graph_weaver 0.4.6 → 0.5.1

data/lib/graph_weaver/schema_loader.rb

@@ -17,57 +17,390 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
   # so a cache round-trip is symmetrical with introspect:
   #      SchemaLoader.load(cached_json)  # from Rails.cache/redis/...
   def self.load(source)
-    return GraphQL::Schema.from_introspection(source) if source.is_a?(Hash)
+    return build_introspection(source) if source.is_a?(Hash)
 
-    if source.lstrip.start_with?("{") # introspection JSON content
-      GraphQL::Schema.from_introspection(JSON.parse(source))
-    elsif source.include?("\n") # multi-line: SDL content
-      unless source.match?(/^\s*(schema|type|interface|union|enum|scalar|directive|input|")/)
-        raise ArgumentError, "unsupported schema content: #{source.lstrip[0, 80].inspect}"
-      end
+    # Rails.root.join(...) hands you a Pathname, and to_path is the
+    # ecosystem's "I am a path" (File.open honors it). Without this the
+    # sniffing below fails as `undefined method 'lstrip'`.
+    source = source.to_path if source.respond_to?(:to_path)
 
+    if source.lstrip.start_with?("{") # introspection JSON content
+      build_introspection(JSON.parse(source))
+    elsif sdl_content?(source) # SDL content, one line or many
       build_sdl(source)
-    else # a file path
-      case File.extname(source)
-      when ".json"
-        GraphQL::Schema.from_introspection(JSON.parse(File.read(source)))
-      when ".graphql", ".gql"
-        build_sdl(File.read(source))
-      else
-        raise ArgumentError, "unsupported schema format: #{source}"
-      end
+    elsif source.include?("\n") # content, but nothing we recognize
+      raise GraphWeaver::Error, "unsupported schema content: #{source.lstrip[0, 80].inspect}"
+    else
+      load_path(source)
+    end
+  end
+
+  # SDL content rather than a file path. Anchored at the start and requiring
+  # a delimiter after the keyword, so `types/schema.graphql` isn't read as a
+  # `type` definition — and a one-line `type Query { hi: String }`, the shape
+  # you'd type in a console, still is.
+  SDL_CONTENT = /\A\s*(?:\#|"|(?:schema|type|interface|union|enum|scalar|directive|input|extend)\b[\s{(@])/
+
+  def self.sdl_content?(source)
+    source.match?(SDL_CONTENT)
+  end
+
+  def self.load_path(path)
+    case File.extname(path)
+    when ".json"
+      build_introspection(JSON.parse(read_schema(path)))
+    when ".graphql", ".gql"
+      build_sdl(read_schema(path))
+    else
+      raise GraphWeaver::Error,
+        "unsupported schema format: #{path} — expected a .json (introspection) or " \
+        ".graphql/.gql (SDL) path, or the content itself#{url_hint(path)}"
     end
   end
+  private_class_method :load_path
+
+  def self.read_schema(path)
+    File.read(path)
+  rescue SystemCallError => e
+    raise GraphWeaver::Error, "can't read the schema at #{path}: #{e.message}"
+  end
+  private_class_method :read_schema
+
+  # A bare host is the near miss worth naming: "unsupported schema format"
+  # sends you looking at the filesystem when the cause is the missing scheme.
+  HOST_LIKE = %r{\A[a-z0-9-]+(?:\.[a-z0-9-]+)+(?::\d+)?(?:/\S*)?\z}i
+  # dotted-but-not-a-host: a file whose extension we simply don't read
+  FILE_SUFFIXES = %w[yaml yml txt xml sdl md rb erb].freeze
+
+  def self.url_hint(source)
+    return unless source.match?(HOST_LIKE)
+
+    suffix = source[%r{\A[^/:]+}].to_s[/[^.]+\z/].to_s
+    return if FILE_SUFFIXES.include?(suffix.downcase)
+
+    %( — "#{source}" looks like a host; did you mean "https://#{source}"?)
+  end
+  private_class_method :url_hint
 
-  # Build a schema from SDL, first stripping Apollo Federation composition
-  # machinery when the SDL is a composed supergraph — so a supergraph dump
-  # (often the only artifact for the merged graph, and what the router
-  # actually serves) loads like any schema, with the federation plumbing
-  # gone rather than leaked into schema.types. Plain SDL passes through.
+  # Build a schema from SDL, first normalizing whichever federation artifact
+  # it is: a composed supergraph gets its composition machinery stripped (so
+  # a supergraph dump — often the only artifact for the merged graph, and
+  # what the router actually serves — loads like any schema, with the
+  # plumbing gone rather than leaked into schema.types); a subgraph gets the
+  # federation directive definitions it applies but doesn't declare. Plain
+  # SDL passes through.
   def self.build_sdl(sdl)
-    GraphQL::Schema.from_definition(federation_sdl?(sdl) ? strip_federation(sdl) : sdl)
+    kind = sdl_kind(sdl)
+    prepared = case kind
+    when :supergraph then strip_federation(sdl)
+    when :subgraph then add_subgraph_definitions(sdl)
+    else sdl
+    end
+
+    build(kind) { GraphQL::Schema.from_definition(prepared) }
   end
   private_class_method :build_sdl
 
