claude_memory 0.4.0 → 0.5.0

data/docs/quality_review.md

@@ -1,743 +1,102 @@
 # Code Quality Review - Ruby Best Practices
 
-**Review Date:** 2026-01-29 (Updated)
-
-**Previous Review:** 2026-01-27
+**Review Date:** 2026-02-04
+**Previous Review:** 2026-01-29
+**Last Quality Update:** 2026-02-04 (21/24 items completed)
 
 ---
 
 ## Executive Summary
 
-**OUTSTANDING PROGRESS!** The team has achieved major architectural breakthroughs since January 27th:
-
-### Major Wins Since Last Review ✅
-
-1. **Recall.rb Reduced 24%**: 754 → 575 lines, 58 → 11 visible public methods
-2. **MCP Tools.rb Refactored 43%**: 1,039 → 592 lines with proper extractions
-3. **MCP Modules Extracted**: 683 lines properly separated into 3 new modules:
-   - ResponseFormatter (331 lines) - Pure formatting logic
-   - ToolDefinitions (279 lines) - Tool schemas as data
-   - SetupStatusAnalyzer (73 lines) - Pure status analysis
-4. **OperationTracker Fixed**: JSON functions replaced with Ruby JSON handling  ✅
-5. **DualQueryTemplate Added**: 64 lines, eliminates dual-database query duplication
-6. **More Pure Core Classes**: ConceptRanker (74 lines), FactQueryBuilder (154 lines)
-
-### Critical Achievements
-
-The codebase has crossed a major quality threshold:
-- **God objects resolved**: Both Recall and MCP Tools dramatically reduced
-- **Functional core growing**: 17+ pure logic classes in Core/
-- **Proper extractions**: ResponseFormatter, ToolDefinitions, SetupStatusAnalyzer
-- **Strategy emerging**: DualQueryTemplate shows path to full strategy pattern
-
-### Remaining Work
-
-Despite excellent progress, some refinements remain:
-1. Complete strategy pattern extraction in Recall (legacy mode conditionals still present)
-2. Individual tool classes for MCP (optional improvement)
-3. String timestamps to DateTime migration
-4. Result objects for consistent returns
-5. Constructor side effects in LexicalFTS
-
----
-
-## 1. Sandi Metz Perspective (POODR)
-
-### What's Been Fixed Since Last Review ✅
-
-- **Recall.rb reduced 24%**: 754 → 575 lines, method count 58 → visible public methods ~11
-- **MCP Tools.rb refactored 43%**: 1,039 → 592 lines
-- **Three major extractions**:
-  - ResponseFormatter (331 lines) - Pure formatting logic
-  - ToolDefinitions (279 lines) - Tool schemas as data
-  - SetupStatusAnalyzer (73 lines) - Pure status analysis
-- **DualQueryTemplate extracted**: 64 lines, eliminates duplication
-- **FactQueryBuilder extracted**: 154 lines, pure query construction
-
-**Evidence of Progress:**
-
-```ruby
-# recall.rb:575 total lines (down from 754)
-# Now clearly organized:
-# - 11 public query methods (lines 42-124)
-# - Private implementation methods well-separated
-# - Uses DualQueryTemplate to eliminate duplication
-
-# mcp/tools.rb:592 total lines (down from 1,039)
-# Clean delegation:
-def recall(args)
-  results = @recall.query(args["query"], limit: limit, scope: scope)
-  ResponseFormatter.format_recall_results(results)  # Extracted!
-end
-
-# New extractions show proper SRP:
-# response_formatter.rb:331 lines - ONLY formatting
-# tool_definitions.rb:279 lines - ONLY schemas
-# setup_status_analyzer.rb:73 lines - ONLY status logic
-```
-
-### Issues Remaining
-
-#### 🟡 Medium Priority: Complete Strategy Pattern in Recall
-
-**Status**: Recall still has legacy mode conditional routing, but impact is now minor:
-
-```ruby
-# recall.rb still has legacy mode checks
-def query(query_text, limit: 10, scope: SCOPE_ALL)
-  if @legacy_mode
-    query_legacy(query_text, limit: limit, scope: scope)
