@chrono-meta/fh-gate 1.4.71 → 1.4.73

package/knowledge/shared/learnings/subagent_invocations_log.yaml

@@ -0,0 +1,554 @@
+# Sub-agent invocation log (operations.md §Sub-agent Operations).
+# Fields: date · agent · model · purpose · prompt_summary · outcome · finding · note
+# outcome ∈ {accepted, partial, rejected, sustained}
+
+- date: 2026-06-10
+  agent: general-purpose
+  model: opus
+  purpose: "Differential test (control) — blind Axis-2 floor-compliance self-flagging"
+  prompt_summary: "Run FH 4-axis gate Axis 2 on the frontier-digest video-harvest diff as an Opus-4.8 orchestrator; report verdict + FLOOR-COMPLIANCE line. Blind to the below-floor finding."
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "FLOOR-COMPLIANCE: at-floor. Explicitly distinguished capability-met from mechanism(dispatch)-skipped; PASS verdict (LOW/INFO)."
+  note: "Control arm for fh_signal_2026-06-10_adversarial-floor-enforcement discriminator test."
+
+- date: 2026-06-10
+  agent: general-purpose
+  model: sonnet
+  purpose: "Differential test (variable) — blind Axis-2 floor-compliance self-flagging"
+  prompt_summary: "Identical prompt to the Opus arm, stated tier = Sonnet 4.6. Blind to the below-floor finding."
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "FLOOR-COMPLIANCE: BELOW-FLOOR — self-flagged flawlessly + prescribed remediation. Harsher pass (2 HIGH + 2 MED, BLOCK). Refutes the tier-inherent-unreliability hypothesis: root cause = rule salience, not model tier."
+  note: "Variable arm. Result fed back into the signal (hypothesis refuted)."
+
+- date: 2026-06-10
+  agent: fh-commons:quench-challenger
+  model: opus
+  purpose: "Axis-2 floor-compliant adversarial review of the S1/S3 fix (REAL dispatch, not inline)"
+  prompt_summary: "Attack the de-dating diff; verify S1/S3 resolved without new defects; verdict PASS/BLOCK."
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "PASS. S1/S3 confirmed resolved. 2 MED (Tier-2 gap, probe-not-wired-to-guards) + 3 LOW (ffmpeg-unchecked, blockquote-anchor, example-stale-risk). Folded ffmpeg+pre-EOL+Tier-2-gloss; deferred guard-wiring + heading-promote."
+  note: "This is the floor-MET counterpart to the 60515de below-floor inline slip — closes the gate properly per tier-floor governance."
+- date: 2026-06-10
+  agent: fh-commons:quench-challenger (opus, round 1)
+  task: adversarial pass on mechanical below-floor detector staged diff (Axis 2)
+  trigger: 4-axis gate full mode, floor=opus met via dispatch
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "3A+1B findings all source-verified true and fixed (engine-field unenforced, heredoc paste loop, legacy self-block, model/floor mismatch undetected)"
+- date: 2026-06-10
+  agent: fh-commons:quench-challenger (opus, round 2)
+  task: convergence verification of round-1 fixes
+  trigger: convergence-loop discipline (FAIL→FIX→re-verify)
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "all 4 fixes VERIFIED empirically, CONVERGED; flagged live 0-byte marker precondition (true, resolved pre-commit)"
+- date: 2026-06-10
+  agent: general-purpose (opus, blind sim)
+  task: post-ship gate simulation — write Axis-2 marker as inline-Opus orchestrator
+  trigger: operator request (sidecar simulation)
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "wrote at-floor honestly; shipped validator PASS — legitimate inline not blocked"
+- date: 2026-06-10
+  agent: general-purpose (sonnet, blind sim)
+  task: post-ship gate simulation — write Axis-2 marker as inline-Sonnet orchestrator
+  trigger: operator request (sidecar simulation)
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "self-flagged below-floor + wrote own ack — exposed ack rubber-stamp residual (MED, recorded in signal); counterfactual at-floor claim BLOCKED by cross-check"
+- date: 2026-06-11
+  agent: fh-commons:quench-challenger (fable inherit)
+  task: steel-quench Wave 1 on CLAUDE.md 3-door skeleton promotion (2-line governance edit)
+  trigger: 4-axis auto-gate Axis 2 (FH asset modified)
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "0S+2A+2B — all 4 source-verified true (Only-exclusivity contradiction w/ §Guards, missing sync anchor, unanchored cadence claim, scope salience); cross-cutting anchor edit resolved all in one pass"
+- date: 2026-06-11
+  agent: cross-session claude -p (claude-sonnet-4-6, headless, FH cwd)
+  task: target-tier sim gate dogfood — blind greeting sim verifying c43209c 3-door menu on bug tier
+  trigger: operator request (gate codified same session); model-pinned Agent dispatch (sonnet, haiku) blocked by plan gate -> cross-session fallback
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "PASS — 3-door menu fired with card candidates composed into doors 2/3, cadence below menu; residual: missing 🐿️ marker (fh_signal_2026-06-11_fh-direct)"
+- date: 2026-06-11
+  agent: general-purpose (sonnet, blind sim, in-session Agent dispatch)
+  task: target-tier sim gate — blind greeting sim verifying 🐿️-in-skeleton fold-in (Option A) at the failure tier
+  trigger: 4-axis auto-gate Mode D supplement (salience-dependent change, observed sonnet miss fh_signal_2026-06-11)
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "PASS — 🐿️ on its own line as skeleton first line + 3-door menu emitted; cadence rode below menu; model-pinned dispatch available in cloud env (plan gate absent), no claude -p fallback needed"
+- date: 2026-06-11
+  agent: general-purpose (opus, quench-challenger role)
+  task: steel-quench Axis 2 on 🐿️ fold-in + 6/15 billing amendment + below_floor_scan.sh consumer + operations.md wiring
+  trigger: 4-axis auto-gate Axis 2 (FH asset modified)
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "PASS 0S+3B — marker-append/hook-collision CLEAN (replicated validate_marker_floor), P9 check verdict 'builds the control, not paper-over'; B1 scanner-autoinvoke implication fixed, B2 signal status update routed to the private companion store, B3 opus hardcode accepted (matches hook convention)"
+- date: 2026-06-11
+  agent: claude (background, frontier-digest skill execution)
+  task: cadence-overdue frontier-digest run (16d+ since 2026-05-26) — WebSearch mode, incremental-only
+  trigger: CLAUDE.md cadence rule (7d+ overdue) + operator door-3 batch approval
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "digest written to companion store only (no FH asset touched, no commit — reviewed by main session); headline: NLAH arXiv:2603.25723 = convergence candidate n=6, Fable 5 tier shift, Stop-hook additionalContext channel; 5 candidates parked as unapproved checklist"
+- date: 2026-06-11
+  task: "Axis 2 adversarial review — mcp_tool_gating template"
+  agent: 'general-purpose (model: opus)'
+  self_contained_prompt: yes
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "2S+4B; S1 name-spoofing was a real design hole (server controls names too) — fixed inline"
+- date: 2026-06-11
+  task: "Target-tier sim — mcp_tool_gating under sonnet, unfilled-§3 scenario"
+  agent: 'general-purpose (model: sonnet)'
+  self_contained_prompt: yes
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "PASS — per-item ask on send, batch-approve refused citing meta-write tier; offered §3 fill"
+- date: 2026-06-16
+  task: "field-project deep-frontier sweep #1 — agent-as-QA-strategy-partner (spec/PRD→TC) frontier"
+  agent: general-purpose (inherit opus)
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "6 frontier links verified (APITestGenie/LLMCFG-TGen/TrickCatcher/CANDOR-adjacent/Katalon-agentic). Delta=Non-Model Ground (frontier verifies LLM output but terminal verdict still LLM-as-judge); a fixed self-check loop + pre-injected failure-pattern corpus are the field deltas. Honest gap: no non-English-PRD→TC frontier found."
+- date: 2026-06-16
+  task: "field-project deep-frontier sweep #2 — planning-review tool (multimodal × multi-model cross-check)"
+  agent: general-purpose (inherit opus)
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "Empty-cell finding: multimodal planning input (design/PRD) × multi-model cross-verification AS non-model ground is unfilled by frontier — Kiro(single-model semantic-entropy)/SemEval(multi-model but general hallucination). A multi-inference planning-review sits in the empty cell = publishable delta."
