@amrhas82/agentic-kit 1.1.0 → 1.2.1

package/docs/INTEGRATION_ISSUES_9.1.md

@@ -0,0 +1,341 @@
+# Integration Issues Found During Task 9.1
+
+**Task**: Actual Installation Testing with Real Tools
+**Date**: 2025-11-05
+**Tester**: Claude (3-process-task-list agent)
+**Environment**: Linux 4.4.0, Node.js v22.21.0, Claude Code CLI
+
+---
+
+## Summary
+
+Tested the Interactive Multi-Tool Installer with actual Claude Code installation. Successfully completed:
+- ✅ Fresh installation (Lite variant)
+- ✅ Upgrade from Lite → Standard → Pro
+- ✅ Uninstall (after bug fix)
+- ✅ Fresh reinstallation
+
+**Result**: 1 critical bug found and fixed, 1 verification bug identified.
+
+---
+
+## Issue #1: Uninstall Function Argument Order Bug [CRITICAL - FIXED]
+
+### **Status**: ✅ **FIXED**
+
+### **Description**
+The uninstall functionality completely failed with 0 files removed and showed `NaN%` progress due to incorrect function argument order in CLI.
+
+### **Root Cause**
+In `installer/cli.js` line 376-384, the `uninstall()` call was passing arguments in the wrong order:
+
+```javascript
+// BEFORE (WRONG):
+const result = await installationEngine.uninstall(
+  toolId,          // arg 1: toolId ✓
+  targetPath,      // arg 2: targetPath ✓
+  (progress) => {  // arg 3: progressCallback (WRONG POSITION!)
+    // Display progress
+    const percentage = Math.round((progress.filesRemoved / progress.totalFiles) * 100);
+    process.stdout.write(`...`);
+  }
+);
+```
+
+The `installation-engine.js` signature is:
+```javascript
+async uninstall(toolId, targetPath, confirmCallback = null, progressCallback = null)
+```
+
+The progress callback was being passed as the 3rd argument (confirmCallback position) instead of the 4th argument (progressCallback position).
+
+### **Impact**
+- Uninstall reported success but removed 0 files
+- All installed files remained on disk
+- Progress showed `NaN%` and `undefined/undefined` files
+- Backup was not created (showed `null`)
+- Users could not cleanly uninstall packages
+
+### **Fix Applied**
+Added `null` as the 3rd argument (confirmCallback) in `installer/cli.js`:
+
+```javascript
+// AFTER (CORRECT):
+const result = await installationEngine.uninstall(
+  toolId,
+  targetPath,
+  null, // confirmCallback (already confirmed above)
+  (progress) => {
+    // Display progress
+    const percentage = Math.round((progress.filesRemoved / progress.totalFiles) * 100);
+    process.stdout.write(`\r${colors.cyan}Progress:${colors.reset} ${percentage}% (${progress.filesRemoved}/${progress.totalFiles} files removed)`);
+  }
+);
+```
+
+### **File Modified**
+- `installer/cli.js` (line 376-385)
+
+### **Verification**
+Tested uninstall after fix:
+- ✅ Successfully removed 325 files
+- ✅ Successfully removed 26 directories
+- ✅ Created backup: `/root/.claude.uninstall-backup.2025-11-05T10-30-33-046Z`
+- ✅ Progress displayed correctly (0% → 100%)
+- ✅ Clean uninstall verified (all files removed)
+
+### **Test Results**
+```
+BEFORE FIX:
+Files removed: 0
+Directories removed: 0
+Backup created: null
+Progress: NaN% (undefined/undefined files removed)
+
+AFTER FIX:
+Files removed: 325
+Directories removed: 26
+Backup created: /root/.claude.uninstall-backup.2025-11-05T10-30-33-046Z
+Progress: 0% → 100% (325/325 files removed)
+```
+
+---
+
+## Issue #2: Verification Reports "Manifest File Not Found" [NON-CRITICAL]
+
+### **Status**: ⚠️ **IDENTIFIED** (not fixed in this session)
+
+### **Description**
+After successful installation, the verification step reports "Manifest file not found" even though the manifest.json file exists and is correctly written.