-  else
-    query_dual(query_text, limit: limit, scope: scope)
-  end
-end
-```
-
-**However**, this is now much less problematic because:
-- Only 10 routing conditionals (down from dozens)
-- DualQueryTemplate handles dual-mode elegantly
-- Legacy mode is for backwards compatibility only
-- File size is reasonable (575 lines)
-
-**Sandi Metz Says:** "This is now acceptable. Legacy support is a valid reason for conditionals when the alternative mode is well-isolated."
-
-**Recommended (Optional) Fix:**
-
-```ruby
-# Could complete strategy pattern, but not urgent
-class Recall
-  def initialize(store_or_manager, **options)
-    @strategy = build_strategy(store_or_manager, options)
-  end
-
-  def query(query_text, limit: 10, scope: SCOPE_ALL)
-    @strategy.query(query_text, limit: limit, scope: scope)
-  end
-
-  private
-
-  def build_strategy(store_or_manager, options)
-    if store_or_manager.is_a?(Store::StoreManager)
-      Recall::DualStoreStrategy.new(store_or_manager, options)
-    else
-      Recall::LegacyStoreStrategy.new(store_or_manager, options)
-    end
-  end
-end
-```
-
-**Estimated Effort:** 1-2 days (optional refinement)
-
-**Priority:** 🟡 Medium (system works well as-is)
-
----
-
-## 2. Jeremy Evans Perspective (Sequel Expert)
-
-### What's Been Fixed Since Last Review ✅
-
-- **OperationTracker JSON functions FIXED**: Now uses Ruby JSON handling! ✅
-- **WAL checkpoint added**: `checkpoint_wal` method implemented ✅
-- **Migrations stable**: 7 proper Sequel migration files
-- **Transaction safety**: Used consistently in critical operations
-
-**Evidence:**
-
-```ruby
-# operation_tracker.rb:113-125 - NOW FIXED!
-stuck.all.each do |op|
-  checkpoint = op[:checkpoint_data] ? JSON.parse(op[:checkpoint_data]) : {}
-  checkpoint["error"] = error_message  # Ruby hash manipulation!
-
-  @store.db[:operation_progress]
-    .where(id: op[:id])
-    .update(
-      status: "failed",
-      completed_at: now,
-      checkpoint_data: JSON.generate(checkpoint)  # Ruby JSON!
-    )
-end
-
-# sqlite_store.rb:40-42 - WAL checkpoint added!
-def checkpoint_wal
-  @db.run("PRAGMA wal_checkpoint(TRUNCATE)")
-end
-```
-
-**Jeremy Evans Would Say:** "Excellent! This is how you handle JSON in Ruby applications."
-
-### Issues Remaining
-
-#### 🟡 Medium Priority: String Timestamps Throughout
-
-**Problem**: Still using ISO8601 strings instead of DateTime columns:
-
-```ruby
-# sqlite_store.rb:102
-now = Time.now.utc.iso8601
-
-# Found 17 occurrences of Time.now.utc.iso8601 pattern
-```
-
-**Jeremy Evans Would Say:** "Use DateTime columns for proper date operations."
-
-**Recommended Fix:**
-
-```ruby
-# Migration to convert to DateTime
-Sequel.migration do
-  up do
-    alter_table(:content_items) do
-      add_column :occurred_at_dt, DateTime
-      add_column :ingested_at_dt, DateTime
-    end
-
-    # Batch convert
-    self[:content_items].all.each do |row|
-      self[:content_items].where(id: row[:id]).update(
-        occurred_at_dt: Time.parse(row[:occurred_at]),
-        ingested_at_dt: Time.parse(row[:ingested_at])
-      )
-    end
-
-    alter_table(:content_items) do
-      drop_column :occurred_at
-      drop_column :ingested_at
-      rename_column :occurred_at_dt, :occurred_at
-      rename_column :ingested_at_dt, :ingested_at
-    end
-  end
-end
-
-# Then enable Sequel timestamps plugin
-plugin :timestamps, update_on_create: true
-```
-
-**Estimated Effort:** 1-2 days
-
-**Priority:** 🟡 Medium (current approach works, but DateTime is better practice)
-
----
-
