@adhdev/daemon-core 0.9.82-rc.40 → 0.9.82-rc.400

package/src/mesh/mesh-reconcile-loop.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,1550 @@
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+// mesh-reconcile-loop — periodic queue → live coordinator reconciliation
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+// Single-model replacement for the old event-based "spontaneous forward" paths
+// (remote P2P mesh_forward_event dispatch + live-CLI PTY fire-and-forget inject).
+// Those pushed events at the moment a worker transitioned state, and silently
+// dropped on the network (P2P) or when the coordinator was generating.
+//
+// The reliable backbone has always been the pending-events queue (SQLite +
+// JSONL): every mesh coordinator event is persisted there before anything else
+// (see injectMeshSystemMessage). What was missing was an *active* drainer that
+// runs on a schedule rather than only when the coordinator (an LLM) happens to
+// call a mesh tool.
+//
+// This loop is that drainer. On a fixed interval it:
+//   1. Finds live CLI coordinator sessions on THIS daemon (meshCoordinatorFor
+//      stamp). For each mesh, drains the local queue scoped to this daemon and
+//      injects pending events into the coordinator. When a coordinator is idle it
+//      receives every queued event. When ONLY generating coordinators exist (the
+//      common case while the coordinator is blocked awaiting a worker result), the
+//      loop force-drains ONLY the force-inject events (completion / approval / stop /
+//      refine·bootstrap terminal) and force-writes them into the generating PTY —
+//      the same busy-bypass send-guard escape the live-CLI inject used to use.
+//      Non-force progress events stay queued for the next idle tick (injecting them
+//      mid-generation would be noise). This is what makes a coordinator parked in
+//      `generating` while awaiting a worker's completion actually receive it.
+//   2. In cloud mode (dispatchMeshCommand present), pulls each remote worker
+//      node daemon's queue over P2P (get_pending_mesh_events) and re-injects via
+//      handleMeshForwardEvent — the same pull the MCP drainCoordinatorPendingEvents
+//      already does, now driven by the daemon timer instead of an LLM tool call.
+//
+// IMPORTANT — limits of this loop:
+//   - It only delivers to *live CLI coordinator instances* on this daemon. A
+//     pure stdio MCP coordinator (an LLM with no live CLI session to inject
+//     into) has no inject target here; that case stays pull-driven — the LLM
+//     drains the queue when it calls mesh_status / mesh_read_chat. We do NOT try
+//     to "wake" an LLM from the daemon; that is structurally impossible over a
+//     stdio request/response transport. See docs/refactoring/2026-06-15-mesh-event-to-queue-polling.md §4.7.
+//   - Queue persistence (queuePendingMeshCoordinatorEvent) and the SQLite
+//     drained=1 idempotency are the trust backbone and are untouched by this loop.
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+import type { DaemonComponents } from '../boot/daemon-lifecycle.js';
+import type { LocalMeshEntry } from '../repo-mesh-types.js';
+import { loadConfig } from '../config/config.js';
+import { listMeshes } from '../config/mesh-config.js';
+import { LOG } from '../logging/logger.js';
+import { drainPendingMeshCoordinatorEvents, getPendingMeshCoordinatorEvents, buildPendingEventFingerprint, queuePendingMeshCoordinatorEvent } from './mesh-events-pending.js';
+import type { PendingMeshCoordinatorEvent } from './mesh-events-pending.js';
+import { appendLedgerEntry } from './mesh-ledger.js';
+import { MeshRuntimeStore } from './mesh-runtime-store.js';
+import { handleMeshForwardEvent, shouldForceInjectMeshEvent, triggerMeshQueue, resolveForwardEventMeshId } from './mesh-events-coordinator.js';
+import {
+    peekUnresolvedDelegateForwards,
+    ackUnresolvedDelegateForward,
+    expireStaleUnresolvedDelegateForwards,
+} from './mesh-unresolved-forward-outbox.js';
+import { readNonEmptyString, readMeshCompletionSummary, buildMeshSystemMessage } from './mesh-events-utils.js';
+import { traceMeshEventStage, traceMeshEventDrop } from './mesh-event-trace.js';
+import { expandDaemonIdForms, daemonIdsEquivalent } from '@adhdev/mesh-shared';
+import { getActiveDirectDispatches, getQueue, reclaimStrandedAssignedTask, updateTaskStatus } from './mesh-work-queue.js';
+import { readLedgerEntries } from './mesh-ledger.js';
+import { pruneStaleDirectDispatches } from './mesh-active-work.js';
+import { findTerminalLedgerEvidenceForTask, reconcileDirectDispatchCompletionFromTranscript } from './mesh-events-stale.js';
+import { extractFinalAssistantSummaryEvidence } from '../providers/chat-message-normalization.js';
+import type { ChatMessage } from '../types.js';
+
+// Default reconcile cadence. approval/completion notifications to a live CLI
+// coordinator land within at most one interval. Overridable via env for tuning.
+const DEFAULT_RECONCILE_INTERVAL_MS = 4_000;
+
+// PHASE 5 (auto-prune) conservative age gate. A direct dispatch whose node/session is
+// orphaned (no longer in the live mesh) is only auto-pruned once it is at least this old,
+// measured from its dispatch time. This protects against a node/session that is only
+// *transiently* invisible (a momentary probe failure, a daemon restart) being pruned the
+// instant it disappears. The MANUAL prune (mesh_prune_stale_direct) has no age gate — an
+// operator pruning explicitly wants the orphan gone now. Overridable via env for tuning.
+const DEFAULT_AUTO_PRUNE_MIN_AGE_MS = 24 * 60 * 60_000; // 24h
+
+function resolveAutoPruneMinAgeMs(): number {
+    const raw = readNonEmptyString(process.env.MESH_AUTO_PRUNE_MIN_AGE_MS);
+    if (raw) {
+        const parsed = Number.parseInt(raw, 10);
+        // Clamp to [1h, 30d] so a mis-set env can't make the gate pathologically aggressive
+        // (prune the moment something blinks) or effectively disable it forever.
+        if (Number.isFinite(parsed) && parsed >= 60 * 60_000 && parsed <= 30 * 24 * 60 * 60_000) return parsed;
+    }
+    return DEFAULT_AUTO_PRUNE_MIN_AGE_MS;
+}
+
+function resolveReconcileIntervalMs(): number {
+    const raw = readNonEmptyString(process.env.MESH_RECONCILE_INTERVAL_MS);
+    if (raw) {
+        const parsed = Number.parseInt(raw, 10);
+        if (Number.isFinite(parsed) && parsed >= 1_000 && parsed <= 60_000) return parsed;
+    }
+    return DEFAULT_RECONCILE_INTERVAL_MS;
+}
+
+// RECONCILE-SYNTH-PREEMPTS-COMPLETION in-flight debounce. PHASE 4 only synthesizes a missing
+// completion when the worker session reads `idle`. But a worker that is GENUINELY generating
+// (it emitted agent:generating_started — the dispatch row is 'acked' — and has not yet
+// completed) can momentarily read `idle` mid-turn: a CLI PTY parser sees an inter-turn blip
+// between tool calls, or the read_chat probe races a brief settle. A single such idle read
+// must NOT fabricate a completion for an in-flight task — doing so writes a synthesized
+// terminal that then masks the REAL completion when it lands seconds later
+// (drop:duplicate_completion_terminal_ledger; the observed 71s task a250fb44 lost its [System]
+// notification this way). We require the session to read `idle` on CONSECUTIVE reconcile ticks
+// before synthesizing for an `acked` (started-generating) dispatch — a transient mid-turn idle
+// flicker clears on the next ~4s tick, whereas a genuinely-settled (completed-but-lost) or dead
+// session reads idle every tick. A dispatch that was never acked (worker never started) is NOT
+// debounced here: there is no in-flight generation to protect, and the downstream grace gate +
+// stale-summary guard remain the backstops for that lost-dispatch case.
+//
+// Keyed by `${meshId}::${taskId}`. The map is pruned each PHASE-4 pass to the set of currently
+// active dispatches, so a completed/pruned task's counter is dropped (no unbounded growth).
+const REQUIRED_CONSECUTIVE_IDLE_TICKS_FOR_INFLIGHT_SYNTH = 2;
+const inFlightIdleObservationCounts = new Map<string, number>();
+
+function inFlightSynthKey(meshId: string, taskId: string): string {
+    return `${meshId}::${taskId}`;
+}
+
+// Test hook: clear the in-flight idle debounce state between cases.
+export function __resetReconcileInFlightSynthDebounceForTests(): void {
+    inFlightIdleObservationCounts.clear();
+}
+
+interface LiveCoordinator {
+    meshId: string;
+    instance: ReturnType<DaemonComponents['instanceManager']['getInstance']>;
+    // Runtime session id of this coordinator instance (getState().instanceId). PHASE 2
+    // strict-matches an event's targetCoordinatorSessionId against this so a completion
+    // routes back to the exact originating coordinator session, not a sibling on the same
+    // daemon (the multi-coordinator misroute).
+    sessionId: string;
+    idle: boolean;
+    // True when the coordinator session is parked on a harness modal awaiting a
+    // human answer — claude-cli AskUserQuestion (waiting_choice) or a tool-consent
+    // prompt (waiting_approval). A force-inject into such a session would write raw
+    // keystrokes the modal key handler consumes, silently selecting a choice the
+    // user never made (data corruption). PHASE 2 excludes these from force-inject
+    // and leaves the event queued for a later (modal-resolved) tick.
+    modalParked: boolean;
+}
+
+// The set of coordinator-daemon ids THIS daemon answers to when draining the
+// pending-events queue. A unicast completion event is stamped with the worker's
+// meshCoordinatorDaemonId, which can be either:
+//   - the daemon's canonical status id (`standalone_<machineId>` / `daemon_<machineId>`),
+//     stamped by the MCP layer via ctx.localDaemonId (= getStatus().status.instanceId), or
+//   - the bare machineId, stamped by the local queue-assignment path (loadConfig().machineId).
+//   - the config-form node daemonId (`daemon_<machineId>`), which the MCP layer's
+//     resolveCoordinatorDaemonId prefers and stamps onto direct-dispatch workers.
+// Draining with only one of these silently misses events stamped with the other —
+// the exact reason a generating coordinator never self-received local completions,
+// and the base-node completion-surface bug (base completions land full-form
+// `daemon_<machineId>` while a coordinator that only knows itself as bare
+// `<machineId>` never matches them). We expand to EVERY equivalent form so the
+// scope match (host gate, self-node detection, and the drain IN-filter downstream)
+// succeeds regardless of which path stamped the event.
+function resolveCoordinatorDaemonIds(components: DaemonComponents): string[] {
+    const statusInstanceId = readNonEmptyString((components as { statusInstanceId?: string }).statusInstanceId);
+    const machineId = readNonEmptyString(loadConfig().machineId);
+    return expandDaemonIdForms([statusInstanceId, machineId]);
+}
+
+// Whether THIS daemon is the coordinator/host for a mesh — i.e. the daemon that
+// owns coordinator ownership and must collect every worker node's completion
+// events into its local queue. This is true regardless of whether a *live CLI*
+// coordinator session currently exists: the coordinator is frequently a pure
+// stdio MCP LLM (no live CLI session to inject into), and that LLM only sees the
+// queue when it next calls a mesh tool. For it to see remote worker completions
+// at all, the daemon must have already pulled them into the local queue on the
+// timer — which is exactly what this predicate gates.
