@danceiny/gotry 0.0.1-rc.9 → 0.2.0-rc.27

package/dist/scripts/ledger-repair-plan-tests.js

@@ -0,0 +1,375 @@
+/**
+ * 账本 tenant 修复计划测试(issue #254 第一切片,run-all §29b)。
+ *
+ * 三类断言:
+ *   A. **零写**:每个场景跑完,state 目录内容哈希与跑之前逐字节一致
+ *      (含 -wal/-shm sidecar——正本目录里多出文件也算写)。
+ *   B. **判定**:无显式证据零搬移;跨租户同 idem_key / 同 wish_id 一律拒绝;
+ *      重复 dry-run 幂等。
+ *   C. **CLI seam**:repair-plan 路由、fail-closed 参数、输出稳定。
+ *
+ * 全部使用 mkdtemp 隔离 stateRoot,绝不触碰 ts/dsh-runtime/gotry-state/ 真实产品数据。
+ * 当前断言数:76;运行(在 ts/ 下):npx tsx scripts/ledger-repair-plan-tests.ts
+ */
+import Database from 'better-sqlite3';
+import { createHash } from 'node:crypto';
+import { existsSync, mkdirSync, mkdtempSync, readFileSync, readdirSync, rmSync, statSync, writeFileSync } from 'node:fs';
+import { tmpdir } from 'node:os';
+import { join } from 'node:path';
+import { spawnSync } from 'node:child_process';
+import { ensureLedger, ledgerDbPath } from '../src/state-ledger.js';
+import { REASON, REPAIR_MAPPING_ROOT_NOT_ARRAY, REPAIR_SOURCE_CHANGED, formatRepairPlan, planLedgerRepair, withImmutableLedgerCopy } from '../src/ledger-repair-plan.js';
+let pass = 0;
+let fail = 0;
+function assert(cond, msg) {
+    if (cond) {
+        pass++;
+        console.log(`  ok - ${msg}`);
+    }
+    else {
+        fail++;
+        console.error(`  FAIL - ${msg}`);
+    }
+}
+function expectSourceChange(fn, label) {
+    try {
+        fn();
+        assert(false, `${label} 应 fail-closed`);
+    }
+    catch (e) {
+        assert(e instanceof Error && e.code === REPAIR_SOURCE_CHANGED, `${label} → ${REPAIR_SOURCE_CHANGED}`);
+    }
+}
+/** 目录内容哈希:文件名 + 大小 + 字节。多出 -wal/-shm 会改变哈希 = 判定为写。 */
+function snapshotDir(path) {
+    const h = createHash('sha256');
+    const walk = (p, rel) => {
+        const st = statSync(p);
+        if (st.isDirectory()) {
+            h.update(`dir:${rel}\n`);
+            for (const name of readdirSync(p).sort())
+                walk(join(p, name), rel ? `${rel}/${name}` : name);
+        }
+        else if (st.isFile()) {
+            h.update(`file:${rel}:${st.size}\n`);
+            h.update(readFileSync(p));
+            h.update('\n');
+        }
+        else {
+            h.update(`other:${rel}\n`);
+        }
+    };
+    walk(path, '');
+    return h.digest('hex');
+}
+const roots = [];
+function newRoot(tag) {
+    const r = mkdtempSync(join(tmpdir(), `gotry-repair-${tag}-`));
+    roots.push(r);
+    return r;
+}
+function stateDir(root) { return join(root, 'gotry-state'); }
+function insertRaw(dbPath, rows) {
+    const db = new Database(dbPath);
+    const stmt = db.prepare(`INSERT INTO events (tenant_id, ts, actor, kind, subject_id, payload, idem_key, run_id)
+     VALUES (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, NULL)`);
+    for (const r of rows)
+        stmt.run(r.tenant, r.ts ?? '2026-09-01T00:00:00.000Z', 'test:fixture', r.kind, r.subject, '{}', r.idem);
+    db.close();
+}
+/** 建一个 v2 账本并直接用 SQL 种事件(不依赖写路径,便于造跨租户夹具) */
+function seedLedger(root, rows) {
+    const led = ensureLedger(root, 'local');
+    led.close(); // 关掉句柄,让 WAL checkpoint 落盘,后续哈希才稳定
+    const dbPath = ledgerDbPath(root);
