@cotal-ai/cli 0.68.0 → 0.69.0

package/dist/commands/up.js

@@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ import { isReachable, DEFAULT_SERVER, createSpaceAuth, serverConfig, openServerC
 import { connect } from "@nats-io/transport-node";
 import { jetstreamManager, StorageType } from "@nats-io/jetstream";
 import { Kvm } from "@nats-io/kv";
-import { assertSingleSpaceBroker, assertUserAuthInfo, authDir, getSoleSpaceAuth, getSpaceAuth, hasUserAuthState, listSpaceAccounts, preloadSpaceAccounts, putSpaceAuth, clearCurrent, findMesh, getCurrent, loadMeshes, connectionEvictorCredsKey, membershipConfigPath, membershipObserverCredsKey, membershipRwCredsKey, MEMBERSHIP_CONFIG_KIND, MEMBERSHIP_RW_CREDS_KIND, parsePositiveIntegerFlag, recordMesh, meshesForRoot, removeMesh, rotateSystemCreds, setCurrent, staleSystemCreds, SYSTEM_CREDS_FILES, userAuthStateDir, userAuthSpacesOnDisk, workspaceSecretStore, acquireMaintenanceLock, assertStoreIdentity, assessRestoreClaim, beginOrdinaryResume, bindOrdinaryResumeListener, consumeRetiredMaintenance, markOrdinaryResumeActive, markOrdinaryResumeDegraded, replaceDeadOrdinaryResumeListener, localProcessOwnerStatus, readMaintenanceJournal, readMaintenanceResumeDocument, seatCheckpointDir, readStoreIdentity, recordOrdinaryResumeManagerCommit, releaseMaintenanceLock, retireOrdinaryResume, sameStoreIdentity, readBrokerPolicy, writeBrokerPolicy, removePidPair, writePidPair, localProcessPath, MANAGER_PIDFILE, assertManagerCanSpare, verifyIdentityPin, isLoopbackHost, connectUserControlOrThrow, userViewAuth, } from "@cotal-ai/workspace";
+import { assertSingleSpaceBroker, assertUserAuthInfo, authDir, getSoleSpaceAuth, getSpaceAuth, hasUserAuthState, listSpaceAccounts, preloadSpaceAccounts, putSpaceAuth, clearCurrent, findMesh, getCurrent, loadMeshes, connectionEvictorCredsKey, membershipConfigPath, membershipObserverCredsKey, membershipRwCredsKey, MEMBERSHIP_CONFIG_KIND, MEMBERSHIP_RW_CREDS_KIND, parsePositiveIntegerFlag, recordMesh, meshesForRoot, removeMesh, rotateSystemCreds, setCurrent, staleSystemCreds, SYSTEM_CREDS_FILES, userAuthStateDir, userAuthSpacesOnDisk, workspaceSecretStore, acquireMaintenanceLock, assertStoreIdentity, assessRestoreClaim, beginOrdinaryResume, bindOrdinaryResumeListener, consumeRetiredMaintenance, markOrdinaryResumeActive, markOrdinaryResumeDegraded, replaceDeadOrdinaryResumeListener, localProcessOwnerStatus, readMaintenanceJournal, readMaintenanceResumeDocument, seatCheckpointDir, readStoreIdentity, recordOrdinaryResumeManagerCommit, releaseMaintenanceLock, retireOrdinaryResume, sameStoreIdentity, readBrokerPolicy, writeBrokerPolicy, removePidPair, writePidPair, isLoopbackHost, connectUserControlOrThrow, userViewAuth, } from "@cotal-ai/workspace";
 import { ensureAuthService, resolveAuthProvider, stopAuthService } from "../lib/auth-proc.js";
 import { resolveSpace } from "../lib/status.js";
 import { c } from "../ui.js";
@@ -21,12 +21,10 @@ import { deliveryStoppedByDown, deliveryUp, ensureControlPlane, ensureDelivery,
 import { RESPONDER_UNBOUND_CONSEQUENCE } from "../lib/delivery-responder.js";
 import { displayCmd } from "../lib/self-exec.js";
 import { liveManagerWouldApplyMaxSessions, managerHasDeliveryMarker, managerLogDisplayPath, managerRecordState, managerUp, stopManager } from "../lib/manager-proc.js";
-import { listManagerSeatsForSpare, printLegacyManagerSpareUncertainty, printSparedAgents } from "../lib/teardown-spare.js";
 import { loadManifest } from "../lib/manifest/index.js";
 import { buildLaunchSpec, genRunId, manifestToChannels, preflightConnectors, writeLaunchSpec } from "../lib/manifest/apply.js";
 import { renderUpPlan, renderInherited, renderWarnings } from "../lib/manifest/render.js";
 import { failManifest } from "./topology.js";
-import { reserveStop } from "./down.js";
 import { extensionNames, preflightRuntime } from "../ext-loader.js";