+//
+// Rule: this daemon hosts the mesh when meshHost.role is 'host' (the default for
+// standalone-compat meshes with no host metadata) AND, when a hostDaemonId is
+// pinned, it resolves to one of this daemon's ids. Member-only daemons return
+// false — their own queue is pulled BY the host, not the other way around.
+//
+// `daemonIds` here is the EXPANDED self-identity set (runtime drain ids ∪ this
+// daemon's mesh-config node id forms) — see resolveCoordinatorSelfIds. The
+// pinned hostDaemonId is itself a config-form id and frequently does NOT equal a
+// runtime id (bare machineId / status id), so gating on the runtime ids alone
+// would wrongly classify the real host as a non-host and skip the remote pull
+// entirely.
+function daemonHostsMesh(mesh: LocalMeshEntry, daemonIds: string[]): boolean {
+    const host = mesh.meshHost;
+    // No metadata → default host (standalone compatibility, see createDefaultMeshHostMetadata).
+    if (!host) return true;
+    if (host.role && host.role !== 'host') return false;
+    const hostDaemonId = readNonEmptyString(host.hostDaemonId);
+    // Host role but no pinned hostDaemonId → treat as host (single-daemon / legacy).
+    if (!hostDaemonId) return true;
+    return daemonIdListIncludes(daemonIds, hostDaemonId);
+}
+
+function daemonIdListIncludes(ids: readonly string[], id: string | undefined): boolean {
+    if (!id) return false;
+    return ids.some(candidate => candidate === id || daemonIdsEquivalent(candidate, id));
+}
+
+// Resolve EVERY id-form this daemon answers to FOR A GIVEN MESH: the runtime drain
+// ids (status id + bare machineId) unioned with this daemon's mesh-config identity
+// forms — the self node's daemonId/machineId (the node whose daemonId/machineId
+// matches a runtime id) and the pinned meshHost.hostDaemonId WHEN it is provably
+// ours. This is the single source of truth for "is this id me?" across both the
+// host gate and the remote pull filter; the worker's meshCoordinatorDaemonId stamp
+// is guaranteed to be one of these forms (it comes from resolveCoordinatorDaemonId,
+// which prefers the coordinator node's config-form daemonId over the runtime status id).
+function resolveCoordinatorSelfIds(mesh: LocalMeshEntry, drainDaemonIds: string[]): string[] {
+    const ids = new Set<string>(drainDaemonIds);
+    // Expand with the config-form id(s) of the self node — the mesh node whose
+    // daemonId/machineId matches a runtime id. Its config-form daemonId is exactly
+    // what resolveCoordinatorNode()→resolveCoordinatorDaemonId() stamps onto a worker.
+    for (const node of mesh.nodes) {
+        const nodeDaemonId = readNonEmptyString(node.daemonId);
+        const nodeMachineId = readNonEmptyString(node.machineId);
+        const isSelf = (nodeDaemonId && daemonIdListIncludes(drainDaemonIds, nodeDaemonId))
+            || (nodeMachineId && daemonIdListIncludes(drainDaemonIds, nodeMachineId));
+        if (!isSelf) continue;
+        if (nodeDaemonId) ids.add(nodeDaemonId);
+        if (nodeMachineId) ids.add(nodeMachineId);
+    }
+    // The pinned host id is included ONLY when it is provably one of THIS daemon's ids
+    // (it already matches a runtime id or a resolved self-node id). A hostDaemonId that
+    // names a DIFFERENT daemon must NOT be claimed — that would make a member-only
+    // daemon believe it is the host and pull queues it does not own. Having a node on
+    // this daemon does not make this daemon the host; daemonHostsMesh still honours a
+    // foreign hostDaemonId and rejects ownership.
+    const hostDaemonId = readNonEmptyString(mesh.meshHost?.hostDaemonId);
+    if (hostDaemonId && daemonIdListIncludes([...ids], hostDaemonId)) ids.add(hostDaemonId);
+    return [...ids];
+}
+
+// Observability: last-seen modal-park state per coordinator session, so we LOG.info
+// only on a TRANSITION (clear → parked, parked → cleared) instead of every 4s tick.
+// Per-process; a restart re-logs the first observation, which is desirable — it
+// re-confirms a coordinator that is still parked after the restart (the exact
+// "restart does not clear it" symptom the operator needs visibility into).
+const coordinatorModalParkState = new Map<string, boolean>();
+
+// Find live CLI coordinator instances on THIS daemon, keyed by mesh.
+function findLiveCoordinators(components: DaemonComponents): LiveCoordinator[] {
+    const out: LiveCoordinator[] = [];
+    for (const inst of components.instanceManager.getByCategory('cli')) {
+        const state = inst.getState();
+        const settings = state.settings && typeof state.settings === 'object'
+            ? state.settings as Record<string, unknown>
+            : {};
+        const meshId = readNonEmptyString(settings.meshCoordinatorFor);
+        if (!meshId) continue;
+        const status = readNonEmptyString(state.status).toLowerCase();
+        // getState() overlays the modal-park statuses: an active AskUserQuestion
+        // prompt surfaces as waiting_choice, a tool-consent prompt as waiting_approval.
+        // Lowercase literal compare — the SessionStatus enum is forked across modules
+        // and waiting_choice is absent from some of them (see cli-provider-instance).
+        const modalParked = status === 'waiting_choice' || status === 'waiting_approval';
+        const sessionId = readNonEmptyString(state.instanceId);
+        // Modal-park transition observability: a coordinator entering modal-park is what
+        // begins holding completion events under `modal_parked`; one leaving it is what
+        // drains them. Both transitions were previously SILENT (the operator had no log
+        // to diagnose a stuck/held completion), so emit a single line per edge.
+        const stateKey = `${meshId}::${sessionId || '?'}`;
+        const prevParked = coordinatorModalParkState.get(stateKey);
+        if (prevParked !== modalParked) {
+            coordinatorModalParkState.set(stateKey, modalParked);
+            if (modalParked) {
+                LOG.info('MeshReconcile', `Coordinator ${sessionId || '?'} (mesh ${meshId}) entered modal-park (status=${status}) — terminal events for it will be held until the modal is answered`);
+            } else if (prevParked === true) {
+                LOG.info('MeshReconcile', `Coordinator ${sessionId || '?'} (mesh ${meshId}) left modal-park (status=${status}) — held events will drain on this/next tick`);
+            }
+        }
+        out.push({ meshId, instance: inst, sessionId, idle: status === 'idle', modalParked });
+    }
+    return out;
+}
+
+/**
+ * DRAIN-WITHOUT-INJECT guard. Classify, for a mesh on THIS daemon, whether a
+ * queue-drain caller (the MCP `get_pending_mesh_events` poll) may safely consume
+ * pending coordinator events — i.e. whether there is a surface that will actually
+ * deliver them.
+ *
+ * Root cause being guarded: `get_pending_mesh_events` marks rows drained=1
+ * atomically and unconditionally. When the live CLI coordinator for the mesh is
+ * GENERATING (or modal-parked), the reconcile loop correctly HOLDS its terminal
+ * events (drained=0) for the coordinator's next idle tick — but a concurrent MCP
+ * poll draining the SAME queue consumes those held rows into a tool result that
+ * the busy coordinator never surfaces as a turn, so the completion is lost
+ * forever (drained=1, never re-queued). The reconcile loop is the authoritative
+ * delivery path for a live CLI coordinator; the MCP poll must defer to it.
+ *
+ * Returns:
+ *  - hasLiveCliCoordinator: a CLI session with meshCoordinatorFor === meshId
+ *    exists on this daemon (the reconcile loop owns its delivery).
+ *  - deliverableNow: there is an IDLE live CLI coordinator (reconcile would
+ *    full-drain into it) — draining now is safe and equivalent.
+ *  - holdForReconcile: a live CLI coordinator exists but is non-idle
+ *    (generating / modal-parked). The MCP poll MUST NOT drain; the reconcile
+ *    loop holds the events undrained and injects them on the next idle tick.
+ *
+ * A mesh with NO live CLI coordinator on this daemon is a pure stdio MCP / LLM
+ * coordinator: the MCP tool result IS the only surface, so the poll legitimately
+ * drains (holdForReconcile=false). No regression to that path.
+ */
+export function resolveCoordinatorDrainDeliverability(
+    components: Pick<DaemonComponents, 'instanceManager'>,
+    meshId: string,
+): { hasLiveCliCoordinator: boolean; deliverableNow: boolean; holdForReconcile: boolean } {
+    const coordinators = findLiveCoordinators(components as DaemonComponents).filter(c => c.meshId === meshId);
+    if (coordinators.length === 0) {
+        return { hasLiveCliCoordinator: false, deliverableNow: false, holdForReconcile: false };
+    }
+    const hasIdle = coordinators.some(c => c.idle);
+    return {
+        hasLiveCliCoordinator: true,
+        deliverableNow: hasIdle,
+        // A live CLI coordinator exists but none is idle → the reconcile loop is
+        // holding the events; the poll must not steal them.
+        holdForReconcile: !hasIdle,
+    };
+}
+
+/**
+ * DRAIN-WITHOUT-INJECT guard for the `get_pending_mesh_events` daemon handler.
+ *
+ * Decides whether an incoming pending-events DRAIN must be held (return nothing,
+ * leave rows drained=0) because the only surface for those events is a LOCAL live
+ * CLI coordinator that is currently busy (generating / modal-parked) — in which
+ * case the reconcile loop owns delivery on the coordinator's next idle tick, and
+ * the poll draining them now would lose them.
+ *
+ * The hold applies ONLY when BOTH:
+ *   1) a live CLI coordinator for this mesh on THIS daemon is non-idle, AND
+ *   2) the drain is targeted at THIS daemon (the requested coordinatorDaemonId is
+ *      empty/broadcast, or matches one of this daemon's id forms).
+ *
+ * A REMOTE coordinator pulling our worker's events passes its own (remote)
+ * coordinatorDaemonId — condition (2) is false — so the drain proceeds and the
+ * remote pull is never blocked by our local coordinator's busy state. A pure
+ * stdio MCP coordinator (no live CLI session) never satisfies (1), so its tool
+ * result remains the surface and the drain proceeds. No regression to either.
+ */
+export function shouldHoldPendingDrainForBusyLocalCoordinator(
+    components: Pick<DaemonComponents, 'instanceManager'> & { statusInstanceId?: string },
+    meshId: string,
+    requestedCoordinatorDaemonId?: string | null,
+): boolean {
+    if (!meshId) return false;
+    const deliverability = resolveCoordinatorDrainDeliverability(components, meshId);
+    if (!deliverability.holdForReconcile) return false;
+    // The local CLI coordinator is busy. Hold only when the drain is for THIS daemon.
+    const requested = readNonEmptyString(requestedCoordinatorDaemonId);
+    if (!requested) return true; // broadcast drain → would consume the held local events
+    const localIds = expandDaemonIdForms([
+        readNonEmptyString((components as { statusInstanceId?: string }).statusInstanceId),
+        readNonEmptyString(loadConfig().machineId),
+    ]);
+    return localIds.some(id => daemonIdsEquivalent(id, requested));
+}
+
+// Inject a drained pending event into a live coordinator session. Force-inject
+// events carry force:true so they bypass the busy send-guard and land in the PTY
+// even while the coordinator is generating (see shouldForceInjectMeshEvent).