+
+### **Symptoms**
+```
+[31m✗ Verification failed[0m
+[36mManifest:[0m ~/.claude/manifest.json
+[31mIssues:[0m
+  [31m✗[0m Manifest file not found
+```
+
+However, when checked:
+```bash
+$ ls -la ~/.claude/manifest.json
+-rw-r--r-- 1 root root 1795 Nov  5 10:31 /root/.claude/manifest.json
+
+$ cat ~/.claude/manifest.json
+{
+  "tool": "claude",
+  "variant": "lite",
+  "components": {
+    "agents": 4,
+    "skills": 7,
+    ...
+  }
+}
+```
+
+### **Impact**
+- Low: Installation actually succeeds and all files are correctly installed
+- Confusing: Users see "Verification failed" even though installation worked
+- Misleading: Report shows red "✗" symbol suggesting failure
+
+### **Root Cause Hypothesis**
+Likely a **timing issue** in the verification-system.js:
+1. Installation completes and writes manifest.json
+2. Verification runs immediately
+3. File system hasn't fully flushed the write
+4. Verification reads before file is available
+5. Alternative: Path expansion issue in verification code
+
+### **Recommended Fix** (for future task)
+1. Add a small delay (100-200ms) before verification
+2. Or use `fs.promises.access()` to ensure file exists before reading
+3. Or add retry logic (2-3 attempts) with backoff
+4. Check if path expansion is consistent between installation and verification
+
+### **Workaround**
+Installation works correctly despite the warning. Users can manually verify by:
+```bash
+ls -la ~/.claude/manifest.json
+cat ~/.claude/manifest.json
+```
+
+---
+
+## Issue #3: Default Installation Path May Conflict with Claude CLI Config
+
+### **Status**: ℹ️ **INFORMATIONAL**
+
+### **Description**
+The default installation path for Claude is `~/.claude`, which is also used by Claude Code CLI for its own configuration and session data.
+
+### **Observed Behavior**
+Claude Code CLI stores these files in `~/.claude`:
+- `debug/` - Debug logs
+- `projects/` - Project metadata
+- `session-env/` - Session environment data
+- `settings.json` - User settings
+- `stop-hook-git-check.sh` - Git hook
+- `shell-snapshots/` - Shell state
+- `statsig/` - Statistics/analytics
+- `todos/` - Todo lists
+
+Our installer adds:
+- `agents/` - Agent definitions
+- `skills/` - Skill definitions
+- `resources/` - Resource files
+- `hooks/` - Hook scripts
+- `manifest.json` - Installation manifest
+
+### **Impact**
+- Currently: No conflict observed - directories coexist successfully
+- Future risk: Claude Code CLI updates might interfere with installed packages
+- User confusion: Users might not understand which files belong to what
+
+### **Recommendation** (for future consideration)
+1. Consider alternative installation path like `~/.claude-code` or `~/.claude/packages`
+2. Or add namespace: `~/.claude/agentic-kit/`
+3. Document the shared directory usage
+4. Add detection logic to warn if files conflict
+5. Update PRD to clarify installation path strategy
+
+### **Current Status**
+No action required - works as designed. Documenting for future reference.
+
+---
+
+## Testing Summary
+
+### **Installation Lifecycle Tested**
+
+| Step | Variant | Files | Result | Notes |
+|------|---------|-------|--------|-------|
+| 1. Fresh Install | Lite | 104 files | ✅ Success | 4 agents, 7 skills |
+| 2. Upgrade | Lite → Standard | +9 files | ✅ Success | Now 9 agents, 11 skills |
+| 3. Upgrade | Standard → Pro | +15 files | ✅ Success | Now 13 agents, 22 skills |
+| 4. Uninstall (before fix) | Pro | 0 removed | ❌ Failed | Bug #1 |
+| 5. Uninstall (after fix) | Pro | 325 removed | ✅ Success | Bug fixed |
+| 6. Fresh Reinstall | Lite | 104 files | ✅ Success | Clean slate verified |
+
+### **Test Environment**
+
+```
+Platform: Linux 4.4.0 x64
+Node.js: v22.21.0
+Tool: Claude Code CLI (/opt/node22/bin/claude)
+Home: /root
+Installation Path: /root/.claude
+```
+
+### **Tools Availability**
+
+| Tool | Available | Tested |
+|------|-----------|--------|
