@chrono-meta/fh-gate 1.1.0 → 1.2.0

package/plugins/fh-meta/skills/sim-conductor/SKILL.md

@@ -0,0 +1,364 @@
+---
+name: sim-conductor
+description: Autonomously runs external user reaction simulations, internal audits, ideation scans, artifact validation, and quality reviews. Profiles the target artifact first, then derives task-appropriate personas, dispatches them as parallel agents, classifies findings into M/S/R tiers, and completes the pipeline through to commit automatically.
+user-invocable: true
+allowed-tools: ["Read", "Write", "Bash", "Grep", "Glob", "Agent"]
+model: opus
+---
+
+# sim-conductor — Meta-Simulation Automation Orchestrator
+
+> Profiles target → derives personas → dispatches parallel agents → M/S/R triage → commit.
+> Personas are sourced installed-first → built-in fallback → external install. Scale: 3 to 16 by task complexity.
+
+## Invocation Triggers
+
+| Trigger pattern | Suggested Area |
+|---|---|
+| "Look at this from an external user's perspective", "How would someone else see this?" | Area A |
+| "Check the harness", "asset audit", "internal audit" | Area B |
+| "Any new ideas?", "ideation scan", "naming candidates" | Area C |
+| "Review this code" (pre-PR), "review this prompt" | Area D (code) |
+| "Check if the session card is correct", "does the skill actually work", "memory cold-start validation" | Area D (consumer) |
+| "Is the output good?", "artifact quality review" | Area E |
+
+Proposal format: `"If it's related to [X], should I simulate with /sim-conductor [Area]?"`
+
+### Natural Language Triggers
+
+| Example utterance | Intent | Mapped Area |
+|---|---|---|
+| "Validate our system virtually" | Full system simulation | Area B |
+| "Test it with personas", "Run an external user simulation" | External user reaction | Area A |
+| "Look at it through someone else's eyes" | External perspective | Area A |
+| "Validate that this actually works" | Real-usage validation | Area D |
+| "Find problems aggressively" | Adversarial validation | Area B (devil persona) |
+
+## Triggers
+
+```
+/sim-conductor                        # default: Area C auto-run
+/sim-conductor A                      # external user simulation
+/sim-conductor B                      # internal meta audit
+/sim-conductor C                      # Innovator scan
+/sim-conductor all                    # full A + B + C
+/sim-conductor A --target <path>      # specific asset target
+/sim-conductor D --target <file>      # code/prompt multi-persona review (pre-PR)
+/sim-conductor D session [--target]   # session card cold-start validation
+/sim-conductor D skill <name>         # skill trigger utterance consumer simulation
+/sim-conductor D memory <file>        # memory file cold-start validation
+/sim-conductor E --target <file>      # artifact quality review (post-pipeline)
+```
+
+**Frequency limits**: Area A after asset changes or manual trigger · Area B max once/week · Area C/D/E no limit.
+
+---
+
+## Step 0 — Environment Sync
+
+Auto-detect harness root, sync sim clone if present, set `$REPORT_DIR`.
+
+> **Detail**: See `SKILL_detail.md §Step0-Bash` — harness root detection, sim clone sync, report dir creation — read when executing Step 0.
+
+**Area B frequency check**: Previous Area B report within 7 days → stop + report date. No file found → treat as first run.
+
+---
+
+## Step 0.3 — Target Profile Analysis
+
+> **Schema**: `knowledge/shared/harness-core/tpa_schema.md` — canonical field definitions, artifact type table, gate routing. Use §Profile Output Format for output block.
+
+Runs when Area is unspecified, or when target file is provided before Area selection.
+**Skip** if user provides a complete directive (e.g. `/sim-conductor A --target <file>`).