+    insertRaw(dbPath, rows);
+    return dbPath;
+}
+function writeMapping(root, name, value) {
+    const p = join(root, name);
+    writeFileSync(p, typeof value === 'string' ? value : JSON.stringify(value), 'utf-8');
+    return p;
+}
+function cli(args) {
+    return spawnSync('npx', ['tsx', 'scripts/state-cli.ts', ...args], { encoding: 'utf-8' });
+}
+/** 跑一段逻辑并断言 state 目录零变化 */
+function assertZeroWrite(root, label, fn) {
+    const before = snapshotDir(stateDir(root));
+    fn();
+    const after = snapshotDir(stateDir(root));
+    assert(before === after, `零写:${label}`);
+}
+function entryBySeq(plan, seq) {
+    return plan.entries.find(e => e.seq === seq);
+}
+console.log('\n== A. 无映射:只读盘点,零搬移零写 ==');
+{
+    const root = newRoot('inv');
+    seedLedger(root, [
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-1', idem: 'import:wish:w-1' },
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'trip.logged', subject: 't-1', idem: 'trip:t-1' },
+        { tenant: 'tenant-a', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-9', idem: 'import:wish:w-9' },
+    ]);
+    let plan;
+    assertZeroWrite(root, '无映射 dry-run', () => { plan = planLedgerRepair({ stateRoot: root }); });
+    assert(plan.totals.candidates === 2, '源租户 local 下候选事件 = 2(不含 tenant-a)');
+    assert(plan.totals.move === 0, '无显式证据映射 → 零搬移');
+    assert(plan.totals.retain === 2, '全部候选原地保留');
+    assert(plan.entries.every(e => e.reason === REASON.NO_EVIDENCE), '保留理由均为 no_explicit_evidence');
+    assert(plan.applyable === false && plan.applyAuthorized === false, '无搬移时 applyable=false,且 applyAuthorized 恒 false');
+    const censusBefore = plan.tenantCensusBefore.map(t => `${t.tenant}=${t.events}`).join(' ');
+    assert(censusBefore === 'local=2 tenant-a=1', `before 分布可审计:${censusBefore}`);
+    assert(JSON.stringify(plan.tenantCensusBefore) === JSON.stringify(plan.tenantCensusAfter), '零搬移时 after 分布与 before 相同');
+}
+console.log('\n== B. 显式证据映射:计划出可审计 before/after,仍零写 ==');
+{
+    const root = newRoot('move');
+    seedLedger(root, [
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-1', idem: 'import:wish:w-1' },
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-2', idem: 'import:wish:w-2' },
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'trip.logged', subject: 't-1', idem: 'trip:t-1' },
+    ]);
+    const mappings = [
+        { seq: 1, fromTenant: 'local', toTenant: 'tenant-a', evidence: 'issue #254 comment: 用户 A 于 2026-03 确认 w-1 属于其账户' },
+    ];
+    let plan;
+    assertZeroWrite(root, '有效映射 dry-run', () => { plan = planLedgerRepair({ stateRoot: root, mappings }); });
+    assert(plan.totals.move === 1 && plan.totals.retain === 2, '仅被映射覆盖的 1 条计划搬移,其余保留');
+    const moved = entryBySeq(plan, 1);
+    assert(moved.decision === 'move' && moved.beforeTenant === 'local' && moved.afterTenant === 'tenant-a', 'before/after 逐条可读:local -> tenant-a');
+    assert(moved.evidence !== null && moved.evidence.includes('#254'), '搬移条目带人工证据原文');
+    const after = plan.tenantCensusAfter.map(t => `${t.tenant}=${t.events}`).join(' ');
+    assert(after === 'local=2 tenant-a=1', `after 分布按计划模拟:${after}`);
