baseline-rb 0.2.0 → 0.3.0

data/lib/baseline/cisco/parser.rb

@@ -12,32 +12,32 @@ module Baseline
       private
 
       # 解析管理访问暴露检查使用的有序 ACL 定义。
-      def access_lists
+      def parse_access_lists
         matching_blocks(/\Aip access-list\s+/).each do |section|
           name = section.text.split.last
           extended = section.text.start_with?("ip access-list extended ") || nxos?
-          register_acl(name, section.children, source: section) { |entry, index| cisco_rule(entry, index, extended: extended) }
+          register_acl(name, section.children, source: section) { |entry, index| parse_acl_rule(entry, index, extended: extended) }
         end
         matching_blocks(/\Aaccess-list\s+/).group_by { |entry| entry.text.split[1] }.each do |name, entries|
           extended = name.to_i.between?(100, 199) || name.to_i.between?(2000, 2699)
-          register_acl(name, entries) { |entry, index| cisco_rule(entry, index, extended: extended, prefix: /\Aaccess-list\s+\S+\s+/) }
+          register_acl(name, entries) { |entry, index| parse_acl_rule(entry, index, extended: extended, prefix: /\Aaccess-list\s+\S+\s+/) }
         end
       end
 
       # 解析 Cisco ACL 条目，保留规则顺序及地址语义。
-      def cisco_rule(entry, index, extended:, prefix: /\A/)
+      def parse_acl_rule(entry, index, extended:, prefix: /\A/)
         text = entry.text.sub(prefix, "")
         match = /\A(?:(\d+)\s+)?(permit|deny)\s+(.+)\z/.match(text)
         return unless match
         parts = match[3].split
         protocol = extended ? parts.shift : "ip"
         return unless %w[ip tcp udp icmp].include?(protocol)
-        network = acl_source_network(parts)
-        return if extended && acl_source_network(parts) != "0.0.0.0/0"
+        network = parse_acl_source_network(parts)
+        return if extended && parse_acl_source_network(parts) != "0.0.0.0/0"
         if extended && parts.first == "eq"
           return unless %w[tcp udp].include?(protocol)
           parts.shift
-          port = service_port(parts.shift)
+          port = parse_service_port(parts.shift)
           return if port.nil?
         end
         return unless (parts - %w[log log-input]).empty?
@@ -48,26 +48,29 @@ module Baseline
       end
 