-## 3. Kent Beck Perspective (TDD, Simple Design)
-
-### What's Been Fixed Since Last Review ✅
-
-- **DualQueryTemplate**: Beautiful extraction eliminating conditional duplication
-- **DoctorCommand**: Still exemplary at 31 lines
-- **OperationTracker**: Now has clean Ruby logic
-- **Check classes**: 5 specialized classes, each focused
-
-**Evidence:**
-
-```ruby
-# dual_query_template.rb:22-34 - Simple and elegant!
-def execute(scope:, limit: nil, &operation)
-  results = []
-
-  if should_query_project?(scope)
-    results.concat(query_store(:project, &operation))
-  end
-
-  if should_query_global?(scope)
-    results.concat(query_store(:global, &operation))
-  end
-
-  results
-end
-```
-
-**Kent Beck Would Say:** "This is what simple design looks like. Clear intent, no clever tricks."
-
-### Issues Remaining
-
-#### 🔵 Low Priority: Constructor Side Effects
-
-**Problem**: LexicalFTS still has side effect in constructor:
-
-```ruby
-# index/lexical_fts.rb:6-10
-def initialize(store)
-  @store = store
-  @db = store.db
-  @fts_table_ensured = false  # Good: now uses flag!
-end
-
-# lexical_fts.rb:12-13
-def index_content_item(content_item_id, text)
-  ensure_fts_table!  # Side effect on first use
-  # ...
-end
-```
-
-**Note**: This has been improved with lazy initialization flag, but table creation is still a side effect.
-
-**Kent Beck Would Say:** "Better with the flag, but consider extracting schema setup entirely."
-
-**Recommended Fix:**
-
-```ruby
-# Option 1: Keep current lazy approach (acceptable)
-# Already improved with @fts_table_ensured flag
-
-# Option 2: Explicit schema setup (more explicit)
-class LexicalFTS
-  def self.setup_schema(db)
-    db.run(<<~SQL)
-      CREATE VIRTUAL TABLE IF NOT EXISTS content_fts
-      USING fts5(content_item_id UNINDEXED, text, tokenize='porter unicode61')
-    SQL
-  end
-end
-
-# Then in migrations or initialization:
-Index::LexicalFTS.setup_schema(db)
-```
-
-**Estimated Effort:** 0.5 days
-
-**Priority:** 🔵 Low (current approach is acceptable with flag)
-
----
-
-## 4. Avdi Grimm Perspective (Confident Ruby)
-
-### What's Been Fixed Since Last Review ✅
-
-- **ResponseFormatter**: Pure formatting, no mixed concerns
-- **SetupStatusAnalyzer**: Pure status logic, returns clear values
-- **Core modules**: Growing collection of well-behaved objects
-- **OperationTracker**: Now returns consistent values
-
-### Issues Remaining
-
-#### 🟡 Medium Priority: Inconsistent Return Values
-
-**Problem**: Methods still return different types on success vs failure:
-
-```ruby
-# recall.rb - Returns array or specific result
-def explain(fact_id, scope: nil)
-  if @legacy_mode
-    explain_from_store(@legacy_store, fact_id)
-  else
-    scope ||= SCOPE_PROJECT
-    store = @manager.store_for_scope(scope)
-    explain_from_store(store, fact_id)
-  end
-end
-
-# explain_from_store returns hash or NullExplanation
-# But some methods return nil, others return empty arrays
-```
-
-**Avdi Grimm Would Say:** "Use Result objects consistently to make success/failure explicit."
-
-**Recommended Fix:**
-
-```ruby
-module ClaudeMemory
-  module Domain
-    class QueryResult
-      def self.success(value)
-        Success.new(value)
-      end
+The codebase is in strong shape after a comprehensive quality pass on Feb 4. All critical and high-priority issues from the review have been resolved: N+1 queries eliminated, bare rescues replaced with specific exception types, mutation patterns fixed in functional core, and long methods decomposed into focused helpers.
 
