photon-skills 3.0.5.dev94__tar.gz → 3.0.5.dev99__tar.gz

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
Files changed (388) hide show
  1. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/PKG-INFO +1 -1
  2. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/figure.md +1 -0
  3. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/literature-search.md +2 -1
  4. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/paper-writing.md +43 -0
  5. photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99/docs/design/paper-orchestra-borrowing.md +215 -0
  6. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/pyproject.toml +1 -1
  7. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-citation/references/registry_contract.md +18 -0
  8. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-figure/SKILL.md +2 -1
  9. photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99/skills-academic/photon-figure/references/figure_contract.md +26 -0
  10. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-literature-search/SKILL.md +6 -1
  11. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/SKILL.md +1 -1
  12. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/references/claim_argument_plan.md +11 -1
  13. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/extensions/academic-skills.zip +0 -0
  14. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/plugin.yaml +1 -1
  15. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/.github/workflows/plugin-contract.yml +0 -0
  16. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/.github/workflows/publish.yml +0 -0
  17. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/.gitignore +0 -0
  18. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/AGENTS.md +0 -0
  19. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/CHANGELOG.md +0 -0
  20. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/CONTRIBUTING.md +0 -0
  21. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/LICENSE +0 -0
  22. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/README.en.md +0 -0
  23. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/README.md +0 -0
  24. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/SECURITY.md +0 -0
  25. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/_shared/README.md +0 -0
  26. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/_shared/__init__.py +0 -0
  27. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/_shared/__main__.py +0 -0
  28. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/_shared/decision_contract.py +0 -0
  29. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/_shared/evidence_contract.py +0 -0
  30. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/_shared/findings_schema.py +0 -0
  31. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/_shared/gate_runner.py +0 -0
  32. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/_shared/semantic_sim.py +0 -0
  33. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/_shared/status_contract.py +0 -0
  34. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/_shared/visual_qa.py +0 -0
  35. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/candidates/a1-slit-128.png +0 -0
  36. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/candidates/a1-slit-16x8.png +0 -0
  37. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/candidates/a1-slit.svg +0 -0
  38. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/candidates/a3-vertical-128.png +0 -0
  39. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/candidates/a3-vertical-16x8.png +0 -0
  40. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/candidates/a3-vertical.svg +0 -0
  41. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/candidates/b1-diagonal-128.png +0 -0
  42. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/candidates/b1-diagonal-16x8.png +0 -0
  43. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/candidates/b1-diagonal.svg +0 -0
  44. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/lockup.html +0 -0
  45. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/logo-exploration-v2.html +0 -0
  46. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/logo-exploration.html +0 -0
  47. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/logo-shortlist.html +0 -0
  48. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/make_flow.py +0 -0
  49. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/make_mark.py +0 -0
  50. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/marker-strike.svg +0 -0
  51. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/brand/src/social.html +0 -0
  52. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/favicon-16.png +0 -0
  53. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/favicon-32.png +0 -0
  54. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/favicon-64.png +0 -0
  55. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/logo-lockup-dark.png +0 -0
  56. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/logo-lockup-light.png +0 -0
  57. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/logo.png +0 -0
  58. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/photon-app-icon-inv.svg +0 -0
  59. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/photon-app-icon-small.svg +0 -0
  60. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/photon-app-icon.svg +0 -0
  61. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/photon-flow.svg +0 -0
  62. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/photon-mark-small.svg +0 -0
  63. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/photon-mark-tile-inv.svg +0 -0
  64. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/photon-mark-tile.svg +0 -0
  65. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/photon-mark.svg +0 -0
  66. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/social-preview.png +0 -0
  67. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/wechat-donation.jpg +0 -0
  68. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/assets/wechat-official-account.jpg +0 -0
  69. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/compatibility/agent-client-compatibility.md +0 -0
  70. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/_shared.md +0 -0
  71. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/citation.md +0 -0
  72. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/consistency.md +0 -0
  73. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/data-engineering.md +0 -0
  74. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/experiment-coding.md +0 -0
  75. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/file-reading.md +0 -0
  76. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/frontend-design.md +0 -0
  77. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/idea-critique.md +0 -0
  78. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/idea-generation.md +0 -0
  79. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/memory-pm.md +0 -0
  80. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/orchestrator.md +0 -0
  81. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/patent-disclosure.md +0 -0
  82. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/project-structure.md +0 -0
  83. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/research-ethics.md +0 -0
  84. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/research-plan.md +0 -0
  85. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/result-analysis.md +0 -0
  86. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/review-rebuttal.md +0 -0
  87. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/software-copyright.md +0 -0
  88. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/system-design.md +0 -0
  89. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/typesetting.md +0 -0
  90. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/competitors/venue-matching.md +0 -0
  91. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/design/consistency-round2-e2e.md +0 -0
  92. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/design/debate-coach.md +0 -0
  93. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/design/git-persistence.md +0 -0
  94. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/design/legacy-parity.md +0 -0
  95. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/design/orchestrator-spec.md +0 -0
  96. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/design/plugin-distribution.md +0 -0
  97. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/design/safety-privacy.md +0 -0
  98. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/design/self-repair.md +0 -0
  99. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/design/student-skill-audit.md +0 -0
  100. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/citation-round2.md +0 -0
  101. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/data-engineering-round2.md +0 -0
  102. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/experiment-coding-round2.md +0 -0
  103. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/ip-extension-gate.md +0 -0
  104. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/orchestrator-round2.md +0 -0
  105. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/paper-writing-round2.md +0 -0
  106. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/project-structure-round2.md +0 -0
  107. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/research-ethics-round2.md +0 -0
  108. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/research-plan-round2.md +0 -0
  109. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/result-analysis-round2.md +0 -0
  110. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/review-rebuttal-round2.md +0 -0
  111. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/round3-release-gate.md +0 -0
  112. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/system-design-round2.md +0 -0
  113. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/typesetting-round2.md +0 -0
  114. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/e2e/venue-matching-round2.md +0 -0
  115. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/learning/ip/ip-upgrade-synthesis.md +0 -0
  116. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/learning/ip/patent-deep-read-report.md +0 -0
  117. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/learning/ip/software-copyright-deep-read-report.md +0 -0
  118. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/legacy-multi-client.md +0 -0
  119. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/docs/releases/v1.0.0.md +0 -0