+function injectPendingIntoCoordinator(
+    coordinator: LiveCoordinator['instance'],
+    pending: PendingMeshCoordinatorEvent,
+): void {
+    if (!coordinator) return;
+    // NOTIF-DROP-SYNTH-NO-MESSAGE (defence-in-depth): a queued event with no coordinatorMessage
+    // used to be dropped here (drain-without-inject) — the row had already been consumed
+    // (drained=1) by the caller's drain, so silently returning lost it forever. The primary fix
+    // makes the transcript-reconcile synth always carry a coordinatorMessage, but as a backstop,
+    // lazily synthesize the [System] text for any force-inject (terminal: completion / approval /
+    // stop / refine·bootstrap) event that still arrives message-less, so it surfaces instead of
+    // vanishing. A NON-force lifecycle event (agent:ready / generating_started) legitimately
+    // carries no message and must NOT be injected (it is queued only to re-drive the claim state
+    // machine on pull) — for it we still return without injecting.
+    let coordinatorMessage = pending.coordinatorMessage;
+    if (!coordinatorMessage) {
+        if (!shouldForceInjectMeshEvent(pending.event)) return;
+        const metadataEvent = pending.metadataEvent && typeof pending.metadataEvent === 'object'
+            ? pending.metadataEvent
+            : {};
+        coordinatorMessage = buildMeshSystemMessage({
+            event: pending.event,
+            nodeLabel: pending.nodeLabel,
+            metadataEvent,
+        });
+        if (!coordinatorMessage) return; // builder produced nothing — nothing to surface
+        LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Lazily synthesized missing coordinatorMessage for ${pending.event} (mesh ${pending.meshId}) at inject time — a queued terminal event arrived message-less`);
+    }
+    const force = shouldForceInjectMeshEvent(pending.event);
+    // EVTTRACE: event surfaced to the coordinator (injected into its live CLI session).
+    // This is the terminal happy-path stage. Observation only.
+    traceMeshEventStage('surfaced', {
+        taskId: pending.metadataEvent?.taskId,
+        sessionId: pending.metadataEvent?.targetSessionId ?? pending.targetCoordinatorSessionId,
+        nodeId: pending.nodeId,
+        meshId: pending.meshId,
+        event: pending.event,
+    }, force ? 'force-inject' : 'inject');
+    coordinator.onEvent('send_message', {
+        input: { text: coordinatorMessage, textFallback: coordinatorMessage },
+        ...(force ? { force: true } : {}),
+    });
+}
+
+// Held-event ledger dedup: fingerprints of held terminal events already written as an
+// `event_held` ledger audit record in THIS process. Prevents the 4s reconcile tick from
+// re-logging the same held event every interval while a coordinator stays modal-parked.
+// Per-process only (not persisted) — if the daemon restarts while an event is still held
+// it is re-logged once, which is desirable: it re-confirms the event is still undelivered.
+const heldEventLedgerRecorded = new Set<string>();
+
+// C1 (data safety): when a terminal completion/approval/bootstrap event cannot be
+// delivered because the only coordinators are modal-parked, the event is held at
+// drained=0 in the pending queue (SQLite + JSONL) for a later tick. That queue is
+// disk-persisted but carries no operator-visible audit trail and can be silently
+// dropped by the pending-file trim (100 KB / 50-entry cap). To guarantee a held
+// completion's worker summary is never silently lost, mirror each held terminal event
+// into the coordinator's mesh ledger as an `event_held` entry — auditable and
+// recoverable (the finalSummary survives even if the pending copy is later trimmed or
+// the coordinator session is force-resolved before re-drain). Idempotent per process
+// via heldEventLedgerRecorded so a long modal park does not spam the ledger.
+function recordHeldTerminalEventsToLedger(
+    meshId: string,
+    drainDaemonIds: string[],
+    reason: string,
+    heldForCoordinatorCount: number,
+): void {
+    let pending: readonly PendingMeshCoordinatorEvent[];
+    try {
+        pending = getPendingMeshCoordinatorEvents(meshId, drainDaemonIds.length > 0 ? drainDaemonIds : undefined);
+    } catch {
+        return; // best-effort audit — never let a peek failure break the tick
+    }
+    for (const event of pending) {
+        // Only audit terminal/force-inject events (completion / approval / stop / refine·
+        // bootstrap). Silent lifecycle events (agent:ready / generating_started) carry no
+        // worker output to preserve and re-drain harmlessly, so they need no audit trail.
+        if (!shouldForceInjectMeshEvent(event.event)) continue;
+        const fingerprint = buildPendingEventFingerprint(event);
+        const key = `${meshId}::${fingerprint || `${event.event}::${event.nodeId || ''}::${event.queuedAt}`}`;
+        if (heldEventLedgerRecorded.has(key)) continue;
+        heldEventLedgerRecorded.add(key);
+        const finalSummary = readMeshCompletionSummary(event.metadataEvent);
+        try {
+            appendLedgerEntry(meshId, {
+                kind: 'event_held',
+                ...(event.nodeId ? { nodeId: event.nodeId } : {}),
+                payload: {
+                    event: event.event,
+                    reason,
+                    recoverable: true,
+                    heldForCoordinators: heldForCoordinatorCount,
+                    nodeLabel: event.nodeLabel,
+                    ...(event.workspace ? { workspace: event.workspace } : {}),
+                    targetCoordinatorDaemonId: event.targetCoordinatorDaemonId ?? null,
+                    queuedAt: event.queuedAt,
+                    ...(fingerprint ? { fingerprint } : {}),
+                    ...(finalSummary ? { finalSummary } : {}),
+                },
+            });
+            LOG.info('MeshReconcile', `Ledger-recorded held ${event.event} for mesh ${meshId} (reason ${reason}) — recoverable from ledger`);
+        } catch (e: any) {
+            // Failed to persist — drop the dedup marker so the next tick retries.
+            heldEventLedgerRecorded.delete(key);
+            LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Failed to ledger-record held ${event.event} for mesh ${meshId}: ${e?.message || e}`);
+        }
+    }
+}
+
+// One reconcile tick. Two independent phases:
+//
+//   PHASE 1 — Remote queue pull (the fix for remote worktree completions never
+//     reaching an MCP/LLM coordinator). For EVERY mesh this daemon hosts/
+//     coordinates, pull each remote worker node's pending-events queue over P2P
+//     into THIS daemon's local queue. This runs *regardless of whether a live CLI
+//     coordinator exists* — the coordinator is usually a pure stdio MCP LLM with
+//     no live CLI session, and it can only observe a remote worker's completion
+//     once that event has been pulled into the local queue (which it then drains
+//     on its next mesh tool call). Previously this pull was gated behind a live
+//     CLI coordinator and so never ran for MCP/LLM coordinators — remote
+//     completions sat on the remote node's queue until the LLM happened to call
+//     mesh_read_chat, which triggered the MCP-side pull. The daemon now does it
+//     autonomously on the timer. Standalone (no dispatchMeshCommand) skips this
+//     phase entirely — there are no remote nodes to pull from.
+//
+//   PHASE 2 — Live CLI inject. For each mesh that has a live CLI coordinator on
+//     THIS daemon, drain the local queue and inject pending events into the PTY.
+//     Unchanged from before.
+// Bug B: how long a row may sit 'assigned' with an unconfirmed dispatch before the
+// watchdog reclaims it. Must be comfortably larger than the per-dispatch confirm
+// timeout (DISPATCH_CONFIRM_TIMEOUT_MS in mesh-events-coordinator) so a slow-but-live
+// dispatch still inside its normal confirm window is never reclaimed early — this is
+// the durable backstop for the case the in-process confirm timer can't cover (a timer
+// lost to a daemon restart between claim and confirm).
+const ASSIGNED_STRANDED_DEADLINE_MS = 5 * 60_000;
+
+// PHASE 2.5 — assigned-stranded dispatch watchdog (Bug B). claimNextTask atomically
+// flips a row to 'assigned' BEFORE the fire-and-forget dispatch runs. If that dispatch
+// neither rejects (→ no .catch requeue) nor is confirmed delivered — a relay that hangs
+// without acking, or a confirm timer lost across a restart — the row stays 'assigned'
+// forever: it contributes 0 pending, so PHASE 3 (gated on pendingQueueTaskCount>0) never
+// re-examines it, and nothing but a manual requeue clears it. This is that missing net.
+//
+// Regression guard: a row whose delivery IS confirmed (delivered/acked/completed) is a
+// genuinely in-flight (or completion-lost) task — left to PHASE 4's completion reconcile,
+// never reclaimed here. And the deadline is generous so a slow-but-live dispatch still in
+// its normal confirm window is never reclaimed early. Reclaimed rows return to 'pending'
+// with ownership cleared, so the PHASE 3 trigger below re-dispatches them this same tick.
+function recoverStrandedAssignedDispatches(meshId: string, store: MeshRuntimeStore): void {
+    const assigned = getQueue(meshId, { status: ['assigned'] });
+    if (!assigned.length) return;
+    const nowMs = Date.now();
+    for (const row of assigned) {
+        const dispatchedAtMs = Date.parse(row.dispatchTimestamp ?? '');
+        if (!Number.isFinite(dispatchedAtMs)) continue;              // no dispatch ts → can't age it
+        if (nowMs - dispatchedAtMs < ASSIGNED_STRANDED_DEADLINE_MS) continue;  // still in confirm window
+        const terminal = findTerminalLedgerEvidenceForTask({
+            meshId,
+            taskId: row.id,
+        });
+        if (terminal) {
+            const status = terminal.kind === 'task_completed' ? 'completed' : 'failed';
+            updateTaskStatus(meshId, row.id, status);
+            LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Skipped stranded reclaim redispatch for terminal task ${row.id} on mesh ${meshId}; ${terminal.kind} ledger evidence already exists`);
+            traceMeshEventDrop('assigned_stranded_terminal_ledger', {
+                taskId: row.id,
+                sessionId: row.assignedSessionId,
+                nodeId: row.assignedNodeId,
+                meshId,
+                event: 'agent:generating_completed',
+            }, terminal.kind);
+            continue;
+        }
+        if (store.taskHasConfirmedDelivery(meshId, row.id)) continue;          // dispatched → PHASE 4's job
+        const reclaimed = reclaimStrandedAssignedTask(meshId, row.id, {
+            reason: 'assigned_stranded_dispatch_unconfirmed',
+            ageMs: nowMs - dispatchedAtMs,
+        });
+        if (reclaimed) {
+            LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Reclaimed stranded assigned task ${row.id} on mesh ${meshId} `
+                + `(node=${row.assignedNodeId ?? '?'} session=${row.assignedSessionId ?? '?'}, dispatched `
+                + `${Math.round((nowMs - dispatchedAtMs) / 1000)}s ago, never confirmed delivered → ${reclaimed.status})`);
+            // EVTTRACE: the dispatch for this task was stranded (assigned, never confirmed
+            // delivered) and reclaimed (CANON-B) — its expected completion event never
+            // arrived. Observation only; the reclaim decision above is unchanged.
