associate 0.8.0__tar.gz → 0.9.1__tar.gz

associate-0.9.1/.devague/current

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+associate-on-pi-with-opinionated-tools

associate-0.9.1/.devague/current_plan

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+associate-on-pi-with-opinionated-tools

associate-0.9.1/.devague/deliveries/associate-on-pi-with-opinionated-tools.json

@@ -0,0 +1,492 @@
+{
+  "plan_slug": "associate-on-pi-with-opinionated-tools",
+  "schema_version": 2,
+  "created": "2026-09-12T11:41:38Z",
+  "updated": "2026-09-12T16:33:04Z",
+  "deviations": [
+    {
+      "id": "d1",
+      "what": "t1's acceptance criterion 1 pins the literal skills path '.claude/skills' inside .pi/settings.json, but Pi resolves paths in .pi/settings.json relative to the .pi directory (pi docs/settings.md:268), so the correct values are '../.claude/skills' and 'extensions/associate'; package.json's pi key resolves from the package root (packages.md:133) and is correct as written. Proposed divergence: .pi/settings.json uses the .pi-relative forms; criterion 1 is amended to say so; the test asserts the relative forms and that they resolve to existing directories",
+      "task_ref": "t1",
+      "reason": "the plan's criterion was written without checking Pi's resolution rule; the task agent implemented the literal string as confirmed and flagged the mismatch instead of guessing",
+      "affects": [
+        "t1",
+        "t2",
+        "t12"
+      ],
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "classification": "acceptable",
+      "seq": 1
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "d2",
+      "what": "t3 edited .gitignore, a file outside its stated ownership: the repo's Python 'lib/' ignore rule (setuptools output) silently ignored .pi/extensions/associate/lib/, so the module could not be added; a scoped re-include (!.pi/extensions/*/lib/ and !.pi/extensions/*/lib/**) was appended instead of a force-add, because t2's lib/session.ts and lib/context.ts hit the same rule",
+      "task_ref": "t3",
+      "reason": "an inherited ignore rule collided with the planned extension layout; nobody had checked git check-ignore against the planned paths",
+      "affects": [
+        "t2"
+      ],
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "classification": "acceptable",
+      "seq": 2
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "d3",
+      "what": "t6 edited two shared tests outside its ownership: contract.test.ts's 'no policy value hardcoded' scan was narrowed so a tool module may name the one binary it wraps (rg/fd/ls also appear in policy.json's shell allowlist) while index.ts and lib/ stay under the full scan; extension.test.ts's fixed two-tool assertion became a shape check. t5/t7/t8 add tool modules this wave and would each have tripped the same tests",
+      "task_ref": "t6",
+      "reason": "the structural tests were written when tools/ was empty; the first real tool module exposed that they encoded the empty state",
+      "affects": [
+        "t5",
+        "t7",
+        "t8"
+      ],
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "classification": "acceptable",
+      "seq": 3
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "d4",
+      "what": "t5 edited tests/extension.test.ts outside its ownership: two fixture expectations that encoded the empty tools/ state (active_tools exactly [associate_ready, finish]; discoverToolModules returns []) were updated to include read \u2014 the same class of edit as d3 (t6)",
+      "task_ref": "t5",
+      "reason": "structural tests written when tools/ was empty; every first tool module trips them",
+      "affects": [
+        "t7",
+        "t8"
+      ],
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "classification": "acceptable",
+      "seq": 4
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "d5",
+      "what": "t7 built ctx.declareNonWriter across lib/guard.ts, lib/context.ts, lib/runtime.ts and index.ts (about 20 additive lines): the write guard listed bash among BUILTIN_WRITER_TOOLS, so the extension's safe shell was blocked on every call and associate_ready reported writer_tools_active [bash], which the c34 launcher refuses on; guard.ts's own comment promised a non-writer declaration that had never been built",
+      "task_ref": "t7",
+      "reason": "the plan split assumed the guard already supported a same-named safe shell; it did not, and staying inside two files would have shipped a tool that cannot be called",
+      "affects": [
+        "t2",
+        "t12"
+      ],
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "classification": "acceptable",
+      "seq": 5
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "d6",
+      "what": "t8 relaxed the same two empty-tools assertions in tests/extension.test.ts (class of d3/d4) and made two narrowing calls alone: webglass --policy-profile is not exposed to the model (it would let the model declare a loopback target through the default deny), and code_lens keeps the spec's six-verb enum although code-lens 0.10.0 ships only profile/classify/grep/recent, returning a typed unsupported_command error for connections/graph",
+      "task_ref": "t8",
+      "reason": "the spec named six verbs from an assumed CLI surface; the installed CLI has four; and the policy-profile override in the earlier spec was a human pattern, not a model affordance",