  120. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/demo-student-project/.gitignore +0 -0
  121. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/demo-student-project/.photon-project +0 -0
  122. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/demo-student-project/decisions.md +0 -0
  123. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/demo-student-project/mentor-feedback/2026-08-01.md +0 -0
  124. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/demo-student-project/mentor-feedback/README.md +0 -0
  125. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/demo-student-project/project-card.md +0 -0
  126. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/demo-student-project/session-log/2026-07-28.md +0 -0
  127. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/demo-student-project/session-log/2026-07-30.md +0 -0
  128. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/demo-student-project/session-log/2026-08-01.md +0 -0
  129. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/demo-student-project/source-log.md +0 -0
  130. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/demo-student-project/task-log.md +0 -0
  131. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/README.md +0 -0
  132. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/artifacts/photon_e2e_case.md +0 -0
  133. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/data/synthetic_experiment.csv +0 -0
  134. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/figures/panels/panel_a_design_frontier.png +0 -0
  135. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/figures/panels/panel_b_signal_screen.png +0 -0
  136. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/figures/panels/panel_c_calibration.png +0 -0
  137. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/figures/panels/panel_d_evidence_strength.png +0 -0
  138. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/figures/panels/panel_e_failure_map.png +0 -0
  139. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/figures/panels/panel_f_quality_trajectory.png +0 -0
  140. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/figures/panels/panel_g_distribution_shift.png +0 -0
  141. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/figures/panels/panel_h_tradeoff_curve.png +0 -0
  142. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/figures/panels/panel_i_risk_budget.png +0 -0
  143. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/figures/research_figure_gallery.png +0 -0
  144. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/scripts/compose_figure_gallery.py +0 -0
  145. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/scripts/generate_synthetic_data.py +0 -0
  146. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/scripts/python_gallery_panels.py +0 -0
  147. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/scripts/r_gallery_panels.R +0 -0
  148. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/examples/e2e-research-demo/scripts/run_demo.py +0 -0
  149. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/README.md +0 -0
  150. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/data/fitted_rate_constants.csv +0 -0
  151. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/data/synthetic_design_table.csv +0 -0
  152. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/data/synthetic_uvvis_timeseries.csv +0 -0
  153. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/figures/figure1_kinetics.png +0 -0
  154. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/figures/figure2_response_surface.png +0 -0
  155. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/figures/figure3_diagnostics.png +0 -0
  156. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/figures/figure4_scavenger_effects.png +0 -0
  157. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/outputs/analysis_summary.json +0 -0
  158. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/outputs/scavenger_summary.csv +0 -0
  159. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/paper/main-preview.png +0 -0
  160. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/paper/main.md +0 -0
  161. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/paper/main.pdf +0 -0
  162. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/paper/main.tex +0 -0
  163. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/scripts/analyze.py +0 -0
  164. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/scripts/build_paper.py +0 -0
  165. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/scripts/generate_data.py +0 -0
  166. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/scripts/make_figures.py +0 -0
  167. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/scripts/render_preview.py +0 -0
  168. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/projects/photocatalytic-dye-kinetics-study/scripts/run_all.py +0 -0
  169. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/scripts/check_plugin_contract.py +0 -0
  170. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/scripts/release.py +0 -0
  171. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/README.md +0 -0
  172. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-citation/SKILL.md +0 -0
  173. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-citation/citation-resource-map.md +0 -0
  174. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-citation/references/locator_audit.md +0 -0
  175. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-citation/references.md +0 -0
  176. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-citation/templates/citation-four-gate.example.json +0 -0
  177. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-citation/templates/citation_input.json +0 -0
  178. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-citation/templates/claim_citation_review.json +0 -0
  179. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-consistency/SKILL.md +0 -0
  180. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-consistency/examples/fact-bindings.example.json +0 -0
  181. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-consistency/examples/materials_paper.txt +0 -0
  182. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-consistency/examples/materials_ppt.txt +0 -0
  183. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-consistency/references/consistency-resource-map.md +0 -0
  184. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-data-engineering/SKILL.md +0 -0
  185. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-data-engineering/examples/derive_spec.example.json +0 -0
  186. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-data-engineering/examples/rules.example.yaml +0 -0
  187. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-data-engineering/examples/worked_example.md +0 -0
  188. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-data-engineering/references/data-resource-map.md +0 -0
  189. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-data-engineering/references.md +0 -0
  190. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-data-engineering/templates/annotation_guide.md +0 -0
  191. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-data-engineering/templates/data-identity-fitness.example.json +0 -0
  192. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-experiment-coding/SKILL.md +0 -0
  193. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-experiment-coding/references/code_examples.md +0 -0
  194. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-experiment-coding/references/debug_protocol.md +0 -0
  195. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-experiment-coding/references/experiment-coding-resource-map.md +0 -0
  196. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-experiment-coding/references/tdd_redflags.md +0 -0
  197. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-experiment-coding/references/tools.md +0 -0
  198. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-experiment-coding/templates/experiment-execution-contract.example.json +0 -0
  199. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-experiment-coding/templates/run_manifest.md +0 -0
  200. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-experiment-coding/templates/run_manifest.template.json +0 -0
  201. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-figure/examples/bad_figure_example.py +0 -0
  202. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-figure/examples/example_framework.dot +0 -0
  203. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-figure/examples/example_framework_render.py +0 -0
  204. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-figure/examples/example_matplotlib_multipanel.py +0 -0
  205. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-figure/examples/example_seaborn_stats.py +0 -0
  206. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-figure/examples/worked_example.md +0 -0
  207. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-figure/references/figure_integrity.md +0 -0
  208. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-figure/templates/figure-delivery.example.json +0 -0
  209. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-figure/templates/figure_plan_card.md +0 -0
  210. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-figure/templates/table_plan_card.md +0 -0
  211. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-file-reading/SKILL.md +0 -0
  212. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-file-reading/references/DOCX-REF.md +0 -0
  213. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-file-reading/references/IMG-REF.md +0 -0
  214. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-file-reading/references/PDF-REF.md +0 -0
  215. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-file-reading/references/PPTX-REF.md +0 -0
  216. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-file-reading/references/XLSX-REF.md +0 -0
  217. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-file-reading/references/reading-resource-map.md +0 -0
  218. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-file-reading/references/tools.md +0 -0
  219. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-frontend-design/SKILL.md +0 -0
  220. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-frontend-design/references/design-systems-map.md +0 -0
  221. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-frontend-design/references/ecosystem-2026.md +0 -0
  222. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-frontend-design/references/fonts-and-colors.md +0 -0
