@c4a/context 0.6.18 → 0.7.0

package/docs/reference/indexer-provider-protocol.md

@@ -0,0 +1,819 @@
+# Indexer Provider protocol
+
+Context defines one Provider manifest, `context-indexer.yaml`, with protocol
+`context.indexer.provider/v1`. Code and Markdown Providers use the same field
+tree; `domains`, profiles and declared operations describe their applicable
+inputs.
+
+This page documents the protocol surface currently exposed by `@c4a/context`.
+It does not imply that the 0.7.0 CLI Route or its release channel is complete.
+
+## Resources and execution
+
+A Provider may contain a controlled program, profile-bound instructions,
+templates, an activation detector and an authoring inspector. Executable
+resources use only:
+
+```yaml
+execution:
+  runtime: node
+  entry: scripts/index.mjs
+  args: [--format=json]
+```
+
+`entry` is a portable path inside the verified Bundle. `args` are literal
+arguments. A free-form command, shell expression, environment interpolation,
+absolute path or parent traversal is invalid.
+
+The CLI never launches an executable from a discovered Skill installation
+directory. A Host or the CLI first resolves an exact Provider envelope, verifies
+the complete file ledger, and copies it to a content-addressed runtime stage.
+The controlled launch then revalidates that stage and resolves the declared
+entry there with `shell: false` and an empty inherited environment.
+
+Allowlisted first-party and verified Bundle programs may enter the trusted
+path directly. Every other Provider program, and every project-local program
+even when it extends an allowlisted Provider, requires an exact
+`context.indexer.program-authorization/v1` receipt from the independent
+program-execution authority. The receipt binds the project, Provider
+fingerprint and manifest, program origin/path/content digest, structured
+execution, requested capabilities, fixed dependencies, source scope, limits
+and policy digest. A local program is restricted to
+`src/indexer/<indexer-id>/index.ts`; the CLI reads a regular non-symlink file
+from the workspace before producing its report.
+
+The controlled invocation rechecks the complete receipt and program identity.
+Changing local bytes, the Provider Bundle, entry or arguments, capabilities,
+dependencies, scope or limits invalidates the authorization. An ordinary
+managed authority cannot issue this receipt, and the receipt always records
+`sandboxed_program: false`: it authorizes trusted execution but does not claim
+malicious-code isolation.
+
+Optional external reads are declared separately under
+`provides.tool_sources[]`. Each declaration contains only a stable id, a
+versioned Host handler and request protocol, the fixed
+`context.indexer.tool-snapshot/v1` output protocol, a closed operation list and
+`optional: true`. It cannot contain an executable path or command. The
+declaration is copied into the Agent-visible Skill capability and the final
+Provider composition plan with its owning Provider layer; it does not grant
+execution authority. The Host validates and executes its own installed adapter,
+while Context validates the resulting tool snapshot and keeps the local parser
+baseline independent from optional tool availability.
+
+## Two-stage selection validation
+
+`validateIndexerSelectionStatic` accepts only the proposed registry. It closes
+requirement ownership, read scope, profile composition, portable distribution,
+exact Provider identity/version/integrity and the data shape of stable config.
+Its output is a canonical list of Provider resolution requests. This phase does
+not resolve, read, stage or execute a Provider resource.
+
+After the resolver returns and the CLI creates a content-addressed stage,
+`validateIndexerSelectionFinal` consumes the exact static report. It rechecks
+the resolved envelope and actual staged file ledger, loads the sole Provider
+manifest, verifies profile/operation/composer/extension bindings, validates
+config against the Bundle's closed data-only schema, binds the project-local
+customization fingerprint and requires a policy digest for executable
+resources. Missing, duplicate, stale or extra inputs fail closed.
+
+The final stable report excludes transport paths, delivery timestamps and
+runtime receipt digests. Those values remain in a separate runtime receipt
+projection, so rematerializing identical content does not make the selection
+stale. The workflow Route must use the static report as the hard predecessor of
+resolution; the protocol functions alone do not authorize Host materialization.
+
+The only default persistent selection authority is `src/indexers.yaml`.
+Distribution locators are portable identities such as `cli-bundled://`,
+`plugin://`, `workspace://`, `package://` or `marketplace://`; a discovered
+Skill installation path and a runtime transport/stage path never enter the
+registry or stable report. The workspace persistence audit rejects the legacy
+`package.json.context.codeIndex.extensions` field. Provider-only projects also
+cannot persist a `src/indexer/` directory; declared local customization is
+limited to the fixed project-relative resource set.
+
+Minimal local customization runs as a resumable subloop. An Agent draft must
+consume a final CLI capability-gap proof. The CLI validates and
+content-address stages the draft, then project preparation revalidates the
+target selection and exact staged Providers before creating a CAS-bound
+proposal. Project-local programs stop for independent execution authorization;
+dependency authorization creates a new locked successor proposal instead of a
+detached result. After the single transactional apply, the CLI records a
+durable apply observation, verifies every target digest, reruns finalized
+selection validation, and returns the applied registry for one final static
+selection audit.
+
+## Skill capability and Provider composition
+
+Context normalizes every verified manifest to
+`context.indexer.skill-capability/v1`. This Agent-visible view contains the
+Skill's profiles, operations, accepted extension fragments, source roles,
+logical units, composers, program capabilities and supported customization
+steps. It is canonical and content-digested; it does not expose a discovered
+installation path or grant execution authority.