       # 根据监听服务、认证方式与 ACL 绑定关系归纳管理访问事实。
-      def management
-        version = last_configured_value(/\Aip ssh version\s+([12])\z/)
-        record("ssh.versions", [ version ]) if version
+      def parse_management
+        version = effective_configured_value(/\Aip ssh version\s+([12])\z/,
+          family: /\A(?:no )?ip ssh version\b/, fact: "ssh.versions", reset: /\Ano ip ssh version(?: [12])?\z/)
+        record_fact("ssh.versions", [ version ]) if version
         ssh = nxos? ? configured_state(/\Afeature ssh\z/, /\Ano feature ssh\z/) : version ? true : nil
-        record("ssh.enabled", ssh, matching_blocks(/\A(?:ip ssh|(?:no )?feature ssh)/))
+        record_fact("ssh.enabled", ssh, matching_blocks(/\A(?:ip ssh|(?:no )?feature ssh)/))
         default_aaa = nxos? || configured_state(/\Aaaa new-model\z/, /\Ano aaa new-model\z/) == true
         vtys = matching_blocks(/\Aline vty(?:\s|\z)/).map do |section|
-          authentication = last_configured_value(/\Alogin authentication\s+(\S+)\z/, section.children)
-          local = section.children.any? { |entry| entry.text == "login local" }
-          { name: section.text, protocols: last_configured_value(/\Atransport input\s+(.+)\z/, section.children)&.split,
-            authentication: local ? "local" : (default_aaa ? "aaa" : nil),
-            authentication_list: authentication || (default_aaa ? "default" : nil),
-            acl: last_configured_value(/\Aaccess-class\s+(\S+)\s+in(?:\s+vrf-also)?\z/, section.children), line: section.line }
+          login = configured_vty_login(section, default_aaa: default_aaa)
+          acl_entries = section.children.reject { |entry| /\A(?:no )?access-class\s+\S+\s+out(?:\s|\z)/.match?(entry.text) }
+          { name: section.text, protocols: effective_configured_value(/\Atransport input\s+((?:all|none|ssh|telnet)(?:\s+(?:ssh|telnet))*)\z/, entries: section.children,
+              family: /\A(?:no )?transport input\b/, fact: "ssh.vty_ssh_only", reset: /\Ano transport input(?:\s+\S+)*\z/)&.split,
+            authentication: login[:authentication], authentication_list: login[:authentication_list],
+            acl: effective_configured_value(/\Aaccess-class\s+(\S+)\s+in(?:\s+vrf-also)?\z/, entries: acl_entries,
+              family: /\A(?:no )?access-class\b/, fact: "management.acl",
+              reset: /\Ano access-class(?:\s+\S+\s+in(?:\s+vrf-also)?)?\z/), line: section.line }
         end
         rotary = matching_blocks(/\A(?:no )?ip ssh port(?:\s|\z)/)
         rotary.concat(matching_blocks(/\Aline vty(?:\s|\z)/).flat_map { |section| matching_blocks(/\A(?:no )?rotary(?:\s|\z)/, section.children) })
-        unknown_listener_port("management.acl", rotary) unless rotary.empty?
+        record_unknown_listener_port("management.acl", rotary) unless rotary.empty?
         telnet_ports = matching_blocks(/\A(?:no )?(?:ip )?telnet(?: server)? port(?:\s|\z)/)
-        unknown_listener_port("management.acl", telnet_ports) unless telnet_ports.empty?
-        @facts.management(vtys: vtys,
+        record_unknown_listener_port("management.acl", telnet_ports) unless telnet_ports.empty?
+        @fact_builder.record_management_access(vtys: vtys,
           ssh_port: rotary.empty? ? listener_port("ssh port", default: 22, scope: "management.acl", negate: "no") : nil,
           telnet_port: telnet_ports.empty? ? 23 : nil)
         telnet = if nxos?
@@ -75,31 +78,80 @@ module Baseline
         elsif vtys.any? && vtys.all? { |entry| entry[:protocols] }
           vtys.any? { |entry| (entry[:protocols] & %w[all telnet]).any? }
         end
-        record("services", { "telnet" => telnet, "http" => configured_state(/\Aip http server\z/, /\Ano ip http server\z/),
+        record_fact("services", { "telnet" => telnet, "http" => configured_state(/\Aip http server\z/, /\Ano ip http server\z/),
           "https" => configured_state(/\Aip http secure-server\z/, /\Ano ip http secure-server\z/),
           "ftp" => configured_state(/\A(?:feature ftp-server|ftp-server enable)\z/, /\Ano (?:feature ftp-server|ftp-server enable)\z/),
           "tftp" => configured_state(/\A(?:feature tftp-server|tftp-server\s+.+)\z/, /\Ano (?:feature tftp-server|tftp-server\s+.+)\z/),
           "finger" => configured_state(/\A(?:ip finger|service finger)\z/, /\Ano (?:ip finger|service finger)\z/) })
       end
 
