metanorma-document 0.2.6 → 0.2.8

data/lib/metanorma/html/standard_renderer.rb

@@ -5,19 +5,31 @@ module Metanorma
     # Renders StandardDocument components to HTML.
     # Extends BaseRenderer with terms, bibliography, and standard sections.
     class StandardRenderer < BaseRenderer
-      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Root, :render_standard_document
+      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Root,
+                      :render_standard_document
       register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Terms::Term, :render_term
-      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::TermsSection, :render_terms_section
-      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::StandardReferencesSection, :render_references_section
-      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::BibliographySection, :render_bibliography
-      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::ClauseSection, :render_clause_section
-      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::AnnexSection, :render_annex_section
-      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::StandardSection, :render_standard_section
-      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::Abstract, :render_abstract_section
-      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::Foreword, :render_foreword_section
-      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::Introduction, :render_introduction_section
-      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::FloatingTitle, :render_floating_title
-      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Blocks::AmendBlock, :render_amend_block
+      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::TermsSection,
+                      :render_terms_section
+      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::StandardReferencesSection,
+                      :render_references_section
+      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::BibliographySection,
+                      :render_bibliography
+      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::ClauseSection,
+                      :render_clause_section
+      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::AnnexSection,
+                      :render_annex_section
+      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::StandardSection,
+                      :render_standard_section
+      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::Abstract,
+                      :render_abstract_section
+      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::Foreword,
+                      :render_foreword_section
+      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::Introduction,
+                      :render_introduction_section
+      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::FloatingTitle,
+                      :render_floating_title
+      register_render Metanorma::StandardDocument::Blocks::AmendBlock,
+                      :render_amend_block
 
       # --- Top-level document rendering ---
 
@@ -48,9 +60,7 @@ module Metanorma
         end
 
         # Index section from indexsect element (presentation XML)
-        if doc.is_a?(Metanorma::IsoDocument::Root) && doc.indexsect
-          render(doc.indexsect)
-        end
+        render(doc.indexsect) if doc.indexsect
 
         # Footnotes section
         render_footnotes_section
@@ -117,7 +127,8 @@ module Metanorma
 
       # --- Section rendering ---
 
-      def render_section(section, level: 1, title_class: nil, with_subsections: false, with_terms: false)
+      def render_section(section, level: 1, title_class: nil,
+with_subsections: false, with_terms: false)
         attrs = element_attrs(id: safe_attr(section, :id))
         tag("div", attrs) do
           if title_class
@@ -184,12 +195,22 @@ module Metanorma
 
           # Domain
           if term.domain
-            domain_text = term.domain.is_a?(String) ? term.domain : safe_attr(term.domain, :text).to_s
+            domain_text = if term.domain.is_a?(String)
+                            term.domain
+                          else
+                            safe_attr(
+                              term.domain, :text
+                            ).to_s
+                          end
             @output << "<p class=\"term-domain\">&lt;#{escape_html(domain_text)}&gt;</p>" unless domain_text.to_s.empty?
           end
 
           # Definitions
-          Array(term.definition).each { |defn| render_term_definition(defn) } if term.definition
+          if term.definition
+            Array(term.definition).each do |defn|
+              render_term_definition(defn)
+            end
+          end
 
           # Notes (mapped from <termnote>)
           term.note&.each_with_index do |note, i|
@@ -222,10 +243,10 @@ module Metanorma
       def extract_designation_name(designation)
         if designation.is_a?(Metanorma::StandardDocument::Terms::Designation) && designation.expression
           expr = designation.expression
-          if expr.is_a?(Metanorma::IsoDocument::Terms::TermExpression) && expr.name
+          if expr.is_a?(Metanorma::StandardDocument::Terms::TermExpression) && expr.name
             Array(expr.name).join
           end
-        elsif designation.is_a?(Metanorma::IsoDocument::Terms::TermExpression) && designation.name
+        elsif designation.is_a?(Metanorma::StandardDocument::Terms::TermExpression) && designation.name
           Array(designation.name).join
         else
           extract_text_value(designation)
@@ -313,7 +334,9 @@ module Metanorma
 