+            traceMeshEventDrop('assigned_stranded_reclaim', {
+                taskId: row.id,
+                sessionId: row.assignedSessionId,
+                nodeId: row.assignedNodeId,
+                meshId,
+                event: 'agent:generating_completed',
+            }, `unconfirmed ${Math.round((nowMs - dispatchedAtMs) / 1000)}s → ${reclaimed.status}`);
+        }
+    }
+}
+
+export async function runMeshReconcileTick(components: DaemonComponents): Promise<void> {
+    const localDaemonId = readNonEmptyString(loadConfig().machineId) || undefined;
+    // The id-set used to scope the local queue drain (status id + machineId). See
+    // resolveCoordinatorDaemonIds — the status id is what the MCP layer stamps and
+    // is mandatory here for a generating CLI coordinator to self-receive completions.
+    const drainDaemonIds = resolveCoordinatorDaemonIds(components);
+    const dispatchMeshCommand = components.dispatchMeshCommand;
+    const store = (() => {
+        try { return MeshRuntimeStore.getInstance(); } catch { return undefined; }
+    })();
+
+    // ── PHASE 0: retry the worker-side unresolved-delegate forward outbox ──────
+    // Cloud-only (needs dispatchMeshCommand). A worker that is NOT a member of the
+    // coordinator's mesh cannot be reached by the coordinator's PHASE 1 pull (it is
+    // in no mesh.node), so its completion must be PUSHED to the coordinator. This
+    // drains the durable outbox enqueued by forwardUnresolvedDelegateEvent and retries
+    // any push that has not yet been acked. See mesh-unresolved-forward-outbox.ts.
+    if (dispatchMeshCommand) {
+        try {
+            await retryUnresolvedDelegateForwards(components);
+        } catch (e: any) {
+            LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Unresolved-delegate forward retry failed: ${e?.message || e}`);
+        }
+    }
+
+    // ── PHASE 1: pull remote node queues for every mesh this daemon hosts ──────
+    // Cloud-only (dispatchMeshCommand present). Runs whether or not a live CLI
+    // coordinator exists — this is what lets an MCP/LLM coordinator ever see a
+    // remote worker's completion.
+    if (dispatchMeshCommand) {
+        for (const mesh of listMeshes()) {
+            // Expand to every id-form this daemon answers to for this mesh (runtime
+            // drain ids ∪ config-form node/host ids) and use it for BOTH the host gate
+            // and the remote pull filter, so a worker stamp in any form is recovered.
+            const selfIds = resolveCoordinatorSelfIds(mesh, drainDaemonIds);
+            if (!daemonHostsMesh(mesh, selfIds)) continue;
+            try {
+                await pullRemoteNodeQueues(components, mesh, localDaemonId, selfIds);
+            } catch (e: any) {
+                LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Remote node pull failed for mesh ${mesh.id}: ${e?.message || e}`);
+            }
+        }
+    }
+
+    // ── PHASE 2.5: assigned-stranded dispatch watchdog (Bug B) ─────────────────
+    // Runs before PHASE 3 so any row it returns to 'pending' is re-dispatched by the
+    // PHASE 3 trigger in this same tick. See recoverStrandedAssignedDispatches.
+    if (store) {
+        for (const mesh of listMeshes()) {
+            const selfIds = resolveCoordinatorSelfIds(mesh, drainDaemonIds);
+            if (!daemonHostsMesh(mesh, selfIds)) continue;
+            try {
+                recoverStrandedAssignedDispatches(mesh.id, store);
+            } catch (e: any) {
+                LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Assigned-stranded watchdog failed for mesh ${mesh.id}: ${e?.message || e}`);
+            }
+        }
+    }
+
+    // ── PHASE 3: recover pending queue claims for newly-idle sessions ──────────
+    // The event-driven claim paths (agent:ready / agent:generating_completed in
+    // mesh-events-coordinator) re-claim the queue the moment a session goes idle,
+    // but that depends on a single event being emitted AND (for a remote node)
+    // successfully forwarded to this coordinator. If that event is missed/dropped,
+    // a pending task targeting a now-idle session would sit unclaimed forever —
+    // there was no periodic safety net. This phase is that net: for every mesh this
+    // daemon hosts that has at least one pending task, run one triggerMeshQueue so a
+    // session that became idle without a delivered ready-event still gets its work.
+    //
+    // O(1) guard: skip the (relatively expensive) full idle-session + remote-idle
+    // scan entirely when the queue has no pending tasks — a COUNT(*) over the
+    // indexed status column, so an idle mesh costs one cheap query per tick.
+    // claimNextQueueTask is atomic, so racing the event-driven path can only have
+    // one winner; double-claiming is impossible.
+    for (const mesh of listMeshes()) {
+        const selfIds = resolveCoordinatorSelfIds(mesh, drainDaemonIds);
+        if (!daemonHostsMesh(mesh, selfIds)) continue;
+        if (store) {
+            try {
+                if (store.pendingQueueTaskCount(mesh.id) === 0) continue;
+            } catch { /* fall through and let triggerMeshQueue decide */ }
+        }
+        try {
+            await triggerMeshQueue(components, mesh.id);
+        } catch (e: any) {
+            LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Pending-claim recovery trigger failed for mesh ${mesh.id}: ${e?.message || e}`);
+        }
+    }
+
+    // ── PHASE 4: synthesize lost completions for unterminated direct dispatches ─
+    // Symmetric to PHASE 3 (which recovers a *lost claim* for a newly-idle session)
+    // but for the opposite gap: a worker that ALREADY completed, went idle, and
+    // whose terminal completion event was never persisted (dropped before reaching
+    // the queue/outbox, or its forward was lost). PHASE 1/2/3 can only deliver an
+    // event that exists in a queue — they cannot recover a completion that was
+    // never recorded, so the coordinator keeps believing the worker is generating.
+    //
+    // reconcileDirectDispatchCompletionFromTranscript already synthesizes the
+    // missing terminal event from the worker's transcript, but until now it ran
+    // ONLY when an LLM coordinator polled mesh_status (mcp_mesh_status_transcript_
+    // reconciliation). This phase pulls that same correction onto the daemon timer
+    // so it no longer depends on the LLM polling. The reconcile is idempotent
+    // (hasTerminalLedgerAfterDispatch guards against re-synthesis), so attempting it
+    // every tick for the same dispatch is safe — once a terminal exists it no-ops.
+    for (const mesh of listMeshes()) {
+        const selfIds = resolveCoordinatorSelfIds(mesh, drainDaemonIds);
+        if (!daemonHostsMesh(mesh, selfIds)) continue;
+        try {
+            await reconcileUnterminatedDirectDispatches(components, mesh, selfIds, localDaemonId);
+        } catch (e: any) {
+            LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Completion reconcile failed for mesh ${mesh.id}: ${e?.message || e}`);
+        }
+    }
+
+    // ── PHASE 5: auto-prune orphaned direct dispatch records ───────────────────
+    // staleDirectWork (orphaned direct-dispatch rows whose node/session is no longer in the
+    // live mesh) otherwise accumulates indefinitely: a removed worktree node or a cleanly
+    // terminated session leaves its direct-dispatch row behind, stuck in a non-terminal status
+    // (e.g. generating) for days. This is NOT a false-idle bug — it is the separate problem of
+    // orphaned records that the only existing cleanup path (manual MCP mesh_prune_stale_direct)
+    // never reaches unless an operator runs it by hand.
+    //
+    // This phase runs the SAME prune core the manual tool calls (pruneStaleDirectDispatches),
+    // in execute mode, on the daemon timer. The only difference from the manual path is a
+    // conservative age gate (DEFAULT_AUTO_PRUNE_MIN_AGE_MS): a freshly-orphaned record is held
+    // back until it is provably stale, so a transient probe miss never auto-prunes live work.
+    // Every other safety rule is inherited unchanged from the core — active/pending/generating
+    // work and fresh unacknowledged dispatch failures are never pruned, ledger-only audit entries
+    // are preserved, and the prune itself is recorded with a direct_dispatch_pruned ledger entry.
+    // Idempotent: a pruned row is gone from getActiveDirectDispatches, so the next tick finds
+    // nothing to re-prune. Isolated in its own try/catch per mesh so it can never kill the tick.
+    {
+        const minAgeMs = resolveAutoPruneMinAgeMs();
+        for (const mesh of listMeshes()) {
+            const selfIds = resolveCoordinatorSelfIds(mesh, drainDaemonIds);
+            if (!daemonHostsMesh(mesh, selfIds)) continue;
+            try {
+                await autoPruneStaleDirectDispatches(components, mesh, selfIds, localDaemonId, minAgeMs);
+            } catch (e: any) {
+                LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Auto-prune stale direct failed for mesh ${mesh.id}: ${e?.message || e}`);
+            }
+        }
+    }
+
+    // ── PHASE 2: inject into live CLI coordinators on this daemon ──────────────
+    const coordinators = findLiveCoordinators(components);
+    if (coordinators.length === 0) {
+        // No live CLI coordinator on this daemon — nothing to inject into.
+        // (MCP-only LLM coordinators drain the local queue via their own tool
+        //  calls; PHASE 1 above has already populated it from remote nodes.)
+        return;
+    }
+
+    // Group coordinators by mesh; multiple coordinator instances for one mesh is
+    // unusual but supported (each gets the same drained events).
+    const byMesh = new Map<string, LiveCoordinator[]>();
+    for (const c of coordinators) {
+        const list = byMesh.get(c.meshId);
+        if (list) list.push(c);
+        else byMesh.set(c.meshId, [c]);
+    }
+
+    for (const [meshId, meshCoordinators] of byMesh) {
+        // Drain the local queue scoped to this coordinator daemon and inject.
+        //     - If an idle coordinator exists, FULL-drain and deliver every event to it
+        //       (the idle input box accepts the prompt as a real next turn). The drain
+        //       marks consumed rows drained=1 atomically, so the pull path can't re-deliver.
+        //     - If only GENERATING coordinators exist (no idle target), we HOLD: leave the
+        //       events queued (drained=0) for the coordinator's next idle/turn-end tick.
+        //
+        // NOTIF-SURFACE-LOCAL (false-idle hold): we used to force-inject terminal events
+        // (completion/approval/stop/refine·bootstrap) straight into a *generating*
+        // coordinator's PTY (forceSendMessage → atomic content+\r write), on the theory it
+        // bypassed the busy send-guard and broke the await-result deadlock. But a raw PTY
+        // write into a claude-cli that is mid-generation is NOT consumed as a new turn — the
+        // bytes land in the terminal input buffer and the LLM never reads them on its next
+        // turn. The `surfaced/force-inject` trace fired, the row was marked drained=1, and the
+        // genuine completion was lost forever (the exact same-daemon local-worktree miss: the
+        // coordinator's OWN session is generating at the moment its worker completes). The
+        // deadlock the force path guarded against does not actually require force: a
+        // coordinator that dispatched a task via mesh_send_task returns to idle when that
+        // tool call resolves (dispatch is fire-and-forget; the worker runs for minutes while
+        // the coordinator is idle/between turns), so the completion lands on the very next
+        // idle tick (≤ one reconcile interval). Holding the event undrained for that idle
+        // tick is therefore the single, reliable delivery — and it is the SAME skip-and-hold
+        // the modal-park branch below already uses. This also makes double-injection
+        // structurally impossible: there is exactly one delivery path (the idle full-drain),
+        // so we never need a surface-time fingerprint to dedup a force-write against a re-drain.