-      # 采集明确启用或禁用的管理服务。
-      def services
-        record("ntp.servers", configured_values(/\Antp server(?: vrf \S+)?\s+(\S+)/), matching_blocks(/\Antp server/))
-        record("ntp.authentication", configured_state(/\Antp authenticate\z/, /\Ano ntp authenticate\z/))
-        record("ntp.source", last_configured_value(/\Antp source(?:-interface)?\s+(\S+)\z/))
-        hosts = configured_values(nxos? ? /\Alogging server\s+(\S+)/ : /\Alogging host(?: ipv6)?\s+(\S+)/)
-        hosts |= configured_values(/\Alogging\s+(\d+(?:\.\d+){3})\z/) unless nxos?
-        record("syslog.servers", hosts, matching_blocks(/\Alogging (?:host|server)/))
-        record("syslog.source", last_configured_value(/\Alogging source-interface\s+(\S+)\z/))
-        snmp = matching_blocks(/\Asnmp-server\b/)
+      # VTY 登录方式属于同一声明族，不能让先前的本地登录覆盖后续列表或撤销。
+      def configured_vty_login(section, default_aaa:)
+        entry = matching_blocks(/\A(?:no )?login\b/, section.children).last
+        fallback = { authentication: default_aaa ? "aaa" : nil, authentication_list: default_aaa ? "default" : nil }
+        return fallback unless entry
+
+        case entry.text
+        when "login local"
+          analyze(entry) { { authentication: "local", authentication_list: nil } }
+        when "login", "no login"
+          analyze(entry) { { authentication: "none", authentication_list: nil } }
+        when /\Alogin authentication\s+(\S+)\z/
+          analyze(entry) { fallback.merge(authentication_list: entry.text.split.last) }
+        else
+          record_unknown_fact("ssh.vty_aaa", [ entry ])
+          record_unknown_fact("tacacs.login", [ entry ])
+          { authentication: nil, authentication_list: nil }
+        end
+      end
+
+      # 提取时间服务器、认证要求与源接口。
+      def parse_ntp
+        ntp_entries = matching_blocks(/\A(?:no )?ntp server(?:\s|\z)/)
+        ntp_pattern = /\Antp server\s+(?:vrf\s+\S+\s+)?(?:(?:ip|ipv6)\s+)?((?!(?:vrf|ip|ipv6)(?:\s|\z))\S+)/
+        servers = configured_server_addresses("ntp.servers", ntp_pattern, ntp_entries, negate: "no") do |text, match|
+          options = parse_server_options(match.post_match, flags: %w[prefer normal-sync burst iburst],
+            integers: { "version" => 1..4, "key" => 1..65_535, "minpoll" => 4..17, "maxpoll" => 4..17 },
+            names: [ "use-vrf" ], interfaces: [ "source" ])
+          vrf = text[/\Antp server\s+vrf\s+(\S+)/, 1]
+          [ match[1], vrf || options["use-vrf"] ] if options && !(vrf && options.key?("use-vrf"))
+        end
+        record_fact("ntp.servers", servers, ntp_entries)
+        record_configured_state("ntp.authentication", /\Antp authenticate\z/, /\Ano ntp authenticate\z/)
+        source_entries = matching_blocks(/\A(?:no )?ntp source(?:-interface)?\b/)
+        source = effective_configured_value(/\Antp source(?:-interface)?\s+(\S+)\z/, entries: source_entries,
+          family: /\A/, fact: "ntp.source", reset: /\Ano ntp source(?:-interface)?(?:\s+\S+)?\z/)
+        record_fact("ntp.source", source, source_entries.last(1))
+      end
+
+      # 提取日志目标与源接口，厂商命令不进入事实归约层。
+      def parse_syslog
+        log_entries = matching_blocks(nxos? ? /\A(?:no )?logging server(?:\s|\z)/ : /\A(?:no )?logging host(?:\s|\z)/)
+        log_pattern = nxos? ? /\Alogging server\s+(\S+)/ : /\Alogging host\s+(?:ipv6\s+)?((?!ipv6(?:\s|\z))\S+)/
+        unless nxos?
+          log_entries += matching_blocks(/\A(?:no )?logging\s+\d+(?:\.\d+){3}\z/)
+          log_entries.sort_by!(&:index)
+          log_pattern = /\Alogging\s+(?:host\s+(?:ipv6\s+)?)?((?!(?:host|ipv6)(?:\s|\z))\S+)/
+        end
+        hosts = configured_server_addresses("syslog.servers", log_pattern, log_entries, negate: "no")
+        record_fact("syslog.servers", hosts, log_entries)
+        source_entries = matching_blocks(/\A(?:no )?logging source-interface\b/)
+        source = effective_configured_value(/\Alogging source-interface\s+(\S+)\z/, entries: source_entries,
+          family: /\A/, fact: "syslog.source", reset: /\Ano logging source-interface(?:\s+\S+)?\z/)
+        record_fact("syslog.source", source, source_entries.last(1))
+      end
+
+      # 提取轮询权限、用户安全属性及来源限制。
+      def parse_snmp
+        snmp_entries = matching_blocks(/\Asnmp-server\b/)
         enabled = nxos? ? configured_state(/\Asnmp-server protocol enable\z/, /\Ano snmp-server protocol enable\z/) : nil
-        enabled = nxos? || snmp.any? if enabled.nil? && (@facts.complete? || snmp.any?)
-        record("snmp.enabled", enabled)
+        enabled = nxos? || snmp_entries.any? if enabled.nil? && (@fact_builder.complete? || snmp_entries.any?)
+        record_fact("snmp.enabled", enabled)
         communities = {}
         matching_blocks(/\Asnmp-server community\b/).each do |entry|
           match = /\Asnmp-server community\s+(\S+)(?:\s+(.*))?\z/.match(entry.text)
           unless match
-            unknown_snmp_access([ entry ])
+            record_unknown_snmp_access([ entry ])
             next
           end
           settings = match[2].to_s
@@ -110,20 +162,24 @@ module Baseline
           community[:write] = SNMP_ROLE_WRITE[role] if role
           acl = nxos? ? settings[/\buse-ipv4acl\s+(\S+)/, 1] : settings[/\A(?:ro|rw)\s+(\S+)\z/i, 1]
           community[:acl] = acl if acl