 import { completingFlagValue } from "../lib/completion.js";
 import { askManager } from "../lib/control.js";
@@ -868,6 +866,12 @@ async function runUp(args, inheritedLock, onAdopt) {
                     });
                     if (!controlPlane)
                         process.exitCode = 1;
+                    // #883: a refresh that HEALED a missing manager must say so — the summary line otherwise reads
+                    // identically to a refresh that found everything already up, and the operator cannot tell which
+                    // world they are in without a second command. Only here does a started manager mean one was
+                    // missing: a launch starts its manager as a matter of course (#2480).
+                    if (controlPlane?.started)
+                        console.log(c.green(`✓ restored in the background: manager (pid ${controlPlane.pid})`));
                 }
                 // A broker was already answering here — this branch starts nothing, so it must not claim the
                 // record as ours (see `Provenance`), and it passes only what this invocation decided.
@@ -936,7 +940,6 @@ async function runUp(args, inheritedLock, onAdopt) {
                         verify: async () => { await verifySpawnedOrdinaryListener(ordinaryAttempt); },
                     },
                 } : {}),
-                skipPostStart: Boolean(resumeAttempt),
             });
             // Transport policy is committed inside startMeshDetached before delivery launch (S5+S9).
             console.log(c.dim(`Started nats-server (${source}).`));
@@ -1023,19 +1026,22 @@ async function runUp(args, inheritedLock, onAdopt) {
             if (!resumeAttempt)
                 process.exit(1);
         });
-        // The control plane is coupled to the broker: stop the delivery daemon AND the detached manager
+        // The control plane is coupled to the broker: stop the detached manager AND the delivery daemon
         // (AND the space's user-auth service) when this `up` stops (Ctrl-C), so none outlives the broker
         // it serves — a surviving manager would reconnect-loop invisibly against the dead (or the NEXT)
         // broker (the documented orphan-supervisor failure mode). All kill by pidfile, symmetric; the
         // auth service's pid is space-scoped so no other space's daemon can ever be hit.
+        // The manager goes first, in `cotal down`'s order, through the stop `cotal down` runs (#1307): it
+        // holds the stop reservation, asserts the exact manager can spare its seats before any signal,
+        // reports the seats left behind, and escalates a wedged manager to SIGKILL. When that stop throws
+        // the manager may still be serving, so NOTHING else is signalled — no delivery, no auth, no broker:
+        // the refusal is printed with the reap route and the latch is released, so the stack keeps running
+        // in the foreground; the operator ends it with `cotal down --with-agents` from another terminal,
+        // and the broker-exit handler below already ends `up` when the broker goes.
         // stopDelivery is the stop `cotal down delivery` performs (reservation, SIGKILL escalation); the
         // rest of the teardown must run even if it fails — the failure is logged, never swallowed
-        // silently. Order preserved: delivery, manager, auth, broker.
-        // The manager stop is the SPARING one `cotal down` performs (#1307): the seat snapshot is taken
-        // while the manager still answers, the spare capability of the exact recorded process is asserted
-        // before any signal, and the seats left behind are reported with the reap route. Teardown is
-        // AWAITED before the broker is signalled — the same order the broker-exit handler below uses — so
-        // manager teardown never races a broker that is already going away.