       def render_bibliography(bib, level: 1, **_opts)
         tag("div", "") do
-          bib.references&.each { |ref| render_references_section(ref, level: level) }
+          bib.references&.each do |ref|
+            render_references_section(ref, level: level)
+          end
           bib.clause&.each { |cl| render(cl, level: level) }
         end
       end
@@ -322,10 +345,13 @@ module Metanorma
         is_normative = safe_attr(section, :normative) == "true"
         attrs = element_attrs(id: safe_attr(section, :id))
         tag("div", attrs) do
-          render_standard_title(section, level, default_class: is_normative ? "" : "section-sub")
+          render_standard_title(section, level,
+                                default_class: is_normative ? "" : "section-sub")
           section.p&.each { |para| render_paragraph(para) }
           section.note&.each { |note| render_paragraph(note) }
-          section.references&.each_with_index { |bibitem, i| render_bibitem(bibitem, i + 1, normative: is_normative) }
+          section.references&.each_with_index do |bibitem, i|
+            render_bibitem(bibitem, i + 1, normative: is_normative)
+          end
           section.table&.each { |t| render_table(t) }
         end
       end
@@ -365,7 +391,9 @@ module Metanorma
         return preferred.content.to_s if preferred && !preferred.content.to_s.empty?
 
         # Fallback: first non-RSS link
-        non_rss = links.find { |l| !l.content.to_s.include?(".rss") && !l.content.to_s.empty? }
+        non_rss = links.find do |l|
+          !l.content.to_s.include?(".rss") && !l.content.to_s.empty?
+        end
         non_rss&.content&.to_s
       end
 
@@ -403,7 +431,9 @@ module Metanorma
 
         if item.title && !item.title.empty?
           titles = Array(item.title)
-          main_title = titles.find { |t| safe_attr(t, :type) == "main" } || titles.first
+          main_title = titles.find do |t|
+            safe_attr(t, :type) == "main"
+          end || titles.first
           if main_title
             @output << ", <i>"
             render_mixed_inline(main_title)
@@ -415,7 +445,8 @@ module Metanorma
       # --- Standard section helpers ---
 
       def render_standard_title(section, level, default_class: "")
-        title_element = safe_attr(section, :fmt_title) || safe_attr(section, :title)
+        title_element = safe_attr(section,
+                                  :fmt_title) || safe_attr(section, :title)
         return unless title_element
 
         section_id = safe_attr(section, :id)
@@ -457,14 +488,16 @@ module Metanorma
         end
 
         # Block elements
-        %i[tables figures formulas examples notes admonitions sourcecode_blocks quote_blocks].each do |attr|
+        %i[tables figures formulas examples notes admonitions sourcecode_blocks
+           quote_blocks].each do |attr|
           values = safe_attr(section, attr)
           Array(values).each { |v| render(v, level: level + 1) } if values
         end
       end
 
       def render_subsections(section, level)
-        clauses = safe_attr(section, :clause) || safe_attr(section, :subsections)
+        clauses = safe_attr(section,
+                            :clause) || safe_attr(section, :subsections)
         Array(clauses).each { |cl| render(cl, level: level + 1) } if clauses
       end
 

data/lib/metanorma/html/theme.rb

@@ -82,7 +82,7 @@ module Metanorma
         @example_bg      = "rgba(232, 248, 245, 0.6)"
         @example_border  = "#0d9488"
         @admonition_color = "#b8860b"
-        @admonition_bg   = "rgba(255, 252, 245, 0.8)"
+        @admonition_bg = "rgba(255, 252, 245, 0.8)"
         @admonition_border = "#e8a820"
         @footer_border_color = nil
         @cover_separator_color = nil
@@ -92,7 +92,7 @@ module Metanorma
         @cover_after_bg    = nil
         @cover_before_bg   = nil
         @progress_bar_color = nil
-        @extra_css         = nil
+        @extra_css = nil
 