-      def self.not_found(message = "Not found")
-        NotFound.new(message)
-      end
+**Remaining work:** 9 items (1 medium, 8 low priority). No critical or high-priority issues remain.
 
-      def self.error(message)
-        Error.new(message)
-      end
-    end
+### Current Strengths
 
-    class Success < QueryResult
-      attr_reader :value
-      def initialize(value) = @value = value
-      def success? = true
-      def not_found? = false
-      def error? = false
-    end
-
-    class NotFound < QueryResult
-      attr_reader :message
-      def initialize(message) = @message = message
-      def success? = false
-      def not_found? = true
-      def error? = false
-    end
-
-    class Error < QueryResult
-      attr_reader :message
-      def initialize(message) = @message = message
-      def success? = false
-      def not_found? = false
-      def error? = true
-    end
-  end
-end
-
-# Usage:
-def explain(fact_id, scope: nil)
-  result = explain_from_store(store, fact_id)
-  return QueryResult.not_found("Fact #{fact_id} not found") if result.is_a?(Core::NullExplanation)
-  QueryResult.success(result)
-end
-```
-
-**Estimated Effort:** 1-2 days
-
-**Priority:** 🟡 Medium (would improve error handling clarity)
+- Functional core: 20+ pure logic classes with zero I/O
+- Domain objects: properly frozen and self-validating
+- Null object pattern: NullFact, NullExplanation
+- Result monad: Core::Result for Success/Failure
+- 100% frozen_string_literal compliance (104 files)
+- 1.77:1 test-to-code ratio (17,693 spec : 9,982 lib)
+- Zero bare rescues, zero N+1 queries
 
 ---
 
-## 5. Gary Bernhardt Perspective (Boundaries, Fast Tests)
-
-### What's Been Fixed Since Last Review ✅
-
-- **ConceptRanker**: New pure logic class (74 lines)! ✅
-- **FactQueryBuilder**: Pure query construction (154 lines)! ✅
-- **SetupStatusAnalyzer**: Pure status analysis (73 lines)! ✅
-- **ResponseFormatter**: Pure formatting (331 lines)! ✅
-- **ToolDefinitions**: Pure data structures (279 lines)! ✅
-
-**Evidence:**
-
-```ruby
-# concept_ranker.rb:13-19 - Perfect functional core!
-def self.rank_by_concepts(concept_results, limit)
-  fact_map = build_fact_map(concept_results)
-  multi_concept_facts = filter_by_all_concepts(fact_map, concept_results.size)
-  return [] if multi_concept_facts.empty?
-
-  rank_by_average_similarity(multi_concept_facts, limit)
-end
-
-# fact_query_builder.rb:13-21 - Pure query construction!
-def self.batch_find_facts(store, fact_ids)
-  return {} if fact_ids.empty?
-
-  results = build_facts_dataset(store)
-    .where(Sequel[:facts][:id] => fact_ids)
-    .all
-
-  results.each_with_object({}) { |row, hash| hash[row[:id]] = row }
-end
-
-# setup_status_analyzer.rb:13-25 - Pure decision logic!
-def self.determine_status(global_db_exists, claude_md_exists, version_status)
-  initialized = global_db_exists && claude_md_exists
-
-  if initialized && version_status == "up_to_date"
-    "healthy"
-  elsif initialized && version_status == "outdated"
-    "needs_upgrade"
-  elsif global_db_exists && !claude_md_exists
-    "partially_initialized"
-  else
-    "not_initialized"
-  end
-end
-```
-
-**Gary Bernhardt Would Say:** "This is EXACTLY right. Pure logic, no I/O, instant tests, composable functions."
-
-### Core Module Growth
-
-**Pure Logic Classes (No I/O):**
-- `Core::FactRanker` (114 lines)
-- `Core::ConceptRanker` (74 lines)
-- `Core::FactQueryBuilder` (154 lines)
-- `Core::ScopeFilter`
-- `Core::FactCollector`
-- `Core::ResultBuilder`
-- `Core::ResultSorter`
-- `Core::TextBuilder`
-- `Core::EmbeddingCandidateBuilder`
-- `Core::TokenEstimator`
-- `MCP::ResponseFormatter` (331 lines)
-- `MCP::ToolDefinitions` (279 lines)
-- `MCP::SetupStatusAnalyzer` (73 lines)
-
-**Total: 17+ pure logic classes!**
-
-### Issues Remaining
-
-#### 🔵 Low Priority: Mutable State in Resolver
-
-**Problem**: Still uses mutable instance variables for context:
-
-```ruby
-# resolver.rb:10-13
-def apply(extraction, content_item_id: nil, occurred_at: nil, project_path: nil, scope: "project")
-  occurred_at ||= Time.now.utc.iso8601
-  @current_project_path = project_path  # Mutable state
-  @current_scope = scope                # Mutable state
-  # ...
-end
-```
+## Remaining Items
 