+        // silently. Teardown is AWAITED before the broker is signalled, so it never races a broker that is
+        // already going away.
         let stopping = false;
         let teardown;
         const stop = () => {
@@ -1047,58 +1053,16 @@ async function runUp(args, inheritedLock, onAdopt) {
             if (child.exitCode !== null || child.signalCode !== null)
                 return;
             teardown = (async () => {
-                const managerContext = { root: cotalRoot(), space };
-                let spared;
-                let spareSeats;
-                let legacyManagerSpareUnverified = false;
-                const managerPidPath = localProcessPath(MANAGER_PIDFILE, managerContext);
-                const stopMarker = `${managerPidPath}.stopping`;
-                let reserved = false;
-                if (existsSync(managerPidPath)) {
-                    const pin = verifyIdentityPin(managerPidPath);
-                    if (pin.kind === "legacy")
-                        legacyManagerSpareUnverified = true;
-                    else if (pin.kind === "match") {
-                        spared = await listManagerSeatsForSpare(managerContext);
-                        try {
-                            // Taken before the capability read and held until the manager is gone, as bare `down`
-                            // holds it, so a concurrent `cotal down` can neither stop this manager nor arm a reap
-                            // while this stop is in flight.
-                            reserveStop("manager", stopMarker);
-                            reserved = true;
-                            spareSeats = assertManagerCanSpare(managerContext, undefined, pin.record);
-                        }
-                        catch (e) {
-                            // THE CAPABILITY ASSERT IS THE SIGNAL GATE, the same rule bare `down` enforces inside
-                            // its beforeSignal hook: a throw there signals nothing. Signal NOTHING here either — no
-                            // manager, no delivery, no auth, no broker — print the refusal with the reap route, and
-                            // release the latch so the stack keeps running in the foreground; the operator ends it
-                            // with `cotal down --with-agents` from another terminal, and the broker-exit handler
-                            // below already ends `up` when the broker goes.
-                            if (reserved)
-                                rmSync(stopMarker, { force: true });
-                            console.error(c.red(`! teardown: ${e.message}`));
-                            console.error(c.red(`the stack is still running; to take managed agents with it, run: cotal down --with-agents`));
-                            stopping = false;
-                            return;
-                        }
-                    }
-                }
-                await stopDelivery(space).catch((e) => console.error(`! delivery teardown: ${e.message}`));
                 try {
-                    await stopManager(undefined, undefined, undefined, space);
-                    if (legacyManagerSpareUnverified)
-                        printLegacyManagerSpareUncertainty();
-                    else if (spared)
-                        printSparedAgents(spared, spareSeats);
+                    await stopManager(space);
                 }
                 catch (e) {
-                    console.error(`! manager teardown: ${e.message}`);
-                }
-                finally {
-                    if (reserved)
-                        rmSync(stopMarker, { force: true });
+                    console.error(c.red(`! teardown: ${e.message}`));
+                    console.error(c.red(`the stack is still running; to take managed agents with it, run: cotal down --with-agents`));
+                    stopping = false;
+                    return;
                 }
+                await stopDelivery(space).catch((e) => console.error(`! delivery teardown: ${e.message}`));
                 await stopAuthService(space).catch((e) => console.error(`! auth teardown: ${e.message}`));
                 child.kill("SIGTERM");
             })();
@@ -1109,11 +1073,11 @@ async function runUp(args, inheritedLock, onAdopt) {
         // so a later `cotal spawn` doesn't try to join a dead mesh.
         child.on("exit", async (code, signal) => {
             removePidPair(cotalPath("nats.pid"), String(child.pid));
-            // One teardown at a time: a delivery stop started while another is in flight is refused the
-            // reservation that one holds, so wait for a Ctrl-C teardown already running instead of racing it.
