charlie 0.7.1 → 0.8.0

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
Files changed (41) hide show
  1. data/History.txt +10 -0
  2. data/Manifest.txt +6 -1
  3. data/README.txt +1 -1
  4. data/Rakefile +1 -1
  5. data/TODO.txt +2 -7
  6. data/data/BENCHMARK +4 -0
  7. data/data/CROSSOVER +10 -2
  8. data/data/GENOTYPE +23 -3
  9. data/data/MUTATION +15 -3
  10. data/data/SELECTION +15 -8
  11. data/examples/EXAMPLES_README.txt +58 -37
  12. data/examples/coevolution.rb +42 -1
  13. data/examples/matrix.rb +49 -0
  14. data/examples/neural.rb +20 -0
  15. data/examples/output/function_optimization_sombrero.html +1518 -1518
  16. data/examples/output/tsp.html +551 -551
  17. data/examples/string.rb +3 -0
  18. data/examples/tree.rb +15 -1
  19. data/examples/tsp.rb +1 -2
  20. data/lib/charlie.rb +5 -1
  21. data/lib/charlie/crossover.rb +1 -0
  22. data/lib/charlie/etc/monkey.rb +5 -4
  23. data/lib/charlie/gabenchmark.rb +24 -3
  24. data/lib/charlie/genotype.rb +19 -2
  25. data/lib/charlie/list/list_crossover.rb +40 -0
  26. data/lib/charlie/list/list_genotype.rb +6 -2
  27. data/lib/charlie/list/matrix.rb +121 -0
  28. data/lib/charlie/list/neural.rb +52 -0
  29. data/lib/charlie/mutate.rb +1 -0
  30. data/lib/charlie/population.rb +84 -21
  31. data/lib/charlie/selection.rb +88 -30
  32. data/lib/charlie/tree/tree.rb +1 -0
  33. data/test/t_common.rb +1 -1
  34. data/test/test_benchmark.rb +18 -0
  35. data/test/test_cross.rb +20 -0
  36. data/test/test_evolve.rb +25 -1
  37. data/test/test_matrix.rb +36 -0
  38. data/test/test_neural.rb +24 -0
  39. data/test/test_sel.rb +36 -0
  40. metadata +10 -3
  41. data/examples/output/bitstring_royalroad.html +0 -1243
data/examples/neural.rb ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
1
+ begin
2
+ require '../lib/charlie'
3
+ rescue LoadError
4
+ require 'rubygems'
5
+ require 'charlie'
6
+ end
7
+
8
+ DATA = [[-1,-1],[-1,1],[1,-1],[1,1]]
9
+ class XOR < NeuralNetworkGenotype(2,3,1)
10
+ def fitness
11
+ DATA.map{|i1,i2| -(output([i1,i2])[0] - i1*i2)**2 }.sum
12
+ end
13
+ def to_s
14
+ genes.map{|f| "%.2f" % f}.join(',')
15
+ end
16
+ cache_fitness
17
+ end
18
+ b=Population.new(XOR,50).evolve_on_console(200).best
19
+ puts " ===== RESULTS ===== "
20
+ DATA.each{|i| puts "#{i.inspect} => #{b.output(i).inspect}" }
data/examples/output/function_optimization_sombrero.html CHANGED
@@ -34,8 +34,8 @@
34
34
 
35
35
  <table>
36
36
  <tr><th colspan=2>Version Info</th></tr>
37
- <tr><td>Ruby Install Name</td><td>ruby1.8</td></tr>
38
- <tr><td>Ruby Version</td><td>1.8.6</td></tr>
37
+ <tr><td>Ruby Install Name</td><td>ruby1.9</td></tr>
38
+ <tr><td>Ruby Version</td><td>1.9.0</td></tr>
39
39
  <tr><td>Charlie Version</td><td>0.7.1</td></tr>
40
40
  <tr><th colspan=2>Benchmark Info</th></tr>
41
41
  <tr><td>Genotype class</td><td>Sombero</td></tr>
@@ -45,2244 +45,2244 @@
45
45
  <tr><td>Tests repeated </td><td>50 times</td></tr>
46
46
  <tr><td>Number of runs </td><td>10000</td></tr>
47
47
  <tr><td>Total number of generations </td><td>150000</td></tr>
48
- <tr><td>Total time</td><td>246.53 seconds</td></tr>
48
+ <tr><td>Total time</td><td>52.50 seconds</td></tr>
49
49
  <tr><th colspan=2>Best Solution Info</th></tr>
50
- <tr><td>Fitness</td><td>1.99999959573235</td></tr>
51
- <tr><td>Solution</td><td><textarea rows=3 cols=40>[-0.00076213032571242, 0.000304855477529398]</textarea></td></tr>
50
+ <tr><td>Fitness</td><td>1.99999436405893</td></tr>
51
+ <tr><td>Solution</td><td><textarea rows=3 cols=40>[0.000822705379082134, 0.00295235599677368]</textarea></td></tr>
52
52
  </table>
53
53
  <h1>Stats for all</h1><table>
54
54
  <tr><th></th><th>min</th><th>max</th><th>avg</th><th>stddev</th><th>time</th></tr>
55
55
  <tr>
56
56
  <td>All</td>
57
- <td>1.05995</td>
58
- <td>2.00000</td>
59
- <td>1.40957</td>
60
- <td>0.33135</td>
61
- <td>0.02465</td>
57
+ <td>0.47145</td>
58
+ <td>1.99999</td>
59
+ <td>1.33374</td>
60
+ <td>0.32800</td>
61
+ <td>0.00524</td>
62
62
  </tr>
63
63
  </table><h1>Stats for selection</h1><table>
64
64
  <tr><th>selection</th><th>min</th><th>max</th><th>avg</th><th>stddev</th><th>time</th></tr>
65
65
  <tr>
66
66
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
67
- <td>1.06021</td>
68
- <td>2.00000</td>
69
- <td>1.44063</td>
70
- <td>0.33209</td>
71
- <td>0.03109</td>
67
+ <td>1.06017</td>
68
+ <td>1.99999</td>
69
+ <td>1.41693</td>
70
+ <td>0.32006</td>
71
+ <td>0.00521</td>
72
72
  </tr>
73
73
  <tr>
74
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
75
- <td>1.05995</td>
76
- <td>2.00000</td>
77
- <td>1.42204</td>
78
- <td>0.34154</td>
79
- <td>0.02499</td>
74
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
75
+ <td>1.05889</td>
76
+ <td>1.99998</td>
77
+ <td>1.39901</td>
78
+ <td>0.31736</td>
79
+ <td>0.00463</td>
80
80
  </tr>
81
81
  <tr>
82
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
83
- <td>1.06012</td>
82
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
83
+ <td>1.06009</td>
84
84
  <td>1.99999</td>
85
- <td>1.41014</td>
86
- <td>0.33262</td>
87
- <td>0.02682</td>
85
+ <td>1.38164</td>
86
+ <td>0.33852</td>
87
+ <td>0.00407</td>
88
88
  </tr>
89
89
  <tr>
90
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
91
- <td>1.06021</td>
92
- <td>1.99999</td>
93
- <td>1.40304</td>
94
- <td>0.31257</td>
95
- <td>0.02355</td>
90
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
91
+ <td>0.47237</td>
92
+ <td>1.99992</td>
93
+ <td>1.23853</td>
94
+ <td>0.30607</td>
95
+ <td>0.00682</td>
96
96
  </tr>
97
97
  <tr>
98
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
99
- <td>1.06008</td>
100
- <td>2.00000</td>
101
- <td>1.37200</td>
102
- <td>0.33334</td>
103
- <td>0.01678</td>
98
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
99
+ <td>0.47145</td>
100
+ <td>1.99996</td>
101
+ <td>1.23256</td>
102
+ <td>0.30614</td>
103
+ <td>0.00548</td>
104
104
  </tr>
105
105
  </table><h1>Stats for crossover</h1><table>
106
106
  <tr><th>crossover</th><th>min</th><th>max</th><th>avg</th><th>stddev</th><th>time</th></tr>
107
107
  <tr>
108
108
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
109
- <td>1.06009</td>
110
- <td>2.00000</td>
111
- <td>1.42051</td>
112
- <td>0.33524</td>
113
- <td>0.02643</td>
109
+ <td>0.47156</td>
110
+ <td>1.99999</td>
111
+ <td>1.34439</td>
112
+ <td>0.33561</td>
113
+ <td>0.00542</td>
114
114
  </tr>
115
115
  <tr>
116
116
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
117
- <td>1.05995</td>
118
- <td>2.00000</td>
119
- <td>1.39863</td>
120
- <td>0.32705</td>
121
- <td>0.02286</td>
117
+ <td>0.47145</td>
118
+ <td>1.99999</td>
119
+ <td>1.32308</td>
120
+ <td>0.31986</td>
121
+ <td>0.00507</td>
122
122
  </tr>
123
123
  </table><h1>Stats for mutation</h1><table>
124
124
  <tr><th>mutation</th><th>min</th><th>max</th><th>avg</th><th>stddev</th><th>time</th></tr>
125
125
  <tr>
126
126
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
127
- <td>1.20421</td>
128
- <td>1.99976</td>
129
- <td>1.71969</td>
130
- <td>0.27589</td>
131
- <td>0.02674</td>
127
+ <td>0.47171</td>
128
+ <td>1.99967</td>
129
+ <td>1.51395</td>
130
+ <td>0.39177</td>
131
+ <td>0.00537</td>
132
+ </tr>
133
+ <tr>
134
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
135
+ <td>0.49181</td>
136
+ <td>1.99998</td>
137
+ <td>1.46120</td>
138
+ <td>0.39803</td>
139
+ <td>0.00465</td>
132
140
  </tr>
133
141
  <tr>
134
142
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
135
- <td>1.19401</td>
143
+ <td>0.47269</td>
136
144
  <td>1.99999</td>
137
- <td>1.68668</td>
138
- <td>0.30148</td>
139
- <td>0.02734</td>
145
+ <td>1.44780</td>
146
+ <td>0.41367</td>
147
+ <td>0.00587</td>
140
148
  </tr>
141
149
  <tr>
142
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
143
- <td>1.06008</td>
144
- <td>1.99994</td>
145
- <td>1.63328</td>
146
- <td>0.34025</td>
147
- <td>0.02151</td>
150
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
151
+ <td>0.47173</td>
152
+ <td>1.99912</td>
153
+ <td>1.41694</td>
154
+ <td>0.38959</td>
155
+ <td>0.00509</td>
148
156
  </tr>
149
157
  <tr>
150
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
151
- <td>1.06018</td>
152
- <td>1.99911</td>
153
- <td>1.55905</td>
154
- <td>0.34260</td>
155
- <td>0.02371</td>
158
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
159
+ <td>0.47156</td>
160
+ <td>1.99995</td>
161
+ <td>1.41643</td>
162
+ <td>0.39322</td>
163
+ <td>0.00496</td>
156
164
  </tr>
157
165
  <tr>
158
166
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
159
- <td>1.06021</td>
160
- <td>1.99872</td>
161
- <td>1.55766</td>
162
- <td>0.30432</td>
163
- <td>0.02463</td>
167
+ <td>0.47270</td>
168
+ <td>1.99890</td>
169
+ <td>1.36072</td>
170
+ <td>0.34176</td>
171
+ <td>0.00586</td>
164
172
  </tr>
165
173
  <tr>
166
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
167
- <td>1.05995</td>
168
- <td>1.99999</td>
169
- <td>1.54775</td>
170
- <td>0.36260</td>
171
- <td>0.02224</td>
174
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
175
+ <td>0.47194</td>
176
+ <td>1.99977</td>
177
+ <td>1.33782</td>
178
+ <td>0.36700</td>
179
+ <td>0.00604</td>
172
180
  </tr>
173
181
  <tr>
174
182
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
175
- <td>1.06009</td>
176
- <td>1.99994</td>
177
- <td>1.45165</td>
178
- <td>0.33875</td>
179
- <td>0.02655</td>
180
- </tr>
181
- <tr>
182
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
183
- <td>1.06015</td>
184
- <td>1.99988</td>
185
- <td>1.44428</td>
186
- <td>0.34792</td>
187
- <td>0.02801</td>
183
+ <td>0.47145</td>
184
+ <td>1.99944</td>
185
+ <td>1.32606</td>
186
+ <td>0.36011</td>
187
+ <td>0.00519</td>
188
188
  </tr>
189
189
  <tr>
190
190
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
191
- <td>1.06019</td>
192
- <td>1.99991</td>
193
- <td>1.33709</td>
194
- <td>0.30059</td>
195
- <td>0.02268</td>
191
+ <td>0.50124</td>
192
+ <td>1.99985</td>
193
+ <td>1.29662</td>
194
+ <td>0.29628</td>
195
+ <td>0.00497</td>
196
196
  </tr>
197
197
  <tr>
198
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
199
- <td>1.06018</td>
200
- <td>1.99992</td>
201
- <td>1.31768</td>
202
- <td>0.27979</td>
203
- <td>0.01979</td>
198
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
199
+ <td>1.00314</td>
200
+ <td>1.99996</td>
201
+ <td>1.29449</td>
202
+ <td>0.27675</td>
203
+ <td>0.00546</td>
204
204
  </tr>
205
205
  <tr>
206
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
207
- <td>1.06022</td>
206
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
207
+ <td>1.03484</td>
208
208
  <td>1.99998</td>
209
- <td>1.31649</td>
210
- <td>0.28712</td>
211
- <td>0.02706</td>
209
+ <td>1.29027</td>
210
+ <td>0.26938</td>
211
+ <td>0.00511</td>
212
212
  </tr>
213
213
  <tr>
214
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
215
- <td>1.06020</td>
216
- <td>1.99979</td>
217
- <td>1.29978</td>
218
- <td>0.26812</td>
219
- <td>0.02818</td>
214
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
215
+ <td>0.67598</td>
216
+ <td>1.99995</td>
217
+ <td>1.28858</td>
218
+ <td>0.27550</td>
219
+ <td>0.00463</td>
220
220
  </tr>
221
221
  <tr>
222
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
223
- <td>1.06019</td>
224
- <td>1.99999</td>
225
- <td>1.29854</td>
226
- <td>0.27556</td>
227
- <td>0.02827</td>
222
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
223
+ <td>0.47243</td>
224
+ <td>1.99966</td>
225
+ <td>1.28751</td>
226
+ <td>0.29749</td>
227
+ <td>0.00481</td>
228
228
  </tr>
229
229
  <tr>
230
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
231
- <td>1.06018</td>
232
- <td>2.00000</td>
233
- <td>1.29514</td>
234
- <td>0.27184</td>
235
- <td>0.02355</td>
230
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
231
+ <td>0.53240</td>
232
+ <td>1.99996</td>
233
+ <td>1.28278</td>
234
+ <td>0.27476</td>
235
+ <td>0.00566</td>
236
236
  </tr>
237
237
  <tr>
238
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
239
- <td>1.06021</td>
240
- <td>2.00000</td>
241
- <td>1.29409</td>
242
- <td>0.27109</td>
243
- <td>0.02712</td>
238
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
239
+ <td>1.04807</td>
240
+ <td>1.99999</td>
241
+ <td>1.27989</td>
242
+ <td>0.25215</td>
243
+ <td>0.00467</td>
244
244
  </tr>
245
245
  <tr>
246
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
247
- <td>1.06022</td>
248
- <td>2.00000</td>
249
- <td>1.29403</td>
250
- <td>0.27520</td>
251
- <td>0.02703</td>
246
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
247
+ <td>1.05027</td>
248
+ <td>1.99999</td>
249
+ <td>1.27869</td>
250
+ <td>0.25796</td>
251
+ <td>0.00481</td>
252
252
  </tr>
253
253
  <tr>
254
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
255
- <td>1.06023</td>
256
- <td>2.00000</td>
257
- <td>1.28861</td>
258
- <td>0.26615</td>
259
- <td>0.02094</td>
254
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
255
+ <td>0.89980</td>
256
+ <td>1.99996</td>
257
+ <td>1.27759</td>
258
+ <td>0.25819</td>
259
+ <td>0.00516</td>
260
260
  </tr>
261
261
  <tr>
262
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
263
- <td>1.06015</td>
264
- <td>1.99977</td>
265
- <td>1.28719</td>
266
- <td>0.26106</td>
267
- <td>0.01976</td>
262
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
263
+ <td>1.05377</td>
264
+ <td>1.99996</td>
265
+ <td>1.27490</td>
266
+ <td>0.25241</td>
267
+ <td>0.00528</td>
268
268
  </tr>
269
269
  <tr>
270
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
271
- <td>1.06020</td>
270
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
271
+ <td>1.02841</td>
272
272
  <td>1.99999</td>
273
- <td>1.28705</td>
274
- <td>0.26614</td>
275
- <td>0.02095</td>
273
+ <td>1.27172</td>
274
+ <td>0.25011</td>
275
+ <td>0.00584</td>
276
276
  </tr>
277
277
  <tr>
278
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
279
- <td>1.06022</td>
280
- <td>1.99999</td>
281
- <td>1.27562</td>
282
- <td>0.25599</td>
283
- <td>0.02686</td>
278
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
279
+ <td>0.61504</td>
280
+ <td>1.99994</td>
281
+ <td>1.27073</td>
282
+ <td>0.27017</td>
283
+ <td>0.00538</td>
284
284
  </tr>
285
285
  </table><h1>Detailed Stats</h1><table>
286
286
  <tr><th>selection</th><th>crossover</th><th>mutation</th><th>min</th><th>max</th><th>avg</th><th>stddev</th><th>time</th></tr>
287
+ <tr>
288
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
289
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
290
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
291
+ <td>1.20779</td>
292
+ <td>1.99889</td>
293
+ <td>1.81921</td>
294
+ <td>0.25630</td>
295
+ <td>0.00444</td>
296
+ </tr>
287
297
  <tr>
288
298
  <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
289
299
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
290
300
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
291
- <td>1.20871</td>
292
- <td>1.99976</td>
293
- <td>1.88650</td>
294
- <td>0.16979</td>
295
- <td>0.01140</td>
301
+ <td>1.20518</td>
302
+ <td>1.99849</td>
303
+ <td>1.80712</td>
304
+ <td>0.27458</td>
305
+ <td>0.00377</td>
306
+ </tr>
307
+ <tr>
308
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
309
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
310
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
311
+ <td>1.20834</td>
312
+ <td>1.99999</td>
313
+ <td>1.74571</td>
314
+ <td>0.31655</td>
315
+ <td>0.00511</td>
296
316
  </tr>
297
317
  <tr>
298
318
  <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
299
319
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
300
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
301
- <td>1.20878</td>
302
- <td>1.99963</td>
303
- <td>1.82297</td>