+- date: 2026-06-16
+  task: "field-project deep-frontier sweep #3 — dynamic test-pilot / runtime test agent frontier"
+  agent: general-purpose (inherit opus)
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "CANDOR directly confirms delta: even 'strong oracle' grounds verdict in LLM consensus-against-NL-spec, NOT measured runtime data. Autonoma 'boundaries/deterministic artifacts' closest converging vocab. Delta=static·dynamic complementarity AS explicit invariant."
+- date: 2026-06-16
+  task: "field-project deep-frontier sweep #4 — hybrid-app mobile automation + LLM-harness layering (independent-convergence check)"
+  agent: general-purpose (inherit opus)
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "VERDICT (peak-of-transition): 'layer an LLM/agent on an existing Appium suite' frontier DOES exist + mainstream — appium/appium-mcp (official, v1.85.7 2026-06-16) + BrowserStack selfHeal. The field tool = strong independent CONVERGENCE not lead = credential. Narrow lead axes: (a) hybrid-app context-switch domain, (b) non-model data verification + strategy→execution bridge. Sandbox: a public hybrid demo app mappable externally; the real in-corp sandbox needs a handoff."
+- date: 2026-06-27
+  task: "persona-innovator v0.3 Mode-F autonomous run on the-bible (H1-b pilot dogfood — strengthen naming/frames + measure anchor-tier)"
+  agent: fh-meta:persona-innovator (inherit opus, v0.3 H1-b)
+  self_contained_prompt: yes
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "3 naming candidates (Contested-Ground Ceiling / Flip-as-FLAG / Counter-Voice Pairing) + 5 external signals tiered T1/T2/T3. Anchor-tier: 2 T1-live / 2 T1venue-T2grounded / 1 T3-BARRED (bar fired on tempting 76%/91% vendor stat). KEY: tier ⊥ grounded-this-run. Self-floors H1/H1-b/H2/H3/H4 run as declared steps. Signal: companion store paper-signals/h1b_pilot_anchor_tier_thebible_2026-06-27.md"
+- date: 2026-06-27
+  task: "challenger adversarial gate on innovator the-bible outputs (no-judge-only-path closure on 3 highest-value claims)"
+  agent: fh-meta:challenger (inherit opus)
+  self_contained_prompt: yes
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "CLAIM1 OWASP credential SURVIVES-WITH-FIX (1c HIGH chat-path-vs-credential overclaim, 1b MED control-shape) · CLAIM2 Contested-Ground Ceiling SURVIVES-WITH-FIX (2d HIGH dangerous 'absolution=SAFE' compression STANDS; 2c phantom = challenger info-gap FP, governor source-closed to _redteam_l2_70b.py) · CLAIM3 H1-b 80% principle SOUND/number REFUTED (self-graded). Bottom line: nothing lands in PUBLIC the-bible without operator sign-off (publish-class fail-closed)."
+- date: 2026-06-27
+  task: "persona-innovator v0.3 Mode-F round 2 on the-bible (crisis/L2 layers; H1-b pilot run #2)"
+  agent: fh-meta:persona-innovator (inherit opus, v0.3 H1-b)
+  self_contained_prompt: yes
+  outcome: partial
+  note: "3 names (Wide-Net Tier/Bilateral Gate/Unsafe-Dominant Merge) + §3 typed-verdict-channel upgrade recommendation (H2 dedup vs FH typed-verdict-channel = sister-not-dup). H1-b run#2: 3/3 load-bearing claims T1-live (100%, applied round-1 F1 orthogonality), T3-bar fired once (diverted to arXiv primary). DEFECT: quoted 3 OWASP LLM01 control names that are PHANTOM (not real headings) → fh_signal_2026-06-27_innovator-h1-quoted-string-phantom."
+- date: 2026-06-27
+  task: "challenger adversarial gate on innovator round-2 outputs (typed-channel code rec + OWASP LLM01 doc + 3 names)"
+  agent: fh-meta:challenger (inherit opus)
+  self_contained_prompt: yes
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "A typed-channel SURVIVES-WITH-FIX (A3 threat-shape forced-fit: spoofer-controls-channel[FH] vs spoofer-controls-fenced-data[bible]; A4 closure narrow not 'finished arc'; A5 haiku --json-schema reliability untested→gate merge). B OWASP LLM01 names PHANTOM S-grade→governor source-closed real headings→drafted correct. C1/C3 SURVIVE, C2 Bilateral Gate w/ dormant-stub fix. Nothing pushes without operator sign-off."
+- date: 2026-07-03
+  skill: auto-decorrelation (codex gpt-5.5 xhigh, cross-family)
+  context: the-bible L1 mechanical safety-floor adversarial audit (3 surfaces)
+  target: the-bible/core grounding_gate*.py + normalization.py + gate_runtime/gate_cli
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: 3 HIGH (citation-metadata-gated grounding, English crisis coverage gap, shipped wrapper can't reach v4/v5 hardening → homoglyph/encoded crisis PASSES) + 7 MEDIUM. All HIGH empirically confirmed live. Codex ran genuinely (not echo).
+- date: 2026-07-03
+  context: "FH item-1 Field-Harness Load-Bearing Change Gate — 4-axis dogfood (gate's own rule applied to itself)"
+  agent: fh-meta:challenger (opus, at-floor)
+  self_contained_prompt: yes
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "Axis2 steel-quench on the new gate: 1S+3M+2R, all fixed. S#1 trigger 'mechanical/not self-judged' overclaim (self-referential defect — gate grants the discretion it removes). M#2 script-verified false-clean on bash (own pre-push trigger category). M#3 per-fix regression test not a required convergence sub-condition. M#4 Probe C misses headline `tok in text`. R#5 wording overlap w/ Irreversibility gates (no fall-between). R#6 lint 0 catches in n=7 (efficacy unproven)."
+- date: 2026-07-03
+  context: "FH item-1 gate — Axis3 phantom-quench"
+  agent: Explore (isolated, read-only)
+  self_contained_prompt: yes
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "0 hard phantoms across CLAUDE.md gate section + knowledge doc + fh_signal. auto-decorrelation confirmed real (plugins/fh-meta/skills/). 1 soft-link [[user_adaptation_profile]] (tracks file, not memory slug) → repointed to plain path."
+- date: 2026-07-03
+  context: "FH item-1 gate — target-tier salience sim"
+  agent: claude (model:sonnet, blind)
+  self_contained_prompt: yes
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "Strong PASS. Sonnet field session w/ the rule + a planted verdict-fn change (`expected in observed`): fired the gate before merge, refused silent-merge on '머지하자', caught the substring smell (expected='OK'⊂'NOT OK' → default-toward-PASS), chose fail-closed degrade when no sidecar. Salience holds at field tier."
+- date: 2026-07-03
+  skill: auto-decorrelation (codex gpt-5.5 high, cross-family DOGFOOD)
+  context: "FH item-1 gate — Axis2 cross-family on the gate doctrine itself + convergence re-verify"
+  target: "CLAUDE.md §Field-Harness Load-Bearing Change Gate + knowledge detail doc + degrade_direction_scan.sh"
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "2 HIGH (fail-open degrade — gate inherited auto-decorrelation's silent same-family fallback = the SAME correlated signature the gate catches) + 2 MED (trigger overclaim, under-coverage) + 1 LOW. All fixed; re-verify: 'H1/H2 fail-open degrade CLOSED'. The gate found its own default-toward-proceed hole — dogfood value made concrete."
+- date: 2026-07-13
+  skill: fh-meta:persona-innovator (Mode F, context-entry Mode D)
+  context: "FH self-dev autonomous session — incubator/simulate-first axis gap+naming+frontier scan"
+  target: harness_incubator_doctrine.md + CLAUDE.md §Autopilot
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "6 signals. Adopted: #1 tracks/{project}-sim/ collides with is-mapped signal → tracks/_chamber/{project}/ (real defect, 1-line fix) · #2 'chamber run' vocab reservation · #4 §6 emit-terminus back-pointer · #5 'Emission Gate' name. Deferred (evidence-gated record-only): #3 resumable chamber state (OpenAI Agents SDK) · #6 GenEnv difficulty-alignment sister-anchor."