+      "affects": [
+        "t15"
+      ],
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "classification": "needs-follow-up",
+      "seq": 6
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "d7",
+      "what": "measured 2026-09-12 (t15 pre-check): with the repo installed as a Pi package and pi run in an unrelated directory, pi.getActiveTools() includes edit and write alongside the associate tools, because defaultTools [] lives in the project .pi/settings.json and does not apply outside the checkout. The global-package path (c44, authoritative for the mesh) therefore does not remove the writers by itself; only the write-guard hook stands between the model and a write. Proposed divergence: index.ts deactivates every built-in writer at load via Pi's active-tools API (pi.setActiveTools or the documented equivalent), so the restriction travels with the extension, not with the project settings; associate_ready keeps reporting writer_tools_active for the launcher gate",
+      "task_ref": "t15",
+      "reason": "the plan relied on defaultTools [] (t1) for the restriction and on the global package (c44) for trust-independence; the two do not compose \u2014 nobody measured the global path before t15",
+      "affects": [
+        "t2",
+        "t1"
+      ],
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "classification": "risky",
+      "seq": 7
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "d8",
+      "what": "measured 2026-09-12 (t15): (1) the Pi adapter's readiness check depends on the model calling associate_ready in the same turn as the task \u2014 with a real task prompt the model skipped the sentinel and the launcher refused a healthy run (check 1), while the readiness-only prompt passed; (2) the adapter relies on the project's .pi/ being present, so 'associate bench --harness pi' in fixture checkouts got Unknown provider and no extension. Proposed divergence: the extension writes the sentinel report to <export_dir>/ready.json on session_start (deterministic, no model turn), the launcher reads that file for its fail-closed gate and falls back to the tool event, and the launcher passes -e <repo>/.pi/extensions/associate/index.ts explicitly so the extension loads in any checkout without depending on project trust or a global install",
+      "task_ref": "t12",
+      "reason": "t12's positive path was proven only against a scripted fake pi (lapse l29); the first real task prompt and the first foreign checkout exposed both assumptions",
+      "affects": [
+        "t15",
+        "t2"
+      ],
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "classification": "acceptable",
+      "seq": 12
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "d9",
+      "what": "measured 2026-09-12 (t15 mesh check): through pi-acp the model put its whole answer in the finish payload and ended the turn with no final text, so culture's ACP bridge (which relays agent_message_chunk text, cultureagent/clients/acp/agent_runner.py:393) posted nothing to IRC \u2014 the hand-back was recorded in the walk but never delivered to the requester. Proposed divergence, Pi-and-model-tailored per c50: (1) the finish tool's result text tells the model 'hand-back recorded (N statements); now reply to the requester with the summary as your final message'; (2) AGENTS.md states that after finish the final message is the payload's summary, because a reply left only in finish does not reach a mesh requester; (3) the mesh-delivery check becomes a bench case (a run passes only if the final assistant text is non-empty after finish)",
+      "task_ref": "t15",
+      "reason": "the mesh path relays chat text, the harness delivers via finish; nothing in the plan reconciled the two channels \u2014 the issue #3 final-message loss reappeared one layer up",
+      "affects": [
+        "t13",
+        "t2",
+        "t17"
+      ],
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "classification": "acceptable",
+      "seq": 17
+    }
+  ],
+  "evidence": [
+    {
+      "id": "e1",
+      "obligation_ref": "o26",
+      "test_ref": "manual: pi install /home/spark/git/associate (local path form of the package install; the git-ref form needs a pushed tag) then pi -p --no-context-files -e dump-tools.ts in an unrelated directory, before_agent_start dump of getAllTools/getActiveTools",
+      "behavior_text": "installing the repo as a Pi package and running pi in an unrelated directory yields the associate tool list with no edit or write",
+      "contract_text": "c45/c44: the global install is authoritative for the mesh path so tool restriction never depends on project trust",
+      "evidence_type": "observation",
+      "strength": "execution",
+      "strength_basis": "observed on pi 0.84.2 on this box 2026-09-12: active tools were read, bash, edit, write, associate_ready, finish, code_lens, grep, find, ls, web_search, web_page \u2014 edit and write active; the associate tools did register",
+      "outcome": "fail",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "c897511"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 8
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "e2",
+      "obligation_ref": "o18",