  223. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-frontend-design/references/redesign-audit.md +0 -0
  224. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-frontend-design/references/resource-map.md +0 -0
  225. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-frontend-design/references/visual-a11y-rules.md +0 -0
  226. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-frontend-design/references.md +0 -0
  227. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-frontend-design/templates/frontend-delivery.example.json +0 -0
  228. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-critique/SKILL.md +0 -0
  229. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-critique/critique-resource-map.md +0 -0
  230. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-critique/examples/worked_example_dermoscopy.md +0 -0
  231. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-critique/references/contract.md +0 -0
  232. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-critique/references/protocol.md +0 -0
  233. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-critique/references/rubric.md +0 -0
  234. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-critique/references.md +0 -0
  235. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-critique/templates/Revision_Roadmap.md +0 -0
  236. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-critique/templates/novelty-evidence.example.json +0 -0
  237. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-critique/templates/verdict_template.md +0 -0
  238. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-generation/.gitignore +0 -0
  239. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-generation/SKILL.md +0 -0
  240. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-generation/examples/candidates.example.json +0 -0
  241. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-generation/examples/idea_candidates.example.md +0 -0
  242. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-generation/idea-resource-map.md +0 -0
  243. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-generation/references.md +0 -0
  244. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-generation/templates/idea-gap-evidence.example.json +0 -0
  245. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-generation/templates/idea-genealogy.example.json +0 -0
  246. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-generation/templates/idea_card.md +0 -0
  247. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-idea-generation/templates/innovation-engine.example.json +0 -0
  248. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-literature-search/examples/goat_littable.md +0 -0
  249. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-literature-search/examples/goat_search.json +0 -0
  250. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-literature-search/examples/worked_example_dairy_goat.md +0 -0
  251. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-literature-search/references.md +0 -0
  252. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-literature-search/search-resource-map.md +0 -0
  253. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-literature-search/templates/search-protocol.example.json +0 -0
  254. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-memory-pm/SKILL.md +0 -0
  255. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-memory-pm/references/cross_harness_resume.md +0 -0
  256. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-memory-pm/references/session_handoff.md +0 -0
  257. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/examples/claim_evidence_walkthrough.md +0 -0
  258. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/paper-writing-resource-map.md +0 -0
  259. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/references/argument_review.md +0 -0
  260. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/references/guideline_map.md +0 -0
  261. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/references/integrity_gate.md +0 -0
  262. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/references/mandatory_inclusions.md +0 -0
  263. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/references/self_review_checklist.md +0 -0
  264. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/templates/01_imrad.md +0 -0
  265. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/templates/06_conference.md +0 -0
  266. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/templates/argument-outline.example.json +0 -0
  267. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/templates/claim_argument_plan.json +0 -0
  268. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/templates/claim_passport.md +0 -0
  269. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-patent-disclosure/SKILL.md +0 -0
  270. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-patent-disclosure/references/patent-interview-and-search.md +0 -0
  271. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-patent-disclosure/references/patent-resource-map.md +0 -0
  272. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-patent-disclosure/templates/patent-disclosure-packet.example.json +0 -0
  273. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-project-structure/SKILL.md +0 -0
  274. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-project-structure/references/project-lifecycle-resource-map.md +0 -0
  275. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-project-structure/references/structure-profiles.json +0 -0
  276. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-project-structure/templates/project-policy.template.json +0 -0
  277. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-project-structure/templates/project-structure-governance.example.json +0 -0
  278. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-ethics/SKILL.md +0 -0
  279. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-ethics/references/cn_compliance.md +0 -0
  280. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-ethics/references/decision_trees.md +0 -0
  281. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-ethics/references/ethics-resource-map.md +0 -0
  282. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-ethics/references/retraction_flag_types.json +0 -0
  283. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-ethics/references/tortured_phrases.json +0 -0
  284. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-orchestrator/SKILL.md +0 -0
  285. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-orchestrator/references/integration-contract.json +0 -0
  286. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-orchestrator/references/orchestrator-resource-map.md +0 -0
  287. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-orchestrator/references/passport.schema.json +0 -0
  288. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-orchestrator/templates/passport.v3.yaml +0 -0
  289. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-orchestrator/templates/task-profile.example.json +0 -0
  290. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-orchestrator/templates/workflow-ledger.example.json +0 -0
  291. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-plan/SKILL.md +0 -0
  292. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-plan/examples/plan_spec.example.json +0 -0
  293. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-plan/references/research-plan-resource-map.md +0 -0
  294. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-plan/references.md +0 -0
  295. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-plan/templates/experiment_matrix.md +0 -0
  296. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-plan/templates/failure-tree.example.json +0 -0
  297. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-plan/templates/plan_package.manifest.example.json +0 -0
  298. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-plan/templates/preregistration.md +0 -0
  299. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-plan/templates/reproducibility-checklist.md +0 -0
  300. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-plan/templates/reproduction-log.md +0 -0
  301. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-plan/templates/research-plan.md +0 -0
  302. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-research-plan/templates/target-chain.example.json +0 -0
  303. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-result-analysis/SKILL.md +0 -0
  304. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-result-analysis/examples/analysis_audit.example.json +0 -0
  305. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-result-analysis/examples/method_compatibility.example.json +0 -0
  306. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-result-analysis/examples/stat_spec.example.json +0 -0
  307. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-result-analysis/examples/worked_example.py +0 -0
  308. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-result-analysis/references.md +0 -0
  309. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-result-analysis/result-analysis-resource-map.md +0 -0
  310. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-result-analysis/scripts/r_analysis_crosscheck.R +0 -0
  311. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-result-analysis/templates/result-card.example.json +0 -0
  312. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-review-rebuttal/SKILL.md +0 -0
  313. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-review-rebuttal/agents/openai.yaml +0 -0
  314. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-review-rebuttal/references/workflow_contract.md +0 -0
  315. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-review-rebuttal/references.md +0 -0
  316. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-review-rebuttal/review-rebuttal-resource-map.md +0 -0
  317. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-review-rebuttal/templates/commitment_ledger.json +0 -0
  318. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-review-rebuttal/templates/experiment_request.example.json +0 -0
  319. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-review-rebuttal/templates/rereview_checklist.md +0 -0
  320. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-review-rebuttal/templates/response_letter_template.md +0 -0
  321. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-review-rebuttal/templates/response_matrix.md +0 -0
  322. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-review-rebuttal/templates/review-response-contract.example.json +0 -0