-          record_credential("snmp-community", "snmp", "plain", match[1], entry) unless @facts.credential_recorded?(community[:line])
+          record_credential("snmp-community", "snmp", "plain", match[1], entry) unless @fact_builder.credential_recorded?(community[:line])
         end
         versions = communities.any? ? %w[v1 v2c] : []
-        groups = snmp_groups(matching_blocks(/\Asnmp-server group\s+.+?\s+v3\b/)) do |entry|
+        unsupported_groups = matching_blocks(/\Asnmp-server group\b/).reject do |entry|
+          /\Asnmp-server group\s+\S+\s+v(?:1|2c|3)(?:\s|\z)/.match?(entry.text)
+        end
+        record_unknown_snmp_access(unsupported_groups, code: :unsupported_snmp_group) unless unsupported_groups.empty?
+        groups = configured_snmp_groups(matching_blocks(/\Asnmp-server group\s+\S+\s+v3(?:\s|\z)/)) do |entry|
           name, settings = entry.text.match(/\Asnmp-server group\s+(.+?)\s+v3(?:\s+(.*))?\z/).captures
-          write = name.include?('"') ? nil : snmp_group_write(settings.to_s)
+          write = name.include?('"') ? nil : snmp_group_write_state(settings.to_s)
           [ name, { acl: entry.text[/\baccess\s+(\S+)/, 1], line: entry.line, write: write } ]
         end
-        record("snmp.groups", groups)
+        record_fact("snmp.groups", groups)
         users = {}
         matching_blocks(/\Asnmp-server user\b/).each do |entry|
           match = /\Asnmp-server user\s+(\S+)\s+(\S+)(.*)\z/.match(entry.text)
           unless match
-            unknown_snmp_access([ entry ])
+            record_unknown_snmp_access([ entry ])
             next
           end
           if nxos? && match[2] == "use-ipv4acl"
@@ -133,11 +189,11 @@ module Baseline
           end
           settings = match[3]
           if /\bv[12]c?\b/.match?(settings)
-            unknown_snmp_access([ entry ], code: :unsupported_snmp_user)
+            record_unknown_snmp_access([ entry ], code: :unsupported_snmp_user)
             next
           end
           unless nxos? || /\bv3\b/.match?(settings)
-            unknown_snmp_access([ entry ])
+            record_unknown_snmp_access([ entry ])
             next
           end
           versions |= [ "v3" ]
@@ -145,33 +201,33 @@ module Baseline
           if nxos?
             (user[:roles] ||= []) << match[2]
             user[:roles].uniq!
-            user[:write] = Facts.write_permission(user[:roles].map { |role| SNMP_ROLE_WRITE[role] })
+            user[:write] = FactBuilder.write_permission_state(user[:roles].map { |role| SNMP_ROLE_WRITE[role] })
             next if settings.strip.empty?
           end
-          modes = { auth: snmp_secret(settings, "auth", algorithms: %w[md5 sha sha-224 sha-256 sha-384 sha-512]),
-            priv: snmp_secret(settings, "priv", algorithms: %w[des 3des aes aes-128 aes-192 aes-256], optional_algorithm: nxos?, aes_size: !nxos?) }
-          security = snmp_credentials("snmp:#{match[1]}", modes, entry, format: /\bencrypted\b/.match?(settings) ? "cipher" : "unknown")
+          modes = { auth: parse_snmp_secret(settings, "auth", algorithms: %w[md5 sha sha-224 sha-256 sha-384 sha-512]),
+            priv: parse_snmp_secret(settings, "priv", algorithms: %w[des 3des aes aes-128 aes-192 aes-256], optional_algorithm: nxos?, aes_size: !nxos?) }
+          security = record_snmp_credentials("snmp:#{match[1]}", modes, entry, format: /\bencrypted\b/.match?(settings) ? "cipher" : "unknown")
           user.merge!(security).merge!(group: match[2])
           acl = settings[/\b(?:access|use-ipv4acl)\s+(\S+)/, 1]
           user[:acl] = acl if acl
         end
         port_overrides = matching_blocks(/\A(?:no )?snmp-server (?:listen-port|udp-port|port)(?:\s|\z)/)
-        unknown_listener_port("snmp.acl", port_overrides) unless port_overrides.empty?
-        @facts.snmp(communities: communities.values, users: users.values, groups: nxos? ? nil : groups,
+        record_unknown_listener_port("snmp.acl", port_overrides) unless port_overrides.empty?
+        @fact_builder.record_snmp_access(communities: communities.values, users: users.values, groups: nxos? ? nil : groups,
           port: port_overrides.empty? ? 161 : nil)
-        nxos_snmp_coverage(users, enabled: enabled) if nxos?
-        unknown("snmp.v3_auth_priv", code: :snmp_user_unresolved) if users.values.any? { |user| !user.key?(:auth) }
+        record_unverified_snmp_user_sync(users, enabled: enabled) if nxos?
+        record_unknown_fact("snmp.v3_auth_priv", code: :snmp_user_unresolved) if users.values.any? { |user| !user.key?(:auth) }
         versions |= configured_values(/\Asnmp-server group\s+\S+\s+(v1|v2c|v3)\b/)
         legacy_groups = matching_blocks(/\Asnmp-server group\s+\S+\s+v(?:1|2c)\b/)
         if legacy_groups.any?
-          @facts.unknown_snmp_permission(lines: legacy_groups.map(&:line), code: :unsupported_snmp_group)
-          unknown("snmp.acl", legacy_groups, code: :unsupported_snmp_group)
+          @fact_builder.record_unknown_snmp_permission(lines: legacy_groups.map(&:line), code: :unsupported_snmp_group)
+          record_unknown_fact("snmp.acl", legacy_groups, code: :unsupported_snmp_group)
         end
-        record("snmp.versions", versions) unless versions.empty?
+        record_fact("snmp.versions", versions) unless versions.empty?
       end
 