+  def self.build_introspection(result)
+    build(:introspection) { GraphQL::Schema.from_introspection(result) }
+  end
+  private_class_method :build_introspection
+
+  # Which artifact an SDL string is — it decides both the normalizing it
+  # needs and what to say when it won't build.
+  def self.sdl_kind(sdl)
+    if federation_sdl?(sdl)
+      :supergraph
+    elsif subgraph_sdl?(sdl)
+      :subgraph
+    else
+      :sdl
+    end
+  end
+  private_class_method :sdl_kind
+
+  SOURCE_KINDS = {
+    supergraph: "a federation supergraph SDL — if it's hand-written, check that nothing " \
+      "left in it still references an @inaccessible element",
+    subgraph: "a federation subgraph SDL — a directive it applies may be outside the " \
+      "subgraph spec; declare that one in the file",
+    sdl: "plain SDL — a supergraph is recognized by its @join__* markers or the @link/@core " \
+      "specs it declares, a subgraph by applied-but-undeclared @key/@shareable/…",
+    introspection: 'an introspection result — it should be the whole envelope, {"data": {"__schema": …}}',
+  }.freeze
+
+  # graphql-ruby reports a schema it can't build with whatever its internals
+  # happen to raise — NoMethodError, ParseError, a bare RuntimeError — often
+  # naming a document the caller never wrote (we reprint federation SDL before
+  # building). Keep those under the umbrella, and say which artifact we took
+  # the source for.
+  def self.build(kind)
+    yield
+  rescue GraphWeaver::Error
+    raise
+  rescue StandardError => e
+    raise GraphWeaver::Error,
+      "couldn't build a schema from #{SOURCE_KINDS.fetch(kind)} (#{e.class}: #{e.message})"
+  end
+  private_class_method :build
+
+  # A composed graph declares the specs that compose it: fed-2 links join,
+  # fed-1 @cores the core spec itself. Neither matches a subgraph, which links
+  # only the federation spec — so this catches the composed graphs the
+  # @join__ marker misses: one that renamed join (`as: "j"`), and a core
+  # schema that merged nothing but still carries core__Purpose.
+  COMPOSITION_SPEC = %r{@(?:link\s*\(\s*url|core\s*\(\s*feature):\s*"https://specs\.apollo\.dev/(?:join|core)/}
+
   # A composed Fed2 supergraph is marked by @join__* directives (every merged
   # type carries them); a plain schema has none.
   def self.federation_sdl?(sdl)
-    sdl.match?(/@join__\w/)
+    sdl.match?(/@join__\w/) || sdl.match?(COMPOSITION_SPEC)
   end
 