+    assert(plan.applyable === true, '无冲突且有搬移 → applyable=true');
+    assert(plan.applyAuthorized === false, '但 applyAuthorized 仍为 false:真实 apply 在单独 owner gate 后');
+    // 计划归计划,账本里 tenant 分布一个字节没动
+    const db = new Database(ledgerDbPath(root), { readonly: true });
+    const live = db.prepare('SELECT tenant_id AS t, COUNT(*) AS n FROM events GROUP BY tenant_id ORDER BY tenant_id').all()
+        .map(r => `${r.t}=${r.n}`).join(' ');
+    db.close();
+    assert(live === 'local=3', `dry-run 后账本真实分布未变:${live}`);
+}
+console.log('\n== C. 无证据不搬移:映射缺 evidence / 格式非法 → 拒绝且零写 ==');
+{
+    const root = newRoot('malformed');
+    seedLedger(root, [
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-1', idem: 'import:wish:w-1' },
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-2', idem: 'import:wish:w-2' },
+    ]);
+    const bad = [
+        { seq: 1, fromTenant: 'local', toTenant: 'tenant-a' }, // 缺 evidence
+        { seq: 2, fromTenant: 'local', toTenant: 'tenant-a', evidence: '   ' }, // evidence 空白
+        { seq: 0, fromTenant: 'local', toTenant: 'tenant-a', evidence: 'x' }, // seq 非正整数
+        { seq: 1, fromTenant: 'local', toTenant: '', evidence: 'x' }, // toTenant 空
+        { seq: 1, fromTenant: '', toTenant: 'tenant-a', evidence: 'x' }, // fromTenant 空
+        'not-an-object', // 条目非对象
+        { seq: 1, fromTenant: 'tenant-zzz', toTenant: 'tenant-a', evidence: 'x' }, // fromTenant 越出 scope
+    ];
+    let plan;
+    assertZeroWrite(root, '非法映射 dry-run', () => { plan = planLedgerRepair({ stateRoot: root, mappings: bad }); });
+    assert(plan.totals.move === 0, '任何非法映射都不产生搬移');
+    const codes = plan.rejectedMappings.map(r => r.reason);
+    assert(codes.includes(REASON.MAPPING_EVIDENCE_MISSING), '缺 evidence → mapping_evidence_missing');
+    assert(codes.filter(c => c === REASON.MAPPING_EVIDENCE_MISSING).length === 2, '空白 evidence 同样按缺失处理');
+    assert(codes.includes(REASON.MAPPING_SEQ_INVALID), 'seq 非正整数 → mapping_seq_invalid');
+    assert(codes.includes(REASON.MAPPING_TO_INVALID), 'toTenant 空 → mapping_to_tenant_invalid');
+    assert(codes.includes(REASON.MAPPING_FROM_INVALID), 'fromTenant 空 → mapping_from_tenant_invalid');
+    assert(codes.includes(REASON.MAPPING_NOT_OBJECT), '条目非对象 → mapping_not_object');
+    assert(codes.includes(REASON.MAPPING_OUT_OF_SCOPE), 'fromTenant 越 scope → mapping_from_tenant_out_of_scope');
+    assert(plan.applyable === false, '存在非法映射 → 计划整体不可 apply');
+    assert(plan.entries.every(e => e.decision === 'retain'), '非法映射不影响其它事件:全部原地保留');
+}
+console.log('\n== D. 重复映射 / 目标即源 / seq 越 scope ==');
+{
+    const root = newRoot('dup');
+    seedLedger(root, [{ tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-1', idem: 'k-1' }]);
+    const plan = planLedgerRepair({ stateRoot: root, mappings: [
+            { seq: 1, fromTenant: 'local', toTenant: 'tenant-a', evidence: 'e1' },
+            { seq: 1, fromTenant: 'local', toTenant: 'tenant-b', evidence: 'e2' },
+        ] });
+    assert(plan.rejectedMappings.some(r => r.reason === REASON.MAPPING_DUPLICATE_SEQ), '同 seq 重复映射 → mapping_duplicate_seq');
+    assert(plan.applyable === false, '重复映射使计划不可 apply(意图不明不猜)');