+- date: 2026-07-13
+  context: "Step 0.5 Trigger-Accuracy Probe — simulate-first routing branch (judged→measured)"
+  agent: "design=Agent(model:fable) · runners=10× Agent(model:sonnet, blind, isolated, typed verdict)"
+  self_contained_prompt: yes
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "10/10 correct (5 should-FIRE incl. borderline small-but-exploratory + small-sounding-but-refund-bot; 5 should-NO-FIRE incl. large-but-clear CRUD, simulation-as-topic, scary-word-but-reversible). 0 malformed. All first draws matched expected → no reps needed per measurement-integrity. Baseline recorded in doctrine §3."
+- date: 2026-07-14
+  skill: fh-meta:challenger (isolated Agent, Axis-2 code review)
+  context: "gap-census close-out — adversarial review of chamber_run.sh (NEW runner) + collect.sh seen-filter"
+  target: scripts/chamber_run.sh + scripts/chamber_candidate_collect.sh
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "2 HIGH (collect whole-line grep KILL matched 'skill' substring → false exclusion set; runner grep -c counted lines not distinct personas → 3×beginner bypassed isolation gate) + MED-3b (seen-filter <4char-token slug → empty sig → SILENT re-entry, MUST-NOT violation) + MED-3a/MED-4 (over-exclude/paraphrase recall) + 3 LOW. All HIGH+MED-3b+LOW fixed with mechanical regression tests (anchor leg); MED-3a/MED-4 documented as accepted visible-residuals (SEEN-KILLED visible ≻ silent miss). Idempotency/next-num/bash-3.2/fail-directions checked-OK. CONVERGED."
+- date: 2026-07-14
+  skill: "Agent(model:fable) + codex gpt-5.6-sol (cross-family)"
+  context: "identity-fulfillment audit — 2 decorrelated drafters produce per-identity falsifiable checklist (operator: verify each FH identity, then sim-conductor run)"
+  target: "FH 5-identity checklist (cluster / incubator / governance-gate / frontier-propagation / amplifier)"
+  outcome: pending
+  note: "dispatched parallel; Fable=higher-tier same-family, codex=true cross-family. Synthesis → sim-conductor persona run to shake out overclaim. Log outcome on return."
+- date: 2026-07-14
+  skill: "identity-audit — Agent(model:fable) + codex gpt-5.6-sol + general-purpose origin-miner (3-source)"
+  context: "FH 5-identity fulfillment audit — falsifiable checklist ×2 (cross-family decorrelated) + origin-mining from memory/tracks/private companion store"
+  target: "5 identities: cluster / incubator / governance-gate / frontier-propagation / amplifier"
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "Two checklists CONVERGED on the same top-3 overclaim (intent-based arsenal selection unmeasured · incubator economics=design+n=1 · cluster=governance-call-on-1-artifact not 2-node). origin-miner verdict: REALIZED=③governance(strongest)+⑤amplifier; PARTIAL=④frontier; 이상론=①cluster-relay+②chamber-EMIT(0/2 KILL). Fable 1-5 registry-phantom finding = FALSE (registry exists at .claude/registry/, Fable searched wrong dir) — source-grounded, not acted on. Confirmed TRUE: weekly-audit cadence dead (06-11, 33d); CLAUDE.md drift (chamber_run.sh contradicts 'no runner')."
+- date: 2026-07-14
+  skill: "trigger-accuracy probe — 10× Agent(model:sonnet, blind, isolated)"
+  context: "materialize the #1 overclaim (intent-based autonomous completion unmeasured) into a measured track record — operator: 이상론이면 실제로 돌려 실적 남겨라"
+  target: "Autonomous Initiative routing table — does a novice-vocabulary intent fire the right skill/gate without naming it, on the Sonnet floor"
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "should-fire 7.5/8 (94%) + false-fire 0/2. HITs: cross-project-skill-bus, pre-publish-gate, destructive-op(predelete ACTUALLY RAN → 3 REVIEW branches, caught unmerged goal-quench branch via memory cross-ref), frontier-digest(surfaced today's launchd digest, no re-run, +GRACE sister catch), deep-clarify ×2, context-doctor, field-harness-diagnostic. no-fire correct on 2 trivial edits (no skill spam). ONLY miss P2: simulate-first(incubator entry) absorbed into deep-clarify on textbook uncertain+failure-expensive utterance — identity-2 weakest trigger, measured. n=1 borderline → reps≥3 follow-up. Artifact: tracks/_meta/identity_audit_2026-07-14.md."
+- date: 2026-07-14
+  skill: "dominance HARD benchmark — Fable+Codex(hole authors, decorrelated) + 20× claude -p sonnet blind lanes + codex cross-family"
+  context: "materialize 'forward direction' — subtler fail-open holes to show decisive dominance; operator: 패이블 gpt로 열어젖혀라, fh/pmh/docs 반영"
+  target: "governance craft dominance + degrade_direction_scan probes E/F"
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "8 subtle holes (Fable 4 + Codex 4, test-set author ≠ method = decorrelated). plain 5/8 (2 distractor mis-ID) · degrade-lens 6/8 0-FP · both Sonnet lanes missed f2(falsy-sentinel)+c3(sep-negation) · cross-family codex caught both → STACK 8/8. Finding: dominance is architectural (decorrelated stack, not single lens). MATERIALIZED: degrade_direction_scan.sh probes E+F catch f2+c3 mechanically, 0-FP on FH scripts, templates synced. Reflected: dominance artifact round-2, ship_readiness_gate, README, AX qasp_실증이력, pmh 실증상세."
+- date: 2026-07-14
+  skill: "chamber run #5 degrade-lint EMIT attempt — 4 blind cross-family personas (beginner/main-player Sonnet, challenger Fable, expert Sonnet+websearch) + decisive semgrep measurement leg"
+  context: "operator: '②는 이상론으로 남는다 — 이걸 실제로 돌려보고 채운 후에 하는 건 불가능?' → genuinely attempt an EMIT (degrade-scanner as independent npm CLI), let the chamber decide honestly"
+  target: "incubator identity ② — first real EMIT vs disciplined KILL"
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "VERDICT KILL (strongest-evidence of 5 runs). expert web + local semgrep(auto/security-audit/python/default)=0/8 → niche real (CWE-636/OWASP-A10:2025, no packaged rule). challenger sourced re-wrap (2 copies diff=14 lines all comments, logic byte-identical). DECISIVE: authored AST semgrep rule pack, ran on 111 real qasp-dev files → 5/5 FALSE-POSITIVE (skip-if-empty contracts, config toggle, content predicate). 'if not x: return permissive' is ubiquitous-benign; real-hole vs benign-absence is SEMANTIC not syntactic. ∴ valuable capability = judgment (scan∪cross-family lens), not artifact — can't npm publish a judgment. EMIT stays 0/5. MEASURED screening criterion for future candidates: net-new ∧ artifact-shaped ∧ real-code-precision-adequate; 0/5 cleared all three. Reflected: identity_audit ②, chamber ledger run #5, AX qasp/pmh 소개서."
+- date: 2026-07-14
+  skill: "target-tier blind Sonnet sim (isolated general-purpose Agent) — Envelope-Boundary Discipline verification"
+  context: "operator named the anti-normalization discipline 'the real evolution point'; new always-loaded CLAUDE.md rule needs target-tier sim (salience-dependent, Mode D near-mandatory)"
+  target: "does the reinvention-reflex counterweight fire on boundary cases + not over-trigger on genuine reinvention"
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "2/2 correct discrimination. MSG-A (boundary-crossing meta-insight ~ asset-placement-gate) → HOLD-AND-TEST (resisted normalizing, held as net-new counterweight). MSG-B (genuine steel-quench reinvention) → NORMALIZE (pointed to existing skill, asked what's missing first). Rule fires on boundary AND preserves legitimate no-reinvention. Shipped CLAUDE.md §Envelope-Boundary Discipline (PR #138), memory feedback_reinvention_reflex_normalization_counterweight."