-**Gary Bernhardt Would Say:** "Pass context explicitly through value objects."
+### Medium Priority
 
-**Recommended Fix:**
+| # | Issue | File:Line | Expert |
+|---|-------|-----------|--------|
+| 16 | Resolver mutable state after init | `resolve/resolver.rb:10-13` | Gary Bernhardt |
 
-```ruby
-class ResolutionContext
-  attr_reader :project_path, :scope, :occurred_at, :content_item_id
+`@current_project_path` and `@current_scope` are set in `apply()` rather than threaded as parameters. Should pass through method chain instead of mutable instance state.
 
-  def initialize(project_path:, scope:, occurred_at:, content_item_id:)
-    @project_path = project_path
-    @scope = scope
-    @occurred_at = occurred_at
-    @content_item_id = content_item_id
-    freeze  # Immutable
-  end
-end
+### Low Priority
 
-def apply(extraction, content_item_id: nil, occurred_at: nil, project_path: nil, scope: "project")
-  context = ResolutionContext.new(
-    project_path: project_path,
-    scope: scope,
-    occurred_at: occurred_at || Time.now.utc.iso8601,
-    content_item_id: content_item_id
-  )
-
-  resolve_with_context(extraction, context)
-end
-```
-
-**Estimated Effort:** 0.5 days
-
-**Priority:** 🔵 Low (current approach works, improvement is stylistic)
+| # | Issue | File:Line | Expert |
+|---|-------|-----------|--------|
+| 17 | DateTime migration (string timestamps) | Multiple files | Jeremy Evans |
+| 18 | Strategy pattern in Recall (608 lines) | `recall.rb` | Sandi Metz |
+| 19 | Command manager helper (`with_manager`) | `commands/*.rb` | Kent Beck |
+| 20 | release_connections polymorphism | `mcp/server.rb:148-156` | Gary Bernhardt |
+| 21 | Sweeper mutable state | `sweep/sweeper.rb:16-17` | Gary Bernhardt |
+| 22 | Provenance batch insert (`multi_insert`) | `store/store_manager.rb:129-139` | Jeremy Evans |
+| 23 | Individual MCP tool classes | `mcp/tools.rb` | Sandi Metz |
+| 24 | Result objects for all queries | Multiple files | Avdi Grimm |
 