  323. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-review-rebuttal/templates/review_input.json +0 -0
  324. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-software-copyright/SKILL.md +0 -0
  325. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-software-copyright/references/materials-workflow.md +0 -0
  326. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-software-copyright/references/software-copyright-resource-map.md +0 -0
  327. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-software-copyright/templates/software-copyright-materials.example.json +0 -0
  328. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-system-design/SKILL.md +0 -0
  329. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-system-design/references/system-design-resource-map.md +0 -0
  330. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-system-design/references.md +0 -0
  331. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-system-design/templates/architecture-package.template.md +0 -0
  332. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-system-design/templates/decision-authorization.template.json +0 -0
  333. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-system-design/templates/design-readiness.example.json +0 -0
  334. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-system-design/templates/migration_expand_contract.sql +0 -0
  335. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-system-design/templates/openapi.yaml +0 -0
  336. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-system-design/templates/rls_policy.sql +0 -0
  337. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-system-design/templates/schema.sql +0 -0
  338. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-system-design/templates/system-intake.template.json +0 -0
  339. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-typesetting/SKILL.md +0 -0
  340. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-typesetting/references/build_contract.md +0 -0
  341. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-typesetting/references/latex_errors.md +0 -0
  342. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-typesetting/references.md +0 -0
  343. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-typesetting/templates/acm_sigconf.tex +0 -0
  344. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-typesetting/templates/ctex_chinese.tex +0 -0
  345. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-typesetting/templates/elsevier_elsarticle.tex +0 -0
  346. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-typesetting/templates/ieee_bare_conf.tex +0 -0
  347. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-typesetting/templates/springer_llncs.tex +0 -0
  348. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-typesetting/templates/submission-readiness.example.json +0 -0
  349. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-typesetting/templates/typesetting_input.json +0 -0
  350. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-typesetting/typesetting-resource-map.md +0 -0
  351. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-venue-matching/SKILL.md +0 -0
  352. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-venue-matching/references/workflow_contract.md +0 -0
  353. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-venue-matching/references.md +0 -0
  354. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-venue-matching/templates/query-privacy.example.json +0 -0
  355. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-venue-matching/templates/user_selection.json +0 -0
  356. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-venue-matching/templates/venue-evidence.example.json +0 -0
  357. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-venue-matching/templates/venue_compare_table.md +0 -0
  358. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-venue-matching/templates/venue_input.json +0 -0
  359. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/skills-academic/photon-venue-matching/venue-resource-map.md +0 -0
  360. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/SOUL.md +0 -0
  361. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/__init__.py +0 -0
  362. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/_base.py +0 -0
  363. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/health.py +0 -0
  364. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-brainstorm/SKILL.md +0 -0
  365. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-debate-coach/SKILL.md +0 -0
  366. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-debate-coach/references/format-presets.md +0 -0
  367. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-debate-coach/templates/case-map.md +0 -0
  368. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-debate-coach/templates/evidence-sheet.md +0 -0
  369. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-debate-coach/templates/format.md +0 -0
  370. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-debate-coach/templates/motion-brief.md +0 -0
  371. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-debate-coach/templates/outline.md +0 -0
  372. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-debate-coach/templates/post-match.md +0 -0
  373. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-debate-coach/templates/rebuttal-cards.md +0 -0
  374. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-method-planner/SKILL.md +0 -0
  375. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-orchestrator/SKILL.md +0 -0
  376. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-pitch-coach/SKILL.md +0 -0
  377. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-pitch-coach/templates/judge-qa-prep.md +0 -0
  378. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-pitch-coach/templates/pitch-deck-outline.md +0 -0
  379. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-pitch-coach/templates/pitch-script-60s.md +0 -0
  380. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-progress-tracker/SKILL.md +0 -0
  381. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-session/SKILL.md +0 -0
  382. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skills/photon-source-filter/SKILL.md +0 -0
  383. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/skillsets.json +0 -0
  384. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/src/photon/workspace.py +0 -0
  385. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/tests/test_cli.py +0 -0
  386. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/tests/test_contract.py +0 -0
  387. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/tests/test_health.py +0 -0
  388. {photon_skills-3.0.5.dev94 → photon_skills-3.0.5.dev99}/tests/test_workspace.py +0 -0
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
1
1
  Metadata-Version: 2.5
2
2
  Name: photon-skills
3
- Version: 3.0.5.dev94
3
+ Version: 3.0.5.dev99
4
4
  Summary: Photon — STEAM research, debate, and pitch competition companion for primary/secondary students
5
5
  Author-email: Uniterra Solutions Limited <harryw07801@uniterra-solutions.com>
6
6
  License-Expression: MIT
@@ -58,6 +58,7 @@
58
58
  | **cnsplots**(faridrashidi) | Cell/Nature/Science 出版图工具,预置 CNS 风格 + 内置统计检验/显著性标注 + 像素级尺寸 | 显著性标注 + 精确栏宽印证(figure_export 同口径) | **样式+标注库**;不判措辞/图强于证据 |
59
59
  | **PlotGen**(arXiv 2502.00988, WWW'25) | 多 agent LLM 绘图:Query-Planning + Code-Gen + 三反馈 agent(Numeric/Lexical/**Visual** 多模态看图自反思),+4-6% MatPlotBench | **render-then-look 学术锚**(Visual Feedback Agent=喂渲染图回多模态精修) | **论文/agent 系统**非可调 skill;不绑证据档、不产 critical |
60
60
  | **ReLook**(arXiv 2510.11498) | 多模态 critic 渲染回看闭环:generate→截图喂 critic 打分→diagnose→refine | `_shared/visual_qa` render-then-look 的学术锚(批 0 已锚) | **论文**非 skill;通用视觉非论文诚实 |
61
+ | **PaperOrchestra**(google-research/paper-orchestra,Apache-2.0 框架,@`d9bae99`,2026-11-21 核) | 论文写作流水线里的**绘图 agent**(`methods/agents/plotting_agent.py`):outline 阶段先出 `plotting_plan`,`figure_id` 语义 id 且禁含 “Figure”、`aspect_ratio` 锁 12 值枚举、`data_source ∈ {idea, log, both}`(`methods/prompts/outline_agent.py` L36–37);生成分两路——`plot` 让 LLM 写 matplotlib 代码交 `execute_plot_code_worker` 执行(程序化),`diagram` 走 `gemini-3-pro-image-preview` **生图**;生成后最多 3 轮 critic 改描述再重生成(`plotting_agent.py` L107–160) | 取**图规划前置成枚举字段**:图型/比例/数据来源在 outline 定死,不留给写作时临时想(可被机读门检查,见 `docs/design/paper-orchestra-borrowing.md`);**不取**其 diagram 生图路径——与“论文数据图绝不 AI 生图”永久底线冲突,且出图片不出可复现代码 |
61
62
  | **matplotlib 3.10.9 / seaborn 0.13.2** | 程序化绘图引擎(viridis 自 2015 默认 cmap;seaborn 统计图) | **程序化生成底座**(铁律 6 例外:科学绘图标准件可用不重造) | **引擎**非门/技能 |
62
63
  | **Okabe-Ito**(Wong 2011 *Nat Methods*) + **viridis/cividis** | 色盲安全色板:Okabe-Ito 8 色对三类色盲可辨(离散首选);viridis 感知均匀(连续首选),灰度可印 | **色盲安全硬锚**(color_palettes 港运对象) | **色板规范**非技能 |
63
64
  | **Cairo《How Charts Lie》(2019)** | y 轴截断="最普遍的图表谎言";零基线规则:编码为高度/长度(柱)须零基线,位置/角度(折线)可非零 | **截 y 轴 critical 判据硬学术锚**(figure_integrity_lint 只对柱类强判) | **通俗书**非技能 |
@@ -79,6 +79,7 @@
79
79
  | **scite.ai** | SaaS | 深度学习把 12 亿+ 引用句分 **supporting/contrasting/mentioning** | 概念借 contrasting→争议/伪热点识别;**硬边界**:无全文+专有分类器,我只 count-based+提请人工 |
80
80
  | **Consensus** | SaaS | claim 级证据方向聚合(support/oppose/mixed) | 借"已成定论 vs 争议"作地图信号;不做 claim 共识表 |
81
81
  | **Idea Novelty Checker / OpenNovelty**(arXiv 2506.22026 / 2601.01576) | 论文 | **facet 分解**(application-domain/purpose/mechanism/evaluation);检索→SPECTER2 top-100→RankGPT facet 重排→**≥1 核心 facet 不同即 novel** | **撞车 findings producer**:`semantic_sim` 找最像前作 + facet 槽位 delta;**novel 判决不自做**(归 idea-critique) |
82
+ | **PaperOrchestra**(google-research/paper-orchestra,Apache-2.0 框架,5,402★ @2026-11-21) | 学术系统(多 agent 流水线) | outline→lit→section→refine 四段无人值守(`methods/paper_writer.py` L92/L106/L135/L153);检索用 Gemini **Google Search grounding** + Semantic Scholar 标题富化(`methods/agents/literature_review_agent.py` L29/L87/L338),`cutoff_date` 硬截断;出稿靠 LaTeX 模板 + `guidelines.md` 页数预算 | 借**检索配额分层**:Intro 宏观 10–20 篇 / Related Work 微观 30–50 篇(`methods/prompts/outline_agent.py` L43/L47/L53)可落成 `search-protocol` 的 tier + 目标量字段,治“两节抢同一批文献”;**不借**其 key 依赖联网取数与 LLM judge。详见 `paper-writing.md` Round 3 补验 |
82
83
 
83
84
  ---
84
85
 
@@ -142,5 +143,5 @@
142
143
 
143
144