-  FEDERATION_PREFIXES = %w[join__ link__ core__].freeze
-  FEDERATION_DIRECTIVES = %w[link core inaccessible].to_set.freeze
+  # The federation spec a fed-2 subgraph @links, and the directives a fed-1
+  # subgraph just applies. Both leave the definitions off the file: fed-1
+  # treats them as implicit, fed-2 imports them. A composed supergraph
+  # defines everything it applies (and federation_sdl? catches it first).
+  SUBGRAPH_LINK = %r{@link\s*\(\s*url:\s*"https://specs\.apollo\.dev/federation/}
+  SUBGRAPH_MARKERS = %w[key external extends provides requires shareable override interfaceObject].freeze
+
+  # A raw subgraph SDL — `rover subgraph fetch`, `_service { sdl }`, or the
+  # .graphql in a service repo — rather than a composed graph.
+  def self.subgraph_sdl?(sdl)
+    return false if federation_sdl?(sdl)
+    return true if sdl.match?(SUBGRAPH_LINK)
+
+    SUBGRAPH_MARKERS.any? { |name| sdl.match?(/@#{name}\b/) && !sdl.match?(/\bdirective\s+@#{name}\b/) }
+  end
+
+  # The subgraph spec's directives and the types they reference, keyed by
+  # what a definition in the SDL would be named ("@key" for a directive).
+  # The helper scalars are spelled `federation__*` — they are weaver's own
+  # injections into someone else's schema, and a subgraph with its own
+  # `FieldSet` type must not collide with one.
+  # https://www.apollographql.com/docs/graphos/schema-design/federated-schemas/reference/subgraph-spec
+  SUBGRAPH_DIRECTIVE_DEFS = {
+    "@key" => "directive @key(fields: federation__FieldSet!, resolvable: Boolean = true) repeatable on OBJECT | INTERFACE",
+    "@external" => "directive @external on OBJECT | FIELD_DEFINITION",
+    "@requires" => "directive @requires(fields: federation__FieldSet!) on FIELD_DEFINITION",
+    "@provides" => "directive @provides(fields: federation__FieldSet!) on FIELD_DEFINITION",
+    "@shareable" => "directive @shareable repeatable on OBJECT | FIELD_DEFINITION",
+    "@extends" => "directive @extends on OBJECT | INTERFACE",
+    "@override" => "directive @override(from: String!, label: String) on FIELD_DEFINITION",
+    "@interfaceObject" => "directive @interfaceObject on OBJECT",
+    "@inaccessible" => "directive @inaccessible on FIELD_DEFINITION | OBJECT | INTERFACE | UNION | ARGUMENT_DEFINITION | SCALAR | ENUM | ENUM_VALUE | INPUT_OBJECT | INPUT_FIELD_DEFINITION",
+    "@tag" => "directive @tag(name: String!) repeatable on FIELD_DEFINITION | OBJECT | INTERFACE | UNION | ARGUMENT_DEFINITION | SCALAR | ENUM | ENUM_VALUE | INPUT_OBJECT | INPUT_FIELD_DEFINITION | SCHEMA",
+    "@composeDirective" => "directive @composeDirective(name: String!) repeatable on SCHEMA",
+    "@authenticated" => "directive @authenticated on FIELD_DEFINITION | OBJECT | INTERFACE | SCALAR | ENUM",
+    "@requiresScopes" => "directive @requiresScopes(scopes: [[federation__Scope!]!]!) on FIELD_DEFINITION | OBJECT | INTERFACE | SCALAR | ENUM",
+    "@policy" => "directive @policy(policies: [[federation__Policy!]!]!) on FIELD_DEFINITION | OBJECT | INTERFACE | SCALAR | ENUM",
+    "@link" => "directive @link(url: String!, as: String, for: link__Purpose, import: [link__Import]) repeatable on SCHEMA",
+  }.freeze
+
+  # The types those definitions reference — injected only alongside a
+  # directive that needs one. `_Any`/`_Entity`/`_Service` (see
+  # entity_plumbing) keep their spec-mandated names; these are ours to
+  # namespace, so they can't shadow a subgraph's own type.
+  SUBGRAPH_HELPER_TYPES = {
+    "federation__FieldSet" => "scalar federation__FieldSet",
+    "federation__Scope" => "scalar federation__Scope",
+    "federation__Policy" => "scalar federation__Policy",
+    "link__Import" => "scalar link__Import",
+    "link__Purpose" => "enum link__Purpose { SECURITY EXECUTION }",
+  }.freeze
+
+  # A fed-2 subgraph that @links the spec under a namespace — `as: "fed"`,
+  # and "federation" is the default — applies every non-imported directive
+  # under it: @federation__key rather than @key.
+  def self.subgraph_namespace(sdl)
+    sdl[/#{SUBGRAPH_LINK}[^)]*\bas:\s*"([^"]+)"/, 1] || "federation"
+  end
+  private_class_method :subgraph_namespace
+
+  # Prepend the definitions this subgraph applies but doesn't declare, under
+  # whichever name it applies them by. Only the missing ones — a duplicate
+  # definition is a hard error in graphql-ruby, and a subgraph spelling out
+  # its own @key (fed-1 style, or a differing shape) must win.
+  def self.add_subgraph_definitions(sdl)
+    defined = GraphQL.parse(sdl).definitions.filter_map do |defn|
+      next unless defn.respond_to?(:name)
+
+      defn.is_a?(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::DirectiveDefinition) ? "@#{defn.name}" : defn.name
+    end.to_set
+    namespace = subgraph_namespace(sdl)
+
+    directives = SUBGRAPH_DIRECTIVE_DEFS.filter_map do |name, defn|
+      applied = [name, "@#{namespace}__#{name.delete_prefix("@")}"]
+        .find { |as| !defined.include?(as) && sdl.match?(/#{as}\b/) }
+      applied && defn.sub(name, applied)
+    end
+    types = SUBGRAPH_HELPER_TYPES
+      .select { |name, _| !defined.include?(name) && directives.any? { |defn| defn.include?(name) } }
+      .values
+
+    added = types + directives + entity_plumbing(sdl, namespace, defined)
+    added.empty? ? sdl : "#{added.join("\n")}\n\n#{sdl}"
+  end
+  private_class_method :add_subgraph_definitions
+
+  # The entity resolver every subgraph serves — and which no subgraph SDL
+  # contains: `_service { sdl }` and `rover subgraph fetch` both print the
+  # published schema, where the plumbing is implicit. Supply it so an
+  # `_entities` query can be typed against the artifact you actually have
+  # (a supergraph doesn't describe `_entities` at all). `_Entity` is the
+  # union of the file's own @key'd types, so it stays accurate per subgraph.
+  # https://www.apollographql.com/docs/graphos/schema-design/federated-schemas/reference/subgraph-spec
+  def self.entity_plumbing(sdl, namespace, defined)
+    doc = GraphQL.parse(sdl)
+    root = query_root_name(doc)
+    entities = entity_names(doc, namespace)
+    return [] if entities.empty? || root.nil? || defined.include?("_Any")
+
+    [
+      "scalar _Any",
+      "type _Service { sdl: String }",
+      "union _Entity = #{entities.join(" | ")}",
+      "extend type #{root} {\n" \
+        "  _entities(representations: [_Any!]!): [_Entity]!\n" \
+        "  _service: _Service!\n" \
+        "}",
+    ]
+  end
+  private_class_method :entity_plumbing
+
+  # The object types this subgraph resolves as entities: the ones it applies
+  # @key to, under whichever name it applies it by (@federation__key when the
+  # spec is linked under a namespace). Type extensions count — fed-1 spells an
+  # entity it doesn't own as `extend type User @key(...)`.
+  def self.entity_names(doc, namespace)
+    key_names = ["key", "#{namespace}__key"]
+
+    doc.definitions.filter_map do |defn|
+      next unless defn.is_a?(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::ObjectTypeDefinition) ||
+        defn.is_a?(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::ObjectTypeExtension)
+
+      defn.name if defn.directives.any? { |d| key_names.include?(d.name) }
+    end.uniq
+  end
+  private_class_method :entity_names
+
+  # The query root's name — `schema { query: Root }` when the file says so,
+  # `Query` by convention. nil when the file has no query root to extend.
+  def self.query_root_name(doc)
+    declared = doc.definitions.grep(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::SchemaDefinition).first ||
+      doc.definitions.grep(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::SchemaExtension).first
+    name = declared&.query || "Query"
+    root_present = doc.definitions.any? do |defn|
+      defn.respond_to?(:name) && defn.name == name &&
+        (defn.is_a?(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::ObjectTypeDefinition) ||
+          defn.is_a?(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::ObjectTypeExtension))
+    end
+    name if root_present
+  end
+  private_class_method :query_root_name
+
+  # how a schema declares the specs it's built from: @link in fed 2, @core in fed 1
+  LINK_DIRECTIVES = %w[link core].to_set.freeze
+
+  # The floor a supergraph gets whether it declares the specs or not — a
+  # hand-written or trimmed one often has no @link header at all. Derivation
+  # only ever adds to this.
+  DEFAULT_PREFIXES = %w[join__ link__ core__].freeze
+  DEFAULT_DIRECTIVES = %w[link core inaccessible].freeze
+
+  # What THIS document calls federation's machinery — type-name prefixes,
+  # directive names, and the local names @inaccessible answers to — read off
+  # its own @link/@core declarations rather than assumed: a linked spec's name
+  # gives both a `join__` type prefix and a root `@join` directive, `as:`
+  # renames it, and each `import:` entry binds one more directive in the root
+  # namespace, possibly under a different local name. A missed @inaccessible
+  # rename over-permits the derived API schema, not merely leaks a type.
+  # https://specs.apollo.dev/link/v1.0/ · https://specs.apollo.dev/core/v0.2/
+  def self.link_namespaces(doc)
+    prefixes = DEFAULT_PREFIXES.dup
+    directives = DEFAULT_DIRECTIVES.to_set
+    inaccessible = Set["inaccessible"]
+
+    link_declarations(doc).each do |args|
+      spec = spec_name(args["url"] || args["feature"])
+      local = args["as"].is_a?(String) ? args["as"] : spec
+      if local
+        prefixes << "#{local}__"
+        directives << local
+        # a spec's root directive is its own name: @link(url: ".../inaccessible/v0.2", as: "private")
+        inaccessible << local if spec == "inaccessible"
+      end
+
+      imports(args["import"]).each do |name, as|
+        next unless as.start_with?("@")
+
+        directives << as.delete_prefix("@")
+        inaccessible << as.delete_prefix("@") if name == "@inaccessible"
+      end
+    end
+
+    { prefixes: prefixes.uniq.freeze, directives: directives.freeze, inaccessible: inaccessible.freeze }
+  end
+  private_class_method :link_namespaces
+
+  # The @link/@core applications on the document's schema definition, each as
+  # a plain argument hash.
+  def self.link_declarations(doc)
+    doc.definitions.flat_map do |defn|
+      next [] unless defn.is_a?(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::SchemaDefinition) ||
+        defn.is_a?(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::SchemaExtension)
+
+      defn.directives
+        .select { |d| LINK_DIRECTIVES.include?(d.name) }
+        .map { |d| d.arguments.to_h { |arg| [arg.name, arg.value] } }
+    end
+  end
+  private_class_method :link_declarations
+
+  # `import: ["@key", {name: "@inaccessible", as: "@private"}]` as
+  # [spec name, local name] pairs.
+  def self.imports(value)
+    Array(value).filter_map do |entry|
+      case entry
+      when String then [entry, entry]
+      when GraphQL::Language::Nodes::InputObject
+        fields = entry.to_h
+        name = fields["name"]
+        [name, fields["as"].is_a?(String) ? fields["as"] : name] if name.is_a?(String)
+      end
+    end
+  end
+  private_class_method :imports
+
+  VERSION_TAG = /\Av\d+\.\d+\z/
+  GRAPHQL_NAME = /\A[A-Za-z][A-Za-z0-9_]*\z/
+
+  # The name a linked spec's elements are namespaced under: the URL's
+  # penultimate path segment when the last is a version tag, else the last one.
+  # Query strings, fragments and empty segments don't count. A segment that
+  # can't be a namespace (a bare host, or a name carrying the `__` separator)
+  # means the URL is just an opaque identifier and nothing is derived.
+  # https://specs.apollo.dev/link/v1.0/
+  def self.spec_name(url)
+    return unless url.is_a?(String)
+
+    segments = url.split(/[?#]/).first.to_s.split("/").reject(&:empty?)
+    segments.pop if segments.last&.match?(VERSION_TAG)
+    name = segments.last
+    name if name&.match?(GRAPHQL_NAME) && !name.include?("__") && !name.end_with?("_")
+  end
+  private_class_method :spec_name
 