304
- <td>0.25979</td>
305
- <td>0.02459</td>
320
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
321
+ <td>1.06021</td>
322
+ <td>1.99971</td>
323
+ <td>1.72748</td>
324
+ <td>0.32853</td>
325
+ <td>0.00514</td>
306
326
  </tr>
307
327
  <tr>
308
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
328
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
329
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
330
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
331
+ <td>1.20845</td>
332
+ <td>1.99897</td>
333
+ <td>1.67776</td>
334
+ <td>0.27685</td>
335
+ <td>0.00469</td>
336
+ </tr>
337
+ <tr>
338
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
309
339
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
310
340
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
311
- <td>1.20881</td>
312
- <td>1.99659</td>
313
- <td>1.81289</td>
314
- <td>0.19134</td>
315
- <td>0.03694</td>
341
+ <td>1.20444</td>
342
+ <td>1.99581</td>
343
+ <td>1.65050</td>
344
+ <td>0.30627</td>
345
+ <td>0.00488</td>
316
346
  </tr>
317
347
  <tr>
318
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
348
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
319
349
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
320
350
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
321
- <td>1.20869</td>
322
- <td>1.99727</td>
323
- <td>1.79090</td>
324
- <td>0.22952</td>
325
- <td>0.02048</td>
351
+ <td>1.20474</td>
352
+ <td>1.99875</td>
353
+ <td>1.64406</td>
354
+ <td>0.30049</td>
355
+ <td>0.00471</td>
326
356
  </tr>
327
357
  <tr>
328
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
358
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
329
359
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
330
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
331
- <td>1.20848</td>
332
- <td>1.99925</td>
333
- <td>1.78934</td>
334
- <td>0.27596</td>
335
- <td>0.04298</td>
360
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
361
+ <td>1.20720</td>
362
+ <td>1.99293</td>
363
+ <td>1.62501</td>
364
+ <td>0.30150</td>
365
+ <td>0.00513</td>
336
366
  </tr>
337
367
  <tr>
338
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
368
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
339
369
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
340
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
341
- <td>1.20844</td>
342
- <td>1.99999</td>
343
- <td>1.78815</td>
344
- <td>0.28799</td>
345
- <td>0.01179</td>
370
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
371
+ <td>1.20773</td>
372
+ <td>1.99390</td>
373
+ <td>1.61213</td>
374
+ <td>0.27395</td>
375
+ <td>0.00442</td>
346
376
  </tr>
347
377
  <tr>
348
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
378
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
349
379
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
350
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
351
- <td>1.20798</td>
352
- <td>1.98698</td>
353
- <td>1.77005</td>
354
- <td>0.22340</td>
355
- <td>0.03269</td>
380
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
381
+ <td>1.06019</td>
382
+ <td>1.98734</td>
383
+ <td>1.60043</td>
384
+ <td>0.32786</td>
385
+ <td>0.00444</td>
356
386
  </tr>
357
387
  <tr>
358
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
359
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
360
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
361
- <td>1.20739</td>
362
- <td>1.99884</td>
363
- <td>1.74801</td>
364
- <td>0.26276</td>
365
- <td>0.01970</td>
388
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
389
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
390
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
391
+ <td>1.20632</td>
392
+ <td>1.99430</td>
393
+ <td>1.59626</td>
394
+ <td>0.32491</td>
395
+ <td>0.00355</td>
366
396
  </tr>
367
397
  <tr>
368
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
398
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
369
399
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
370
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
371
- <td>1.20817</td>
372
- <td>1.99864</td>
373
- <td>1.73543</td>
374
- <td>0.29926</td>
375
- <td>0.01911</td>
400
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
401
+ <td>1.20744</td>
402
+ <td>1.99890</td>
403
+ <td>1.58788</td>
404
+ <td>0.32834</td>
405
+ <td>0.00418</td>
376
406
  </tr>
377
407
  <tr>
378
408
  <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
379
409
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
380
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
381
- <td>1.20759</td>
382
- <td>1.99921</td>
383
- <td>1.72798</td>
384
- <td>0.30942</td>
385
- <td>0.02696</td>
410
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
411
+ <td>1.06016</td>
412
+ <td>1.99998</td>
413
+ <td>1.58564</td>
414
+ <td>0.39130</td>
415
+ <td>0.00391</td>
386
416
  </tr>
387
417
  <tr>
388
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
389
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
390
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
391
- <td>1.20853</td>
392
- <td>1.99982</td>
393
- <td>1.72521</td>
394
- <td>0.29958</td>
395
- <td>0.02086</td>
418
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
419
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
420
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
421
+ <td>1.20384</td>
422
+ <td>1.99514</td>
423
+ <td>1.58450</td>
424
+ <td>0.32235</td>
425
+ <td>0.00573</td>
396
426
  </tr>
397
427
  <tr>
398
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
399
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
400
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
401
- <td>1.20852</td>
402
- <td>1.99538</td>
403
- <td>1.72020</td>
404
- <td>0.27973</td>
405
- <td>0.03057</td>
428
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
429
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
430
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
431
+ <td>1.08970</td>
432
+ <td>1.99846</td>
433
+ <td>1.58352</td>
434
+ <td>0.35901</td>
435
+ <td>0.00438</td>
406
436
  </tr>
407
437
  <tr>
408
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
438
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
409
439
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
410
440
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
411
- <td>1.20858</td>
412
- <td>1.99510</td>
413
- <td>1.70832</td>
414
- <td>0.27175</td>
415
- <td>0.03867</td>
441
+ <td>1.20671</td>
442
+ <td>1.99876</td>
443
+ <td>1.58013</td>
444
+ <td>0.31831</td>
445
+ <td>0.00630</td>
416
446
  </tr>
417
447
  <tr>
418
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
448
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
419
449
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
420
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
421
- <td>1.20828</td>
422
- <td>1.99732</td>
423
- <td>1.68760</td>
424
- <td>0.31337</td>
425
- <td>0.02556</td>
450
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
451
+ <td>1.20602</td>
452
+ <td>1.99573</td>
453
+ <td>1.58003</td>
454
+ <td>0.31735</td>
455
+ <td>0.00513</td>
426
456
  </tr>
427
457
  <tr>
428
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
458
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
429
459
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
430
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
431
- <td>1.20866</td>
432
- <td>1.99624</td>
433
- <td>1.67607</td>
434
- <td>0.31377</td>
435
- <td>0.01822</td>
460
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
461
+ <td>1.20792</td>
462
+ <td>1.99719</td>
463
+ <td>1.57741</td>
464
+ <td>0.32234</td>
465
+ <td>0.00475</td>
436
466
  </tr>
437
467
  <tr>
438
468
  <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
439
469
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
440
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
441
- <td>1.20775</td>
442
- <td>1.98782</td>
443
- <td>1.67377</td>
444
- <td>0.25462</td>
445
- <td>0.02395</td>
470
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
471
+ <td>1.20506</td>
472
+ <td>1.99985</td>
473
+ <td>1.56036</td>
474
+ <td>0.31940</td>
475
+ <td>0.00519</td>
446
476
  </tr>
447
477
  <tr>
448
478
  <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
449
479
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
450
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
451
- <td>1.20832</td>
452
- <td>1.99725</td>
453
- <td>1.67040</td>
454
- <td>0.29294</td>
455
- <td>0.01185</td>
456
- </tr>
457
- <tr>
458
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
459
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
460
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
461
- <td>1.20767</td>
462
- <td>1.99559</td>
463
- <td>1.66890</td>
464
- <td>0.29631</td>
465
- <td>0.01996</td>
480
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
481
+ <td>1.06022</td>
482
+ <td>1.99912</td>
483
+ <td>1.54918</td>
484
+ <td>0.37822</td>
485
+ <td>0.00370</td>
466
486
  </tr>
467
487
  <tr>
468
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
488
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
469
489
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
470
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
471
- <td>1.20722</td>
472
- <td>1.99823</td>
473
- <td>1.66690</td>
474
- <td>0.30333</td>
475
- <td>0.01339</td>
490
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
491
+ <td>1.20426</td>
492
+ <td>1.99977</td>
493
+ <td>1.54759</td>
494
+ <td>0.34772</td>
495
+ <td>0.00688</td>
476
496
  </tr>
477
497
  <tr>
478
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
498
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
479
499
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
480
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
500
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
481
501
  <td>1.06023</td>
482
- <td>1.99895</td>
483
- <td>1.66459</td>
484
- <td>0.34012</td>
485
- <td>0.03151</td>
502
+ <td>1.99995</td>
503
+ <td>1.54367</td>
504
+ <td>0.39141</td>
505
+ <td>0.00504</td>
486
506
  </tr>
487
507
  <tr>
488
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
508
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
489
509
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
490
510
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
491
- <td>1.20860</td>
492
- <td>1.99891</td>
493
- <td>1.65860</td>
494
- <td>0.32241</td>
495
- <td>0.01821</td>
511
+ <td>1.18544</td>
512
+ <td>1.98952</td>
513
+ <td>1.54117</td>
514
+ <td>0.30504</td>
515
+ <td>0.00517</td>
496
516
  </tr>
497
517
  <tr>
498
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
518
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
499
519
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
500
520
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
501
- <td>1.20712</td>
502
- <td>1.99969</td>
503
- <td>1.64994</td>
504
- <td>0.32970</td>
505
- <td>0.01889</td>
521
+ <td>1.05889</td>
522
+ <td>1.99072</td>
523
+ <td>1.54097</td>
524
+ <td>0.33371</td>
525
+ <td>0.00429</td>
506
526
  </tr>
507
527
  <tr>
508
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
528
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
509
529
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
510
530
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
511
- <td>1.06023</td>
512
- <td>1.99881</td>
513
- <td>1.64532</td>
514
- <td>0.32998</td>
515
- <td>0.01828</td>
531
+ <td>1.06021</td>
532
+ <td>1.99949</td>
533
+ <td>1.53216</td>
534
+ <td>0.38677</td>
535
+ <td>0.00284</td>
516
536
  </tr>
517
537
  <tr>
518
538
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
519
539
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
520
540
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
521
- <td>1.20563</td>
522
- <td>1.99893</td>
523
- <td>1.64388</td>
524
- <td>0.29797</td>
525
- <td>0.01719</td>
541
+ <td>1.20317</td>
542
+ <td>1.99257</td>
543
+ <td>1.52108</td>
544
+ <td>0.31948</td>
545
+ <td>0.00462</td>
526
546
  </tr>
527
547
  <tr>
528
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
529
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
530
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
531
- <td>1.20838</td>
532
- <td>1.97600</td>
533
- <td>1.63474</td>
534
- <td>0.33702</td>
535
- <td>0.02990</td>
548
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
549
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
550
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
551
+ <td>1.06000</td>
552
+ <td>1.99493</td>
553
+ <td>1.51519</td>
554
+ <td>0.28158</td>
555
+ <td>0.00546</td>
536
556
  </tr>
537
557
  <tr>
538
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
558
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
539
559
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
540
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
541
- <td>1.20846</td>
542
- <td>1.99869</td>
543
- <td>1.63095</td>
544
- <td>0.30361</td>
545
- <td>0.02163</td>
560
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
561
+ <td>1.20430</td>
562
+ <td>1.99525</td>
563
+ <td>1.50543</td>
564
+ <td>0.32885</td>
565
+ <td>0.00474</td>
546
566
  </tr>
547
567
  <tr>
548
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
549
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
550
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
551
- <td>1.06019</td>
552
- <td>1.99777</td>
553
- <td>1.62723</td>
554
- <td>0.35195</td>
555
- <td>0.02642</td>
568
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
569
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
570
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
571
+ <td>1.20559</td>
572
+ <td>1.99446</td>
573
+ <td>1.49713</td>
574
+ <td>0.32065</td>
575
+ <td>0.00449</td>
556
576
  </tr>
557
577
  <tr>
558
578
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
559
579
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
560
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
561
- <td>1.19625</td>
562
- <td>1.99380</td>
563
- <td>1.62550</td>
564
- <td>0.30892</td>
565
- <td>0.02687</td>
580
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
581
+ <td>1.20462</td>
582
+ <td>1.99837</td>
583
+ <td>1.49636</td>
584
+ <td>0.28772</td>
585
+ <td>0.00568</td>
566
586
  </tr>
567
587
  <tr>
568
588
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
569
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
589
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
570
590
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
571
- <td>1.19401</td>
572
- <td>1.99763</td>
573
- <td>1.61934</td>
574
- <td>0.29690</td>
575
- <td>0.03622</td>
591
+ <td>1.20566</td>
592
+ <td>1.99592</td>
593
+ <td>1.49625</td>
594
+ <td>0.31677</td>
595
+ <td>0.00552</td>
576
596
  </tr>
577
597
  <tr>
578
598
  <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
579
599
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
580
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
581
- <td>1.20754</td>
582
- <td>1.99563</td>
583
- <td>1.61078</td>
584
- <td>0.29266</td>
585
- <td>0.03720</td>
600
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
601
+ <td>1.06021</td>
602
+ <td>1.99856</td>
603
+ <td>1.49261</td>
604
+ <td>0.31501</td>
605
+ <td>0.00464</td>
586
606
  </tr>
587
607
  <tr>
588
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
608
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
589
609
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
590
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
