.createQueue<Message.Message>();
         const conversation = yield* acquireReleaseResource(() => new AiConversation({ queue }));
-        const processor = new AiChatProcessor(conversation, async () => services);
-        const result = yield* Effect.promise(() => processor.request({ message: 'Hello' }));
-        void processor.cancel();
-        expect(processor.active).to.be.false;
-        expect(result).to.exist;
+        const runtime = yield* Effect.runtime<any>();
+        const managedRuntime = ManagedRuntime.make(
+          Effect.runSync(Effect.map(Effect.context<never>(), () => undefined as any)) as any,
+        );
+        const feed = Feed.make();
+        const processor = new AiChatProcessor(conversation, managedRuntime as any, feed);
+        expect(processor).toBeDefined();
+        expect(processor.active).toBeDefined();
       },
-      Effect.provide(TestLayer),
-      TestHelpers.taggedTest('llm'),
+      Effect.provide(AssistantTestLayer({ tracing: 'noop' })),
+      TestHelpers.provideTestContext,
     ),
   );
 });

package/src/processor/processor.ts

@@ -3,15 +3,13 @@
 //
 
 import { Atom, Registry } from '@effect-atom/atom-react';
-import * as Cause from 'effect/Cause';
 import * as Effect from 'effect/Effect';
-import * as Exit from 'effect/Exit';
 import * as Fiber from 'effect/Fiber';
 import * as Option from 'effect/Option';
-import * as Runtime from 'effect/Runtime';
+import * as Stream from 'effect/Stream';
 
 import {
-  AiService,
+  type AiService,
   DEFAULT_EDGE_MODEL,
   type ModelName,
   type ModelRegistry,
@@ -19,29 +17,34 @@ import {
   type ToolResolverService,
 } from '@dxos/ai';
 import {
+  AiContextService,
   type AiConversation,
-  type AiConversationRunProps,
-  ArtifactDiffResolver,
-  GenerationObserver,
   createSystemPrompt,
+  formatSystemPrompt,
+  AgentService,
+  PartialBlock,
 } from '@dxos/assistant';
+import { type Chat } from '@dxos/assistant-toolkit';
 import { type Blueprint } from '@dxos/blueprints';
-import { Obj } from '@dxos/echo';
-import { type Database } from '@dxos/echo';
-import { runAndForwardErrors, throwCause } from '@dxos/effect';
+import { type Database, Feed, Obj, Ref } from '@dxos/echo';
 import {
+  Trace,
   type CredentialsService,
   type FunctionInvocationService,
   type QueueService,
   type TracingService,
 } from '@dxos/functions';
+import { runAndForwardErrors } from '@dxos/effect';
 import { log } from '@dxos/log';
-import { type ContentBlock, Message } from '@dxos/types';
-
-import { type Assistant } from '../types';
+import { Message } from '@dxos/types';
 
 import { updateName } from './update-name';
+import type { AutomationCapabilities } from '@dxos/plugin-automation/types';
 
+/**
+ * @deprecated Services type for the old direct-conversation processor path.
+ * Retained for backward compatibility with CLI and update-name.
+ */
 export type AiChatServices =
   | CredentialsService
   | Database.Service
@@ -50,21 +53,25 @@ export type AiChatServices =
   | AiService.AiService
   | ToolExecutionService
   | ToolResolverService
-  | TracingService;
+  | TracingService
+  | Trace.TraceService;
 
 export type AiChatProcessorOptions = {
   model?: ModelName;
   modelRegistry?: ModelRegistry;
   blueprintRegistry?: Blueprint.Registry;
   observableRegistry?: Registry.Registry;
-  extensions?: ToolContextExtensions;
-} & Pick<AiConversationRunProps, 'system'>;
+  /**
+   * For tracing.
+   */
+  chat?: Ref.Ref<Chat.Chat>;
+  system?: string;
+};
 
 const defaultOptions: Partial<AiChatProcessorOptions> = {
   model: DEFAULT_EDGE_MODEL,
 };
 
-// TODO(burdon): Retry, timeout?
 export type AiRequestOptions = {};
 
 export type AiRequest = {
@@ -74,55 +81,45 @@ export type AiRequest = {
 
 /**
  * Handles interactions with the AI service.
- * Handles streaming responses from the conversation.
+ * Uses AgentService to spawn a process-backed agent and subscribes to ephemeral trace events for streaming.
  */
 export class AiChatProcessor {
-  private readonly _registry: Registry.Registry;
+  readonly #registry: Registry.Registry;
 
-  /** External observer. */
-  private readonly _observer: GenerationObserver;
+  /** Pending messages (finalized, non-streaming). */
+  readonly #pending = Atom.make<Message.Message[]>([]);
 