   # Synthetic composition TYPES are always prefixed (join__Graph, link__Import).
   # The bare names (link/core/inaccessible) are DIRECTIVES only — a user type
   # literally named `link` (Hasura-style lowercase) must not be dropped.
-  def self.federation_type_name?(name)
-    !!name && name.start_with?(*FEDERATION_PREFIXES)
+  def self.federation_type_name?(name, ns)
+    !!name && name.start_with?(*ns[:prefixes])
   end
   private_class_method :federation_type_name?
 
-  def self.federation_directive_name?(name)
-    !!name && (name.start_with?(*FEDERATION_PREFIXES) || FEDERATION_DIRECTIVES.include?(name))
+  def self.federation_directive_name?(name, ns)
+    !!name && (name.start_with?(*ns[:prefixes]) || ns[:directives].include?(name))
   end
   private_class_method :federation_directive_name?
 
@@ -80,9 +413,10 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
   # and no join__* leaking into schema.types.
   def self.strip_federation(sdl)
     doc = GraphQL.parse(sdl)
-    defs = remove_inaccessible(doc.definitions)
-      .reject { |defn| federation_definition?(defn) }
-      .map { |defn| strip_federation_directives(defn) }
+    ns = link_namespaces(doc)
+    defs = remove_inaccessible(doc.definitions, ns)
+      .reject { |defn| federation_definition?(defn, ns) }
+      .map { |defn| strip_federation_directives(defn, ns) }
 
     if defs.none? { |d| d.is_a?(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::ObjectTypeDefinition) }
       raise GraphWeaver::Error,
@@ -95,13 +429,13 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
 
   # a synthetic composition definition to drop: a federation directive
   # definition (by name), or a synthetic join__*/link__* type (by prefix)
-  def self.federation_definition?(defn)
+  def self.federation_definition?(defn, ns)
     return false unless defn.respond_to?(:name)
 
     if defn.is_a?(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::DirectiveDefinition)
-      federation_directive_name?(defn.name)
+      federation_directive_name?(defn.name, ns)
     else
-      federation_type_name?(defn.name)
+      federation_type_name?(defn.name, ns)
     end
   end
   private_class_method :federation_definition?
@@ -114,12 +448,12 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
   # removed — repeated to a fixpoint. So codegen matches exactly what clients
   # can query, without the over-permitting a raw supergraph would allow and
   # without Apollo's JS tooling to subtract the API schema.
-  def self.remove_inaccessible(definitions)
-    removed = definitions.select { |d| type_definition?(d) && inaccessible?(d) }.map(&:name).to_set
+  def self.remove_inaccessible(definitions, ns)
+    removed = definitions.select { |d| type_definition?(d) && inaccessible?(d, ns) }.map(&:name).to_set
     loop do
       survivors = definitions
         .reject { |d| type_definition?(d) && removed.include?(d.name) }
-        .map { |d| prune_inaccessible(d, removed) }
+        .map { |d| prune_inaccessible(d, removed, ns) }
       # survivors already exclude `removed`, so anything newly emptied is fresh
       newly = survivors.select { |d| type_definition?(d) && type_emptied?(d) }.map(&:name)
       return survivors if newly.empty?
@@ -138,8 +472,9 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
   end
   private_class_method :type_definition?
 
-  def self.inaccessible?(node)
-    node.respond_to?(:directives) && node.directives.any? { |d| d.name == "inaccessible" }
+  # @inaccessible under whatever local name the schema's @link bound it to.
+  def self.inaccessible?(node, ns)
+    node.respond_to?(:directives) && node.directives.any? { |d| ns[:inaccessible].include?(d.name) }
   end
   private_class_method :inaccessible?
 