+        const idleCoordinators = meshCoordinators.filter(c => c.idle);
+        // A coordinator parked on a harness modal (waiting_choice / waiting_approval) is
+        // non-idle; it is held under the modal-park branch (a force-inject into a modal would
+        // write raw keystrokes the modal key handler eats, silently selecting a choice the
+        // user never made). A plainly-generating coordinator (non-idle, non-modal-parked) is
+        // ALSO held now — for the false-idle reason above — but separately, so the C1 ledger
+        // audit and the operator-facing skip log can name the right hold reason.
+        const generatingCoordinators = meshCoordinators.filter(c => !c.idle && !c.modalParked);
+        const modalParkedCoordinators = meshCoordinators.filter(c => !c.idle && c.modalParked);
+        // Only an IDLE coordinator is a deliverable target. A generating coordinator's PTY
+        // does not consume an injected prompt as a turn, so it is held (not a target).
+        const targetCoordinators = idleCoordinators;
+
+        // ── no-idle-target short-circuit (MUST precede the drain) ─────────────────
+        // When there is no IDLE coordinator for this mesh — only generating and/or
+        // modal-parked ones — there is nowhere a queued event can land as a real turn.
+        // We skip-and-hold: by NOT draining we leave the events at drained=0 in the queue,
+        // so a later tick (once a coordinator returns to idle) delivers them. This
+        // short-circuit MUST run BEFORE drainPendingMeshCoordinatorEvents — the drain marks
+        // rows drained=1 atomically, which would lose the events for a coordinator that is
+        // only transiently busy (the false-idle local-worktree miss). Both the generating
+        // hold and the modal-park hold record a C1 ledger audit copy so a held completion's
+        // worker summary is recoverable even if the coordinator never returns or the pending
+        // file is later trimmed.
+        if (targetCoordinators.length === 0) {
+            if (modalParkedCoordinators.length > 0) {
+                // ── orphan escape (MUST precede the blanket modal-park hold) ──────────
+                // A modal-parked coordinator with no idle/generating sibling otherwise
+                // wedges EVERY pending event under `modal_parked` until that modal resolves
+                // — including a STRICT-routed completion whose originating coordinator
+                // session is GONE (an orphan: the worktree/session that produced it was
+                // removed, or that coordinator session died). Such an event will never be
+                // deliverable to its target session no matter what the modal-parked sibling
+                // does, so holding it under modal_parked is a permanent-held leak (the very
+                // "data restart re-reproduces it" symptom — the gate is reconstructed live
+                // from the still-parked modal, so a restart does not clear it). Route those
+                // orphan events through the strict-route hold/expire path so the bounded
+                // STRICT_SESSION_MATCH_TTL eventually expires them (recoverable, ledgered)
+                // instead of leaving them held forever. A strict event whose target session
+                // IS live but merely modal-parked is left to the blanket hold below (it is
+                // genuinely transiently blocked, not orphaned).
+                const liveSessionIds = new Set(
+                    meshCoordinators.map(c => readNonEmptyString(c.sessionId)).filter(Boolean),
+                );
+                let orphanEscaped = 0;
+                const hasPendingForOrphanPeek = !store
+                    || (() => { try { return store.pendingEventCount(meshId) > 0; } catch { return true; } })();
+                if (hasPendingForOrphanPeek) {
+                    // Identify which pending event NAMES correspond to orphan-targeted events
+                    // (a strict targetCoordinatorSessionId that matches no live coordinator).
+                    let peeked: readonly PendingMeshCoordinatorEvent[] = [];
+                    try {
+                        peeked = getPendingMeshCoordinatorEvents(meshId, drainDaemonIds.length > 0 ? drainDaemonIds : undefined);
+                    } catch { peeked = []; }
+                    const isOrphan = (e: PendingMeshCoordinatorEvent): boolean => {
+                        const want = readNonEmptyString(e.targetCoordinatorSessionId);
+                        return !!want && !liveSessionIds.has(want);
+                    };
+                    const orphanEventNames = new Set(peeked.filter(isOrphan).map(e => e.event));
+                    if (orphanEventNames.size > 0) {
+                        // The drain filter is event-NAME scoped (not per-row), so draining by the
+                        // orphan event names also pulls any non-orphan event sharing that name. Drain
+                        // them all, then re-route: orphan-targeted events go through the strict-route
+                        // hold/expire path (bounded TTL → eventually ledger-expired, recoverable);
+                        // non-orphan events of the same name are re-queued unchanged (queuedAt
+                        // preserved) so they remain genuinely held for their still-live, modal-parked
+                        // target. This is the same per-event strict routing PHASE 2 does below — just
+                        // reached here because the blanket modal-park short-circuit would otherwise
+                        // wedge the orphans forever.
+                        let drained: PendingMeshCoordinatorEvent[] = [];
+                        try {
+                            drained = drainPendingMeshCoordinatorEvents(
+                                meshId,
+                                drainDaemonIds.length > 0 ? drainDaemonIds : localDaemonId,
+                                { onlyEvents: orphanEventNames },
+                            );
+                        } catch (e: any) {
+                            LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Orphan-escape drain failed for mesh ${meshId}: ${e?.message || e}`);
+                            drained = [];
+                        }
+                        for (const pending of drained) {
+                            if (isOrphan(pending)) {
+                                holdOrExpireStrictUnmatchedEvent(pending, readNonEmptyString(pending.targetCoordinatorSessionId), meshId);
+                                orphanEscaped++;
+                            } else {
+                                // Still-live (modal-parked) target — re-queue unchanged so it is held
+                                // for the next modal-resolved tick, exactly like the blanket hold would.
+                                try { queuePendingMeshCoordinatorEvent(pending); } catch { /* best-effort re-queue */ }
+                            }
+                        }
+                    }
+                }
+                LOG.info('MeshReconcile', `Reconcile skip → modal-parked: holding pending event(s) for mesh ${meshId} (${modalParkedCoordinators.length} coordinator(s) awaiting a modal answer; events left queued${orphanEscaped > 0 ? `; ${orphanEscaped} orphan-targeted event(s) routed to strict-route TTL` : ''})`);
+                // C1: mirror held terminal events into the ledger so a held completion's
+                // worker summary is auditable/recoverable even if the modal is never
+                // resolved, the coordinator restarts, or the pending file is later trimmed.
+                // The events stay queued (drained=0) for re-drain on a later tick; this only
+                // adds the durable audit copy. Idempotent per process — only newly-held
+                // events are logged. O(1)-gated: skip the peek when the queue is empty.
+                let hasPending = true;
+                if (store) {
+                    try { hasPending = store.pendingEventCount(meshId) > 0; } catch { /* peek below */ }
+                }
+                if (hasPending) {
+                    recordHeldTerminalEventsToLedger(
+                        meshId,
+                        drainDaemonIds.length > 0 ? drainDaemonIds : (localDaemonId ? [localDaemonId] : []),
+                        'modal_parked',
+                        modalParkedCoordinators.length,
+                    );
+                }
+            } else if (generatingCoordinators.length > 0) {
+                // ── generating hold (NOTIF-SURFACE-LOCAL false-idle fix) ─────────────
+                // The only coordinator(s) for this mesh are plainly generating (no idle, no
+                // modal). A raw force-write into a generating claude-cli PTY is not consumed
+                // as a turn, so we do NOT inject and do NOT drain — the events stay queued
+                // (drained=0) and the next tick that finds the coordinator idle full-drains
+                // them as real turns (the coordinator returns to idle when its current
+                // tool-call/turn resolves; a dispatched worker runs for minutes while the
+                // coordinator is idle, so this lands within one reconcile interval). C1: mirror
+                // any held terminal events into the ledger so a completion's worker summary is
+                // recoverable even before that idle tick. Idempotent per process; O(1)-gated.
+                let hasPending = true;
+                if (store) {
+                    try { hasPending = store.pendingEventCount(meshId) > 0; } catch { /* peek below */ }
+                }
+                if (hasPending) {
+                    LOG.info('MeshReconcile', `Reconcile skip → generating: holding pending event(s) for mesh ${meshId} (${generatingCoordinators.length} coordinator(s) busy; events left queued for the next idle tick)`);
+                    recordHeldTerminalEventsToLedger(
+                        meshId,
+                        drainDaemonIds.length > 0 ? drainDaemonIds : (localDaemonId ? [localDaemonId] : []),
+                        'generating_no_idle_coordinator',
+                        generatingCoordinators.length,
+                    );
+                }
+            }
+            continue;
+        }
+
+        // O(1) guard: skip the drain entirely when the queue is empty.
+        if (store) {
+            try {
+                if (store.pendingEventCount(meshId) === 0) continue;
+            } catch { /* fall through to drain */ }
+        }
+
+        // An idle coordinator is present (targetCoordinators.length > 0): FULL-drain every
+        // queued event and deliver it to the idle input box as a real turn. The no-idle case
+        // (generating/modal-only) was already held above and never reaches here, so there is
+        // no force-drain-into-generating path left — the single delivery is the idle drain.
+        let pendingEvents: PendingMeshCoordinatorEvent[] = [];
+        try {
+            pendingEvents = drainPendingMeshCoordinatorEvents(
+                meshId,
+                drainDaemonIds.length > 0 ? drainDaemonIds : localDaemonId,
+            );
+        } catch (e: any) {
+            LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Drain failed for mesh ${meshId}: ${e?.message || e}`);
+            continue;
+        }
+        if (pendingEvents.length === 0) continue;
+
+        LOG.info('MeshReconcile', `Reconcile inject → idle: ${pendingEvents.length} pending event(s) → ${targetCoordinators.length} coordinator(s) for mesh ${meshId}`);
+        for (const pending of pendingEvents) {
+            // Strict session routing (multi-coordinator): when the event names an
+            // originating coordinator session, deliver ONLY to the live coordinator whose
+            // session id matches — a sibling coordinator on the same daemon must NOT receive
+            // another coordinator's completion. When the event carries no session id (legacy /
+            // version-skewed / single-coordinator), fall back to the daemon-level set
+            // (unchanged behaviour — regression-0 for the common case).
+            const wantSession = readNonEmptyString(pending.targetCoordinatorSessionId);
+            if (wantSession) {
+                const matched = targetCoordinators.filter(c => c.sessionId === wantSession);
+                if (matched.length === 0) {
+                    // The originating coordinator session is not deliverable on this daemon
+                    // right now (gone, or modal-parked and excluded from targets). Strict mode
+                    // does NOT broadcast to siblings — hold the event for a later tick, and
+                    // ledger-expire it past a TTL so it can never wedge forever.
+                    holdOrExpireStrictUnmatchedEvent(pending, wantSession, meshId);
+                    continue;
+                }
+                for (const c of matched) injectPendingIntoCoordinator(c.instance, pending);
+                continue;
+            }
+            for (const c of targetCoordinators) {
+                injectPendingIntoCoordinator(c.instance, pending);
+            }
+        }
+    }
+}
+
+// Strict-routing TTL: how long a drained completion whose originating coordinator session
+// is not currently deliverable is held (re-queued for re-drain) before it is ledger-
+// expired. Bounded so a coordinator session that never returns cannot wedge the event
+// forever; broad enough to ride out a transient modal-park / brief restart.
+const STRICT_SESSION_MATCH_TTL_MS = 60_000;
+
+// Re-queue (hold) a strict-routed event whose coordinator session is not live, or — once it
+// has aged past STRICT_SESSION_MATCH_TTL_MS — ledger-expire it (recoverable) and drop it.