+
+Final selection builds one
+`context.indexer.provider-composition-plan/v1` for each Indexer owner. The plan
+binds every active profile to its exact Provider layer, keeps one primary
+authority for each enabled operation, admits only declared pre-authority
+fragments, merges identical source-role and logical-unit capabilities, and
+rejects conflicting logical-unit definitions. Provider instruction resources
+remain independently attributed instead of being concatenated implicitly,
+layer configs remain separately digested, and an exact project template
+override replaces only its matching template id/profile. Input array order is
+not authority: all projections use canonical identity sorting.
+
+The complete composition plans are part of the stable final selection report,
+so downstream workset and authoring steps consume a validated composition
+rather than rediscovering Provider precedence.
+
+## Partition strategy authority
+
+A Provider may declare profile-bound partition strategies under
+`provides.partition_strategies[]` with a stable id and non-negative priority.
+The manifest does not provide its own authority digest. Context derives the
+implementation identity from the verified Bundle and manifest; a validated
+local customization uses its exact file digest, while a CLI builtin is bound to
+the current CLI release digest.
+
+`context.indexer.partition-strategy-resolution/v1` binds the Indexer and
+registry fingerprints, selected profiles, Provider integrity, optional local
+customization and every strategy authority. A local declaration with the same
+id replaces only that Provider strategy. All effective project strategies are
+ordered by declared priority and id before any CLI builtin. A CLI builtin
+cannot shadow a project strategy, and an undeclared profile or ambiguous
+per-profile priority fails validation. The order-sensitive strategy-set digest
+is copied into the partition workset, so reordering or changing any authority
+makes prior work stale.
+
+## Source roles and Artifact policy
+
+A Provider may declare source-role and logical-unit identifiers, but the
+selected CLI profile contract owns Artifact kinds, metrics, thresholds and
+policy variants. Final selection rejects `quality_guidance.metric_ids`,
+`logical_units[].artifacts.recommended` kinds and
+`supported_policy_variants` that are not registered by the selected base
+profile. A namespaced extension inherits this check from its declared base
+profile. The strict manifest schema has no numeric limit or threshold field.
+
+Before authoring a logical unit, the CLI evaluates each selected policy
+variant's restricted eligibility selector over an allowlisted canonical-fact
+projection. The resulting
+`context.indexer.artifact-policy-eligibility/v1` binds the profile and operator
+contracts, canonical facts, Provider-supported variant set, eligible Artifact
+kinds and derived thresholds. `inflation-sensitive` maximums use the fixed CLI
+rule; the Provider cannot return a threshold or self-report a pass.
+
+An author Result declares one validated source role and, when it emits
+Artifacts, one `context.indexer.artifact-bundle/v1` for its logical unit. The
+Bundle chooses exactly one eligible variant and classifies each Artifact as
+required, discretionary or a semantic split. The CLI requires exact agreement
+between the Bundle and Result payload, registered required/discretionary kinds,
+known evidence, authorized reader questions and the derived discretionary
+fan-out limit. Semantic split parts retain `split_of`, the parent's kind and a
+non-overlapping stable boundary. An empty Result has no Bundle; a non-empty
+Result cannot omit it. There is no global hard limit on total valid logical
+units or physical Artifacts.
+
+Before author worksets can materialize Candidate content, Context requires a
+canonical `context.indexer.projected-artifact-plan/v1` and runs
+`context.indexer.projected-artifact-fan-out-audit/v1`. Each projection binds a
+stable projection key to an exact PartitionPlan group, Bundle digest, current
+CLI policy-eligibility digest and evidence justification. Missing or mismatched
+owner, Bundle variant or evidence increments the unassigned count; complete
+Bundles, expanded variants, semantic split parts and the single CLI
+`catalog-fallback` parent do not. Counts up to 100 continue, 101 through 300
+continue with a warning, and counts above 300 return the non-Gate
+`indexer-plan-revision-required` outcome before any author workset runs. That
+partial outcome consumes neither a user Gate nor the three-attempt profile
+revision ledger.
+
+Artifact content has three mechanically separate layers. `facts[]` contains
+canonical, source-bound values and never reader prose. A structured
+`deterministic-block` contains only a registered renderer and `fact_refs`; the
+CLI resolves those Facts and derives both Markdown and evidence, so a Provider
+cannot relabel arbitrary JSON or prose as a catalog. A `semantic-prose` block
+contains evidence-bound Markdown and cannot cite Facts as a way to increase
+deterministic coverage. The normalized rendered Section retains ordered
+`content_blocks` with the layer, Fact refs, evidence refs and per-block digest;
+its Section digest covers that ledger and the exact reader-visible Markdown.
+
+`ArtifactResult` also carries
+`context.indexer.capability-group-evidence/v1`. It repeats the complete member
+set bound by the author workset even when no capability group is selected. A
+non-empty capability group has a stable ref derived only from the logical unit
+and capability key, at least two explicit member-to-evidence bindings, and one
+or more actual Artifact Section evidence bindings. A member cannot belong to
+two capability groups. Every member evidence ref must be a current Result
+evidence binding and must be visible in one of the declared Sections. Unknown
+members or Sections, page-level evidence without Section consumption, and
+workset/member-set drift are rejected. This protocol does not assign projection
+dispositions to members outside capability groups.