         # Dark mode defaults
         @dark_bg          = "#0f1118"

data/lib/metanorma/html.rb

@@ -1,9 +1,56 @@
 # frozen_string_literal: true
 
-require "metanorma/html/whitespace_patch"
+require "liquid"
+require "nokogiri"
 
 module Metanorma
   module Html
+    unless defined?(TEMPLATES_ROOT)
+      TEMPLATES_ROOT = File.join(__dir__, "html", "templates")
+
+      Liquid::Environment.default.file_system = Liquid::LocalFileSystem.new(
+        TEMPLATES_ROOT, "_%s.html.liquid"
+      )
+
+      Moxml::Adapter::Nokogiri.class_eval do
+        class << self
+          alias_method :_original_children_patched, :children
+          remove_method :children
+        end
+
+        def self.children(node)
+          node.children.to_a
+        end
+      end
+
+      Lutaml::Xml::XmlElement.class_eval do
+        remove_method :order
+
+        def order
+          return @order_cache if @order_cache
+
+          @order_cache = children.filter_map do |child|
+            if child.text?
+              Lutaml::Xml::Element.new("Text", "text",
+                                       text_content: child.text,
+                                       node_type: :text)
+            elsif child.cdata?
+              Lutaml::Xml::Element.new("Text", "#cdata-section",
+                                       text_content: child.text,
+                                       node_type: :cdata)
+            elsif child.comment?
+              nil
+            else
+              Lutaml::Xml::Element.new("Element", child.unprefixed_name,
+                                       node_type: :element,
+                                       namespace_uri: child.namespace_uri,
+                                       namespace_prefix: child.namespace_prefix)
+            end
+          end
+        end
+      end
+    end
+
     autoload :BaseRenderer, "metanorma/html/base_renderer"
     autoload :Generator, "metanorma/html/generator"
     autoload :Theme, "metanorma/html/theme"

data/lib/metanorma/iec_document/root.rb

@@ -1,65 +1,26 @@
 # frozen_string_literal: true
 
-require "metanorma/standard_document"
-require "metanorma/iso_document"
-
 module Metanorma
   module IecDocument
-    class Root < Metanorma::StandardDocument::Root
-      attribute :version, :string
-      attribute :type, :string
-      attribute :schema_version, :string
-      attribute :flavor, :string
+    class Root < Lutaml::Model::Serializable
+      include Metanorma::StandardDocument::RootAttributes
+
+      def self.lutaml_default_register
+        :iec_document
+      end
 
       attribute :bibdata,
                 Metanorma::IsoDocument::Metadata::IsoBibliographicItem
-
-      attribute :term_sources,
-                Metanorma::Document::Components::ReferenceElements::Citation,
-                collection: true
-
       attribute :preface, Metanorma::IsoDocument::Sections::IsoPreface
       attribute :sections, Metanorma::IsoDocument::Sections::IsoSections
       attribute :annex, Metanorma::IsoDocument::Sections::IsoAnnexSection,
                 collection: true
-      attribute :bibliography,
-                Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::BibliographySection
-      attribute :boilerplate, Metanorma::IsoDocument::Boilerplate
-      attribute :metanorma_extension,
-                Metanorma::IsoDocument::Metadata::MetanormaExtension
-      attribute :annotation_container, Metanorma::IsoDocument::AnnotationContainer
-      attribute :indexsect,
-                Metanorma::Document::Components::Sections::BasicSection
-      attribute :autonum, :string
-      attribute :fmt_xref_label, :string
-      attribute :localized_strings,
-                Metanorma::Document::Components::Inline::LocalizedStringsElement
-      attribute :fmt_footnote_container,
-                Metanorma::Document::Components::Inline::FmtFootnoteContainerElement
-      attribute :colophon, Metanorma::IsoDocument::Sections::Colophon
 
       xml do
         element "metanorma"
         namespace Metanorma::StandardDocument::Namespace
-        map_attribute "type", to: :type
-        map_attribute "version", to: :version
-        map_attribute "schema-version", to: :schema_version
-        map_attribute "flavor", to: :flavor
-        map_element "bibdata", to: :bibdata
-        map_element "termdocsource", to: :term_sources
-        map_element "metanorma-extension", to: :metanorma_extension
-        map_element "boilerplate", to: :boilerplate
-        map_element "preface", to: :preface
-        map_element "sections", to: :sections
-        map_element "annex", to: :annex
-        map_element "bibliography", to: :bibliography
-        map_element "annotation-container", to: :annotation_container
-        map_element "indexsect", to: :indexsect
-        map_element "localized-strings", to: :localized_strings
-        map_element "fmt-footnote-container", to: :fmt_footnote_container
-        map_element "colophon", to: :colophon
-        map_attribute "autonum", to: :autonum
-        map_attribute "fmt-xref-label", to: :fmt_xref_label
+
+        Metanorma::StandardDocument::RootXmlMapping.apply(self)
       end
     end
   end