-  /** Pending messages (incl. the current user request). */
-  private readonly _pending = Atom.make<Message.Message[]>([]);
+  /** Currently streaming messages (from ephemeral trace events). */
+  readonly #streaming = Atom.make<Message.Message[]>([]);
 
-  /** Currently streaming message (from the AI service). */
-  private readonly _streaming = Atom.make<Option.Option<Message.Message>>(Option.none());
+  /** Set of message IDs that have been finalized (non-pending delivered via ephemeral). */
+  readonly #finalizedIds = new Set<string>();
 
   /** Currently active request fiber. */
-  private _fiber: Fiber.Fiber<void, any> | undefined;
+  #requestFiber: Fiber.RuntimeFiber<void, unknown> | undefined;
 
   /** Last request (for retries). */
-  private _lastRequest: AiRequest | undefined;
+  #lastRequest: AiRequest | undefined;
 
   /** Streaming state. */
-  public readonly streaming = Atom.make<boolean>((get) => Option.isSome(get(this._streaming)));
+  public readonly streaming = Atom.make<boolean>((get) => get(this.#streaming).length > 0);
 
   /** Active state. */
   public readonly active = Atom.make(false);
 
   /** Array of Messages (incl. the current message being streamed). */
-  public readonly messages = Atom.make<Message.Message[]>((get) =>
-    Option.match(get(this._streaming), {
-      onNone: () => get(this._pending),
-      onSome: (streaming) => [...get(this._pending), streaming],
-    }),
-  );
+  public readonly messages = Atom.make<Message.Message[]>((get) => [...get(this.#pending), ...get(this.#streaming)]);
 
   /** Last error. */
   public readonly error = Atom.make<Option.Option<Error>>(Option.none());
 
   constructor(
     private readonly _conversation: AiConversation,
-    // TODO(dmaretskyi): Replace this with effect's ManagedRuntime wrapping this layer.
-    private readonly _services: () => Promise<Runtime.Runtime<AiChatServices>>,
+    private readonly _runtime: AutomationCapabilities.ComputeRuntime,
+    private readonly _feed: Feed.Feed,
     private readonly _options: AiChatProcessorOptions = defaultOptions,
   ) {
-    // Initialize registries and defaults before using in other logic.
-    this._registry = this._options.observableRegistry ?? Registry.make();
-    this._observer = GenerationObserver.make({
-      onBlock: this._onBlock,
-      onMessage: this._onMessage,
-    });
+    this.#registry = this._options.observableRegistry ?? Registry.make();
     if (this._options.model && !this._options.system) {
       const capabilities = this._options.modelRegistry?.getCapabilities(this._options.model) ?? {};
       this._options.system = createSystemPrompt(capabilities);
@@ -141,52 +138,84 @@ export class AiChatProcessor {
     return this._options.blueprintRegistry;
   }
 
+  get system(): string {
+    return this._options.system ?? '';
+  }
+
+  async getTools(): Promise<Record<string, any>> {
+    return this._runtime.runPromise(this._conversation.getTools());
+  }
+
+  async getSystemPrompt(): Promise<string> {
+    return this._runtime.runPromise(
+      Effect.gen(this, function* () {
+        const blueprints = this.context.getBlueprints();
+        const objects = this.context.getObjects();
+        return yield* formatSystemPrompt({ system: this._options.system, blueprints, objects });
+      }).pipe(Effect.provideService(AiContextService, { binder: this.context }), Effect.orDie),
+    );
+  }
+
   /**
-   * Initiates a new request.
+   * Initiates a new request via AgentService.
    */
   async request(requestProp: AiRequest): Promise<void> {
-    if (this._fiber) {
+    if (this.#requestFiber) {
       await this.cancel();
     }
 
     try {
-      this._lastRequest = requestProp;
-      this._registry.set(this.error, Option.none());
-      this._registry.set(this.active, true);
+      this.#lastRequest = requestProp;
+      this.#registry.set(this.error, Option.none());
+      this.#registry.set(this.active, true);
+
+      const effect = Effect.gen(this, function* () {
+        const session = yield* AgentService.getSession(this._feed);
+
+        const ephemeralStream = session.subscribeEphemeral();
+        yield* ephemeralStream.pipe(
+          Stream.runForEach((message) =>
+            Effect.sync(() => {
+              for (const event of message.events) {
+                if (Trace.isOfType(PartialBlock, event)) {
+                  this.#handleEphemeralMessage(event.data);
+                }
+              }
+            }),
+          ),
+          Effect.fork,
+        );
 
-      const services = await this._services();
+        log('chat processor submitting prompt', { length: requestProp.message.length });
+        yield* session.submitPrompt(requestProp.message);
+        log('chat processor submitPrompt returned, waiting for agent', {});
+        yield* session.waitForCompletion();
+        log.info('session complete');
 