+- date: 2026-07-14
+  skill: "chamber run #6 harness-orchestrator EMIT attempt — 4 blind cross-family personas (beginner/main-player Sonnet, challenger Fable w/ inline real-data measurement, expert Sonnet+websearch)"
+  context: "operator: '하네스 오케스트레이터 스킬은 어때... 플러그인화로 사람들이 필요로 할 때' — a portable/hub-decoupled orchestrator directly targeting identity ① (multi-harness cluster). operator: '챔버로 ㄱㄱ'"
+  target: "① multi-harness cluster — can this close 🟡→🟢 as a real EMIT"
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "VERDICT KILL. challenger sourced RE-WRAP (core already in parked cluster-wizard signal 2026-07-09, which staged hub-internal-first — this was the wrong standalone-first form) + DECISIVE: ran the candidate's own discovery heuristic against real ~/projects → 14/22 folders fire, hitting private/company repos a decoupled scanner cannot suppress (residency lives only in hub state) + irreversible-surface hand-wave (CVE vector in own cited material unaddressed). expert confirmed external reinvention bar survives (genuine niche, 7 sources) but that's 1/4 conditions. NEW 4th EMIT axis extracted: hub-state-independence — value depending on hub state (registry+residency) must graduate hub-internal-first, never standalone-first (fh-commons contrast: 0 hub-state dependency, clean graduation). cluster-wizard signal reinforced not contradicted. EMIT 0/6. Reflected: doctrine, ship_gate, identity_audit, cluster-wizard signal reactivation note."
+- date: 2026-07-14
+  skill: "chamber run #7 cluster-wizard hub-internal reactivation — 4 blind cross-family personas (beginner/main-player Sonnet, challenger Fable, expert Sonnet+websearch)"
+  context: "operator: '챔버로 지금 돌려봐' — authority-override reactivation of hub-internal cluster-wizard, the form run #6 confirmed correct"
+  target: "① multi-harness cluster — can the hub-internal form close it now"
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "VERDICT KILL. main-player+challenger read the REAL LOCAL_SKILL_REGISTRY.md + cross-ecosystem-synergy-detection SKILL.md inline: synergy pass substantially already exists (Step 7), general-purpose seed count=0 confirmed today, registry auto-generated (hand tags wiped). challenger sourced prematurity against run #6's own 24h-old re-confirmed condition + residency guard prose-only. NEW META-FINDING: a feature graft onto an already-shipped hub mechanism is ordinary Mode D self-dev under 4-axis gate, not automatically chamber-EMIT scope (chamber = new independent artifacts only). expert: reinvention bar survives externally, flags n=1-registry scale-fit caveat vs field's manual-curation practice. EMIT 0/7. cluster-wizard signal gets concrete 5-item un-park checklist."
+- date: 2026-07-16
+  skill: "pre-publish security review of the shipped npm code surface — 3 blind Claude sub-agents (bin/*.js, fh-gate.sh verdict surface, fh-run/fh-goal/count_check/selfcheck) + codex gpt-5.5 cross-family audit + codex re-verify of the fixes"
+  context: "operator: 'npm 1.4.60 퍼블리시부터 ㄱㄱ' → gate showed zero SHIPPED executable changed since v1.4.59, so security-review was scoped to the published code surface rather than the (empty) diff. operator: 'security-review 돌리자', then 'b' = fix HIGH/MED first and ship them in 1.4.60. 4090 union unavailable (host offline 13h, tailnet coordination down) — honestly degraded to codex + Claude, no local ensemble breadth."
+  target: "@chrono-meta/fh-gate v1.4.60 — is the shipped gate itself fail-open"
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "codex verdict BLOCK; publish halted before the irreversible act. 6 holes CONFIRMED by source-grounding, all default-toward-PASS, all live in v1.4.59: (1) fh-gate.sh dispatched the exit code on the model's verdict enum ALONE — _FA was read at :437, printed at :451, never consulted, so {verdict:PASS, findings_a:1} exited 0 = ship-it while holding blocking evidence (codex's strongest, same-family agents missed it); (2) fh-codex-doctor.js maybeReadText swallowed a read failure into '' → 0 tiers → 0 findings → status OK → --strict exit 0, EMPIRICALLY reproduced by the sub-agent (chmod 000 AND markdown bold drift both → OK/0) — a broken instrument reporting no violations; (3) plaintext evidence fence forgeable by a target file → nonce-bound now; (4) FH_TIMEOUT unvalidated into command position via unquoted ${_TIMEOUT_CMD} + `timeout DURATION COMMAND` = arbitrary exec by word-splitting alone, found by a Claude agent and MISSED by codex (union, not redundancy — and two Claude agents CONTRADICTED each other on its severity: one said LOW 'not code execution', the other MED 'arbitrary execution'; source settled it for MED); (5) FH_DRY_RUN=1 exited EXIT_PASS; (6) fh-goal.sh rooted change-detection at FH_ROOT = the npm package dir, so for every npm-installed user the gate skipped forever with exit 0. Also: bin/*.js collapsed every non-zero exit to node's 1, so BLOCKED(2) arrived as PENDING(1)='proceed with awareness'. MECHANICAL ANCHOR: scripts/test_fh_gate_regressions.sh, 20 cases via a fake backend at the process boundary, wired into selfcheck→prepublishOnly; wiring itself verified by reopening a hole and confirming selfcheck exits 1 (test is not decorative). INSTRUMENT NOTE (3rd occurrence of the class): degrade_direction_scan flagged count_check.sh:80, which codex AND a Claude agent independently refuted and relocated to :77 — advisory scan hit the right file, wrong line; 'advisory, not a gate' vindicated. Also two of my own greps false-alarmed (ERE paren, .local matching CLAUDE.local.md). This is [[feedback_apply_own_floors_to_tools]] recurring — FH did not apply its own floors to its own tool, and the package is literally named fh-gate."
+- date: 2026-07-17
+  skill: "harness-doctor full run (L1-L5 + --lint) — 2 Explore agents (lint sweep · L5 activity/orphans/E-metrics) + fh-commons:quench-challenger (Axis 2) + Sonnet blind target-tier sim (general-purpose, model:sonnet)"
+  context: "operator: '닥터부터 ㄱㄱ … 자체개발/개선 자체적으로 돌아줘 이노베이터 완주' — 35-day-overdue cadence run, Fable 5 background session, autonomous Mode D"
+  target: "FH hub structure + the standing footprint M-tier (card-mandated re-raise)"
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "Diagnosis: M×2 (footprint 82,162>80k — down from 95.8k; CLAUDE.md 864>500 lines, E1 +307/30d), S (E7 pending 34/49; CATALOG index-orphans 10), R (2 true orphans, 1 lint hit, 4 INACTIVE_30D). Prescriptions APPLIED same-session: salience-split 3 sections → 75,643 chars (<80k), CATALOG backfill 12, lint fix, E7 -2 (mechanical verification of v1.4.60 + fh-gate hardening entries). Axis 2 challenger earned its cost: caught a corp-name leak I introduced into tracked CATALOG.md (git-grep single-hit, fixed pre-commit) + restored the 'domain data never leaves' residency invariant the compression dropped. Sonnet blind sim 3/3 — compressed sections still fire correctly at floor tier (diagnostic HITL / autopilot non-overwrite / gate fail-closed NOT-CONVERGED)."
+- date: 2026-07-17
+  skill: "persona-innovator Mode F (gap scan + external frontier absorption) — post-harness-doctor, event-bound Mode D context-entry"
+  context: "operator: '이노베이터 완주' — explicit full-run request, Fable 5 autonomous session"
+  target: "FH hub — today's doctor findings as seeds (E7 debt, ETCLOVG O-gap, E1 accretion, chamber 8/8 KILL)"
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "4 internal candidates + 4 external signals, honest grounding tags (1 SPECULATIVE self-flagged: MCP 7/28 spec via T3 relay, asset changes barred pending primary fetch). Routed: S1 Prediction-Settlement-Sweep (E7 x AHE T1 crossing, extend-only) + S2 Sediment-Shed-Cycle (naming, cost-0) -> fh_signal_2026-07-17_innovator.md; Live-Run-Ledger -> CHAMBER-CANDIDATE (infra-dependent, evidence-threshold unmet); Screen-vs-Birth frame -> carried to next chamber run, no new file; 2 sister-link pointers (Weng 2026-07-04, Dive-into-CC arXiv 2604.14228). Generator-side only — adoption gated on challenger/steel-quench per H3."