+
+## Full-path example identity
+
+Providers report normalized example observations through
+`context.indexer.example-inventory/v1`. The stable `example_ref` is derived
+only from the public target ref, scenario key and full path relative to the
+authorized source/module root. Paths use Unicode NFC and `/`; absolute paths
+and parent traversal are invalid. Source/module identity, content digest and
+evidence form a separate observation ref, so additional evidence for the same
+observation can merge without changing the example identity.
+
+Context recomputes `context.indexer.example-identity-audit/v1`. Equal basenames
+under different full paths are distinct examples, as are equal paths for
+different targets or scenarios. Multiple distinct source/content observations
+for the same complete example identity are a hard
+`example-identity-collision`; a Provider cannot override the audit result or
+forge an empty collision list. Candidate disposition and linkage are separate
+downstream contracts.
+
+## SubjectKey schema authority
+
+Community profile identity rules have one authority: the top-level
+`subject_key_schemas` array in the CLI profile contract. A community Provider
+manifest cannot copy or replace that schema. A namespaced additional profile
+has the other allowed authority: the exact owner Provider's
+`composition.extensions[].subject_key_schema`. The extension declaration is
+required and may use only the CLI's closed namespace/local-key derivation
+operators, kind identifiers and normalization rules.
+
+Final selection resolves both forms to
+`context.indexer.resolved-subject-key-schema/v1`. The record binds the Indexer,
+profile, base-contract or Provider authority, schema digest and resolution
+digest. Its canonical set digest is part of the stable final selection report;
+transport paths and runtime receipts are not. Subject keys must match a kind in
+the resolved schema and satisfy its normalization before they can become a
+canonical NodeRef.
+
+An unchanged schema is equivalent. Adding a kind while preserving the existing
+namespace, normalization and local-key operators is compatible. Removing or
+changing an existing identity derivation is identity-breaking: the owning
+authority must advance its major version and the schema version must increase.
+When approved Nodes exist, Context requires a non-delegable
+`confirm-subject-reidentification` authorization bound to the exact old/new
+schema digests, approved catalog, complete deterministic mapping and report.
+Missing mappings, one old Node mapping to multiple Nodes, multiple old Nodes
+colliding on one new Node, stale authorization or digest drift blocks
+activation. With no approved Node, the human Gate is omitted but conformance
+and major-version checks still apply.
+
+## Requirement change authority
+
+`context.indexer.requirement-change-report/v1` retains both complete
+requirements, their digests, the canonical comparator inputs, the recomputed
+comparison and its report digest. Equivalent and strengthening changes use
+`confirm-index-requirements` and may follow managed review authority.
+Contraction or incomparable replacement instead uses
+`confirm-index-requirement-contraction`; its confirmation is always human and
+non-delegable, and binds the exact old/new requirement, comparison and report
+digests. A self-digested caller classification is insufficient because Context
+recomputes the comparator before issuing or consuming the confirmation.
+
+Material-gap severity remains derived from the current requirement domain:
+`required` is blocking, `optional` is recommended and `out-of-scope` creates no
+gap. Severity is not written into worksets or the retained ledger, so a domain
+change must pass the requirement Gate instead of editing a stored severity.
+
+## Provider discovery and composition Route
+
+`configure-indexer-providers` is a static Agent Action. It reports the exact
+CLI-bundled catalog together with other Indexer entry Skills already visible to
+the current Host, then returns a path-free
+`context.indexer.provider-route-input/v1`. The visible list remains
+conversation-only: the protocol carries names, readable versions and source
+types, never installation or cache paths, and the CLI does not scan for more
+Skills. When the Host exposes an exact Skill root, discovery may read only the
+Skill frontmatter and sibling `context-indexer.yaml`; the manifest version is
+authoritative and its `metadata.context-provider-version` copy must match.
+Conversational output groups the same Skill name and exact version into one
+item with all observed source types, while `visible_skills` retains distinct
+source observations because its `source_type` field is singular. Identical
+bundled and installed observations are not separate Providers and never create
+selection precedence; different exact versions remain separate identities.
+
+`route-indexer-provider-selection` recomputes required
+requirement/domain/source/module owner cells against the unchanged applied
+requirement set. Read-scope overlap is reported but remains legal. A closed
+selection may contain multiple fixed Skill identities and continues as one
+`multi-skill` composition to `validate-indexer-selection-proposal`. Duplicate
+primary owners instead return `indexer-provider-conflict` and cannot be
+resolved by YAML or discovery order.
+
+If a first pass leaves an owner cell unmatched, the Graph records `partial` and
+runs `configure-community-indexer-fallback`. The second pass is explicitly
+marked `community_fallback_attempted: true`; any remaining unowned required
+cell becomes `indexer-customization-required` with its exact owner cell,
+coverage capability and `context.indexer.capability-gap-proof/v1`. This is the
+only Provider-discovery outcome that authorizes the local-customization Route;
+the proof protocol remains a capability audit artifact rather than a second
+Graph outcome. Only `selection-validation-required` returns a selection
+proposal input. The Route writes no workspace or runtime state, and neither a
+visible-Skill claim nor the Route report authorizes Bundle materialization.