  - 真·同类 skill(star 当天核):[imbad0202/academic-research-skills](https://github.com/imbad0202/academic-research-skills)(`deep-research/SKILL.md`+`examples/idea_diversity_coverage_gap_advisory.md`) · [K-Dense-AI/scientific-agent-skills](https://github.com/K-Dense-AI/scientific-agent-skills)(`skills/literature-review/`) · [davila7/claude-code-templates](https://github.com/davila7/claude-code-templates)(`components/agents/deep-research-team/`) · [wanshuiyin/ARIS](https://github.com/wanshuiyin/auto-claude-code-research-in-sleep)(`skills/idea-discovery/SKILL.md`) · [alirezarezvani/claude-skills](https://github.com/alirezarezvani/claude-skills) · [Galaxy-Dawn/claude-scholar](https://github.com/Galaxy-Dawn/claude-scholar) · [Weizhena/Deep-Research-skills](https://github.com/Weizhena/Deep-Research-skills) · [borghei/Claude-Skills](https://github.com/borghei/Claude-Skills) · [Aperivue/medsci-skills](https://github.com/Aperivue/medsci-skills) · [lingzhi227/agent-research-skills](https://github.com/lingzhi227/agent-research-skills) · [ykdojo/paper-search](https://github.com/ykdojo/paper-search) · [yy/claude-scholar](https://github.com/yy/claude-scholar) · [shiquda/openalex-skill](https://github.com/shiquda/openalex-skill)
144
145
  - 目录/技能包(发现源):[ComposioHQ/awesome-claude-skills](https://github.com/ComposioHQ/awesome-claude-skills)(65,996★) · [travisvn/awesome-claude-skills](https://github.com/travisvn/awesome-claude-skills) · [rohitg00/awesome-claude-code-toolkit](https://github.com/rohitg00/awesome-claude-code-toolkit)
145
- - 机制锚:undermind.ai [Aaron Tay 2024-04](http://musingsaboutlibrarianship.blogspot.com/2024/04/undermindai-different-type-of-ai-agent.html) · PaperQA2 [FutureHouse](https://github.com/future-house/paper-qa) · OpenScholar [arXiv 2411.14199](https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.14199) · STORM [arXiv 2402.14207](https://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14207) · Elicit [systematic-review](https://elicit.com/solutions/systematic-review) · Connected Papers [LMU LibGuide](https://libguides.lmu.edu/AIresearchtools/CP) · scite vs Consensus [paperguide](https://paperguide.ai/blog/consensus-vs-scite/) · 撞车 facet 法 [arXiv 2506.22026](https://arxiv.org/html/2506.22026v1) · [OpenNovelty 2601.01576](https://arxiv.org/pdf/2601.01576)
146
+ - 机制锚:undermind.ai [Aaron Tay 2024-04](http://musingsaboutlibrarianship.blogspot.com/2024/04/undermindai-different-type-of-ai-agent.html) · PaperQA2 [FutureHouse](https://github.com/future-house/paper-qa) · OpenScholar [arXiv 2411.14199](https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.14199) · STORM [arXiv 2402.14207](https://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14207) · Elicit [systematic-review](https://elicit.com/solutions/systematic-review) · Connected Papers [LMU LibGuide](https://libguides.lmu.edu/AIresearchtools/CP) · scite vs Consensus [paperguide](https://paperguide.ai/blog/consensus-vs-scite/) · 撞车 facet 法 [arXiv 2506.22026](https://arxiv.org/html/2506.22026v1) · [OpenNovelty 2601.01576](https://arxiv.org/pdf/2601.01576) · PaperOrchestra [google-research/paper-orchestra](https://github.com/google-research/paper-orchestra)(@`d9bae99`,2026-11-21 核)
146
147
  - 数据源端点真相源:port 自 v1 `references.md`(OpenAlex/Crossref/arXiv/S2/Europe PMC/DOAJ/bioRxiv,2026-06 逐条 curl 核;arXiv 须 https、DOAJ 403、OpenAlex 匿名+mailto 仍 200)
@@ -116,6 +116,49 @@
116
116
  这直接修复旧实现的 critical 漏报:claim A 的 strong evidence 不再能放过 claim B 的无证据 SOTA/因果/显著提升断言;result-analysis
117
117
  的 guardrail/counter-metric `claim_impact` 也不能在写论文时丢掉。
118
118
 
119
+ ## Round 3 补验(2026-11-21)· google-research/paper-orchestra(相邻框架,非 skill,不占 §0.A 名额)
120
+
121
+ > 核验日:2026-11-21。Star **5,402(整仓,2026-11-21 核验时 API 值)**;commit `d9bae997e793a015ed38bb1605be9eb58c00284f`(2026-11-15);**Apache-2.0**。读的是真实代码:`paper_writing_cli.py`、`methods/paper_writer.py`、`methods/prompts/*.py`、`methods/agents/*.py`、`autoraters/*.py`、`requirements.txt`。它没有 `SKILL.md`,是框架不是 skill,所以不占 0.A 的 8 个名额;记在这里是因为它与 paper-writing 的“整条写作流水线”正面重叠。
122
+
123
+ ### 它真做什么
124
+
125
+ - README L6 自述:把 idea + experimental log 这类 pre-writing materials 转成 **submission-ready LaTeX manuscript**;L19 主打 LaTeX Automation;L23 要 conda py3.11;**L50 明说论文数据集不随仓库发布**(“will be released separately”)。
126
+ - 四段编排(`methods/paper_writer.py`):L92 Step 1 OutlineAgent → L106 Step 2 HybridLiteratureAgent → L135 Step 3 SectionWritingAgent → L153 Step 4 ContentRefinementAgent;`--use_plotting` 走 `paper_writer_with_plotting.py`(多一个绘图 agent)。CLI 单篇跑,`--raw_materials_dir` 与 `--latex_template_dir` 均 required(`paper_writing_cli.py` L29/L39),模板目录必须自带 `template.tex` + `guidelines.md`(`paper_writer.py` L70–71 取路径,L78–89 缺一即 assert)。
127
+ - 检索不是纯记忆:`methods/agents/literature_review_agent.py` L29 import `s2_title_search`、L87/L468 用 Gemini **Google Search grounding**(`types.GoogleSearch()`)、L338 再用 Semantic Scholar 富化候选标题,全程 `cutoff_date` 截断。
128
+ - 评审是 **LLM judge,不是确定性门**:`autoraters/agent_review.py` L23–33 把 10/8/6/5/3/1 分档写成“top 2% / top 10% / …”rubric;`autoraters/sxs_paper_quality.py` L35/L49 把 PDF 逐页转图做成对 SxS;`autoraters/citation_f1.py` L170–198 先用 LLM 给参考文献分 **P0/P1 优先级**,L262–330 才算 overall/P0/P1 的 precision/recall/F1(要 Semantic Scholar key)。
129
+
130
+ ### 五个可借机制(已对位到本仓库结构)
131
+
132
+ 1. **Intro / Related Work 的检索配额分层**:`methods/prompts/outline_agent.py` L43 写死 “Prevent Citation Overlap”,L47 Introduction 宏观 10–20 篇,L53 Related Work 微观 30–50 篇。它把“两节抢同一批文献”当显式失败模式,并给下游检索 agent 写检索方向,而不是让作者边写边找。→ 对位 `photon-literature-search/templates/search-protocol.example.json`:可加 `tier`(macro/micro)与目标量字段,把配额写进协议而非提示词。
133
+ 2. **`citation_hints` 的“单一 canonical paper + 穷尽覆盖”**(同文件 L70–71):数据集、优化器、指标、基座模型都要有一条 hint,且每条必须指向唯一一篇原始论文。这把引用台账从散文变成可核查条目。→ 对位 `photon-citation` 的 registry 与四 gate;hint 天然对应“必引 P0 / 可引 P1”,与 `citation_f1.py` 的分层口径同源。
134
+ 3. **图规划的枚举契约**(同文件 L36–37):`figure_id` 必须是语义 id 且不得含 “Figure”;`aspect_ratio` 锁在 12 个枚举值;`data_source` 只能是 idea / log / both。→ 对位 `photon-figure` 的 figure requirements:枚举能被机读门检查,自由文本不能。
135
+ 4. **“只改表达、不造实验”的硬边界**(`methods/prompts/content_refinement_agent.py` L44):审稿人要 log 里没有的新实验/新基线时**直接忽略**;反思轮数有界(`paper_writer.py` L167–172,`max_reflections=3`)。→ 正好是 `8→7 / 8→6` 回炉的对手参照:它选择“不写”,Light 选择“先回炉补证据再写”,两条路都比在 prose 里编造强。
136
+ 5. **写 section 的数值纪律**(`methods/prompts/section_writing_agent.py` L34 不改已填章节、L42 “Do not hallucinate numbers. Use the exact values provided in the log.”、L43 表格必须在 Conclusion 之前)。→ 与 claim→evidence 绑定同向,但它是提示词约束,不是可执行门。
137
+
138
+ ### 不迁移边界(写清,避免下次又当“可直接接”)
139
+
140
+ - **依赖与运行面**:`requirements.txt` = google-genai / openai / PyMuPDF / matplotlib / streamlit / pydantic 等;conda py3.11;要 Gemini 或 OpenAI key,检索要 Google Search grounding,citation F1 还要 Semantic Scholar key。与 Photon **零第三方依赖 + 离线 selftest** 的硬约束正面冲突(`pyproject.toml` `dependencies = []`)。
141
+ - **许可**:Apache-2.0。真抄代码进 MIT 仓库要保留 NOTICE 与版权头;本轮只借机制与字段口径,不搬文件。
142
+ - **不是门**:三个 autorater 都是 LLM 判官(rubric / SxS / 分层 F1),无 exit code、无 provenance、不可离线复验,SxS 还要把 PDF 渲成图送多模态。**不接进 `_shared/gate_runner`**,最多作设计期 eval。
143
+ - **产品方向相反**:它的目标是“从 log 直接产出可投稿稿件”,与 `photon-paper-writing` 的 `claim_evidence` critical 门、`photon-research-ethics` 的交付红线正相反。学生场景这条不能借,只能当“外部工具能做到什么”的对照。
144
+
145
+ ### 诚实比较
146
+
147
+ - 它强在**无人值守跑完整条流水线并输出可编译 PDF**,且把“引用覆盖 / 图表规划 / 页数预算”写成 outline 阶段的结构化 JSON(L25 用 `guidelines.md` 的页数上限反推字数)——这是我们的 `argument-outline` 目前没写全的部分;评审侧还自带 rubric + SxS + citation F1 三套自动指标。
148
+ - Light 强在**确定性**:零依赖离线机检、逐 claim 绑定 draft hash 与 evidence ID、canonical `light.findings.v1`、stage 8 checkpoint 阻断、8→7/8→6 回炉。它的 LLM judge 给不出“哪条 claim 没证据”的可复验判决。
149
+ - 它的“覆盖度”是引用数量口径,不是召回口径;Light 的三层检索 + 覆盖度如实标注仍更诚实。反过来,**P0/P1 分层 P/R/F1** 比 Light 现在的引用台账更可量化,值得在 `photon-citation` 补。
150
+
151
+ ### 可复验命令
152
+
153
+ ```bash
154
+ git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/google-research/paper-orchestra /tmp/paper-orchestra
155
+ cd /tmp/paper-orchestra && git log -1 --format='%H %ad' --date=short
156
+ sed -n '43,71p' methods/prompts/outline_agent.py
157
+ sed -n '34,43p' methods/prompts/section_writing_agent.py
158
+ sed -n '40,46p' methods/prompts/content_refinement_agent.py
159
+ grep -n 'Step [0-9]' methods/paper_writer.py
160
+ ```
161
+
119
162
  ## Light 的诚实比较
120
163
 
121
164
  ### 真优势
@@ -0,0 +1,215 @@
1
+ # PaperOrchestra outline contracts — what to borrow
2
+
3
+ > Status: **proposal, not implemented**. Verified 2026-11-21 against
4
+ > `google-research/paper-orchestra` @ `d9bae997e793a015ed38bb1605be9eb58c00284f`
5
+ > (Apache-2.0, 5,402★ whole repo at verification). Nothing in this note ships until R1–R5 land.
6
+ >
7
+ > Evidence: `docs/competitors/paper-writing.md` §Round 3 补验(2026-11-21);
8
+ > `docs/competitors/literature-search.md` §0.B.
9
+
10
+ ## Status (2026-11-21)
11
+
12
+ | Req | Landed as | Where |
13
+ |---|---|---|
14
+ | R1 | prose only — no schema key | `skills-academic/photon-literature-search/SKILL.md`(ACT 段「检索配额分层」) |
15
+ | R2 | prose contract section | `skills-academic/photon-citation/references/registry_contract.md` §Priority tiers (P0/P1) |
16
+ | R3 | single owner file + two pointers | `skills-academic/photon-figure/references/figure_contract.md`(`figure_id` / `aspect_ratio` / `data_source`),SKILL 规划步骤与 paper-writing `figure_requirements` 段落指过来 |
17
+ | R4 | prose boundary section | `skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/references/claim_argument_plan.md` §修订请求的回炉边界 |
18
+ | R5 | **not landed** — blocked by B1 | — |
19
+
20
+ **B1 — no validator in this tree.** Six `find` checks return 0: `search_protocol_gate.py`,
21
+ `citation_four_gate.py`, `validate_plan_card.py`, `figure_contract.py`,
22
+ `argument_contract.py`, `claim_binding.py` are "manual mode" files — each
23
+ academic SKILL's own *Bundled files* section says they do not ship with the
24
+ plugin, and this repository does not contain them either. While that holds, **no
25
+ new JSON key is added to any machine-consumed template**: a schema that
26
+ advertises a field nothing validates is the failure mode this repo already
27
+ rejects. That is why R1–R3 landed as prose and the R1/R2 template fields and R5
28
+ wait on the same blocker.
29
+
30
+
31
+ ## Why this note exists
32
+
33
+ The question that started it: *can `google-research/paper-orchestra` be used to
34
+ develop Photon-skills?* Answer, in one line each:
35
+
36
+ - **As a dependency — no.** `requirements.txt` pulls google-genai / openai /
37
+ PyMuPDF / matplotlib / streamlit, needs Gemini or OpenAI keys and a conda
38
+ py3.11 env; Photon is stdlib-only with an offline `--selftest`. Apache-2.0 code
39
+ vendored into an MIT repo also carries a NOTICE obligation.
40
+ - **As a contract reference — yes**, for three outline/ledger fields and one
41
+ wording rule. That is what R1–R5 below propose.
42
+ - **As a gate — no.** Its three `autoraters/` are LLM judges (rubric, SxS on
43
+ rendered PDF pages, citation F1 with LLM-assigned P0/P1). No exit code, no
44
+ provenance, not offline-replayable.