+
+Read target artifact(s) → classify on 5 dimensions → output recommendation → user confirms or overrides:
+
+| Dimension | Signal → Weight shift |
+|---|---|
+| `artifact_type` | SKILL.md / design-doc → Area B + D-skill↑ · README / CHEATSHEET → Area A↑ · code / config → Area D-code↑ |
+| `audience` | external installer / first-time user → newcomer↑ · internal team only → devil↑ |
+| `claim_density` | 3+ stated benefits or superlatives → devil-advocate↑ |
+| `risk_level` | external publish / marketplace listing → steel-quench prerequisite triggered |
+| `novelty` | first-of-its-kind / no prior session evidence → source-grounding-audit recommended |
+
+```
+Target Profile output:
+  artifact_type: [type]
+  audience: [internal | external | mixed]
+  claim_density: [low | medium | high] ([N] stated claims)
+  risk_level: [low | medium | high]
+
+Recommendation:
+  Areas: [list + rationale]
+  Persona composition: [list + weight]
+  Scale: [Minimum 3 | Extended 4–8 | Full ≤16]
+  Prerequisites: [steel-quench / source-grounding-audit / none]
+```
+
+#### Persona Discovery (after profile → before dispatch)
+
+After profiling, sim-conductor determines the needed perspective types, then maps each to the best available agent:
+
+```
+For each needed perspective:
+  ① Scan installed plugins + .claude/agents/ → exact match? → use it
+  ② Built-in fallback palette → approximate match? → inject as prompt directive
+  ③ GAP: no ①② match for a high-weight perspective
+       → query /plugin-recommender: "find agents for [perspective] matching [artifact_type] context"
+       → present: name · install command · estimated fit · token cost
+       → user chooses: install now / skip / substitute with ②
+```
+
+Persona Discovery output:
+
+```
+Persona Map:
+  newcomer       → [installed agent name] OR [built-in fallback]
+  devil-advocate → [installed agent name] OR [built-in fallback]
+  [profile-specific role] → ⚠️ GAP — plugin-recommender recommends: [X] (install? y/n)
+```
+
+Gaps on **high-weight personas** (from profile) block dispatch until resolved. Gaps on low-weight personas → auto-fill with built-in fallback, no block.
+
+**Degraded coverage rule**: When user skips a high-weight gap (substitutes with built-in fallback), flag in the Step 3 report under "Persona composition used" as `⚠️ degraded: [perspective]`. Do not silently proceed. Degraded coverage on risk_level=high targets → additionally warn before dispatch.
+
+Overriding a prerequisite recommendation requires explicit "skip [prerequisite]" utterance.
+
+> **Detail**: See `SKILL_detail.md §PersonaDiscovery` — plugin-recommender query format, gap resolution decision tree, persona map examples for each artifact type — read when running Persona Discovery.
+
+> **Detail**: See `SKILL_detail.md §Profile-Examples` — worked profiles for SKILL.md, README, bash script, design doc — read when result is ambiguous or to calibrate weights.
+
+---
+
+## Step 0.5 — Precondition Validation
+
+Proactively surface 1 concern, then confirm whether to proceed. Skip if no concern.
+
+| Check | Concern trigger condition |
+|---|---|
+| Area B frequency guard | Previous run within 7 days + S-tier unresolved |
+| Unresolved M-tier | New simulation without processing previous M-tier |
+| steel-quench not run | Area A in external publish context → **mandatory gate: Area A does not proceed until steel-quench completes** |
+| Self-recursive path | sim-conductor attempting to auto-PR its own M-tier |
+| Goal-method alignment | Requested Area doesn't match actual problem |
+| D/E --target missing | Area D(code)/E runs without --target file |
+| D session target not found | Session start card file not found → confirm path |
+| E execution timing error | Area E before pipeline run (no artifact yet) |
+
+Concern format: `"One thing to check before [Area X]: [concern]. Proceed?"`
+
+---
+
+## Step 1 — Area-Specific Simulation
+
+### Area A — External User Perspective
+
+Target: skill descriptions, README, CHEATSHEET entry points.
+
+#### Task-Adaptive Persona Selection
+
+sim-conductor does **not** run a fixed persona set. It derives needed perspectives from the task, then sources each persona in priority order:
+
+```
+① Installed first — scan installed plugins + .claude/agents/ for a matching persona/agent
+② Built-in fallback — inject role as prompt directive into general-purpose Agent (Path B)
+③ External fetch — chain to /plugin-recommender when ①② insufficient for high-stakes tasks
+```
+
+Built-in fallback palette (② tier):
+
+| Role | Perspective | Focus |
+|---|---|---|
+| Newcomer | First-time user, zero development context | Clarity, terminology, onboarding friction |
+| Power-user | Advanced user, edge cases | Undocumented behavior, limits |
+| Devil-advocate | Adversarial critic | Claim-evidence gaps, naming-substance mismatch |
+| Domain-expert | Adjacent-field subject matter expert | Technical accuracy, completeness |
+| Skeptic | Pragmatic outsider | ROI, "why not just X?" |
+
+Derive task-specific personas (e.g. "security auditor", "non-native reader") when the task profile demands it.