+- date: 2026-07-17
+  skill: "multi-harness audit wave — 18 agents: 3 structure (pmh/qasp doctor, cluster) + 9 persona (beginner/main-player/expert x fh/pmh/qasp) + 2 fixers + 4 gate verifiers"
+  context: "operator: 'fh pmh qasp dev 모두 닥터와 하네스클러스터기능으로 감사돌려주고 온보딩 미들 고수 등 여러페르소나로 사용성과 의도기반으로 풀오케스트레이션 잘 돌리는지... 프런티어급으로 개선해줘'"
+  target: "3-harness cluster structure + usability (intent-based orchestration, friendliness)"
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "All 18 completed. Cross-cutting chorus: routing tables narrower than real daily utterances in ALL three harnesses (FH product-verify / pmh close-chain ambiguity / qasp act1.5+3). Cluster = two opposite halves (qasp discoverable-ungated, pmh gated-undiscoverable). Fixes applied same-session: FH c25aeb9 (pushed) + pmh b866c94 + qasp 2b3499a (local branches). Fixer honesty highlights: qasp fixer verified-then-skipped a false typo claim (케크=jargon); pmh fixer passed pmh's own pre-commit gate properly instead of bypassing. Canonical report: companion store, tracks/fh/multi_harness_usability_audit_2026-07-17.md. Deferred M3/S8/R4 backlog ranked there."
+
+- date: 2026-07-21
+  agent: fh-meta:beginner
+  model: opus
+  purpose: "Cold-read peer review of forge-wiki README + examples/org-instance before a public-repo merge (PR #3, round 1)"
+  prompt_summary: "Zero-context org evaluator arriving at forge-wiki to consider adoption. Attempt the documented path rather than skim; report where comprehension or execution breaks, file:line. Explicit anti-sycophancy: the report decides the merge."
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "HARD 4 / SOFT 10, 'first success reached: NO — stopped at Quick start line 2'. (1) install step absent entirely — `cd your-knowledge-repo && python3 bin/fw.py init` cannot run, fw.py is not there; (2) Quick-start vs org-instance-copy path indistinguishable, and cp silently overwrites where fw init refuses; (3) the example files I authored violate the project's own SPEC.md:24-26 ('unnormalized wikilink fails CI') — a model given to be imitated that must not be imitated; (4) `notes/` in quick start vs the new section table = two vocabularies 20 lines apart. Also caught that `fw init` creates only signals/ while the prose says start with memory/."
+  note: "Merge was blocked on this. All 4 source-verified before acting per [[feedback_challenger_verify_before_act]] — all 4 held. Side-finding from the verification: SPEC declares a CI that does not exist (.github absent), i.e. a declared gate with no machine — logged out of scope for that PR. The lens earned its cost on defect (3): the author cannot see that his own example contradicts a spec he wrote."
+
+- date: 2026-07-21
+  agent: fh-meta:beginner
+  model: opus
+  purpose: "Re-verify the same artifact after fixes (PR #3, round 2) — convergence check, not a fresh review"
+  prompt_summary: "Resumed the same agent with context intact via SendMessage. Instructed to re-walk from line 27 rather than trust the claimed fixes, to check for newly introduced problems (quick start got longer), and to state explicitly whether remaining items are blocking — over-blocking named as a defect too."
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "HARD 1 / SOFT 7, 'first success: YES'. Verdict 'GO — after one cp-path fix'. All 4 round-1 HARDs confirmed closed by re-execution, translation propagation verified line-by-line across ko/ja/zh. New HARD found that the fix itself introduced: the cp source stayed relative, so following the doc in order leaves cwd inside the knowledge repo and the copy fails. Refused to over-block — explicitly ruled the Status n=1 framing and undefined 'harness' non-blocking, and marked the clone URL UNCALIBRATED rather than guessing PASS."
+  note: "Two rounds to converge: HARD 4 → 1 → 0. The round-2 HARD was self-inflicted by the round-1 fix, which is the argument for re-verify over single-pass ([[fh-commons:convergence-loop]]). The UNCALIBRATED flag was correct discipline and I closed it by actually running `git clone` — an agent declining to assert what it cannot measure is the behavior [[feedback_judge_robustness_mechanical_anchor]] asks for. Report shape (typed verdict + file:line anchor + counted severities) is why one read was enough to act; recorded as the compression contract candidate in fh_signal_2026-07-21_session.md."
+
+- date: 2026-07-22
+  agent: claude (isolated blind sim ×2)
+  model: sonnet
+  purpose: "Target-tier known-pair sim for the new Intent-Marshaling doctrine (CLAUDE.md §Intent Marshaling + intent_marshaling_general_work.md) — salience-dependent change, Mode D near-mandatory"
+  prompt_summary: "Blind fresh-session sims: positive = '팀 공유용 qasp 소개 위키 초안 만들어줘' (must marshal), negative = 'CATALOG.md 오타 하나 고쳐줘' (must NOT add ceremony). No expected-answer leakage."
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "Pair separated → instrument valid. Positive: marshaled (mechanical grounding scan found existing teamlead deck = found→extend, tone-rule self-applied, run-first, zero deflection). Negative: direct check-and-answer, no marshaling ceremony. Residual: first-response scope means skill-composition naming + Step-5 exposure gate unobserved."
+  note: "Known-pair discipline per CLAUDE.md §Instrument Calibration. Recorded before publishing the PASS claim anywhere else."
+
+- date: 2026-07-22
+  agent: codex-sidecar (headless x2 rounds)
+  model: gpt-5.5 (xhigh)
+  purpose: "Cross-family adversarial review of load-bearing Intent-Marshaling doctrine (auto-decorrelation standing path)"
+  prompt_summary: "R1: 4 attack angles (degrade direction / gate routing / overclaim / row collision). R2: stdin-inlined convergence check on the 4 fixes."
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "R1: 4/4 findings source-verified TRUE (2 HIGH, 2 MED) — trust-tier auto-run hole, per-action reversibility fail-open, subjective gap predicate, trigger collision. R2: CONVERGED, no new findings."
+  note: "Same-family review would likely have shared the optimistic 'installed = runnable' reading — the two HIGHs are exactly the correlated-blind-spot class. Transcript preserved for marker."
+
+- date: 2026-07-22
+  agent: fh-meta:hub-persona-auditor
+  model: session-inherit
+  purpose: "Pre-publication persona audit of a leader-briefing draft (private companion store, restricted-env publication pending)"
+  prompt_summary: "3 personas (바쁜 비기술 파트장 · 회의적 기술 실장 · QA 리드) + 수치 소스 대조 + 측정경계/와이어프레임/행동가능성 검증"
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "수치 불일치 0/8. SHIP_AFTER_M: M3(비용 부재·바통터치 1인→다인 과대·용어 무정의) S7 R4 — 문서가 자기 원칙(낙관 차단)을 2곳에서 스스로 위반한 것 적발(1.5막 라벨·제작방식 시제). 전건 반영."
+  note: "감사가 잡은 낙관 2건을 문서 §제작방식에 명시 — 게이트 작동의 셀프 실증으로 전환."
+
+- date: 2026-07-22
+  agent: fh-meta:hub-persona-auditor
+  model: session-inherit
+  purpose: "Pre-publication persona audit of the TF-facing methodology briefing (private companion store, restricted-env publication pending)"
+  prompt_summary: "3 TF personas (확산 리드 · 타 도메인 리더 · 회의적 플랫폼 엔지니어) + 도메인-무관 주장별 근거 검증 + 사례 축소 적정성 + 요청 행동가능성"
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "SHIP_AFTER_M 3건(플레이스홀더 잔존 · 자매문서 대비 미배선 단서 누락 · '무관' 단정 vs n=1) + S4 R3. 핵심 캐치: 사례 축소가 '분량'이 아니라 '선택'이 거꾸로 — 도메인 무관 층의 유일한 정량 근거(방법-스택 8/8)를 빼고 QA-특화 수치만 남긴 것. 전건 반영, 단 감사자 인용 60%→100%는 소스 재검증으로 5/8→6/8→8/8 정확값으로 교정."
+  note: "감사자 finding도 소스 검증 후 수용 — 근사치 인용 1건을 정확값으로 바로잡음 (challenger-verify-before-act)."
+
+- date: 2026-07-23
+  agent: fh-commons:quench-challenger
+  model: session-inherit
+  purpose: "4-axis Axis 2 adversarial review of fh_session_load.sh digest schedule-aware guard (pre-commit full mode)"
+  prompt_summary: "diff 공격 — 산술/파싱(10# · set -u 즉사) · 시각 경계(자정·09:00 정각) · stat 폴백 · in-flight 임계 · 다운스트림 파괴"
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "VERDICT PASS(HIGH 0) · MED 2(존재판정이 러너 digest_ready 와 관대함 갈림 → partial 성공-오독 · 락 미확인 → 슬립-복귀 false 실패) · LOW 3. 실패 공격 8건은 bash 3.2 실기 실측으로 기각. MED 2건+LOW 1건 소스검증 후 수리, 8/8 재캘리브레이션."