+            // One teardown at a time: a stop started while another is in flight is refused the reservation
+            // that one holds, so wait for a Ctrl-C teardown already running instead of racing it.
             await teardown;
             await stopDelivery(space).catch((e) => console.error(`! delivery teardown: ${e.message}`));
-            await stopManager(undefined, undefined, undefined, space).catch((e) => console.error(`! manager teardown: ${e.message}`));
+            await stopManager(space).catch((e) => console.error(`! manager teardown: ${e.message}`));
             await stopAuthService(space).catch((e) => console.error(`! auth teardown: ${e.message}`));
             // Unrecording (and the exit code below) both depend on WHY the broker is gone. `stopping` is
             // true only for the intended shutdown `stop()` drives (Ctrl-C, SIGTERM) — everything else here
@@ -1164,46 +1128,7 @@ async function runUp(args, inheritedLock, onAdopt) {
             console.error(c.yellow(`! nats-server ${v.version} is below 2.14.5 and the presence bucket of "${space}" is file-backed: it can latch after a stall and close the mesh to new joins (#1356); put a nats-server 2.14.5 or newer on PATH (it wins over the bundled one)`));
         if (restored)
             await provePreparedRestoreListener(restored);
-        // Listener ready — commit the transport decision (S5: not before start).
-        commitTransportPolicy(meshRoot, transport);
         {
-            if (!resumeAttempt)
-                await postStart(server, space, setup, seedFile);
-            else
-                await recreateMemoryBuckets(server, space, setup);
-            // USER MODE: the auth service comes up FIRST among the daemons — until its callout answers,
-            // every user-mode connect to this broker is denied, so `up` must not report a usable user mesh
-            // (nor let agents race it) on a half-started auth plane. (Foreground `up` doesn't exit here, so
-            // `ok` has no exit code to carry — the red consequence line above is the operator signal.)
-            const svc = await startUserAuthService(space, server, setup, publicExchange);
-            // Record BEFORE the control plane comes up: the manager's fail-closed mode detection requires
-            // an authoritative registry entry (marker-without-registry is a refused start, not a guess),
-            // so the record must exist by the time it boots. A manager/delivery failure after this leaves
-            // a recorded-but-degraded mesh — the documented, healable posture.
-            // Resolve exposure BEFORE recording. This path also serves a RESUME of an already-recorded mesh
-            // (`down --preserve-state` then a bare `up`), where the operator's `--host` lives only in the
-            // registry — and the record below is written whole, so reading it afterwards would find the
-            // field this very call had just erased.
-            const effectiveAttachHost = attachHostFor(space, values.host);
-            const effectiveMaxSessions = maxSessionsFor(space, maxSessions);
-            recordOurMesh({
-                space, server, root: cotalRoot(),
-                mode: setup?.prepared ? "user" : useAuth ? "auth" : "open",
-                // Written ALWAYS, as a boolean, unlike `attachHost` below. Absence and `false` resolve
-                // identically for clients, so an omitted field would be indistinguishable from a deliberate
-                // plaintext mesh — and this is the one field whose whole purpose is that the answer was
-                // stated rather than defaulted.
-                tlsRequired: transport.kind === "tls-required",
-                ...(svc.userAuth ? { userAuth: svc.userAuth } : {}),
-                // Only a real decision is persisted — an explicit `--host` now, or one carried forward from a
-                // previous launch. The bare case stays absent rather than recording the loopback default as
-                // though the operator had chosen it.
-                ...(effectiveAttachHost ? { attachHost: effectiveAttachHost } : {}),
-                ...(effectiveMaxSessions !== undefined ? { maxSessions: effectiveMaxSessions } : {}),
-                ...(maxFileStore !== undefined ? { maxFileStore } : {}),
-                storeDir,
-                ts: new Date().toISOString(),
-            }, "started");
             // A DAEMON THAT DIES UNDER THIS RUNNING BROKER IS RESTARTED HERE (#2469). It exits on its own once
             // it cannot reach the broker, and a starved host makes a running broker look unreachable, so it can
             // end while this broker serves on. Nothing else brings it back, and every static retirement then
@@ -1254,26 +1179,21 @@ async function runUp(args, inheritedLock, onAdopt) {
                     restartingDelivery = false;
                 })();
             };
-            // Bring up the delivery daemon WITH the server (auth mode only — it self-gates on `.cotal/auth`).
-            // It is part of the server, so `cotal up` starts it by default; open dev mode has no daemon.