+
+## Contract overlay validation and trust
+
+`validate-indexer-contract-overlays` recomputes the complete data-only overlay
+against the exact CLI base and operator contracts. Invalid DSL, executable
+fields, identity redefinition, threshold weakening, digest drift or a partial
+attestation/trust bundle fails before any authorization Route exists. A
+resolver's self-reported `verified` value is not an accepted input.
+
+A valid detached Ed25519 attestation is checked locally against a matching key
+in the complete Host trust-bundle policy, including key validity and
+revocation, and directly produces the common
+`context.indexer.overlay-trust-receipt/v1`. The receipt binds the exact Host
+adapter identity/version and management-authority digest as well as the policy
+digest, so any policy-envelope drift makes the audit stale. An unsigned overlay, an attestation
+without an installed trust bundle, or an attestation whose issuer/key is absent
+from the canonical bundle returns `authorization-required`; the request binds
+the exact attestation digest (or null) together with the
+project/overlay/base/operator/Provider/conformance digest set. The
+non-delegable `authorize-indexer-contract-overlay` Gate may issue that
+project-exact authorization under the independent
+`context.indexer-contract-overlay` authority; revalidation then produces the
+same trust-receipt protocol with trust class
+`project-authorized-exact-digest`. Cross-project or stale reports cannot be
+reused. Once the bundle contains the declared issuer/key, an invalid signature,
+expired key, revoked key, or malformed policy is a hard trust failure and
+cannot downgrade to project authorization.
+
+## Question amendment back-edge
+
+A CLI base-contract question can be expanded and confirmed before Provider
+resolution. `context.indexer.base-question-amendment/v1` copies the complete
+canonical contract from the selected base profile, changes only the requirement
+question binding, and applies the confirmed snapshot with an expected-base CAS
+and durable single-file journal. A Skill question ref is guidance only; it
+cannot provide or alter the contract payload.
+
+An overlay-backed question follows a different sequence. Context first
+recomputes overlay DSL conformance and verifies an enterprise or exact-project
+trust receipt. Only then may
+`context.indexer.overlay-question-amendment/v1` expand namespaced question and
+target-domain additions from that overlay. The target coverage domain must
+already be in scope and have one existing primary owner. The amendment is a
+pure strengthening and remains in runtime staging after confirmation; it is not
+written as a standalone requirement update.
+
+The executable sequence is
+`propose-overlay-question-amendment`,
+`confirm-overlay-question-amendment`, then
+`rebind-indexer-selection-to-requirement`. Proposal and rebind inputs carry the
+exact trusted overlay validation input and result; Context recomputes and
+compares that pair instead of accepting a detached receipt. Confirmation emits
+the exact amendment decision and performs no project write.
+
+The rebind Action then proves that Indexer/provider
+identity, operations, scopes, profile composition, requirement bindings, owner
+closure and read authority are byte-identical. It revalidates overlay trust,
+reuses the exact staged Bundles, and reruns both static and final selection
+against the target requirement digest. Provider and SubjectKey authority must
+remain unchanged. Final selection resolves every CLI-base question back to its
+exact selected profile contract and requires one current trust/conformance proof
+for every overlay question; forged bindings and duplicate, stale, or unused
+proofs fail before the final report is issued. The report binds the resulting
+question authority set digest. The resulting
+`context.indexer.overlay-question-registry-apply-proposal/v1` contains the full
+target `src/indexers.yaml` snapshot and binds the amendment, confirmation,
+overlay trust, rebound selection, SubjectKey schema set and finalized reports.
+The proposal goes through the same `stage-indexer-project-proposal` and
+`apply-indexer-project` Actions as ordinary registry/customization proposals.
+The latter dispatches this typed proposal to one expected-base CAS, project
+write lock and persistent journal, so the requirement binding and rebound
+registry are committed by one complete file replacement. Recovery observes
+only the old or new registry snapshot; it never reconstructs authority from a
+temporary Provider path.
+
+## Controlled invocation
+
+`context.indexer.controlled-invocation/v1` binds:
+
+- the exact Indexer, Provider, version, Bundle integrity and stable Provider
+  fingerprint;
+- the manifest-declared `runtime + entry + args`;
+- requested and granted Context SDK capabilities;
+- an exact fixed dependency set with package, version, lock integrity and
+  resolved content digest;
+- one authorized source/module scope;
+- a stable trust-policy and authority digest;
+- timeout and stdin/stdout/stderr byte limits.
+
+The 0.7.0 built-in Host capability is `sandboxed_program: false`. A first-party,
+verified or exact project-authorized program may use the `trusted-program` path,
+which is not an isolation claim. An untrusted program without a real sandbox is
+not executable.
+
+The program input remains the operation-discriminated
+`context.indexer.run-request/v1` (`main-index` or `material-answer`). Its output
+is `context.indexer.run-result/v1`, wrapped by
+`context.indexer.controlled-program-result/v1` to bind the exact invocation and
+payload digest. Context still validates the operation-specific Result and
+recomputes mechanical gates independently.
+
+## Primary execution identity and workset reads
+
+Context derives `context.indexer.primary-registry-projection/v1` from the
+finalized registry. The projection contains the selected Indexer's requirement
+bindings, read scope, `main-index` operation, primary/additional profiles,
+primary or pre-authority Provider layers and customization mode. It excludes
+`profile.composers[]` and Provider layers used only after primary authoring.