591
- <td>1.20751</td>
592
- <td>1.99955</td>
593
- <td>1.60589</td>
594
- <td>0.30256</td>
595
- <td>0.02518</td>
610
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
611
+ <td>1.19950</td>
612
+ <td>1.99591</td>
613
+ <td>1.49092</td>
614
+ <td>0.34282</td>
615
+ <td>0.00592</td>
596
616
  </tr>
597
617
  <tr>
598
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
618
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
599
619
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
600
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
601
- <td>1.20047</td>
602
- <td>1.99581</td>
603
- <td>1.60272</td>
604
- <td>0.26955</td>
605
- <td>0.03688</td>
620
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
621
+ <td>1.18532</td>
622
+ <td>1.99872</td>
623
+ <td>1.48572</td>
624
+ <td>0.35273</td>
625
+ <td>0.00467</td>
606
626
  </tr>
607
627
  <tr>
608
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
609
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
628
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
629
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
610
630
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
611
- <td>1.06022</td>
612
- <td>1.99999</td>
613
- <td>1.59792</td>
614
- <td>0.38885</td>
615
- <td>0.03360</td>
631
+ <td>1.06023</td>
632
+ <td>1.98952</td>
633
+ <td>1.48487</td>
634
+ <td>0.33064</td>
635
+ <td>0.00398</td>
616
636
  </tr>
617
637
  <tr>
618
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
619
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
620
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
621
- <td>1.06008</td>
622
- <td>1.99994</td>
623
- <td>1.58874</td>
624
- <td>0.39321</td>
625
- <td>0.01538</td>
626
- </tr>
627
- <tr>
628
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
638
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
629
639
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
630
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
631
- <td>1.20761</td>
632
- <td>1.99880</td>
633
- <td>1.58578</td>
634
- <td>0.32105</td>
635
- <td>0.03373</td>
640
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
641
+ <td>1.20114</td>
642
+ <td>1.99754</td>
643
+ <td>1.48428</td>
644
+ <td>0.29494</td>
645
+ <td>0.00567</td>
636
646
  </tr>
637
647
  <tr>
638
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
648
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
639
649
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
640
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
641
- <td>1.20799</td>
642
- <td>1.99933</td>
643
- <td>1.57921</td>
644
- <td>0.33519</td>
645
- <td>0.03017</td>
646
- </tr>
647
- <tr>
648
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
649
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
650
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
651
- <td>1.20749</td>
652
- <td>1.99901</td>
653
- <td>1.57909</td>
654
- <td>0.31508</td>
655
- <td>0.02123</td>
650
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
651
+ <td>1.20540</td>
652
+ <td>1.99896</td>
653
+ <td>1.48407</td>
654
+ <td>0.35212</td>
655
+ <td>0.00496</td>
656
656
  </tr>
657
657
  <tr>
658
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
658
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
659
659
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
660
660
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
661
- <td>1.06017</td>
662
- <td>1.99881</td>
663
- <td>1.57887</td>
664
- <td>0.36789</td>
665
- <td>0.01726</td>
666
- </tr>
667
- <tr>
668
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
669
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
670
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
671
- <td>1.20506</td>
672
- <td>1.98917</td>
673
- <td>1.57825</td>
674
- <td>0.28832</td>
675
- <td>0.03548</td>
661
+ <td>1.06023</td>
662
+ <td>1.99964</td>
663
+ <td>1.48080</td>
664
+ <td>0.36342</td>
665
+ <td>0.00354</td>
676
666
  </tr>
677
667
  <tr>
678
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
679
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
680
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
681
- <td>1.20637</td>
682
- <td>1.99771</td>
683
- <td>1.56831</td>
684
- <td>0.34392</td>
685
- <td>0.02405</td>
668
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
669
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
670
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
671
+ <td>1.06023</td>
672
+ <td>1.99867</td>
673
+ <td>1.47845</td>
674
+ <td>0.36012</td>
675
+ <td>0.00432</td>
686
676
  </tr>
687
677
  <tr>
688
678
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
689
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
679
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
690
680
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
691
- <td>1.20615</td>
692
- <td>1.99924</td>
693
- <td>1.56753</td>
694
- <td>0.33609</td>
695
- <td>0.03607</td>
681
+ <td>1.19789</td>
682
+ <td>1.99878</td>
683
+ <td>1.46730</td>
684
+ <td>0.28953</td>
685
+ <td>0.00541</td>
696
686
  </tr>
697
687
  <tr>
698
688
  <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
699
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
700
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
701
- <td>1.20413</td>
702
- <td>1.99691</td>
703
- <td>1.56673</td>
704
- <td>0.34874</td>
705
- <td>0.02117</td>
689
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
690
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
691
+ <td>1.19199</td>
692
+ <td>1.98948</td>
693
+ <td>1.46471</td>
694
+ <td>0.29447</td>
695
+ <td>0.00584</td>
706
696
  </tr>
707
697
  <tr>
708
698
  <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
709
699
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
710
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
711
- <td>1.20842</td>
712
- <td>1.99899</td>
713
- <td>1.56458</td>
714
- <td>0.32886</td>
715
- <td>0.01473</td>
700
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
701
+ <td>1.12074</td>
702
+ <td>1.99700</td>
703
+ <td>1.45726</td>
704
+ <td>0.32946</td>
705
+ <td>0.00542</td>
716
706
  </tr>
717
707
  <tr>
718
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
708
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
719
709
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
720
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
721
- <td>1.05995</td>
722
- <td>1.99954</td>
723
- <td>1.56409</td>
724
- <td>0.37169</td>
725
- <td>0.02851</td>
710
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
711
+ <td>1.06009</td>
712
+ <td>1.99938</td>
713
+ <td>1.42720</td>
714
+ <td>0.37442</td>
715
+ <td>0.00383</td>
726
716
  </tr>
727
717
  <tr>
728
718
  <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
729
719
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
730
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
731
- <td>1.20764</td>
732
- <td>1.99643</td>
733
- <td>1.56372</td>
734
- <td>0.33869</td>
735
- <td>0.02338</td>
720
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
721
+ <td>1.06019</td>
722
+ <td>1.99747</td>
723
+ <td>1.42419</td>
724
+ <td>0.33689</td>
725
+ <td>0.00524</td>
736
726
  </tr>
737
727
  <tr>
738
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
728
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
729
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
730
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
731
+ <td>1.20013</td>
732
+ <td>1.98281</td>
733
+ <td>1.42073</td>
734
+ <td>0.27550</td>
735
+ <td>0.00540</td>
736
+ </tr>
737
+ <tr>
738
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
739
739
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
740
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
741
- <td>1.20748</td>
742
- <td>1.99696</td>
743
- <td>1.56216</td>
744
- <td>0.34346</td>
745
- <td>0.03422</td>
740
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
741
+ <td>1.06022</td>
742
+ <td>1.99994</td>
743
+ <td>1.41809</td>
744
+ <td>0.35722</td>
745
+ <td>0.00413</td>
746
746
  </tr>
747
747
  <tr>
748
748
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
749
749
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
750
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
751
- <td>1.20789</td>
752
- <td>1.99669</td>
753
- <td>1.56215</td>
754
- <td>0.31990</td>
755
- <td>0.03199</td>
750
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
751
+ <td>1.06019</td>
752
+ <td>1.99815</td>
753
+ <td>1.41384</td>
754
+ <td>0.33369</td>
755
+ <td>0.00601</td>
756
756
  </tr>
757
757
  <tr>
758
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
758
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
759
759
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
760
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
761
- <td>1.06023</td>
762
- <td>1.99257</td>
763
- <td>1.56140</td>
764
- <td>0.36331</td>
765
- <td>0.01786</td>
760
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
761
+ <td>1.18551</td>
762
+ <td>1.99514</td>
763
+ <td>1.41260</td>
764
+ <td>0.33104</td>
765
+ <td>0.00536</td>
766
766
  </tr>
767
767
  <tr>
768
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
768
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
769
769
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
770
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
771
- <td>1.20716</td>
772
- <td>1.99928</td>
773
- <td>1.55716</td>
774
- <td>0.34805</td>
775
- <td>0.03940</td>
770
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
771
+ <td>1.06023</td>
772
+ <td>1.99134</td>
773
+ <td>1.41039</td>
774
+ <td>0.30432</td>
775
+ <td>0.00459</td>
776
776
  </tr>
777
777
  <tr>
778
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
778
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
779
779
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
780
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
781
- <td>1.20828</td>
782
- <td>1.99358</td>
783
- <td>1.55704</td>
784
- <td>0.29805</td>
785
- <td>0.02095</td>
780
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
781
+ <td>1.20868</td>
782
+ <td>1.99996</td>
783
+ <td>1.40727</td>
784
+ <td>0.33520</td>
785
+ <td>0.00538</td>
786
786
  </tr>
787
787
  <tr>
788
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
788
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
789
789
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
790
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
791
- <td>1.20421</td>
792
- <td>1.99219</td>
793
- <td>1.55142</td>
794
- <td>0.27474</td>
795
- <td>0.03020</td>
790
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
791
+ <td>1.06021</td>
792
+ <td>1.99876</td>
793
+ <td>1.39673</td>
794
+ <td>0.32648</td>
795
+ <td>0.00555</td>
796
796
  </tr>
797
797
  <tr>
798
798
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
799
799
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
800
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
801
- <td>1.20741</td>
802
- <td>1.99581</td>
803
- <td>1.54336</td>
804
- <td>0.34459</td>
805
- <td>0.03416</td>
800
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
801
+ <td>1.20761</td>
802
+ <td>1.99965</td>
803
+ <td>1.38897</td>
804
+ <td>0.32175</td>
805
+ <td>0.00516</td>
806
806
  </tr>
807
807
  <tr>
808
808
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
809
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
809
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
810
810
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
811
- <td>1.20845</td>
812
- <td>1.99957</td>
813
- <td>1.53375</td>
814
- <td>0.36310</td>
815
- <td>0.03707</td>
811
+ <td>1.06022</td>
812
+ <td>1.99943</td>
813
+ <td>1.38075</td>
814
+ <td>0.31072</td>
815
+ <td>0.00473</td>
816
816
  </tr>
817
817
  <tr>
818
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
818
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
819
819
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
820
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
821
- <td>1.17597</td>
822
- <td>1.99911</td>
823
- <td>1.53330</td>
824
- <td>0.32745</td>
825
- <td>0.03756</td>
820
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
821
+ <td>1.06023</td>
822
+ <td>1.99938</td>
823
+ <td>1.37123</td>
824
+ <td>0.33632</td>
825
+ <td>0.00532</td>
826
+ </tr>
827
+ <tr>
828
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
829
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
830
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
831
+ <td>1.06023</td>
832
+ <td>1.99971</td>
833
+ <td>1.35997</td>
834
+ <td>0.31848</td>
835
+ <td>0.00421</td>
826
836
  </tr>
827
837
  <tr>
828
838
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
829
839
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
830
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
831
- <td>1.20772</td>
832
- <td>1.98700</td>
833
- <td>1.52486</td>
834
- <td>0.31807</td>
835
- <td>0.03737</td>
840
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
841
+ <td>1.17950</td>
842
+ <td>1.92829</td>
843
+ <td>1.35951</td>
844
+ <td>0.23588</td>
845
+ <td>0.00664</td>
836
846
  </tr>
837
847
  <tr>
838
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
848
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
839
849
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
840
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
841
- <td>1.06022</td>
842
- <td>1.99942</td>
843
- <td>1.51624</td>
844
- <td>0.36071</td>
845
- <td>0.02024</td>
850
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
851
+ <td>1.06023</td>
852
+ <td>1.99702</td>
853
+ <td>1.35600</td>
854
+ <td>0.30443</td>
855
+ <td>0.00443</td>
846
856
  </tr>
847
857
  <tr>
848
858
  <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
849
859
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
850
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
851
- <td>1.06018</td>
852
- <td>1.99905</td>
853
- <td>1.51511</td>
854
- <td>0.37465</td>
855
- <td>0.01694</td>
856
- </tr>
857
- <tr>
858
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
859
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
860
860
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
861
861
  <td>1.06023</td>
862
- <td>1.99893</td>
863
- <td>1.48806</td>
864
- <td>0.34588</td>
865
- <td>0.02130</td>
862
+ <td>1.99836</td>
863
+ <td>1.35214</td>
864
+ <td>0.31894</td>
865
+ <td>0.00456</td>
866
866
  </tr>
867
867
  <tr>
868
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
868
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
869
869
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
870
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
871
- <td>1.06021</td>
872
- <td>1.99987</td>
873
- <td>1.48060</td>
874
- <td>0.37166</td>
875
- <td>0.03412</td>
870
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
871
+ <td>1.06022</td>
872
+ <td>1.99893</td>
873
+ <td>1.35146</td>
874
+ <td>0.29272</td>
875
+ <td>0.00460</td>
876
876
  </tr>
877
877
  <tr>
878
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
879
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
878
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
879
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
880
880
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
881
- <td>1.20790</td>
882
- <td>1.99899</td>
883
- <td>1.47777</td>
884
- <td>0.36544</td>
885
- <td>0.00985</td>
881
+ <td>0.50249</td>
882
+ <td>1.97336</td>
883
+ <td>1.35028</td>
884
+ <td>0.41975</td>
885
+ <td>0.00579</td>
886
+ </tr>
887
+ <tr>
888