@@ -164,9 +499,9 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
   # Remove @inaccessible children and children referencing a removed type,
   # from a type's fields (and their arguments), enum values, union members,
   # and implemented interfaces.
-  def self.prune_inaccessible(node, removed)
+  def self.prune_inaccessible(node, removed, ns)
     gone = lambda do |child|
-      inaccessible?(child) || (child.respond_to?(:type) && removed.include?(unwrapped_type_name(child)))
+      inaccessible?(child, ns) || (child.respond_to?(:type) && removed.include?(unwrapped_type_name(child)))
     end
 
     changes = {}
@@ -176,6 +511,10 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
         args && args.any? ? field.merge(arguments: args.reject(&gone)) : field
       end
     end
+    # a directive definition's own arguments — the only top-level node with
+    # them, and Apollo's REFERENCED_INACCESSIBLE rule should already have
+    # rejected such a supergraph; belt and braces for hand-written ones
+    changes[:arguments] = node.arguments.reject(&gone) if node.respond_to?(:arguments) && node.arguments
     changes[:values] = node.values.reject(&gone) if node.respond_to?(:values) && node.values
     changes[:types] = node.types.reject { |t| removed.include?(t.name) } if node.respond_to?(:types) && node.types
     if node.respond_to?(:interfaces) && node.interfaces
@@ -187,14 +526,23 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
 
   # Recursively remove @join__*/@link applications from a definition and its
   # fields, arguments, and enum values.
-  def self.strip_federation_directives(node)
+  def self.strip_federation_directives(node, ns)
     changes = {}
     if node.respond_to?(:directives) && node.directives
-      changes[:directives] = node.directives.reject { |d| federation_directive_name?(d.name) }
+      # A schema definition keeps NONE: graphql-ruby's printer omits the
+      # `{ query: Query }` body when the root type names are conventional but
+      # still prints directives, so any survivor (@tag, @composeDirective, a
+      # composed custom one) reprints as an unparseable braceless `schema @tag`.
+      # Codegen never reads schema directives.
+      changes[:directives] = if node.is_a?(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::SchemaDefinition)
+        []
+      else
+        node.directives.reject { |d| federation_directive_name?(d.name, ns) }
+      end
     end
-    changes[:fields] = node.fields.map { |c| strip_federation_directives(c) } if node.respond_to?(:fields) && node.fields
-    changes[:arguments] = node.arguments.map { |c| strip_federation_directives(c) } if node.respond_to?(:arguments) && node.arguments
-    changes[:values] = node.values.map { |c| strip_federation_directives(c) } if node.respond_to?(:values) && node.values
+    changes[:fields] = node.fields.map { |c| strip_federation_directives(c, ns) } if node.respond_to?(:fields) && node.fields
+    changes[:arguments] = node.arguments.map { |c| strip_federation_directives(c, ns) } if node.respond_to?(:arguments) && node.arguments
+    changes[:values] = node.values.map { |c| strip_federation_directives(c, ns) } if node.respond_to?(:values) && node.values
     changes.empty? ? node : node.merge(changes)
   end
   private_class_method :strip_federation_directives
@@ -212,7 +560,10 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
   #     reads (its extension picks the format)
   #   - a path — the extension picks the format: .json is the verbatim
   #     introspection result, .graphql/.gql is SDL (human-readable,
-  #     PR-reviewable diffs); both load back identically
+  #     PR-reviewable diffs). Both load back to the same schema, but not
+  #     at the same cost: SDL has to be parsed, so on a big schema
+  #     (GitHub's 2.9 MB) it's roughly twice as slow to load — SDL for
+  #     reviewability, JSON when boot time matters.
   #   - :json / :graphql / :gql — GraphWeaver.schema_path's location, in
   #     that format
   # Reading is format-agnostic: any fresh sibling dump counts, whatever
@@ -230,7 +581,7 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
   #        GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader.introspect(transport).to_json
   #      end
   #      schema = GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader.load(json)
-  def self.introspect(transport, cache: nil, ttl: nil)
+  def self.introspect(transport, cache: nil, ttl: nil, auth_env: nil)
     cache = cache_path(cache)
 
     if cache
@@ -246,12 +597,21 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
       GraphWeaver.log(:info) { "schema cache miss: #{cache}" }
     end
 
-    result = GraphWeaver.log_timed(:info, "introspected #{transport.respond_to?(:url) ? transport.url : transport.class}") do
+    result = GraphWeaver.log_timed(:info, "introspected #{endpoint(transport)}") do
       transport.execute(GraphQL::Introspection.query, variables: {}).to_h
     end
     if (errors = result["errors"])
       raise GraphWeaver::Error, "introspection failed: #{errors.inspect}"
     end
+    # a 200 of well-formed JSON that isn't an introspection result — a REST
+    # base url, a GraphiQL page, a proxy that ate the path. from_introspection
+    # would raise a bare NoMethodError on the missing "__schema" key.
+    data = result["data"]
+    unless data.is_a?(Hash) && data["__schema"]
+      raise GraphWeaver::Error,
+        "introspection at #{endpoint(transport)} returned no __schema — is that a GraphQL " \
+        "endpoint? got: #{result.inspect[0, 200]}"
+    end
 
     schema = GraphQL::Schema.from_introspection(result)
 
@@ -260,7 +620,7 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
       # the extension picks the format: .json is the verbatim wire
       # artifact; .graphql/.gql is SDL — human-readable, PR-reviewable
       # diffs (both generate byte-identical code)
-      meta = stamp(transport)
+      meta = stamp(transport, auth_env)
       content = if cache.end_with?(".json")
         JSON.generate(meta ? result.merge("graph_weaver" => meta) : result)
       else
@@ -274,6 +634,13 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
     schema
   end
 
+  # What to call the thing we introspected, for a log line or an error: its
+  # url when it has one, else the class (a schema class, a fake).
+  def self.endpoint(transport)
+    (transport.respond_to?(:url) && transport.url) || transport.class
+  end
+  private_class_method :endpoint
+
   # The conventional schema dump, whatever its format: schema_path or the
   # first sibling extension that exists. nil when none is on disk.
   def self.locate_path(path = GraphWeaver.schema_path)
@@ -286,8 +653,13 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
     found && load(found)
   end
 
+  # The ENV var holding the token for a private API, when the dump doesn't
+  # name its own.
+  DEFAULT_AUTH_ENV = "GRAPHWEAVER_AUTH"
+
   # The provenance recorded in a dump ({"url" => ..., "introspected_at"
-  # => ...}), whichever format holds it; nil for local/unannotated dumps.
+  # => ..., "auth_env" => ...}), whichever format holds it; nil for
+  # local/unannotated dumps.
   def self.provenance(path)
     content = File.read(path)
     if path.end_with?(".json")
@@ -297,10 +669,19 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
     end
   end
 