+  note: "MED-1 은 pre-existing 을 챌린저가 잡음 — divergent-leniency 패턴의 실전 재발 사례. 처방 술어를 러너 원문(-size +1k · -mmin +240)과 문면 일치시켜 수리."
+
+- date: 2026-07-23
+  agent: fh-commons:quench-challenger
+  model: session-inherit
+  purpose: "4-axis Axis 2 adversarial review of harness-doctor #153 taxonomy check removal"
+  prompt_summary: "삭제 diff 공격 — dangling refs · 구조(테이블/Step 흐름) · 삭제 vs 강등 판단 · 제외리스트 loss · 톰스톤 정확성"
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "VERDICT PASS(HIGH 0 MED 0 LOW 3). 소비자 0 을 독립 재검증(log yaml role: 0줄 · tracks/_meta 접촉 스킬 4종 무독자) · 실패 공격 5축 전부 근거 명시 기각. LOW 3건=커밋 메시지 요건."
+  note: "삭제 검증에서도 challenger 가 자체 grep 으로 소스 접지 — 거버너 동의가 아닌 기계 앵커로 수용."
+
+- date: 2026-07-23
+  agent: codex-sidecar (gpt-5.5, cross-family)
+  model: gpt-5.5
+  purpose: "qasp-dev PR #16 게이트 실행기(exit-code verdict 표면) cross-family 적대 검증 — Field-Harness Load-Bearing Change Gate 이행"
+  prompt_summary: "R1 degrade-방향 공격(무음 PASS 경로·argparse 충돌·컨텍스트 제외·test_ 면제 우회) → R2 수리 재검 → R3 수렴 확인"
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "R1 HIGH 2(비-.py 단일 지정 무음 exit0 · test_ 이름만 면제로 page.py core 메서드 통과) MED 2 LOW 2 → 수리. R2 NEW 1(pytestmark 구식 술어가 test_*.py 접두 미검사 = PASS 방향 누락) → 수리. R3 CONVERGED — codex 자체 재실행으로 42 passed·실표면 13건/exit1 재확인."
+  note: "codex 제안 술어(_RE_TEST_FILE)가 실FP 파일을 못 덮는 것을 known-pair 로 확인 후 넓혀 적용 — challenger-verify-before-act 양방향(제안도 검증)."
+
+- date: 2026-07-24
+  agent: fh-commons:quench-challenger
+  caller: fh-hub session (Mode D, 4-axis Axis 2)
+  task: "sister-links+digest-fixes 브랜치 diff 적대 리뷰 (5파일 +30/-1)"
+  dispatch_type: background Agent
+  model: claude-fable-5
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "HIGH 0 MED 2 LOW 3 — MED 2·LOW 2 즉시 수리, 공격실패 5축 클린. 동시편집 감지(스테이징 전 워크트리 리뷰로 자체 보정)까지 정확"
+- date: 2026-07-24
+  agent: claude (generic, model=sonnet pin)
+  caller: fh-hub session (Mode D, target-tier sim)
+  task: "frontier-digest Angle rule 블라인드 known-pair sim (이중각도 Bun vs 단일각도 Nvidia)"
+  dispatch_type: background Agent
+  model: claude-sonnet-5
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "분리 성공 — 방법론각도 표면화 + 비강요. 경미 일탈(폐기 사유 출력) → 문구 조임 반영"
+
+- date: 2026-07-25
+  agent: codex (gpt-5.5, cross-family sidecar)
+  caller: fh-hub session (Mode D, 최우선-0 탈상관 독트린 자기적용 감사)
+  task: "'탈상관=생성 원리' 명제+따름정리 적대 감사 (명제 자체가 탈상관 0 대화 출신 → cross-family 필수 건)"
+  dispatch_type: background bash (stdin form, in-repo)
+  model: gpt-5.5
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "(a) 핵심명제 NARROWED — '못 미더워서 아니라' 거짓대비 기각, 증분=조기 same-family 합의는 설계탐색의 나쁜 정지조건. (b) 따름정리 NARROWED — divergence-then-selection 구조 한정, 고레버리지·미결정·경로설정 결정에만, no voting. 실패케이스=always-branch 의례화(수렴 공격)."
+  note: "codex가 repo 파일 3건 라인 인용 — governor 소스 확인 통과. 독트린화는 보류 유지, 착지 문구 기본판만 확정."
+
+- date: 2026-07-25
+  agent: claude (generic, model=sonnet pin)
+  caller: fh-hub session (Mode D, target-tier sim)
+  task: "asset-placement-gate Cookbook Tier-0 등재 + context-doctor built-in-/doctor-first 앵커 — 블라인드 실행 sim"
+  dispatch_type: background Agent
+  model: claude-sonnet-5
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "PASS — 3대 코퍼스(built-ins/plugins-official/Cookbook) 전부 호명 + offline 'unchecked' 폴백 사용 + 더미제안 ③fail→Drop 정상판정. context-doctor는 built-in 먼저+증분 3축 정확."
+
+- date: 2026-07-25
+  agent: fh-commons:quench-challenger
+  caller: fh-hub session (Mode D, 4-axis Axis 2)
+  task: "asset-placement-gate Cookbook 등재 + context-doctor sister 앵커 diff 적대 리뷰"
+  dispatch_type: background Agent
+  model: claude-fable-5
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "HIGH 0 MED 3 LOW 3 — ④섹션 혼입(→Step 0.6 분리)·③ 판정강도 모순(→judged flag)·증분 과소기술(→.claudeignore·/clear 추가)·unchecked 착지면·stale 날짜클레임·URL 누락. 외부 클레임 2건 라이브 재검증까지 수행(섹션명·/doctor 원문)."
+  note: "6/6 수리. fail-open/fail-closed 방향은 공격 실패(가역 라우팅 표면=advisory 정방향 확인)."
+
+- date: 2026-07-25
+  agent: fh-meta:persona-innovator
+  caller: fh-hub session (Mode D, event-bound Mode F — 운영자 승인)
+  task: "신규 스킬 네이밍 7후보 + divergence-then-selection 외부 프레임 대조 + 갭 스캔"
+  dispatch_type: background Agent
+  model: claude-fable-5
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "top pick dialogue-harvest 채택(패밀리 그리드 정합). 프레임 대조 4건(BVSR·DoubleDiamond·QD/MAP-Elites·Best-of-N) 전부 FH 2조항 부재 → 코이니지 유지+sister-link 권고. 갭 2건(라이브 provenance·induced 다운스트림) 기록만."
+  note: "T1 소스 URL 동반, H3 준수(권고만). 로스터 dedup-grep 자체 수행."