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
889
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
890
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
891
+ <td>1.06020</td>
892
+ <td>1.99994</td>
893
+ <td>1.34956</td>
894
+ <td>0.32182</td>
895
+ <td>0.00432</td>
886
896
  </tr>
887
897
  <tr>
888
898
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
889
899
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
890
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
891
- <td>1.20468</td>
892
- <td>1.99745</td>
893
- <td>1.47721</td>
894
- <td>0.31978</td>
895
- <td>0.03359</td>
900
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
901
+ <td>1.06020</td>
902
+ <td>1.98596</td>
903
+ <td>1.34885</td>
904
+ <td>0.29050</td>
905
+ <td>0.00449</td>
896
906
  </tr>
897
907
  <tr>
898
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
908
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
899
909
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
900
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
901
- <td>1.06022</td>
902
- <td>1.99765</td>
903
- <td>1.47449</td>
904
- <td>0.36222</td>
905
- <td>0.01243</td>
910
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
911
+ <td>1.06023</td>
912
+ <td>1.99887</td>
913
+ <td>1.34547</td>
914
+ <td>0.30032</td>
915
+ <td>0.00585</td>
906
916
  </tr>
907
917
  <tr>
908
918
  <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
909
919
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
910
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
911
- <td>1.18772</td>
912
- <td>1.96922</td>
913
- <td>1.47341</td>
914
- <td>0.26375</td>
915
- <td>0.02509</td>
920
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
921
+ <td>1.06023</td>
922
+ <td>1.99454</td>
923
+ <td>1.34469</td>
924
+ <td>0.28781</td>
925
+ <td>0.00371</td>
916
926
  </tr>
917
927
  <tr>
918
928
  <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
919
929
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
920
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
930
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
921
931
  <td>1.06023</td>
922
- <td>1.99275</td>
923
- <td>1.46851</td>
924
- <td>0.31191</td>
925
- <td>0.01534</td>
926
- </tr>
927
- <tr>
928
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
929
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
930
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
931
- <td>1.06013</td>
932
- <td>1.99894</td>
933
- <td>1.46655</td>
934
- <td>0.37957</td>
935
- <td>0.01185</td>
932
+ <td>1.99988</td>
933
+ <td>1.34442</td>
934
+ <td>0.30629</td>
935
+ <td>0.00445</td>
936
936
  </tr>
937
937
  <tr>
938
938
  <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
939
939
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
940
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
941
- <td>1.06021</td>
942
- <td>1.99466</td>
943
- <td>1.45937</td>
944
- <td>0.34562</td>
945
- <td>0.02700</td>
940
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
941
+ <td>1.06022</td>
942
+ <td>1.99875</td>
943
+ <td>1.34265</td>
944
+ <td>0.32380</td>
945
+ <td>0.00514</td>
946
946
  </tr>
947
947
  <tr>
948
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
949
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
950
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
951
- <td>1.06021</td>
952
- <td>1.99872</td>
953
- <td>1.45019</td>
954
- <td>0.29172</td>
955
- <td>0.02090</td>
948
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
949
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
950
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
951
+ <td>1.06022</td>
952
+ <td>1.99918</td>
953
+ <td>1.33735</td>
954
+ <td>0.30792</td>
955
+ <td>0.00482</td>
956
956
  </tr>
957
957
  <tr>
958
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
958
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
959
959
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
960
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
960
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
961
961
  <td>1.06022</td>
962
- <td>1.99931</td>
963
- <td>1.44985</td>
964
- <td>0.36550</td>
965
- <td>0.01696</td>
962
+ <td>1.99959</td>
963
+ <td>1.33432</td>
964
+ <td>0.30992</td>
965
+ <td>0.00491</td>
966
966
  </tr>
967
967
  <tr>
968
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
968
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
969
969
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
970
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
970
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
971
971
  <td>1.06023</td>
972
- <td>1.99959</td>
973
- <td>1.44802</td>
974
- <td>0.36339</td>
975
- <td>0.03323</td>
972
+ <td>1.99979</td>
973
+ <td>1.33416</td>
974
+ <td>0.33766</td>
975
+ <td>0.00422</td>
976
976
  </tr>
977
977
  <tr>
978
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
978
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
979
979
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
980
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
981
- <td>1.20865</td>
982
- <td>1.99935</td>
983
- <td>1.44126</td>
984
- <td>0.35062</td>
985
- <td>0.04045</td>
980
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
981
+ <td>1.06016</td>
982
+ <td>1.99944</td>
983
+ <td>1.33294</td>
984
+ <td>0.30566</td>
985
+ <td>0.00429</td>
986
986
  </tr>
987
987
  <tr>
988
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
988
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
989
989
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
990
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
990
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
991
991
  <td>1.06023</td>
992
- <td>1.99978</td>
993
- <td>1.43687</td>
994
- <td>0.36258</td>
995
- <td>0.01893</td>
992
+ <td>1.99976</td>
993
+ <td>1.33134</td>
994
+ <td>0.28965</td>
995
+ <td>0.00544</td>
996
996
  </tr>
997
997
  <tr>
998
998
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
999
999
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1000
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1000
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1001
1001
  <td>1.06023</td>
1002
- <td>1.99928</td>
1003
- <td>1.43653</td>
1004
- <td>0.35509</td>
1005
- <td>0.03376</td>
1002
+ <td>1.99963</td>
1003
+ <td>1.33094</td>
1004
+ <td>0.28933</td>
1005
+ <td>0.00542</td>
1006
1006
  </tr>
1007
1007
  <tr>
1008
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1008
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1009
1009
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1010
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1011
- <td>1.06023</td>
1012
- <td>1.99664</td>
1013
- <td>1.43183</td>
1014
- <td>0.32839</td>
1015
- <td>0.04072</td>
1010
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1011
+ <td>1.05997</td>
1012
+ <td>1.99992</td>
1013
+ <td>1.32837</td>
1014
+ <td>0.29547</td>
1015
+ <td>0.00668</td>
1016
1016
  </tr>
1017
1017
  <tr>
1018
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1018
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1019
1019
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1020
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1021
- <td>1.06023</td>
1022
- <td>1.99983</td>
1023
- <td>1.42715</td>
1024
- <td>0.34284</td>
1025
- <td>0.01467</td>
1020
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1021
+ <td>1.04807</td>
1022
+ <td>1.99837</td>
1023
+ <td>1.32834</td>
1024
+ <td>0.30858</td>
1025
+ <td>0.00672</td>
1026
+ </tr>
1027
+ <tr>
1028
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1029
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1030
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1031
+ <td>1.06022</td>
1032
+ <td>1.99945</td>
1033
+ <td>1.32768</td>
1034
+ <td>0.31235</td>
1035
+ <td>0.00523</td>
1026
1036
  </tr>
1027
1037
  <tr>
1028
1038
  <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1029
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1030
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
1031
- <td>1.19397</td>
1032
- <td>1.99120</td>
1033
- <td>1.42704</td>
1034
- <td>0.25603</td>
1035
- <td>0.03008</td>
1039
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1040
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1041
+ <td>1.06023</td>
1042
+ <td>1.99931</td>
1043
+ <td>1.32545</td>
1044
+ <td>0.29368</td>
1045
+ <td>0.00463</td>
1036
1046
  </tr>
1037
1047
  <tr>
1038
1048
  <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1039
1049
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1040
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1041
- <td>1.06012</td>
1042
- <td>1.99251</td>
1043
- <td>1.42466</td>
1044
- <td>0.33168</td>
1045
- <td>0.01874</td>
1050
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
1051
+ <td>0.60943</td>
1052
+ <td>1.95920</td>
1053
+ <td>1.32479</td>
1054
+ <td>0.36596</td>
1055
+ <td>0.00437</td>
1046
1056
  </tr>
1047
1057
  <tr>
1048
1058
  <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1049
1059
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1050
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1051
- <td>1.20598</td>
1052
- <td>1.99470</td>
1053
- <td>1.42137</td>
1054
- <td>0.29130</td>
1055
- <td>0.02501</td>
1060
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1061
+ <td>1.06023</td>
1062
+ <td>1.99964</td>
1063
+ <td>1.32308</td>
1064
+ <td>0.29695</td>
1065
+ <td>0.00388</td>
1056
1066
  </tr>
1057
1067
  <tr>
1058
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1059
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1060
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1061
- <td>1.06022</td>
1062
- <td>1.99979</td>
1063
- <td>1.41689</td>
1064
- <td>0.34451</td>
1065
- <td>0.03650</td>
1068
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1069
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1070
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
1071
+ <td>0.47191</td>
1072
+ <td>1.99967</td>
1073
+ <td>1.32260</td>
1074
+ <td>0.43554</td>
1075
+ <td>0.00534</td>
1066
1076
  </tr>
1067
1077
  <tr>
1068
1078
  <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1069
1079
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1070
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1080
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1071
1081
  <td>1.06023</td>
1072
- <td>1.99877</td>
1073
- <td>1.41662</td>
1074
- <td>0.33362</td>
1075
- <td>0.03404</td>
1082
+ <td>1.99996</td>
1083
+ <td>1.32224</td>
1084
+ <td>0.29505</td>
1085
+ <td>0.00447</td>
1076
1086
  </tr>
1077
1087
  <tr>
1078
1088
  <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1089
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1090
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1091
+ <td>1.06022</td>
1092
+ <td>1.99977</td>
1093
+ <td>1.32097</td>
1094
+ <td>0.32198</td>
1095
+ <td>0.00443</td>
1096
+ </tr>
1097
+ <tr>
1098
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1079
1099
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1080
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1081
- <td>1.06015</td>
1082
- <td>1.99886</td>
1083
- <td>1.41636</td>
1084
- <td>0.35606</td>
1085
- <td>0.01214</td>
1086
- </tr>
1087
- <tr>
1088
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1089
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1090
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1100
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1091
1101
  <td>1.06023</td>
1092
- <td>1.99944</td>
1093
- <td>1.41373</td>
1094
- <td>0.31814</td>
1095
- <td>0.03027</td>
1102
+ <td>1.99999</td>
1103
+ <td>1.31670</td>
1104
+ <td>0.27899</td>
1105
+ <td>0.00403</td>
1096
1106
  </tr>
1097
1107
  <tr>
1098
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1108
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1099
1109
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1100
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1110
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1101
1111
  <td>1.06023</td>
1102
- <td>1.99974</td>
1103
- <td>1.41145</td>
1104
- <td>0.34441</td>
1105
- <td>0.03715</td>
1112
+ <td>1.99826</td>
1113
+ <td>1.31388</td>
1114
+ <td>0.25457</td>
1115
+ <td>0.00530</td>
1106
1116
  </tr>
1107
1117
  <tr>
1108
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1118
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1109
1119
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1110
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
1111
- <td>1.12502</td>
1112
- <td>1.97233</td>
1113
- <td>1.40838</td>
1114
- <td>0.27028</td>
1115
- <td>0.03344</td>
1120
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1121
+ <td>1.06023</td>
1122
+ <td>1.99910</td>
1123
+ <td>1.31235</td>
1124
+ <td>0.27529</td>
1125
+ <td>0.00552</td>
1116
1126
  </tr>
1117
1127
  <tr>
1118
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1128
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1119
1129
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1120
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1130
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1121
1131
  <td>1.06018</td>
1122
- <td>1.99973</td>
1123
- <td>1.40184</td>
1124
- <td>0.34805</td>
1125
- <td>0.02117</td>
1132
+ <td>1.99679</td>
1133
+ <td>1.31166</td>
1134
+ <td>0.25993</td>
1135
+ <td>0.00385</td>
1126
1136
  </tr>
1127
1137
  <tr>
1128
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1138
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1129
1139
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1130
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1131
- <td>1.06021</td>
1132
- <td>1.99988</td>
1133
- <td>1.39123</td>
1134
- <td>0.33127</td>
1135
- <td>0.03952</td>
1140
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1141
+ <td>1.06022</td>
1142
+ <td>1.99996</td>
1143
+ <td>1.30847</td>
1144
+ <td>0.30643</td>
1145
+ <td>0.00403</td>
1136
1146
  </tr>
1137
1147
  <tr>
1138
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1148
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1139
1149
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1140
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1141
- <td>1.06022</td>
1142
- <td>1.99977</td>
1143
- <td>1.38550</td>
1144
- <td>0.33770</td>
1145
- <td>0.03110</td>
1150
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1151
+ <td>1.06015</td>
1152
+ <td>1.99985</td>
1153
+ <td>1.30826</td>
1154
+ <td>0.30599</td>
1155
+ <td>0.00380</td>
1146
1156
  </tr>
1147
1157
  <tr>
1148
1158
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1149
1159
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1150
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1151
- <td>1.06023</td>
1152
- <td>1.99935</td>
1153
- <td>1.38473</td>
1154
- <td>0.32619</td>
1155
- <td>0.03863</td>
1160
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1161
+ <td>1.06022</td>
1162
+ <td>1.99993</td>
1163
+ <td>1.30664</td>
1164
+ <td>0.27976</td>
1165
+ <td>0.00414</td>
1156
1166
  </tr>
1157
1167
  <tr>
1158
1168
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1159
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1160
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1161
- <td>1.20639</td>
1162
- <td>1.99552</td>
1163
- <td>1.38295</td>
1164
- <td>0.30566</td>
1165
- <td>0.04109</td>
1166
- </tr>
1167
- <tr>
1168
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1169
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1170
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1169