+`context.indexer.primary-execution-projection/v1` separately binds the primary
+program, instructions, templates, config, CLI/profile contracts and only
+`primary | pre-authority` resources. Its resource subprojection produces
+`primary_resource_binding_digest`; a post-author resource cannot satisfy that
+schema.
+
+`context.indexer.main-workset/v1` digests its complete canonical payload. A
+workset set permits only one author workset for an Indexer, owner cohort and
+group key. `context.indexer.main-transport-batch/v1` may carry several complete
+worksets but intentionally has no batch identity, digest, page number or
+reader-facing name. Regrouping worksets for Host transport therefore cannot
+change an individual workset or Result identity.
+
+Each partition run request also carries one exact
+`partition_strategy_attempt`: its resolution order, strategy reference and
+digest, plus the previous attempt digest after a retry. The field participates
+in the execution request digest and is `null` for author work. Context accepts
+only a semantic partition. Ordinal, fixed-count and alphabetical axes are
+recorded in a content-addressed convergence chain and atomically requeue the
+same workset with the next authorized strategy. This path has no user Gate and
+does not consume profile-revision attempts; an exhausted strategy set routes
+to the CLI catalog fallback.
+
+Source and evidence are read through
+`context.indexer.workset-read-request/v1`. The stable request identity binds the
+current workset, read kind and exact authorized ref set. Cursor and page size
+are transport fields and do not enter that identity. Every response carries a
+digest of its canonical page payload; cursor fields are again excluded. The
+CLI closes a complete, acyclic cursor chain into
+`context.indexer.workset-read-receipt/v1`, requiring exact coverage of the
+requested refs. A main Result contains the canonically sorted receipt digest
+set, and operation validation compares it with the actual CLI-issued receipts.
+Changing a cursor, page size, call grouping or Host batch cannot manufacture a
+new logical unit such as `batch-1` or alter an Artifact identity.
+
+Post-author composition uses its own
+`context.indexer.post-author-run-ledger/v1`; it never reuses primary main-run
+progress. Each entry is keyed by composer ref and current workset digest and is
+`pending`, `running`, `accepted`, `failed` or `stale`. An accepted entry stores
+the complete validated Result, materialized fragments and invocation receipt,
+including a valid zero-fragment Result. Rebuilding a workset set reuses only an
+accepted entry whose workset, request, View, Result, receipt and fragment set
+all remain current. A `running` entry without that complete record returns to
+`pending` on recovery; a changed workset becomes `stale` without discarding
+unchanged accepted peers.
+
+`context.indexer.post-author-status/v1` exposes deterministic total, pending,
+accepted, failed and stale counts, sorted next refs and the accepted receipt-set
+digest. Zero effective composers yields `post_author_envelope.state =
+not-required` without creating a View or envelope and may reconcile. A nonzero
+set may reconcile only when every composer is accepted and the supplied
+`context.indexer.composed-result-envelope/v1` exactly matches the recomposed
+current envelope. Missing or mismatched envelope data is `stale`; partial,
+failed or stale worksets cannot reconcile.
+
+## Parser coordinates and locks
+
+A runtime profile declares each parser as a
+`context.indexer.parser-requirement/v1`: an abstract capability, parser ABI and
+exact community package/export/version coordinate. The capability name is not
+an import alias and the presence of parser source in a Context or downstream source mirror
+does not prove that the capability is installed.
+
+The configured registry resolves that requirement to
+`context.indexer.parser-coordinate-mapping/v1`. A direct mapping preserves the
+community coordinate exactly. A wrapper may use another coordinate only while
+preserving the same ABI digest; it may re-export the ABI but cannot redefine
+parser facts. Installation then produces
+`context.indexer.parser-resolution-lock/v1`, which records the actual
+package/export/version, mapping digest, lock integrity, resolved content digest
+and ABI digest.
+
+Provider or local-customization imports must carry the exact capability and
+parser lock digest and must import the actual locked package/export/version.
+The locked dependency projection feeds controlled execution and stale
+identity. Community aliases, mirror paths and whether a sync copied parser
+source are not accepted as runtime evidence. Internal release smoke must load
+the configured actual export; that later release check does not change this
+protocol authority.
+
+## Section collection mapping and layout
+
+Collection remains the closed package and query classification vocabulary. A
+Provider Result declares only each Section's `section_key`, owner Indexer,
+document kind, reader goal and Artifact kind. The selected CLI profile contract
+owns the versioned `layout_mappings`; exactly one mapping must match the
+profile, source role and complete Section projection. A Result containing a
+collection, output path or unknown top-level package namespace is invalid.
+
+Collection belongs to a physical Artifact. Every actual or material-gap
+Section in that Artifact must resolve to the same collection. A mixed source
+may route different Sections to different collections only by declaring
+separate Artifacts in its validated Bundle; the CLI does not silently split or
+merge reader pages to repair a Provider Result.