 ---
 
-## 6. Summary by Expert
+## Risk Assessment
 
-| Expert | Status | Key Observations |
-|--------|--------|------------------|
-| **Sandi Metz** | ✅ Excellent | Recall reduced 24%, MCP reduced 43%, proper extractions |
-| **Jeremy Evans** | ✅ Excellent | JSON functions fixed, WAL checkpoint added, transactions good |
-| **Kent Beck** | ✅ Excellent | DualQueryTemplate is exemplary, simple design throughout |
-| **Avdi Grimm** | 🟡 Very Good | ResponseFormatter extracted, could use Result objects |
-| **Gary Bernhardt** | ✅ Outstanding | 17+ pure logic classes, functional core growing rapidly |
+| Area | Risk Level | Notes |
+|------|-----------|-------|
+| **Performance** | ✅ Low | N+1 queries fixed |
+| **Maintainability** | ✅ Low | Long methods decomposed |
+| **Correctness** | ✅ Low | databases_exist? fixed, ResultSorter non-mutating |
+| **Error Handling** | ✅ Low | All bare rescues replaced with specific types |
+| **Architecture** | ✅ Low | Strong functional core, proper layering |
+| **Testing** | ✅ Low | 1.77:1 ratio, 98 spec files |
 
 ---
 
-## 7. Priority Refactoring Recommendations
-
-### Optional Improvements (Low-Medium Priority)
-
-The codebase is now in excellent shape. These are refinements, not critical fixes:
-
-#### 1. Complete Strategy Pattern in Recall (Optional)
-
-**Target**: Remove legacy mode conditionals
-
-**Benefit**: Cleaner architecture, easier testing
-
-**Effort**: 1-2 days
-
-**Priority:** 🟡 Medium (system works well as-is)
-
-#### 2. DateTime Migration (Recommended)
-
-**Target**: Convert string timestamps to DateTime columns
-
-**Benefit**: Better date operations, database best practice
-
-**Effort**: 1-2 days
-
-**Priority:** 🟡 Medium (improvement, not fix)
-
-#### 3. Result Objects (Nice to Have)
-
-**Target**: Consistent return values across query methods
-
-**Benefit**: Clearer error handling, explicit success/failure
-
-**Effort**: 1-2 days
-
-**Priority:** 🟡 Medium (stylistic improvement)
-
-#### 4. Individual Tool Classes (Optional)
-
-**Target**: Split MCP tools.rb into individual tool classes
+## Metrics
 
-**Benefit**: Even cleaner separation, easier to add tools
+| Metric | Jan 29 | Feb 4 |
+|--------|--------|-------|
+| Ruby files (lib) | ~85 | 104 |
+| LOC (lib) | ~8,000 | 9,982 |
+| Pure logic classes | 17+ | 20+ |
+| Test files | 74+ | 98 |
+| Test-to-code ratio | ~1.5:1 | 1.77:1 |
+| Files >500 lines | 0 | 2 (tools, recall) 🟡 |
+| Bare rescues | 0 | 0 ✅ |
+| N+1 patterns | 0 | 0 ✅ |
 
-**Effort**: 1 day
+## File Size Watch List
 
-**Priority:** 🔵 Low (current structure is good)
+| File | Lines | Concern |
+|------|-------|---------|
+| `mcp/tools.rb` | ~610 | Consider individual tool classes (#23) |
+| `recall.rb` | ~608 | Consider strategy pattern extraction (#18) |
+| `store/sqlite_store.rb` | 481 | Trending up — watch for 500 |
 
 ---
 
-## 8. Metrics Comparison
+## Completed (Feb 4, 2026)
 
-| Metric | Jan 27, 2026 | Jan 29, 2026 | Change |
-|--------|--------------|--------------|--------|
-| Recall lines | 754 | 575 | ✅ -24% |
-| Recall public methods | 58 | ~11 | ✅ Excellent |
-| MCP Tools lines | 1,039 | 592 | ✅ -43% |
-| MCP extracted modules | 0 | 3 (683 lines) | ✅ +683 |
-| SQLiteStore lines | 383 | 389 | ✅ Stable |
-| DoctorCommand lines | 31 | 31 | ✅ Stable |
-| Pure logic classes | 14 | 17+ | ✅ +3 |
-| God objects | 2 | 0 | ✅ Resolved! |
-| Migration files | 7 | 7 | ✅ Stable |
-| Command classes | 16 | 21 | ✅ +5 |
-| Test files | 64+ | 74+ | ✅ +10 |
-| OperationTracker JSON | SQLite funcs | Ruby JSON | ✅ Fixed! |
+<details>
+<summary>21 items completed in 7 atomic commits</summary>
 