+  # The ENV var a dump's token lives in — whichever the generator recorded,
+  # else GRAPHWEAVER_AUTH. Keeps `--auth MY_TOKEN` from producing an app
+  # that authenticates and rake tasks that 401.
+  def self.auth_env(path = nil)
+    # the first refresh names a dump that doesn't exist yet
+    recorded = provenance(path)&.dig("auth_env") if path && File.exist?(path)
+    recorded || DEFAULT_AUTH_ENV
+  end
+
   # Re-introspect a dump's source and compare — true when the server has
   # drifted from what's on disk. transport: overrides the transport (auth
   # etc); by default one is built from the dump's recorded url. Wired up
-  # as `rake graph_weaver:schema:verify` / `:refresh`.
+  # as `rake graph_weaver:schema:diff` / `:refresh`.
   def self.stale?(path, transport: nil)
     transport ||= source_transport(path)
     fresh = introspect(transport)
@@ -308,28 +689,63 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
     fresh.to_definition != load(path).to_definition
   end
 
-  # a transport to the dump's recorded url (GRAPHWEAVER_AUTH supplies a
-  # token when set)
+  # Re-introspect and rewrite the local dump, returning [path, url].
+  # url: defaults to the one the dump recorded, so a refresh needs no
+  # arguments once a dump exists — and passing one bootstraps the first
+  # dump, which is what `rails g graph_weaver:install` does.
+  # auth_env: the ENV var holding the token — defaults to whichever the
+  # dump recorded, so `--auth MY_TOKEN` keeps working on every later
+  # refresh without being repeated. auth: passes a token directly.
+  def self.refresh!(url: nil, auth_env: nil, auth: nil)
+    path = locate_path
+    url ||= path && provenance(path)&.dig("url")
+    raise GraphWeaver::Error, refresh_hint(path) unless url
+
+    path ||= GraphWeaver.schema_path
+    auth_env ||= self.auth_env(path)
+    auth ||= ENV[auth_env]
+    # ttl: 0 — an existing dump never counts as fresh, a refresh always refetches
+    introspect(GraphWeaver.new(url, auth:).transport, cache: path, ttl: 0, auth_env:)
+    [path, url]
+  end
+
+  def self.refresh_hint(path)
+    missing = path ? "#{path} records no source url" : "no schema dump at #{GraphWeaver.schema_path}"
+    "#{missing} — pass one: rake graph_weaver:schema:refresh URL=https://api.example.com/graphql " \
+      "(a dump taken from a schema class is rebuilt from code, not re-fetched — see " \
+      "docs/getting_started.md#your-apps-own-schema-in-process)"
+  end
+  private_class_method :refresh_hint
+
+  # A transport to the dump's recorded url, authenticated from whichever ENV
+  # var the dump named (else DEFAULT_AUTH_ENV). The single way to reach a
+  # dump's own server — building one at a call site is how `--auth MY_TOKEN`
+  # ends up honoured in some places and not others.
   def self.source_transport(path)
     meta = provenance(path)
     unless meta&.key?("url")
-      raise GraphWeaver::Error, "#{path} records no source url — pass transport:"
+      raise GraphWeaver::Error,
+        "#{path} records no source url — it wasn't introspected from one. Pass transport:, " \
+        "or rebuild it from the schema class that produced it."
     end
 
-    GraphWeaver.new(meta["url"], auth: ENV["GRAPHWEAVER_AUTH"]).transport
+    GraphWeaver.new(meta["url"], auth: ENV[auth_env(path)]).transport
   end
-  private_class_method :source_transport
 
   # Where a dump came from, recorded into the file so it can be
   # re-verified later — a parsable header comment in SDL, a
   # "graph_weaver" sibling key in introspection JSON (from_introspection
   # reads only "data"). nil when the transport has no url (schema
   # classes, fakes).
-  def self.stamp(transport)
+  def self.stamp(transport, auth_env = nil)
     return unless transport.respond_to?(:url) && transport.url
 
     require "time"
-    { "url" => transport.url, "introspected_at" => Time.now.utc.iso8601 }
+    meta = { "url" => transport.url, "introspected_at" => Time.now.utc.iso8601 }
+    # only the non-default var is worth recording — auth_env falls back to
+    # DEFAULT_AUTH_ENV, so an unannotated dump reads the same either way
+    meta["auth_env"] = auth_env if auth_env && auth_env != DEFAULT_AUTH_ENV
+    meta
   end
   private_class_method :stamp
 