45
+ - **As a product direction — no.** It writes the paper from the log. That is the
46
+ opposite of `photon-paper-writing`'s `claim_evidence` critical gate and
47
+ `photon-research-ethics`' delivery red line.
48
+
49
+ ## Verified baseline
50
+
51
+ | Fact | Value | How verified |
52
+ |---|---|---|
53
+ | Commit / date | `d9bae997e793a015ed38bb1605be9eb58c00284f` (2026-11-15) | `git clone --depth 1` → `git log -1` |
54
+ | Licence | Apache-2.0 | `gh api repos/google-research/paper-orchestra --jq .license.spdx_id` |
55
+ | Stars | 5,402(整仓,2026-11-21 核验时) | `gh api … --jq .stargazers_count` |
56
+ | Python / env | conda env `paper_orchestra`, py3.11 | `README.md` L23 |
57
+ | Dataset | not in repo, "released separately" | `README.md` L50 |
58
+ | Entry point | one paper per run; `--raw_materials_dir` + `--latex_template_dir` required | `paper_writing_cli.py` L27–39 |
59
+ | Template contract | target dir must contain `template.tex` + `guidelines.md` | `methods/paper_writer.py` L70–71, asserts L78–89 |
60
+ | Pipeline | outline → literature → section writing → content refinement (+ plotting variant) | `methods/paper_writer.py` L92/L106/L135/L153 |
61
+ | Gates | none deterministic; 3 LLM autoraters | `autoraters/{agent_review,sxs_paper_quality,citation_f1}.py` |
62
+ | Photon engine scripts | `claim_binding.py` / `claim_evidence_gate.py` / `draft_lint.py` / `argument_contract.py` are **not** in `skills-academic/` nor inside `src/photon/extensions/academic-skills.zip` (the zip carries one script: `photon-result-analysis/scripts/r_analysis_crosscheck.R`) | `find`, `unzip -l` |
63
+
64
+ That last row is the gating fact for this note: the outline is currently an
65
+ example file plus prose, so **adding fields to it would be name-without-engine**
66
+ until `argument_contract.py` exists again. Hence R1–R4 specify *documented*
67
+ additions; only R5 touches the shipped payload, and only after the engine is
68
+ restored.
69
+
70
+ ## Decisions
71
+
72
+ | # | Mechanic in PaperOrchestra | Decision | Why |
73
+ |---|---|---|---|
74
+ | D1 | Intro macro 10–20 papers vs Related Work micro 30–50 (`methods/prompts/outline_agent.py` L43/L47/L53) | **Adopt** as optional protocol fields with `basis: assumed` default | Turns "don't let two sections raid one pool" from a prose wish into a checkable per-section target; counts stay advisory, never a hard gate |
75
+ | D2 | `citation_hints` — one hint per dataset/optimizer/metric/base model, each pinned to a single canonical paper (L70–71) | **Adopt** as a ledger field with P0/P1 priority | Mirrors `citation_f1.py`'s P0/P1 split; a hint without a verified canonical target stays `pending` and cannot be P0 |
76
+ | D3 | `plotting_plan` enums: `figure_id` (no "Figure"), 12-value `aspect_ratio`, `data_source ∈ {idea, log, both}` (L36–37) | **Adopt** into figure requirements | Enums are machine-checkable; free text is not |
77
+ | D4 | "Reviewer asks for experiments not in the log → ignore; presentation refinement only" (`content_refinement_agent.py` L44) | **Adopt as wording**, one sentence in the paper-writing reference | It is the honest sibling of 8→7 / 8→6: it declines to write, we reroute to produce evidence. Both beat inventing results |
78
+ | D5 | Rubric / SxS / citation-F1 autoraters | **Reject as gate**, allow as design-time eval only | No deterministic verdict to feed `_shared/gate_runner` |
79
+ | D6 | Vendor any code or prompt text verbatim | **Reject** | Dependency policy + Apache-2.0 NOTICE; the mechanics are field-level, not implementation-level |
80
+
81
+ ## Proposed additions to the outline contract
82
+
83
+ Additive only — `schema` stays `light.paper_argument.v1` until the engine can
84
+ decide whether unknown fields fail closed or are tolerated (see open question 1).
85
+
86
+ ```json
87
+ {
88
+ "schema": "light.paper_argument.v1",
89
+ "sections": [
90
+ {
91
+ "section_id": "related-work",
92
+ "tier": "micro",
93
+ "target_literature": { "min": 30, "max": 50, "basis": "assumed" }
94
+ }
95
+ ],
96
+ "claims": [
97
+ {
98
+ "claim_id": "C1",
99
+ "citation_hints": [
100
+ {
101
+ "hint_id": "cit-adamw",
102
+ "priority": "P0",
103
+ "canonical": { "title": "…", "doi": "…", "verified_at": "2026-11-21" }
104
+ }
105
+ ],
106
+ "figure_plan": [
107
+ {
108
+ "figure_id": "fig_framework_overview",
109
+ "kind": "diagram",
110
+ "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
111
+ "data_source": "idea.md"
112
+ }
113
+ ]
114
+ }
115
+ ]
116
+ }
117
+ ```
118
+
119
+ Rules that come with the fields:
120
+
121
+ 1. `tier ∈ {macro, micro}`; `target_literature.basis ∈ {venue-guideline,
122
+ author-declared, assumed}`. Missing target → no target, not a silent zero.
123
+ 2. A hint is `P0` only when its `canonical` block carries a real
124
+ `doi`/`url` and `verified_at`; otherwise `priority: pending` and the claim
125
+ cannot be marked evidence-complete.
126
+ 3. `figure_id` must not contain the word "Figure"; `aspect_ratio` is one of
127
+ `1:1 1:4 2:3 3:2 3:4 4:1 4:3 4:5 5:4 9:16 16:9 21:9`; `data_source` is
128
+ `idea.md`, `experimental_log.md`, or `both`.
129
+ 4. None of these are gates. They are fields a gate *could* read later.
130
+
131
+ ## Requirements
132
+
133
+ Pre-implementation state (2026-11-21): all four verification greps below
134
+ returned 0. R1–R4 have since landed **as prose** (see the status table above);
135
+ the machine-readable template fields stay blocked with R5. These requirements
136
+ describe the target state, not what shipped.
137
+
138
+ **R1 — literature-search protocol carries tier + target.**
139
+ `photon-literature-search/templates/search-protocol.example.json` gains
140
+ `sections[].tier` and `sections[].target_literature`; the SKILL says a missing
141
+ `basis` defaults to `assumed` and is reported as such.
142
+ *Acceptance:* example parses as JSON; every field is documented in the SKILL or
143
+ its resource map; no network call added.
144
+ *Verify:* `python -c "import json;json.load(open('skills-academic/photon-literature-search/templates/search-protocol.example.json'))"`.
145
+
146
+ **R2 — citation ledger carries P0/P1.**
147
+ `photon-citation/templates/citation_input.json` accepts a `priority` field;
148
+ `references/registry_contract.md` defines P0 (must-cite, tied to a claim) and P1
149
+ (background), and states plainly that the PaperOrchestra-style tiered
150
+ precision/recall/F1 is **not** computed offline — only manual sampling.
151
+ *Acceptance:* template parses; SKILL frontmatter draws no new claim; the
152
+ "not computed offline" line is present.
153
+ *Verify:* `grep -n "P0" skills-academic/photon-citation/references/registry_contract.md`.
154
+
155
+ **R3 — figure requirements use the enums.**
156
+ The three enum rules live in exactly one place, and both
157
+ `photon-paper-writing/templates/argument-outline.example.json` and
158
+ `photon-figure` point at it.
159
+ *Acceptance:* one owner file for the enum lists; both skills link to it; no
160
+ duplicated literal enum pasted twice.
161
+ *Verify:* `grep -rln "21:9" skills-academic` returns exactly one file — the owner.
162
+
163
+ **R4 — revision boundary wording.**
164
+ `photon-paper-writing/references/claim_argument_plan.md` gains one paragraph:
165
+ a reviewer request for data that does not exist in the evidence set is a
166
+ **reroute signal** (8→7 / 8→6), never a paragraph to invent.
167
+ *Acceptance:* the paragraph names both reroute edges and forbids writing the
168
+ missing result.
169
+ *Verify:* `grep -n "8→7" skills-academic/photon-paper-writing/references/claim_argument_plan.md`.
170
+
171
+ **R5 — land the shipped payload (blocked on the engine).**
172
+ Template + references edits, then rebuild `src/photon/extensions/academic-skills.zip`
173
+ byte-identically and re-run the contract gate.
174
+ *Acceptance:* `python scripts/check_plugin_contract.py` exits 0; the zip mirrors
175
+ `skills-academic/`; no version bump.
176
+ *Verify:* as above.