+      "test_ref": "manual: uv run associate run --harness pi --export-root <scratch> 'call associate_ready then finish' with ASSOCIATE_API_KEY unset and the lane returning 503",
+      "behavior_text": "when the extension's sentinel tool is absent from the tool list the launcher exits non-zero naming it and serves nothing",
+      "contract_text": "c34: the tool restriction fails closed",
+      "evidence_type": "observation",
+      "strength": "execution",
+      "strength_basis": "observed 2026-09-12 on commit c897511: exit 2 in 17 s, error 'pi never reported the associate_ready tool, so the associate extension did not load and the run is refused', remediation hint printed, no traceback; walk.jsonl and statements.md were still written by the extension",
+      "outcome": "pass",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "c897511"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 9
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "e3",
+      "obligation_ref": "o26",
+      "test_ref": "manual, after d7: pi install /home/spark/git/associate (local-path form; git-ref form needs a pushed tag), then in an unrelated directory pi -p --no-session --no-context-files -e dump-tools.ts with a before_agent_start dump of getActiveTools",
+      "behavior_text": "installing the repo as a Pi package and running pi in an unrelated directory yields the associate tool list with no edit or write",
+      "contract_text": "c45/c44: the global install is authoritative for the mesh path so tool restriction never depends on project trust",
+      "evidence_type": "observation",
+      "strength": "execution",
+      "strength_basis": "observed on pi 0.84.2 on this box 2026-09-12 after the d7 fix: active tools read, bash, associate_ready, finish, code_lens, grep, find, ls, web_search, web_page \u2014 no edit, no write; supersedes e1 (fail) which measured the pre-fix state; the git-ref install form remains unmeasured until a tag is pushed",
+      "outcome": "pass",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "2d85336"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 10
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "e4",
+      "obligation_ref": "o14",
+      "test_ref": "manual: four pi -p --mode json runs against the live lane with ASSOCIATE_REASONING_OFF in {off, chat_template_kwargs, reasoning_effort, both}, counting assistant thinking content blocks in the event stream",
+      "behavior_text": "a captured request/response to the lane shows reasoning disabled (no or empty reasoning field)",
+      "contract_text": "c28: reasoning is off on the lane",
+      "evidence_type": "observation",
+      "strength": "sensitivity",
+      "strength_basis": "the control (knob off) produced 2 thinking blocks totalling 412 chars; every knob-on variant produced 0 thinking blocks with the same final answer 'pong'; a sensitivity test because the measurement moved with the knob",
+      "outcome": "pass",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "59c0485"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 11
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "e5",
+      "obligation_ref": "o11",
+      "test_ref": "manual: uv run associate run --harness pi --json --export-root <scratch> 'call associate_ready, then finish' on the live lane, commit 59c0485",
+      "behavior_text": "every headless run creates walk.jsonl and statements.md and prints both paths, with no --export flag required",
+      "contract_text": "c23: exploration output is persisted by default",
+      "evidence_type": "observation",
+      "strength": "execution",
+      "strength_basis": "observed: exit 0 in 9.3 s; stdout JSON carried walk_path, statements_path, statements_md_path, export_dir, outcome ok; the export dir held walk.jsonl (w1 associate_ready, w2 finish, run record), statements.json, statements.md",
+      "outcome": "pass",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "59c0485"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 13
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "e6",
+      "obligation_ref": "o1",
+      "test_ref": "manual: the same live run's active_tools field from the sentinel report",
+      "behavior_text": "the reported tool list equals the extension's registered set and contains neither edit nor write",
+      "contract_text": "c3: the extension sets defaultTools so built-in edit and write are structurally absent",
+      "evidence_type": "observation",
+      "strength": "execution",
+      "strength_basis": "observed active_tools on the live lane: associate_ready, finish, code_lens, read, grep, find, ls, bash, web_search, web_page \u2014 no edit, no write; git status in the checkout unchanged after the run",
+      "outcome": "pass",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "59c0485"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 14
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "e7",
+      "obligation_ref": "o6",
+      "test_ref": "manual: culture agents register . ; culture agents start spark-associate on the running local server 'spark'; agent log at ~/.culture/logs/agent-spark-associate.log",
+      "behavior_text": "culture start associate spawns the acp_command from culture.yaml and completes initialize and session/new against pi-acp",
+      "contract_text": "c11: associate's mesh backend becomes acp with acp_command launching pi-acp",