+// We deliberately do NOT broadcast an aged-out event to sibling coordinators: that is the
+// very misroute strict routing exists to prevent. The drain already marked the row drained=1,
+// so re-queuing re-persists a fresh undrained copy (dedup keys on drained=0 only); queuedAt is
+// preserved so the TTL measures the event's true age across re-queues.
+function holdOrExpireStrictUnmatchedEvent(
+    pending: PendingMeshCoordinatorEvent,
+    wantSession: string,
+    meshId: string,
+): void {
+    const queuedAt = typeof pending.queuedAt === 'number' ? pending.queuedAt : Date.now();
+    if (Date.now() - queuedAt <= STRICT_SESSION_MATCH_TTL_MS) {
+        try {
+            queuePendingMeshCoordinatorEvent(pending); // preserves queuedAt → true age retained
+            LOG.info('MeshReconcile', `Strict route hold: coordinator session ${wantSession} not live on mesh ${meshId} — re-queued (${pending.event})`);
+            // EVTTRACE: event held (re-queued) — its originating coordinator session is not
+            // currently deliverable. Held, not dropped; surfaces later or expires past TTL.
+            traceMeshEventDrop('strict_route_hold', {
+                taskId: pending.metadataEvent?.taskId,
+                sessionId: pending.metadataEvent?.targetSessionId ?? wantSession,
+                nodeId: pending.nodeId,
+                meshId,
+                event: pending.event,
+            }, `coordinatorSession=${wantSession} not live`);
+        } catch (e: any) {
+            LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Strict route re-queue failed for ${pending.event} on mesh ${meshId}: ${e?.message || e}`);
+        }
+        return;
+    }
+    const finalSummary = readMeshCompletionSummary(pending.metadataEvent || {});
+    try {
+        appendLedgerEntry(meshId, {
+            kind: 'event_held',
+            ...(pending.nodeId ? { nodeId: pending.nodeId } : {}),
+            payload: {
+                event: pending.event,
+                reason: 'strict_route_expired',
+                recoverable: true,
+                targetCoordinatorSessionId: wantSession,
+                targetCoordinatorDaemonId: pending.targetCoordinatorDaemonId ?? null,
+                nodeLabel: pending.nodeLabel,
+                ...(pending.workspace ? { workspace: pending.workspace } : {}),
+                queuedAt,
+                ...(finalSummary ? { finalSummary } : {}),
+            },
+        });
+        LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Strict route expire: coordinator session ${wantSession} never returned for mesh ${meshId} — recorded to ledger (recoverable), dropped (${pending.event})`);
+        // EVTTRACE: event expired past the strict-route TTL — dropped (recoverable, ledgered).
+        traceMeshEventDrop('strict_route_expired', {
+            taskId: pending.metadataEvent?.taskId,
+            sessionId: pending.metadataEvent?.targetSessionId ?? wantSession,
+            nodeId: pending.nodeId,
+            meshId,
+            event: pending.event,
+        }, `coordinatorSession=${wantSession} never returned`);
+    } catch (e: any) {
+        LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Failed to ledger-expire strict-unmatched ${pending.event} for mesh ${meshId}: ${e?.message || e}`);
+    }
+}
+
+// Cloud-only: retry the worker-side unresolved-delegate forward outbox. For each
+// durably-queued entry, push it to its coordinator daemon over P2P (mesh_forward_event)
+// and ack (mark drained) ONLY on a successful, non-rejected response. A failed or
+// rejected push leaves the entry queued for the next tick — at-least-once delivery.
+// Stale entries (coordinator unreachable past the max age) are expired first so the
+// outbox can't grow without bound. The coordinator dedups duplicate deliveries on its
+// own fingerprint, so a retry that races the original immediate push is harmless.
+// RECONCILE-MESHID-DROP: per-entry count of consecutive HARD rejections (the coordinator
+// returned success:false, e.g. "meshId required"). A rejection means the push was delivered
+// and deterministically refused — retrying the identical payload every 4s can never succeed,
+// so it would loop until the 30-minute age expiry, spamming the log the whole time. After
+// MAX_FORWARD_REJECTIONS such rejections we drop the entry (drain it) with ONE fail-loud
+// warning. Transient transport failures (the dispatch throws — coordinator momentarily
+// unreachable) do NOT count here; those legitimately retry until the age expiry. In-memory
+// (keyed by the durable outbox row id) is sufficient: a daemon restart re-arms the loop, and
+// the age expiry remains the durable backstop. Cleared whenever an entry is delivered/drained.
+const unresolvedForwardRejectionCounts = new Map<string, number>();
+const MAX_FORWARD_REJECTIONS = 5;
+
+export function __resetUnresolvedForwardRejectionCountsForTests(): void {
+    unresolvedForwardRejectionCounts.clear();
+}
+
+async function retryUnresolvedDelegateForwards(components: DaemonComponents): Promise<void> {
+    const dispatchMeshCommand = components.dispatchMeshCommand;
+    if (!dispatchMeshCommand) return;
+
+    // Drop entries that have exhausted their retry budget (fail-loud inside).
+    expireStaleUnresolvedDelegateForwards();
+
+    const entries = peekUnresolvedDelegateForwards();
+    if (entries.length === 0) {
+        // Nothing queued — clear any stale per-entry rejection counters so the map can't grow.
+        if (unresolvedForwardRejectionCounts.size > 0) unresolvedForwardRejectionCounts.clear();
+        return;
+    }
+
+    // Every id-form THIS daemon answers to. A self-addressed outbox entry (coordinator
+    // == this daemon) must never be cross-dialled — see the self-route branch below.
+    const selfIds = resolveCoordinatorDaemonIds(components);
+    const isSelfCoordinatorId = (id: string): boolean =>
+        selfIds.some(self => daemonIdsEquivalent(self, id));
+
+    for (const entry of entries) {
+        // EVTTRACE correlation context for this outbox entry's retry.
+        const entryTraceCtx = {
+            taskId: (entry.payload as Record<string, unknown>).taskId,
+            sessionId: readNonEmptyString(entry.payload.targetSessionId) || readNonEmptyString(entry.payload.sessionId),
+            nodeId: readNonEmptyString(entry.payload.nodeId),
+            event: readNonEmptyString(entry.payload.event),
+        };
+
+        // Self-addressed forward: the coordinator daemon this entry targets IS this
+        // daemon (a self-coordinating / single-node mesh, or a delegate whose coordinator
+        // anchor resolved to our own id). A cross-daemon mesh_forward_event to our own id
+        // is REFUSED by the dispatch self-dial guard ("Refusing to send ... to this
+        // daemon's own id; route via the local router instead") on every retry, so the
+        // entry can never be acked and loops forever (~every tick), spamming the log and
+        // pinning the outbox row permanently undrained. Honour the guard's own advice:
+        // route the event straight through the local receiver (handleMeshForwardEvent —
+        // the same path the coordinator runs on receiving a remote push), then ack it.
+        // We drain regardless of the local result: a cross-daemon dispatch could not have
+        // resolved it either (the guard rejects before the receiver ever runs), so leaving
+        // it queued only re-spams. handleMeshForwardEvent has the BEST recovery chance —
+        // this daemon hosts the mesh, so its workspace/nodeId → meshId recovery applies.
+        if (isSelfCoordinatorId(entry.coordinatorDaemonId)) {
+            let localResult: any;
+            try {
+                traceMeshEventStage('forward_send', entryTraceCtx, `self → local router (${entry.coordinatorDaemonId})`);
+                localResult = handleMeshForwardEvent(components, entry.payload);
+            } catch (e: any) {
+                LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Local route of self-addressed forward to ${entry.coordinatorDaemonId} threw: ${e?.message || e} — draining anyway to break the retry loop`);
+            }
+            ackUnresolvedDelegateForward(entry.id);
+            unresolvedForwardRejectionCounts.delete(entry.id);
+            if (localResult && localResult.success === false) {
+                LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Self-addressed unresolved-delegate ${readNonEmptyString(entry.payload.event)} rejected by local router (${readNonEmptyString(localResult.error) || 'no reason'}) — drained to break the self-forward retry loop`);
+                traceMeshEventDrop('self_forward_local_rejected', entryTraceCtx, readNonEmptyString(localResult.error) || 'no reason');
+            } else {
+                LOG.info('MeshReconcile', `Self-addressed unresolved-delegate ${readNonEmptyString(entry.payload.event)} routed via local router (coordinator ${entry.coordinatorDaemonId} is self) — drained`);
+            }
+            continue;
+        }
+
+        // RECONCILE-MESHID-DROP: the stored forward payload was built when the worker
+        // "couldn't resolve" its meshId, so the coordinator rejects it "meshId required"
+        // when its own workspace/nodeId recovery misses. The worker can usually resolve it
+        // now (member node membership / live-session meshNodeFor) — stamp it on so the
+        // coordinator accepts. Covers entries persisted before this fix AND late-bound
+        // sessions. No-op when the payload already carries a meshId or none is resolvable.
+        let pushPayload = entry.payload;
+        if (!readNonEmptyString(pushPayload.meshId)) {
+            const recoveredMeshId = resolveForwardEventMeshId(components, pushPayload);
+            if (recoveredMeshId) {
+                pushPayload = { ...pushPayload, meshId: recoveredMeshId };
+                traceMeshEventStage('forward_meshid_recovered', entryTraceCtx, `meshId=${recoveredMeshId}`);
+            }
+        }
+
+        let result: any;
+        try {
+            traceMeshEventStage('forward_send', entryTraceCtx, `retry → ${entry.coordinatorDaemonId}`);
+            result = await dispatchMeshCommand(entry.coordinatorDaemonId, 'mesh_forward_event', pushPayload);
+        } catch (e: any) {
+            // Coordinator unreachable (transport threw) — keep the entry queued and try again
+            // next tick. This is NOT a hard rejection, so it does not count toward the cap;
+            // the age expiry bounds a permanently-offline coordinator.
+            LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Retry forward to coordinator ${entry.coordinatorDaemonId} failed: ${e?.message || e} — left queued`);
+            traceMeshEventDrop('retry_forward_failed', entryTraceCtx, e?.message || String(e));
+            continue;
+        }
+        if (result && result.success === false) {
+            // Hard rejection: the push was delivered and deterministically refused. Retrying
+            // the identical payload can never succeed, so bound it — after MAX_FORWARD_REJECTIONS
+            // drop (drain) the entry with one fail-loud warning instead of re-spamming every tick.
+            const rejections = (unresolvedForwardRejectionCounts.get(entry.id) || 0) + 1;
+            unresolvedForwardRejectionCounts.set(entry.id, rejections);
+            const reason = readNonEmptyString(result.error) || 'no reason';
+            if (rejections >= MAX_FORWARD_REJECTIONS) {
+                ackUnresolvedDelegateForward(entry.id);
+                unresolvedForwardRejectionCounts.delete(entry.id);
+                LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Retry forward to coordinator ${entry.coordinatorDaemonId} rejected ${rejections}x (${reason}) — dropping unresolved-delegate ${readNonEmptyString(entry.payload.event)} (sess=${readNonEmptyString(entry.payload.targetSessionId) || readNonEmptyString(entry.payload.sessionId) || '-'}) to stop the retry loop`);
+                traceMeshEventDrop('retry_forward_exhausted', entryTraceCtx, `${reason} (${rejections} rejections)`);
+            } else {
+                LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Retry forward to coordinator ${entry.coordinatorDaemonId} rejected (${reason}) — left queued (attempt ${rejections}/${MAX_FORWARD_REJECTIONS})`);
+                traceMeshEventDrop('retry_forward_rejected', entryTraceCtx, reason);
+            }
+            continue;
+        }
+        // Acked — mark the durable copy delivered.