177
+ *Blocker:* `argument_contract.py` must exist before the schema can accept the
178
+ new keys — otherwise the example advertises fields nothing validates.
179
+
180
+ ## Out of scope
181
+
182
+ - Any runtime dependency, API key, network call, or conda environment.
183
+ - Any LLM judge wired into `_shared/gate_runner`.
184
+ - Copying PaperOrchestra code or prompt text.
185
+ - A student-facing "generate my paper from my log" feature.
186
+ - Plotting automation (`plotting_agent.py` generates figure visuals; Photon's
187
+ standing rule is programmatic data figures, no AI-drawn data figures).
188
+
189
+ ## Open questions
190
+
191
+ 1. **Unknown-field behaviour.** Does a restored `argument_contract.py` fail
192
+ closed on unknown keys? If yes, R5 needs a schema bump (`v1.1`) and a
193
+ migration note; if it tolerates extra keys, additive-only is fine.
194
+ 2. **Engine restoration order.** The four engine scripts named in
195
+ `photon-paper-writing`'s frontmatter are absent from tree and payload. Is
196
+ restoring them part of the academic extension, or a separate effort? This
197
+ note is only documentation until that is answered.
198
+ 3. **Where targets come from.** `10–20 / 30–50` are PaperOrchestra's defaults for
199
+ ML conference papers. For a secondary-school STEAM project they are almost
200
+ certainly wrong; the field should carry `basis: assumed` and a much smaller
201
+ author-declared range rather than inherit those numbers.
202
+ 4. ~~**Single owner for the enums.**~~ Resolved: `photon-figure/references/figure_contract.md`
203
+ owns them; `grep -rln "21:9" skills-academic` must hit only that file.
204
+
205
+ ## How this note was verified
206
+
207
+ ```bash
208
+ gh api repos/google-research/paper-orchestra --jq '{stars:.stargazers_count,pushed:.pushed_at,license:.license.spdx_id}'
209
+ git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/google-research/paper-orchestra /tmp/paper-orchestra
210
+ cd /tmp/paper-orchestra && git log -1 --format='%H %ad' --date=short
211
+ sed -n '43,71p' methods/prompts/outline_agent.py
212
+ sed -n '170,198p' autoraters/citation_f1.py
213
+ cd - && find . -name 'claim_evidence_gate.py' -o -name 'argument_contract.py'
214
+ unzip -l src/photon/extensions/academic-skills.zip | grep scripts/
215
+ ```
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ build-backend = "hatchling.build"
4
4
 
5
5
  [project]
6
6
  name = "photon-skills"
7
- version = "3.0.5.dev94"
7
+ version = "3.0.5.dev99"
8
8
  description = "Photon — STEAM research, debate, and pitch competition companion for primary/secondary students"
9
9
  authors = [
10
10
  { name = "Uniterra Solutions Limited", email = "harryw07801@uniterra-solutions.com" },
@@ -54,6 +54,24 @@ locators are demoted to `REVIEW_REQUIRED`. `PARTIAL`,
54
54
  `RELATED_ONLY`, `UNSUPPORTED`, and `REVIEW_REQUIRED` all produce relevance
55
55
  warnings for human resolution; they never enlarge stage 10's critical surface.
56
56
 
57
+ ## Priority tiers (P0 / P1)
58
+
59
+ Borrowed wording from PaperOrchestra's citation autorater
60
+ (`autoraters/citation_f1.py` L170–198): every reference the manuscript depends
61
+ on is either **P0** — must cite: a dataset, metric, base model, optimizer or
62
+ baseline the results are actually compared against — or **P1** — background:
63
+ context, surveys, related work. Record the tier on the **claim edge**, not on the
64
+ work row, because the same paper can be P0 for one claim and P1 for another.
65
+
66
+ - A P0 edge needs a resolved `work_id` plus a real source locator. An
67
+ `UNRESOLVED`, `UNAVAILABLE` or `is_chimeric` work cannot be P0.
68
+ - P0 edges are what the delivery audit counts. P1 edges only produce relevance
69
+ warnings and never enlarge stage 10's critical surface.
70
+ - **No F1 score here.** PaperOrchestra computes tiered precision/recall/F1
71
+ against a gold bibliography it gets from its own dataset. We have no gold
72
+ bibliography, so any precision or recall number we printed would be invented.
73
+ Report coverage as counts and named gaps; do not manufacture a metric.
74
+
57
75
  ## Derived delivery
58
76
 
59
77
  - `references.bib`: only confirmed, non-chimeric works.
@@ -14,7 +14,7 @@ description: >-
14
14
  **论文数据图必须程序化生成(matplotlib/seaborn/R),绝不 AI 生图**(永久底线);静态 lint 只抓形态可疑,真误导终判需图注+人/审稿人。
15
15
  本技能是 **9→7(把不显著当主图/图文不一致→result-analysis)回炉发起方**。
16
16
  metadata:
17
- version: 2.2.0-round3
17
+ version: 2.2.1-round3
18
18
  truth_source: ../../docs/competitors/figure.md
19
19
  engine: scripts/visual_honesty_gate.py(视觉诚实/把不显著当主图 critical 门 producer,六 gate→light.findings.v1,消费 evidence_strength.json + 编排 figure_integrity_lint/audit_figure_set)· figure_contract.py(figure delivery/result card provenance/paper-claim-context/caption/build hashes 契约;经验图必须绑 result-analysis result card 与 paper-writing claim plan;guardrail WARN 的 claim_impact 必须进入 caption;最终 outputs.path 必须是包内相对路径且 SHA 匹配真实文件)· figure_integrity_lint.py(静态扫绘图代码:截 y 轴/双 y 轴/jet-rainbow/误差棒缺失)· audit_figure_set.py(集合 display-item 预算 + 反冗余 panel,挂 semantic_sim)· figure_visual_qa.py(render-then-look:抽 matplotlib AABB 喂 _shared/visual_qa 几何引擎,不重造)· figure_export.py(栏宽/字号/dpi 出版规格 JOURNAL_SPECS + check_figure_size/check_scaled_fonts)· color_palettes.py(Okabe-Ito/viridis 色盲安全色板)· recommend_chart.py(图型启发式推荐)· validate_plan_card.py(规划卡契约校验)· **r_ggplot.py(R3 python+R 双路径:探测 Rscript+ggplot2+scales→可用走 ggplot2 出版图[森林/箱线/分面/统计标注]、不可用诚实降级 matplotlib;manifest 只写包内相对路径;复用 figure_export/color_palettes 不重造)**
20
20
  emits: light.findings.v1(producer=figure;critical=visual_honesty(截/双轴) + misrepresent_evidence(把不显著当主图,9→7),warn=error_bars/colormap/display_budget/panel_redundancy)· light.visual_qa.v1(figure_visual_qa 渲染回看)
@@ -128,6 +128,7 @@ metadata:
128
128
  散点、分布→箱线/直方、不确定性→点+误差棒)。诚实:这是启发式(Cleveland-McGill 感知精度),最终人定。
129
129
  3. **填规划卡**:用 [`templates/figure_plan_card.md`](templates/figure_plan_card.md)(图)/ [`templates/table_plan_card.md`](templates/table_plan_card.md)(表)。
130
130
  ⚠ **填 `claim_id`** 精确绑 result-analysis 证据档(留空则按文本语义匹配)。
131
+ - **id / 比例 / 数据来源的取值**见 [`references/figure_contract.md`](references/figure_contract.md):`figure_id` 用 `F#`/`T#`(唯一、不含 "Figure")、`aspect_ratio` 12 值枚举(仅限独立交付物,正文以栏宽为准)、`data_source` 四选一(含无数据的 `conceptual`)。