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1170
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1171
1171
  <td>1.06022</td>
1172
- <td>1.99960</td>
1173
- <td>1.37984</td>
1174
- <td>0.35176</td>
1175
- <td>0.02524</td>
1172
+ <td>1.99949</td>
1173
+ <td>1.30633</td>
1174
+ <td>0.27894</td>
1175
+ <td>0.00413</td>
1176
1176
  </tr>
1177
1177
  <tr>
1178
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1178
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1179
1179
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1180
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1180
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1181
1181
  <td>1.06023</td>
1182
- <td>1.99987</td>
1183
- <td>1.37652</td>
1184
- <td>0.33139</td>
1185
- <td>0.03833</td>
1182
+ <td>1.99983</td>
1183
+ <td>1.30443</td>
1184
+ <td>0.28325</td>
1185
+ <td>0.00428</td>
1186
1186
  </tr>
1187
1187
  <tr>
1188
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1188
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1189
1189
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1190
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1190
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1191
1191
  <td>1.06023</td>
1192
- <td>1.99859</td>
1193
- <td>1.37379</td>
1194
- <td>0.32080</td>
1195
- <td>0.01944</td>
1192
+ <td>1.99998</td>
1193
+ <td>1.29822</td>
1194
+ <td>0.28610</td>
1195
+ <td>0.00350</td>
1196
1196
  </tr>
1197
1197
  <tr>
1198
1198
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1199
1199
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1200
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1201
- <td>1.17536</td>
1202
- <td>1.99992</td>
1203
- <td>1.36799</td>
1204
- <td>0.30297</td>
1205
- <td>0.02411</td>
1200
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1201
+ <td>1.06023</td>
1202
+ <td>1.99931</td>
1203
+ <td>1.29675</td>
1204
+ <td>0.25844</td>
1205
+ <td>0.00529</td>
1206
1206
  </tr>
1207
1207
  <tr>
1208
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1208
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1209
1209
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1210
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1211
- <td>1.06023</td>
1212
- <td>1.99991</td>
1213
- <td>1.36574</td>
1214
- <td>0.29713</td>
1215
- <td>0.01266</td>
1210
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
1211
+ <td>0.49218</td>
1212
+ <td>1.99549</td>
1213
+ <td>1.29590</td>
1214
+ <td>0.38699</td>
1215
+ <td>0.00621</td>
1216
1216
  </tr>
1217
1217
  <tr>
1218
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1219
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1220
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1221
- <td>1.20861</td>
1218
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1219
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1220
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1221
+ <td>1.06023</td>
1222
1222
  <td>1.99999</td>
1223
- <td>1.36529</td>
1224
- <td>0.31302</td>
1225
- <td>0.01527</td>
1223
+ <td>1.29577</td>
1224
+ <td>0.28904</td>
1225
+ <td>0.00321</td>
1226
1226
  </tr>
1227
1227
  <tr>
1228
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1228
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1229
1229
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1230
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1231
- <td>1.06023</td>
1232
- <td>1.99986</td>
1233
- <td>1.35975</td>
1234
- <td>0.29469</td>
1235
- <td>0.02258</td>
1230
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1231
+ <td>1.05679</td>
1232
+ <td>1.99985</td>
1233
+ <td>1.29561</td>
1234
+ <td>0.28212</td>
1235
+ <td>0.00582</td>
1236
1236
  </tr>
1237
1237
  <tr>
1238
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1238
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1239
1239
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1240
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1241
- <td>1.06020</td>
1242
- <td>1.99832</td>
1243
- <td>1.35730</td>
1244
- <td>0.33684</td>
1245
- <td>0.01164</td>
1240
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1241
+ <td>1.04992</td>
1242
+ <td>1.99900</td>
1243
+ <td>1.29379</td>
1244
+ <td>0.28619</td>
1245
+ <td>0.00548</td>
1246
1246
  </tr>
1247
1247
  <tr>
1248
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1249
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1250
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1248
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1249
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1250
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1251
1251
  <td>1.06023</td>
1252
- <td>1.99832</td>
1253
- <td>1.35364</td>
1254
- <td>0.30469</td>
1255
- <td>0.01882</td>
1252
+ <td>1.99998</td>
1253
+ <td>1.29282</td>
1254
+ <td>0.29072</td>
1255
+ <td>0.00311</td>
1256
1256
  </tr>
1257
1257
  <tr>
1258
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1258
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1259
1259
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1260
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1261
- <td>1.20878</td>
1262
- <td>1.99877</td>
1263
- <td>1.34997</td>
1264
- <td>0.30131</td>
1265
- <td>0.02319</td>
1266
- </tr>
1267
- <tr>
1268
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1269
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1270
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1271
- <td>1.20845</td>
1272
- <td>1.99498</td>
1273
- <td>1.34885</td>
1274
- <td>0.28460</td>
1275
- <td>0.02477</td>
1260
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1261
+ <td>1.06023</td>
1262
+ <td>1.99992</td>
1263
+ <td>1.29271</td>
1264
+ <td>0.29047</td>
1265
+ <td>0.00378</td>
1276
1266
  </tr>
1277
1267
  <tr>
1278
1268
  <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1279
1269
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1280
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1281
- <td>1.06022</td>
1282
- <td>1.99861</td>
1283
- <td>1.34694</td>
1284
- <td>0.31029</td>
1285
- <td>0.03585</td>
1270
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1271
+ <td>1.05433</td>
1272
+ <td>1.99980</td>
1273
+ <td>1.29235</td>
1274
+ <td>0.25769</td>
1275
+ <td>0.00572</td>
1286
1276
  </tr>
1287
1277
  <tr>
1288
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1289
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1290
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1278
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1279
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1280
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1291
1281
  <td>1.06023</td>
1292
1282
  <td>1.99977</td>
1293
- <td>1.34551</td>
1294
- <td>0.29958</td>
1295
- <td>0.03076</td>
1283
+ <td>1.28982</td>
1284
+ <td>0.24851</td>
1285
+ <td>0.00526</td>
1296
1286
  </tr>
1297
1287
  <tr>
1298
1288
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1299
1289
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1300
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1301
- <td>1.06022</td>
1302
- <td>1.99968</td>
1303
- <td>1.34511</td>
1304
- <td>0.32852</td>
1305
- <td>0.02213</td>
1290
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1291
+ <td>0.89980</td>
1292
+ <td>1.99906</td>
1293
+ <td>1.28834</td>
1294
+ <td>0.28126</td>
1295
+ <td>0.00668</td>
1306
1296
  </tr>
1307
1297
  <tr>
1308
1298
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1309
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1310
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1299
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1300
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1311
1301
  <td>1.06022</td>
1312
- <td>1.99980</td>
1313
- <td>1.34327</td>
1314
- <td>0.30806</td>
1315
- <td>0.01914</td>
1302
+ <td>1.99843</td>
1303
+ <td>1.28800</td>
1304
+ <td>0.26399</td>
1305
+ <td>0.00536</td>
1316
1306
  </tr>
1317
1307
  <tr>
1318
1308
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1319
1309
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1320
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1321
- <td>1.06021</td>
1322
- <td>1.99583</td>
1323
- <td>1.33992</td>
1324
- <td>0.28567</td>
1325
- <td>0.03046</td>
1310
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1311
+ <td>1.06005</td>
1312
+ <td>1.99959</td>
1313
+ <td>1.28752</td>
1314
+ <td>0.25391</td>
1315
+ <td>0.00781</td>
1326
1316
  </tr>
1327
1317
  <tr>
1328
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1318
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1329
1319
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1330
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1320
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1331
1321
  <td>1.06023</td>
1332
- <td>1.99991</td>
1333
- <td>1.33907</td>
1334
- <td>0.29687</td>
1335
- <td>0.02770</td>
1322
+ <td>1.99995</td>
1323
+ <td>1.28716</td>
1324
+ <td>0.26178</td>
1325
+ <td>0.00374</td>
1336
1326
  </tr>
1337
1327
  <tr>
1338
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1328
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1339
1329
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1340
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1341
- <td>1.06020</td>
1342
- <td>1.99993</td>
1343
- <td>1.33904</td>
1344
- <td>0.31146</td>
1345
- <td>0.01681</td>
1330
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1331
+ <td>1.06022</td>
1332
+ <td>1.99943</td>
1333
+ <td>1.28556</td>
1334
+ <td>0.26712</td>
1335
+ <td>0.00413</td>
1346
1336
  </tr>
1347
1337
  <tr>
1348
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1338
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1349
1339
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1350
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1340
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1351
1341
  <td>1.06023</td>
1352
- <td>1.99970</td>
1353
- <td>1.33822</td>
1354
- <td>0.30975</td>
1355
- <td>0.01813</td>
1342
+ <td>1.99996</td>
1343
+ <td>1.28545</td>
1344
+ <td>0.26673</td>
1345
+ <td>0.00472</td>
1356
1346
  </tr>
1357
1347
  <tr>
1358
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1348
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1349
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1350
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1351
+ <td>1.06023</td>
1352
+ <td>1.99997</td>
1353
+ <td>1.28495</td>
1354
+ <td>0.25635</td>
1355
+ <td>0.00565</td>
1356
+ </tr>
1357
+ <tr>
1358
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1359
1359
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1360
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1361
- <td>1.20862</td>
1362
- <td>1.99925</td>
1363
- <td>1.33364</td>
1364
- <td>0.28605</td>
1365
- <td>0.01300</td>
1360
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1361
+ <td>1.05645</td>
1362
+ <td>1.99969</td>
1363
+ <td>1.28478</td>
1364
+ <td>0.24638</td>
1365
+ <td>0.00518</td>
1366
1366
  </tr>
1367
1367
  <tr>
1368
1368
  <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1369
1369
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1370
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1371
- <td>1.20814</td>
1372
- <td>1.99587</td>
1373
- <td>1.33190</td>
1374
- <td>0.28224</td>
1375
- <td>0.02939</td>
1370
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
1371
+ <td>0.47222</td>
1372
+ <td>1.99542</td>
1373
+ <td>1.28232</td>
1374
+ <td>0.43583</td>
1375
+ <td>0.00510</td>
1376
1376
  </tr>
1377
1377
  <tr>
1378
1378
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1379
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1380
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1381
- <td>1.06023</td>
1382
- <td>1.99996</td>
1383
- <td>1.33030</td>
1384
- <td>0.31750</td>
1385
- <td>0.02914</td>
1379
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1380
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1381
+ <td>1.05720</td>
1382
+ <td>1.99800</td>
1383
+ <td>1.28021</td>
1384
+ <td>0.25182</td>
1385
+ <td>0.00734</td>
1386
1386
  </tr>
1387
1387
  <tr>
1388
1388
  <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1389
1389
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1390
1390
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1391
- <td>1.06021</td>
1392
- <td>1.99949</td>
1393
- <td>1.32897</td>
1394
- <td>0.31485</td>
1395
- <td>0.00953</td>
1396
- </tr>
1397
- <tr>
1398
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1399
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1400
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1401
1391
  <td>1.06023</td>
1402
- <td>1.99998</td>
1403
- <td>1.32739</td>
1404
- <td>0.31943</td>
1405
- <td>0.01824</td>
1406
- </tr>
1407
- <tr>
1408
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1409
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1410
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1411
- <td>1.06021</td>
1412
- <td>1.99880</td>
1413
- <td>1.32703</td>
1414
- <td>0.28832</td>
1415
- <td>0.01935</td>
1392
+ <td>1.99924</td>
1393
+ <td>1.27790</td>
1394
+ <td>0.23966</td>
1395
+ <td>0.00272</td>
1416
1396
  </tr>
1417
1397
  <tr>
1418
1398
  <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1419
1399
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1420
1400
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1421
- <td>1.06023</td>
1422
- <td>1.99993</td>
1423
- <td>1.32642</td>
1424
- <td>0.29585</td>
1425
- <td>0.03192</td>
1401
+ <td>1.05652</td>
1402
+ <td>1.99924</td>
1403
+ <td>1.27750</td>
1404
+ <td>0.26038</td>
1405
+ <td>0.00641</td>
1426
1406
  </tr>
1427
1407
  <tr>
1428
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1408
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1429
1409
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1430
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1431
- <td>1.06023</td>
1432
- <td>1.99977</td>
1433
- <td>1.32601</td>
1434
- <td>0.29493</td>
1435
- <td>0.02300</td>
1410
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1411
+ <td>0.93315</td>
1412
+ <td>1.99870</td>
1413
+ <td>1.27700</td>
1414
+ <td>0.24420</td>
1415
+ <td>0.00592</td>
1436
1416
  </tr>
1437
1417
  <tr>
1438
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1418
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1439
1419
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1440
1420
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1441
- <td>1.06022</td>
1442
- <td>1.99985</td>
1443
- <td>1.32233</td>
1444
- <td>0.29532</td>
1445
- <td>0.01932</td>
1421
+ <td>1.06023</td>
1422
+ <td>1.99988</td>
1423
+ <td>1.27576</td>
1424
+ <td>0.24381</td>
1425
+ <td>0.00521</td>
1446
1426
  </tr>
1447
1427
  <tr>
1448
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1449
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1450
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1451
- <td>1.06022</td>
1452
- <td>1.99995</td>
1453
- <td>1.31954</td>
1454
- <td>0.29755</td>
1455
- <td>0.01934</td>
1428
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1429
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1430
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
1431
+ <td>0.47156</td>
1432
+ <td>1.99859</td>
1433
+ <td>1.27499</td>
1434
+ <td>0.42778</td>
1435
+ <td>0.00531</td>
1456
1436
  </tr>
1457
1437
  <tr>
1458
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1459
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1438
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1439
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1460