@@ -377,4 +793,347 @@ module GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader
     File.exist?(path) && (ttl.nil? || Time.now - File.mtime(path) < ttl)
   end
   private_class_method :fresh?
+
+  # The other half of a supergraph. `load` strips the @join__* machinery to
+  # get the API schema; this keeps it — who resolves what:
+  #
+  #      table = GraphWeaver::SchemaLoader.routing_table("supergraph.graphql")
+  #      table.owners("Product", "shippingEstimate")  # => ["reviews"]
+  #      table.keys("Product", "products")            # => [["upc"]]
+  #
+  # Takes the same sources `load` does, minus an introspection result — a
+  # router's introspection answers with the API schema, which by design says
+  # nothing about subgraphs.
+  def self.routing_table(source)
+    sdl = supergraph_sdl(source)
+    unless federation_sdl?(sdl)
+      raise GraphWeaver::Error,
+        "no routing table here — a composed supergraph SDL carries one in its @join__* markers, " \
+        "and this schema has none (a subgraph or an API schema describes one service's slice, " \
+        "not who resolves what)"
+    end
+
+    RoutingTable.new(sdl)
+  end
+
+  def self.supergraph_sdl(source)
+    if source.is_a?(Hash)
+      raise GraphWeaver::Error,
+        "an introspection result carries no routing table — introspection answers with the API " \
+        "schema. Load the composed supergraph SDL instead."
+    end
+
+    text = source.to_s
+    sdl_content?(text) ? text : read_schema(text)
+  end
+  private_class_method :supergraph_sdl
+
+  # Which subgraph resolves what, read off a composed supergraph's @join__*
+  # directives. Subgraphs are named the way `@join__graph(name:)` names them —
+  # the same strings a router config and `rover` use — not the SDL's uppercase
+  # enum spelling.
+  #
+  # Everything here is a plain read of the artifact. It cannot plan a query;
+  # it answers the questions a planner (or an error message) asks.
+  class RoutingTable
+    # One field's routing: `graphs` resolve it, `external` declare it without
+    # resolving it (an @external copy exists so that subgraph can @key or
+    # @requires on it), and requires/provides/override carry the field sets and
+    # the migration marker verbatim.
+    Field = Struct.new(:graphs, :external, :requires, :provides, :override)
+
+    # Every @join__ directive this table understands. One it doesn't is a
+    # federation construct nobody has taught it to read, and it lands in
+    # `unsupported` rather than being skipped — a routing table that silently
+    # ignores half a spec version routes confidently and wrongly.
+    KNOWN = %w[
+      join__type join__field join__graph join__implements
+      join__unionMember join__enumValue join__owner
+    ].to_set.freeze
+
+    # every subgraph in the graph, in the order the supergraph declares them
+    attr_reader :subgraphs
+
+    # constructs found in this supergraph that the table can't describe
+    # faithfully, each as a one-line explanation
+    attr_reader :unsupported
+
+    # { "Media" => ["catalog"] } — types a subgraph resolves as an
+    # @interfaceObject, so it answers a whole interface's implementations and
+    # this table can't attribute their fields subgraph by subgraph. Not in
+    # `unsupported` because it is a fact about one type rather than about the
+    # table: a query that never reaches the type is unaffected, and only a
+    # caller planning one can tell.
+    attr_reader :interface_objects
+
+    def initialize(sdl)
+      @document = GraphQL.parse(sdl)
+      @names = {}        # "ACCOUNTS" => "accounts"
+      @declared_in = {}  # "User" => ["accounts", "reviews"]
+      @keys = {}         # "User" => { "accounts" => [["id"]] }
+      @fields = {}       # "User" => { "reviews" => Field }
+      @field_names = {}  # "User" => Set["id", "username"]
+      @abstract = {}     # "FeedItem" => ["Announcement", "Review"]
+      @possible = {}     # "FeedItem" => { "reviews" => ["Announcement", "Review"] }
+      @unsupported = []
+      @interface_objects = {}
+
+      read_graphs
+      read_abstracts
+      read_types
+      @subgraphs = @names.values.freeze
+    end
+
+    # Which subgraphs can resolve Type.field, by name. A field with no
+    # @join__field at all lives wherever its type does — the composer omits
+    # the directive when it has nothing to say, and that omission is the
+    # supergraph spec's way of saying "everywhere".
+    def owners(type_name, field_name)
+      field = self.field(type_name, field_name)
+      return declared_in(type_name) if field.nil?
+      return field.graphs if field.graphs.any?
+
+      # declared only as @external/@usedOverridden: a reference, not a resolver
+      field.external.any? ? [] : declared_in(type_name)
+    end
+
+    # The routing for Type.field, or nil when the supergraph says nothing
+    # about it (see owners).
+    def field(type_name, field_name) = @fields.dig(type_name, field_name)
+
+    # which subgraphs declare a type, by name
+    def declared_in(type_name) = @declared_in[type_name] || []
+
+    # every type the supergraph places, in the order it declares them —
+    # owners/declared_in answer questions about one, this is the list
+    def types = @declared_in.keys
+
+    # The fields of a type the supergraph routes explicitly. A field with no
+    # @join__field isn't here: it lives wherever its type does, so the
+    # supergraph names no subgraph for it (see owners).
+    def fields(type_name) = (@fields[type_name] || {}).keys
+
+    # Every field the supergraph's type declares, routed or not — `fields`
+    # answers which of them it routes explicitly, this answers what is
+    # there.
+    def declared_fields(type_name) = @field_names[type_name]&.to_a || []
+
+    # Whether the supergraph carries this coordinate at all — a type, or a
+    # field on it. `owners`/`fields` answer who resolves what the supergraph
+    # has; this answers whether it has it, which is the question a local
+    # schema's extra field poses.
+    def declares?(type_name, field_name = nil)
+      return @declared_in.key?(type_name) if field_name.nil?
+
+      !!@field_names[type_name]&.include?(field_name)
+    end
+
+    # Who to name in an error about a coordinate: the subgraphs that resolve
+    # Type.field, or — for a bare type, or a field the supergraph no longer
+    # carries — the ones that declare the type. Empty when it places
+    # neither, so a message can simply say nothing.
+    def responsible(type_name, field_name = nil)
+      return declared_in(type_name) unless field_name && declares?(type_name, field_name)
+
+      owners(type_name, field_name)
+    end
+
+    # A `subgraphs:` map with string keys, refusing a name this supergraph
+    # doesn't have — a typo'd key would otherwise silently configure nothing.
+    # Lives here so the test router and the drift check refuse identically:
+    # two copies of this drifted apart once already.
+    def named_subgraphs(given)
+      map = (given || {}).to_h { |name, schema| [name.to_s, schema] }
+      unknown = map.keys - subgraphs
+      return map if unknown.empty?
+
+      raise GraphWeaver::ConfigurationError, "subgraphs: names #{unknown.join(", ")}, which " \
+        "this supergraph doesn't have (its subgraphs are #{subgraphs.join(", ")})"
+    end
+
+    # The @key field sets a subgraph will answer an `_entities` fetch on, each
+    # as a list of dotted paths ("id organization { id }" => ["id",
+    # "organization.id"]). A `resolvable: false` key declares a shape this