+
+The compile-internal resolver emits `context.indexer.layout-proposal/v1`. It
+binds the exact Artifact Result, profile contract, validated SubjectKey schema
+set and exact schema digest, Indexer and source. The resolver validates the
+SubjectKey against the selected schema normalization before deriving NodeRef;
+a caller-supplied digest is not accepted as schema authority. NodeRef plus the
+logical Artifact id/kind derives ArtifactRef. NodeRef, owner Indexer, Artifact
+kind and Section key derive a stable logical Section identity; its placement
+under one Artifact derives SectionRef. This lets a diff distinguish a moved
+Section from new content without allowing the same logical Section to have two
+primary placements. The ViewRef is an internal projection. Output paths are
+derived under `knowledge/<collection>/` and never accepted from a Provider.
+
+Template Artifacts enter layout only after validated rendering. Only rendered
+Sections exist; an omitted optional projection does not create an empty
+Section, while a retained material gap remains a planned landing without
+reader-visible placeholder content. Artifact Bundle purpose and `split_of`
+lineage are retained in the proposal. A proposal set rejects duplicate Node
+owners, Artifact identities, logical Section identities, Section placements
+and output paths across Indexers, as well as missing, nested or kind-changing
+semantic-split parents.
+
+Before Candidate Review, Context builds
+`context.indexer.artifact-manifest/v1` from the current layout set and the
+actual physical Markdown set. The manifest stores paths, content digests,
+byte/body-line counts and exact logical-unit or registered-navigation ownership;
+it does not retain the Markdown body. A separate
+`context.indexer.physical-artifact-audit/v1` recomputes Bundle numerator and
+denominator, per-unit physical fan-out, semantic split count, and the complete
+missing/empty/orphan/unresolved-material sample set. Any such diagnostic is a
+non-overridable completeness failure.
+
+Generated navigation must use a content-addressed
+`context.indexer.navigation-artifact-plan/v1`. Nested navigation is allowed,
+but every navigation Artifact must reach a logical-unit Artifact; unknown
+children, cycles, path collisions and unregistered files fail. Reader bodies
+over 1500 lines produce a non-blocking advisory only. Total physical Artifact
+count has no global maximum.
+
+An initial layout does not create a structural Gate. A content-only increment
+reuses the existing Artifact identity and also skips the Gate. Adding reader
+fan-out to an already approved Node, removing or renaming an Artifact,
+splitting/merging its declared lineage, moving a logical Section, or changing
+an approved collection/path is represented by a digest-bound layout change
+report and requires the human, non-delegable `confirm-layout-change` Gate.
+`context.indexer.layout-transition/v1` first validates an explicit
+no-planned-output state or a material-answer actualization whose digest and
+actual ArtifactRef/SectionRef all belong to the current proposal set; only
+then does it expose the conditional Gate. Replacing the proposal set makes the
+prior actualization stale. The legacy align Route remains available only until
+the workflow cutover; it is not an authority for the new Indexer protocol.
+
+## Explicit Result-bound Candidate compile
+
+`compile-indexer-candidates` consumes the complete current set of accepted
+author Results from the durable main-run store. Its input repeats only the
+exact workset, execution-request, acceptance and Artifact Result digests; the
+CLI rejects a missing, extra, forged or stale Result reference before
+materialization. Callers cannot provide an alternate Result body, Provider
+contract, default plan or prose-compile payload.
+
+The compiler validates every accepted run envelope and acceptance record,
+then binds each Candidate to the same Indexer Result, source identity,
+Provider layer and integrity, Bundle digest, configuration fingerprint and
+optional customization fingerprint used by layout. The supplied layout
+proposal set and transition must bind the same Artifact Result set. Any
+destructive layout report additionally requires its exact non-delegable
+confirmation; unresolved material gaps stop compile.
+
+Structured Section blocks are materialized directly. Template-backed
+Artifacts use only an exact rendered Artifact bound to the same Result digest.
+The CLI derives physical paths from layout, builds the physical Artifact
+manifest, and requires the completeness audit to pass before returning the
+Candidate set. The durable current record lives under Context runtime state;
+it does not write approved knowledge. Review and apply remain the only route
+to approved Markdown.
+
+No generic fallback exists after Provider resolution. A minimal local
+customization may be proposed only after the explicit
+`indexer-customization-required` outcome and its capability-gap proof; compile
+itself never invents one.
+
+## Material-answer dispatch, baseline, Review, and layout actualization
+
+`context.indexer.material-question-workset/v1` is built only by the CLI after a
+material-gap checkpoint. It binds the current requirement and registry digests,
+question contract and target inventory, source-input digests, exact question
+revision, predecessor ledger revision, authorized sources, and eligible answer
+Indexers. Eligibility is derived from the registry-enabled `material-answer`
+operation, an enricher binding, the primary Provider manifest, read scope, and
+the evidence-kind intersection; callers cannot add an eligible Indexer.
+
+The CLI creates one `context.indexer.run-request/v1` per eligible answer Indexer.
+Its Provider composition fingerprint is recomputed from the answer Indexer,
+exact final Provider authority, and layer-composition view digest. The separate
+material-answer run ledger uses CAS transitions and content-addressed accepted
+records. A complete accepted empty Result is recovered without another dispatch;
+an interrupted running entry without its accepted record returns to pending.
+Before acceptance, every evidence claim must resolve through an exact current
+source-span read receipt, and unused or stale receipts are rejected.