+    const p2 = planLedgerRepair({ stateRoot: root, mappings: [{ seq: 1, fromTenant: 'local', toTenant: 'local', evidence: 'e' }] });
+    assert(entryBySeq(p2, 1).reason === REASON.TARGET_EQUALS_SOURCE, '目标租户 = 源租户 → target_tenant_equals_source');
+    assert(p2.totals.move === 0, '无搬移语义时零搬移');
+    const p3 = planLedgerRepair({ stateRoot: root, mappings: [{ seq: 999, fromTenant: 'local', toTenant: 'tenant-a', evidence: 'e' }] });
+    const e999 = entryBySeq(p3, 999);
+    assert(e999.decision === 'reject' && e999.reason === REASON.EVENT_NOT_IN_SCOPE, 'seq 不在源 scope → event_not_found_in_scope');
+    assert(p3.totals.move === 0, '越 scope 的 seq 零搬移');
+}
+console.log('\n== E. 跨租户同 idem_key / 同 wish_id 夹具:拒绝且零写 ==');
+{
+    const root = newRoot('conflict');
+    seedLedger(root, [
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-same', idem: 'import:wish:w-same' }, // seq 1
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'trip.logged', subject: 't-1', idem: 'dup-idem' }, // seq 2
+        { tenant: 'tenant-a', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-same', idem: 'other-1' }, // seq 3 同 wish_id
+        { tenant: 'tenant-a', kind: 'trip.logged', subject: 't-9', idem: 'dup-idem' }, // seq 4 同 idem_key
+    ]);
+    let plan;
+    assertZeroWrite(root, '跨租户同 id 夹具 dry-run', () => {
+        plan = planLedgerRepair({ stateRoot: root, mappings: [
+                { seq: 1, fromTenant: 'local', toTenant: 'tenant-a', evidence: '人工确认 A' },
+                { seq: 2, fromTenant: 'local', toTenant: 'tenant-a', evidence: '人工确认 B' },
+            ] });
+    });
+    assert(entryBySeq(plan, 1).reason === REASON.SUBJECT_CONFLICT, '目标租户已存在同 wish_id → target_subject_conflict');
+    assert(entryBySeq(plan, 2).reason === REASON.IDEM_CONFLICT, '目标租户已存在同 idem_key → target_idem_key_conflict');
+    assert(plan.totals.move === 0 && plan.totals.reject === 2, '两类跨租户同 id 冲突都零搬移');
+    assert(entryBySeq(plan, 1).afterTenant === 'local' && entryBySeq(plan, 2).afterTenant === 'local', '冲突事件 after 仍是原租户(留在原地)');
+    assert(plan.applyable === false, '有冲突 → 计划不可 apply');
+}
+console.log('\n== F. 重复 dry-run 幂等 ==');
+{
+    const root = newRoot('idem');
+    seedLedger(root, [
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-1', idem: 'k1' },
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-2', idem: 'k2' },
+        { tenant: 'tenant-a', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-3', idem: 'k3' },
+    ]);
+    const mappings = [{ seq: 1, fromTenant: 'local', toTenant: 'tenant-a', evidence: 'e' }];
+    const before = snapshotDir(stateDir(root));
+    const digests = [];
+    const reports = [];
+    for (let i = 0; i < 3; i++) {
+        const p = planLedgerRepair({ stateRoot: root, mappings });
+        digests.push(p.planDigest);
+        reports.push(formatRepairPlan(p));
+    }
+    const after = snapshotDir(stateDir(root));
+    assert(before === after, '零写:连续 3 次 dry-run 后 state 目录逐字节不变');
+    assert(new Set(digests).size === 1, `重复 dry-run 幂等:plan-digest 恒为 ${digests[0]}`);
+    assert(new Set(reports).size === 1, '重复 dry-run 报告逐字节相同');
+}