-            // Class-2 credential renewal is NOT wired here: the MANAGER is the renewal owner (it is resident
-            // in every mesh mode — foreground, --detach, refresh — where this foreground process is not).
-            const controlPlane = await startDeliveryWithBroker(space, server, transport.kind === "tls-required", {
-                onDeliveryExit,
-                runtime: values.runtime,
-                // The address the broker was bound to. This is what lets `cotal attach` reach this manager
-                // from another machine; without it the attach face stays loopback-only, so exposing terminals
-                // is never a side effect of anything but the operator binding the mesh somewhere reachable.
-                attachHost: effectiveAttachHost,
-                maxSessions: effectiveMaxSessions,
-                noManager,
+            const { authService, controlPlane } = await serveReadyListener({
+                child, server, space, storeDir, setup, seedFile, transport,
+                host: values.host,
+                maxSessions,
+                maxFileStore,
+                publicExchange,
                 resumeAttempt,
                 resumeCommitToken: restored?.managerCommit?.durableCommitToken ?? ordinaryAttempt?.managerCommit?.durableCommitToken,
-                wsPort: setup?.wsPort, // P2 item 6: the console session client's broker ws port
+                runtime: values.runtime,
+                noManager,
+                onDeliveryExit,
             });
             if (restored && process.env.COTAL_SMOKE_FAIL_AFTER_RESTORE_LISTENER_READY === "1")
                 throw new Error("smoke-injected failure after restore listener readiness");
-            await completeResumeActivation(resumeAttempt, controlPlane && svc.ok, !svc.ok ? "normal listener started but the user-auth service is unavailable" : "normal listener started but the control plane is degraded", server, startupLock);
+            await completeResumeActivation(resumeAttempt, controlPlane !== undefined && authService, !authService ? "normal listener started but the user-auth service is unavailable" : "normal listener started but the control plane is degraded", server, startupLock);
             activationFinished = true;
         }
         await new Promise(() => { });
@@ -1651,7 +1571,7 @@ async function resumeProvenOrdinaryListener(pending, heldLock) {
         resumeAttempt: pending.attemptId,
         resumeCommitToken: pending.managerCommit?.durableCommitToken,
     });
-    await completeResumeActivation(pending.attemptId, controlPlane && svc.ok, !svc.ok ? "adopted resume listener has no user-auth service" : "adopted resume listener has a degraded control plane", pending.server, heldLock);
+    await completeResumeActivation(pending.attemptId, controlPlane !== undefined && svc.ok, !svc.ok ? "adopted resume listener has no user-auth service" : "adopted resume listener has a degraded control plane", pending.server, heldLock);
 }
 async function ensureRecoveredUserAuth(prepared) {
     if (prepared.mode !== "user")
@@ -1697,7 +1617,7 @@ async function resumeProvenRestoreListener(prepared, heldLock) {
         resumeAttempt: prepared.attemptId,
         resumeCommitToken: prepared.managerCommit?.durableCommitToken,
     });
-    await completeResumeActivation(prepared.attemptId, controlPlane && svc.ok, !svc.ok ? "proven restore listener has no user-auth service" : "proven restore listener has a degraded control plane", prepared.server, heldLock);
+    await completeResumeActivation(prepared.attemptId, controlPlane !== undefined && svc.ok, !svc.ok ? "proven restore listener has no user-auth service" : "proven restore listener has a degraded control plane", prepared.server, heldLock);
 }
 async function completeResumeActivation(attemptId, healthy, reason, server, heldLock) {
     if (!attemptId)
@@ -2061,7 +1981,7 @@ async function upManifest(file, opts) {
     // A leftover detached manager (its broker is gone — the reachability check above proved nothing
     // lives at this address) would win the fresh mesh's lease and the launch manager would refuse.
     // Stop it, so the manager started below WITH the launch spec is THE manager.