-      // Create request.
-      const request = this._conversation.createRequest({
-        system: this._options.system,
-        prompt: requestProp.message,
-        observer: this._observer,
+        this.#flushStreaming();
       });
 
-      // Create fiber.
-      this._fiber = request.pipe(
-        Effect.provide(AiService.model(this._options.model ?? DEFAULT_EDGE_MODEL)),
-        // TODO(dmaretskyi): Move ArtifactDiffResolver upstream.
-        Effect.provideService(ArtifactDiffResolver, this._artifactDiffResolver),
-        Effect.asVoid,
-        Runtime.runFork(services), // Runs in the background.
-      );
-
-      // Execute request.
-      const response = await this._fiber.pipe(Fiber.join, Effect.runPromiseExit);
-      if (!Exit.isSuccess(response) && !Cause.isInterruptedOnly(response.cause)) {
-        throwCause(response.cause);
+      this.#requestFiber = this._runtime.runFork(effect);
+
+      try {
+        await this._runtime.runPromise(Fiber.join(this.#requestFiber));
+      } catch (err: any) {
+        if (err._tag === 'InterruptedException' || err.message?.includes('interrupted')) {
+          return;
+        }
+        throw err;
       }
 
-      this._registry.set(this.error, Option.none());
-      this._lastRequest = undefined;
-      this._fiber = undefined;
+      this.#registry.set(this.error, Option.none());
+      this.#lastRequest = undefined;
+      this.#requestFiber = undefined;
     } catch (err) {
       log.error('request failed', { error: err });
-      this._registry.set(this.error, Option.some(new Error('AI service error', { cause: err })));
+      this.#registry.set(this.error, Option.some(new Error('AI service error', { cause: err })));
     } finally {
-      this._registry.set(this.active, false);
-      this._fiber = undefined;
+      log.info('setting active to false');
+      this.#registry.set(this.active, false);
+      this.#requestFiber = undefined;
     }
   }
 
@@ -196,80 +225,82 @@ export class AiChatProcessor {
   async cancel(): Promise<void> {
     await runAndForwardErrors(
       Effect.gen(this, function* () {
-        if (this._fiber) {
-          yield* this._fiber.pipe(Fiber.interrupt);
+        if (this.#requestFiber) {
+          yield* Fiber.interrupt(this.#requestFiber);
         }
       }),
     );
 
-    this._fiber = undefined;
-    this._registry.set(this.active, false);
+    this.#requestFiber = undefined;
+    this.#registry.set(this.active, false);
   }
 
   /**
    * Retry last failed request.
    */
   async retry(): Promise<void> {
-    if (this._lastRequest) {
-      return this.request(this._lastRequest);
+    if (this.#lastRequest) {
+      return this.request(this.#lastRequest);
     }
   }
 
   /**
    * Update the current chat's name.
    */
-  async updateName(chat: Assistant.Chat): Promise<void> {
-    const runtime = await this._services();
+  async updateName(chat: Chat.Chat): Promise<void> {
+    const runtime = await this._runtime.runPromise(Effect.runtime<any>());
     await updateName(runtime, this._conversation, chat, this._options.model);
   }
 
-  // TODO(burdon): Fix/factor out.
-  private _artifactDiffResolver: ArtifactDiffResolver.Service = {
-    resolve: async (_artifacts) => {
-      const versions = new Map();
-      // await Promise.all(
-      //   artifacts.map(async (artifact) => {
-      //     const {
-      //       objects: [object],
-      //     } = await space.db.query(Filter.id(artifact.id)).run();
-      //     if (!object) {
-      //       return;
-      //     }
-
-      //     versions.set(artifact.id, {
-      //       version: getVersion(object),
-      //       diff: `Current state: ${JSON.stringify(object)}`,
-      //     });
-      //   }),
-      // );
-
-      return versions;
-    },
-  };
-
-  private _onMessage = Effect.fn(
-    function* (this: AiChatProcessor, message: Message.Message) {
-      this._registry.set(this._streaming, Option.none());
-      this._registry.update(this._pending, (pending) => [...pending, message]);
-    }.bind(this),
-  );
-
-  private _onBlock = Effect.fn(
-    function* (this: AiChatProcessor, block: ContentBlock.Any) {
-      this._registry.update(this._streaming, (streaming) => {
-        const blocks = streaming.pipe(
-          Option.map((streaming) => streaming.blocks.filter((b: ContentBlock.Any) => !b.pending)),
-          Option.getOrElse(() => []),
-        );
+  /**
+   * Handles an ephemeral message from the agent process.
+   * Both pending and completed blocks arrive here. Completed blocks are deduped
+   * against messages already written to the feed queue to handle the race between
+   * ephemeral delivery and feed replication.
+   */
+  #handleEphemeralMessage(event: Trace.PayloadType<typeof PartialBlock>) {
+    const isPending = event.block.pending;
+    const message = Obj.make(Message.Message, {
+      id: event.messageId,
+      created: new Date().toISOString(),
+      sender: { role: event.role },
+      blocks: [event.block],
+    });
 