+console.log('\n== G. v1 形态账本:只读呈现,绝不就地迁移 ==');
+{
+    const root = newRoot('v1');
+    const dir = stateDir(root);
+    mkdirSync(dir, { recursive: true });
+    const dbPath = join(dir, 'gotry-state.db');
+    const v1 = new Database(dbPath);
+    v1.exec(`
+CREATE TABLE events (
+  seq INTEGER PRIMARY KEY AUTOINCREMENT, ts TEXT NOT NULL, actor TEXT NOT NULL, kind TEXT NOT NULL,
+  subject_id TEXT NOT NULL DEFAULT '', payload TEXT NOT NULL, idem_key TEXT, run_id TEXT
+);
+CREATE UNIQUE INDEX events_idem ON events(idem_key) WHERE idem_key IS NOT NULL;`);
+    v1.prepare(`INSERT INTO events (ts, actor, kind, subject_id, payload, idem_key) VALUES (?,?,?,?,?,?)`)
+        .run('2026-01-01T00:00:00.000Z', 'legacy', 'wish.added', 'w-legacy', '{}', 'import:wish:w-legacy');
+    v1.close();
+    let plan;
+    assertZeroWrite(root, 'v1 账本 dry-run(对照:openLedgerIfExists 会 ALTER/DROP 重建)', () => {
+        plan = planLedgerRepair({ stateRoot: root });
+    });
+    const probe = new Database(dbPath, { readonly: true });
+    const cols = probe.prepare('PRAGMA table_info(events)').all().map(c => c.name);
+    const uv = probe.pragma('user_version', { simple: true });
+    const tables = probe.prepare("SELECT name FROM sqlite_master WHERE type='table' ORDER BY name").all().map(t => t.name);
+    probe.close();
+    assert(!cols.includes('tenant_id'), 'v1 的 events 仍无 tenant_id 列(未被偷偷迁移)');
+    assert(uv === 0, 'user_version 仍为 0(未被顶到 2)');
+    assert(!tables.includes('projection_docs') && !tables.includes('kv'), '未凭空建出 v2 的投影/kv 表');
+    assert(plan.totals.candidates === 1 && plan.totals.retain === 1, 'v1 事件按 local 只读呈现');
+    assert(plan.notes.some(n => n.includes('v1 形态')), '报告显式提示 v1 形态与其边界');
+}
+console.log('\n== H. 未 checkpoint WAL:副本包含 WAL 可见事件 ==');
+{
+    const root = newRoot('wal');
+    const dbPath = seedLedger(root, [
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-main', idem: 'k-main' },
+    ]);
+    const writer = new Database(dbPath);
+    writer.pragma('journal_mode = WAL');
+    writer.prepare(`INSERT INTO events (tenant_id, ts, actor, kind, subject_id, payload, idem_key, run_id)
+     VALUES (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, NULL)`).run('local', '2026-09-01T00:00:00.000Z', 'test:wal', 'wish.added', 'w-wal', '{}', 'k-wal');
+    assert(existsSync(`${dbPath}-wal`), '夹具保持未 checkpoint 的 -wal sidecar');
+    const before = snapshotDir(stateDir(root));
+    const plan = planLedgerRepair({ stateRoot: root });
+    assert(plan.totals.candidates === 2, '只读副本可见主库 + 未 checkpoint WAL 的 2 条事件');
+    assert(plan.entries.some(e => e.subjectId === 'w-wal'), 'WAL 中事件进入计划视图');
+    assert(snapshotDir(stateDir(root)) === before, '读取未 checkpoint WAL 后正本目录零写');
+    writer.close();
+}
+console.log('\n== I. 并发变化:复制/读取期间 source mutation fail-closed ==');
+{
+    const root = newRoot('mutation');
+    const dbPath = seedLedger(root, [
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-before', idem: 'k-before' },
+    ]);
+    expectSourceChange(() => withImmutableLedgerCopy(root, db => {
+        // Deterministic stand-in for a concurrent writer after the immutable copy is opened.