+
+A `material-answer` Result cannot move a retained gap directly to an approved
+state. Context first validates the exact workset, question revision, eligible
+Indexer, Provider fingerprint, source authority, canonical spans, evidence
+content digests, provenance selector and minimum item/origin counts. Only a
+passing candidate can produce
+`context.indexer.material-answer-baseline-report/v1`. Its fixed Review scope is
+`question-target-source-span-evidence-binding`; the strict schema has no field
+for approving a reader page, Artifact content or final knowledge candidate.
+
+`context.indexer.material-answer-review-decision/v1` binds that report, the
+candidate set, workset, question revision and binding digest. Applying an
+`approved` decision uses the workset's predecessor ledger revision as a CAS
+base, consumes that workset and records the decision digest in the canonical
+answer binding. A successor ledger revision does not make the consumed workset
+self-stale. A rejected, insufficient, forged or differently scoped decision
+cannot create `answer-approved` state.
+
+Layout uses an unapplied
+`context.indexer.material-answer-layout-proposal/v1`. Each planned or existing
+answer landing must map uniquely to an actual `node:`, `artifact:` or
+`section:` ref. Before creating a resolved actualization, Context recomputes
+`context.indexer.material-answer-evidence-compatibility/v1` from the retained
+canonical evidence and current question/source authority. A changed source set,
+origin, snapshot, kind, span, content digest, provenance rule or minimum count
+reopens the gap to `unresolved`. A missing or colliding landing remains
+`answer-approved`; rejecting or replacing a layout proposal invalidates its
+resolved mappings back to `answer-approved`.
+
+`context.indexer.material-answer-flow-status/v1` is the admission fact for the
+next stages. An unresolved blocking gap stops layout. An `answer-approved`
+blocking gap may enter layout but cannot consume a conditional layout Gate or
+enter the main Candidate Review. Those two admissions become true only when
+every blocking answer has a current actualization for the exact layout digest.
+Optional gaps remain reported but do not become blocking. Final close removes
+a resolved ledger entry only when the approved structure projection carries
+the same question, binding, actualized target and complete canonical evidence
+ref set.
+
+## Detector and inspector
+
+An activation detector consumes `context.indexer.activation-request/v1`. The
+request contains the exact declared required, supporting and negative signal
+set plus one `context.indexer.parser-fact-view/v1`. The view is built from
+validated Evidence Adapter Results and their process-local structured fact
+payload sidecars. It binds the authorized source/module scope, canonical file
+inventory, origin Result digests and every payload digest. Raw source or
+configuration text is not part of this input.
+
+Parser adapters expose a materialization helper that returns the wire-safe
+`context.indexer.evidence-adapter-result/v1` together with `fact_payloads`.
+Those payloads intentionally do not serialize inside the Result and cannot be
+recovered after a JSON round trip. The caller must construct the parser fact
+view while the sidecar is still present; missing, extra, stale or out-of-view
+payloads fail closed.
+
+`context.indexer.activation-result/v1` must close every signal as
+`present`, `absent` or `unknown`; a present signal requires evidence. Context,
+not the detector, derives `matched`, `not-matched` or `indeterminate`.
+
+An authoring inspector consumes `context.indexer.inspector-request/v1` and
+returns `context.indexer.inspector-result/v1`. Its evidence payload is the
+shared `context.indexer.evidence-adapter-result/v1`. Inspector files are always
+`enricher` plus `lightweight-evidence`; they cannot own baseline inventory or
+contribute a denominator. The Result must close the requested inventory and
+authorized source/module scope. Detector and inspector entries run only from
+the reverified content-addressed stage through the same empty-environment,
+no-shell, bounded JSON subprocess runner. Timeout, stdin/stdout/stderr overflow,
+invalid UTF-8/JSON, undeclared evidence and scope expansion are typed failures;
+a successful execution returns a digest-bound receipt.
+
+## Project-local customization
+
+A Provider-only project does not create `src/indexer/`. When the registry
+explicitly selects `extend` or `replace`, Context reads only
+`src/indexer/<indexer-id>/` and the fixed resources `index.ts`, `variables.ts`,
+`helpers.ts`, `instructions.md` and `templates/<id>.md`. Each file requires an
+exact `@context-indexer-origin` header. `replace` additionally requires a current
+capability-gap proof.
+
+Every customization view also carries a validated
+`context.indexer.customization-plan/v1`. The fixed escalation ladder is
+`provider-only`, `config`, `instructions-append`, `template-override`,
+`program-extend`, then `replace`. Selecting a step requires ordered evidence
+that every smaller step is insufficient. `replace` additionally requires three
+distinct failed extension-attempt digests and human confirmation; adding an
+external dependency also makes confirmation mandatory. The selected step must
+match the actual loaded files and the registry's `none | extend | replace`
+mode. A Provider-only workspace gets a deterministic `provider-only` plan and
+must not supply a local escalation plan. A non-empty registry config remains
+registry-only but requires an exact `config` plan with Provider-only closure
+evidence.
+
+Project changes are represented by
+`context.indexer.project-proposal/v1`. A proposal binds the unchanged
+requirement-set authority, complete target registry, actual changed files,
+fixed dependency intents, validation reports and expected-base digests. It is
+staged under runtime state before any source write. Applying it uses the project
+write lock and a persistent multi-file journal; recovery accepts only complete
+base or target file states and refuses unknown external drift.