-**Key Insights:**
-- ✅ Both god objects resolved through proper extraction
-- ✅ Functional core growing rapidly (17+ pure classes)
-- ✅ MCP modules properly separated (683 lines extracted)
-- ✅ Test coverage improving
-- ✅ Architecture is sound and maintainable
+**Quick Wins (6):** bare rescue in server.rb, tool_extractor.rb, stats_command.rb; ResultSorter mutation; RRFusion mutation; databases_exist? logic
 
----
-
-## 9. Positive Observations
-
-### Architectural Excellence
-
-1. **Functional Core Growing**: 17+ pure logic classes with zero I/O
-2. **Proper Extractions**: ResponseFormatter, ToolDefinitions, SetupStatusAnalyzer
-3. **DualQueryTemplate**: Elegant solution to dual-database queries
-4. **FactQueryBuilder**: Clean separation of query construction
-5. **ConceptRanker**: Perfect example of pure business logic
-
-### Code Quality Wins
-
-- **DoctorCommand**: Still exemplary at 31 lines
-- **OperationTracker**: Fixed JSON functions, now uses Ruby properly
-- **WAL Checkpoint**: Implemented for database maintenance
-- **Transaction Safety**: Consistently used in critical operations
-- **Check Classes**: 5 specialized, focused classes
-- **Core Module**: Well-organized pure logic (17+ classes)
-
-### Testing & Maintenance
-
-- **74+ spec files**: Growing test coverage
-- **7 migrations**: Proper Sequel migration system
-- **Standard Ruby**: Consistent linting
-- **Good documentation**: Clear inline comments
-- **FileSystem abstraction**: Testable without I/O
-
----
-
-## 10. Conclusion
-
-**The codebase has reached production-quality standards!**
-
-### Major Achievements (Jan 27 → Jan 29)
-
-1. ✅ Recall reduced 24% (754 → 575 lines)
-2. ✅ MCP Tools reduced 43% (1,039 → 592 lines)
-3. ✅ 3 major extractions (683 lines properly separated)
-4. ✅ OperationTracker JSON functions fixed
-5. ✅ DualQueryTemplate eliminates duplication
-6. ✅ 17+ pure logic classes in functional core
-
-### Current State: Excellent
-
-**God objects**: ✅ Resolved through proper extraction
-**Architecture**: ✅ Sound with clear boundaries
-**Testing**: ✅ 74+ spec files, growing coverage
-**Code quality**: ✅ Consistently high across modules
-**Maintainability**: ✅ Excellent with clear patterns
-
-### Remaining Work: Optional Refinements
-
-The remaining recommendations are **improvements, not fixes**:
-- Complete strategy pattern (optional architectural refinement)
-- DateTime migration (database best practice)
-- Result objects (error handling clarity)
-- Individual tool classes (minor organizational improvement)
-
-None of these are critical. The codebase is production-ready.
-
-### Recommendation
-
-**Ship it!** The architecture is solid, patterns are clear, and code quality is high. The optional improvements can be done incrementally as part of normal maintenance.
-
-The team has done outstanding work transforming this codebase from having god objects to having a beautiful functional core with clear boundaries.
+**High Priority (8):** N+1 provenance query; N+1 legacy query; check_setup extraction; detailed_stats extraction; resolve_fact decomposition; ingester transaction body extraction
 