+        ackUnresolvedDelegateForward(entry.id);
+        unresolvedForwardRejectionCounts.delete(entry.id);
+        LOG.info('MeshReconcile', `Retried+delivered unresolved-delegate ${readNonEmptyString(entry.payload.event)} to coordinator ${entry.coordinatorDaemonId}`);
+    }
+}
+
+// Cloud-only: poll each remote worker node daemon for pending coordinator events
+// and re-inject them locally via handleMeshForwardEvent (which re-queues +
+// surfaces to the live coordinator on the next tick / immediately if idle).
+//
+// Scoping: the remote handler (get_pending_mesh_events) drains its queue filtered
+// by coordinatorDaemonId — returning events targeted at that id OR unscoped, and
+// leaving events targeted at a *different* coordinator. A remote worker stamps the
+// coordinator id in one of SEVERAL forms (the canonical status id `standalone_`/
+// `daemon_<machineId>` stamped by the MCP layer, the bare machineId stamped by the
+// local queue path, OR — most commonly for remote launches — the coordinator mesh
+// node's config-form `daemonId`, which resolveCoordinatorDaemonId prefers and which
+// is NOT canonicalised). `candidateDaemonIds` is the already-expanded self-identity
+// set (resolveCoordinatorSelfIds: runtime drain ids ∪ this daemon's mesh-config node/
+// host id forms), so we pull ONCE PER candidate id and a completion stamped with any
+// of them is recovered. The remote drain is atomic (drained=1), so issuing multiple
+// pulls cannot double-deliver — the first pull that matches consumes the event; the
+// rest see nothing. When no ids resolve we fall back to a single unscoped pull.
+async function pullRemoteNodeQueues(
+    components: DaemonComponents,
+    mesh: LocalMeshEntry,
+    localDaemonId: string | undefined,
+    candidateDaemonIds: string[],
+): Promise<void> {
+    const dispatchMeshCommand = components.dispatchMeshCommand;
+    if (!dispatchMeshCommand) return;
+    const meshId = mesh.id;
+
+    // One args object per candidate coordinator-id form, or a single unscoped pull
+    // when none resolve.
+    const pulls: Array<Record<string, unknown>> = candidateDaemonIds.length > 0
+        ? candidateDaemonIds.map(id => ({ meshId, coordinatorDaemonId: id }))
+        : [{ meshId }];
+
+    for (const node of mesh.nodes) {
+        const nodeDaemonId = readNonEmptyString(node.daemonId);
+        // Skip nodes without a daemon, and nodes on THIS daemon (their events are
+        // already in the local queue drained in PHASE 2). "This daemon" is matched
+        // against the full self-identity set (candidateDaemonIds), not just the bare
+        // localDaemonId — a self node can be registered under the config-form daemonId
+        // (`daemon_<machineId>`) which would NOT equal bare localDaemonId, and pulling
+        // from ourselves over P2P is both wasteful and a self-dispatch hazard.
+        if (!nodeDaemonId) continue;
+        if (daemonIdsEquivalent(nodeDaemonId, localDaemonId)) continue;
+        if (daemonIdListIncludes(candidateDaemonIds, nodeDaemonId)) continue;
+
+        for (const pendingEventArgs of pulls) {
+            let events: unknown;
+            try {
+                events = await dispatchMeshCommand(nodeDaemonId, 'get_pending_mesh_events', pendingEventArgs);
+            } catch {
+                // Remote pull is best-effort; the node may be offline. Retry next tick.
+                break; // node unreachable — don't bother with the other id form this tick.
+            }
+            const list = extractPendingEvents(events).filter(e => readNonEmptyString(e?.meshId) === meshId);
+            for (const event of list) {
+                const payload = buildForwardPayloadFromPending(event);
+                if (!payload.event || !payload.meshId) continue;
+                try {
+                    handleMeshForwardEvent(components, payload);
+                } catch { /* best-effort re-inject */ }
+            }
+        }
+    }
+}
+
+// Pull the read_chat payload out of whatever envelope the transport returned.
+// A local commandHandler.handle() returns the CommandResult directly; a remote
+// dispatchMeshCommand returns it possibly wrapped in { payload } / { result }.
+function unwrapReadChatPayload(raw: unknown): Record<string, unknown> | null {
+    let cursor: unknown = raw;
+    for (let depth = 0; depth < 4 && cursor && typeof cursor === 'object'; depth++) {
+        const record = cursor as Record<string, unknown>;
+        if (Array.isArray(record.messages)) return record;
+        if (record.payload && typeof record.payload === 'object') { cursor = record.payload; continue; }
+        if (record.result && typeof record.result === 'object') { cursor = record.result; continue; }
+        if (record.data && typeof record.data === 'object') { cursor = record.data; continue; }
+        break;
+    }
+    return cursor && typeof cursor === 'object' ? cursor as Record<string, unknown> : null;
+}
+
+function readChatPayloadStatus(payload: Record<string, unknown> | null): string {
+    return readNonEmptyString(payload?.status).toLowerCase();
+}
+
+// PHASE 4 helper. For every active (non-terminal) direct dispatch this daemon
+// hosts, confirm the worker session is idle via a read_chat and — if a final
+// assistant summary is present but no terminal ledger exists for that dispatch —
+// synthesize the missing completion through reconcileDirectDispatchCompletionFromTranscript.
+//
+// read_chat is resolved against the target node: a node on THIS daemon is read
+// through the local commandHandler; a remote node is read over P2P via
+// dispatchMeshCommand. Both yield the same { messages, status, providerSessionId }
+// shape. We only synthesize when the session reports idle AND a final assistant
+// message exists — the same evidence bar the MCP poll path uses — so an actively
+// generating worker is never falsely completed. The reconcile itself is idempotent.
+async function reconcileUnterminatedDirectDispatches(
+    components: DaemonComponents,
+    mesh: LocalMeshEntry,
+    selfIds: string[],
+    localDaemonId: string | undefined,
+): Promise<void> {
+    const dispatches = getActiveDirectDispatches(mesh.id);
+    if (dispatches.length === 0) return; // cheap exit — nothing dispatched, nothing to reconcile
+
+    // Prune the in-flight idle debounce map to the tasks still active in THIS mesh, so a
+    // completed/pruned task's counter is dropped (the map never grows without bound).
+    const activeTaskKeys = new Set(
+        dispatches
+            .map(d => readNonEmptyString(d.taskId))
+            .filter(Boolean)
+            .map(taskId => inFlightSynthKey(mesh.id, taskId)),
+    );
+    for (const key of inFlightIdleObservationCounts.keys()) {
+        if (key.startsWith(`${mesh.id}::`) && !activeTaskKeys.has(key)) {
+            inFlightIdleObservationCounts.delete(key);
+        }
+    }
+
+    const dispatchMeshCommand = components.dispatchMeshCommand;
+    const nodeById = new Map(mesh.nodes.map(n => [n.id, n] as const));
+
+    for (const dispatch of dispatches) {
+        const sessionId = readNonEmptyString(dispatch.sessionId);
+        const nodeId = readNonEmptyString(dispatch.nodeId);
+        const taskId = readNonEmptyString(dispatch.taskId);
+        if (!sessionId || !nodeId || !taskId) continue;
+
+        const node = nodeById.get(nodeId);
+        const nodeDaemonId = readNonEmptyString(node?.daemonId);
+        // A node is local when it has no daemonId, names this daemon, or actually
+        // has a live instance here. Anything else is reached over P2P.
+        const isLocalNode = !nodeDaemonId
+            || daemonIdListIncludes(selfIds, nodeDaemonId)
+            || daemonIdsEquivalent(nodeDaemonId, localDaemonId)
+            || !!components.instanceManager.getInstance(sessionId);
+
+        const providerType = readNonEmptyString(dispatch.providerType);
+        const readArgs: Record<string, unknown> = {
+            sessionId,
+            targetSessionId: sessionId,
+            tailLimit: 10,
+            ...(node?.workspace ? { workspace: node.workspace } : {}),
+            ...(providerType ? { agentType: providerType, providerType } : {}),
+        };
+
+        let payload: Record<string, unknown> | null = null;
+        try {
+            if (isLocalNode) {
+                const result = await components.commandHandler.handle('read_chat', readArgs);
+                if (result && (result as { success?: boolean }).success === false) continue;
+                payload = unwrapReadChatPayload(result);
+            } else if (dispatchMeshCommand) {
+                const result = await dispatchMeshCommand(nodeDaemonId, 'read_chat', readArgs);
+                payload = unwrapReadChatPayload(result);
+                if (payload && (payload as { success?: boolean }).success === false) continue;
+            } else {
+                continue; // remote node but no P2P transport — can't read; retry next tick
+            }
+        } catch {
+            continue; // best-effort; session may be gone or node offline — retry next tick
+        }
+        if (!payload) continue;
+
+        // Only act on a session that has actually settled to idle. A generating /
+        // waiting_approval session is mid-turn — synthesizing a completion now would
+        // be wrong. (idle is the only status the MCP poll path reconciles too.)
+        const synthKey = inFlightSynthKey(mesh.id, taskId);
+        if (readChatPayloadStatus(payload) !== 'idle') {
+            // Not idle → the worker is mid-turn. Reset any partial idle streak so a single
+            // idle blip during a long generation never accumulates toward the synth threshold.
+            inFlightIdleObservationCounts.delete(synthKey);
+            continue;
+        }
+
+        // RECONCILE-SYNTH-PREEMPTS-COMPLETION: a dispatch whose worker was OBSERVED to start
+        // generating (the agent:generating_started ack flipped the row to 'acked') and has no
+        // terminal yet is potentially still in-flight — its `idle` read here may be a transient
+        // mid-turn flicker, not a settled completion. Require CONSECUTIVE idle observations
+        // before synthesizing for such a task: a flicker clears next tick (counter reset above),
+        // while a genuinely-settled (completed-but-lost) or dead session reads idle every tick
+        // and crosses the threshold within ~one extra interval. A never-acked dispatch (worker
+        // never started) is exempt — there is no in-flight generation to pre-empt, and its
+        // lost-dispatch case is still covered by the downstream grace + stale-summary guards.