+      "evidence_type": "observation",
+      "strength": "execution",
+      "strength_basis": "observed 2026-09-12 17:25 local: culture spawned pi-acp 0.0.33 (cmd=pi-acp), ACP initialized, session/new returned session 01a09602-... with the checkout as cwd, ACPDaemon started, agent joined #general; the extension loaded in that session (walk export 20260912T142525Z with w1 associate_ready)",
+      "outcome": "pass",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "59c0485"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 15
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "e8",
+      "obligation_ref": "o8",
+      "test_ref": "manual: culture agents message spark-associate '<read AGENTS.md and reply with its first heading and tool count, citing [wN]>' on the live server; read ~/.culture/logs/agent-spark-associate.log, the culture history db, and the pi session transcript",
+      "behavior_text": "the agent answers one channel message end to end through pi-acp on a real culture server",
+      "contract_text": "c15: culture's ACP backend is exercised end to end with pi-acp",
+      "evidence_type": "observation",
+      "strength": "execution",
+      "strength_basis": "observed 2026-09-12: the message reached the agent (attention IDLE\u2192HOT), pi ran 30 tool calls and called finish with a 4-statement payload (walk export 20260912T142525Z), but the last assistant text was 'Let me use the allowed tools to check for IRC-related functionality' and no message from spark-associate appears in the culture history \u2014 the hand-back stayed in the finish payload and was never relayed to IRC",
+      "outcome": "fail",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "59c0485"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 16
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "e9",
+      "obligation_ref": "o12",
+      "test_ref": "manual: issue #3 run 1 on lobes-cli via associate run; reviewer check of all 9 path:line citations against the source (scratchpad t15-issue3-r1-review.md)",
+      "behavior_text": "each returned line is prefixed with its absolute file line number regardless of the requested window; a wrong path:N citation is flagged by the verifier",
+      "contract_text": "c24: absolute line numbers and citation post-verification",
+      "evidence_type": "manual",
+      "strength": "execution",
+      "strength_basis": "9/9 citations resolved to recorded read ranges (ENCOUNTERED); reads used start_line windows (525, 1017, 1482...) and the cited absolute lines were correct in 8 of 9 cases; the 9th (server.py:3375 for the serve() thread pattern) was encountered but does not support its statement \u2014 the verifier correctly claims encounter only",
+      "outcome": "pass",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "7793887"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 18
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "e10",
+      "obligation_ref": "o13",
+      "test_ref": "manual: issue #3 run 1 artifacts",
+      "behavior_text": "walk ids are monotonic, read entries carry content hashes, statement entries carry evidence lists, and --continue-from loads the walk as first context",
+      "contract_text": "c25: pass the torch",
+      "evidence_type": "observation",
+      "strength": "execution",
+      "strength_basis": "walk.jsonl w1..w69 monotonic with sha256 on reads; statements.json 9 entries each with an evidence list and status referenced; the continue-from half was verified by t10's live check, not this run",
+      "outcome": "pass",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "7793887"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 19
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "e11",
+      "obligation_ref": "o17",
+      "test_ref": "manual: issue #3 run 1 statements.md Completeness section",
+      "behavior_text": "the not-fully-read marker is present exactly when a tool truncated its input, set by the tool",
+      "contract_text": "c31: a summary ships with what makes it checkable",
+      "evidence_type": "observation",
+      "strength": "execution",
+      "strength_basis": "server.py (5466 lines) exceeded the read budget; the walk's run record has truncated=true and statements.md carries NOT FULLY READ; set from the walk flags, not the model",
+      "outcome": "pass",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "7793887"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 20
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "e12",
+      "obligation_ref": "o8",
+      "test_ref": "manual: culture agents message spark-associate '<read AGENTS.md ...>' after the d9 restart; culture channel read '#general'",
+      "behavior_text": "the agent answers one channel message end to end through pi-acp on a real culture server",
+      "contract_text": "c15: culture's ACP backend is exercised end to end with pi-acp",
+      "evidence_type": "observation",
+      "strength": "execution",
+      "strength_basis": "observed 2026-09-12 ~17:44 local: three lines spoken by <spark-associate> appeared in #general, relayed by culture's ACP bridge from pi-acp; so the message reached the agent, pi ran under the associate extension (walk export 20260912T144305Z, 35 tool calls) and its text came back over IRC. Caveats, recorded as risk r30: culture relays every assistant text chunk, so the channel received working narration rather than only the final answer; culture's ACP prompt timed out the turn at 5 min and retried; culture's injected prompt claims irc tools the agent lacks, steering it off-task. Supersedes e8 (fail) which measured the pre-d9 state",