1440
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1461
- <td>1.06023</td>
1462
- <td>1.99894</td>
1463
- <td>1.31827</td>
1464
- <td>0.28669</td>
1465
- <td>0.03487</td>
1441
+ <td>1.06020</td>
1442
+ <td>1.99646</td>
1443
+ <td>1.27462</td>
1444
+ <td>0.24071</td>
1445
+ <td>0.00570</td>
1466
1446
  </tr>
1467
1447
  <tr>
1468
1448
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1469
1449
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1470
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1450
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1471
1451
  <td>1.06023</td>
1472
- <td>1.99993</td>
1473
- <td>1.31592</td>
1474
- <td>0.27488</td>
1475
- <td>0.03782</td>
1452
+ <td>1.99999</td>
1453
+ <td>1.27452</td>
1454
+ <td>0.21342</td>
1455
+ <td>0.00466</td>
1476
1456
  </tr>
1477
1457
  <tr>
1478
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1479
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1458
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1459
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1480
1460
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1481
- <td>1.06023</td>
1482
- <td>1.99933</td>
1483
- <td>1.31311</td>
1484
- <td>0.27714</td>
1485
- <td>0.01591</td>
1461
+ <td>1.01031</td>
1462
+ <td>1.99533</td>
1463
+ <td>1.27401</td>
1464
+ <td>0.24862</td>
1465
+ <td>0.00602</td>
1486
1466
  </tr>
1487
1467
  <tr>
1488
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1468
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1489
1469
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1490
1470
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1491
1471
  <td>1.06023</td>
1492
- <td>2.00000</td>
1493
- <td>1.31193</td>
1494
- <td>0.27476</td>
1495
- <td>0.03502</td>
1496
- </tr>
1497
- <tr>
1498
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1499
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1500
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1501
- <td>1.06023</td>
1502
- <td>1.99999</td>
1503
- <td>1.31050</td>
1504
- <td>0.28007</td>
1505
- <td>0.02318</td>
1472
+ <td>1.99959</td>
1473
+ <td>1.27375</td>
1474
+ <td>0.27359</td>
1475
+ <td>0.00482</td>
1506
1476
  </tr>
1507
1477
  <tr>
1508
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1478
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1509
1479
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1510
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1511
- <td>1.06022</td>
1512
- <td>1.99954</td>
1513
- <td>1.31012</td>
1514
- <td>0.27900</td>
1515
- <td>0.03741</td>
1480
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
1481
+ <td>0.47171</td>
1482
+ <td>1.96463</td>
1483
+ <td>1.27350</td>
1484
+ <td>0.38651</td>
1485
+ <td>0.00490</td>
1516
1486
  </tr>
1517
1487
  <tr>
1518
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1488
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1519
1489
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1520
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1521
- <td>1.06021</td>
1522
- <td>1.99951</td>
1523
- <td>1.30669</td>
1524
- <td>0.27975</td>
1525
- <td>0.02097</td>
1490
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1491
+ <td>1.05027</td>
1492
+ <td>1.99996</td>
1493
+ <td>1.27114</td>
1494
+ <td>0.27154</td>
1495
+ <td>0.00468</td>
1526
1496
  </tr>
1527
1497
  <tr>
1528
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1498
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1529
1499
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1530
1500
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1531
- <td>1.06022</td>
1532
- <td>1.99845</td>
1533
- <td>1.30597</td>
1534
- <td>0.27011</td>
1535
- <td>0.04000</td>
1501
+ <td>1.06023</td>
1502
+ <td>1.99997</td>
1503
+ <td>1.27006</td>
1504
+ <td>0.24784</td>
1505
+ <td>0.00458</td>
1536
1506
  </tr>
1537
1507
  <tr>
1538
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1508
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1539
1509
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1540
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1541
- <td>1.06023</td>
1542
- <td>1.99999</td>
1543
- <td>1.30561</td>
1544
- <td>0.30834</td>
1545
- <td>0.01799</td>
1510
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1511
+ <td>1.05150</td>
1512
+ <td>1.99745</td>
1513
+ <td>1.26850</td>
1514
+ <td>0.24452</td>
1515
+ <td>0.00712</td>
1546
1516
  </tr>
1547
1517
  <tr>
1548
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1518
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1549
1519
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1550
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1551
- <td>1.06009</td>
1552
- <td>1.99994</td>
1553
- <td>1.30484</td>
1554
- <td>0.27968</td>
1555
- <td>0.02167</td>
1520
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1521
+ <td>1.06023</td>
1522
+ <td>1.99721</td>
1523
+ <td>1.26784</td>
1524
+ <td>0.21370</td>
1525
+ <td>0.00502</td>
1556
1526
  </tr>
1557
1527
  <tr>
1558
1528
  <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1559
1529
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1560
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1561
- <td>1.20878</td>
1562
- <td>1.99995</td>
1563
- <td>1.30320</td>
1564
- <td>0.25560</td>
1565
- <td>0.03874</td>
1566
- </tr>
1567
- <tr>
1568
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1569
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1570
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1571
- <td>1.06023</td>
1572
- <td>1.99994</td>
1573
- <td>1.30160</td>
1574
- <td>0.28537</td>
1575
- <td>0.01877</td>
1530
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1531
+ <td>1.00314</td>
1532
+ <td>1.99573</td>
1533
+ <td>1.26748</td>
1534
+ <td>0.26410</td>
1535
+ <td>0.00574</td>
1576
1536
  </tr>
1577
1537
  <tr>
1578
1538
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1579
1539
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1580
1540
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1581
- <td>1.06023</td>
1582
- <td>1.99999</td>
1583
- <td>1.30159</td>
1584
- <td>0.28533</td>
1585
- <td>0.02242</td>
1541
+ <td>1.04740</td>
1542
+ <td>1.99722</td>
1543
+ <td>1.26744</td>
1544
+ <td>0.24716</td>
1545
+ <td>0.00682</td>
1586
1546
  </tr>
1587
1547
  <tr>
1588
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1589
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1590
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1591
- <td>1.06023</td>
1592
- <td>1.99963</td>
1593
- <td>1.30056</td>
1594
- <td>0.25840</td>
1595
- <td>0.01439</td>
1548
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1549
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1550
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1551
+ <td>1.05572</td>
1552
+ <td>1.95834</td>
1553
+ <td>1.26690</td>
1554
+ <td>0.23434</td>
1555
+ <td>0.00714</td>
1596
1556
  </tr>
1597
1557
  <tr>
1598
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1558
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1599
1559
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1600
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1601
- <td>1.06023</td>
1602
- <td>1.99996</td>
1603
- <td>1.29868</td>
1604
- <td>0.28723</td>
1605
- <td>0.01727</td>
1560
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
1561
+ <td>0.47686</td>
1562
+ <td>1.96902</td>
1563
+ <td>1.26494</td>
1564
+ <td>0.36958</td>
1565
+ <td>0.00763</td>
1606
1566
  </tr>
1607
1567
  <tr>
1608
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1568
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1609
1569
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1610
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1611
- <td>1.06023</td>
1612
- <td>1.99680</td>
1613
- <td>1.29829</td>
1614
- <td>0.25235</td>
1615
- <td>0.02504</td>
1570
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1571
+ <td>1.00919</td>
1572
+ <td>1.99009</td>
1573
+ <td>1.26457</td>
1574
+ <td>0.26222</td>
1575
+ <td>0.00611</td>
1616
1576
  </tr>
1617
1577
  <tr>
1618
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1578
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1619
1579
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1620
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1621
- <td>1.06023</td>
1622
- <td>1.99997</td>
1623
- <td>1.29741</td>
1624
- <td>0.25983</td>
1625
- <td>0.02461</td>
1580
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1581
+ <td>1.06019</td>
1582
+ <td>1.99914</td>
1583
+ <td>1.26306</td>
1584
+ <td>0.21972</td>
1585
+ <td>0.00372</td>
1626
1586
  </tr>
1627
1587
  <tr>
1628
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1588
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1629
1589
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1630
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1631
- <td>1.06023</td>
1632
- <td>1.99999</td>
1633
- <td>1.29575</td>
1634
- <td>0.28900</td>
1635
- <td>0.00923</td>
1590
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1591
+ <td>0.79235</td>
1592
+ <td>1.99621</td>
1593
+ <td>1.26261</td>
1594
+ <td>0.27294</td>
1595
+ <td>0.00641</td>
1636
1596
  </tr>
1637
1597
  <tr>
1638
1598
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1639
1599
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1640
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1641
- <td>1.06023</td>
1642
- <td>1.99986</td>
1643
- <td>1.29276</td>
1644
- <td>0.29058</td>
1645
- <td>0.02025</td>
1600
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
1601
+ <td>0.51835</td>
1602
+ <td>1.94256</td>
1603
+ <td>1.26117</td>
1604
+ <td>0.35552</td>
1605
+ <td>0.00795</td>
1646
1606
  </tr>
1647
1607
  <tr>
1648
1608
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1649
1609
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1650
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1651
- <td>1.06023</td>
1652
- <td>1.99997</td>
1653
- <td>1.29169</td>
1654
- <td>0.26406</td>
1655
- <td>0.02014</td>
1656
- </tr>
1657
- <tr>
1658
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1659
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1660
1610
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1661
- <td>1.06021</td>
1662
- <td>1.99986</td>
1663
- <td>1.28919</td>
1664
- <td>0.24286</td>
1665
- <td>0.02046</td>
1611
+ <td>0.47243</td>
1612
+ <td>1.99966</td>
1613
+ <td>1.26106</td>
1614
+ <td>0.30568</td>
1615
+ <td>0.00721</td>
1666
1616
  </tr>
1667
1617
  <tr>
1668
1618
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1669
1619
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1670
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1671
- <td>1.06023</td>
1672
- <td>1.99980</td>
1673
- <td>1.28886</td>
1674
- <td>0.26617</td>
1675
- <td>0.02362</td>
1620
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
1621
+ <td>0.47237</td>
1622
+ <td>1.98927</td>
1623
+ <td>1.26065</td>
1624
+ <td>0.38325</td>
1625
+ <td>0.00672</td>
1676
1626
  </tr>
1677
1627
  <tr>
1678
1628
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1679
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1680
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1681
- <td>1.06023</td>
1682
- <td>2.00000</td>
1683
- <td>1.28883</td>
1684
- <td>0.26610</td>
1685
- <td>0.03119</td>
1629
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1630
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1631
+ <td>1.03429</td>
1632
+ <td>1.99948</td>
1633
+ <td>1.26036</td>
1634
+ <td>0.24788</td>
1635
+ <td>0.00577</td>
1686
1636
  </tr>
1687
1637
  <tr>
1688
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1689
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1690
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1691
- <td>1.06023</td>
1692
- <td>1.99998</td>
1693
- <td>1.28880</td>
1694
- <td>0.26602</td>
1695
- <td>0.03549</td>
1638
+ <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1639
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1640
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1641
+ <td>1.06017</td>
1642
+ <td>1.99973</td>
1643
+ <td>1.26010</td>
1644
+ <td>0.21084</td>
1645
+ <td>0.00471</td>
1696
1646
  </tr>
1697
1647
  <tr>
1698
1648
  <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1699
1649
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1700
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1701
- <td>1.06023</td>
1702
- <td>1.99886</td>
1703
- <td>1.28682</td>
1704
- <td>0.26515</td>
1705
- <td>0.03387</td>
1650
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1651
+ <td>1.06022</td>
1652
+ <td>1.99917</td>
1653
+ <td>1.25951</td>
1654
+ <td>0.22018</td>
1655
+ <td>0.00467</td>
1706
1656
  </tr>
1707
1657
  <tr>
1708
1658
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1709
1659
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1710
1660
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1711
- <td>1.06020</td>
1712
- <td>1.99956</td>
1713
- <td>1.28518</td>
1714
- <td>0.26647</td>
1715
- <td>0.02076</td>
1661
+ <td>0.91613</td>
1662
+ <td>1.99724</td>
1663
+ <td>1.25823</td>
1664
+ <td>0.27691</td>
1665
+ <td>0.00738</td>
1666
+ </tr>
1667
+ <tr>
1668
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1669
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1670
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1671
+ <td>1.06022</td>
1672
+ <td>1.99972</td>
1673
+ <td>1.25800</td>
1674
+ <td>0.25351</td>
1675
+ <td>0.00288</td>
1716
1676
  </tr>
1717
1677
  <tr>
1718
1678
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1719
1679
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1720
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1721
- <td>1.06019</td>
1722
- <td>1.99897</td>
1723
- <td>1.28206</td>
1724
- <td>0.26734</td>
1725
- <td>0.01754</td>
1680
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1681
+ <td>1.03556</td>
1682
+ <td>1.99685</td>
1683
+ <td>1.25277</td>
1684
+ <td>0.25321</td>
1685
+ <td>0.00609</td>
1726
1686
  </tr>
1727
1687
  <tr>
1728
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1688
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1729
1689
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1730
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1731
- <td>1.06023</td>
1732
- <td>1.99999</td>
1733
- <td>1.28194</td>
1734
- <td>0.24094</td>
1735
- <td>0.03044</td>
1690
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
1691
+ <td>0.48456</td>
1692
+ <td>1.99414</td>
1693
+ <td>1.25240</td>
1694
+ <td>0.36868</td>
1695
+ <td>0.00473</td>
1736
1696
  </tr>
1737
1697
  <tr>
1738
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1739
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1740
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1741
- <td>1.06023</td>
1742
- <td>1.99999</td>
1743
- <td>1.28187</td>
1744
- <td>0.24073</td>
1745
- <td>0.02135</td>
1698
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1699
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1700
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1701
+ <td>1.06022</td>
1702
+ <td>1.99996</td>
1703
+ <td>1.25129</td>
1704
+ <td>0.22656</td>
1705
+ <td>0.00372</td>
1746
1706
  </tr>
1747
1707
  <tr>
1748
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1708
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1749
1709
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1750
1710
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1751
- <td>1.06023</td>
1752
- <td>1.99965</td>
1753
- <td>1.28143</td>
1754