+        if (dispatch.status === 'acked') {
+            const idleStreak = (inFlightIdleObservationCounts.get(synthKey) ?? 0) + 1;
+            inFlightIdleObservationCounts.set(synthKey, idleStreak);
+            if (idleStreak < REQUIRED_CONSECUTIVE_IDLE_TICKS_FOR_INFLIGHT_SYNTH) {
+                LOG.info('MeshReconcile', `In-flight synth hold: task ${taskId} on node ${nodeId} (mesh ${mesh.id}) read idle ${idleStreak}/${REQUIRED_CONSECUTIVE_IDLE_TICKS_FOR_INFLIGHT_SYNTH} consecutive tick(s) after generating_started — deferring completion synth until the idle settle is confirmed (guards against a mid-turn idle flicker pre-empting the real completion)`);
+                continue;
+            }
+        }
+
+        const messages = Array.isArray(payload.messages) ? payload.messages as ChatMessage[] : [];
+        const evidence = extractFinalAssistantSummaryEvidence(messages);
+        if (!evidence.finalSummary) continue; // no assistant result yet — nothing to attribute
+
+        // STALE-SUMMARY guard (modal-parked / reused-session misattribution): a direct
+        // dispatch frequently reuses a session that already ran a PRIOR task. read_chat
+        // returns the tail of the WHOLE session, so extractFinalAssistantSummaryEvidence
+        // picks the latest user-facing assistant message — which, for a task that has
+        // barely started (the session momentarily reads idle between turns), is the prior
+        // task's final summary. The downstream reconcile proves the summary is after the
+        // LEDGER task_dispatched entry; here we additionally have the AUTHORITATIVE per-task
+        // dispatchedAt (the dispatch-store row, immune to ledger-ordering quirks), so when
+        // the selected transcript message is provably BEFORE this task's own dispatch we
+        // refuse it outright — it is a prior task's summary, not this task's output (the
+        // 2843ms-duration stale-summary bug where task 2e3f501e copy-pasted 4eca2d9d's
+        // summary). When the message carries no usable timestamp we do NOT block here: the
+        // downstream reconcile already rejects a non-JSON summary it cannot prove is
+        // post-dispatch (transcript_not_proven_after_dispatch), and a structured
+        // final_summary_json is self-attributing — so a timeless provider is not
+        // over-blocked while the provable-stale case is still caught.
+        const dispatchedAtMs = Date.parse(readNonEmptyString(dispatch.dispatchedAt));
+        const transcriptAtMs = Date.parse(evidence.transcriptMessageAt ?? '');
+        if (Number.isFinite(dispatchedAtMs) && Number.isFinite(transcriptAtMs) && transcriptAtMs < dispatchedAtMs) {
+            LOG.info('MeshReconcile', `Stale-summary guard: skipping transcript reconcile for task ${taskId} on node ${nodeId} (mesh ${mesh.id}) — final assistant message (${evidence.transcriptMessageAt}) predates this task's dispatch (${dispatch.dispatchedAt}); it is a prior task's summary`);
+            traceMeshEventDrop('reconcile_stale_summary_before_dispatch', {
+                taskId, sessionId, nodeId, meshId: mesh.id, event: 'agent:generating_completed',
+            }, `transcriptAt=${evidence.transcriptMessageAt} < dispatchedAt=${dispatch.dispatchedAt}`);
+            continue;
+        }
+
+        const providerSessionId = readNonEmptyString(payload.providerSessionId);
+        const coordinatorDaemonId = selfIds.find(id => !!id);
+        try {
+            const result = reconcileDirectDispatchCompletionFromTranscript({
+                meshId: mesh.id,
+                nodeId,
+                sessionId,
+                providerType: providerType || undefined,
+                providerSessionId: providerSessionId || undefined,
+                taskId,
+                finalSummary: evidence.finalSummary,
+                ...(evidence.transcriptMessageAt ? { transcriptMessageAt: evidence.transcriptMessageAt } : {}),
+                ...(coordinatorDaemonId ? { targetCoordinatorDaemonId: coordinatorDaemonId } : {}),
+                source: 'daemon_reconcile_transcript_completion',
+            });
+            if (result.reconciled) {
+                LOG.info('MeshReconcile', `Synthesized missing completion (${result.kind}) for task ${taskId} on node ${nodeId} (mesh ${mesh.id})`);
+            }
+        } catch (e: any) {
+            LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Transcript completion reconcile threw for task ${taskId}: ${e?.message || e}`);
+        }
+    }
+}
+
+// PHASE 5 helper. Build the live-node view (mesh.nodes decorated with each node's live
+// session list) and run the shared prune core in execute mode with the conservative age gate.
+//
+// Orphan detection needs the SAME live-session evidence the manual MCP prune uses: a node still
+// in mesh.nodes whose session list no longer contains the dispatched sessionId is "session not
+// present" (prunable); a node missing from mesh.nodes entirely is "node no longer in live mesh"
+// (prunable). We obtain live sessions per node via get_status_metadata — local nodes through the
+// local commandHandler, remote nodes over P2P (dispatchMeshCommand) — exactly the transports
+// PHASE 4 already uses. A node we cannot probe (offline) keeps an empty session list; combined
+// with the age gate that only matters once the orphan is genuinely old.
+//
+// O(1) fast exit: when there are no active direct dispatches at all there is nothing to prune,
+// so we skip the (per-node) status probes entirely — an idle mesh costs one indexed query.
+async function autoPruneStaleDirectDispatches(
+    components: DaemonComponents,
+    mesh: LocalMeshEntry,
+    selfIds: string[],
+    localDaemonId: string | undefined,
+    minAgeMs: number,
+): Promise<void> {
+    const directDispatches = getActiveDirectDispatches(mesh.id);
+    if (directDispatches.length === 0) return; // nothing dispatched → nothing to prune
+
+    const liveNodes = await collectLiveNodesWithSessions(components, mesh, selfIds, localDaemonId);
+
+    const result = pruneStaleDirectDispatches({
+        meshId: mesh.id,
+        queue: getQueue(mesh.id),
+        ledgerEntries: readLedgerEntries(mesh.id, { tail: 500 }),
+        directDispatches,
+        nodes: liveNodes,
+        execute: true,
+        minAgeMs,
+        source: 'daemon_reconcile_auto_prune',
+    });
+
+    // Log only when something was actually pruned — silence on the common no-op tick.
+    if (result.prunedCount > 0) {
+        LOG.info('MeshReconcile', `Auto-pruned ${result.prunedCount} orphaned direct dispatch record(s) for mesh ${mesh.id}`);
+    }
+}
+
+// Probe each node for its live session list (get_status_metadata) and return mesh.nodes
+// decorated with a `sessions` array — the shape buildMeshActiveWork / sessionStatusFromNodes
+// consume to decide whether a dispatched session is still present. Best-effort: an unreachable
+// node yields an empty session list rather than throwing.
+async function collectLiveNodesWithSessions(
+    components: DaemonComponents,
+    mesh: LocalMeshEntry,
+    selfIds: string[],
+    localDaemonId: string | undefined,
+): Promise<any[]> {
+    const dispatchMeshCommand = components.dispatchMeshCommand;
+    return Promise.all(mesh.nodes.map(async (node) => {
+        const nodeDaemonId = readNonEmptyString(node.daemonId);
+        const isLocalNode = !nodeDaemonId
+            || daemonIdListIncludes(selfIds, nodeDaemonId)
+            || daemonIdsEquivalent(nodeDaemonId, localDaemonId);
+        let statusResult: unknown;
+        try {
+            if (isLocalNode) {
+                statusResult = await components.commandHandler.handle('get_status_metadata', {});
+            } else if (dispatchMeshCommand) {
+                statusResult = await dispatchMeshCommand(nodeDaemonId, 'get_status_metadata', {});
+            } else {
+                return node; // remote node, no P2P transport — leave undecorated
+            }
+        } catch {
+            return node; // unreachable — leave undecorated (empty session list)
+        }
+        const sessions = extractStatusMetadataSessions(statusResult);
+        return sessions.length > 0 ? { ...node, sessions } : node;
+    }));
+}
+
+// Pull the live session list out of a get_status_metadata result, tolerating the same
+// envelope shapes unwrapReadChatPayload handles (direct CommandResult or { payload }/{ result }).
+function extractStatusMetadataSessions(raw: unknown): any[] {
+    let cursor: unknown = raw;
+    for (let depth = 0; depth < 4 && cursor && typeof cursor === 'object'; depth++) {
+        const record = cursor as Record<string, unknown>;
+        const status = record.status && typeof record.status === 'object' ? record.status as Record<string, unknown> : undefined;
+        if (status && Array.isArray(status.sessions)) return status.sessions;
+        if (Array.isArray(record.sessions)) return record.sessions;
+        if (record.payload && typeof record.payload === 'object') { cursor = record.payload; continue; }
+        if (record.result && typeof record.result === 'object') { cursor = record.result; continue; }
+        if (record.data && typeof record.data === 'object') { cursor = record.data; continue; }
+        break;
+    }
+    return [];
+}
+
+function extractPendingEvents(raw: unknown): any[] {
+    if (Array.isArray(raw)) return raw;
+    if (raw && typeof raw === 'object') {
+        const events = (raw as Record<string, unknown>).events;
+        if (Array.isArray(events)) return events;
+    }
+    return [];
+}
+
+// Flatten a queued PendingMeshCoordinatorEvent into the flat payload shape
+// handleMeshForwardEvent expects (mirrors the MCP buildMeshForwardPayloadFromPendingEvent).
+function buildForwardPayloadFromPending(event: any): Record<string, unknown> {
+    const metadata = event?.metadataEvent && typeof event.metadataEvent === 'object'
+        ? event.metadataEvent as Record<string, unknown>
+        : {};
+    return {
+        event: readNonEmptyString(event?.event),
+        meshId: readNonEmptyString(event?.meshId),
+        nodeId: readNonEmptyString(event?.nodeId) || readNonEmptyString(metadata.meshNodeId),
+        workspace: readNonEmptyString(event?.workspace) || readNonEmptyString(metadata.workspace),
+        // Preserve the originating coordinator session id across the relay. It is normally
+        // carried inside metadataEvent.meshCoordinatorSessionId (spread below), but pass the
+        // top-level field through explicitly too so the handleMeshForwardEvent whitelist
+        // recovers it regardless of which carrier the producing daemon used.
+        ...(readNonEmptyString(event?.targetCoordinatorSessionId)
+            ? { targetCoordinatorSessionId: readNonEmptyString(event.targetCoordinatorSessionId) }
+            : {}),
+        ...metadata,
+        // NOTIF-MISS (FIX 3): surface the dispatch task id at the TOP LEVEL so the relay's
+        // received-stage trace (and buildRelayMetadataEvent) recovers it regardless of which
+        // carrier the producing daemon used. The metadata spread above may carry the id only as
+        // `meshActiveTaskId` (a worker provider event), leaving top-level `taskId` unset and the
+        // received stage rendering `task=-`. Resolve both carriers into an explicit `taskId` so
+        // dedup stays task-scoped end-to-end. Only set when a non-empty id exists (no clobber to
+        // undefined when neither is present).
+        ...((): Record<string, unknown> => {
+            const tid = readNonEmptyString(metadata.taskId) || readNonEmptyString(metadata.meshActiveTaskId);
+            return tid ? { taskId: tid } : {};
+        })(),
+    };
+}
+
+interface ReconcileLoopHandle {
+    stop(): void;
+}
+
+// Start the periodic reconcile loop. Returns a handle with stop() for shutdown.
+export function setupMeshReconcileLoop(components: DaemonComponents): ReconcileLoopHandle {
+    const intervalMs = resolveReconcileIntervalMs();
+    let running = false;
+    const timer = setInterval(() => {
+        if (running) return; // never overlap ticks
+        running = true;
+        void runMeshReconcileTick(components)
+            .catch((e: any) => LOG.warn('MeshReconcile', `Reconcile tick error: ${e?.message || e}`))
+            .finally(() => { running = false; });
+    }, intervalMs);
+    // Don't keep the process alive solely for this timer.
+    if (typeof timer.unref === 'function') timer.unref();
+    LOG.info('MeshReconcile', `Mesh reconcile loop started (interval ${intervalMs}ms)`);
+    return {
+        stop() {
+            clearInterval(timer);
+            LOG.info('MeshReconcile', 'Mesh reconcile loop stopped');
+        },
+    };
+}