+        insertRaw(dbPath, [{ tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-during-read', idem: 'k-during-read' }]);
+        db.prepare('SELECT count(*) AS n FROM events').get();
+    }), 'source 在只读回调期间变化');
+    const probe = new Database(dbPath, { readonly: true });
+    const count = probe.prepare('SELECT count(*) AS n FROM events').get().n;
+    probe.close();
+    assert(count === 2, '反例只改变隔离夹具正本,未被计划副本隐式吸收');
+}
+console.log('\n== J. tenant scope:非 local 源租户只看自己 ==');
+{
+    const root = newRoot('scope');
+    seedLedger(root, [
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-1', idem: 'k1' },
+        { tenant: 'tenant-a', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-2', idem: 'k2' },
+        { tenant: 'tenant-a', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-3', idem: 'k3' },
+    ]);
+    const p = planLedgerRepair({ stateRoot: root, sourceTenant: 'tenant-a' });
+    assert(p.totals.candidates === 2, 'sourceTenant=tenant-a 只盘点 tenant-a 的 2 条');
+    assert(p.entries.every(e => e.beforeTenant === 'tenant-a'), '候选不串到 local');
+}
+console.log('\n== K. CLI seam ==');
+{
+    const root = newRoot('cli');
+    seedLedger(root, [
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-1', idem: 'k1' },
+        { tenant: 'local', kind: 'wish.added', subject: 'w-2', idem: 'k2' },
+    ]);
+    const before = snapshotDir(stateDir(root));
+    const text = cli(['repair-plan', root]);
+    assert(text.status === 0, 'repair-plan 命令存在且退出码 0');
+    assert(/plan-digest=/.test(text.stdout ?? ''), '文本报告带 plan-digest');
+    assert(/applyAuthorized=false/.test(text.stdout ?? ''), '文本报告显式声明 applyAuthorized=false');
+    assert(/no_explicit_evidence/.test(text.stdout ?? ''), '无映射时逐条标注 no_explicit_evidence');
+    const again = cli(['repair-plan', root]);
+    assert(again.stdout === text.stdout, 'CLI 重复执行 stdout 逐字节相同(幂等)');
+    const mapPath = writeMapping(root, 'mapping.json', [
+        { seq: 1, fromTenant: 'local', toTenant: 'tenant-a', evidence: '人工确认:issue #254 附件' },
+    ]);
+    const withMap = cli(['repair-plan', root, '--mapping', mapPath, '--format', 'json']);
+    assert(withMap.status === 0, '--mapping + --format json 可用');
+    const parsed = JSON.parse(withMap.stdout);
+    assert(parsed.schema === 'gotry.ledger-repair-plan/1', 'JSON 输出带 schema 版本');
+    assert(parsed.totals.move === 1 && parsed.applyAuthorized === false, 'JSON 计划:1 条搬移,applyAuthorized=false');
+    const missing = cli(['repair-plan', root, '--mapping', join(root, 'nope.json')]);
+    assert(missing.status === 1, '映射文件缺失 → fail-closed 退出码 1');
+    assert(/不可读/.test(missing.stderr ?? ''), '缺失映射有明确报错');
+    writeMapping(root, 'bad.json', '{ not json');
+    const badJson = cli(['repair-plan', root, '--mapping', join(root, 'bad.json')]);
+    assert(badJson.status === 1, '映射文件非法 JSON → fail-closed 退出码 1');
+    const notArray = writeMapping(root, 'obj.json', { seq: 1 });
+    const rootNotArray = cli(['repair-plan', root, '--mapping', notArray, '--format', 'json']);
+    const rna = JSON.parse(rootNotArray.stdout);
+    assert(rna.rejectedMappings[0]?.reason === REPAIR_MAPPING_ROOT_NOT_ARRAY, '映射根节点非数组 → mapping_root_not_array');
+    assert(rna.totals.move === 0, '根节点非数组时零搬移');
+    const badFormat = cli(['repair-plan', root, '--format', 'yaml']);
+    assert(badFormat.status === 1, '--format 非法值 fail-closed');
+    const mapOnLog = cli(['log', root, '--mapping', mapPath]);
+    assert(mapOnLog.status === 1, '--mapping 只属于 repair-plan,用在 log 上被拒');
+    const fmtOnStats = cli(['stats', root, '--format', 'json']);
+    assert(fmtOnStats.status === 1, '--format 只属于 repair-plan,用在 stats 上被拒');
+    const extraPos = cli(['repair-plan', root, 'extra']);
+    assert(extraPos.status === 1, 'repair-plan 不接受额外位置参数');
+    const after = snapshotDir(stateDir(root));
+    assert(before === after, '零写:全部 CLI repair-plan 调用后 state 目录逐字节不变');
+    const empty = newRoot('cli-empty');
+    const noLedger = cli(['repair-plan', empty]);
+    assert(noLedger.status === 1 && /无账本/.test(noLedger.stderr ?? ''), '无账本 root → 退出码 1,不建库');
+    assert(readdirSync(empty).length === 0, '无账本时不在 root 下创建任何文件/目录');
+}
+for (const r of roots)
+    rmSync(r, { recursive: true, force: true });
+console.log(`\nLEDGER-REPAIR-PLAN TESTS: ${pass} ok, ${fail} fail`);
+if (fail > 0)
+    process.exit(1);