- <td>0.23943</td>
1755
- <td>0.03344</td>
1711
+ <td>1.03590</td>
1712
+ <td>1.99109</td>
1713
+ <td>1.25043</td>
1714
+ <td>0.23311</td>
1715
+ <td>0.00634</td>
1756
1716
  </tr>
1757
1717
  <tr>
1758
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1718
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1759
1719
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1760
1720
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1761
- <td>1.06023</td>
1762
- <td>1.99954</td>
1763
- <td>1.28025</td>
1764
- <td>0.23926</td>
1765
- <td>0.01760</td>
1721
+ <td>1.03484</td>
1722
+ <td>1.99991</td>
1723
+ <td>1.25032</td>
1724
+ <td>0.25169</td>
1725
+ <td>0.00473</td>
1766
1726
  </tr>
1767
1727
  <tr>
1768
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1769
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1770
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1771
- <td>1.06019</td>
1772
- <td>1.99999</td>
1773
- <td>1.27889</td>
1774
- <td>0.24249</td>
1775
- <td>0.03894</td>
1728
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1729
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1730
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
1731
+ <td>0.47489</td>
1732
+ <td>1.97270</td>
1733
+ <td>1.25014</td>
1734
+ <td>0.42015</td>
1735
+ <td>0.00788</td>
1776
1736
  </tr>
1777
1737
  <tr>
1778
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1779
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1780
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1781
- <td>1.06021</td>
1782
- <td>1.99960</td>
1783
- <td>1.27586</td>
1784
- <td>0.24409</td>
1785
- <td>0.02433</td>
1738
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1739
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1740
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1741
+ <td>1.06020</td>
1742
+ <td>1.99987</td>
1743
+ <td>1.24829</td>
1744
+ <td>0.22797</td>
1745
+ <td>0.00332</td>
1786
1746
  </tr>
1787
1747
  <tr>
1788
1748
  <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1789
1749
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1790
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1791
- <td>1.06023</td>
1792
- <td>1.99928</td>
1793
- <td>1.27572</td>
1794
- <td>0.24369</td>
1795
- <td>0.03374</td>
1750
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1751
+ <td>0.47194</td>
1752
+ <td>1.99692</td>
1753
+ <td>1.24620</td>
1754
+ <td>0.36798</td>
1755
+ <td>0.00612</td>
1796
1756
  </tr>
1797
1757
  <tr>
1798
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1758
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1799
1759
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1800
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1801
- <td>1.06023</td>
1802
- <td>1.99816</td>
1803
- <td>1.27560</td>
1804
- <td>0.24330</td>
1805
- <td>0.02732</td>
1760
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1761
+ <td>0.99832</td>
1762
+ <td>1.99848</td>
1763
+ <td>1.24598</td>
1764
+ <td>0.23744</td>
1765
+ <td>0.00552</td>
1806
1766
  </tr>
1807
1767
  <tr>
1808
1768
  <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1809
1769
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1810
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1811
- <td>1.06022</td>
1812
- <td>1.99757</td>
1813
- <td>1.27522</td>
1814
- <td>0.24220</td>
1815
- <td>0.01558</td>
1770
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1771
+ <td>1.05779</td>
1772
+ <td>1.99516</td>
1773
+ <td>1.24506</td>
1774
+ <td>0.21537</td>
1775
+ <td>0.00534</td>
1776
+ </tr>
1777
+ <tr>
1778
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1779
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1780
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1781
+ <td>1.05553</td>
1782
+ <td>1.99746</td>
1783
+ <td>1.24465</td>
1784
+ <td>0.21964</td>
1785
+ <td>0.00558</td>
1816
1786
  </tr>
1817
1787
  <tr>
1818
1788
  <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1819
1789
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1820
1790
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1821
1791
  <td>1.06023</td>
1822
- <td>1.99979</td>
1823
- <td>1.27487</td>
1824
- <td>0.29947</td>
1825
- <td>0.02517</td>
1792
+ <td>1.99999</td>
1793
+ <td>1.24239</td>
1794
+ <td>0.23098</td>
1795
+ <td>0.00516</td>
1826
1796
  </tr>
1827
1797
  <tr>
1828
1798
  <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1829
1799
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1830
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1800
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1831
1801
  <td>1.06023</td>
1832
- <td>2.00000</td>
1833
- <td>1.27402</td>
1834
- <td>0.27431</td>
1835
- <td>0.05456</td>
1802
+ <td>1.99992</td>
1803
+ <td>1.24238</td>
1804
+ <td>0.23094</td>
1805
+ <td>0.00338</td>
1836
1806
  </tr>
1837
1807
  <tr>
1838
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1839
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1840
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1841
- <td>1.06022</td>
1842
- <td>1.99970</td>
1843
- <td>1.27376</td>
1844
- <td>0.27366</td>
1845
- <td>0.03216</td>
1808
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1809
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1810
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1811
+ <td>0.53240</td>
1812
+ <td>1.99926</td>
1813
+ <td>1.23895</td>
1814
+ <td>0.29647</td>
1815
+ <td>0.00734</td>
1846
1816
  </tr>
1847
1817
  <tr>
1848
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1818
+ <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1849
1819
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1850
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1820
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1851
1821
  <td>1.06023</td>
1852
- <td>1.99996</td>
1853
- <td>1.27279</td>
1854
- <td>0.24550</td>
1855
- <td>0.02067</td>
1822
+ <td>1.99995</td>
1823
+ <td>1.23838</td>
1824
+ <td>0.19802</td>
1825
+ <td>0.00388</td>
1856
1826
  </tr>
1857
1827
  <tr>
1858
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1828
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1859
1829
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1860
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
1861
- <td>1.06023</td>
1862
- <td>1.99907</td>
1863
- <td>1.27235</td>
1864
- <td>0.24436</td>
1865
- <td>0.00984</td>
1830
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1831
+ <td>0.67598</td>
1832
+ <td>1.99649</td>
1833
+ <td>1.23684</td>
1834
+ <td>0.22818</td>
1835
+ <td>0.00532</td>
1866
1836
  </tr>
1867
1837
  <tr>
1868
1838
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1869
1839
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1870
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1871
- <td>1.06023</td>
1872
- <td>1.99846</td>
1873
- <td>1.27233</td>
1874
- <td>0.24414</td>
1875
- <td>0.02883</td>
1840
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1841
+ <td>1.02841</td>
1842
+ <td>1.99864</td>
1843
+ <td>1.23675</td>
1844
+ <td>0.19807</td>
1845
+ <td>0.00756</td>
1876
1846
  </tr>
1877
1847
  <tr>
1878
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1848
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1879
1849
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1880
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1850
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1881
1851
  <td>1.06023</td>
1882
- <td>1.99937</td>
1883
- <td>1.27201</td>
1884
- <td>0.24322</td>
1885
- <td>0.03268</td>
1852
+ <td>1.99989</td>
1853
+ <td>1.23548</td>
1854
+ <td>0.19981</td>
1855
+ <td>0.00352</td>
1886
1856
  </tr>
1887
1857
  <tr>
1888
1858
  <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1889
1859
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1890
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1891
- <td>1.06023</td>
1892
- <td>1.99988</td>
1893
- <td>1.27007</td>
1894
- <td>0.24786</td>
1895
- <td>0.01706</td>
1860
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1861
+ <td>0.75069</td>
1862
+ <td>1.98842</td>
1863
+ <td>1.23471</td>
1864
+ <td>0.23311</td>
1865
+ <td>0.00531</td>
1896
1866
  </tr>
1897
1867
  <tr>
1898
1868
  <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1899
1869
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1900
1870
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1901
1871
  <td>1.06023</td>
1902
- <td>1.99977</td>
1903
- <td>1.26992</td>
1904
- <td>0.24742</td>
1905
- <td>0.02438</td>
1906
- </tr>
1907
- <tr>
1908
- <td>Elitism(RouletteSelection,1)</td>
1909
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1910
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1911
- <td>1.06023</td>
1912
- <td>1.99904</td>
1913
- <td>1.26829</td>
1914
- <td>0.24431</td>
1915
- <td>0.03125</td>
1872
+ <td>1.99965</td>
1873
+ <td>1.23228</td>
1874
+ <td>0.20044</td>
1875
+ <td>0.00494</td>
1916
1876
  </tr>
1917
1877
  <tr>
1918
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1919
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1920
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1921
- <td>1.06023</td>
1922
- <td>2.00000</td>
1923
- <td>1.26710</td>
1924
- <td>0.24946</td>
1925
- <td>0.00921</td>
1878
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1879
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1880
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
1881
+ <td>0.53208</td>
1882
+ <td>1.99924</td>
1883
+ <td>1.23096</td>
1884
+ <td>0.29747</td>
1885
+ <td>0.00505</td>
1926
1886
  </tr>
1927
1887
  <tr>
1928
1888
  <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1929
1889
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1930
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1931
- <td>1.06022</td>
1890
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
1891
+ <td>1.06023</td>
1932
1892
  <td>1.99998</td>
1933
- <td>1.26685</td>
1934
- <td>0.24875</td>
1935
- <td>0.02564</td>
1893
+ <td>1.23050</td>
1894
+ <td>0.23617</td>
1895
+ <td>0.00480</td>
1936
1896
  </tr>
1937
1897
  <tr>
1938
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1939
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1940
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1898
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1899
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1900
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1941
1901
  <td>1.06023</td>
1942
- <td>1.99871</td>
1943
- <td>1.26601</td>
1944
- <td>0.21780</td>
1945
- <td>0.03396</td>
1902
+ <td>1.99947</td>
1903
+ <td>1.22854</td>
1904
+ <td>0.16236</td>
1905
+ <td>0.00362</td>
1946
1906
  </tr>
1947
1907
  <tr>
1948
- <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1908
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1949
1909
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1950
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1951
- <td>1.06023</td>
1952
- <td>1.99982</td>
1953
- <td>1.26411</td>
1954
- <td>0.25096</td>
1955
- <td>0.03180</td>
1910
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
1911
+ <td>0.47463</td>
1912
+ <td>1.98898</td>
1913
+ <td>1.22826</td>
1914
+ <td>0.39510</td>
1915
+ <td>0.00542</td>
1956
1916
  </tr>
1957
1917
  <tr>
1958
1918
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1959
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1960
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
1961
- <td>1.06023</td>
1962
- <td>1.99991</td>
1963
- <td>1.26395</td>
1964
- <td>0.25052</td>
1965
- <td>0.02762</td>
1919
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1920
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
1921
+ <td>0.55746</td>
1922
+ <td>1.98443</td>
1923
+ <td>1.22536</td>
1924
+ <td>0.38129</td>
1925
+ <td>0.00681</td>
1966
1926
  </tr>
1967
1927
  <tr>
1968
1928
  <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
1969
1929
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1970
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1971
- <td>1.06022</td>
1972
- <td>1.99882</td>
1973
- <td>1.26355</td>
1974
- <td>0.24935</td>
1975
- <td>0.01885</td>
1976
- </tr>
1977
- <tr>
1978
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
1979
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1980
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1981
- <td>1.06023</td>
1982
- <td>1.99999</td>
1983
- <td>1.26117</td>
1984
- <td>0.25258</td>
1985
- <td>0.01781</td>
1930
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1931
+ <td>0.94628</td>
1932
+ <td>1.99512</td>
1933
+ <td>1.22477</td>
1934
+ <td>0.20495</td>
1935
+ <td>0.00547</td>
1986
1936
  </tr>
1987
1937
  <tr>
1988
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
1938
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1989
1939
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
1990
1940
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
1991
- <td>1.06022</td>
1992
- <td>1.99939</td>
1993
- <td>1.26012</td>
1994
- <td>0.22147</td>
1995
- <td>0.02223</td>
1941
+ <td>1.02527</td>
1942
+ <td>1.99701</td>
1943
+ <td>1.22432</td>
1944
+ <td>0.20223</td>
1945
+ <td>0.00641</td>
1996
1946
  </tr>
1997
1947
  <tr>
1998
1948
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
1999
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
1949
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2000
1950
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
2001
- <td>1.06022</td>
2002
- <td>1.99904</td>
2003
- <td>1.25794</td>
2004
- <td>0.25330</td>
2005
- <td>0.03454</td>
1951
+ <td>1.03310</td>
1952
+ <td>1.98520</td>
1953
+ <td>1.22426</td>
1954
+ <td>0.17796</td>
1955
+ <td>0.00702</td>
2006
1956
  </tr>
2007
1957
  <tr>
2008
1958
  <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2009
1959
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
2010
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
2011
- <td>1.06023</td>
2012
- <td>1.99964</td>
2013
- <td>1.25403</td>
2014
- <td>0.22425</td>
2015
- <td>0.01712</td>
2016
- </tr>
2017
- <tr>
2018
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2019
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2020
1960
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
2021
- <td>1.06023</td>
2022
- <td>1.99998</td>
2023
- <td>1.25131</td>
2024
- <td>0.22662</td>
2025
- <td>0.01002</td>
1961
+ <td>1.05168</td>
1962
+ <td>1.99776</td>
1963
+ <td>1.22195</td>
1964
+ <td>0.17015</td>
1965
+ <td>0.00537</td>
2026
1966
  </tr>
2027
1967
  <tr>
2028
1968
  <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2029
1969
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
2030
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
2031
- <td>1.06023</td>
2032
- <td>1.99986</td>
2033
- <td>1.25117</td>
2034
- <td>0.22617</td>
2035
- <td>0.01607</td>
1970
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
1971
+ <td>0.47173</td>
1972
+ <td>1.97989</td>
1973
+ <td>1.22145</td>
1974
+ <td>0.39092</td>
1975
+ <td>0.00472</td>
2036
1976
  </tr>
2037
1977
  <tr>
2038
1978
  <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2039
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2040
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
1979
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
1980
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
2041
1981
  <td>1.06023</td>
2042
- <td>1.99977</td>
2043
- <td>1.25088</td>
2044
- <td>0.22524</td>
2045
- <td>0.02383</td>
1982
+ <td>1.99917</td>
1983
+ <td>1.21444</td>
1984
+ <td>0.20816</td>
1985
+ <td>0.00454</td>
2046
1986
  </tr>
2047
1987
  <tr>
2048
1988
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