-    await stopManager(undefined, undefined, undefined, m.space);
+    await stopManager(m.space);
     let pid;
     let controlPlane = false;
     let authService = true;
@@ -2131,8 +2051,9 @@ function applyUpOverrides(prepared, o) {
  *  cotal_spawn find a manager without any setup side effect. Coupled to the broker by the
  *  daemon's watchdog + the `up`/`down` teardown. `mgr` rides through to the manager start — the
  *  `up -f` path hands THE manager its runtime + resolved launch spec here (one manager per space,
- *  so the launch can never be a second supervise). Returns whether the control plane came up, so a
- *  caller whose output claims a manager (the `up -f` launching line) can tell the truth. */
+ *  so the launch can never be a second supervise). Returns the control plane it ensured, or
+ *  `undefined` when it is degraded, so a caller whose output claims a manager (the `up -f` launching
+ *  line) can tell the truth. */
 async function startDeliveryWithBroker(space, server, 
 /**
  * Whether this listener requires TLS, decided by the CALLER.
@@ -2153,11 +2074,6 @@ async function startDeliveryWithBroker(space, server,
 tlsRequired, mgr) {
     try {
         const plane = await ensureControlPlane({ space, server, tls: tlsRequired, ...(mgr ?? {}) });
-        // #883: a refresh that HEALED a missing manager must say so — the summary line otherwise reads
-        // identically to a refresh that found everything already up, and the operator cannot tell which
-        // world they are in without a second command.
-        if (plane.started)
-            console.log(c.green(`✓ restored in the background: manager (pid ${plane.pid})`));
         // #1576: `up` either BINDS the responder or SAYS SO HERE. The delivery daemon is a hard
         // dependency of spawn, retirement and join, and this function used to return `true` for a boot
         // that started a daemon whose responder never bound — so `cotal up` printed its success banner
@@ -2167,16 +2083,101 @@ tlsRequired, mgr) {
         if (plane.responderBound === false)
             console.error(c.yellow(`! delivery responder did not bind before this boot finished - ${RESPONDER_UNBOUND_CONSEQUENCE}`) +
                 c.dim(`\n  The daemon process is running and the wait is open-ended; boot durable joins reconcile by themselves once it binds (agents do NOT need respawning).\n  Watch it with \`${displayCmd()} status --components\`.`));
-        return true;
+        return plane;
     }
     catch (e) {
         // Non-fatal (live messaging is unaffected) — but never SILENT: without the manager,
         // `spawn --detach` / cotal_spawn have no responder, and the operator must hear it here,
         // not as an unexplained "no manager reachable" later.
         console.error(c.dim(`! control plane degraded: ${e.message} - durable delivery/manager may be down; start one with: cotal supervise`));
-        return false;
+        return undefined;
     }
 }
+/**
+ * Everything a launch runs once its listener answers: the space setup, the user-auth service, the
+ * mesh record, the transport commit and the control plane. Foreground `up` and
+ * {@link startMeshDetached} both call it, so the two launch modes cannot drift apart (#2496).
+ *
+ * A fresh boot whose setup throws stops the listener and removes `nats.pid` before rethrowing the
+ * original error. Nothing has recorded the mesh yet, so a listener left running would hold the port
+ * with no registry entry for `cotal down` to reach. A channel seed with an unparseable value fails
+ * here. A resume keeps its listener: its maintenance journal is already bound to it.
+ */
+async function serveReadyListener(l) {
+    const { child, server, space, setup, transport } = l;
+    if (l.resumeAttempt)
+        await recreateMemoryBuckets(server, space, setup);
+    else {
+        try {
+            await postStart(server, space, setup, l.seedFile);
+        }
+        catch (e) {
+            try {
+                child.kill("SIGTERM");
+            }
+            catch { /* already gone */ }
+            try {
+                removePidPair(cotalPath("nats.pid"), String(child.pid));
+            }
+            catch { /* best effort */ }
+            throw e;
+        }
+    }
+    // USER MODE: the auth service comes up FIRST among the daemons — until its callout answers,
+    // every user-mode connect to this broker is denied, so `up` must not report a usable user mesh
+    // (nor let agents race it) on a half-started auth plane.