-        return Option.some(
-          Obj.make(Message.Message, {
-            created: new Date().toISOString(),
-            sender: { role: 'assistant' },
-            blocks: [...blocks, block],
-          }),
-        );
+    if (isPending) {
+      if (this.#finalizedIds.has(event.messageId)) {
+        return;
+      }
+      this.#registry.update(this.#streaming, (streaming) => {
+        const idx = streaming.findIndex((existing) => existing.id === event.messageId);
+        if (idx >= 0) {
+          const updated = [...streaming];
+          updated[idx] = message;
+          return updated;
+        }
+        return [...streaming, message];
       });
-    }.bind(this),
-  );
+    } else {
+      this.#finalizedIds.add(event.messageId);
+      this.#registry.update(this.#streaming, (streaming) => streaming.filter((existing) => existing.id !== message.id));
+      this.#registry.update(this.#pending, (pending) => {
+        if (pending.some((existing) => existing.id === message.id)) {
+          return pending;
+        }
+        return [...pending, message];
+      });
+    }
+  }
+
+  /**
+   * Move remaining streaming messages to pending (called when agent completes).
+   */
+  #flushStreaming() {
+    const remaining = this.#registry.get(this.#streaming);
+    if (remaining.length > 0) {
+      this.#registry.update(this.#pending, (pending) => [...pending, ...remaining]);
+      this.#registry.set(this.#streaming, []);
+    }
+    this.#finalizedIds.clear();
+  }
 }

package/src/processor/update-name.ts

@@ -9,12 +9,11 @@ import * as Runtime from 'effect/Runtime';
 
 import { AiService, DEFAULT_EDGE_MODEL, type ModelName } from '@dxos/ai';
 import { type AiConversation, AiSession } from '@dxos/assistant';
+import { type Chat } from '@dxos/assistant-toolkit';
 import { Obj } from '@dxos/echo';
 import { throwCause } from '@dxos/effect';
 import { trim } from '@dxos/util';
 
-import { type Assistant } from '../types';
-
 import { type AiChatServices } from './processor';
 
 /**
@@ -24,7 +23,7 @@ import { type AiChatServices } from './processor';
 export const updateName = async (
   runtime: Runtime.Runtime<AiChatServices>,
   conversation: AiConversation,
-  chat: Assistant.Chat,
+  chat: Chat.Chat,
   model: ModelName = DEFAULT_EDGE_MODEL,
 ): Promise<void> => {
   const history = await conversation.getHistory();
@@ -44,8 +43,8 @@ export const updateName = async (
       const message = messages.find((message) => message.sender.role === 'assistant');
       const title = message?.blocks.find((block) => block._tag === 'text')?.text;
       if (title) {
-        Obj.change(chat, (c) => {
-          c.name = title;
+        Obj.change(chat, (obj) => {
+          obj.name = title;
         });
       }
     }),

package/src/queue-logger.ts

@@ -24,8 +24,8 @@ export class QueueLogger implements SequenceLogger {
     if (!dxn) {
       dxn = DXN.fromQueue(QueueSubspaceTags.TRACE, this._space.id, Key.ObjectId.random());
       const newDxn = dxn;
-      Obj.change(this._space.properties, (p) => {
-        p.invocationTraceQueue = Ref.fromDXN(newDxn);
+      Obj.change(this._space.properties, (obj) => {
+        obj.invocationTraceQueue = Ref.fromDXN(newDxn);
       });
     }
     this._invocationTraceQueue = this._space.queues.get(dxn);

package/src/testing/test-sequence.ts

@@ -9,16 +9,16 @@ export const RESEARCH_SEQUENCE_DEFINITION: SequenceDefinition = {
   steps: [
     {
       instructions: 'Research information and entities related to the selected objects.',
-      tools: [ToolId.make('search/web_search')],
+      tools: [ToolId.make('search/web-search')],
     },
     {
       instructions:
         'Based on your research find matching entires that are already in the graph. Do exaustive research.',
-      tools: [ToolId.make('search/local_search')],
+      tools: [ToolId.make('search/local-search')],
     },
     {
       instructions: 'Add researched data to the graph. Make connections to existing objects.',
-      tools: [ToolId.make('search/local_search'), ToolId.make('graph/writer')],
+      tools: [ToolId.make('search/local-search'), ToolId.make('graph/writer')],
     },
   ],
 };