+    # subgraph does not answer for, so it isn't one.
+    def keys(type_name, subgraph) = @keys.dig(type_name, subgraph) || []
+
+    # whether any subgraph will resolve this type from a key
+    def entity?(type_name) = (@keys[type_name] || {}).each_value.any?(&:any?)
+
+    # The concrete types `subgraph` can answer an abstract type with — a
+    # union's members there, an interface's implementations there. Only these
+    # may be named in a fetch to it: a subgraph rejects an `... on T` its own
+    # schema doesn't place in the abstract type.
+    #
+    # nil when the supergraph doesn't say, which a caller has to treat as
+    # unknown rather than empty. @join__unionMember / @join__implements record
+    # it; a supergraph composed before those existed carries neither, and then
+    # only a type declared in ONE subgraph is answerable — everything it can
+    # possibly return is that subgraph's.
+    def possible_types(type_name, subgraph)
+      all = @abstract[type_name] or return
+
+      per_graph = @possible[type_name]
+      return per_graph[subgraph] || [] if per_graph
+
+      all if declared_in(type_name).one?
+    end
+
+    def inspect = "#<#{self.class.name} subgraphs=#{@subgraphs.inspect}>"
+    alias to_s inspect
+
+    # A @key/@requires/@provides field set is a selection set. Flattened to
+    # dotted paths, so a nested one is recognizable as nested by its shape.
+    def self.parse_field_set(text)
+      flatten(GraphQL.parse("{ #{text} }").definitions.first.selections, [])
+    end
+
+    def self.flatten(selections, prefix)
+      selections.flat_map do |node|
+        unless node.is_a?(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::Field)
+          raise GraphWeaver::Error, "a field set holds plain fields only, got #{node.class}"
+        end
+
+        if node.selections.any?
+          flatten(node.selections, prefix + [node.name])
+        else
+          [(prefix + [node.name]).join(".")]
+        end
+      end
+    end
+    private_class_method :flatten
+
+    private
+
+    # join__Graph's enum values ARE the subgraphs: ACCOUNTS
+    # @join__graph(name: "accounts", url: "...").
+    #
+    # This table reads the join spec under its default name, and only that —
+    # a supergraph that renamed it (`@link(url: ".../join/v0.3", as: "j")`)
+    # spells every marker `j__` and lands here with nothing found. Being told
+    # a composed graph has no subgraphs is worse than being refused, so an
+    # empty read is `unsupported` rather than an answer.
+    def read_graphs
+      enum = @document.definitions.find do |defn|
+        defn.is_a?(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::EnumTypeDefinition) && defn.name == "join__Graph"
+      end
+
+      enum&.values&.each do |value|
+        name = argument(value.directives.find { |d| d.name == "join__graph" }, "name")
+        @names[value.name] = name if name
+      end
+
+      return if @names.any?
+
+      @unsupported << "no join__Graph enum names the subgraphs — this schema declares a " \
+        "composition spec, so either it merged nothing, or it renamed the join spec " \
+        "(@link(url: \".../join/v0.3\", as: \"...\")), which this table doesn't follow"
+    end
+
+    # What each abstract type can be, from the SDL alone — a union's members,
+    # and the objects that name an interface in their `implements`. The
+    # per-subgraph split comes from @join__ directives in read_types; this is
+    # the whole of it, which is all a single-subgraph abstract type needs.
+    def read_abstracts
+      @document.definitions.each do |defn|
+        case defn
+        when GraphQL::Language::Nodes::UnionTypeDefinition
+          @abstract[defn.name] = defn.types.map(&:name)
+        when GraphQL::Language::Nodes::InterfaceTypeDefinition
+          @abstract[defn.name] ||= []
+        when GraphQL::Language::Nodes::ObjectTypeDefinition
+          defn.interfaces.each { |iface| (@abstract[iface.name] ||= []) << defn.name }
+        end
+      end
+    end
+
+    # An interface implemented by another interface isn't a possible type —
+    # only the objects underneath it are, and each names the interface itself.
+    def read_possible(defn)
+      defn.directives.each do |directive|
+        name = subgraph(directive) or next
+        case directive.name
+        when "join__unionMember"
+          member = argument(directive, "member") or next
+          ((@possible[defn.name] ||= {})[name] ||= []) << member
+        when "join__implements"
+          next unless defn.is_a?(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::ObjectTypeDefinition)
+
+          iface = argument(directive, "interface") or next
+          ((@possible[iface] ||= {})[name] ||= []) << defn.name
+        end
+      end
+    end
+
+    def read_types
+      @document.definitions.each do |defn|
+        note_unknown(defn, defn.respond_to?(:name) ? defn.name : "schema")
+        next unless defn.respond_to?(:name) && defn.respond_to?(:directives)
+        next if defn.name.start_with?("join__", "link__", "core__")
+
+        joins = defn.directives.select { |d| d.name == "join__type" }
+        @declared_in[defn.name] = joins.filter_map { |d| subgraph(d) }.uniq
+        @keys[defn.name] = read_keys(joins)
+        read_possible(defn)
+
+        as_object = joins.select { |d| argument(d, "isInterfaceObject") == true }
+        @interface_objects[defn.name] = as_object.filter_map { |d| subgraph(d) } if as_object.any?
+
+        read_fields(defn)
+      end
+    end
+
+    def read_keys(joins)
+      joins.each_with_object({}) do |directive, acc|
+        name = subgraph(directive) or next
+        acc[name] ||= []
+        key = argument(directive, "key")
+        acc[name] << self.class.parse_field_set(key) if key && argument(directive, "resolvable") != false
+      end
+    end
+
+    def read_fields(defn)
+      return unless defn.respond_to?(:fields) && defn.fields
+
+      @field_names[defn.name] = defn.fields.map(&:name).to_set
+      @fields[defn.name] = defn.fields.filter_map do |field|
+        note_unknown(field, "#{defn.name}.#{field.name}")
+        applied = field.directives.select { |d| d.name == "join__field" }
+        next if applied.empty? # the supergraph says nothing — see owners
+
+        external, resolvable = applied.partition do |d|
+          argument(d, "external") == true || argument(d, "usedOverridden") == true
+        end
+
+        [field.name, Field.new(
+          resolvable.filter_map { |d| subgraph(d) },
+          external.filter_map { |d| subgraph(d) },
+          resolvable.filter_map { |d| argument(d, "requires") }.first,
+          resolvable.filter_map { |d| argument(d, "provides") }.first,
+          applied.filter_map { |d| argument(d, "override") }.first,
+        )]
+      end.to_h
+    end
+
+    def note_unknown(node, where)
+      return unless node.respond_to?(:directives) && node.directives
+
+      node.directives.each do |directive|
+        next unless directive.name.start_with?("join__")
+        next if KNOWN.include?(directive.name)
+
+        @unsupported << "#{where} applies @#{directive.name}, which this table doesn't read"
+      end
+    end
+
+    # the subgraph NAME a directive's graph: argument points at
+    def subgraph(directive) = @names[argument(directive, "graph")]
+
+    def argument(directive, name)
+      return unless directive
+
+      value = directive.arguments.find { |arg| arg.name == name }&.value
+      value.is_a?(GraphQL::Language::Nodes::Enum) ? value.name : value
+    end
+  end
 end