data/lib/metanorma/iec_document.rb

@@ -1,10 +1,9 @@
 # frozen_string_literal: true
 
-require "metanorma/standard_document"
-require "metanorma/iso_document"
-
 module Metanorma
   module IecDocument
     autoload :Root, "metanorma/iec_document/root"
   end
 end
+
+Metanorma::Registers::Setup.setup_iec_register

data/lib/metanorma/ieee_document/root.rb

@@ -1,64 +1,28 @@
 # frozen_string_literal: true
 
-require "metanorma/standard_document"
-require "metanorma/iso_document"
-
 module Metanorma
   module IeeeDocument
-    class Root < Metanorma::StandardDocument::Root
-      attribute :version, :string
-      attribute :type, :string
-      attribute :schema_version, :string
-      attribute :flavor, :string
-
-      attribute :bibdata, Metadata::IeeeBibliographicItem
+    class Root < Lutaml::Model::Serializable
+      include Metanorma::StandardDocument::RootAttributes
 
-      attribute :term_sources,
-                Metanorma::Document::Components::ReferenceElements::Citation,
-                collection: true
+      def self.lutaml_default_register
+        :ieee_document
+      end
 
-      attribute :preface, Metanorma::IsoDocument::Sections::IsoPreface
-      attribute :sections, Metanorma::IsoDocument::Sections::IsoSections
-      attribute :annex, Metanorma::IsoDocument::Sections::IsoAnnexSection,
+      attribute :bibdata, Metadata::IeeeBibliographicItem
+      attribute :preface,
+                Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::Preface
+      attribute :sections,
+                IeeeDocument::Sections::IeeeSections
+      attribute :annex,
+                Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::AnnexSection,
                 collection: true
-      attribute :bibliography,
-                Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::BibliographySection
-      attribute :boilerplate, Metanorma::IsoDocument::Boilerplate
-      attribute :metanorma_extension,
-                Metanorma::IsoDocument::Metadata::MetanormaExtension
-      attribute :annotation_container, Metanorma::IsoDocument::AnnotationContainer
-      attribute :indexsect,
-                Metanorma::Document::Components::Sections::BasicSection
-      attribute :autonum, :string
-      attribute :fmt_xref_label, :string
-      attribute :localized_strings,
-                Metanorma::Document::Components::Inline::LocalizedStringsElement
-      attribute :fmt_footnote_container,
-                Metanorma::Document::Components::Inline::FmtFootnoteContainerElement
-      attribute :colophon, Metanorma::IsoDocument::Sections::Colophon
 
       xml do
         element "metanorma"
         namespace Metanorma::StandardDocument::Namespace
-        map_attribute "type", to: :type
-        map_attribute "version", to: :version
-        map_attribute "schema-version", to: :schema_version
-        map_attribute "flavor", to: :flavor
-        map_element "bibdata", to: :bibdata
-        map_element "termdocsource", to: :term_sources
-        map_element "metanorma-extension", to: :metanorma_extension
-        map_element "boilerplate", to: :boilerplate
-        map_element "preface", to: :preface
-        map_element "sections", to: :sections
-        map_element "annex", to: :annex
-        map_element "bibliography", to: :bibliography
-        map_element "annotation-container", to: :annotation_container
-        map_element "indexsect", to: :indexsect
-        map_element "localized-strings", to: :localized_strings
-        map_element "fmt-footnote-container", to: :fmt_footnote_container
-        map_element "colophon", to: :colophon
-        map_attribute "autonum", to: :autonum
-        map_attribute "fmt-xref-label", to: :fmt_xref_label
+
+        Metanorma::StandardDocument::RootXmlMapping.apply(self)
       end
     end
   end