131
132
  4. **校验 + 集合预算**:`python validate_plan_card.py F1.md ...`(栏宽键/figure_id 唯一/source_card 必填)+
132
133
  `python audit_figure_set.py F1.md F2.md T1.md --cap 8`(计数对照 venue 上限 + 反冗余)。
133
134
  - ✅ `--cap` 取**目标刊作者指南权威值**(NeurIPS 9 页/CVPR 8 页/刊作者指南)。
@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
1
+ # 图规划取值契约(id / 比例 / 数据来源)
2
+
3
+ 这份文件是三个枚举取值的**唯一来源**:`photon-figure`(规划卡、导出)与 `photon-paper-writing`(`figure_requirements`)都指向这里,不要在别处再抄一份字面量。
4
+
5
+ > 状态(2026-11-21):**文档层契约,尚无机检**。`validate_plan_card.py` / `figure_contract.py` 不随精简构建(Issue #47 manual mode)安装,本仓库当前也不含这些脚本。写"已校验"之前,先确认脚本存在并真跑过 `--selftest`。
6
+
7
+ ## 1. figure_id
8
+
9
+ - 论文内稳定、唯一;主文图用 `F#`、表格用 `T#`,与论文模板的 `[图位 F1]` / `[表位 T1]` 占位对齐。
10
+ - **不得含 "Figure" 字样**(借 PaperOrchestra 的规则,`methods/prompts/outline_agent.py` L37),否则图注会渲染成 "Figure Figure 1"。
11
+ - 语义描述放 `title` 字段,不要塞进 id:id 一旦进图注就能被交叉引用,改名等于断链。
12
+
13
+ ## 2. aspect_ratio
14
+
15
+ - 取值锁死 12 个枚举:`1:1` `1:4` `2:3` `3:2` `3:4` `4:1` `4:3` `4:5` `5:4` `9:16` `16:9` `21:9`(与 PaperOrchestra 同一组,L36)。闭集才能被机检,也才是版式/图像工具认的值。
16
+ - **只用于独立交付物**(slide / poster / 单页图)。**论文正文图的比例由栏宽决定**(`figure_export` 的 `JOURNAL_SPECS`,如 Nature 89/183mm),不要用 aspect_ratio 覆盖栏宽;两者冲突时栏宽优先。
17
+
18
+ ## 3. data_source
19
+
20
+ - 四选一:`idea.md` / `experimental_log.md` / `both` / `conceptual`。
21
+ - 前三个借 PaperOrchestra 的 `data_source` 口径(L36–37);`conceptual` 是 Photon 增的:框架图、流程图这类**没有数据**的图必须显式写它,并因此**禁止出现任何数值标注**——没有数据来源的数字就是编造。
22
+ - 有数据的图与无数据的图分开,是"论文数据图程序化生成、绝不 AI 生图"红线在规划层的落地:概念图同样要 diagram-as-code(Draw.io / TikZ / Graphviz)出源码,不接受生图模型。
23
+
24
+ ## 变更方式
25
+
26
+ 改枚举 = 改本文件,同时确认 `photon-figure` SKILL 的规划步骤与 `photon-paper-writing` 的 `figure_requirements` 段落指针仍有效。不要把字面量复制到第三处:`grep -rln "21:9" skills-academic` 只应命中本文件。
@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ description: >-
10
10
  找论文 / 撞车 / 新颖性摸底 / 跨领域 / 检索式。核心纪律:不臆造 DOI/被引(查不到写 unknown);三层分别排序
11
11
  不一锅 relevance;撞车只产**信号**不下 novel 判决(归 idea-critique);覆盖度按真实 HTTP 码诚实标。
12
12
  metadata:
13
- version: 2.2.1-round3
13
+ version: 2.2.2-round3
14
14
  truth_source: ../../docs/competitors/literature-search.md
15
15
  workflow_map: search-resource-map.md # R2:研究者视角找种子→滚雪球→多源→建地图→追新 5 步闭环 + 资源 access 分级
16
16
  engine: scripts/domain_map.py(三层编排+findings)· search_protocol_gate(冻结协议/覆盖/计数/停止声明门)· search_normalize/arxiv_search/cross_domain_search/snowball/verify_citations/biomedical_search/prisma_flow/tracker/cn_journal_probe/pipeline
@@ -62,6 +62,11 @@ idea-generation 的领域地图**:这个方向怎么演化来的(脉络)、有
62
62
  原始响应 locator+哈希、known-item recall、included seed 引文扩展、筛选计数、覆盖总结、停止证据 locator+哈希、
63
63
  修订账与非未来日期;并把用户提供/确认的范围、时间窗、语种、文献类型和 review type 作为
64
64
  `scope_decision` 绑定原话/决定记录 locator+hash。`FROZEN/REGISTERED/AMENDED` 必须有协议哈希与冻结日期。
65
+ - **检索配额分层(借 PaperOrchestra 的 Intro/Related Work 分工)**:写作期两节抢同一批文献是常见病——
66
+ 引言吃**宏观语境**(10–20 篇领域锚/综述),相关工作吃**微观技术基线**(30–50 篇同类方法)。检索时按 tier 分开记两份
67
+ 检索方向与目标量,写进检索笔记与 `question.scope_boundary`。**数量是启发式,不是及格线**:学生项目按实际规模
68
+ 缩小,并在笔记里标 `assumed`。这条目前是**文档层约定**:`search-protocol.example.json` 尚未加 `sections[]`,
69
+ 等 `search_protocol_gate.py` 支持未知字段后再升为 schema 字段——模板不承诺无人机检的键。
65
70
  - **检索期防幻觉**:可疑 DOI → `verify_citations.py` 核真实存在(投稿终审交 photon-citation)。
66
71
  - **产 findings**:`domain_map.py --report` 出 `light.findings.v1`(覆盖度 + 撞车),交总控 `run_checkpoint --stage` 聚合。
67
72
 
@@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ description: >-
13
13
  不显著只能报「未见显著差异」、绝不过度宣称;机检措辞有边界,逻辑/创新/论证终判仍需人/审稿人。
14
14
  本技能是 **8→7(claim 无证据→result-analysis)/ 8→6(实现缺口→experiment-coding)回炉发起方**。
15
15
  metadata:
16
- version: 2.2.0-round3
16
+ version: 2.2.1-round3
17
17
  truth_source: ../../docs/competitors/paper-writing.md
18
18
  engine: scripts/claim_binding.py(light.paper_claims.v1 逐 claim 绑定 + draft_sha256 防旧稿绑定 + checked_at/source path/hash 防伪 provenance + result-card/guardrail handoff)· argument_contract.py(claim type/paragraph role/因果·机制·null·post-hoc 论证闭包)· claim_evidence_gate.py(claim 必有证据/过度宣称/result-card guardrail producer,五 gate→light.findings.v1,消费 claim map+evidence_strength+result_card+evidence_contract)· draft_lint.py(GAP/声明/SOTA/引用台账/逐 claim 措辞门)· contribution_consistency.py(贡献三处一致 warn)· mechanical_check.py(离线机检)· style_fingerprint.py(作者文风指纹)· polish.py(默认离线·--online opt-in)
19
19
  emits: light.findings.v1(producer=paper-writing;critical=claim_evidence,warn=overclaim/contribution_consistency)
@@ -23,11 +23,21 @@
23
23
  - `sections`:该 claim 应覆盖 abstract/introduction/results/discussion/conclusion 的哪些位置。
24
24
  - `claim_type`:建议与 `argument_contract.py` 对齐:`RESULT` / `NULL_RESULT` / `MECHANISM` / `CAUSAL` / `SPECULATION` / `LIMITATION` / `METHOD` / `POSITIONING`。
25
25
  - `citation_candidates`:只交候选与 locator,真实性归 citation。
26
- - `figure_requirements`:只交 claim、数据与证据要求,绘图归 figure。
26
+ - `figure_requirements`:只交 claim、数据与证据要求,绘图归 figure。id / 比例 / 数据来源的取值见 `photon-figure/references/figure_contract.md`(唯一 owner,别在这里抄枚举)。
27
27
  - `limitations`:该 claim 的样本、数据域、设计或外推边界。
28
28
  - `post_hoc`:看结果后新提炼的贡献必须为 `true`,不得伪装成预先计划。
29
29
  - `owner` / `updated_at`:多人协作与变更追踪。
30
30
 
31
+ ## 修订请求的回炉边界
32
+
33
+ 审稿人、导师或竞赛评委要求补实验、补基线、补消融时,先查 `experimental_log.md`、`evidence_strength.json` 与 result card 里有没有对应产出:
34
+
35
+ - **有**:照常写进 Results/Discussion,claim 绑定与证据档保持一致。
36
+ - **没有**:这是**回炉信号**,不是写作任务。回到 `8→7`(result-analysis 补证据档)或 `8→6`(experiment-coding 补实验),并**停下问用户**走哪条。禁止在 prose 里"顺带"给出没有实验支撑的数字、显著性判断,或 "preliminary results suggest" 式暗示。
37
+ - 也不要把评审意见改写成更弱的 claim 混过门:措辞可以降档(strong→hedged),但证据缺口必须写进 `limitations`,不能靠 hedge 掩盖。
38
+
39
+ PaperOrchestra 的做法是"评审要的 log 里没有就直接忽略"(`methods/prompts/content_refinement_agent.py` L44)——它选择不写,本技能选择回炉补证据。两条都胜过编造,但只有回炉真正闭合缺口;这也是 `claim_evidence` 保持 critical 的原因。
40
+
31
41
  ## 写作顺序
32
42
 
33
43
  1. 冻结 venue、研究问题与一到三条核心贡献。
@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
1
1
  name: photon-skills
2
- version: 3.0.5.dev94
2
+ version: 3.0.5.dev99
3
3
  description: >-
4
4
  Photon — STEAM project companion for students: research workflow, debate and
5
5
  symposium coaching, pitch preparation, and a git-backed project workspace.