+
+Dependency intents begin as `requires-authorization` and cannot make a proposal
+apply-ready. The separate `authorize-indexer-dependencies` Gate requires the
+`context.indexer-dependency-install` authority and binds the proposal, original
+intent-set digest, exact package versions, importers, lock integrity, resolved
+content digests and authority scope. Its CLI Action returns a digest-bound
+authorization receipt plus a new `locked` intent set; install scripts remain
+structurally `false`. A locked intent without its exact receipt, an unused
+receipt, a changed resolution or an ordinary managed authority fails closed.
+The Agent must use that locked set and the complete package/lock snapshots in a
+replacement staged proposal before `apply-indexer-project`; the apply journal
+never writes `node_modules`, which is reconstructed only from the accepted lock.
+
+## Indexer template rendering
+
+Indexer authoring templates are not package-output Handlebars templates. Each
+Provider template is one manifest-declared Markdown file under that Provider's
+`templates/` tree. A project may replace only the same template id/profile at
+`src/indexer/<indexer-id>/templates/<id>.md`; all other templates continue to
+come from the verified, content-addressed Provider stage.
+
+The Markdown file begins with closed YAML frontmatter using
+`context.indexer.template/v1`. It declares the reader goal, applicable artifact
+policy variants, typed variables with an explicit `deterministic-fact` or
+`semantic-prose` content layer, registered deterministic blocks, required and
+optional Sections, question refs, evidence kinds/cardinality, deletion rules,
+page-boundary guidance, anonymous examples, anti-examples, forbidden output and
+a rendered byte budget. Every body Section uses exact markers:
+
+```md
+<!-- context:indexer-section summary -->
+# {{variable:title}}
+
+{{variable:summary}}
+<!-- /context:indexer-section -->
+```
+
+Only `{{variable:<id>}}` and `{{block:<id>}}` are accepted. Direct variables are
+semantic prose. A block source variable is a deterministic Fact projection,
+must bind canonical `fact_refs`, and must equal the CLI's normalized projection
+of those Facts. Blocks select one of
+the CLI-owned `bullet-list`, `key-value-table` or `json-code-block` renderers;
+templates cannot register code or helpers. A block directive occupies its own
+template line so the renderer can retain an exact content-layer boundary. The
+contract and body must declare exactly the same Sections and placeholders.
+
+`ArtifactResult` binds every template variable to current evidence refs and
+binds every declared Section to `section_key`, owner Indexer, document kind,
+reader goal and Artifact kind. Rendering validates the Provider/customization
+fingerprints, template digest, current CLI-owned applicability conditions,
+variable types and expansion limits, per-variable evidence boundary and exact
+CLI-owned question target. An optional Section without data
+or sufficient evidence is absent from the rendered Candidate. A required
+Section in the same state becomes the already-declared material-question
+transition and makes `review_ready` false.
+
+Before a Candidate can enter Review, Context rejects unknown directives,
+unresolved variables, template comments, example placeholders, standalone or
+bracketed `TODO`/`TBD`/`待补充`/`待生成` markers, title-only Sections and budget
+overflow. A source-backed sentence that discusses a known TODO is not treated
+as a placeholder merely because it contains that token; it remains semantic
+prose and therefore requires Agent Review. The rendered
+Section content, ordered content-layer ledger and evidence receive stable
+digests. Deterministic blocks contribute catalog completeness but never
+semantic-prose density. Later `build` projects this approved body; it does not
+perform a first render or change its structure.
+
+An ArtifactResult may emit
+`context.indexer.structured-claim-set/v1`. Every claim binds a stable claim
+kind and subject to one real Artifact/Section owner and one or more evidence
+refs carried by that exact Section. The subject must be the current logical
+unit, one of its CLI-owned inventory members, or an authorized target-resolution
+identity. Missing owners, outside subjects, unknown evidence and evidence that
+is known globally but absent from the owner Section all fail Result validation.
+
+Main-run validation derives
+`context.indexer.generated-authoring-audit/v1`. It reports controlled generated
+placeholder and empty emitted-Section hard findings, proves that every emitted
+structured claim passed owner-local evidence coverage, and lists every
+semantic-prose block or direct authored template variable as
+`semantic-prose-agent-review-required`. It does not scan free prose to claim
+that unsupported natural-language assertions were mechanically detected.
+
+## Material-question target exclusion
+
+A target exclusion is not a Provider Result and does not change the confirmed
+requirement. Context first emits
+`context.indexer.material-question-exclusion-report/v1` for one current
+unresolved `QuestionTargetKey`. The report binds the project, predecessor
+ledger revision, question-target inventory, question contract and revision,
+target ref/item digest, exact allowlisted reason, derived severity and the
+reader-visible impact.
+
+`confirm-material-question-exclusion` accepts only that report and always emits
+`context.indexer.material-question-exclusion-confirmation/v1` with human,
+non-delegable authority. Managed mode, Provider omission, wildcard targets and
+non-allowlisted reasons cannot create the decision. Apply revalidates the
+report against the current resolved question and ledger before retaining only
+the reason code and decision digest in the entry.
+
+The successor ledger is checkpointed with the predecessor revision through the
+same durable structure journal. A question contract, owner, target item,
+question revision or other pair dependency change replaces the retained
+exclusion with an unresolved entry in one checkpoint. The Material Gap ledger
+is intentionally absent from the main-workset identity, so this target-level
+decision does not invalidate unrelated main indexing worksets.