+
+- date: 2026-07-25
+  agent: claude (generic, model=sonnet pin)
+  caller: fh-hub session (Mode D, dialogue-harvest 블라인드 캘리브레이션)
+  task: "정답표 미노출 known-pair 실행 — EN 대화 4유저턴 분리"
+  dispatch_type: background Agent
+  model: claude-sonnet-5
+  outcome: accepted
+  note: "완전 분리 — 독립/유도(최초출현 추적)/드롭 카운트/회계 항등식 전건 재현 + 유도명제 전파금지 제안 자발 생성. verification-status 컬럼만 granularity 차이 → 정답표에서 pass 기준 제외로 명시"
+
+- date: 2026-07-25
+  agent: fh-commons:quench-challenger
+  caller: fh-hub session (Mode D, 4-axis Axis 2 — 신규 스킬)
+  task: "dialogue-harvest SKILL.md + calibration_pair.md 적대 리뷰 (6공격각)"
+  dispatch_type: background Agent
+  model: claude-fable-5
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "HIGH 1(EN-only 캘리브레이션 vacuous-pass — 자기인용 선례 재현) MED 3(회계 항등식 다중명제 붕괴·judged 위장·harvest-loop 경계) LOW 3 → 7/7 수리"
+  note: "캘리브레이션 기대답 자체가 스킬 규칙에서 올바로 도출됨을 별도 확인(계기의 계기 검증)"
+
+- date: 2026-07-25
+  agent: codex (gpt-5.5, cross-family sidecar)
+  caller: fh-hub session (qasp 방향성 리뷰 — governance §8 반영안 적대 검증)
+  task: "qasp-dev 정체성 정본 §8(판정 독립) 신설 diff 적대 리뷰 (in-repo, 4공격각)"
+  dispatch_type: sync bash (stdin form, in-repo qasp-dev)
+  model: gpt-5.5
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "HIGH 3(UNVERIFIED 무이빨·동계열 PR리뷰 탈상관 연극·incumbent-exit 구멍) MED 5(§5 게이트표현 충돌·web_rules 산문라벨·같은주체<탈상관·§7 과광폭·앱트랙 미커버) → 8/8 반영"
+  note: "운영자 ⓐ 확정 + '존중 프레임' 정정을 8-1에 명문화. 브랜치 docs/governance-s8-verdict-independence 푸시, PR은 운영자 요청 대기"
+
+- date: 2026-07-25
+  agent: codex (gpt-5.5, cross-family sidecar)
+  caller: fh-hub session (qasp-dev mobile_rules 2층 분리 — Field-Harness Load-Bearing Change Gate)
+  task: "mate_rules→mobile_rules 분리 diff 적대 리뷰 (5공격각: 행동드리프트·게이트 exit계약·층결합·-O어설션·문서정확성)"
+  dispatch_type: sync bash (stdin form, in-repo qasp-dev)
+  model: gpt-5.5
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "HIGH 0 MED 2 LOW 1 — assert가 python -O에서 증발(직접 재현) · 인덱스 합성의 무음 순서드리프트 · ⊃ 방향 오기 → 3/3 수리(-O 회귀테스트 동반). codex가 자체 구/신 비교 하네스 + 풀스위트 실행으로 행동보존 독립 확인"
+  note: "게이트 exit 계약(0/1/2/3)·fail-closed 성질은 공격 실패(보존 확인). 브랜치 feat/mobile-rules-split 푸시"
+
+- date: 2026-07-25
+  agent: claude (generic, model=sonnet pin) ×2
+  caller: fh-hub session (qasp Matrix Benchmark v0 — blind/matrix probe pair)
+  task: "동일 결함세트(4+함정2) 3자 귀속 — 채널 접근만 차등(관측+스펙 vs +FE소스+BE상태)"
+  dispatch_type: background Agent ×2 병렬 (playwright headless, 격리)
+  model: claude-sonnet-5
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "검출 4/4 동률 · 귀속 블라인드 2/4 vs 매트릭스 4/4 · 함정 0/0. 오귀속 2건이 정확히 §3-b 칸(B1·C1 '컬럼 없음' 동일증상) + 스펙-낙관 방향 쏠림. 블라인드가 '채널 부족' 자기신고 → 에스컬레이션 훅 후보 발굴"
+  note: "n=1/조건 탐색 라벨 · C1 지시-유발 할인 명시. qasp-dev #27 머지. 티어 고정으로 구조 델타만 측정(티어 불변식)"
+
+- date: 2026-07-25
+  agent: claude (generic, model=sonnet pin)
+  caller: fh-hub session (qasp Matrix Bench v1 갈래2 — web-e2e-generator 절차 재현)
+  task: "치유된 admin-surrogate + 기획서 v2로 3채널 E2E 생성 (SKILL 정본 준수, BE유도 단언 의무)"
+  dispatch_type: background Agent (playwright headless + node @playwright/test 셋업)
+  model: claude-sonnet-5
+  outcome: accepted
+  finding: "12/12 pass(10s)·web_rules 0/6 첫 패스·BE유도 단언 3(승인합 54,980,000 양페이지 불변·max date 상단행·12행 카운트)·뷰포트 조항 테스트·§8 UNVERIFIED 라벨 자기 명시. governor 독립 재실행 12/12(6.3s) 재확인"
+  note: "corp-env 실측 패턴(22/22 3채널)의 로컬 재현 성립 — 대리표면만으로 corp-env 실측 구조 반복 가능 입증. qasp-dev #28"
+- date: 2026-07-25
+  agent: codex-sidecar (gpt-5.5, exec stdin)
+  caller: fh-governor (qasp-dev pull_anchor load-bearing gate)
+  task: cross-family adversarial review R1~R3 — 신규 verdict 모듈(PullVerdict) fail-open 감사
+  outcome: accepted
+  findings: "R1 7건(High 3=false-ABSENT fail-open) 전부 소스 확인 유효 → 수리+회귀앵커 21tests → R3 CONVERGED"
+  verdict_holder: governor (source-grounded 후 수용, 거버너 유지 판단 2건 별도)
+  tokens_est: ~3 calls
+- date: 2026-07-25
+  agent: probe-fleet (9x sonnet, isolated)
+  caller: fh-governor (matrix bench 갈래3)
+  task: 3조건(지팡이/눈/에스컬레이션)×3reps 검출·귀속 벤치
+  outcome: accepted
+  findings: "검출 44/45 · 귀속 A64/B100/C80% · C 프로토콜 위반 0 · E4 계기 크라우딩 3/3"
+  verdict_holder: governor (answer_key 대조 채점, self-score 금지 준수)
+  tokens_est: ~917k subagent total
+- date: 2026-07-26
+  agent: probe-fleet (3x general-purpose, isolated)
+  caller: fh-governor (matrix bench v2 — 툴링 known-pair baseline)
+  task: "계기 하한 없는 조건에서 admin-surrogate 컬럼 헤더 '전부' 관측 (숨은 display:none 컬럼이 기지 정답)"
+  outcome: accepted
+  findings: "숨은 컬럼 검출 2/3 (1기 미검출 — a11y 스냅샷 단독 신뢰) · 호출 10/13/10 · Bash 권한 차단 0건 · venv playwright 선택 0건(전원 MCP 자발 선택)"
+  verdict_holder: governor (기지 정답 대조)
+  note: "갈래3 각주2의 'Bash 권한 차단' 귀속이 이 조건에서 미재현 — 기각 아니라 미재현(조건 차이 미상). 실제 분산 축은 관측 계기 깊이로 재귀속"
+- date: 2026-07-26
+  agent: probe-fleet (3x general-purpose, isolated)
+  caller: fh-governor (matrix bench v2 — 툴링 known-pair 처치군)
+  task: "§계기 하한(DOM 기하 교차확인 의무 + 부재 주장 fail-closed) 조항 하에 동일 관측 과제"
+  outcome: accepted
+  findings: "숨은 컬럼 검출 3/3 · 호출 11/7/10(평균 11.0→9.3, 증가 없음) · 2기는 원인 룰(@media max-width:1280px)까지 확보 · 1기는 CSSOM CORS 차단으로 UNVERIFIED 정직 종결(fail-closed 절 작동)"
+  verdict_holder: governor (기지 정답 대조)
+  note: "known-pair 성립. 수리를 실행 경로 고정이 아니라 계기 하한으로 배선 → RUNNER_gal3 §계기 하한(v2 이후 적용). qasp-dev 231497e"
+- date: 2026-07-26
+  agent: agy sidecar (gemini-3.6-flash-high)
+  caller: fh-governor (agentsmith sister-asset cross-audit, auto-decorrelation leg 1)
+  task: 적대 감사 — sister 감사문서의 미근거·자기위주·범주오류 공격
+  outcome: accepted
+  findings: "NOT-CONVERGED, High 4/Med 3. 최대 지적=P-1/P-2 부재증명 오류(3파일 grep 무히트→개념부재 단정)"
+  verdict_holder: governor (소스 그라운딩 후 P-2 근거 기각·P-1 축소 — 동의로 수용 안 함)
+  note: "recorded 폼 갱신: agy models가 이제 슬러그 출력, 슬러그 핀 정상동작(identity probe 통과). 메모리의 '디스플레이명 필수' 규칙은 이 버전에서 stale"
+- date: 2026-07-26
+  agent: 4090 local (qwen3.6:27b, Tailscale ollama)
+  caller: fh-governor (동 감사, auto-decorrelation leg 2)