       # NX-OS 通常会同步 CLI 与 SNMP 账号；缺少证据时不能构造虚拟用户。
-      def nxos_snmp_coverage(users, enabled:)
+      def record_unverified_snmp_user_sync(users, enabled:)
         return if enabled == false
         sync_disabled = configured_state(/\Asnmp-server disable snmp-aaa sync\z/, /\Ano snmp-server disable snmp-aaa sync\z/)
         return if sync_disabled == true
@@ -181,12 +237,12 @@ module Baseline
           covered = users[name]&.fetch(:roles, []) || []
           next if roles.any? && (roles - covered).empty?
 
-          @facts.unknown_snmp_permission(lines: entries.map(&:line), code: :snmp_user_sync_unconfirmed)
+          @fact_builder.record_unknown_snmp_permission(lines: entries.map(&:line), code: :snmp_user_sync_unconfirmed)
         end
       end
 
       # IOS 默认不授予写视图；不熟悉的组配置项不能证明只读权限。
-      def snmp_group_write(settings)
+      def snmp_group_write_state(settings)
         syntax = /\A(?:auth|noauth|priv)(?:\s+(?:read|(?<write>write)|notify|context)\s+[^\s"]+|\s+match\s+(?:exact|prefix)|\s+access(?:\s+ipv6)?\s+[^\s"]+)*\z/
         match = syntax.match(settings)
         return unless match
@@ -195,25 +251,32 @@ module Baseline
       end
 