data/lib/metanorma/ieee_document/sections/ieee_sections.rb

@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
+# frozen_string_literal: true
+
+module Metanorma
+  module IeeeDocument
+    module Sections
+      # IEEE sections container.
+      # Corresponds to ieee.rnc:
+      #   sections = element sections {
+      #     note?,
+      #     ( clause | terms | term-clause | definitions | floating-title )+
+      #   }
+      #
+      # Differs from isodoc default by adding an optional leading note.
+      class IeeeSections < Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::Sections
+        attribute :note,
+                  Metanorma::Document::Components::Blocks::NoteBlock
+
+        xml do
+          element "sections"
+          ordered
+
+          map_element "note", to: :note
+
+          Metanorma::StandardDocument::SectionXmlMapping.apply_sections_elements(self)
+
+          Metanorma::StandardDocument::SectionXmlMapping.apply_sections_attributes(self)
+        end
+      end
+    end
+  end
+end

data/lib/metanorma/ieee_document/sections.rb

@@ -0,0 +1,9 @@
+# frozen_string_literal: true
+
+module Metanorma
+  module IeeeDocument
+    module Sections
+      autoload :IeeeSections, "#{__dir__}/sections/ieee_sections"
+    end
+  end
+end

data/lib/metanorma/ieee_document.rb

@@ -1,11 +1,11 @@
 # frozen_string_literal: true
 
-require "metanorma/standard_document"
-require "metanorma/iso_document"
-
 module Metanorma
   module IeeeDocument
     autoload :Metadata, "metanorma/ieee_document/metadata"
     autoload :Root, "metanorma/ieee_document/root"
+    autoload :Sections, "metanorma/ieee_document/sections"
   end
 end
+
+Metanorma::Registers::Setup.setup_ieee_register

data/lib/metanorma/ietf_document/metadata/ietf_bib_data_extension_type.rb

@@ -1,7 +1,5 @@
 # frozen_string_literal: true
 
-require "lutaml/model"
-
 module Metanorma
   module IetfDocument
     module Metadata

data/lib/metanorma/ietf_document/metadata/ietf_bibliographic_item.rb

@@ -1,7 +1,5 @@
 # frozen_string_literal: true
 
-require "metanorma/document"
-
 module Metanorma
   module IetfDocument
     module Metadata

data/lib/metanorma/ietf_document/root.rb

@@ -1,65 +1,29 @@
 # frozen_string_literal: true
 
-require "metanorma/standard_document"
-require "metanorma/iso_document"
-require_relative "metadata"
-require_relative "sections"
-
 module Metanorma
   module IetfDocument
-    class Root < Metanorma::StandardDocument::Root
-      attribute :version, :string
-      attribute :type, :string
-      attribute :schema_version, :string
-      attribute :flavor, :string
+    class Root < Lutaml::Model::Serializable
+      include Metanorma::StandardDocument::RootAttributes
+
+      def self.lutaml_default_register
+        :ietf_document
+      end
 
       attribute :bibdata,
                 Metanorma::IetfDocument::Metadata::IetfBibliographicItem
-
-      attribute :term_sources,
-                Metanorma::Document::Components::ReferenceElements::Citation,
+      attribute :preface,
+                Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::Preface
+      attribute :sections,
+                Metanorma::IetfDocument::Sections::IetfSections
+      attribute :annex,
+                Metanorma::IetfDocument::Sections::IetfAnnexSection,
                 collection: true
 