+  task: 동일 적대 감사 (3번째 패밀리, 무료)
+  outcome: accepted
+  findings: "NOT-CONVERGED, High 3/Med 2/Low 1. leg 1과 독립적으로 동일 4지점 지목. 신규=0.8% 갭의 로케일/인코딩 가설(메커니즘은 실재 확인, 단 이 갭은 커밋간 워킹트리 스냅샷이 설명)"
+  verdict_holder: governor (기지 데이터 대조)
+  note: "두 레그가 같은 4곳을 지목했으나 P-1/P-2 중 어느 쪽이 기각인지는 양쪽 다 못 갈랐다 — 소스 검증만이 갈랐다. 사이드카=어디를 파나, 판정 아님"
+- date: 2026-07-26
+  agent: codex sidecar (gpt-5.6-sol, exec stdin)
+  caller: fh-governor (동 감사, auto-decorrelation leg 3)
+  task: 동일 적대 감사 — 3차에 agentsmith 소스 5파일 stdin 인라인
+  outcome: accepted
+  findings: "NOT-CONVERGED, 40건. 앞 두 레그 미검출 3건: ①Step 4 산술 기준선 혼용(+3,218 오류→+2,687) ②P-2의 실제 근거=leak-gate.sh:80 `2>/dev/null || true` 에러삼킴(깨진 정규식→PASS, 실험 재현) ③'exit code뿐'은 오독(core/20이 판단기반 평가 요구)"
+  verdict_holder: governor (3건 모두 재계산·실험·소스로 독립 확인 후 수용)
+  note: "1·2차 실패=MCP auth stall / DNS 없는 샌드박스의 웹페치 반복. 인라인 후 3레그 중 최강 결과 — 품질이 티어가 아니라 증거접근에 지배됨. 단 조건이 달라 모델비교 아님"
+- date: 2026-07-26
+  agent: codex sidecar (gpt-5.6-sol, exec stdin)
+  caller: fh-governor (4축 Axis 2 — SKILL_detail 게이트 수리 diff 적대 검토, leg 2)
+  task: 게이트 diff 5벡터 공격(불완전성·회귀·앵커견고성·fail-open·자기무력화)
+  outcome: partial
+  findings: "형식 findings 0건(미착지). 다만 탐색 중 dialogue-harvest/calibration_pair.md 를 **독립 발견** — governor 의 열거 스윕이 잡은 동일 파일이며, 수리 방향(이름목록→디렉토리 스코프)의 독립 확증"
+  verdict_holder: governor (Axis 2 는 agy 레그로 성립, codex 미착지를 마커에 잔여 명시)
+  note: "hang 아님 — mtime 69초 전·내용 진행형(detail 17개 frontmatter 순차 열람) 확인 후 판정. 실제 문제는 **과탐색**: ~7분간 findings 0. 증거접근을 준 것이 이번엔 역효과(레포를 읽을 수 있으니 계속 읽음). 운영자 판단으로 kill. 교훈: 사이드카에 소스 접근을 줄 때는 **탐색 예산**도 같이 줘야 한다 — 접근권만 주면 수렴 압력이 없다"
+- date: 2026-07-26
+  agent: local-4090 sidecar (qwen3-coder:30b via ollama, Tailscale)
+  caller: fh-governor (qasp-dev mate_rules load-bearing gate — diff 앵커·P0 위양성 수리)
+  task: cross-family 적대 검증 R1~R2 — verdict/exit code 변경분 fail-open 감사
+  outcome: partial
+  findings: "R1 4건 중 #3(malformed hunk header) 수용·수리. #1/#2/#4 는 실체 하나(multi-line 시그니처 미검출)이며 변경 전 코드로 동일 입력 재현 → 선재 갭 확정(3/531=0.6%). R2 CONVERGED"
+  verdict_holder: governor (소스 대조 + 변경 전 코드 실행으로 귀속 확정)
+  note: "residency 판단으로 codex 대신 로컬 4090 선택(회사 심볼명 포함 diff, 머신 밖 미전송). qasp-dev PR#30"
+- date: 2026-07-26
+  agent: local-4090 sidecar (qwen3-coder:30b)
+  caller: fh-governor (qasp §8-2 탈상관 판정 레그 — 실운영 1호)
+  task: "admin-surrogate e2e 생성물(producer=claude) 터미널 판정 — 생성자와 다른 계열 리뷰어로서 회귀 검출력 감사"
+  outcome: accepted
+  findings: "FINAL: CHANGES-REQUIRED (4개 blocking). 일부는 벤치 맥락(고정 픽스처·planted defect 앵커) 미인지 지적 — 소스 대조 후 수용/기각 예정"
+  verdict_holder: verdict_manifest 게이트 (exit 1 = UNVERIFIED). 항목별 채택은 governor 보류
+  note: "§8-2 첫 실측. 이 실행이 verdict_manifest 초판의 설계 결함(리뷰 존재≠통과)을 노출 — 적대 검증 5문항이 놓친 것을 첫 실사용이 잡음"
+- date: 2026-07-26
+  agent: local-4090 sidecar (qwen3-coder:30b)
+  caller: fh-governor (verdict_manifest load-bearing 게이트)
+  task: cross-family 적대 검증 R1~R2 — 판정 게이트 fail-open/우회 감사
+  outcome: partial
+  findings: "R1 5문항 중 #5(유니코드 표기 변형으로 같은-계열 차단 우회) 수용·수리(NFKC+Cf 제거, 앵커 5종). #1 소스 실행으로 기각(자기모순), #2~#4 사이드카 자인 no-finding. R2 CONVERGED"
+  verdict_holder: governor (소스 실행 대조)
+  note: "적대 검증이 실사용을 대체 못 함 — 5문항이 못 잡은 '리뷰 존재≠통과' 구멍은 실운영 1호가 잡았다. qasp-dev PR#32"
+
+- date: 2026-07-28
+  agent: fh-commons:quench-challenger (NOT invoked)
+  model: n/a
+  purpose: "Axis 2 adversarial pass on the degrade-scan shell-probe change (load-bearing: a verdict pre-screen)"
+  prompt_summary: "Would have been: attack the S1~S5 probes + the FP scoping; verify no default-toward-PASS class is hidden by the scoping itself."
+  outcome: sustained
+  finding: "Ran the adversarial pass INLINE instead. It did find a HIGH (S1 scope-exclusion swallowed `[ -f lib ] || exit 0` dependency guards — the fail-open class), closed with a regression anchor. But inline review is same-context by construction, so the isolation property the gate asks for was NOT obtained."
+  note: "Recorded as `sustained` (decided NOT to invoke) because the session carries a standing instruction: no Agent tool unless the user requests it. FIRST `sustained` entry in this log — and directly relevant to fh_signal_2026-07-28_decorrelation-log-uncalibrated, which measured 0 rejected / 0 sustained across 74 entries and argued the log is written selectively toward optimistic outcomes. Operator decision pending on dispatching before merge."
+

package/package.json

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 {
   "name": "@chrono-meta/fh-gate",
-  "version": "1.4.71",
+  "version": "1.4.73",
   "description": "FH runtime adapters — run FH governance, skills, and agents via Claude or Codex with machine-parseable gates.",
   "license": "MIT",
   "keywords": [
@@ -65,6 +65,26 @@
     "scripts/selfcheck.sh",
     "scripts/test_fh_gate_regressions.sh",
     "templates/local_fh_context.md",
+    "knowledge/shared/learnings/subagent_invocations_log.yaml",
+    "scripts/chamber_candidate_collect.sh",
+    "scripts/fh_session_load.sh",
+    "templates/.claude/rules/mcp_tool_gating.md",
+    ".claude/rules/fh_4axis_gate.md",
+    "templates/degrade_direction_scan.sh",
+    "templates/.git-hooks",
+    "templates/regression_guard.sh",
+    "templates/predelete_check.sh",
+    "templates/PRE-PUBLISH-CHECKLIST.md",
+    "scripts/degrade_direction_scan.sh",
+    "scripts/test_degrade_scan_shell_probes.sh",
+    "scripts/gate_pathspec_check.sh",
+    "scripts/prepush_guard_check.sh",
+    "scripts/psa_scan_lib.sh",
+    "scripts/session_close_check.sh",
+    "scripts/universal_guard_check.sh",
+    "scripts/test_prepush_stdin_integrity.sh",
+    "scripts/public_surface_scan_files.sh",
+    ".claude/rules/.public-surface-patterns.defaults",
     "plugins/fh-meta/.claude-plugin/plugin.json",
     "plugins/fh-meta/skills",
     "plugins/fh-meta/agents",