       # 解析实际生效的认证方法及外部服务器引用。
-      def authentication
+      def parse_authentication
         servers, aliases, keyed = [], {}, []
         global_key = matching_blocks(/\Atacacs-server key\s+/)
-        global_key.each { |entry| parse_key("tacacs", entry.text.sub(/\Atacacs-server key\s+/, ""), entry) }
-        matching_blocks(/\Atacacs-server host\s+/).each do |entry|
-          host = entry.text.split[2]
-          servers << host
+        global_key.each { |entry| record_tacacs_key("tacacs", entry.text.sub(/\Atacacs-server key\s+/, ""), entry) }
+        legacy_hosts = matching_blocks(/\A(?:no )?tacacs-server host(?:\s|\z)/)
+        hosts = configured_server_addresses("tacacs", /\Atacacs-server host\s+(\S+)/, legacy_hosts, negate: "no")
+        servers |= hosts
+        active_hosts = {}
+        legacy_hosts.each do |entry|
+          host = entry.text[/\A(?:no )?tacacs-server host\s+(\S+)/, 1]
+          next unless server_address?(host)
+          entry.text.start_with?("no ") ? active_hosts.delete(host) : active_hosts[host] = entry
+        end
+        active_hosts.each do |host, entry|
           key = entry.text[/\bkey\s+(.+)\z/, 1]
           if key
-            parse_key("tacacs:#{host}", key, entry)
+            record_tacacs_key("tacacs:#{host}", key, entry)
             keyed << host
           end
         end
         matching_blocks(/\Atacacs server\s+/).each do |section|
-          hosts = configured_values(/\Aaddress ipv[46]\s+(\S+)/, section.children)
+          hosts = configured_server_addresses("tacacs", /\Aaddress ipv[46]\s+(\S+)/, matching_blocks(/\A(?:no )?address ipv[46](?:\s|\z)/, section.children), negate: "no")
           aliases[section.text.split.last] = hosts
           servers |= hosts
           matching_blocks(/\Akey\s+/, section.children).each do |entry|
-            parse_key("tacacs:#{section.text.split.last}", entry.text.delete_prefix("key "), entry)
+            record_tacacs_key("tacacs:#{section.text.split.last}", entry.text.delete_prefix("key "), entry)
             keyed |= hosts
           end
         end
@@ -221,57 +284,68 @@ module Baseline
           members = configured_values(/\Aserver(?: name)?\s+(\S+)/, section.children)
           [ section.text.split.last, members.flat_map { |member| aliases.fetch(member, [ member ]) } ]
         end
-        record("tacacs.servers", servers.uniq)
-        record("tacacs.groups", groups)
-        tacacs_login(servers, groups)
-        patterns = { "authorization" => /\Aaaa authorization (?:exec|commands(?: \d+)?) default\s+(.+)\z/,
-          "accounting" => /\Aaaa accounting (?:(?:exec|commands(?: \d+)?) )?default\s+(.+)\z/ }
-        patterns.each do |kind, pattern|
-          references = configured_values(pattern).flat_map { |methods| methods.scan(/\bgroup\s+(\S+)/).flatten }
-          selected = references.flat_map { |name| name == "tacacs+" ? servers : groups.fetch(name, []) }.uniq
-          unresolved = references.any? { |name| name != "radius" && name != "tacacs+" && !groups.key?(name) } || (selected - servers).any?
-          if unresolved
-            unknown("tacacs.#{kind}", matching_blocks(pattern), code: :tacacs_group_unresolved)
-          else
-            used = selected.any?
-            record("tacacs.#{kind}", used, matching_blocks(pattern)) if @facts.complete? || used
+        record_fact("tacacs.servers", servers.uniq)
+        record_fact("tacacs.groups", groups)
+        record_tacacs_login_usage(servers, groups)
+        %w[authorization accounting].each { |kind| record_tacacs_action_usage(kind, servers, groups) }
+        record_fact("tacacs.keys_present", global_key.any? || (servers - keyed).empty?) unless servers.empty?
+        parse_local_accounts
+      end
+
+      # 授权和计费按动作及命令级别分别覆盖，只有全部最终声明都首选 TACACS 才确认使用。
+      def record_tacacs_action_usage(kind, servers, groups)
+        pattern = /\A(?:no )?aaa #{kind} (?:(exec|commands(?: \d+)?) )?default(?:\s|\z)/
+        entries = matching_blocks(pattern).group_by { |entry| entry.text[pattern, 1] }.values.map(&:last)
+        results = entries.map do |entry|
+          match = /\Aaaa #{kind} (?:(?:exec|commands(?: \d+)?) )?default\s+(.+)\z/.match(entry.text)
+          next :unsupported_authentication_method unless match
+
+          methods = match[1]
+          if kind == "accounting"
+            next analyze(entry) { false } if methods == "none"
+            methods = methods.sub(/\A(?:start-stop|stop-only)\s+/, "")
           end
+          analyze(entry) { tacacs_login_method_state(methods, servers, groups) }
+        end
+        if (reason = results.find { |value| value.is_a?(Symbol) })
+          record_unknown_fact("tacacs.#{kind}", entries, code: reason)
+        else
+          used = results.any? && results.all?(true)
+          record_fact("tacacs.#{kind}", used, entries) if @fact_builder.complete? || used
         end
-        record("tacacs.keys_present", global_key.any? || (servers - keyed).empty?) unless servers.empty?
-        accounts
       end
 