2049
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
2050
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
2051
- <td>1.06018</td>
2052
- <td>1.99592</td>
2053
- <td>1.24967</td>
2054
- <td>0.22130</td>
2055
- <td>0.02849</td>
1989
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
1990
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
1991
+ <td>1.05867</td>
1992
+ <td>1.99992</td>
1993
+ <td>1.21405</td>
1994
+ <td>0.11762</td>
1995
+ <td>0.00704</td>
2056
1996
  </tr>
2057
1997
  <tr>
2058
1998
  <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
2059
1999
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
2060
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
2000
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
2061
2001
  <td>1.06022</td>
2062
- <td>1.99913</td>
2063
- <td>1.24781</td>
2064
- <td>0.22642</td>
2065
- <td>0.02085</td>
2002
+ <td>1.99775</td>
2003
+ <td>1.21362</td>
2004
+ <td>0.16980</td>
2005
+ <td>0.00544</td>
2006
+ </tr>
2007
+ <tr>
2008
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2009
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2010
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
2011
+ <td>1.05377</td>
2012
+ <td>1.99934</td>
2013
+ <td>1.21321</td>
2014
+ <td>0.15871</td>
2015
+ <td>0.00534</td>
2016
+ </tr>
2017
+ <tr>
2018
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
2019
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
2020
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
2021
+ <td>0.47548</td>
2022
+ <td>1.98634</td>
2023
+ <td>1.21078</td>
2024
+ <td>0.39748</td>
2025
+ <td>0.00613</td>
2066
2026
  </tr>
2067
2027
  <tr>
2068
2028
  <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2069
2029
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
2070
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
2030
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
2071
2031
  <td>1.06023</td>
2072
- <td>1.99998</td>
2073
- <td>1.24737</td>
2074
- <td>0.19334</td>
2075
- <td>0.01196</td>
2032
+ <td>1.99976</td>
2033
+ <td>1.21067</td>
2034
+ <td>0.17133</td>
2035
+ <td>0.00374</td>
2076
2036
  </tr>
2077
2037
  <tr>
2078
2038
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
2039
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2040
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
2041
+ <td>0.47269</td>
2042
+ <td>1.98189</td>
2043
+ <td>1.20988</td>
2044
+ <td>0.44818</td>
2045
+ <td>0.00641</td>
2046
+ </tr>
2047
+ <tr>
2048
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2079
2049
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
2080
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
2050
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
2081
2051
  <td>1.06023</td>
2082
- <td>1.99995</td>
2083
- <td>1.24536</td>
2084
- <td>0.22956</td>
2085
- <td>0.02860</td>
2052
+ <td>1.99959</td>
2053
+ <td>1.20977</td>
2054
+ <td>0.12130</td>
2055
+ <td>0.00329</td>
2086
2056
  </tr>
2087
2057
  <tr>
2088
2058
  <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
2089
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2090
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
2091
- <td>1.06022</td>
2092
- <td>1.99990</td>
2093
- <td>1.24524</td>
2094
- <td>0.22917</td>
2095
- <td>0.02834</td>
2059
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
2060
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
2061
+ <td>0.50124</td>
2062
+ <td>1.99642</td>
2063
+ <td>1.20719</td>
2064
+ <td>0.26292</td>
2065
+ <td>0.00668</td>
2096
2066
  </tr>
2097
2067
  <tr>
2098
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2068
+ <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2099
2069
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2100
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
2101
- <td>1.06023</td>
2102
- <td>1.99996</td>
2103
- <td>1.24141</td>
2104
- <td>0.19663</td>
2105
- <td>0.03905</td>
2070
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
2071
+ <td>1.06016</td>
2072
+ <td>1.99833</td>
2073
+ <td>1.20449</td>
2074
+ <td>0.17274</td>
2075
+ <td>0.00512</td>
2106
2076
  </tr>
2107
2077
  <tr>
2108
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2078
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
2109
2079
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
2110
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
2111
- <td>1.06023</td>
2112
- <td>1.99955</td>
2113
- <td>1.24140</td>
2114
- <td>0.19658</td>
2115
- <td>0.02107</td>
2080
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
2081
+ <td>0.47548</td>
2082
+ <td>1.99348</td>
2083
+ <td>1.20305</td>
2084
+ <td>0.36851</td>
2085
+ <td>0.00904</td>
2116
2086
  </tr>
2117
2087
  <tr>
2118
2088
  <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2119
2089
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2120
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
2121
- <td>1.06023</td>
2122
- <td>1.99998</td>
2123
- <td>1.24137</td>
2124
- <td>0.19649</td>
2125
- <td>0.03266</td>
2090
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
2091
+ <td>0.61343</td>
2092
+ <td>1.99815</td>
2093
+ <td>1.19952</td>
2094
+ <td>0.28187</td>
2095
+ <td>0.00539</td>
2126
2096
  </tr>
2127
2097
  <tr>
2128
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2098
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2129
2099
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
2130
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
2131
- <td>1.06015</td>
2132
- <td>1.99967</td>
2133
- <td>1.24135</td>
2134
- <td>0.19646</td>
2135
- <td>0.00901</td>
2100
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
2101
+ <td>0.96592</td>
2102
+ <td>1.97126</td>
2103
+ <td>1.19421</td>
2104
+ <td>0.16999</td>
2105
+ <td>0.00571</td>
2136
2106
  </tr>
2137
2107
  <tr>
2138
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2108
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
2139
2109
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2140
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
2141
- <td>1.06018</td>
2142
- <td>1.99999</td>
2143
- <td>1.23939</td>
2144
- <td>0.23227</td>
2145
- <td>0.01359</td>
2110
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
2111
+ <td>0.55704</td>
2112
+ <td>1.99942</td>
2113
+ <td>1.19410</td>
2114
+ <td>0.27713</td>
2115
+ <td>0.00699</td>
2146
2116
  </tr>
2147
2117
  <tr>
2148
2118
  <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2149
2119
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
2150
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
2151
- <td>1.06021</td>
2152
- <td>1.99968</td>
2153
- <td>1.23841</td>
2154
- <td>0.19815</td>
2155
- <td>0.01572</td>
2120
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
2121
+ <td>0.48289</td>
2122
+ <td>1.99695</td>
2123
+ <td>1.19234</td>
2124
+ <td>0.32224</td>
2125
+ <td>0.00614</td>
2156
2126
  </tr>
2157
2127
  <tr>
2158
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2128
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
2159
2129
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
2160
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 0.4])</td>
2161
- <td>1.06023</td>
2162
- <td>1.99999</td>
2163
- <td>1.23739</td>
2164
- <td>0.26314</td>
2165
- <td>0.02046</td>
2130
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
2131
+ <td>0.47352</td>
2132
+ <td>1.97532</td>
2133
+ <td>1.18938</td>
2134
+ <td>0.31615</td>
2135
+ <td>0.00639</td>
2166
2136
  </tr>
2167
2137
  <tr>
2168
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2169
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
2170
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
2171
- <td>1.06023</td>
2172
- <td>2.00000</td>
2173
- <td>1.23636</td>
2174
- <td>0.23340</td>
2175
- <td>0.02081</td>
2138
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2139
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2140
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 6.4])</td>
2141
+ <td>0.49181</td>
2142
+ <td>1.99088</td>
2143
+ <td>1.18717</td>
2144
+ <td>0.44397</td>
2145
+ <td>0.00627</td>
2176
2146
  </tr>
2177
2147
  <tr>
2178
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2148
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
2179
2149
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2180
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
2181
- <td>1.06023</td>
2182
- <td>1.99992</td>
2183
- <td>1.23548</td>
2184
- <td>0.19981</td>
2185
- <td>0.00982</td>
2150
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
2151
+ <td>0.48484</td>
2152
+ <td>1.97819</td>
2153
+ <td>1.18016</td>
2154
+ <td>0.36282</td>
2155
+ <td>0.00745</td>
2186
2156
  </tr>
2187
2157
  <tr>
2188
- <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2158
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
2189
2159
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
2190
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
2191
- <td>1.06023</td>
2192
- <td>1.99847</td>
2193
- <td>1.22846</td>
2194
- <td>0.16195</td>
2195
- <td>0.01911</td>
2160
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
2161
+ <td>0.48689</td>
2162
+ <td>1.97368</td>
2163
+ <td>1.17596</td>
2164
+ <td>0.29538</td>
2165
+ <td>0.00739</td>
2196
2166
  </tr>
2197
2167
  <tr>
2198
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2199
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
2200
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 0.8])</td>
2201
- <td>1.06022</td>
2202
- <td>1.99905</td>
2203
- <td>1.21960</td>
2204
- <td>0.16712</td>
2205
- <td>0.01174</td>
2168
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2169
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2170
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
2171
+ <td>0.47194</td>
2172
+ <td>1.98363</td>
2173
+ <td>1.16604</td>
2174
+ <td>0.37137</td>
2175
+ <td>0.00536</td>
2206
2176
  </tr>
2207
2177
  <tr>
2208
- <td>Elitism(ScaledRouletteSelection[1,2,3,4,...],1)</td>
2209
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
2178
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2179
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2210
2180
  <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
2211
- <td>1.06022</td>
2212
- <td>1.97876</td>
2213
- <td>1.21824</td>
2214
- <td>0.11247</td>
2215
- <td>0.02410</td>
2181
+ <td>0.86882</td>
2182
+ <td>1.98493</td>
2183
+ <td>1.16521</td>
2184
+ <td>0.19059</td>
2185
+ <td>0.00522</td>
2216
2186
  </tr>
2217
2187
  <tr>
2218
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2219
- <td>NullCrossover</td>
2220
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
2221
- <td>1.06021</td>
2222
- <td>1.99148</td>
2223
- <td>1.21577</td>
2224
- <td>0.16462</td>
2225
- <td>0.01622</td>
2188
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2189
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2190
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 3.2])</td>
2191
+ <td>0.48904</td>
2192
+ <td>1.99933</td>
2193
+ <td>1.16456</td>
2194
+ <td>0.39812</td>
2195
+ <td>0.00626</td>
2226
2196
  </tr>
2227
2197
  <tr>
2228
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2198
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
2229
2199
  <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2230
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.8])</td>
2231
- <td>1.06023</td>
2232
- <td>1.99982</td>
2233
- <td>1.20772</td>
2234
- <td>0.17265</td>
2235
- <td>0.02252</td>
2200
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
2201
+ <td>0.47270</td>
2202
+ <td>1.94150</td>
2203
+ <td>1.16271</td>
2204
+ <td>0.29133</td>
2205
+ <td>0.00620</td>
2206
+ </tr>
2207
+ <tr>
2208
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
2209
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2210
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
2211
+ <td>0.47493</td>
2212
+ <td>1.99460</td>
2213
+ <td>1.16255</td>
2214
+ <td>0.34281</td>
2215
+ <td>0.00599</td>
2216
+ </tr>
2217
+ <tr>
2218
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
2219
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
2220
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
2221
+ <td>0.47416</td>
2222
+ <td>1.94263</td>
2223
+ <td>1.16147</td>
2224
+ <td>0.25227</td>
2225
+ <td>0.00610</td>
2236
2226
  </tr>
2237
2227
  <tr>
2238
2228
  <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2239
2229
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
2240
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
2241
- <td>1.06023</td>
2242
- <td>1.99170</td>
2243
- <td>1.20366</td>
2244
- <td>0.12378</td>
2245
- <td>0.01651</td>
2230
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
2231
+ <td>0.71229</td>
2232
+ <td>1.96131</td>
2233
+ <td>1.15431</td>
2234
+ <td>0.20531</td>
2235
+ <td>0.00520</td>
2246
2236
  </tr>
2247
2237
  <tr>
2248
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2249
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2250
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
2251
- <td>1.06022</td>
2252
- <td>1.99938</td>
2253
- <td>1.19491</td>
2254
- <td>0.12931</td>
2255
- <td>0.00965</td>
2238
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
2239
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
2240
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 1.6])</td>
2241
+ <td>0.61504</td>
2242
+ <td>1.92795</td>
2243
+ <td>1.15350</td>
2244
+ <td>0.16561</td>
2245
+ <td>0.00693</td>
2256
2246
  </tr>
2257
2247
  <tr>
2258
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2259
- <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2260
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
2261
- <td>1.06019</td>
2262
- <td>1.99819</td>
2263
- <td>1.19487</td>
2264
- <td>0.12917</td>
2265
- <td>0.01206</td>
2248
+ <td>TournamentSelection(3,nil)</td>
2249
+ <td>NullCrossover</td>
2250
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
2251
+ <td>0.50919</td>
2252
+ <td>1.93400</td>
2253
+ <td>1.13103</td>
2254
+ <td>0.25299</td>
2255
+ <td>0.00644</td>
2266
2256
  </tr>
2267
2257
  <tr>
2268
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2258
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2269
2259
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
2270
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 1],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
2271
- <td>1.06021</td>
2272
- <td>1.99877</td>
2273
- <td>1.18003</td>
2274
- <td>0.13519</td>
2275
- <td>0.01671</td>
2260
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 1.6])</td>
2261
+ <td>0.48535</td>
2262
+ <td>1.87224</td>
2263
+ <td>1.12305</td>
2264
+ <td>0.29824</td>
2265
+ <td>0.00593</td>
2276
2266
  </tr>
2277
2267
  <tr>
2278
- <td>TruncationSelection(1)</td>
2268
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2269
+ <td>SinglePointCrossover</td>
2270
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:gaussian, 6.4])</td>
2271
+ <td>0.48514</td>
2272
+ <td>1.90858</td>
2273
+ <td>1.12203</td>
2274
+ <td>0.28168</td>
2275
+ <td>0.00596</td>
2276
+ </tr>
2277
+ <tr>
2278
+ <td>TournamentSelection(4,nil)</td>
2279
2279
  <td>NullCrossover</td>
2280
- <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 0.4])</td>
2281
- <td>1.06023</td>
2282
- <td>1.20882</td>
2283
- <td>1.17316</td>
2284
- <td>0.06346</td>
2285
- <td>0.01830</td>
2280
+ <td>ListMutator([:n_point, 2],[:uniform, 3.2])</td>
2281
+ <td>0.47145</td>
2282
+ <td>1.53318</td>
2283
+ <td>1.06274</td>
2284
+ <td>0.23274</td>
2285
+ <td>0.00503</td>
2286
2286
  </tr>
2287
2287
  </table>
2288
2288
  </body>