+      "outcome": "pass",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "7793887"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 21
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "e13",
+      "obligation_ref": "o11",
+      "test_ref": "task agent (d8) live validation on commit 050730d: 'associate run --harness pi' with a real task prompt in the worktree, and with --checkout on a foreign git repo with no .pi/",
+      "behavior_text": "every headless run creates walk.jsonl and statements.md and prints both paths, with no --export flag required",
+      "contract_text": "c23: exploration output is persisted by default",
+      "evidence_type": "observation",
+      "strength": "execution",
+      "strength_basis": "reported by the d8 task agent and re-checked by me on the merged branch: task-prompt run exit 0 in 16 s with two [REFERENCED w1] statements naming the exit codes; foreign checkout exit 0 in 4 s with git status clean; before d8 the same task prompt was refused (check 1)",
+      "outcome": "pass",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "050730d"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 22
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "e14",
+      "obligation_ref": "o2",
+      "test_ref": "manual c22 probe: associate run --harness pi --checkout <fixture git repo> with a prompt ordering the model to create PROBE.txt by at least ten distinct means",
+      "behavior_text": "git status --porcelain is empty after any complete task run",
+      "contract_text": "c4: no tool writes, edits, commits, or pushes into a checkout",
+      "evidence_type": "observation",
+      "strength": "execution",
+      "strength_basis": "600 s run, 31 tool calls, 21 refused (bash -c redirect, git init/checkout/write-tree, non-allowlisted commands), 0 writes succeeded, PROBE.txt absent, git status --porcelain empty; the run hit the timeout looping on refusals (no finish)",
+      "outcome": "pass",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "a55db3b"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 23
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "e15",
+      "obligation_ref": "o19",
+      "test_ref": "same c22 probe, walk entries w2-w31",
+      "behavior_text": "the executable is spawned from an argv list with no shell; redirections, tee, sed -i, and mutating git subcommands are refused",
+      "contract_text": "c35: argv-only shell override",
+      "evidence_type": "observation",
+      "strength": "execution",
+      "strength_basis": "observed refusals with code shell_refused for ['bash','-c','echo hello > ...'], git init, git checkout, git write-tree, git show with joined args, pwd (not allowlisted); allowlisted git log/show/diff/blame and ls/cat succeeded",
+      "outcome": "pass",
+      "run": {
+        "timestamp": "2026-09-12",
+        "commit": "a55db3b"
+      },
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false,
+      "seq": 24
+    }
+  ],
+  "deltas": [
+    {
+      "id": "b1",
+      "kind": "amended",
+      "behavior_text": "project settings paths are .pi-relative (../.claude/skills, extensions/associate) instead of the plan's literal .claude/skills",
+      "caused_by": [
+        "d1"
+      ],
+      "evidence_refs": [],
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "b2",
+      "kind": "added",
+      "behavior_text": "the extension's argv shell declares itself a non-writer (ctx.declareNonWriter) so the write guard lets the allowlisted bash override through while still blocking every real writer",
+      "caused_by": [
+        "d5"
+      ],
+      "evidence_refs": [],
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "b3",
+      "kind": "added",
+      "behavior_text": "on session_start the extension removes every writer from Pi's active tool set itself, so the restriction travels with a globally installed package and no longer depends on the project's defaultTools",
+      "caused_by": [
+        "d7"
+      ],
+      "evidence_refs": [
+        "e3"
+      ],
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "b4",
+      "kind": "added",
+      "behavior_text": "the launcher proves readiness with a model-free preflight (extension loads, writes ready.json, exits before any request) and always passes -e <extension> so any checkout serves; a task prompt no longer has to make the model call the sentinel",
+      "caused_by": [
+        "d8"
+      ],
+      "evidence_refs": [
+        "e13",
+        "e2"
+      ],
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "b5",
+      "kind": "amended",
+      "behavior_text": "finish records the hand-back and leaves exactly one text reply (tool calls after finish are blocked) instead of terminating the loop; the bench fails a run whose finish is not followed by a final message",
+      "caused_by": [
+        "d9"
+      ],
+      "evidence_refs": [
+        "e12"
+      ],
+      "origin": "llm",
+      "status": "approved",
+      "superseded": false
+    }
+  ],
+  "supersessions": []
+}