+    const svc = await startUserAuthService(space, server, setup, l.publicExchange);
+    // Record BEFORE the control plane comes up: the manager's fail-closed mode detection requires
+    // an authoritative registry entry (marker-without-registry is a refused start, not a guess),
+    // so the record must exist by the time it boots. A manager/delivery failure after this leaves
+    // a recorded-but-degraded mesh — the documented, healable posture.
+    // Resolve exposure BEFORE recording. A RESUME of an already-recorded mesh (`down
+    // --preserve-state` then a bare `up`) carries the operator's `--host` only in the registry, and
+    // the record below is written whole, so reading it afterwards would find the field this very call
+    // had just erased.
+    const attachHost = attachHostFor(space, l.host);
+    const maxSessions = maxSessionsFor(space, l.maxSessions);
+    recordOurMesh({
+        space, server, root: cotalRoot(),
+        mode: setup?.prepared ? "user" : setup ? "auth" : "open",
+        // Written ALWAYS, as a boolean, unlike `attachHost` below. Absence and `false` resolve
+        // identically for clients, so an omitted field would be indistinguishable from a deliberate
+        // plaintext mesh — and this is the one field whose whole purpose is that the answer was
+        // stated rather than defaulted.
+        tlsRequired: transport.kind === "tls-required",
+        ...(svc.userAuth ? { userAuth: svc.userAuth } : {}),
+        // Only a real decision is persisted — an explicit `--host` now, or one carried forward from a
+        // previous launch. The bare case stays absent rather than recording the loopback default as
+        // though the operator had chosen it.
+        ...(attachHost ? { attachHost } : {}),
+        ...(maxSessions !== undefined ? { maxSessions } : {}),
+        ...(l.maxFileStore !== undefined ? { maxFileStore: l.maxFileStore } : {}),
+        storeDir: l.storeDir,
+        ts: new Date().toISOString(),
+    }, "started");
+    // Commit the policy only for a listener that is up and recorded (S5), and before the control
+    // plane (S9). startDeliveryWithBroker is HANDED the transport decision, so it does not depend on
+    // the file at all.
+    commitTransportPolicy(cotalRoot(), transport);
+    // The delivery daemon self-gates on `.cotal/auth`, so an open mesh has none. Class-2 credential
+    // renewal is NOT wired here: the MANAGER is the renewal owner (it is resident in every mesh mode,
+    // where a foreground `up` process is not).
+    const controlPlane = await startDeliveryWithBroker(space, server, transport.kind === "tls-required", {
+        onDeliveryExit: l.onDeliveryExit,
+        runtime: l.runtime,
+        launch: l.launch,
+        // The address the broker was bound to. This is what lets `cotal attach` reach this manager
+        // from another machine; without it the attach face stays loopback-only, so exposing terminals
+        // is never a side effect of anything but the operator binding the mesh somewhere reachable.
+        attachHost,
+        maxSessions,
+        noManager: l.noManager,
+        resumeAttempt: l.resumeAttempt,
+        resumeCommitToken: l.resumeCommitToken,
+        wsPort: setup?.wsPort, // P2 item 6: the console session client's broker ws port
+    });
+    return { authService: svc.ok, controlPlane };
+}
 /**
  * Start a background nats-server (JetStream), wait until it's reachable, pre-create the
  * space's streams, and leave it running detached (pid in `.cotal/nats.pid`). Used by
@@ -2267,85 +2268,24 @@ opts) {
     }
     if (opts.boundListener)
         await opts.boundListener.verify();
-    // POST-START MUST NOT LEAVE AN ORPHAN LISTENER.
-    //
-    // Everything above has already bound the port and written `nats.pid`, but NOTHING has recorded the
-    // mesh yet — `recordOurMesh` is below. So a throw between here and there used to exit non-zero
-    // while leaving a live broker holding the port with no registry entry, which `cotal down` cannot
-    // reach because `down` works from the registry. A third state between "started" and "refused",
-    // and the operator's only recourse is to hunt a pid.
-    //
-    // This is reachable BECAUSE of TLS and cannot happen on `main`: the post-start client verifies the
-    // certificate, so a private CA without `NODE_EXTRA_CA_CERTS` fails here — after the listener is up.