+
+#### Scale
+
+| Scale | Count | When |
+|---|---|---|
+| **Minimum** | 3 | Routine Area A — most task-relevant 3 perspectives |
+| **Extended** | 4–8 | High-stakes publish / external release |
+| **Full** | Up to 16 parallel | Pre-major-version / architecture review |
+
+All personas run as **parallel Agents** — no sequential bottleneck. Use agent-composer Medium/Large fan-out for Extended/Full.
+
+**Simplification guard**: Routine internal audits → ② built-in fallback at Minimum scale. Chain to ③ only when a needed perspective has no ①② match, or stakes are high.
+
+#### Multi-Team Mode (when external CLIs available)
+
+When 1+ external CLIs detected, Area A upgrades to Multi-Team Panel: each CLI forms an independent team. Cross-team: 2+ teams flag same issue → tier-up (S→S-confirmed). External-only findings → "Claude blind spot" flag.
+
+Pre-entry user confirmation required before multi-team execution.
+
+> **Detail**: See `SKILL_detail.md §MultiTeam` — team formation table (T0–T4), CLI detection bash, confirmation dialog, cross-team synthesis format — read when multi-team mode activates.
+
+**A-1** (Newcomer Agent) — description friendliness · onboarding friction · terminology clarity
+**A-2** (Power-user Agent) — install conflicts · duplication · silent overwrite
+**A-3** (challenger Agent, artifact_type="SKILL") — claim-evidence gaps · angles U3, U5, S2
+
+> ⚠️ **Human review gate**: Area A S-tier judgments require owner review before entering AI-AI loop.
+
+---
+
+### Area B — Internal Meta Audit
+
+Target: all fh-meta assets (skills + agents + plugin.json).
+
+> **Self-recursive caution**: When M-tier found in sim-conductor itself → report only, delegate to user.
+
+**Dispatch pattern**: hub-persona-auditor ∥ persona-innovator (parallel) → challenger (after, with both outputs as context)
+
+1. **hub-persona-auditor** — README/CHEATSHEET as external briefing, 4-axis review, 3-tier suggestions
+2. **persona-innovator** (Mode I) — naming gaps + structural gaps + 3-5 candidates
+3. **challenger** (artifact_type="SKILL") — receives 1+2 outputs, angles U2, D3, U5 — "what was missed?"
+
+Rationale: 1+2 run without influencing each other; challenger synthesizes both perspectives independently, avoiding Cost of Consensus.
+
+> **Detail**: See `SKILL_detail.md §AreaB-Baseline` — external baseline injection methods, dual-validation principle, Area B → steel-quench handoff — read when setting up Area B defenses.
+
+> ⚠️ **Human review gate**: Area B convergence is provisional until owner confirms.
+
+---
+
+### Area C — Innovator Scan
+
+Runs independently. Skip if included in Area B.
+
+**persona-innovator** (Mode F = Internal + External): current harness gaps + frontier scan. Output: naming candidates + absorption signals + top 1 priority action.
+
+---
+
+### Area D — Artifact Validity Validation
+
+| Mode | Trigger | Core question |
+|---|---|---|
+| **code** | `/sim-conductor D --target <file>` | Is the code/prompt well-built? |
+| **consumer** | `/sim-conductor D session/skill/memory` | Does the artifact work for the intended consumer? |
+
+#### D-code — Profile-Aware Persona Routing
+
+Persona composition adapts to `artifact_type` from Step 0.3 profile:
+
+| Artifact type | Primary persona | Supporting persona | Focus |
+|---|---|---|---|
+| SKILL.md / design doc | challenger (artifact_type="SKILL") | Newcomer | Governance gaps, behavioral rule coverage |
+| Python / JS / bash code | challenger (artifact_type="Code") | Power-user | Edge cases, performance, security surface |
+| Prompt / config | Newcomer | challenger | Interpretation errors, implicit assumptions |
+| Auth / security-sensitive | challenger + Security-auditor† | Power-user | Attack surface, privilege escalation |
+
+† Security-auditor = built-in fallback role (② tier) injected as prompt directive.
+
+All personas run in parallel. Findings = M/S/R → M-tier items fixed immediately.
+
+#### D-consumer — Artifact Consumer Simulation
+
+Consumer agent attempts actual use (not just reads and judges). Grades: F (functional) / P (partial → S-tier) / B (broken → M-tier immediate fix).