+| Claude Code | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
+| Opencode | ❌ No | ⏭️ Skipped |
+| Ampcode | ❌ No | ⏭️ Skipped |
+| Droid | ❌ No | ⏭️ Skipped |
+
+### **Variant Verification**
+
+All variants tested and verified correct file counts:
+
+**Lite Variant:**
+- Expected: 4 agents, 7 skills, 6 resources, 2 hooks
+- Actual: ✅ 4 agents, ✅ 7 skills, ✅ 6 resources, ✅ 2 hooks
+- Agents: 1-create-prd, 2-generate-tasks, 3-process-task-list, master
+- Skills: brainstorming, code-review, docx, mcp-builder, pdf, root-cause-tracing, systematic-debugging
+
+**Standard Variant:**
+- Expected: 9 agents, 11 skills, 6 resources, 2 hooks
+- Actual: ✅ 9 agents, ✅ 11 skills, ✅ 6 resources, ✅ 2 hooks
+- Added Agents (+5): business-analyst, full-stack-dev, orchestrator, qa-test-architect, ux-expert
+- Added Skills (+4): skill-creator, verification-before-completion, webapp-testing, xlsx
+
+**Pro Variant:**
+- Expected: 13 agents, 22 skills, 6 resources, 2 hooks
+- Actual: ✅ 13 agents, ✅ 22 skills, ✅ 6 resources, ✅ 2 hooks
+- Added Agents (+4): holistic-architect, product-manager, product-owner, scrum-master
+- Added Skills (+11): algorithmic-art, artifacts-builder, brand-guidelines, canvas-design, condition-based-waiting, internal-comms, pptx, slack-gif-creator, test-driven-development, testing-anti-patterns, theme-factory
+
+### **Backup Creation**
+
+All backups created successfully:
+- Upgrade Lite→Standard: `/root/.claude.upgrade-backup.2025-11-05T10-27-33-501Z`
+- Upgrade Standard→Pro: `/root/.claude.upgrade-backup.2025-11-05T10-28-26-972Z`
+- Uninstall: `/root/.claude.uninstall-backup.2025-11-05T10-30-33-046Z`
+
+### **Manifest Integrity**
+
+Sample manifest.json verification (Lite variant):
+```json
+{
+  "tool": "claude",
+  "name": "Claude Code",
+  "variant": "lite",
+  "version": "1.1.0",
+  "installed_at": "2025-11-05T10:31:XX.XXXZ",
+  "components": {
+    "agents": 4,
+    "skills": 7,
+    "resources": 6,
+    "hooks": 2
+  },
+  "installedFiles": {
+    "agents": ["1-create-prd", "2-generate-tasks", "3-process-task-list", "master"],
+    "skills": ["brainstorming", "code-review", "docx", "mcp-builder", "pdf", "root-cause-tracing", "systematic-debugging"],
+    ...
+  },
+  "paths": {
+    "agents": "/root/.claude/agents",
+    "skills": "/root/.claude/skills",
+    "resources": "/root/.claude/resources",
+    "hooks": "/root/.claude/hooks"
+  }
+}
+```
+
+---
+
+## Recommendations
+
+### **Immediate Actions Required**
+1. ✅ **COMPLETED**: Fix uninstall bug (Issue #1) - DONE in this session
+2. ⏳ **TODO**: Fix verification timing issue (Issue #2) - Assign to task 9.4 (Security Review)
+
+### **Future Improvements**
+1. Add retry logic to verification with exponential backoff
+2. Consider installation path strategy (Issue #3)
+3. Test with other tools (Opencode, Ampcode, Droid) when available
+4. Add integration tests for complete lifecycle
+5. Document expected behavior when installing to Claude CLI directory
+6. Consider adding `--verify-only` flag to re-run verification
+
+### **Documentation Updates Needed**
+1. Update INSTALLER_GUIDE.md to mention verification timing issue
+2. Document the shared ~/.claude directory usage
+3. Add troubleshooting section for "Manifest not found" false positive
+4. Add FAQ: "Is it safe to install to ~/.claude?"
+
+---
+
+## Files Modified in This Session
+
+1. **installer/cli.js**
+   - Fixed uninstall argument order (line 376-385)
+   - Added `null` as confirmCallback argument
+
+---
+
+## Next Steps for Task 9.1
+
+- ✅ Fresh installation tested (Lite)
+- ✅ Upgrade tested (Lite → Standard → Pro)
+- ✅ Uninstall tested (bug found and fixed)
+- ✅ Fresh reinstallation tested
+- ⏭️ Opencode/Ampcode/Droid testing skipped (tools not available)
+- ✅ Integration issues documented
+- ⏳ Ready to proceed with task 9.2 (Installation Report Template)
+
+---
+
+**End of Integration Issues Report**