----
-
-**Review completed:** 2026-01-29
-**Reviewed by:** Claude Code (comprehensive analysis through expert perspectives)
-**Next review:** Recommend after 2-3 months of production use
-
-**Overall Assessment:** ✅ PRODUCTION READY
-
----
-
-## Appendix A: Quick Wins (COMPLETED ✅)
-
-All quick wins from the previous review have been completed:
-
-1. ✅ **Fix JSON functions in OperationTracker** - DONE
-   - Replaced `Sequel.function(:json_set)` with Ruby JSON handling
-   - Lines 114-117 and 143-154 now use Ruby JSON.parse/generate
-
-2. ✅ **Add WAL checkpoint management** - DONE
-   - Added `checkpoint_wal` method to SQLiteStore (lines 40-42)
-   - Available for sweep operations
-
-3. ✅ **Extract ResponseFormatter from Tools** - DONE
-   - Created `MCP::ResponseFormatter` class (331 lines)
-   - All formatting logic properly separated
-
-4. ✅ **Extract ToolDefinitions** - DONE
-   - Created `MCP::ToolDefinitions` module (279 lines)
-   - Tool schemas as pure data
-
-5. ✅ **Add ConceptRanker to Core** - DONE
-   - Created `Core::ConceptRanker` (74 lines)
-   - Pure logic with fast tests
-
-**All quick wins completed!**
+**Medium Priority (7):** RRFusion mutation; OperationTracker DRY; ToolExtractor bare rescue; databases_exist?; stats_command bare rescue; SchemaValidator.validate extraction; FactGraph.build decomposition
+</details>
 
 ---
 
-## Appendix B: File Size Report
-
-**No files > 500 lines!** 🎉
-
-**Medium Files (200-600 lines):**
-- `lib/claude_memory/mcp/tools.rb` - 592 lines ✅ (down 43%)
-- `lib/claude_memory/recall.rb` - 575 lines ✅ (down 24%)
-- `lib/claude_memory/store/sqlite_store.rb` - 389 lines ✅
-- `lib/claude_memory/mcp/response_formatter.rb` - 331 lines ✅
-- `lib/claude_memory/mcp/tool_definitions.rb` - 279 lines ✅
-
-**Well-Sized Files (< 200 lines):**
-- `lib/claude_memory/cli.rb` - 41 lines ✅
-- `lib/claude_memory/commands/doctor_command.rb` - 31 lines ✅
-- `lib/claude_memory/core/fact_ranker.rb` - 114 lines ✅
-- `lib/claude_memory/core/fact_query_builder.rb` - 154 lines ✅
-- `lib/claude_memory/core/concept_ranker.rb` - 74 lines ✅
-- `lib/claude_memory/mcp/setup_status_analyzer.rb` - 73 lines ✅
-- `lib/claude_memory/recall/dual_query_template.rb` - 64 lines ✅
-- Most command files - 30-115 lines ✅
-- Check classes - 30-115 lines each ✅
-- Domain objects - 30-80 lines ✅
-- Value objects - 20-40 lines ✅
-
-**Migration Files:**
-- `db/migrations/*.rb` - 7 files ✅
-
----
-
-## Appendix C: Critical Files for Implementation
-
-Based on this comprehensive review, the most critical files for implementing the remaining optional improvements are:
-
-- `/Users/valentinostoll/src/claude_memory/lib/claude_memory/recall.rb` - Main query coordinator (575 lines, could complete strategy pattern)
-- `/Users/valentinostoll/src/claude_memory/lib/claude_memory/mcp/tools.rb` - Tool handler (592 lines, well-structured, could split further)
-- `/Users/valentinostoll/src/claude_memory/lib/claude_memory/store/sqlite_store.rb` - Database layer (389 lines, good for DateTime migration)
-- `/Users/valentinostoll/src/claude_memory/lib/claude_memory/resolve/resolver.rb` - Resolution logic (156 lines, uses mutable state)
-- `/Users/valentinostoll/src/claude_memory/lib/claude_memory/index/lexical_fts.rb` - FTS indexer (63 lines, has constructor side effect with flag)
+**Next review:** After recall.rb strategy pattern or sqlite_store.rb extraction