+
+> **Detail**: See `SKILL_detail.md §AreaD-Consumer` — D-session 4 questions, D-skill cold-start procedure, D-memory check items, verdict criteria — read when executing D-consumer.
+
+---
+
+### Area E — Artifact Quality Review
+
+Domain-expert objection (E-1) + Practitioner confusion (E-2) in parallel → Pattern structuring (E-3) integrates both.
+
+> **Detail**: See `SKILL_detail.md §AreaE-Detail` — E-1/E-2/E-3 execution, finding format, pattern naming procedure — read when executing Area E.
+
+---
+
+## Step 2 — Synthesis
+
+| Tier | Criteria | Action |
+|---|---|---|
+| **M (Mandatory)** | Blocks external user entry / naming-substance mismatch / security/trust damage | Immediate fix required |
+| **S (Strong)** | Feature degradation / found by 3+ personas | Address within next session |
+| **R (Recommended)** | Improvement value / found by single persona | Backlog |
+
+**Deduplication**: Multiple personas → same location: M > S > R.
+
+**Early Convergence Detection**: 2+ Areas independently classify same item as M-tier → immediate fix, remaining Areas continue for S/R coverage only.
+
+---
+
+## Step 3 — Report
+
+File: `$REPORT_DIR/sim_YYYY_MM_DD_area_[X].md`
+
+> **Detail**: See `SKILL_detail.md §Report-Format` — full report template with frontmatter, M/S/R sections, emerging asset candidates — read when writing the report.
+
+---
+
+## Step 4 — PR or Direct Commit
+
+1+ M-tier → fix immediately → commit. PR creation requires explicit user request.
+0 M-tier → commit report only + report S/R backlog.
+
+> **Detail**: See `SKILL_detail.md §PR-Bash` — branch creation bash, commit + push, gh pr create template — read when creating a PR.
+
+---
+
+## Human Gate Principle
+
+Convergence within an AI-AI loop is **provisional**. Elevated to final only after human gate.
+
+| Stage | Human gate condition |
+|---|---|
+| Area A S-tier | User reviews + says "convergence approved" |
+| Area B convergence | AI-AI loop is provisional → elevated after user confirmation |
+| M-tier auto-fix | Commit after fix (no PR gate); PR requires explicit user request |
+| Three-Doctor Loop end | User reviews convergence and decides next action |
+
+---
+
+## Done When
+
+| Condition | Verdict |
+|---|---|
+| `sim-conductor [Area X] complete` format output | ✅ Simulation complete |
+| 1+ M-tier → fixed + committed (or "none") | ✅ Prescription complete |
+| Report `tracks/_meta/sim_YYYY_MM_DD_*.md` saved | ✅ Persistence complete |
+| 0 M-tier → report committed + S/R backlog reported | ✅ Health check complete |
+
+Verdicts: PASS · CONDITIONAL_PASS (S/R only, or Area B cadence skip) · FAIL (M-tier unresolved) · ESCALATE (persona conflict requiring human judgment).
+
+**Mandatory for Area A (external publish)**: steel-quench must complete in same session before Area A is marked complete.
+
+---
+
+## Simplification Guard
+
+- Area B 2+ times in one week: check whether previous S-tier resolved first
+- New simulation without processing M-tier: warn about unresolved M-tier
+- Add new persona: require 1+ empirical cases not captured by current palette
+
+---
+
+## Operations Notes
+
+**AI-AI Loop Bias Defense**: sim-conductor → hub-cc-pr-reviewer → sim-conductor loop shares LLM cognitive blind spots. Internal convergence is "provisional convergence" — elevated only by external review or human gate. Area A/B convergence without human gate = incomplete.
+
+---
+
+## Three-Doctor Loop Integration
+
+harness-doctor (structure) · context-doctor (context) · sim-conductor (future behavior) form a closed loop.
+
+| Situation | Next skill |
+|---|---|
+| Structural problem in simulation results | `/harness-doctor` |
+| Token waste pattern | `/context-doctor` |
+| All three mentioned simultaneously | Three-Doctor Loop: diagnosis→prescription→re-diagnosis cycle |
+| Area A before external publish | `/steel-quench` **required** first — mandatory gate |
+
+---
+
+## Path B (External Environment)
+
+When `~/sim/` absent: fallback to harness root, logical isolation only.
+
+> **Detail**: See `SKILL_detail.md §PathB-Detail` — git fallback, logical isolation prompt directive, Area restriction rules — read when running in external/restricted environment.