       # 解析各 VTY 实际选用的登录列表，包括命名列表。
-      def tacacs_login(servers, groups)
+      def record_tacacs_login_usage(servers, groups)
         pattern = /\Aaaa authentication login\s+(\S+)\s+(.+)\z/
         lists = matching_blocks(pattern).each_with_object({}) do |entry, result|
           name, methods = analyze(entry) { entry.text.match(pattern).captures }
           result[name] = { methods: methods, entry: entry }
         end
-        entries = @facts.vtys.filter_map { |vty| lists[vty[:authentication_list]]&.fetch(:entry) }.uniq
-        results = @facts.vtys.map do |vty|
+        entries = @fact_builder.vtys.filter_map { |vty| lists[vty[:authentication_list]]&.fetch(:entry) }.uniq
+        results = @fact_builder.vtys.map do |vty|
           if vty[:authentication].nil?
             :vty_authentication_unknown
           elsif vty[:authentication] != "aaa"
             false
           elsif (list = lists[vty[:authentication_list]])
-            tacacs_login_method(list[:methods], servers, groups)
+            tacacs_login_method_state(list[:methods], servers, groups)
           else
             :authentication_list_unresolved
           end
         end
         results << :vty_authentication_unknown if results.empty?
         if results.include?(false)
-          record("tacacs.login", false, entries) if @facts.complete?
+          record_fact("tacacs.login", false, entries) if @fact_builder.complete?
         elsif (reason = results.find { |value| value.is_a?(Symbol) })
-          unknown("tacacs.login", entries, code: reason)
+          record_unknown_fact("tacacs.login", entries, code: reason)
         else
-          record("tacacs.login", true, entries)
+          record_fact("tacacs.login", true, entries)
         end
       end
 
       # 仅当首选认证方法引用可解析的 TACACS 组时，才确认使用 TACACS。
-      def tacacs_login_method(methods, servers, groups)
+      def tacacs_login_method_state(methods, servers, groups)
         tokens = methods.split
         outcomes = []
         until tokens.empty?
@@ -296,13 +370,13 @@ module Baseline
       end
 
       # 提取已配置的凭据编码方式，不保留秘密值。
-      def parse_key(owner, text, entry)
+      def record_tacacs_key(owner, text, entry)
         match = /\A(?:(\d+)\s+)?(\S+)/.match(text)
         record_credential(owner, "tacacs", match&.[](1) || "plain", match&.[](2), entry)
       end
 
       # 提取本地账号角色及凭据存储属性。
-      def accounts
+      def parse_local_accounts
         matching_blocks(/\Ausername\s+/).group_by { |entry| entry.text.split[1] }.each do |name, entries|
           passwords = entries.filter_map do |entry|
             match = /\b(?:password|secret)\s+(?:(\d+)\s+)?(\S+)/.match(entry.text)