-      attribute :preface, Metanorma::IsoDocument::Sections::IsoPreface
-      attribute :sections, Metanorma::IetfDocument::Sections::IetfSections
-      attribute :annex, Metanorma::IsoDocument::Sections::IsoAnnexSection,
-                collection: true
-      attribute :bibliography,
-                Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::BibliographySection
-      attribute :boilerplate, Metanorma::IsoDocument::Boilerplate
-      attribute :metanorma_extension,
-                Metanorma::IsoDocument::Metadata::MetanormaExtension
-      attribute :annotation_container, Metanorma::IsoDocument::AnnotationContainer
-      attribute :indexsect,
-                Metanorma::Document::Components::Sections::BasicSection
-      attribute :localized_strings,
-                Metanorma::Document::Components::Inline::LocalizedStringsElement
-      attribute :fmt_footnote_container,
-                Metanorma::Document::Components::Inline::FmtFootnoteContainerElement
-      attribute :colophon, Metanorma::IsoDocument::Sections::Colophon
-
       xml do
         element "metanorma"
         namespace Metanorma::StandardDocument::Namespace
-        map_attribute "type", to: :type
-        map_attribute "version", to: :version
-        map_attribute "schema-version", to: :schema_version
-        map_attribute "flavor", to: :flavor
-        map_element "bibdata", to: :bibdata
-        map_element "termdocsource", to: :term_sources
-        map_element "metanorma-extension", to: :metanorma_extension
-        map_element "boilerplate", to: :boilerplate
-        map_element "preface", to: :preface
-        map_element "sections", to: :sections
-        map_element "annex", to: :annex
-        map_element "bibliography", to: :bibliography
-        map_element "annotation-container", to: :annotation_container
-        map_element "indexsect", to: :indexsect
-        map_element "localized-strings", to: :localized_strings
-        map_element "fmt-footnote-container", to: :fmt_footnote_container
-        map_element "colophon", to: :colophon
-        map_attribute "autonum", to: :autonum
-        map_attribute "fmt-xref-label", to: :fmt_xref_label
+
+        Metanorma::StandardDocument::RootXmlMapping.apply(self)
       end
     end
   end

data/lib/metanorma/ietf_document/sections/ietf_annex_section.rb

@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
+# frozen_string_literal: true
+
+module Metanorma
+  module IetfDocument
+    module Sections
+      class IetfAnnexSection < Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::AnnexSection
+        # IETF-specific attributes
+        attribute :numbered, :string
+        attribute :remove_in_rfc, :string
+
+        # Sub-clauses within IETF annex use IetfClauseSection
+        attribute :clause, IetfClauseSection, collection: true
+
+        xml do
+          element "annex"
+          ordered
+
+          Metanorma::StandardDocument::SectionXmlMapping.apply_annex_attributes(self)
+          map_attribute "numbered",    to: :numbered
+          map_attribute "removeInRFC", to: :remove_in_rfc
+          Metanorma::StandardDocument::SectionXmlMapping.apply_annex_elements(self)
+        end
+      end
+    end
+  end
+end

data/lib/metanorma/ietf_document/sections/ietf_clause_section.rb

@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
+# frozen_string_literal: true
+
+module Metanorma
+  module IetfDocument
+    module Sections
+      class IetfClauseSection < Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::ClauseSection
+        # IETF-specific attributes
+        attribute :numbered, :string
+        attribute :remove_in_rfc, :string
+
+        # Recursive IETF sub-clauses
+        attribute :clause, IetfClauseSection, collection: true
+
+        xml do
+          element "clause"
+          ordered
+
+          Metanorma::StandardDocument::SectionXmlMapping.apply_clause_attributes(self)
+          map_attribute "numbered",    to: :numbered
+          map_attribute "removeInRFC", to: :remove_in_rfc
+          Metanorma::StandardDocument::SectionXmlMapping.apply_clause_elements(self)
+        end
+      end
+    end
+  end
+end

data/lib/metanorma/ietf_document/sections/ietf_content_section.rb

@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
+# frozen_string_literal: true
+
+module Metanorma
+  module IetfDocument
+    module Sections
+      class IetfContentSection < Metanorma::StandardDocument::Sections::ContentSection
+        attribute :numbered, :string
+        attribute :remove_in_rfc, :string
+
+        # Recursive IETF sub-clauses
+        attribute :subsection, IetfContentSection, collection: true
+
+        xml do
+          element "clause"
+          ordered
+
+          Metanorma::StandardDocument::SectionXmlMapping.apply_content_section_attributes(self)
+          map_attribute "numbered",       to: :numbered
+          map_attribute "removeInRFC",    to: :remove_in_rfc
+          Metanorma::StandardDocument::SectionXmlMapping.apply_content_section_elements(self)
+        end
+      end
+    end
+  end
+end