-    // The feature introduced the state, so the feature tears it down.
-    //
-    // Deliberately narrow: this is a teardown on the failure path, not a restructuring of the launch
-    // sequence. The listener is stopped and the pid file removed, then the original error is rethrown
-    // unchanged — the operator needs the certificate error, not a message about cleanup.
-    if (!opts.skipPostStart) {
-        try {
-            await postStart(server, space, setup, seedFile);
-        }
-        catch (e) {
-            try {
-                child.kill("SIGTERM");
-            }
-            catch { /* already gone */ }
-            try {
-                removePidPair(cotalPath("nats.pid"), String(child.pid));
-            }
-            catch { /* best effort */ }
-            throw e;
-        }
-    }
-    else {
-        await recreateMemoryBuckets(server, space, setup);
-    }
-    // USER MODE: the auth service comes up FIRST among the daemons (see the foreground path).
-    const svc = await startUserAuthService(space, server, setup, opts.publicExchange);
-    // Record BEFORE the control plane: the manager's fail-closed mode detection needs the
-    // authoritative registry entry at boot (marker-without-registry refuses). Detached: the entry
-    // outlives this process — `cotal down` removes it.
-    // Same capture-before-record as the foreground path: this also runs for a bare `up --detach` that
-    // RESUMES an already-recorded mesh, whose exposure decision exists only in the registry entry the
-    // call below rewrites.
-    const effectiveAttachHost = attachHostFor(space, opts.host);
-    const effectiveMaxSessions = maxSessionsFor(space, opts.maxSessions);
-    recordOurMesh({
-        space, server, root: cotalRoot(),
-        mode: setup?.prepared ? "user" : useAuth ? "auth" : "open",
-        // The detached listener is started from `transport` a few lines above, so this is the same
-        // decision that shaped the config file — not a re-derivation.
-        tlsRequired: transport.kind === "tls-required",
-        ...(svc.userAuth ? { userAuth: svc.userAuth } : {}),
-        // Persist only a real decision — declared now, or carried forward — never the loopback default.
-        ...(effectiveAttachHost ? { attachHost: effectiveAttachHost } : {}),
-        ...(effectiveMaxSessions !== undefined ? { maxSessions: effectiveMaxSessions } : {}),
-        ...(opts.maxFileStore !== undefined ? { maxFileStore: opts.maxFileStore } : {}),
-        storeDir,
-        ts: new Date().toISOString(),
-    }, "started");
-    // Commit policy BEFORE delivery launch (S9). Listener is proved; refuse paths never reach here.
-    // startDeliveryWithBroker is HANDED the transport decision, so it does not depend on the file at all.
-    commitTransportPolicy(cotalRoot(), transport);
-    // Bring up the delivery daemon WITH the detached broker (auth mode only; `cotal down` tears both down).
-    const controlPlane = await startDeliveryWithBroker(space, server, transport.kind === "tls-required", {
+    const { authService, controlPlane } = await serveReadyListener({
+        child, server, space, storeDir, setup, seedFile, transport,
+        host: opts.host,
+        maxSessions: opts.maxSessions,
+        maxFileStore: opts.maxFileStore,
+        publicExchange: opts.publicExchange,
+        resumeAttempt: opts.resumeAttempt,
+        resumeCommitToken: opts.resumeCommitToken,
         runtime: opts.runtime,
         launch: opts.launch,
-        // See the foreground path: the broker's bind address is what makes attach reachable off-box.
-        attachHost: effectiveAttachHost,
-        maxSessions: effectiveMaxSessions,
         noManager: opts.noManager,
-        resumeAttempt: opts.resumeAttempt,
-        resumeCommitToken: opts.resumeCommitToken,
-        wsPort: setup?.wsPort, // P2 item 6: the console session client's broker ws port
     });
     return {
         server,
         pid: child.pid ?? 0,
         source,
-        controlPlane,
-        authService: svc.ok,
+        controlPlane: controlPlane !== undefined,
+        authService,
         delivery: useAuth && deliveryUp(space),
         manager: managerUp(space),
     };